The self-nonself discrimination: a one- or two-signal mechanism?

On recognizing 'shades-of-gray' (self-nonself discrimination) or 'colour' (Integrity model) by the immune system

The aim is to discuss Cohn's T-cell receptor (TCR) Tritope model of recognition, propose a novel suggestion for prior-to-positive selection of thymocytes contributing to inherent major histocompatibility complex (MHC) reactivity of a T-cell repertoire and clarify the Integrity model about the function of the immune system. If we compare the perception of light with the recognition of nonself, we could imagine that the opacity might be a measure of docking interaction between specific receptors for antigen on T or B cells (TCR/peptide-MHC or BCR/antigen). From this viewpoint, the self-nonself discrimination (S-NS) metaphor would be perception of black (self) versus white (nonself). However, whereas detection of shades-of-gray suffices to describe S-NS discrimination principle, colour vision of the antigenic world portrays best the Integrity model. In concert with recognition of opacity, the Integrity model proposes detection of at least three colours (signals): red (harmful), blue (useful) and yellow (the rest, including homoeostatic ones). As a result, recognition of nonself is transferred into communication within self while deciding on type of the immune response. Hence, the S-NS discrimination model seems to be an oversimplification, because it fails to see colours and consequently lacks the need for suppressor/regulatory function. Similarly, the Danger model stops short of detecting being useful signals that confer immune asylum to helpful micro-organisms like commensals. I suggest that the immune system's repertoire for recognition, in general, has evolved by a novel drive called 'natural integrity' alongside natural selection, thus facilitating communication between cells of the immune system.

On ‘Credo 2004’ as Viewed Under the ‘Development-Context’ Model of Colin Anderson

In analysing the Zinkernagel and Hengartner's 'Credo 2004,' Anderson introduces his 'development-context model' for the immunity-tolerance discrimination. He compares this model with the 'geographical model of Credo 2004' and our 'time-based two-signal model'. The discussion here deals with the advantages and limitations of the Anderson model considered largely at the level of principle. A meaningful discussion requires that we agree on the principle which separates the pathway of the effector output into two decision steps, the sorting of the repertoire and the regulation of effector class. The mechanism for the sorting of the repertoire is what might be referred to as the Self-Nonself discrimination. The black box approach, antigen-in, effector response-out, is what is referred to as the immunity-tolerance discrimination which includes the sorting of the repertoire. If this point of principle is accepted then we are left with a 'time-based two signal default model'.

Requirement of dying cells and environmental adjuvants for the induction of autoimmunity

OBJECTIVE

Cells commonly die without eliciting autoimmunity. However, dying cells are a potential initiating stimulus for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Our goal was to verify whether immune adjuvants influence the autoimmunity induction that ensues following in vivo injection of dying cells.

METHODS

Mice were immunized with apoptotic thymocytes in the presence of artificial moieties, such as Freund's incomplete adjuvant (IFA), or natural adjuvants, such as dendritic cells (DCs). Renal involvement and the development of autoantibodies were monitored.

RESULTS

Apoptotic cells failed to induce clinical disease or to sustain production of autoantibodies in (NZB x NZW)F(1) mice. In contrast, autoimmunity developed in the presence of IFA or DCs. The characteristics of the adjuvant influenced the array of autoantibodies, the kinetics of their development, and the severity of the disease. DCs were required for induction of anti-beta(2)-glycoprotein I IgG. Adjuvants alone did not elicit disease.

CONCLUSION

A "two-hit" signal composed of autoantigens and adjuvants initiates systemic autoimmunity. Moreover, environmental signals at the site of clearance of dead cells shape the features and the severity of the autoimmune disease. Strategies aimed at preventing the accumulation of dying cells and at modulating endogenous adjuvants may be beneficial for the treatment of SLE.

