Dynamic regulation of archaeal proteasome gate opening as studied by TROSY NMR

Bortezomib Inhibits Open Configurations of the 20S Proteasome

Bortezomib, a small dipeptide-like molecule, is a proteasome inhibitor used widely in the treatment of myeloma and lymphoma. This molecule reacts with threonine side chains near the center of the 20S proteasome and disrupts proteostasis by blocking enzymatic sites that are responsible for protein degradation. In this work, we use novel mass-spectrometry-based techniques to examine the influence of bortezomib on the structures and stabilities of the 20S core particle. These studies indicate that bortezomib binding dramatically favors compact 20S structures (in which the axial gate is closed) over larger structures (in which the axial gate is open)─suppressing gate opening by factors of at least ∼400 to 1300 over the temperature range that is studied. Thus, bortezomib may also restrict degradation in the 20S proteasome by preventing substrates from entering the catalytic pore. That bortezomib influences structures at the entrance region of the pore at such a long distance (∼65 to 75 Å) from its binding sites raises a number of interesting biophysical issues.

Occupancy of the HbYX hydrophobic pocket is sufficient to induce gate opening in the archaeal 20S proteasomes

Enhancing proteasome function has been a long-standing but challenging target of interest for the potential treatment of neurodegenerative diseases, emphasizing the importance of understanding proteasome activation mechanisms. Most proteasome activator complexes use the C-terminal HbYX motif to bind and trigger gate-opening in the 20S proteasome. This study defines a critical molecular interaction in the HbYX mechanism that triggers gate opening. Here, we focus on the Hb site interaction and find it plays a surprisingly central and crucial role in driving the allosteric conformational changes that induce gate opening in the archaeal 20S. We examined the cryo-EM structure of two mutant archaeal proteasomes, αV24Y T20S and αV24F T20S. These two mutants were engineered to place a bulky aromatic residue in the HbYX hydrophobic pocket and both mutants are highly active, though their mechanisms of activation are undefined. Collectively, our findings indicate that the interaction between the Hb group of the HbYX motif and its corresponding hydrophobic pocket is sufficient to induce gate opening in a mechanistically similar way to the HbYX motif. The involved activation mechanism appears to involve expansion of this hydrophobic binding site affecting the state of the IT switch to triggering gate-opening. Furthermore, we show that the canonical αK66 residue, understood to be critical for proteasome activator binding, plays a key role in stabilizing the open gate, irrespective of activator binding. This study differentiates between the residues in the HbYX motif that support binding interactions ("YX") versus those that allosterically contribute to gate opening (Hb). The insights reported here will guide future drug development efforts, particularly in designing small molecule proteasome activators, by targeting the identified hydrophobic pocket.

Differential Interactions of the Proteasome Inhibitor PI31 with Constitutive and Immuno-20S Proteasomes

PI31 (Proteasome Inhibitor of 31,000 Da) is a 20S proteasome binding protein originally identified as an in vitro inhibitor of 20S proteasome proteolytic activity. Recently reported cryo-electron microscopy structures of 20S-PI31 complexes have revealed that the natively disordered proline-rich C-terminus of PI31 enters the central chamber in the interior of the 20S proteasome and interacts directly with the proteasome's multiple catalytic threonine residues in a manner predicted to inhibit their enzymatic function while evading its own proteolysis. Higher eukaryotes express an alternative form of the 20S proteasome (termed "immuno-proteasome") that features genetically and functionally distinct catalytic subunits. The effect of PI31 on immuno-proteasome function is unknown. We examine the relative inhibitory effects of PI31 on purified constitutive (20Sc) and immuno-(20Si) 20S proteasomes in vitro and show that PI31 inhibits 20Si hydrolytic activity to a significantly lesser degree than that of 20Sc. Unlike 20Sc, 20Si hydrolyzes the carboxyl-terminus of PI31 and this effect contributes to the reduced inhibitory activity of PI31 toward 20Si. Conversely, loss of 20Sc inhibition by PI31 point mutants leads to PI31 degradation by 20Sc. These results demonstrate unexpected differential interactions of PI31 with 20Sc and 20Si and document their functional consequences.

Biomolecular NMR in the AI-assisted structural biology era: Old tricks and new opportunities

Over the last 40 years nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has established itself as one of the most versatile techniques for the characterization of biomolecules, especially proteins. Given the molecular size limitations of NMR together with recent advances in cryo-electron microscopy and artificial intelligence-assisted protein structure prediction, the bright future of NMR in structural biology has been put into question. In this mini review we argue the contrary. We discuss the unique opportunities solution NMR offers to the protein chemist that distinguish it from all other experimental or computational methods, and how it can benefit from machine learning.

Activation of caspase-9 on the apoptosome as studied by methyl-TROSY NMR

Mitochondrial apoptotic signaling cascades lead to the formation of the apoptosome, a 1.1-MDa heptameric protein scaffold that recruits and activates the caspase-9 protease. Once activated, caspase-9 cleaves and activates downstream effector caspases, triggering the onset of cell death through caspase-mediated proteolysis of cellular proteins. Failure to activate caspase-9 enables the evasion of programmed cell death, which occurs in various forms of cancer. Despite the critical apoptotic function of caspase-9, the structural mechanism by which it is activated on the apoptosome has remained elusive. Here, we used a combination of methyl-transverse relaxation-optimized NMR spectroscopy, protein engineering, and biochemical assays to study the activation of caspase-9 bound to the apoptosome. In the absence of peptide substrate, we observed that both caspase-9 and its isolated protease domain (PD) only very weakly dimerize with dissociation constants in the millimolar range. Methyl-NMR spectra of isotope-labeled caspase-9, within the 1.3-MDa native apoptosome complex or an engineered 480-kDa apoptosome mimic, reveal that the caspase-9 PD remains monomeric after recruitment to the scaffold. Binding to the apoptosome, therefore, organizes caspase-9 PDs so that they can rapidly and extensively dimerize only when substrate is present, providing an important layer in the regulation of caspase-9 activation. Our work highlights the unique role of NMR spectroscopy to structurally characterize protein domains that are flexibly tethered to large scaffolds, even in cases where the molecular targets are in excess of 1 MDa, as in the present example.

Minimal mechanistic component of HbYX-dependent proteasome activation that reverses impairment by neurodegenerative-associated oligomers

The implication of reduced proteasomal function in neurodegenerative diseases combined with studies showing the protective effects of increasing proteasome activity in animal models highlight the need to understand the capacity for proteasome activation by small molecules. The C-terminal HbYX motif is present on many proteasome binding proteins and functions to tether activators to the 20S core particle. Previous studies have shown that peptides with a HbYX motif can autonomously activate 20S gate-opening to allow protein degradation. In this study, through an iterative process of peptide synthesis, we design a HbYX-like dipeptide mimetic that represents only the fundamental components of the HbYX motif. The mimetic robustly induces gate-opening in archaeal, yeast, and mammalian proteasomes. We identify multiple proteasome α subunit residues in the archaeal proteasome involved in HbYX-dependent activation. When stimulated by the mimetic, the mammalian 20S can degrade unfolded proteins such as tau. Findings using our peptide mimetic suggest the HbYX-dependent mechanism requires cooperative binding in at least two intersubunit pockets of the α ring. Most significantly, our peptide mimetic reverses proteasome impairment by neurodegenerative disease-associated oligomers. Collectively, these results validate HbYX-like molecules as having robust potential to stimulate proteasome function, which are potentially useful for treating neurodegenerative diseases.

