Analysis of lymphocyte cell death and apoptosis in HIV-2-infected patients

Pathophysiology of CD4+ T-Cell Depletion in HIV-1 and HIV-2 Infections

The hall mark of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection is a gradual loss of CD4+ T-cells and imbalance in CD4+ T-cell homeostasis, with progressive impairment of immunity that leads ultimately to death. HIV infection in humans is caused by two related yet distinct viruses: HIV-1 and HIV-2. HIV-2 is typically less virulent than HIV-1 and permits the host to mount a more effective and sustained T-cell immunity. Although both infections manifest the same clinical spectrum, the much lower rate of CD4+ T-cell decline and slower progression of disease in HIV-2 infected individuals have grabbed the attention of several researchers. Here, we review the most recent findings on the differential rate of decline of CD4+ T-cell in HIV-1 and HIV-2 infections and provide plausible reasons for the observed differences between the two groups.

Insight into HIV-2 latency may disclose strategies for a cure for HIV-1 infection

HIV-1 and HIV-2 originate from two distinct zoonotic transmissions of simian immunodeficiency viruses from primate to human. Although both share similar modes of transmission and can result in the development of AIDS with similar clinical manifestations, HIV-2 infection is generally milder and less likely to progress to AIDS. HIV is currently incurable due to the presence of HIV provirus integrated into the host DNA of long-lived memory cells of the immune system without active replication. As such, the latent virus is immunologically inert and remains insensitive to the administered antiviral drugs targeting active viral replication steps. Recent evidence suggests that persistent HIV replication may occur in anatomical sanctuaries such as the lymphoid tissue due to low drug penetration. At present, different strategies are being evaluated either to completely eradicate the virus from the patient (sterilising cure) or to allow treatment interruption without viral rebound (functional cure). Because HIV-2 is naturally less pathogenic and displays a more latent phenotype than HIV-1, it may represent a valuable model that provides elementary information to cure HIV-1 infection. Insight into the viral and cellular determinants of HIV-2 replication may therefore pave the way for alternative strategies to eradicate HIV-1 or promote viral remission.

Comparing HIV-1 and HIV-2 infection: Lessons for viral immunopathogenesis

HIV-1 and HIV-2 share many similarities including their basic gene arrangement, modes of transmission, intracellular replication pathways and clinical consequences: both result in AIDS. However, HIV-2 is characterised by lower transmissibility and reduced likelihood of progression to AIDS. The underlying mechanistic differences between these two infections illuminate broader issues of retroviral pathogenesis, which remain incompletely understood. Comparisons between these two infections from epidemiological, clinical, virologic and immunologic viewpoints provide a basis for hypothesis generation and testing in this 'natural experiment' in viral pathogenesis. In terms of epidemiology, HIV-2 remains largely confined to West Africa, whereas HIV-1 extends worldwide. Clinically, HIV-2 infected individuals seem to dichotomise, most remaining long-term non-progressors, whereas most HIV-1 infected individuals progress. When clinical progression occurs, both diseases demonstrate very similar pathological processes, although progression in HIV-2 occurs at higher CD4 counts. Plasma viral loads are consistently lower in HIV-2, as are average levels of immune activation. Significant differences exist between the two infections in all components of the immune system. For example, cellular responses to HIV-2 tend to be more polyfunctional and produce more IL-2; humoral responses appear broader with lower magnitude intratype neutralisation responses; innate responses appear more robust, possibly through differential effects of tripartite motif protein isoform 5 alpha. Overall, the immune response to HIV-2 appears more protective against disease progression suggesting that pivotal immune factors limit viral pathology. If such immune responses could be replicated or induced in HIV-1 infected patients, they might extend survival and reduce requirements for antiretroviral therapy.

Immune dysregulation in human immunodeficiency virus infection: know it, fix it, prevent it?

