Adipocytes as a vehicle for ex vivo gene therapy: Novel replacement therapy for diabetes and other metabolic diseases

Novel therapeutic opportunities for familial lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferase deficiency: promises and challenges

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Genetic lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) deficiency is a rare, inherited, recessive disease, which manifests as two different syndromes: Familial LCAT deficiency (FLD) and Fish-eye disease (FED), characterized by low HDL-C and corneal opacity. FLD patients also develop anaemia and renal disease. There is currently no therapy for FLD, but novel therapeutics are at different stages of development. Here, we summarize the most recent advances and the opportunities for and barriers to the further development of such therapies.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent publications highlight the heterogeneous phenotype of FLD and the uncertainty over the natural history of disease and the factors contributing to disease progression. Therapies that restore LCAT function (protein and gene replacement therapies and LCAT activators) showed promising effects on markers of LCAT activity. Although they do not restore LCAT function, HDL mimetics may slow renal disease progression.

SUMMARY

The further development of novel therapeutics requires the identification of efficacy endpoints, which include quantitative biomarkers of disease progression. Because of the heterogeneity of renal disease progression among FLD individuals, future treatments for FLD will have to be tailored based on the specific clinical characteristics of the patient. Extensive studies of the natural history and biomarkers of the disease will be required to achieve this goal.

LCAT-trial-24 weeks: Protocol for a clinical study to evaluate the safety of regenerative medicine and gene therapy by the autologous transplantation of human lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferase gene-transduced human pre-adipocytes

Backgrounds

Despite the absolute need for life-long treatment of inherited and genetic diseases, there has been little effort to develop such treatments for most of these conditions due to their rarity. Familial lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) deficiency is recognized as one such orphan disease. We have been developing an adipocyte-based ex vivo gene therapy/regenerative medicine, a novel methodology that differs from the adeno-associated virus-mediated in vivo gene therapy or ex vivo gene-transduced hematopoietic cell therapy, to treat familial LCAT deficiency. Recently, a first-in-human (FIH) clinical study was conducted under the Act on Securement of Safety of Regenerative Medicine, wherein a patient with familial LCAT deficiency was treated. To obtain approval to put this treatment into practical use, a clinical trial has been designed with reference to the FIH clinical study.

Methods

An interventional, open-label, unblinded dose-escalation trial was planned, referring to previous FIH clinical study. The trial aims to evaluate the safety of the investigational product in relation to the characteristics of the investigational product (ex vivo gene/cell therapy product by retroviral vector-mediated LCAT gene transduction) using two doses, and the efficacy of the treatment will be evaluated exploratively. A total of three patients will be enrolled sequentially and followed for 24 weeks after administration. This study is designed as a multicenter trial, with Chiba University Hospital administering and evaluating the safety/efficacy of the investigational products at the prescribed visit.

Conclusion

This clinical trial is expected to facilitate the provision of lifelong treatment to many patients with LCAT deficiency.

Trial registration number

Japan Registry of Clinical Trials (jRCT2033200096).

•

Familial LCAT deficiency is an orphan disease without any effective treatment.

•

We have been developing a novel adipocyte-based ex vivo gene therapy that enables life-long enzyme replacement.

•

This clinical study was designed to assess the dose-response and the safety in a limited number of orphan disease patients.

•

The protocol includes a preclinical tumorigenicity test in immunodeficient (NSG) mice as one of the primary endpoints.

LCAT- targeted therapies: Progress, failures and future

Lecithin: cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) is the only enzyme in plasma which is able to esterify cholesterol and boost cholesterol esterify with phospholipid-derived acyl chains. In order to better understand the progress of LCAT research, it is always inescapable that it is linked to high-density lipoprotein (HDL) metabolism and reverse cholesterol transport (RCT). Because LCAT plays a central role in HDL metabolism and RCT, many animal studies and clinical studies are currently aimed at improving plasma lipid metabolism by increasing LCAT activity in order to find better treatment options for familial LCAT deficiency (FLD), fish eye disease (FED), and cardiovascular disease. Recombinant human LCAT (rhLCAT) injections, cells and gene therapy, and small molecule activators have been carried out with promising results. Recently rhLCAT therapies have entered clinical phase II trials with good prospects. In this review, we discuss the diseases associated with LCAT and therapies that use LCAT as a target hoping to find out whether LCAT can be an effective therapeutic target for coronary heart disease and atherosclerosis. Also, probing the mechanism of action of LCAT may help better understand the heterogeneity of HDL and the action mechanism of dynamic lipoprotein particles.

Novel lecithin: cholesterol acyltransferase-based therapeutic approaches

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To review recent lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferas (LCAT)-based therapeutic approaches for atherosclerosis, acute coronary syndrome, and LCAT deficiency disorders.