Ηigh-resolution structure of mammalian PI31-20S proteasome complex reveals mechanism of proteasome inhibition

Proteasome-catalyzed protein degradation mediates and regulates critical aspects of many cellular functions and is an important element of proteostasis in health and disease. Proteasome function is determined in part by the types of proteasome holoenzymes formed between the 20S core particle that catalyzes peptide bond hydrolysis and any of multiple regulatory proteins to which it binds. One of these regulators, PI31, was previously identified as an in vitro 20S proteasome inhibitor, but neither the molecular mechanism nor the possible physiologic significance of PI31-mediated proteasome inhibition has been clear. Here we report a high-resolution cryo-EM structure of the mammalian 20S proteasome in complex with PI31. The structure shows that two copies of the intrinsically disordered carboxyl terminus of PI31 are present in the central cavity of the closed-gate conformation of the proteasome and interact with proteasome catalytic sites in a manner that blocks proteolysis of substrates but resists their own degradation. The two inhibitory polypeptide chains appear to originate from PI31 monomers that enter the catalytic chamber from opposite ends of the 20S cylinder. We present evidence that PI31 can inhibit proteasome activity in mammalian cells and may serve regulatory functions for the control of cellular proteostasis.

Method of Monitoring 26S Proteasome in Cells Revealed the Crucial Role of PSMA3 C-Terminus in 26S Integrity

Proteasomes critically regulate proteostasis via protein degradation. Proteasomes are multi-subunit complexes composed of the 20S proteolytic core particle (20S CP) that, in association with one or two 19S regulatory particles (19S RPs), generates the 26S proteasome, which is the major proteasomal complex in cells. Native gel protocols are used to investigate the 26S/20S ratio. However, a simple method for detecting these proteasome complexes in cells is missing. To this end, using CRISPR technology, we YFP-tagged the endogenous PSMB6 (β1) gene, a 20S CP subunit, and co-tagged endogenous PSMD6 (Rpn7), a 19S RP subunit, with the mScarlet fluorescent protein. We observed the colocalization of the YFP and mScarlet fluorescent proteins in the cells, with higher nuclear accumulation. Nuclear proteasomal granules are formed under osmotic stress, and all were positive for YFP and mScarlet. Previously, we have reported that PSMD1 knockdown, one of the 19 RP subunits, gives rise to a high level of "free" 20S CPs. Intriguingly, under this condition, the 20S-YFP remained nuclear, whereas the PSMD6-mScarlet was mostly in cytoplasm, demonstrating the distinct subcellular distribution of uncapped 20S CPs. Lately, we have shown that the PSMA3 (α7) C-terminus, a 20S CP subunit, binds multiple intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs). Remarkably, the truncation of the PSMA3 C-terminus is phenotypically reminiscent of PSMD1 knockdown. These data suggest that the PSMA3 C-terminal region is critical for 26S proteasome integrity.

A methyl-TROSY based 13C relaxation dispersion NMR experiment for studies of chemical exchange in proteins

A methyl Transverse Relaxation Optimized Spectroscopy (methyl-TROSY) based, multiple quantum (MQ) ¹³C Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) relaxation dispersion NMR experiment is described. The experiment is derived from the previously developed MQ ¹³C-¹H CPMG scheme (Korzhnev in J Am Chem Soc 126: 3964-73, 2004) supplemented with a CPMG train of refocusing ¹H pulses applied with constant frequency and synchronized with the ¹³C CPMG pulse train. The optimal ¹H 'decoupling' scheme that minimizes the amount of fast-relaxing methyl MQ magnetization present during CPMG intervals, makes use of an XY-4 phase cycling of the refocusing composite ¹H pulses. For small-to-medium sized proteins, the MQ ¹³C CPMG experiment has the advantage over its single quantum (SQ) ¹³C counterpart of significantly reducing intrinsic, exchange-free relaxation rates of methyl coherences. For high molecular weight proteins, the MQ ¹³C CPMG experiment eliminates complications in the interpretation of MQ ¹³C-¹H CPMG relaxation dispersion profiles arising from contributions to exchange from differences in methyl ¹H chemical shifts between ground and excited states. The MQ ¹³C CPMG experiment is tested on two protein systems: (1) a triple mutant of the Fyn SH3 domain that interconverts slowly on the chemical shift time scale between the major folded state and an excited state folding intermediate; and (2) the 82-kDa enzyme Malate Synthase G (MSG), where chemical exchange at individual Ile δ1 methyl positions occurs on a much faster time-scale.

High-resolution structure of mammalian PI31â€"20S proteasome complex reveals mechanism of proteasome inhibition

Proteasome-catalyzed protein degradation mediates and regulates critical aspects of many cellular functions and is an important element of proteostasis in health and disease. Proteasome function is determined in part by the types of proteasome holoenzymes formed between the 20S core particle that catalyzes peptide bond hydrolysis and any of multiple regulatory proteins to which it binds. One of these regulators, PI31, was previously identified as an in vitro 20S proteasome inhibitor, but neither the molecular mechanism nor the possible physiologic significance of PI31-mediated proteasome inhibition has been clear. Here we report a high- resolution cryo-EM structure of the mammalian 20S proteasome in complex with PI31. The structure shows that two copies of the intrinsically-disordered carboxyl-terminus of PI31 are present in the central cavity of the closed-gate conformation of the proteasome and interact with proteasome catalytic sites in a manner that blocks proteolysis of substrates but resists their own degradation. The two inhibitory polypeptide chains appear to originate from PI31 monomers that enter the catalytic chamber from opposite ends of the 20S cylinder. We present evidence that PI31 can inhibit proteasome activity in mammalian cells and may serve regulatory functions for the control of cellular proteostasis.

The C-Terminus of the PSMA3 Proteasome Subunit Preferentially Traps Intrinsically Disordered Proteins for Degradation

The degradation of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) by a non-26S proteasome process does not require proteasomal targeting by polyubiquitin. However, whether and how IDPs are recognized by the non-26S proteasome, including the 20S complex, remains unknown. Analyses of protein interactome datasets revealed that the 20S proteasome subunit, PSMA3, preferentially interacts with many IDPs. In vivo and cell-free experiments revealed that the C-terminus of PSMA3, a 69-amino-acids-long fragment, is an IDP trapper. A recombinant trapper is sufficient to interact with many IDPs, and blocks IDP degradation in vitro by the 20S proteasome, possibly by competing with the native trapper. In addition, over a third of the PSMA3 trapper-binding proteins have previously been identified as 20S proteasome substrates and, based on published datasets, many of the trapper-binding proteins are associated with the intracellular proteasomes. The PSMA3-trapped IDPs that are proteasome substrates have the unique features previously recognized as characteristic 20S proteasome substrates in vitro. We propose a model whereby the PSMA3 C-terminal region traps a subset of IDPs to facilitate their proteasomal degradation.