Infection of humans by the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) causes a progressive, multifactorial impairment of the immune system eventually leading to the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). No cure or vaccine exists yet against HIV infection. More worrisome is the fact that despite having identified HIV as the cause of the AIDS, we still do not understand what pathogenic mechanisms lead to the debacle of the immune system. In this review we consider the extent and the limits of our knowledge of HIV pathogenesis, and how this knowledge may be used to design preventive and therapeutic approaches.

HIV-2: the forgotten AIDS virus

HIV type 2 (HIV-2), a closely related retrovirus discovered a few years after HIV type 1, causes AIDS in only a minority of infected individuals. Determining why HIV-2 causes asymptomatic infection in most patients could further our understanding of HIV immunopathogenesis. Studies to date have suggested that both enhanced immune responses and lower viral replication could play a role. We summarize the important findings to date and highlight areas that warrant further exploration.

Immunologic and virologic response after tetanus toxoid booster among HIV-1- and HIV-2-infected Senegalese individuals

Twelve HIV-1-infected, nine HIV-2-infected patients and eight HIV-negative subjects were given a 40IU booster dose of tetanus toxoid (TT). Blood was collected on days 0, 7 and 30 after immunization. Changes in HIV-1 or HIV-2 RNA load were evaluated by nested PCR. TT-IgG antibody levels were quantified by ELISA. CD4 cell counts as well as activation, memory and maturation markers of T lymphocyte subsets were determined by flow cytometry. The induction of apoptosis was investigated using 7-aminoactinomycin D (AAD) and propidium iodide (PI) staining. Proliferative responses to TT and pokeweed mitogen (PWM) were determined by the level of [(3)H] thymidine incorporation. Seven and 30 days after immunization, there was no detectable increase in HIV-1 or HIV-2 plasma load. There were also no changes in CD4 cell counts, CD69, HLA-DR and memory CD45RO or naive CD45RA antigens. Immunization did not increase the spontaneous apoptosis of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs), CD4+ and CD8+ T cells subsets neither in controls nor in HIV-infected patients. Similarly, apoptosis induced in vitro by PWM or by the specific TT recall antigen did not vary during the study period. The proliferative response to PWM and to the TT recall antigen was decreased both in HIV-1- and HIV-2-infected patients compared to HIV-negative controls. Immunization significantly increased the TT-IgG levels in healthy controls and in HIV-infected patients. However, the anti-TT-IgG response, as measured by the fold-increase index between days 0 and 30, was significantly higher in healthy controls than in HIV-1- (P=0.036) and HIV-2-infected patients (P=0.003). In conclusion, we found no deleterious immunologic or virologic effect was detected in healthy HIV-1- and HIV-2-infected individuals after antigenic challenge with a TT booster. However, the response to TT vaccination was lower in HIV-1- and in HIV-2-infected individuals than in healthy HIV-negative controls.

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 accessory protein Vpu induces apoptosis by suppressing the nuclear factor kappaB-dependent expression of antiapoptotic factors

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1 Vpu is an integral membrane protein with a unique affinity for betaTrCP (TrCP), a key member of the SkpI-Cullin-F-box E3 ubiquitin ligase complex that is involved in the regulated degradation of cellular proteins, including IkappaB. Remarkably, Vpu is resistant to TrCP-mediated degradation and competitively inhibits TrCP-dependent degradation of IkappaB, resulting in the suppression of nuclear factor (NF)-kappaB activity in Vpu-expressing cells. We now report that Vpu, through its interaction with TrCP, potently contributes to the induction of apoptosis in HIV-infected T cells. Vpu-induced apoptosis is specific and independent of other viral proteins. Mutation of a TrCP-binding motif in Vpu abolishes its apoptogenic property, demonstrating a close correlation between this property of Vpu and its ability to inhibit NF-kappaB activity. The involvement of NF-kappaB in Vpu-induced apoptosis is further supported by the finding that the levels of antiapoptotic factors Bcl-xL, A1/Bfl-1, and TNF receptor-associated factor (TRAF)1, all of which are expressed in an NF-kappaB-dependent manner, are reduced and, at the same time, levels of active caspase-3 are elevated. Thus, Vpu induces apoptosis through activation of the caspase pathway by way of inhibiting the NF-kappaB-dependent expression of antiapoptotic genes.

