Protein engineering of the transcriptional activator FhlA To enhance hydrogen production in Escherichia coli

FhlA is a Formate Binding Protein

Escherichia coli uses glycolysis and mixed acid fermentation and produces formate as by product. One system E. coli uses for formate oxidation is formate hydrogen lyase complex (FHL). The expression of the FHL complex is dependent on formate and regulated by the transcriptional regulator FhlA. The structure of FhlA is composed of three domains. The N-terminal domain is putatively responsible for formate binding and FhlA oligomerization as a tetramer, the central portion of FhlA contains a AAA+ domain that hydrolyzes ATP, and the C-terminal domain binds DNA. Formate enhances FhlA-mediated expression of FHL; however, FhlA direct interaction with formate has never been demonstrated. Formate-protein interactions are challenging to assess, due to the small and ubiquitous nature of the molecule. Here, we have developed three techniques to assess formate-protein interaction. We use these techniques to confirm that FhlA binds formate in the N-terminal domain in vitro, and that this interaction is partially dependent on residues E183 and E363, consistent with previous reports. This study is a proof of concept that these techniques can be used to assess other formate-protein interactions.

Proton conductance and regulation of proton/potassium fluxes in Escherichia coli FhlA-lacking cells during fermentation of mixed carbon sources

Escherichia coli uptake potassium ions with the coupling of proton efflux and energy utilization via proton FOF1-ATPase. In this study contribution of formate hydrogen lyase (FHL) complexes in the proton/potassium fluxes and the formation of proton conductance (CMH+) were investigated using fhlA mutant strain. The proton flux rate (JH+) decreased in fhlA by ∼ 25 % and ∼70 % during the utilization of glucose and glycerol, respectively, at 20 h suggesting H+ transport via or through FHL complexes. The decrease in JK+ in fhlA by ∼40 % proposed the interaction between FHL and Trk secondary transport system during mixed carbon fermentation. Moreover, the usage of N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) demonstrated the mediation of FOF1-ATPase in this interaction. CMH+ was 13.4 nmol min-1 mV-1 in WT at 20 h, which decreased by 20 % in fhlA. Taken together, FHL complexes have a significant contribution to the modulation of H+/K+ fluxes and the CMH + for efficient energy transduction and regulation of the proton motive force during mixed carbon sources fermentation.

Renewable Hydrogen Production and Storage Via Enzymatic Interconversion of CO2 and Formate with Electrochemical Cofactor Regeneration

The urgent need to reduce CO2 emissions has motivated the development of CO2 capture and utilization technologies. An emerging application is CO2 transformation into storage chemicals for clean energy carriers. Formic acid (FA), a valuable product of CO2 reduction, is an excellent hydrogen carrier. CO2 conversion to FA, followed by H2 release from FA, are conventionally chemically catalyzed. Biocatalysts offer a highly specific and less energy-intensive alternative. CO2 conversion to formate is catalyzed by formate dehydrogenase (FDH), which usually requires a cofactor to function. Several FDHs have been incorporated in bioelectrochemical systems where formate is produced by the biocathode and the cofactor is electrochemically regenerated. H2 production from formate is also catalyzed by several microorganisms possessing either formate hydrogenlyase or hydrogen-dependent CO2 reductase complexes. Combination of these two processes can lead to a CO2 -recycling cycle for H2 production, storage, and release with potentially lower environmental impact than conventional methods.

Debottlenecking the biological hydrogen production pathway of dark fermentation: insight into the impact of strain improvement

Confronted with the exhaustion of the earth’s fossil fuel reservoirs, bio-based process to produce renewable energy is receiving significant interest. Hydrogen is considered as an attractive energy carrier that can replace fossil fuels in the future mainly due to its high energy content, recyclability and environment-friendly nature. Biological hydrogen production from renewable biomass or waste materials by dark fermentation is a promising alternative to conventional routes since it is energy-saving and reduces environmental pollution. However, the current yield and evolution rate of fermentative hydrogen production are still low. Strain improvement of the microorganisms employed for hydrogen production is required to make the process competitive with traditional production methods. The present review summarizes recent progresses on the screening for highly efficient hydrogen-producing strains using various strategies. As the metabolic pathways for fermentative hydrogen production have been largely resolved, it is now possible to engineer the hydrogen-producing strains by rational design. The hydrogen yields and production rates by different genetically modified microorganisms are discussed. The key limitations and challenges faced in present studies are also proposed. We hope that this review can provide useful information for scientists in the field of fermentative hydrogen production.