Protein Data Bank: A Comprehensive Review of 3D Structure Holdings and Worldwide Utilization by Researchers, Educators, and Students

The Research Collaboratory for Structural Bioinformatics Protein Data Bank (RCSB PDB), funded by the United States National Science Foundation, National Institutes of Health, and Department of Energy, supports structural biologists and Protein Data Bank (PDB) data users around the world. The RCSB PDB, a founding member of the Worldwide Protein Data Bank (wwPDB) partnership, serves as the US data center for the global PDB archive housing experimentally-determined three-dimensional (3D) structure data for biological macromolecules. As the wwPDB-designated Archive Keeper, RCSB PDB is also responsible for the security of PDB data and weekly update of the archive. RCSB PDB serves tens of thousands of data depositors (using macromolecular crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, electron microscopy, and micro-electron diffraction) annually working on all permanently inhabited continents. RCSB PDB makes PDB data available from its research-focused web portal at no charge and without usage restrictions to many millions of PDB data consumers around the globe. It also provides educators, students, and the general public with an introduction to the PDB and related training materials through its outreach and education-focused web portal. This review article describes growth of the PDB, examines evolution of experimental methods for structure determination viewed through the lens of the PDB archive, and provides a detailed accounting of PDB archival holdings and their utilization by researchers, educators, and students worldwide.

The role of structural dynamics in the thermal adaptation of hyperthermophilic enzymes

Proteins from hyperthermophilic organisms are evolutionary optimised to adopt functional structures and dynamics under conditions in which their mesophilic homologues are generally inactive or unfolded. Understanding the nature of such adaptation is of crucial interest to clarify the underlying mechanisms of biological activity in proteins. Here we measured NMR residual dipolar couplings of a hyperthermophilic acylphosphatase enzyme at 80°C and used these data to generate an accurate structural ensemble representative of its native state. The resulting energy landscape was compared to that obtained for a human homologue at 37°C, and additional NMR experiments were carried out to probe fast (¹⁵N relaxation) and slow (H/D exchange) backbone dynamics, collectively sampling fluctuations of the two proteins ranging from the nanosecond to the millisecond timescale. The results identified key differences in the strategies for protein-protein and protein-ligand interactions of the two enzymes at the respective physiological temperatures. These include the dynamical behaviour of a β-strand involved in the protection against aberrant protein aggregation and concerted motions of loops involved in substrate binding and catalysis. Taken together these results elucidate the structure-dynamics-function relationship associated with the strategies of thermal adaptation of protein molecules.

Motional clustering in supra-τc conformational exchange influences NOE cross-relaxation rate

Biomolecular spin relaxation processes, such as the NOE, are commonly modeled by rotational τ_c-tumbling combined with fast motions on the sub-τ_c timescale. Motions on the supra-τ_c timescale, in contrast, are considered to be completely decorrelated to the molecular tumbling and therefore invisible. Here, we show how supra-τ_c dynamics can nonetheless influence the NOE build-up between methyl groups. This effect arises because supra-τ_c motions can cluster the fast-motion ensembles into discrete states, affecting distance averaging as well as the fast-motion order parameter and hence the cross-relaxation rate. We present a computational approach to estimate methyl-methyl cross-relaxation rates from extensive (>100×τ_c) all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) trajectories on the example of the 723-residue protein Malate Synthase G. The approach uses Markov state models (MSMs) to resolve transitions between metastable states and thus to discriminate between sub-τ_c and supra-τ_c conformational exchange. We find that supra-τ_c exchange typically increases NOESY cross-peak intensities. The methods described in this work extend the theory of modeling sub-μs dynamics in spin relaxation and thus contribute to a quantitative estimation of NOE cross-relaxation rates from MD simulations, eventually leading to increased precision in structural and functional studies of large proteins.

Structural basis of protein substrate processing by human mitochondrial high-temperature requirement A2 protease

Protein aggregates are often toxic, leading to impaired cellular activities and disease. The human HtrA2 trimeric enzyme cleaves such aggregates, and mutations in HtrA2 are causative for various neurodegenerative disorders, such as Parkinson’s disease and essential tremor. The mechanism by which cleavage occurs has been studied using small peptides, but little information is available as to how HtrA2 protects cells from the pathologic effects of aggregation involving protein molecules that can form well-folded structures. Using solution NMR spectroscopy, we investigated the structural dynamics of the interaction between HtrA2 and a model protein substrate, demonstrating that HtrA2 preferentially binds to an unfolded substrate ensemble and providing insights into how HtrA2 function is regulated.

The human high-temperature requirement A2 (HtrA2) protein is a trimeric protease that cleaves misfolded proteins to protect cells from stresses caused by toxic, proteinaceous aggregates, and the aberrant function of HtrA2 is closely related to the onset of neurodegenerative disorders. Our methyl-transverse relaxation optimized spectroscopy (TROSY)–based NMR studies using small-peptide ligands have previously revealed a stepwise activation mechanism involving multiple distinct conformational states. However, very little is known about how HtrA2 binds to protein substrates and if the distinct conformational states observed in previous peptide studies might be involved in the processing of protein clients. Herein, we use solution-based NMR spectroscopy to investigate the interaction between the N-terminal Src homology 3 domain from downstream of receptor kinase (drk) with an added C-terminal HtrA2-binding motif (drkN SH3-PDZbm) that exhibits marginal folding stability and serves as a mimic of a physiological protein substrate. We show that drkN SH3-PDZbm binds to HtrA2 via a two-pronged interaction, involving both its C-terminal PDZ-domain binding motif and a central hydrophobic region, with binding occurring preferentially via an unfolded ensemble of substrate molecules. Multivalent interactions between several clients and a single HtrA2 trimer significantly stimulate the catalytic activity of HtrA2, suggesting that binding avidity plays an important role in regulating substrate processing. Our results provide a thermodynamic, kinetic, and structural description of the interaction of HtrA2 with protein substrates and highlight the importance of a trimeric architecture for function as a stress-protective protease that mitigates aggregation.

Functional control of a 0.5 MDa TET aminopeptidase by a flexible loop revealed by MAS NMR

Large oligomeric enzymes control a myriad of cellular processes, from protein synthesis and degradation to metabolism. The 0.5 MDa large TET2 aminopeptidase, a prototypical protease important for cellular homeostasis, degrades peptides within a ca. 60 Å wide tetrahedral chamber with four lateral openings. The mechanisms of substrate trafficking and processing remain debated. Here, we integrate magic-angle spinning (MAS) NMR, mutagenesis, co-evolution analysis and molecular dynamics simulations and reveal that a loop in the catalytic chamber is a key element for enzymatic function. The loop is able to stabilize ligands in the active site and may additionally have a direct role in activating the catalytic water molecule whereby a conserved histidine plays a key role. Our data provide a strong case for the functional importance of highly dynamic - and often overlooked - parts of an enzyme, and the potential of MAS NMR to investigate their dynamics at atomic resolution.

Probing allosteric interactions in homo-oligomeric molecular machines using solution NMR spectroscopy

Developments in solution NMR spectroscopy have significantly impacted the biological questions that can now be addressed by this methodology. By means of illustration, we present here a perspective focusing on studies of a number of molecular machines that are critical for cellular homeostasis. The role of NMR in elucidating the structural dynamics of these important molecules is emphasized, focusing specifically on intersubunit allosteric communication in homo-oligomers. In many biophysical studies of oligomers, allostery is inferred by showing that models specifically including intersubunit communication best fit the data of interest. Ideally, however, experimental studies focusing on one subunit of a multisubunit system would be performed as an important complement to the more traditional bulk measurements in which signals from all components are measured simultaneously. Using an approach whereby asymmetric molecules are prepared in concert with NMR experiments focusing on the structural dynamics of individual protomers, we present examples of how intersubunit allostery can be directly observed in high-molecular-weight protein systems. These examples highlight some of the unique roles of solution NMR spectroscopy in studies of complex biomolecules and emphasize the important synergy between NMR and other atomic resolution biophysical methods.

