Transfer of immunity to Nematospiroides dubius: co-operation between lymphoid cells and antibodies in mediating worm expulsion

Understanding the role of antibodies in murine infections with Heligmosomoides (polygyrus) bakeri: 35 years ago, now and 35 years ahead

The rodent intestinal nematode H.p.bakeri has played an important role in the exploration of the host-parasite relationship of chronic nematode infections for over six decades, since the parasite was first isolated in the 1950s by Ehrenford. It soon became a popular laboratory model providing a tractable experimental system that is easy to maintain in the laboratory and far more cost-effective than other laboratory nematode-rodent model systems. Immunity to this parasite is complex, dependent on antibodies, but confounded by the parasite's potent immunosuppressive secretions that facilitate chronic survival in murine hosts. In this review, we remind readers of the state of knowledge in the 1970s, when the first volume of Parasite Immunology was published, focusing on the role of antibodies in protective immunity. We show how our understanding of the host-parasite relationship then developed over the following 35 years to date, we propose testable hypotheses for future researchers to tackle, and we speculate on how the new technologies will be applied to enable an increasingly refined understanding of the role of antibodies in host-protective immunity, and its evasion, to be achieved in the longer term.

To B or not to B: B cells and the Th2-type immune response to helminths

Similar T helper (Th)2-type immune responses are generated against different helminth parasites, but the mechanisms that initiate Th2 immunity, and the specific immune components that mediate protection against these parasites, can vary greatly. B cells are increasingly recognized as important during the Th2-type immune response to helminths, and B cell activation might be a target for effective vaccine development. Antibody production is a function of B cells during helminth infection and understanding how polyclonal and antigen-specific antibodies contribute should provide important insights into how protective immunity develops. In addition, B cells might also contribute to the host response against helminths through antibody-independent functions including, antigen presentation, as well as regulatory and effector activity. In this review, we examine the role of B cells during Th2-type immune response to these multicellular parasites.

Cytokine-producing effector B cells regulate type 2 immunity to H. polygyrus

Immunity to the intestinal parasite Heligomosomoides polygyrus is dependent on the successful generation of T helper 2 (Th2) memory cells. We showed that B cells contribute to immunity against H. polygyrus by producing antibody (Ab) and by promoting expansion and differentiation of primary and memory Th2 cells. We also demonstrated that cytokine-producing effector B cells were essential for effective immunity to H. polygyrus. Tumor necrosis factor alpha production by B cells was necessary for sustained Ab production, whereas interleukin 2 production by B cells was necessary for Th2 cell expansion and differentiation. These results show that B cells mediate protection from pathogens not only by presenting antigen and secreting antibody but also by producing cytokines that regulate the quality and magnitude of humoral and cellular immune responses.

Immunodepression reduces learning performance in male laboratory mice (Mus musculus)

Several theoretical and empirical studies have suggested that immunocompetence may act as a constraint on learning, due to a trade-off in investment in the two processes. Here we tested whether experimentally depressing immune responsiveness of male BKW mice using antithymocyte serum (ATS) would lead to reduced learning performance in a radial maze task. Correct choices in the maze were indicated by the presence of familiar odours, incorrect choices by unfamiliar odours. We showed that temporarily depressing cellular immunity led to a reduction in performance in terms of a reduced proportion of correct choices. We also found a positive relationship between the proportion of correct entries over the period of testing and haemagglutination titre, indicating that mice showing greater immune responsiveness performed better in the maze. We conclude that depressing the immune system reduces learning performance in a combined odour/spatial learning task, and that some individuals are better able to compensate for the experimental immunodepression. In contrast to previous studies, there was no evidence that the effect of ATS was mediated by associated changes in corticosterone or testosterone secretion. There were no significant effects of the presence of female odour on learning performance, and therefore no evidence that the down regulation of learning in relation to immune depression was influenced by apparent reproductive opportunity.

Systemic dissemination and persistence of Th2 and type 2 cells in response to infection with a strictly enteric nematode parasite

Oral infection with the nematode parasite Heligmosomoides polygyrus H. polygyrus is entirely restricted to the small intestine. Although the evoked Th2 response has been extensively studied in secondary lymphoid organs, little is known about the systemic dissemination of Th2 cells or type 2 associated eosinophils and basophils. In this study we use bicistronic 4get IL-4 reporter mice to directly visualize the type 2 response to H. polygyrus infection. We observed that CD4(+)/GFP(+) Th2 cells spread systemically and found that these cells accumulated in nonlymphoid "hot spots" in the liver, the lung airways, and the peritoneal cavity. Interestingly, the total number of Th2 cells in the peritoneal cavity was comparable to those found in the draining mesenteric lymph node or the spleen. Peritoneal Th2 cells were distinguished by an exceptionally low apoptotic potential and high expression of the intestinal homing receptor alpha(4)beta(7) integrin. CD4(+)/GFP(+) Th2 cells from these peripheral sites were fully functional as indicated by rapid IL-4 production upon polyclonal or Ag-specific restimulation. Th2 cells persisted in the intestinal tissue and the peritoneal cavity of drug-cured mice for weeks. The presence of peripheral memory Th2 cells in the intestine might be crucial for immunity to recall infections. These findings have important implications for the design of vaccination strategies because it may be necessary to establish and maintain memory CD4(+) T cells at the potential future site of infection.