Hydrogen can be generated by microorganisms.

Dark fermentation is efficient for biological hydrogen production.

Strain improvement is critical to enhancing hydrogen-producing ability.

Is energy excess the initial trigger of carbon overflow metabolism? Transcriptional network response of carbon-limited Escherichia coli to transient carbon excess

Background

Escherichia coli adapted to carbon-limiting conditions is generally geared for energy-efficient carbon utilization. This includes also the efficient utilization of glucose, which serves as a source for cellular building blocks as well as energy. Thus, catabolic and anabolic functions are balanced under these conditions to minimize wasteful carbon utilization. Exposure to glucose excess interferes with the fine-tuned coupling of anabolism and catabolism leading to the so-called carbon overflow metabolism noticeable through acetate formation and eventually growth inhibition.

Results

Cellular adaptations towards sudden but timely limited carbon excess conditions were analyzed by exposing slow-growing cells in steady state glucose-limited continuous culture to a single glucose pulse. Concentrations of metabolites as well as time-dependent transcriptome alterations were analyzed and a transcriptional network analysis performed to determine the most relevant transcription and sigma factor combinations which govern these adaptations. Down-regulation of genes related to carbon catabolism is observed mainly at the level of substrate uptake and downstream of pyruvate and not in between in the glycolytic pathway. It is mainly accomplished through the reduced activity of CRP-cAMP and through an increased influence of phosphorylated ArcA. The initiated transcriptomic change is directed towards down-regulation of genes, which contribute to active movement, carbon uptake and catabolic carbon processing, in particular to down-regulation of genes which contribute to efficient energy generation. Long-term changes persisting after glucose depletion and consumption of acetete encompassed reduced expression of genes related to active cell movement and enhanced expression of genes related to acid resistance, in particular acid resistance system 2 (GABA shunt) which can be also considered as an inefficient bypass of the TCA cycle.

Conclusions

Our analysis revealed that the major part of the trancriptomic response towards the glucose pulse is not directed towards enhanced cell proliferation but towards protection against excessive intracellular accumulation of potentially harmful concentration of metabolites including among others energy rich compounds such as ATP. Thus, resources are mainly utilized to cope with “overfeeding” and not for growth including long-lasting changes which may compromise the cells future ability to perform optimally under carbon-limiting conditions (reduced motility and ineffective substrate utilization).

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12934-022-01787-4.

The role of Escherichia coli FhlA transcriptional activator in generation of proton motive force and FO F1 -ATPase activity at pH 7.5

Escherichia coli is able to utilize the mixture of carbon sources and produce molecular hydrogen (H₂ ) via formate hydrogen lyase (FHL) complexes. In current work role of transcriptional activator of formate regulon FhlA in generation of fermentation end products and proton motive force, N'N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD)-sensitive ATPase activity at 20 and 72 hr growth during utilization of mixture of glucose, glycerol, and formate were investigated. It was shown that in fhlA mutant specific growth rate was ~1.5 fold lower compared to wt, while addition of DCCD abolished the growth in fhlA but not in wt. Formate was not utilized in fhlA mutant but wt cells simultaneously utilized formate with glucose. Glycerol utilization started earlier (from 2 hr) in fhlA than in wt. The DCCD-sensitive ATPase activity in wt cells membrane vesicles increased ~2 fold at 72 hr and was decreased 70% in fhlA. Addition of formate in the assays increased proton ATPase activity in wt and mutant strain. FhlA absence mainly affected the ΔpH but not ΔΨ component of Δp in the cells grown at 72 hr but not in 24 hr. The Δp in wt cells decreased from 24 to 72 hr of growth ~40 mV while in fhlA mutant it was stable. Taken together, it is suggested that FhlA regulates the concentration of fermentation end products and via influencing F_O F₁ -ATPase activity contributes to the proton motive force generation.