Local Deuteration Enables NMR Observation of Methyl Groups in Proteins from Eukaryotic and Cell-Free Expression Systems

Therapeutically relevant proteins such as GPCRs, antibodies and kinases face clear limitations in NMR studies due to the challenges in site-specific isotope labeling and deuteration in eukaryotic expression systems. Here we describe an efficient and simple method to observe the methyl groups of leucine residues in proteins expressed in bacterial, eukaryotic or cell-free expression systems without modification of the expression protocol. The method relies on simple stereo-selective 13 C-labeling and deuteration of leucine that alleviates the need for additional deuteration of the protein. The spectroscopic benefits of "local" deuteration are examined in detail through Forbidden Coherence Transfer (FCT) experiments and simulations. The utility of this labeling method is demonstrated in the cell-free synthesis of bacteriorhodopsin and in the insect-cell expression of the RRM2 domain of human RBM39.

Structural Fluctuations of the Human Proteasome α7 Homo-Tetradecamer Double Ring Imply the Proteasomal α-Ring Assembly Mechanism

The 20S proteasome, which is composed of layered α and β heptameric rings, is the core complex of the eukaryotic proteasome involved in proteolysis. The α7 subunit is a component of the α ring, and it self-assembles into a homo-tetradecamer consisting of two layers of α7 heptameric rings. However, the structure of the α7 double ring in solution has not been fully elucidated. We applied cryo-electron microscopy to delineate the structure of the α7 double ring in solution, revealing a structure different from the previously reported crystallographic model. The D7-symmetrical double ring was stacked with a 15° clockwise twist and a separation of 3 Å between the two rings. Two more conformations, dislocated and fully open, were also identified. Our observations suggest that the α7 double-ring structure fluctuates considerably in solution, allowing for the insertion of homologous α subunits, finally converting to the hetero-heptameric α rings in the 20S proteasome.

Entropic Inhibition: How the Activity of a AAA+ Machine Is Modulated by Its Substrate-Binding Domain

ClpB is a tightly regulated AAA+ disaggregation machine. Each ClpB molecule is composed of a flexibly attached N-terminal domain (NTD), an essential middle domain (MD) that activates the machine by tilting, and two nucleotide-binding domains. The NTD is not well-characterized structurally and is commonly considered to serve as a dispensable substrate-binding domain. Here, we use single-molecule FRET spectroscopy to directly monitor the real-time dynamics of ClpB's NTD and reveal its unexpected autoinhibitory function. We find that the NTD fluctuates on the microsecond time scale, and these dynamics result in steric hindrance that limits the conformational space of the MD to restrict its tilting. This leads to significantly inhibited ATPase and disaggregation activities of ClpB, an effect that is alleviated upon binding of a substrate protein or the cochaperone DnaK. This entropic inhibition mechanism, which is mediated by ultrafast motions of the NTD and is not dependent on any strong interactions, might be common in related ATP-dependent proteases and other multidomain proteins to ensure their fast and reversible activation.

Structure, Dynamics and Function of the 26S Proteasome

The 26S proteasome is the most complex ATP-dependent protease machinery, of ~2.5 MDa mass, ubiquitously found in all eukaryotes. It selectively degrades ubiquitin-conjugated proteins and plays fundamentally indispensable roles in regulating almost all major aspects of cellular activities. To serve as the sole terminal "processor" for myriad ubiquitylation pathways, the proteasome evolved exceptional adaptability in dynamically organizing a large network of proteins, including ubiquitin receptors, shuttle factors, deubiquitinases, AAA-ATPase unfoldases, and ubiquitin ligases, to enable substrate selectivity and processing efficiency and to achieve regulation precision of a vast diversity of substrates. The inner working of the 26S proteasome is among the most sophisticated, enigmatic mechanisms of enzyme machinery in eukaryotic cells. Recent breakthroughs in three-dimensional atomic-level visualization of the 26S proteasome dynamics during polyubiquitylated substrate degradation elucidated an extensively detailed picture of its functional mechanisms, owing to progressive methodological advances associated with cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM). Multiple sites of ubiquitin binding in the proteasome revealed a canonical mode of ubiquitin-dependent substrate engagement. The proteasome conformation in the act of substrate deubiquitylation provided insights into how the deubiquitylating activity of RPN11 is enhanced in the holoenzyme and is coupled to substrate translocation. Intriguingly, three principal modes of coordinated ATP hydrolysis in the heterohexameric AAA-ATPase motor  were discovered to regulate intermediate functional steps of the proteasome, including ubiquitin-substrate engagement, deubiquitylation, initiation of substrate translocation and processive substrate degradation. The atomic dissection of the innermost working of the 26S proteasome opens up a new era in our understanding of the ubiquitin-proteasome system and has far-reaching implications in health and disease.

A suite of 19F based relaxation dispersion experiments to assess biomolecular motions

Proteins and nucleic acids are highly dynamic bio-molecules that can populate a variety of conformational states. NMR relaxation dispersion (RD) methods are uniquely suited to quantify the associated kinetic and thermodynamic parameters. Here, we present a consistent suite of ¹⁹F-based CPMG, on-resonance R_1ρ and off-resonance R_1ρ RD experiments. We validate these experiments by studying the unfolding transition of a 7.5 kDa cold shock protein. Furthermore we show that the ¹⁹F RD experiments are applicable to very large molecular machines by quantifying dynamics in the 360 kDa half-proteasome. Our approach significantly extends the timescale of chemical exchange that can be studied with ¹⁹F RD, adds robustness to the extraction of exchange parameters and can determine the absolute chemical shifts of excited states. Importantly, due to the simplicity of ¹⁹F NMR spectra, it is possible to record complete datasets within hours on samples that are of very low costs. This makes the presented experiments ideally suited to complement static structural information from cryo-EM and X-ray crystallography with insights into functionally relevant motions.

Analyzing multi-step ligand binding reactions for oligomeric proteins by NMR: Theoretical and computational considerations

Solution NMR spectroscopy is widely used to investigate the thermodynamics and kinetics of the binding of ligands to their biological receptors, as it provides detailed, atomistic information, potentially leading to microscopic affinities for each binding event, and, to the development of allosteric pathways describing how the binding at one site affects distal sites in the molecule. Importantly, weak interactions that are often invisible to other biophysical methods can also be probed. Methodological advancements in NMR have enabled the investigation of high molecular weight, homo-oligomeric complexes that bind multiple ligand molecules, with increasing numbers of studies of the structural dynamics and binding properties of these systems. It therefore becomes of interest to consider how binding and kinetics parameters can be extracted from experiments on these more complicated molecules. Here we present the theoretical framework for analyzing binding reactions of homo-oligomeric complexes by NMR, taking into account all of the chemical species in solution and their corresponding NMR observables. A number of simulations are presented to illustrate the utility of the derived expressions.