Role of CD40 ligand in Mycobacterium avium infection

Mycobacterium avium is a common opportunistic pathogen in immunocompromised patients such as those infected with human immunodeficiency virus. Although M. avium is an intracellular organism replicating predominantly in macrophages, disseminated M. avium infection is seen in AIDS patients with CD4(+) cell counts of <50 cells/microliters, suggesting a possible involvement of a T cell-macrophage interaction for the elimination of M. avium. To determine whether CD40-CD40 ligand (CD40L) interactions play a role in M. avium infection, we studied the ability of CD40L to restrict M. avium replication in human monocyte-derived macrophages (MDM) in vitro. MDM were infected with M. avium and cocultured with CD40L-transfected 293 cells for 7 days. Intracellular growth of M. avium in these MDM was assessed by colony counting. CD40L-expressing cells inhibited growth of M. avium in MDM by 86.5% +/- 4.2% compared to MDM cultured with control cells. These findings were verified by assays using purified, soluble recombinant human CD40L (CD40LT). CD40LT (5 micrograms/ml) inhibited intracellular growth of M. avium by 76.9% +/- 18.0% compared to cells treated with medium alone. Inhibition by CD40LT was reduced by monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) against CD40 and CD40L. The inhibitory effect of CD40LT was not accompanied by enhancement of interleukin-12 (IL-12) production by M. avium-infected MDM, while CD40L-expressing cells stimulated IL-12 production by these cells. Treatment of M. avium-infected mice with MAb against murine CD40L resulted in recovery of larger numbers of organisms (0.8 to 1.0 log) from the spleens, livers, and lungs of these animals compared to infected mice which received normal immunoglobulin G. These results indicate that CD40-CD40L signaling may be an important step in host immune response against M. avium infection.

Quantitative evidence against inactivation of self-reactive B-cell clones

The frequencies of murine B-cell precursors developing into clones secreting antibodies which bind to autologous (mouse) or heterologous (rabbit or human) forms of the same protein antigen (myosin and albumin) were determined in an attempt to directly test the hypothesis of higher decay rates of B lymphocytes exposed to self-antigens. The results exclude, on a quantitative basis, any form of inactivation or deletion of such cells.

Towards a logical analysis of the immune response

We present a new way to conceive, formalize and analyse models of the immune network. The models proposed are minimal ones, based essentially on the well-established negative feedback loop between helper and suppressor T cells. The occurrence of T-T interactions in both helper and suppressor circuits. These T-T interactions are represented here by autocatalytic feedback loops on TH and TS. The fact that immature B cells are sensitive to negative signaling, as was originally suggested by Lederberg (1959). There is a functional inactivation of immature B cells encountering antigen or anti-idiotypic antibody. This prevents further differentiation to a stage where the B cells become fully responsive. We describe the role of a logical method in the generation and analysis of the models, and the complementarity between this logical method and the more classical description by continuous differential equations. Logical analysis and numerical simulations of the differential equations show that the emerging model accounts for, the occurrence of multiple steady states (a virgin state, a memory state and a non-responsive state) in the absence of antigen, the kinetics of primary and secondary responses, high dose paralysis, low dose of paralysis. Its fit with real situations is surprisingly good for a model of this simplicity. Nevertheless, we give it as an example of what can now be done in the field rather than as a stable model.

Self tolerance is H-2-restricted

H-2 restriction is an established characteristic of T-cell behaviour and, in effect, it means that mouse T cells are activated against foreign antigens only if those antigens are presented in a membrane association with molecules of the mouse major histocompatibility complex, H-2. Whether T-cell inactivation or tolerance is also H-2-restricted is a question which has been tested directly and indirectly several times in the past. In each case the answer was 'No' but in each case the answer was inconclusive. Doubts arose because of the observation that activation of T cells, in vivo, is an H-2-restricted event which appears unrestricted because of antigen processing by the host. If antigen processing is involved in the induction of tolerance, then tolerance might also be an H-2-restricted process disguised to appear unrestricted. We report here a study designed to minimize antigen processing in which we find that T-cell tolerance induction to 'self' minor histocompatibility (H) antigens is indeed H-2-restricted.

A general interactive model for B cell activation II. Experimental verification

The general interactive model described in the previous paper was subjected to experimental testing. We examined the high affinity anti-TNP plaque-forming cell response of cultures of murine lymphocytes exposed to lipopolysaccharide and trinitrophenylated lipopolysaccharide (TNP--LPS). From our model we predicted the effects of the addition of free LPS on the dose response to TNP--LPS, the effect of the addition of Polymyxin B to cultures stimulated with TNP--LPS, and the effect on the response to TNP--LPS preparations with different haptenation ratios. The results obtained were consistent with the predictions of the general interactive model.