Activation of a [NiFe]-hydrogenase-4 isoenzyme by maturation proteases

Maturation of [NiFe]-hydrogenases often involves specific proteases responsible for cleavage of the catalytic subunits. Escherichia coli HycI is the protease dedicated to maturation of the Hydrogenase-3 isoenzyme, a component of formate hydrogenlyase-1. In this work, it is demonstrated that a Pectobacterium atrosepticum HycI homologue, HyfK, is required for hydrogenase-4 activity, a component of formate hydrogenlyase-2, in that bacterium. The P. atrosepticum ΔhyfK mutant phenotype could be rescued by either P. atrosepticum hyfK or E. coli hycI on a plasmid. Conversely, an E. coli ΔhycI mutant was complemented by either E. coli hycI or P. atrosepticum hyfK in trans. E. coli is a rare example of a bacterium containing both hydrogenase-3 and hydrogenase-4, however the operon encoding hydrogenase-4 has no maturation protease gene. This work suggests HycI should be sufficient for maturation of both E. coli formate hydrogenlyases, however no formate hydrogenlyase-2 activity was detected in any E. coli strains tested here.

The Role of Some Transcription Factors in Expression of GyrA and GyrB Following Exposure to Ciprofloxacin

Background: GyrA and gyrB genes encode DNA gyrase subunits. This enzyme regulates DNA supercoiling. Inhibitors of this enzyme, such as ciprofloxacin, may change the level of supercoiling and the expression level of genes, including gyrA and gyrB. Objectives: The aims of this research were first to select some transcription factors, which regulate the expression of gyrA and gyrB. Secondly, the effect of these transcription factors was investigated on the expression of these genes in Escherichia coli mutants with different levels of resistance to ciprofloxacin in the presence and absence of these transcription factors. Methods: For this purpose, the online software called Promoter Analyzer in Virtual Footprint version 3 was used to find and select some transcription factors. The relative expression of genes was determined by quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR). Results: Theoretical results showed that CspA, FhlA, and SoxS transcription factors (with a score of match higher than 6), could be selected for further analysis. The expression of gyrA and gyrB genes remained unchanged in the presence and absence of CspA and FhlA transcription factors following exposure to the low amount of ciprofloxacin. However, SoxS transcription activator might have indirect effects on the expression of these genes, as soxS gene was overexpressed following treatment with a higher amount of ciprofloxacin. Conclusions: It is concluded that overexpression of gyrA and gyrB genes is not dependent on CspA and FhlA transcription factors, but may be dependent indirectly on regulatory proteins involved in oxidative stress following exposure to ciprofloxacin.

Enhanced biohydrogen production from cotton stalk hydrolysate of Enterobacter cloacae WL1318 by overexpression of the formate hydrogen lyase activator gene

BACKGROUND

Biohydrogen production from lignocellulose has become an important hydrogen production method due to its diversity, renewability, and cheapness. Overexpression of the formate hydrogen lyase activator (fhlA) gene is a promising tactic for enhancement of hydrogen production in facultative anaerobic Enterobacter. As a species of Enterobacter, Enterobacter cloacae was reported as a highly efficient hydrogen-producing bacterium. However, little work has been reported in terms of cloning and expressing the fhlA gene in E. cloacae for lignocellulose-based hydrogen production.

RESULTS

In this study, the formate hydrogen lyase activator (fhlA) gene was cloned and overexpressed in Enterobacter cloacae WL1318. We found that the recombinant strain significantly enhanced cumulative hydrogen production by 188% following fermentation of cotton stalk hydrolysate for 24 h, and maintained improved production above 30% throughout the fermentation process compared to the wild strain. Accordingly, overexpression of the fhlA gene resulted in an enhanced hydrogen production potential (P) and maximum hydrogen production rate (R _m), as well as a shortened lag phase time (λ) for the recombinant strain. Additionally, the recombinant strain also displayed improved glucose (12%) and xylose (3.4%) consumption and hydrogen yield Y(H₂/S) (37.0%) compared to the wild strain. Moreover, the metabolites and specific enzyme profiles demonstrated that reduced flux in the competitive branch, including succinic, acetic, and lactic acids, and ethanol generation, coupled with increased flux in the pyruvate node and formate splitting branch, benefited hydrogen synthesis.

CONCLUSIONS

The results conclusively prove that overexpression of fhlA gene in E. cloacae WL1318 can effectively enhance the hydrogen production from cotton stalk hydrolysate, and reduce the metabolic flux in the competitive branch. It is the first attempt to engineer the fhlA gene in the hydrogen-producing bacterium E. cloacae. This work provides a highly efficient engineered bacterium for biohydrogen production from fermentation of lignocellulosic hydrolysate in the future.