A methyl-TROSY approach for NMR studies of high-molecular-weight DNA with application to the nucleosome core particle

The development of methyl-transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy (methyl-TROSY)-based NMR methods, in concert with robust strategies for incorporation of methyl-group probes of structure and dynamics into the protein of interest, has facilitated quantitative studies of high-molecular-weight protein complexes. Here we develop a one-pot in vitro reaction for producing NMR quantities of methyl-labeled DNA at the C5 and N6 positions of cytosine (5mC) and adenine (6mA) nucleobases, respectively, enabling the study of high-molecular-weight DNA molecules using TROSY approaches originally developed for protein applications. Our biosynthetic strategy exploits the large number of naturally available methyltransferases to specifically methylate DNA at a desired number of sites that serve as probes of structure and dynamics. We illustrate the methodology with studies of the 153-base pair Widom DNA molecule that is simultaneously methyl-labeled at five sites, showing that high-quality 13C-1H spectra can be recorded on 100 μM samples in a few minutes. NMR spin relaxation studies of labeled methyl groups in both DNA and the H2B histone protein component of the 200-kDa nucleosome core particle (NCP) establish that methyl groups at 5mC and 6mA positions are, in general, more rigid than Ile, Leu, and Val methyl probes in protein side chains. Studies focusing on histone H2B of NCPs wrapped with either wild-type DNA or DNA methylated at all 26 CpG sites highlight the utility of NMR in investigating the structural dynamics of the NCP and how its histone core is affected through DNA methylation, an important regulator of transcription.

Biophysical Properties of HP1-Mediated Heterochromatin

Heterochromatin is a classic context for studying the mechanisms of chromatin organization. At the core of a highly conserved type of heterochromatin is the complex formed between chromatin methylated on histone H3 lysine 9 and HP1 proteins. This type of heterochromatin plays central roles in gene repression, genome stability, and nuclear mechanics. Systematic studies over the last several decades have provided insight into the biophysical mechanisms by which the HP1-chromatin complex is formed. Here, we discuss these studies together with recent findings indicating a role for phase separation in heterochromatin organization and function. We suggest that the different functions of HP1-mediated heterochromatin may rely on the increasing diversity being uncovered in the biophysical properties of HP1-chromatin complexes.

Automated assignment of methyl NMR spectra from large proteins

As structural biology trends towards larger and more complex biomolecular targets, a detailed understanding of their interactions and underlying structures and dynamics is required. The development of methyl-TROSY has enabled NMR spectroscopy to provide atomic-resolution insight into the mechanisms of large molecular assemblies in solution. However, the applicability of methyl-TROSY has been hindered by the laborious and time-consuming resonance assignment process, typically performed with domain fragmentation, site-directed mutagenesis, and analysis of NOE data in the context of a crystal structure. In response, several structure-based automatic methyl assignment strategies have been developed over the past decade. Here, we present a comprehensive analysis of all available methods and compare their input data requirements, algorithmic strategies, and reported performance. In general, the methods fall into two categories: those that primarily rely on inter-methyl NOEs, and those that utilize methyl PRE- and PCS-based restraints. We discuss their advantages and limitations, and highlight the potential benefits from standardizing and combining different methods.

An allosteric switch regulates Mycobacterium tuberculosis ClpP1P2 protease function as established by cryo-EM and methyl-TROSY NMR

The 300-kDa ClpP1P2 protease from Mycobacterium tuberculosis collaborates with the AAA+ (ATPases associated with a variety of cellular activities) unfoldases, ClpC1 and ClpX, to degrade substrate proteins. Unlike in other bacteria, all of the components of the Clp system are essential for growth and virulence of mycobacteria, and their inhibitors show promise as antibiotics. MtClpP1P2 is unique in that it contains a pair of distinct ClpP1 and ClpP2 rings and also requires the presence of activator peptides, such as benzoyl-leucyl-leucine (Bz-LL), for function. Understanding the structural basis for this requirement has been elusive but is critical for the rational design and improvement of antituberculosis (anti-TB) therapeutics that target the Clp system. Here, we present a combined biophysical and biochemical study to explore the structure-dynamics-function relationship in MtClpP1P2. Electron cryomicroscopy (cryo-EM) structures of apo and acyldepsipeptide-bound MtClpP1P2 explain their lack of activity by showing loss of a key β-sheet in a sequence known as the handle region that is critical for the proper formation of the catalytic triad. Methyl transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy (TROSY)-based NMR, cryo-EM, and biochemical assays show that, on binding Bz-LL or covalent inhibitors, MtClpP1P2 undergoes a conformational change from an inactive compact state to an active extended structure that can be explained by a modified Monod-Wyman-Changeux model. Our study establishes a critical role for the handle region as an on/off switch for function and shows extensive allosteric interactions involving both intra- and interring communication that regulate MtClpP1P2 activity and that can potentially be exploited by small molecules to target M. tuberculosis.

Exploring long-range cooperativity in the 20S proteasome core particle from Thermoplasma acidophilum using methyl-TROSY-based NMR

The 20S core particle (CP) proteasome is a molecular assembly catalyzing the degradation of misfolded proteins or proteins no longer required for function. It is composed of four stacked heptameric rings that form a barrel-like structure, sequestering proteolytic sites inside its lumen. Proteasome function is regulated by gates derived from the termini of α-rings and through binding of regulatory particles (RPs) to one or both ends of the barrel. The CP is dynamic, with an extensive allosteric pathway extending from one end of the molecule to catalytic sites in its center. Here, using methyl-transverse relaxation optimized spectroscopy (TROSY)-based NMR optimized for studies of high-molecular-weight complexes, we evaluate whether the pathway extends over the entire 150-Å length of the molecule. By exploiting a number of different labeling schemes, the two halves of the molecule can be distinguished, so that the effects of 11S RP binding, or the introduction of gate or allosteric pathway mutations at one end of the barrel can be evaluated at the distal end. Our results establish that while 11S binding and the introduction of key mutations affect each half of the CP allosterically, they do not further couple opposite ends of the molecule. This may have implications for the function of so-called "hybrid" proteasomes where each end of the CP is bound with a different regulator, allowing the CP to be responsive to both RPs simultaneously. The methodology presented introduces a general NMR strategy for dissecting pathways of communication in homo-oligomeric molecular machines.

Methyl TROSY spectroscopy: A versatile NMR approach to study challenging biological systems

A major goal in structural biology is to unravel how molecular machines function in detail. To that end, solution-state NMR spectroscopy is ideally suited as it is able to study biological assemblies in a near natural environment. Based on methyl TROSY methods, it is now possible to record high-quality data on complexes that are far over 100 kDa in molecular weight. In this review, we discuss the theoretical background of methyl TROSY spectroscopy, the information that can be extracted from methyl TROSY spectra and approaches that can be used to assign methyl resonances in large complexes. In addition, we touch upon insights that have been obtained for a number of challenging biological systems, including the 20S proteasome, the RNA exosome, molecular chaperones and G-protein-coupled receptors. We anticipate that methyl TROSY methods will be increasingly important in modern structural biology approaches, where information regarding static structures is complemented with insights into conformational changes and dynamic intermolecular interactions.

Automatic structure-based NMR methyl resonance assignment in large proteins

Isotopically labeled methyl groups provide NMR probes in large, otherwise deuterated proteins. However, the resonance assignment constitutes a bottleneck for broader applicability of methyl-based NMR. Here, we present the automated MethylFLYA method for the assignment of methyl groups that is based on methyl-methyl nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (NOESY) peak lists. MethylFLYA is applied to five proteins (28–358 kDa) comprising a total of 708 isotope-labeled methyl groups, of which 612 contribute NOESY cross peaks. MethylFLYA confidently assigns 488 methyl groups, i.e. 80% of those with NOESY data. Of these, 459 agree with the reference, 6 were different, and 23 were without reference assignment. MethylFLYA assigns significantly more methyl groups than alternative algorithms, has an average error rate of 1%, modest runtimes of 0.4–1.2 h, and can handle arbitrary isotope labeling patterns and data from other types of NMR spectra.