A general interactive model for B cell activation. I. The theory

A quantitative model of the B lymphocyte triggering apparatus is proposed in which mitogen receptors and surface immunoglobulins are described as allosteric proteins that interact with mitogens and antigens. An equation is derived that describes the activation of a cell as a function of the states of these receptors as defined by ligand and receptor concentrations, ligand receptor equilibrium constants, and receptor allosteric constants. We analyze the model and show that different parameter sets will actually generate a description of the one-nonspecific-signal model, the matrix model, or the two-signal model of B cell triggering. We suggest that our general interactive model provides a useful conceptual approach to studies of B cell activation because it encompasses other available models that are individually consistent with some experiments, but mutually exclusive to each other. A companion paper describes a series of experiments that verify the consistency of the general model.

Augmentation of in vitro humoral immune responses in the mouse by an antibody to IgD

Heterologous anti-delta-chain antibodies have an adjuvant effect on specific in vivo humoral immune responses to simultaneously, or subsequently, injected antigens in the rat and rhesus monkey. We have used a hybridoma-secreted antibody that binds murine delta-chain of the allotype (4.22aM delta a) to study this phenomenon in the mouse and to investigate the mechanism of this effect. Injection of 4.22aM delta a into BALB/c mice removes almost all surface IgD (sIgD) from splenic B lymphocites. sIgD does not reappear until the serum level of 4.22aM delta a decreased 5-7 d after injection. 4.22aM delta a fails to induce detectable proliferation or to raise total serum Ig levels substantially above control values. However, 4.22aM dalta a injected 24 h before antigen elicits an approximately twofold enhancement of serum IgM and a 3- to 10-fold enhancement of serum IgG anti-trintriphenyl (TNP) antibodies in response to immunization with optimal doses of TNP-Ficoll or TNP-sheep red blood cells (TNP-SRBC). 4.22aM delta a injected 1 wk before or 3 d after TNP-SRBC, however, has no effect on IgG anti-TNP levels. The adjuvant effect of anti-delta-chain antibody was markedly decreased when suboptimal antigen doses were used. Furthermore, even in the case of TNP-Ficoll, a relatively T-independent antigen, the ability of 4.22aM dalta a to enhance the anti-TNP antibody response was T cell dependent. Our data suggest that the binding of anti-delta-chain antibody to cell sIgD may partially activate B lymphocytes and make them more capable of differentiating into antibody-secreting cells when stimulated by antigen-specific T cell help.

Is self tolerance H-2 restricted?

An individual's immune system must be capable of responding to a wide variety of antigens, but must not react against tissues of the individual itself. The specificity of this 'self tolerance' is determined early in life and recent work has dealt with the mechanisms by which self tolerance is maintained. We report here a study designed to determine whether products of the major histocompatibility complex are involved in the induction of self tolerance; in particular, whether the induction of self tolerance in the mouse is H-2 restricted. H-2 restriction refers to the finding that mouse T cells generally recognize foreign antigens only when presented in association with the products of H-2 alleles. We questioned whether T-cell precursors are made tolerant directly by antigen alone, or whether the antigen must be associated in the cell membrane with an appropriate H-2 molecule. We find that T-cell tolerance to 'self' membrane components does not seem to be H-2 restricted and discuss the possibility that this apparent lack of H-2 restriction is due to antigen processing.

Failure of allogeneic thymocytes to survive in nude mice

Athymic nude mice or thymectomized mice, irradiated and reconstituted with T-depleted bone marrow cells ("B mice"), were injected with allogeneic or syngeneic thymocytes bearing caryotypically distinct chromosomes. The fate of the thymocytes was investigated after various periods of time using two methods: (a) frequency of the cells bearing the Thy-1 antigen as detected by immunofluorescence with a heteroantiserum among the recipient spleen cells, (b) presence of chromosomally detectable donor cells in phytohemagglutinin-stimulated spleen cell cultures. These two methods indicate that allogeneic thymocytes disappear after about 7 days, semiallogeneic thymocytes after about 20 days, while syngeneic thymocytes, even when injected in 50 times lower number (10(6) cells), are detectable for months, thanks to the sensitivity of the caryotypic method. Allogeneic thymocytes induce the production of high titers of alloantibodies, which were shown to react specifically against their own H-2, a phenomenon interpreted as a "suicidal" allogeneic collaboration. These experiments demonstrate that the failure of allogeneic thymocytes, in contrast to syngeneic thymocytes, to achieve long-term restoration of the immune responsiveness of T-depleted mice is due to a rejection of the foreign thymocytes, and not to a failure of T and B cells to collaborate across the histocompatibility barrier.