Pseudogene product YqiG is important for pflB expression and biohydrogen production in Escherichia coli BW25113

Pseudogenes in the Escherichia coli genome are assumed to be non-functional. In this study, Keio collection BW25113∆yqiG and YqiG-producing strain (BW25113/pCA24N-YqiG) were used to evaluate the importance of pseudogene yqiG in hydrogen metabolism. Our results show pseudogene protein YqiG was identified as an essential protein in the production of biohydrogen from glucose. The mutant yqiG decreased biohydrogen production from 37 µmol mg^-1 protein to 6 µmol mg^-1 protein compared to the wild-type strain, and glucose consumption was reduced by 80%. Through transcriptional analysis, we found that the yqiG mutation represses pflB transcription tenfold; pflB encodes pyruvate-formate lyase, one of the key enzymes in the anaerobic metabolism of E. coli. Moreover, production of YqiG stimulated glycolysis and increased biohydrogen productivity 1.5-fold compared to that of the wild-type strain. Thus, YqiG is important for the central glycolysis reaction and is able to influence hydrogen metabolism activity in E. coli.

Transformation of the Anticancer Drug Doxorubicin in the Human Gut Microbiome

Bacteria living in the human gut are implicated in the etiology of several diseases. Moreover, dozens of drugs are metabolized by elements of the gut microbiome, which may have further implications for human health. Here, we screened a collection of gut isolates for their ability to inactivate the widely used antineoplastic drug doxorubicin and identified a strain of Raoultella planticola as a potent inactivator under anaerobic conditions. We demonstrate that R. planticola deglycosylates doxorubicin to metabolites 7-deoxydoxorubicinol and 7-deoxydoxorubicinolone via a reductive deglycosylation mechanism. We further show that doxorubicin is degraded anaerobically by Klebsiella pneumoniae and Escherichia coli BW25113 and present evidence that this phenotype is dependent on molybdopterin-dependent enzyme(s). Deglycosylation of doxorubicin by R. planticola under anaerobic conditions is found to reduce toxicity to the model species Caenorhabditis elegans, providing a model to begin understanding the role of doxorubicin metabolism by microbes in the human gut. Understanding the in vivo metabolism of important therapeutics like doxorubicin by the gut microbiome has the potential to guide clinical dosing to maximize therapeutic benefit while limiting undesirable side effects.

A hemolytic-uremic syndrome-associated strain O113:H21 Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli specifically expresses a transcriptional module containing dicA and is related to gene network dysregulation in Caco-2 cells

Shiga toxin-producing (Stx) Escherichia coli (STEC) O113:H21 strains are associated with human diarrhea and some of these strains may cause hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS). The molecular mechanism underlying this capacity and the differential host cell response to HUS-causing strains are not yet completely understood. In Brazil O113:H21 strains are commonly found in cattle but, so far, were not isolated from HUS patients. Here we conducted comparative gene co-expression network (GCN) analyses of two O113:H21 STEC strains: EH41, reference strain, isolated from HUS patient in Australia, and Ec472/01, isolated from cattle feces in Brazil. These strains were cultured in fresh or in Caco-2 cell conditioned media. GCN analyses were also accomplished for cultured Caco-2 cells exposed to EH41 or Ec472/01. Differential transcriptome profiles for EH41 and Ec472/01 were not significantly changed by exposure to fresh or Caco-2 conditioned media. Conversely, global gene expression comparison of both strains cultured in conditioned medium revealed a gene set exclusively expressed in EH41, which includes the dicA putative virulence factor regulator. Network analysis showed that this set of genes constitutes an EH41 specific transcriptional module. PCR analysis in Ec472/01 and in other 10 Brazilian cattle-isolated STEC strains revealed absence of dicA in all these strains. The GCNs of Caco-2 cells exposed to EH41 or to Ec472/01 presented a major transcriptional module containing many hubs related to inflammatory response that was not found in the GCN of control cells. Moreover, EH41 seems to cause gene network dysregulation in Caco-2 as evidenced by the large number of genes with high positive and negative covariance interactions. EH41 grows slowly than Ec472/01 when cultured in Caco-2 conditioned medium and fitness-related genes are hypoexpressed in that strain. Therefore, EH41 virulence may be derived from its capacity for dysregulating enterocyte genome functioning and its enhanced enteric survival due to slow growth.