RECENT FINDINGS

A wide variety of approaches to using LCAT as a novel therapeutic target have been proposed. Enzyme replacement therapy with recombinant human LCAT is the most clinically advanced therapy for atherosclerosis and familial LCAT deficiency (FLD), with Phase I and Phase 2A clinical trials recently completed. Liver-directed LCAT gene therapy and engineered cell therapies are also another promising approach. Peptide and small molecule activators have shown efficacy in early-stage preclinical studies. Finally, lifestyle modifications, such as fat-restricted diets, cessation of cigarette smoking, and a diet rich in antioxidants may potentially suppress lipoprotein abnormalities in FLD patients and help preserve LCAT activity and renal function but have not been adequately tested.

SUMMARY

Preclinical and early-stage clinical trials demonstrate the promise of novel LCAT therapies as HDL-raising agents that may be used to treat not only FLD but potentially also atherosclerosis and other disorders with low or dysfunctional HDL.

A Novel Approach to the Treatment of Plasma Protein Deficiency: Ex Vivo-Manipulated Adipocytes for Sustained Secretion of Therapeutic Proteins

Despite the critical need for lifelong treatment of inherited and genetic diseases, there are no developmental efforts for most such diseases due to their rarity. Recent progress in gene therapy, including the approvals of two products (Glybera and Strimvelis) that may provide patients with sustained effects, has shed light on the development of gene therapy products. Most gene therapy products are based on either adeno-associated virus-mediated in vivo gene transfer to target tissues or administration of ex vivo gene-transduced hematopoietic cells. In such circumstances, there is room for different approaches to provide clinicians with other therapeutic options through a variety of principles based on studies not only to gain an understanding of the pathological mechanisms of diseases, but also to understand the physiological functions of target tissues and cells. In this review, we summarize recent progress in gene therapy-mediated enzyme replacement and introduce a different approach using adipocytes to enable lifelong treatment for intractable plasma protein deficiencies.

Gene-manipulated Adipocytes for the Treatment of Various Intractable Diseases

Although protein replacement is an effective treatment for serum protein deficiencies such as diabetes and hemophilia, recombinant protein products are not available for all rare inherited diseases due to the instability of the recombinant proteins and/or to cost. Gene therapy is the most attractive option for treating patients with such rare diseases. To develop an effective ex vivo gene therapy-based protein replacement treatment requires recipient cells that differ from those used in standard gene therapy, which is performed to correct the function of the recipient cells. Adipose tissue is an expected source of proliferative cells for cell-based therapies, including regenerative medicine and gene transfer applications. Based on recent advances in cell biology and extensive clinical experience in transplantation therapy for adipose tissue, we focused on the mature adipocyte fraction, which is the floating fraction after collagenase digestion and centrifugation of adipose tissue. Proliferative adipocytes were propagated from the floating fraction by the ceiling culture technique. These cells are designated as ceiling culture-derived proliferative adipocytes (ccdPAs). We first focused on lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) deficiency, an inherited metabolic disorder caused by lcat gene mutation, and ccdPAs as a therapeutic gene vehicle for LCAT replacement therapy. In our recent in vitro and animal model studies, we developed an adipose cell manipulation procedure using advanced gene transduction methods and transplantation scaffolds. We herein introduce the progress made in novel adipose tissue-based therapeutic strategies for the treatment of protein deficiencies and describe their future applications for other intractable diseases.

Lipoprotein subfractions highly associated with renal damage in familial lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferase deficiency

OBJECTIVE

In familial lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) deficiency (FLD), deposition of abnormal lipoproteins in the renal stroma ultimately leads to renal failure. However, fish-eye disease (FED) does not lead to renal damage although the causative mutations for both FLD and FED lie within the same LCAT gene. This study was performed to identify the lipoproteins important for the development of renal failure in genetically diagnosed FLD in comparison with FED, using high-performance liquid chromatography with a gel filtration column.

APPROACH AND RESULTS

Lipoprotein profiles of 9 patients with LCAT deficiency were examined. Four lipoprotein fractions specific to both FLD and FED were identified: (1) large lipoproteins (>80 nm), (2) lipoproteins corresponding to large low-density lipoprotein (LDL), (3) lipoproteins corresponding to small LDL to large high-density lipoprotein, and (4) to small high-density lipoprotein. Contents of cholesteryl ester and triglyceride of the large LDL in FLD (below detection limit and 45.8±3.8%) and FED (20.7±6.4% and 28.0±6.5%) were significantly different, respectively. On in vitro incubation with recombinant LCAT, content of cholesteryl ester in the large LDL in FLD, but not in FED, was significantly increased (to 4.2±1.4%), whereas dysfunctional high-density lipoprotein was diminished in both FLD and FED.