Mucosal immunity against parasitic gastrointestinal nematodes

The last two decades witnessed significant advances in the efforts of immunoparasitologists to elucidate the nature and role of the host mucosal defence mechanisms against intestinal nematode parasites. Aided by recent advances in basic immunology and biotechnology with the concomitant development of well defined laboratory models of infection, immunoparasitologists have more precisely analyzed and defined the different immune effector mechanisms during the infection; resulting in great improvement in our current knowledge and understanding of protective immunity against gastrointestinal (GI) nematode parasites. Much of this current understanding comes from experimental studies in laboratory rodents, which have been used as models of livestock and human GI nematode infections. These rodent studies, which have concentrated on Heligmosomoides polygyrus, Nippostrongylus brasiliensis, Strongyloides ratti/S. venezuelensis, Trichinella spiralis and Trichuris muris infections in mice and rats, have helped in defining the types of T cell responses that regulate effector mechanisms and the effector mechanisms responsible for worm expulsion. In addition, these studies bear indications that traditionally accepted mechanisms of resistance such as eosinophilia and IgE responses may not play as important roles in protection as were previously conceived. In this review, we shall, from these rodent studies, attempt an overview of the mucosal and other effector responses against intestinal nematode parasites beginning with the indices of immune protection as a model of the protective immune responses that may occur in animals and man.

Immunity costs and behavioural modulation in male laboratory mice (Mus musculus) exposed to the odours of females

In a previous study, male laboratory mice experimentally immunodepressed with anti-thymocyte serum (ATS) showed changes in behaviour (aggression, general locomotory activity, and sleeping) and testosterone that are consistent with decision-making being modulated adaptively with respect to immunocompetence. We tested this idea further by repeating the experiment with the addition of female odours (soiled sawdust) to the home cages of males following ATS/control treatment. We predicted that, in the presence of cues suggesting reproductive opportunity, immunodepressed males would trade off potential immunity costs by failing to modulate behaviour. This expectation was borne out in that ATS-treated mice showed no change in aggression, locomotory activity, mounting, or sleeping relative to control animals, and mice overall showed differences in behaviour in the expected direction compared with a previous study in which female odours were not presented. However, despite the lack of difference in behaviour between ATS and control treatments, there was still evidence of a degree of behavioural modulation in relation to measures of immunocompetence.

Modulation of behaviour and testosterone concentration in immunodepressed male laboratory mice (Mus musculus)

Recent ideas suggest that current immunocompetence may act as a constraint on behavioural and physiological decisions, where these risk imposing an additional burden on immune function. We tested this in the context of time budgeting and the secretion of the potentially immunodepressive hormones testosterone and corticosterone, by treating adult male CFLP laboratory mice with antithymocyte serum (ATS) to depress thymus-mediated immune function. In comparison with males given a naive rabbit serum (NRS) vehicle control, ATS-treated mice showed a reduction in serum testosterone concentration, aggressive behaviour, and general activity, and maintained time spent sleeping, relative to pretreatment levels. Behaviours that differed between treatments correlated with measures of immunodepression (reduction in relative thymus weight or serum total IgG concentration), but relationships with behavioural changes were independent of those with testosterone. There was little evidence that changes were affected by social status. The results are discussed in the context of the adaptive modulation of immune function and physiological and behavioural decision-making.