First insights into the pleiotropic role of vrf (yedF), a newly characterized gene of Salmonella Typhimurium

Salmonella possesses virulence determinants that allow replication under extreme conditions and invasion of host cells, causing disease. Here, we examined four putative genes predicted to encode membrane proteins (ydiY, ybdJ, STM1441 and ynaJ) and a putative transcriptional factor (yedF). These genes were identified in a previous study of a S. Typhimurium clinical isolate and its multidrug-resistant counterpart. For STM1441 and yedF a reduced ability to interact with HeLa cells was observed in the knock-out mutants, but an increase in this ability was absent when these genes were overexpressed, except for yedF which phenotype was rescued when yedF was restored. In the absence of yedF, decreased expression was seen for: i) virulence-related genes involved in motility, chemotaxis, attachment and survival inside the host cell; ii) global regulators of the invasion process (hilA, hilC and hilD); and iii) factors involved in LPS biosynthesis. In contrast, an increased expression was observed for anaerobic metabolism genes. We propose yedF is involved in the regulation of Salmonella pathogenesis and contributes to the activation of the virulence machinery. Moreover, we propose that, when oxygen is available, yedF contributes sustained repression of the anaerobic pathway. Therefore, we recommend this gene be named vrf, for virulence-related factor.

Anaerobic Formate and Hydrogen Metabolism

Numerous recent developments in the biochemistry, molecular biology, and physiology of formate and H2 metabolism and of the [NiFe]-hydrogenase (Hyd) cofactor biosynthetic machinery are highlighted. Formate export and import by the aquaporin-like pentameric formate channel FocA is governed by interaction with pyruvate formate-lyase, the enzyme that generates formate. Formate is disproportionated by the reversible formate hydrogenlyase (FHL) complex, which has been isolated, allowing biochemical dissection of evolutionary parallels with complex I of the respiratory chain. A recently identified sulfido-ligand attached to Mo in the active site of formate dehydrogenases led to the proposal of a modified catalytic mechanism. Structural analysis of the homologous, H2-oxidizing Hyd-1 and Hyd-5 identified a novel proximal [4Fe-3S] cluster in the small subunit involved in conferring oxygen tolerance to the enzymes. Synthesis of Salmonella Typhimurium Hyd-5 occurs aerobically, which is novel for an enterobacterial Hyd. The O2-sensitive Hyd-2 enzyme has been shown to be reversible: it presumably acts as a conformational proton pump in the H2-oxidizing mode and is capable of coupling reverse electron transport to drive H2 release. The structural characterization of all the Hyp maturation proteins has given new impulse to studies on the biosynthesis of the Fe(CN)2CO moiety of the [NiFe] cofactor. It is synthesized on a Hyp-scaffold complex, mainly comprising HypC and HypD, before insertion into the apo-large subunit. Finally, clear evidence now exists indicating that Escherichia coli can mature Hyd enzymes differentially, depending on metal ion availability and the prevailing metabolic state. Notably, Hyd-3 of the FHL complex takes precedence over the H2-oxidizing enzymes.

The Model [NiFe]-Hydrogenases of Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, hydrogen metabolism plays a prominent role in anaerobic physiology. The genome contains the capability to produce and assemble up to four [NiFe]-hydrogenases, each of which are known, or predicted, to contribute to different aspects of cellular metabolism. In recent years, there have been major advances in the understanding of the structure, function, and roles of the E. coli [NiFe]-hydrogenases. The membrane-bound, periplasmically oriented, respiratory Hyd-1 isoenzyme has become one of the most important paradigm systems for understanding an important class of oxygen-tolerant enzymes, as well as providing key information on the mechanism of hydrogen activation per se. The membrane-bound, periplasmically oriented, Hyd-2 isoenzyme has emerged as an unusual, bidirectional redox valve able to link hydrogen oxidation to quinone reduction during anaerobic respiration, or to allow disposal of excess reducing equivalents as hydrogen gas. The membrane-bound, cytoplasmically oriented, Hyd-3 isoenzyme is part of the formate hydrogenlyase complex, which acts to detoxify excess formic acid under anaerobic fermentative conditions and is geared towards hydrogen production under those conditions. Sequence identity between some Hyd-3 subunits and those of the respiratory NADH dehydrogenases has led to hypotheses that the activity of this isoenzyme may be tightly coupled to the formation of transmembrane ion gradients. Finally, the E. coli genome encodes a homologue of Hyd-3, termed Hyd-4, however strong evidence for a physiological role for E. coli Hyd-4 remains elusive. In this review, the versatile hydrogen metabolism of E. coli will be discussed and the roles and potential applications of the spectrum of different types of [NiFe]-hydrogenases available will be explored.