Marked immunosuppressive effects of the HIV-2 envelope protein in spite of the lower HIV-2 pathogenicity

OBJECTIVE

HIV-1 envelope proteins have immunosuppressive properties and it is thought that they have a role in the establishment of immunodeficiency. This study characterizes the immunological effects of HIV-2 envelope protein gp105, a virus which is associated with a slower rate of disease progression.

METHODS

The effects of recombinant baculovirus-expressed envelope proteins from HIV-IIIB HIV-1MN, HIV-2ROD and SIVmac251 on anti-CD3-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from healthy donors were evaluated by incorporation of 3H-thymidine, flow cytometric analysis of bromodeoxyuridine incorporation in different T cell subsets, kinetics of expression of costimulatory molecules (CD40L/OX40) and assessment of cell death by annexin V/propidium iodide staining. The effects on production of tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) by monocytes were assessed at the single-cell level after a 6 h culture of unstimulated PBMC.

RESULTS

HIV-2 gp105 was more inhibitory than HIV-1 gp120 of T cell proliferation and the upregulation of CD40L and OX40; in the absence of signficant induction of apoptosis. This inhibition affected both CD4 and CD8 T cells and was only partially reversed by costimulation with interleukin 2 or CD28. gp105 strongly inducted TNF-alpha production by monocytes.

CONCLUSION

The immunosuppressive properties of the HIV envelope proteins could be beneficial rather than detrimental to the host by interfering with the heightened state of immunocellular activation that characterizes HIV infection and by limiting the bursts of viral replication. This hypothesis could in part explain the slower decline of CD4 cell numbers in HIV-2 infection and deserves further exploration.

Early reduction of the over-expression of CD40L, OX40 and Fas on T cells in HIV-1 infection during triple anti-retroviral therapy: possible implications for lymphocyte traffic and functional recovery

Fas, CD40L and OX40 are members of the tumour necrosis factor (TNF) receptor superfamily with critical roles in T cell activation and death, B cell function, dendritic cell maturation and leucocyte traffic regulation. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of anti-retroviral therapy (HAART) on CD40L, OX40 and Fas expression on freshly isolated peripheral blood T cells by three-colour flow cytometry and compare them with lymphoproliferative responses, peripheral blood cell counts and viral load. Fourteen asymptomatic HIV-1+ patients treated with Lamivudine, Stavudine and Nelfinavir were prospectively investigated sequentially for 48 weeks. At baseline, patients exhibited significantly enhanced proportions and counts of CD40L+ and OX40+ cells within the CD4 subset which were corrected by weeks 8-16 of HAART. Interestingly, in the five patients showing viral load rebound during therapy in spite of increasing CD4 counts, the reduction of the levels of these costimulatory molecules was similarly maintained. Therapy induced a decrease in the over-expression of Fas, particularly in the CD4 subset where normal levels were reached at week 8. This reduction occurred in parallel with the major recovery of lymphoproliferative responses. Higher basal levels and lower reduction of Fas were associated with suboptimal suppression of viraemia. In conclusion, this previously undescribed increased expression of CD40L and OX40 may play a role in the HIV-associated pan-immune activation and represent a possible target for immunointervention, as suggested for several immunologically mediated diseases. Moreover, HAART induced an early correction of the over-expression of Fas, CD40L and OX40 in CD4 T cells which could be involved in the recovery of the cell traffic disturbances and in the T cell renewal capacity.