The structures and dynamics of large proteins can be studied with methyl-based NMR but peak assignment is still challenging. Here the authors present MethylFLYA that allows automated assignment of methyl groups and apply it to five proteins with molecular weights in the range from 28 to 358 kDa.

Opportunities and Challenges of Backbone, Sidechain, and RDC Experiments to Study Membrane Protein Dynamics in a Detergent-Free Lipid Environment Using Solution State NMR

Whereas solution state NMR provided a wealth of information on the dynamics landscape of soluble proteins, only few studies have investigated membrane protein dynamics in a detergent-free lipid environment. Recent developments of smaller nanodiscs and other lipid-scaffolding polymers, such as styrene maleic acid (SMA), however, open new and promising avenues to explore the function-dynamics relationship of membrane proteins as well as between membrane proteins and their surrounding lipid environment. Favorably sized lipid-bilayer nanodiscs, established membrane protein reconstitution protocols and sophisticated solution NMR relaxation methods probing dynamics over a wide range of timescales will eventually reveal unprecedented lipid-membrane protein interdependencies that allow us to explain things we have not been able to explain so far. In particular, methyl group dynamics resulting from CEST, CPMG, ZZ exchange, and RDC experiments are expected to provide new and surprising insights due to their proximity to lipids, their applicability in large 100+ kDa assemblies and their simple labeling due to the availability of commercial precursors. This review summarizes the recent developments of membrane protein dynamics with a special focus on membrane protein dynamics in lipid-bilayer nanodiscs. Opportunities and challenges of backbone, side chain and RDC dynamics applied to membrane proteins are discussed. Solution-state NMR and lipid nanodiscs bear great potential to change our molecular understanding of lipid-membrane protein interactions.

Artifacts can emerge in spectra recorded with even the simplest of pulse schemes: an HMQC case study

With the development of sophisticated pulsed field gradient- and phase cycling-approaches for suppressing certain coherence transfer pathways and selecting for others it is sometimes easy to forget that the process is not flawless. In some cases artifacts can emerge because unwanted transfers are immune to the phase cycle or the application of gradients. We consider here a simple ¹H,¹³C HMQC pulse scheme and show that imperfections in the single ¹H 180° refocusing pulse can give rise to small artifacts in methyl spectra that cannot be eliminated through extensive phase cycling or the use of gradients, but that are easily removed when the pulse is of the composite variety.

Preparation of a Well-Defined and Stable β-Barrel Pore-Forming Aβ42 Oligomer

The formation of amyloid-β peptide (Aβ) oligomers at the cellular membrane is considered a crucial process that underlies neurotoxicity in Alzheimer's disease (AD). To obtain structural information on this type of oligomers, we were inspired by membrane protein approaches used to stabilize, characterize, and analyze the function of such proteins. Using these approaches, we developed conditions under which Aβ42, the Aβ variant most strongly linked to the aetiology of AD, assembles into an oligomer that inserts into lipid bilayers as a well-defined pore and adopts a specific structure with characteristics of a β-barrel arrangement. We named this oligomer β-barrel Pore-Forming Aβ42 Oligomer (βPFO_Aβ42). Here, we describe detailed protocols for its preparation and characterization. We expect βPFO_Aβ42 to be useful in establishing the involvement of membrane-associated Aβ oligomers in AD.

Aromatic Ring Dynamics, Thermal Activation, and Transient Conformations of a 468 kDa Enzyme by Specific 1H-13C Labeling and Fast Magic-Angle Spinning NMR

Aromatic residues are located at structurally important sites of many proteins. Probing their interactions and dynamics can provide important functional insight but is challenging in large proteins. Here, we introduce approaches to characterize the dynamics of phenylalanine residues using ¹H-detected fast magic-angle spinning (MAS) NMR combined with a tailored isotope-labeling scheme. Our approach yields isolated two-spin systems that are ideally suited for artifact-free dynamics measurements, and allows probing motions effectively without molecular weight limitations. The application to the TET2 enzyme assembly of ∼0.5 MDa size, the currently largest protein assigned by MAS NMR, provides insights into motions occurring on a wide range of time scales (picoseconds to milliseconds). We quantitatively probe ring-flip motions and show the temperature dependence by MAS NMR measurements down to 100 K. Interestingly, favorable line widths are observed down to 100 K, with potential implications for DNP NMR. Furthermore, we report the first ¹³C R_1ρ MAS NMR relaxation-dispersion measurements and detect structural excursions occurring on a microsecond time scale in the entry pore to the catalytic chamber and at a trimer interface that was proposed as the exit pore. We show that the labeling scheme with deuteration at ca. 50 kHz MAS provides superior resolution compared to 100 kHz MAS experiments with protonated, uniformly ¹³C-labeled samples.

Monitoring Conformational Changes in an Enzyme Conversion Inhibitor Using Pure Shift Exchange NMR Spectroscopy

We report the acquisition of 2D NMR EXSY spectra with ultrahigh resolution, which allows for probing the slow conformational exchange process in a pharmaceutical compound. The resolution enhancement is achieved by implementing interferogram based PSYCHE homonuclear decoupling to generate a pure shift proton spectrum along the direct domain of the resulting data. The performance of this pure shift EXSY pulse sequence is compared to the standard experiment recorded under identical conditions. It is found that although being less sensitive and requiring a longer acquisition time, the quality of pure shift spectra allows for extracting exchange rates values that are coherent with the ones determined by standard approach, on a temperature range that demonstrates the robustness of the chosen homonuclear decoupling method. The resolution enhancement provided by the simplification of proton line shape allows for probing a higher number of proton sites whose analysis would have been biased using a standard method. These results open the way to a thorough and accurate study of chemical exchange processes based on a multi-site analysis of 2D pure shift EXSY spectra.

Characterization of the 20S proteasome of the lepidopteran, Spodoptera frugiperda

Multiple complexes of 20S proteasomes with accessory factors play an essential role in proteolysis in eukaryotic cells. In this report, several forms of 20S proteasomes from extracts of Spodoptera frugiperda (Sf9) cells were separated using electrophoresis in a native polyacrylamide gel and examined for proteolytic activity in the gel and by Western blotting. Distinct proteasome bands isolated from the gel were subjected to liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry and identified as free core particles (CP) and complexes of CP with one or two dimers of assembly chaperones PAC1-PAC2 and activators PA28γ or PA200. In contrast to the activators PA28γ and PA200 that regulate the access of protein substrates to the internal proteolytic chamber of CP in an ATP-independent manner, the 19S regulatory particle (RP) in 26S proteasomes performs stepwise substrate unfolding and opens the chamber gate in an ATP-dependent manner. Electron microscopic analysis suggested that spontaneous dissociation of RP in isolated 26S proteasomes leaves CPs with different gate sizes related presumably to different stages in the gate opening. The primary structure of 20S proteasome subunits in Sf9 cells was determined by a search of databases and by sequencing. The protein sequences were confirmed by mass spectrometry and verified by 2D gel electrophoresis. The relative rates of sequence divergence in the evolution of 20S proteasome subunits, the assembly chaperones and activators were determined by using bioinformatics. The data confirmed the conservation of regular CP subunits and PA28γ, a more accelerated evolution of PAC2 and PA200, and especially high divergence rates of PAC1.