Energy restriction and severe zinc deficiency influence growth, survival and reproduction of Heligmosomoides polygyrus (Nematoda) during primary and challenge infections in mice

The objectives of this study were (1) to determine the impact of severe zinc deficiency on the establishment, growth, survival and reproduction of Heligmosomoides polygyrus in the laboratory mouse, during both primary and challenge infection protocols, and (2) to determine whether the observed effects resulted from zinc deficiency per se, or from the accompanying energy restriction. Three diet groups were used: zinc-sufficient (Zn+:60 mg zinc/kg diet), zinc-deficient (Zn-:0.75 mg zinc/kg diet) and energy restricted (ER:60 mg zinc/kg diet pair fed to Zn- mice). Neither Zn- nor ER influenced the establishment of the parasite during a primary infection. However, both significantly influenced the early development of the parasite. The proportion of adult worms recovered 9 days post-infection (p.i.) was highest in Zn- mice, intermediate in ER mice and lowest in Zn+ mice. Worms were also distributed more distally in the intestine of the Zn- mice and worm survival was highest in Zn- mice, intermediate in ER mice and lowest in Zn+ mice at both 4 and 5 weeks p.i. Although the length of female worms was reduced in Zn- mice, neither per capita fecundity nor egg viability was affected by zinc deficiency. Energy restriction, on the other hand, significantly reduced worm fecundity at 5 weeks post-primary infection, but had no effect on egg viability. Zinc concentration of adult H. polygyrus was similar among dietary groups. The effects of zinc deficiency and energy restriction were also investigated 4 and 5 weeks after a challenge infection. Whereas strong host resistance was evident in Zn+ and ER mice, based on comparison of worm numbers between challenged mice and primary infection controls, no evidence of resistance was detected in Zn- mice. As in the primary infection, female worms were shorter in Zn- mice than in ER and Zn+ mice, and energy restriction but not zinc deficiency significantly affected per capita fecundity. However, in contrast to the primary infection, ER mice had elevated rather than reduced fecundity. This study demonstrates a complex interaction between H. polygyrus and zinc and energy restriction, and highlights the importance of controlling for reduced food intake in nutrition-infection studies.

The influence of protein deficiency on immunity to Heligmosomoides polygyrus (Nematoda) in mice

The influence of dietary protein on the efficiency with which mice could be immunized against infection with the nematode Heligomosomoides polygyrus was investigated. Immunization with irradiated larvae did not protect outbred mice fed synthetic diets containing 2% or 4% protein against a challenge infection, while animals fed a diet containing 8% protein were significantly resistant. In further experiments with high-responder NIH mice, protein malnutrition was again found to cause a significant depression in immunity. Immunization primed all mice for an intense production of antibody against larval worms in a challenge infection, and although a slightly higher titre of antibody was detected in the plasma of mice fed a 16% compared with a 2% protein diet it seemed unlikely that this was sufficient to account for the reduced resistance of the malnourished mice. The development of eosinophilia in the blood of immunized mice was significantly delayed in malnourished animals following challenge, and it is suggested that a reduction in the number of granulocytes attacking larval worms contributed to the low level of resistance observed in these animals. Protein malnutrition thus markedly suppresses the effectiveness of immunization of mice against an intestinal nematode, and it is suggested that this result may be of general significance with regard to the potential for widespread immunization of people against infections of this type.

Nematospiroides dubius: passive transfer of protective immunity to mice with monoclonal antibodies

Nine hybridoma cell lines secreting monoclonal antibodies specific for Nematospiroides dubius were produced by fusion of the mouse myeloma cell line NS-1 to either spleen cells or mesenteric lymph node cells from mice repeatedly infected with N. dubius. Seven of the antibodies were identified as IgM and two as IgG1. Each monoclonal antibody bound to polypeptide epitopes on both infective larvae (L3) and adult worms. However, five antibodies bound preferentially to L3 and three to adult worms. All nine antibodies reacted with high molecular weight protein antigens. Passive protective immunity in Balb/c mice was demonstrated with monoclonal antibodies Nd2 and Nd3 in ascites fluid which stunted both male and female worms and reduced parasite fecundity.

Immunological relationships during primary infection with Heligmosomoides polygyrus (Nematospiroides dubius): the capacity of adult worms to survive following transplantation to recipient mice

Chronic primary infections with Heligmosomoides polygyrus (Nematospiroides dubius) are still relatively poorly documented, particularly in relation to the role of host resistance in limiting worm survival. In the present work the duration of infection with H. polygyrus was studied in CFLP mice given doses of infective larvae ranging from 50 to 500 L3. The least heavily infected (50 L3) group ceased egg production earliest (week 36) whereas eggs were still detected in the faeces of mice given 500 larvae in week 42. At autopsy (week 42) mice given 50 larvae had virtually lost their entire worm burden with 5 out of 11 mice still harbouring a single worm each. However, all the mice in the group given 500 larvae were still infected, the highest worm burden being 93. The concentration of serum IgG1 and specific antibody was highest in mice given 500 larvae, but sera taken from mice with declining worm burdens 19-38 weeks post-infection did not contain detectable host-protective antibody. During the course of infection in CFLP mice, H. polygyrus sustained irreversible changes in its capacity for subsequent survival. Thus, adult worms transferred to naive mice 2, 7, 14, 30 or 36 weeks post-infection did not live longer than worms of a comparable age in the respective donor group. In contrast, primary infection worms taken from jirds in which expulsion is usually completed by 6 weeks post-infection, re-established in mice and survived considerably longer than in the group of donor jirds. These results were discussed in relation to the possible interactions between parasite senility and immunomodulation, and host resistance in limiting primary infections with H. polygyrus in mice and jirds.