The regulation of apoptosis by microbial pathogens

In the past few years, there has been remarkable progress unraveling the mechanism and significance of eukaryotic programmed cell death (PCD), or apoptosis. Not surprisingly, it has been discovered that numerous, unrelated microbial pathogens engage or circumvent the host's apoptotic program. In this chapter, we briefly summarize apoptosis, emphasizing those studies which assist the reader in understanding the subsequent discussion on PCD and pathogens. We then examine the relationship between virulent bacteria and apoptosis. This section is organized to reflect both common and diverse mechanisms employed by bacteria to induce PCD. A short discussion of parasites and fungi is followed by a detailed description of the interaction of viral pathogens with the apoptotic machinery. Throughout the review, apoptosis is considered within the broader contexts of pathogenesis, virulence, and host defense. Our goals are to update the reader on this rapidly expanding field and identify topics in the current literature which demand further investigation.

Does HIV cause depletion of CD4+ T cells in vivo by the induction of apoptosis?

The central pathogenic feature of AIDS is the dramatic loss of CD4+ lymphocytes. Despite more than a decade of intense research, the exact mechanism by which HIV causes this is still not understood. A major model for T cell depletion, proposed originally by Ameison and Capron in a report published in 1991, is that HIV sensitizes CD4+ T cells for activation-induced apoptosis. The apoptotic model of T cell depletion is discussed, and experiments that address the questions of whether apoptosis is restricted to infected cells or 'bystander' T cells, and whether T cell apoptosis requires participation of separate HIV-infected haematopoietic cell populations, are reviewed.

HIV-2 and T cell recognition

HIV-2 is less pathogenic and less transmissible than HIV-1. Recent research in relation to deletions in the HIV nef gene and to immune cross-reactions between infections by HIV-2, HIV-1 and simian immunodeficiency virus suggests that T cell recognition and the control of viral replication may be more efficient in HIV-2 infection than in HIV-1 infection. These insights may be crucial to the design of effective vaccines.

Tumor necrosis factor beta and soluble APO-1/Fas independently predict progression to AIDS in HIV-seropositive patients

The relationship between serum concentration of different components of the nerve growth factor/tumor necrosis factor (TNF) receptor family, including soluble APO-1/Fas (sAPO-1/Fas) and progression of HIV infection, was analyzed in a case-control study of individuals selected from a cohort of HIV-seropositive patients who were progressing or not progressing to AIDS while being treated with nucleoside analogs. HIV-seronegative healthy controls were also analyzed. The results showed that, despite close matching for immunologic (CD4 cell count, beta2-microglobulin concentration) and virologic (p24 antigen, detection of HIV syncytium-inducing phenotype, plasma HIV viremia) parameters, the baseline serum concentrations of TNF-beta and sAPO-1/Fas were statistically different between progressing and nonprogressing patients. In addition, serum concentrations of TNF-beta and sAPO-1/Fas showed the strongest independent predictive power for progression to AIDS in a multivariate conditional logistic regression model. Because TNF-beta and Fas were suggested to be mediators of antigen-induced cell death (AICD) in HIV infection and sAPO-1/Fas was hypothesized to protect lymphocyte against AICD, these data suggest an important pathogenetic role for AICD in the progression of HIV infection.

Single-cell analysis of lymphokine imbalance in asymptomatic HIV-1 infection: evidence for a major alteration within the CD8+ T cell subset