A chemical approach to the mechanism of B-lymphocyte activation. II. The pure presentation of haptens does not inactivate B lymphocytes

Dinitrophenyl (DNP)-lysine-polymethylmethacrylate and DNP-cellulose conjugates do not irreversibly inactivate anti-DNP antigen-sensitive cells, regardless of the dose (up to 10 mg) or persistence of the stimulation (up to 2 weeks). Since these conjugates constitute pure hapten presentations, it is concluded that the pure hapten presentation to B lymphocyte does not irreversibly inactivate them. When murine spleen cells are cultured with Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and (non-immunogenic) DNP-lysine-polymethylmethacrylate or (non-immunogenic) DNP-cellulose conjugates, an anti-DNP immune response occurs. However, replacement of DNP-lysine-polymethylmethacrylate with polymethylmethacrylate, or DNP-cellulose with cellulose, also results in a similar anti-DNP response. It is consequently concluded that the anti-DNP responses are entirely elicited by LPS, the hapten Dnp being inoperative. The anti-DNP response elicited by DNP-Ficoll is, upon exhaustive testing, carrier-dependent. This implies that the mechanism of DNP-Ficoll immunogenicity is not two cooperative signals passed on to B lymphocytes via the hapten DNP. These results argue against any two-signal model of B-lymphocyte activation.

Role of membrane receptors in the induction of an in vitro secondary anti-hapten response. I. differentiation of B memory cells to plasma cells is independent of antigen-immunoglobulin receptor interaction

In these experiments, we show that the interaction of antigen and B cell surface immunoglobulin is not essential for the generation of an IgG in vitro response to the hapten p-azophenyl-lactoside (lac). In our experimental system, keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) was first selectively attached either to H-2, Ia or Ig receptors of lac-primed B cells by a hapten sandwich technique or to Fc receptors by complexes of azophenyl arsonate (ars)-coupled KLH and anti-ars. The labeled cells were then cultured with KLH-specific T cells for 5 days in the absence of antigen. Under all conditions of attachment we observed a significant anti-lac IgG response. We have demonstrated an absolute requirement for KLH-specific helper T cells. The results thus indicate that T helper cells are by themselves, regardless of the B cell antigen that serves to effect bridging, sufficient to activate B memory cells. We could find no evidence to support either a matrix theory or a two-signal hypothesis as currently proposed.

Macrophages in immunobiology

Macrophages are now known to be important not only in resistance to infection but also in immunoregulation, in resistance to tumours and as secretory cells. Among problems requiring further investigation are the ways in which they destroy intracellular organisms, the ways in which they recognize and destroy tumour cells and the extent of their heterogeneity.

Characterization of an inhibitory allogeneic effect on humoral responsiveness in vitro

Evidence is presented that the induction of a humoral response is inhibitable by a thymus-derived cell (TI) that acts on the antigen-sensitive precursors of both the thymus-derived cooperating and the bone marrow-derived antibody-secreting cell-that is, the tC and B cell respectively. The inhibition of induction of the tC and B cell by the TI cell is shown to be reversed by increasing the effective level of cooperation. This competitive interaction between the inhibitory (TI) and cooperating (TC) systems is postulated to be part of the mechanism for regulating the class of the response, cell-mediated or humoral. The following properties of the inhibitory system were demonstrated: [1] The tI cell--the antigen-sensitive precursor of the TI cell--is both paralyzable and inducible. [2] The TI cell appears during the induction of a cell-mediated response and, if not identical to the effector cytotoxic ('killer') TK cell, the TI cell is induced in parallel with it. [3] The effector function of the TI cell, like that of the TK cell, is H-2-restricted.