Integrated NMR and cryo-EM atomic-resolution structure determination of a half-megadalton enzyme complex

Atomic-resolution structure determination is crucial for understanding protein function. Cryo-EM and NMR spectroscopy both provide structural information, but currently cryo-EM does not routinely give access to atomic-level structural data, and, generally, NMR structure determination is restricted to small (<30 kDa) proteins. We introduce an integrated structure determination approach that simultaneously uses NMR and EM data to overcome the limits of each of these methods. The approach enables structure determination of the 468 kDa large dodecameric aminopeptidase TET2 to a precision and accuracy below 1 Å by combining secondary-structure information obtained from near-complete magic-angle-spinning NMR assignments of the 39 kDa-large subunits, distance restraints from backbone amides and ILV methyl groups, and a 4.1 Å resolution EM map. The resulting structure exceeds current standards of NMR and EM structure determination in terms of molecular weight and precision. Importantly, the approach is successful even in cases where only medium-resolution cryo-EM data are available.

NMR structure determination is challenging for proteins with a molecular weight above 30 kDa and atomic-resolution structure determination from cryo-EM data is currently not the rule. Here the authors describe an integrated structure determination approach that simultaneously uses NMR and EM data and allows them to determine the structure of the 468 kDa dodecameric aminopeptidase TET2 complex.

A Practical Review of Proteasome Pharmacology

The ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS) degrades individual proteins in a highly regulated fashion and is responsible for the degradation of misfolded, damaged, or unneeded cellular proteins. During the past 20 years, investigators have established a critical role for the UPS in essentially every cellular process, including cell cycle progression, transcriptional regulation, genome integrity, apoptosis, immune responses, and neuronal plasticity. At the center of the UPS is the proteasome, a large and complex molecular machine containing a multicatalytic protease complex. When the efficiency of this proteostasis system is perturbed, misfolded and damaged protein aggregates can accumulate to toxic levels and cause neuronal dysfunction, which may underlie many neurodegenerative diseases. In addition, many cancers rely on robust proteasome activity for degrading tumor suppressors and cell cycle checkpoint inhibitors necessary for rapid cell division. Thus, proteasome inhibitors have proven clinically useful to treat some types of cancer, especially multiple myeloma. Numerous cellular processes rely on finely tuned proteasome function, making it a crucial target for future therapeutic intervention in many diseases, including neurodegenerative diseases, cystic fibrosis, atherosclerosis, autoimmune diseases, diabetes, and cancer. In this review, we discuss the structure and function of the proteasome, the mechanisms of action of different proteasome inhibitors, various techniques to evaluate proteasome function in vitro and in vivo, proteasome inhibitors in preclinical and clinical development, and the feasibility for pharmacological activation of the proteasome to potentially treat neurodegenerative disease.

Aromatic 19F-13C TROSY: a background-free approach to probe biomolecular structure, function, and dynamics

Atomic-level information about the structure and dynamics of biomolecules is critical for an understanding of their function. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy provides unique insights into the dynamic nature of biomolecules and their interactions, capturing transient conformers and their features. However, relaxation-induced line broadening and signal overlap make it challenging to apply NMR spectroscopy to large biological systems. Here we took advantage of the high sensitivity and broad chemical shift range of 19F nuclei and leveraged the remarkable relaxation properties of the aromatic 19F-13C spin pair to disperse 19F resonances in a two-dimensional transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy spectrum. We demonstrate the application of 19F-13C transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy to investigate proteins and nucleic acids. This experiment expands the scope of 19F NMR in the study of the structure, dynamics, and function of large and complex biological systems and provides a powerful background-free NMR probe.

NMR analysis of GPCR conformational landscapes and dynamics

Understanding the signal transduction mechanism mediated by the G Protein-Coupled Receptors (GPCRs) in eukaryote cells represents one of the main issues in modern biology. At the molecular level, various biophysical approaches have provided important insights on the functional plasticity of these complex allosteric machines. In this context, X-ray crystal structures published during the last decade represent a major breakthrough in GPCR structural biology, delivering important information on the activation process of these receptors through the description of the three-dimensional organization of their active and inactive states. In complement to crystals and cryo-electronic microscopy structures, information on the probability of existence of different GPCR conformations and the dynamic barriers separating those structural sub-states is required to better understand GPCR function. Among the panel of techniques available, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy represents a powerful tool to characterize both conformational landscapes and dynamics. Here, we will outline the potential of NMR to address such biological questions, and we will illustrate the functional insights that NMR has brought in the field of GPCRs in the recent years.

Cryo-EM structures of the archaeal PAN-proteasome reveal an around-the-ring ATPase cycle

Proteasomes are ATP-dependent proteases that occur in all three domains of life, and are the principal molecular machines for the regulated degradation of intracellular proteins. The eukaryotic 26S proteasome has been extensively characterized. However, its evolutionary precursor, the archaeal proteasome–ATPase complex, remains poorly understood. The inherent instability of these primordial protein complexes has so far hindered attempts for detailed structure determination. Using cryo-EM single-particle analysis, we were able to determine the structure of an archaeal PAN-proteasome, which is a complex of the proteolytic core and the ATPase PAN (proteasome-activating nucleotidase). The structures reported here not only provide insights into the functional cycle of PAN-proteasomes, they reveal a fundamental mechanism of ATPase operation.

Proteasomes occur in all three domains of life, and are the principal molecular machines for the regulated degradation of intracellular proteins. They play key roles in the maintenance of protein homeostasis, and control vital cellular processes. While the eukaryotic 26S proteasome is extensively characterized, its putative evolutionary precursor, the archaeal proteasome, remains poorly understood. The primordial archaeal proteasome consists of a 20S proteolytic core particle (CP), and an AAA-ATPase module. This minimal complex degrades protein unassisted by non-ATPase subunits that are present in a 26S proteasome regulatory particle (RP). Using cryo-EM single-particle analysis, we determined structures of the archaeal CP in complex with the AAA-ATPase PAN (proteasome-activating nucleotidase). Five conformational states were identified, elucidating the functional cycle of PAN, and its interaction with the CP. Coexisting nucleotide states, and correlated intersubunit signaling features, coordinate rotation of the PAN-ATPase staircase, and allosterically regulate N-domain motions and CP gate opening. These findings reveal the structural basis for a sequential around-the-ring ATPase cycle, which is likely conserved in AAA-ATPases.