In this study we investigated at single-cell level by flow cytometry the potential of T cell cytokine production in asymptomatic HIV-1-infected subjects with > 200 CD4 counts and possible correlation with T helper cell depletion and viral load. Mitogen-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 32 HIV-1+ patients and 16 healthy subjects were intracytoplasmically stained for IL-2, interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), IL-4 or IL-10, and the frequency of cytokine-producing cells was assessed in total T cells, CD4, CD8 and CD45RO subsets as well as in CD69+CD3+ gated lymphocytes. HIV-1+ patients, irrespective of their degree of CD4 depletion, exhibited a major increase in IFN-gamma+ CD8 T cells, largely due to CD28- cells, as well as a decrease in the capacity of CD8 T cells to produce IL-2. Patients with > 500 CD4 counts showed a diminished frequency of IL-4 expression in CD4 T cells and a negative correlation was found between this parameter and the ex vivo CD4 counts in the 32 patients. Analysis of patients stratified according to viral load revealed a significantly higher proportion of IL-2-producing CD4 cells in the group with < 5000 RNA copies/ml. In short, using single-cell analysis and an antigen-presenting cell-independent stimulus, we have not been able to find any significant cytokine imbalances in the CD4 subset, suggesting that the well described T helper defects are not due to intrinsic alterations in the potential of CD4 T cells to produce cytokines. On the other hand, the major disturbances in the CD8 T lymphocytes agree with the marked activation and possible replicative senescence of CD8 T cells and emphasize the role of this subset in HIV immunopathogenesis.

Distinct mechanisms trigger apoptosis in human immunodeficiency virus type 1-infected and in uninfected bystander T lymphocytes

Apoptosis is a main feature of AIDS pathogenesis and is thought to play a role in the progressive decrease of CD4+ T lymphocytes in infected individuals. To determine whether apoptosis occurs in infected and/or in uninfected peripheral blood T lymphocytes, we have used a recombinant human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) infectious clone expressing the green fluorescent protein (GFP). Using flow cytometry, we have determined the incidence of apoptosis by either terminal transferase dUTP nick end labeling or annexin-V assays in different cell subpopulations, i.e., in CD4+ or CD8+ T cells that were GFP positive or negative. After HIV-1 infection of purified peripheral blood lymphocytes, we observed that apoptosis occurred mostly in infected CD4+ peripheral blood lymphocytes. Remarkably, the presence of monocyte-derived macrophages in the culture increased dramatically the apoptosis of uninfected bystander T lymphocytes, while apoptosis in HIV-infected T lymphocytes was not changed. We therefore demonstrate that HIV-induced apoptosis results from at least two distinct mechanisms: (i) direct apoptosis in HIV-infected CD4+ T lymphocytes and (ii) indirect apoptosis in uninfected T cells mediated by antigen-presenting cells.

Impaired induction of the apoptosis-protective protein Bcl-xL in activated PBMC from asymptomatic HIV-infected individuals

Progression to AIDS in asymptomatic HIV-infected individuals is characterized by a gradual but progressive loss of CD4+ T cells. While the mechanisms underlying this decline are currently unknown, recent evidence suggests that these cells are abnormally sensitive to apoptosis in response to activation signals. Recent work has implicated downregulation of Bcl-2 with the increased spontaneous apoptosis in lymphocytes from HIV-infected patients. We have evaluated the roles of the apoptosis-protective proteins Bcl-2 and Bcl-x in stimulated PBMC from asymptomatic HIV-infected and HIV-uninfected individuals. We found that Bcl-2 was constitutively expressed in PBMC from both HIV-infected and uninfected samples. However, Bcl-x induction was delayed and responses were decreased in stimulated HIV-infected samples. Additionally, single-cell intracellular staining of Bcl-x revealed a significant inverse correlation between PWM-induced Bcl-x expression and apoptosis (r = -0.695, P = 0.05). This was confirmed at the single-cell level in direct experiments when stimulated cells were sorted based on Bcl-x induction and then measured for apoptosis. Furthermore, low Bcl-x expression was not due to reduced lymphocyte activation following PWM stimulation. Our data indicate that the induction of Bcl-x is markedly impaired in asymptomatic HIV-infected patients and that stimuli which induce inadequate expression of Bcl-x are associated with increased levels of apoptosis in these cells.