Regulation of mouse colony abundance by Heligmosomoides polygyrus

Despite the ubiquitous presence of parasites, parasitism has not been considered among the list of regulatory factors in animal populations until recently. A detailed long-term study on the impact of the direct life-cycle nematode Heligmosomoides polygyrus on a breeding population of laboratory mice provides a clear example of the ability of helminths to regulate host abundance. In the absence of the parasite, the mouse population equilibrated at a density of 320 mice/m2 as a result of density-dependent effects on recruitment. When the parasite was added and transmission was maintained at high levels, infected mouse populations equilibrated at densities of less than 18 mice/m2. Reduced rates of parasite transmission and elimination of the parasite from the system both resulted in an increase in mouse density. These results have implications for both ecology and parasitology as they demonstrate a potentially important but often ignored component of host populations that may well influence host abundance and community structure.

Heligmosomoides polygyrus (Nematoda): the dynamics of primary and repeated infection in outbred mice

The population dynamics of Heligmosomoides polygyrus were studied in outbred male MF1 mice subject either to primary or repeated experimental infection. Little variability in susceptibility was observed between mice, but heterogeneity increased with both duration and intensity of primary infection; this result indicates that there are differences in parasite survival between hosts. The rate of parasite-induced host mortality was 4 X 10(-4) per parasite per host per parasite lifespan. The mortality rates of male and female larvae during their development in the intestinal wall were estimated as 0.033 and 0.021 per parasite per day respectively, and estimates of the expected lifespans of the adult male and female parasites in primary infection of 11.22 and 9.92 weeks were obtained. Approximately 40% of female worms were observed in copula at any one time, although this proportion was significantly depressed in hosts harbouring fewer than 50 parasites and during the first four weeks of infection. Parasite fecundity was markedly age-dependent; each female worm produced approximately 31,000 eggs during its lifespan. No density dependence in either worm survival or fecundity in primary infection was apparent. The only detectable effect of worm density was in association with spatial distribution in the intestine; high levels of infection were associated with a posterior shift in the location of a proportion of the parasite population. Characterization of the dynamics of primary infection allowed predictions to be made about the expected dynamics of repeated infection. The comparison of predicted results and observed data revealed unequivocal epidemiological evidence for the density-dependent regulation of parasite population growth during repeated infection, affecting both parasite survival and parasite fecundity. The results also demonstrated the existence of two types of host individual in which the dynamics of repeated infection were markedly different. It is concluded that immunological differences between mice (possibly under genetic control) may be responsible for the observed effects; approximately 25% of MF1 mice seem unable to generate any protective immunity against H. polygyrus, whereas 75% become almost completely refractory to reinfection. This experimental system could be used for quantitative investigation of the impact of acquired immunity and genetic heterogeneity on helminth population dynamics. Both are of obvious relevance with respect to the control of infections of medical and veterinary significance.

The suppression of homologous immunity by soluble adult antigens of Nematospiroides dubius

An established adult infection of Nematospiroides dubius was unaffected by the administration of immune lymphocytes and immune sera whereas an incoming larval infection was expelled. Past experiments have shown that the immune inoculum at least had the ability to recognize adult stages, leading to the hypothesis that adult stages secrete or excrete an immunomodulatory shield around themselves in the gastrointestinal tract. This hypothesis was given further credence by the demonstration that soluble antigens derived from adults abolished the generation of homologous immunity to this parasite. Modulation of immunity was reflected by increased fecundity, increased worm size, and increased survival time in the gut.

Litomosoides carinii in jirds (Meriones unguiculatus): ability to retard development of challenge larvae can be transferred with cells and serum

To test the ability of cells and/or serum from jirds (Meriones unguiculatus) infected with Litomosoides carinii to transfer the ability to retard development of challenge larvae, a series of transfer experiments were done. Groups of jirds received larval challenge preceded by one of eight preparations: spleen cells and/or serum from 10-day-patent infected jirds; normal spleen cells and/or normal serum; primary larvae; challenge larvae only. No significant differences in size or numbers of larvae recovered were found among groups receiving either cells or serum only. However, significant differences in larval size were found between groups receiving both cells and serum from infected donors and those receiving normal cells and serum. These comparisons indicate that the ability of infected jirds to retard development of challenge infection larvae can be transferred with cells and serum together but not separately.