What Drives 15N Spin Relaxation in Disordered Proteins? Combined NMR/MD Study of the H4 Histone Tail

Backbone (¹⁵N) NMR relaxation is one of the main sources of information on dynamics of disordered proteins. Yet, we do not know very well what drives ¹⁵N relaxation in such systems, i.e., how different forms of motion contribute to the measurable relaxation rates. To address this problem, we have investigated, both experimentally and via molecular dynamics simulations, the dynamics of a 26-residue peptide imitating the N-terminal portion of the histone protein H4. One part of the peptide was found to be fully flexible, whereas the other part features some transient structure (a hairpin stabilized by hydrogen bonds). The following motional modes proved relevant for ¹⁵N relaxation. 1) Sub-picosecond librations attenuate relaxation rates according to S² ∼0.85-0.90. 2) Axial peptide-plane fluctuations along a stretch of the peptide chain contribute to relaxation-active dynamics on a fast timescale (from tens to hundreds of picoseconds). 3) φ/ψ backbone jumps contribute to relaxation-active dynamics on both fast (from tens to hundreds of picoseconds) and slow (from hundreds of picoseconds to a nanosecond) timescales. The major contribution is from polyproline II (PPII) ↔ β transitions in the Ramachandran space; in the case of glycine residues, the major contribution is from PPII ↔ (β) ↔ rPPII transitions, in which rPPII is the mirror-image (right-handed) version of the PPII geometry, whereas β geometry plays the role of an intermediate state. 4) Reorientational motion of certain (sufficiently long-lived) elements of transient structure, i.e., rotational tumbling, contributes to slow relaxation-active dynamics on ∼1-ns timescale (however, it is difficult to isolate this contribution). In conclusion, recent advances in the area of force-field development have made it possible to obtain viable Molecular Dynamics models of protein disorder. After careful validation against the experimental relaxation data, these models can provide a valuable insight into mechanistic origins of spin relaxation in disordered peptides and proteins.

Methyl-Based NMR Spectroscopy Methods for Uncovering Structural Dynamics in Large Proteins and Protein Complexes

NMR spectroscopy is particularly adept at site-specifically monitoring dynamic processes in proteins, such as protein folding, domain movements, ligand binding, and side-chain rotations. By coupling the favorable spectroscopic properties of highly dynamic side-chain methyl groups with transverse-relaxation-optimized spectroscopy (TROSY), it is now possible to routinely study such dynamic processes in high-molecular-weight proteins and complexes approaching 1 MDa. In this Perspective, we describe many elegant methyl-based NMR experiments that probe slow (second) to fast (picosecond) dynamics in large systems. To demonstrate the power of these methods, we also provide interesting examples of studies that utilized each methyl-based NMR technique to uncover functionally important dynamics. In many cases, the NMR experiments are paired with site-directed mutagenesis and/or other biochemical assays to put the dynamics and function into context. Our vision of the future of structural biology involves pairing methyl-based NMR spectroscopy with biochemical studies to advance our knowledge of the motions large proteins and macromolecular complexes use to choreograph complex functions. Such studies will be essential in elucidating the critical structural dynamics that underlie function and characterizing alterations in these processes that can lead to human disease.

Probing Conformational Diversity of Fc Domains in Aggregation-Prone Monoclonal Antibodies

PURPOSE

Fc domains are an integral component of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and Fc-based fusion proteins. Engineering mutations in the Fc domain is a common approach to achieve desired effector function and clinical efficacy of therapeutic mAbs. It remains debatable, however, whether molecular engineering either by changing glycosylation patterns or by amino acid mutation in Fc domain could impact the higher order structure of Fc domain potentially leading to increased aggregation propensities in mAbs.

METHODS

Here, we use NMR fingerprinting analysis of Fc domains, generated from selected Pfizer mAbs with similar glycosylation patterns, to address this question. Specifically, we use high resolution 2D [¹³C-¹H] NMR spectra of Fc fragments, which fingerprints methyl sidechain bearing residues, to probe the correlation of higher order structure with the storage stability of mAbs. Thermal calorimetric studies were also performed to assess the stability of mAb fragments.

RESULTS

Unlike NMR fingerprinting, thermal melting temperature as obtained from calorimetric studies for the intact mAbs and fragments (Fc and Fab), did not reveal any correlation with the aggregation propensities of mAbs. Despite >97% sequence homology, NMR data suggests that higher order structure of Fc domains could be dynamic and may result in unique conformation(s) in solution.

CONCLUSION

The overall glycosylation pattern of these mAbs being similar, these conformation(s) could be linked to the inherent plasticity of the Fc domain, and may act as early transients to the overall aggregation of mAbs.

Molecular insights into the interaction of Hsp90 with allosteric inhibitors targeting the C-terminal domain

Unique to targeting the C-terminal domain of Hsp90 (C-Hsp90) is the ability to uncouple the cytotoxic and cytoprotective outcomes of Hsp90 modulation. After the identification of novobiocin as a C-Hsp90 interacting ligand a diverse gamut of novologues emerged, from which KU-32 and KU-596 exhibited strong neuroprotective activity. However, further development of these ligands is hampered by the difficulty to obtain structural information on their complexes with Hsp90. Using saturation transfer difference (STD) NMR spectroscopy, we found that the primary binding epitopes of KU-32 and KU596 map at the ring systems of the ligands and specifically the coumarin and biphenyl structures, respectively. Based on both relative and absolute STD effects, we identified KU-596 sites that can be explored to design novel third-generation novologues. In addition, chemical shift perturbations obtained by methyl-TROSY reveal that novologues bind at the cryptic, C-Hsp90 ATP-binding pocket and produce global, long-range structural rearrangements to dimeric Hsp90.

Improving yields of deuterated, methyl labeled protein by growing in H2O

Solution NMR continues to make strides in addressing protein systems of significant size and complexity. A fundamental requirement to fully exploit the ¹⁵N-¹H TROSY and ¹³C-¹H₃ methyl TROSY effects is highly deuterated protein. Unfortunately, traditional overexpression in Escherichia coli (E. coli) during growth on media prepared in D₂O leads to many difficulties and limitations, such as cell toxicity, decreased yield, and the need to unfold or destabilize proteins for back exchange of amide protons. These issues are exacerbated for non-ideal systems such as membrane proteins. Expression of protein during growth in H₂O, with the addition of ²H-labeled amino acids derived from algal extract, can potentially avoid these issues. We demonstrate a novel fermentation methodology for high-density bacterial growth in H₂O M9 medium that allows for appropriate isotopic labeling and deuteration. Yields are significantly higher than those achieved in D₂O M9 for a variety of protein targets while still achieving 75-80% deuteration. Because the procedure does not require bulk D₂O or deuterated glucose, the cost per liter of growth medium is significantly decreased; taking into account improvements in yield, these savings can be quite dramatic. Triple-labeled protein is also efficiently produced including specific ¹³CH₃ labeling of isoleucine, leucine, and valine using the traditional ILV precursors in combination with an ILV-depleted mix of ²H/¹⁵N amino acids. These results are demonstrated for the membrane protein sensory rhodopsin II and the soluble proteins human aldoketoreductase AKR1c3, human ubiquitin, and bacterial flavodoxin. Limitations of the approach in the context of very large molecular weight proteins are illustrated using the bacterial Lac repressor transcription factor.

On the use of Pichia pastoris for isotopic labeling of human GPCRs for NMR studies

NMR studies of human integral membrane proteins provide unique opportunities to probe structure and dynamics at specific locations and on multiple timescales, often with significant implications for disease mechanism and drug development. Since membrane proteins such as G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are highly dynamic and regulated by ligands or other perturbations, NMR methods are potentially well suited to answer basic functional questions (such as addressing the biophysical basis of ligand efficacy) as well as guiding applications (such as novel ligand design). However, such studies on eukaryotic membrane proteins have often been limited by the inability to incorporate optimal isotopic labels for NMR methods developed for large protein/lipid complexes, including methyl TROSY. We review the different expression systems for production of isotopically labeled membrane proteins and highlight the use of the yeast Pichia pastoris to achieve perdeuteration and ¹³C methyl probe incorporation within isoleucine sidechains. We further illustrate the use of this method for labeling of several biomedically significant GPCRs.