Acquired immune deficiency syndrome caused by hyperimmunity

Normal immunocytes including T and B cells are equilibrated by a reciprocal attacking mechanism called a network. Continuous disequilibrium of this network results in general immunodeficiency with oligo- and polyclonal hyperimmunity, for example, T-cell activation due to spontaneous reticuloendotheliosis, paraneoplastic autoimmune syndromes, and human immunodeficiency virus infection. In these disorders, reciprocal self-reactivity, including autologous graft-versus-host reaction, plays a role in the immunodeficiency. A priori self-targeting immunity is a key mechanism to explain autoimmunity in the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome. In the treatment of the immunodeficiency due to hyperimmunity, I propose immunological suppression by agents and reconstitution of the network by bone-marrow transplantation.

Programmed cell death in brains of HIV-1-positive AIDS and pre-AIDS patients

Neuropathological studies have revealed that the brains of HIV-1-infected AIDS patients show the typical encephalitis and, in addition, neuronal loss. More recently, this neuronal cell loss has been thought to take place via programmed cell death (apoptosis) which has been demonstrated by an in situ end labelling (ISEL) technique. In this study 54 brains of HIV-1-positive patients were investigated by the ISEL technique to investigate whether apoptosis is also present in the brains of patients at the asymptomatic stage. Of these, 10 patients suffered from HIV encephalitis (HIVE), 8 had AIDS without neuropathological disorders and 36 were HIV-1-positive pre-AIDS patients. Apoptotic cells were detected in 6 of the 10 HIVE, 1 of the 8 AIDS without central nervous system (CNS) disease and 4 of the 36 asymptomatic individuals. A difference seen between the AIDS and pre-AIDS cases was that, in the latter, apoptotic cells were found in the white matter in all 4 cases, while only 2 of these 4 showed apoptotic neurons. The presence of apoptotic cells in a number, albeit small, of brains of HIV-1-positive pre-AIDS individuals, combined with abnormalities described previously in the same group of patients gives further support to the opinion that brain damage already occurs during the early stages of HIV infection.

YOPRO-1 permits cytofluorometric analysis of programmed cell death (apoptosis) without interfering with cell viability

In the absence of cell permeabilization, the impermeant nuclear dye YOPRO-1 permits accurate analysis of apoptosis using cytofluorometry or fluorescent microscopy. Several immune cell populations were studied including dexamethasone-treated thymocytes, irradiated peripheral blood mononuclear cells and a growth factor-depleted tumor B cell line. Excellent correlation values were found with acridine orange using cytofluorometry and with eosin-hematoxylin using optical microscopy. Under fluorescent microscopy, YOPRO-1-fluorescent cells demonstrate the morphological features of cells undergoing apoptosis such as nuclear shrinkage and fragmentation. An important characteristic of the dye that differs from all other nuclear dyes previously used for the detection of apoptosis is that it does not label living cells. Cell sorting after flow cytofluorometry analysis confirmed that only the apoptotic cell population was labelled with YOPRO-1. Further studies showed that while incubation of living cells with Hoechst 33342 almost completely abrogated the capacity of T cells to proliferate in response to several stimuli, YOPRO-1 had no inhibitory effect. This new simple, rapid and reproducible use of the YOPRO-1 dye should prove useful in the analysis of apoptotic cells as well as for investigations of the functional properties of living cells in a culture containing apoptotic cells.

Role of apoptosis in HIV disease pathogenesis

After approximately one and a half decades of intensive studies, the exact mechanisms to explain HIV-mediated cytopathicity are still enigmatic and need closer scrutiny. There has been a dichotomy between virological and immunological viewpoints in understanding HIV-mediated cytopathicity, the former emphasizing a killing of infected cells by HIV-1 and the latter emphasizing indirect mechanisms wherein HIV or its soluble component(s) alter CD4 T-cell function and induce susceptibility to apoptosis. Accumulating evidence points to the notion that apoptosis might be a major contributor to the depletion of CD4 T-cells in HIV infection. This review summarizes current information about the regulatory mechanisms of T-cell apoptosis and the role of apoptosis in HIV pathogenesis with the goal of providing an integrated view of HIV cytopathicity.