CONCLUSIONS

Our novel analytic approach using high-performance liquid chromatography with a gel filtration column identified large LDL and high-density lipoprotein with a composition specific to FLD, but not to FED. The abnormal lipoproteins were sensitive to treatment with recombinant LCAT and thus may play a causal role in the renal pathology of FLD.

Nephrotic syndrome caused by immune-mediated acquired LCAT deficiency

Lecithin-cholesterol acyltransferase (LCAT) is an enzyme involved in maintaining cholesterol homeostasis. In familial LCAT deficiency (FLD), abnormal lipid deposition causes renal injury and nephrotic syndrome, frequently progressing to ESRD. Here, we describe a 63-year-old Japanese woman with no family history of renal disease who presented with nephrotic syndrome. The laboratory data revealed an extremely low level of serum HDL and undetectable serum LCAT activity. Renal biopsy showed glomerular lipid deposition with prominent accumulation of foam cells, similar to the histologic findings of FLD. In addition, she had subepithelial electron-dense deposits compatible with membranous nephropathy, which are not typical of FLD. A mixing test and coimmunoprecipitation study demonstrated the presence of an inhibitory anti-LCAT antibody in the patient's serum. Immunohistochemistry and immunofluorescence detected LCAT along parts of the glomerular capillary walls, suggesting that LCAT was an antigen responsible for the membranous nephropathy. Treatment with steroids resulted in complete remission of the nephrotic syndrome, normalization of serum LCAT activity and HDL level, and disappearance of foam cell accumulation in renal tissue. In summary, inhibitory anti-LCAT antibody can lead to glomerular lesions similar to those observed in FLD.

Phosphate-catalyzed degradation of D-glucosone in aqueous solution is accompanied by C1-C2 transposition

Pathways in the degradation of the C(6) 1,2-dicarbonyl sugar (osone) D-glucosone 2 (D-arabino-hexos-2-ulose) in aqueous phosphate buffer at pH 7.5 and 37 °C have been investigated by (13)C and (1)H NMR spectroscopy with the use of singly and doubly (13)C-labeled isotopomers of 2. Unlike its 3-deoxy analogue, 3-deoxy-D-glucosone (3-deoxy-D-erythro-hexos-2-ulose) (1), 2 does not degrade via a 1,2-hydrogen shift mechanism but instead initially undergoes C1-C2 bond cleavage to yield d-ribulose 3 and formate. The latter bond cleavage occurs via a 1,3-dicarbonyl intermediate initially produced by enolization at C3 of 2. However, a careful monitoring of the fates of the sketetal carbons of 2 during its conversion to 3 revealed unexpectedly that C1-C2 bond cleavage is accompanied by C1-C2 transposition in about 1 out of every 10 transformations. Furthermore, the degradation of 2 is catalyzed by inorganic phosphate (P(i)), and by the P(i)-surrogate, arsenate. C1-C2 transposition was also observed during the degradation of the C(5) osone, D-xylosone (D-threo-pentose-2-ulose), showing that this transposition may be a common feature in the breakdown of 1,2-dicarbonyl sugars bearing an hydroxyl group at C3. Mechanisms involving the reversible formation of phosphate adducts to 2 are proposed to explain the mode of P(i) catalysis and the C1-C2 transposition. These findings suggest that the breakdown of 2 in vivo is probably catalyzed by P(i) and likely involves C1-C2 transposition.

Fibrin glue is a candidate scaffold for long-term therapeutic protein expression in spontaneously differentiated adipocytes in vitro

Adipose tissue is expected to provide a source of cells for protein replacement therapies via auto-transplantation. However, the conditioning of the environment surrounding the transplanted adipocytes for their long-term survival and protein secretion properties has not been established. We have recently developed a preparation procedure for preadipocytes, ceiling culture-derived proliferative adipocytes (ccdPAs), as a therapeutic gene vehicle suitable for stable gene product secretion. We herein report the results of our evaluation of using fibrin glue as a scaffold for the transplanted ccdPAs for the expression of a transduced gene in a three-dimensional culture system. The ccdPAs secreted the functional protein translated from an exogenously transduced gene, as well as physiological adipocyte proteins, and the long viability of ccdPAs (up to 84 days) was dependent on the fibrinogen concentrations. The ccdPAs spontaneously accumulated lipid droplets, and their expression levels of the transduced exogenous gene with its product were maintained for at least 56 days. The fibrinogen concentration modified the adipogenic differentiation of ccdPAs and their exogenous gene expression levels, and the levels of exogenously transduced gene expression at the different fibrinogen concentrations were dependent on the extent of adipogenic differentiation in the gel. These results indicate that fibrin glue helps to maintain the high adipogenic potential of cultured adipocytes after passaging in a 3D culture system, and suggests that once they are successfully implanted at the transplantation site, the cells exhibit increased expression of the transduced gene with adipogenic differentiation.