Lack of effect of thymectomy on spontaneous recovery from tolerance to levan

Adult CBA mice were made tolerant with 1 mg levan and tested subsequently for sponteneous recovery by plaque-forming cell assay in response to immunizing challenge. Weakening of tolerance was first detectable only after 100 days, while return to full normal responsiveness required 400 days. Thymectomy 2 weeks prior to tolerization neither retarded nor diminished the recovery process. Loss of tolerance which had been induced by 1 mg dextran B512 was much slower in onset (greater than 250 days), yet not delayed by thymectomy (full recovery was not followed). These findings in relation to other considerations imply that associative recognition by T cells is not required for B cell responses to these "thymus-independent" antigens.

Characterization of dextran-sulfate-sensitive cells

The cell type participating in the mitotic response to the polyclonal B-cell activator (PBA) dextran-sulfate (DS) was investigated. Cells from murine fetal liver, adult bone marrow, and spleen were studied; only a limited number of all cells present in each organ responded to DS. Morphological studies of the activated cells showed the major population of activated cells in spleen to have the appearance of lymphoblasts. In bone marrow, several classes of hematopoietic cells were mitotically active, including mononuclear cells (lymphoblasts and monocytes), megakaryocytes, and myeloblasts. In these cultures, however, it was not possible to differentiate between DS-activated and spontaneously proliferating cells. Bone marrow and, to some extent, spleen cell cultures activated with DS contained a relative increase in numbers of phagocytic cells, whereas stimulation of spleen cells with lipopolysaccharide did not result in an increased phagocytosis. However, adherent cells were not necessary for activation of DNA synthesis by DS in spleen, and this cell type did not contribute to a measurable degree to the DNA synthetical response. DS cannot be regarded as a general stem cell mitogen for bone marrow cells since it failed to promote colony growth of hematopoietic cells in an in vitro system. However, supernatants from DS-activated spleen and bone marrow cell cultures did stimulate colony growth of murine bone marrow cells, indicating that stem cells of nonlymphoid origin might be indirectly activated by DS. In conclusion, the major cell population activated by DS in spleen is lymphocytes. In bone marrow, other cell types seem to participate in the response as well, but the activation mechanism may be indirect and not primarily the result of DS interaction with these cells.

The lymphocyte plasma membrane: locus of control in the immune response

The lymphocyte plasma membrane is the locus of events which control the immune response. T and B lymphocytes, which mediate cellular and humoral immunity respectively, show distinctive plasma membrane morphologies and cell surface receptors. The dynamic state of these plasma components is emphasized by their lateral mobility in the fluid plane of the membrane, as well as variation in their structure or expression as the lymphocyte proliferates and differentiates in response to stimulation by antigen or mitogens. The best understood membrane glycoproteins are surface membrane immunoglobulins that serve as antigen receptors on B cells, and the histocompatability-beta2 microglobulin complex that has an immunoglobulin-like structure. Other less well defined surface structures showing modulation during the cell cycle may affect growth regulation of proliferating lymphocytes. Some of these are shared by fetal and neoplastic cells. Major theories of lymphocyte signaling are discussed, and the early events in lymphocyte activation are reviewed. While a complete model encompassing all these early events is not yet possible, the central issues can be usefully discussed in term of receptor-transducer-effector concepts derived by strong parallels from a knowledge of hormone-membrane interactions.

A theory of regulation and self-nonself discrimination in an immune network

A mechanism is suggested for the regulation of the immune response that involves antigen-binding and anti-idiotypic lymphocytes. The cross-linking of receptors is postulated to be a general mechanism for triggering T cells, B cells and cytotoxic effector cells (e.g. macrophages). A key role in regulation is ascribed to antigen-specific T cell-dependent factors, which are assumed to be able to block the receptors of both T cells and B cells of the anti-idiotypic specificities. The simple postulates of the model lead to feasible mechanisms for the helper, suppressor and killer roles of T cells, cellular and humoral immune responses, low zone tolerance and the tolerogenic effects of monomers, immune memory, antigenic competition, the abrogation of tolerance with cross-reacting antigens, the usefulness of the switch from IgM to IgG, and self-tolerance to both serum antigens and cell surface antigens. Biological roles are suggested for one of the Ia antigens and beta 2-microglobulin. The theory leads to a number of predictions, which can be tested experimentally. A simple mathematical model is included, which provides an indication of how the theory may be further developed on a quantitative basis.