Enhanced H2 Production and Redirected Metabolic Flux via Overexpression of fhlA and pncB in Klebsiella HQ-3 Strain

Genetic modifications are considered as one of the most important technologies for improving fermentative hydrogen yield. Herein, we overexpress fhlA and pncB genes from Klebsiella HQ-3 independently to enhance hydrogen molar yield. HQ-3-fhlA/pncB strain is developed by manipulation of pET28-Pkan/fhlA Kan(r) and pBBR1-MCS5/pncB Gm(r) as expression vectors to examine the synchronous effects of fhlA and pncB. Optimization of anaerobic batch fermentations is achieved and the maximum yield of biohydrogen (1.42 mol H2/mol of glucose) is produced in the range of pH 6.5-7.0 at 33-37 °C. Whole cell H2 yield is increased up to 40 % from HQ-3-fhlA/pncB, as compared with HQ-3-fhlA 20 % and HQ-3-pncB 12 % keeping HQ-3-C as a control. Mechanism of improved H2 yield is studied in combination with metabolic flux analysis by measuring glucose consumption and other metabolites including formate, succinate, 2,3 butanediol, lactate, acetate, ethanol, and hydrogen. The results suggest that under transient conditions, the increase in the total level of NAD by NAPRTase can enhance the rate of NADH-dependent pathways, and therefore, final distribution of metabolites is changed. Combined overexpression of fhlA and pncB eventually modifies the energy and carbon balance leading to enhanced H2 production from FHL as well as by NADH pathway.

A comprehensive and quantitative review of dark fermentative biohydrogen production

Biohydrogen production (BHP) can be achieved by direct or indirect biophotolysis, photo-fermentation and dark fermentation, whereof only the latter does not require the input of light energy. Our motivation to compile this review was to quantify and comprehensively report strains and process performance of dark fermentative BHP. This review summarizes the work done on pure and defined co-culture dark fermentative BHP since the year 1901. Qualitative growth characteristics and quantitative normalized results of H2 production for more than 2000 conditions are presented in a normalized and therefore comparable format to the scientific community.Statistically based evidence shows that thermophilic strains comprise high substrate conversion efficiency, but mesophilic strains achieve high volumetric productivity. Moreover, microbes of Thermoanaerobacterales (Family III) have to be preferred when aiming to achieve high substrate conversion efficiency in comparison to the families Clostridiaceae and Enterobacteriaceae. The limited number of results available on dark fermentative BHP from fed-batch cultivations indicates the yet underestimated potential of this bioprocessing application. A Design of Experiments strategy should be preferred for efficient bioprocess development and optimization of BHP aiming at improving medium, cultivation conditions and revealing inhibitory effects. This will enable comparing and optimizing strains and processes independent of initial conditions and scale.

Hydrogen production by recombinant Escherichia coli strains

The production of hydrogen via microbial biotechnology is an active field of research. Given its ease of manipulation, the best‐studied bacterium Escherichia coli has become a workhorse for enhanced hydrogen production through metabolic engineering, heterologous gene expression, adaptive evolution, and protein engineering. Herein, the utility of E. coli strains to produce hydrogen, via native hydrogenases or heterologous ones, is reviewed. In addition, potential strategies for increasing hydrogen production are outlined and whole‐cell systems and cell‐free systems are compared.

GGDEF proteins YeaI, YedQ, and YfiN reduce early biofilm formation and swimming motility in Escherichia coli

The second messenger 3'-5'-cyclic diguanylic acid (c-di-GMP) promotes biofilm formation, and c-di-GMP is synthesized by diguanylate cyclases (characterized by a GGDEF domain) and degraded by phosphodiesterases. Here, we evaluated the effect of the 12 E. coli GGDEF-only proteins on biofilm formation and motility. Deletions of the genes encoding the GGDEF proteins YeaI, YedQ, YfiN, YeaJ, and YneF increased swimming motility as expected for strains with reduced c-di-GMP. Alanine substitution in the EGEVF motif of YeaI abolished its impact on swimming motility. In addition, extracellular DNA (eDNA) was increased as expected for the deletions of yeaI (tenfold), yedQ (1.8-fold), and yfiN (3.2-fold). As a result of the significantly enhanced motility, but contrary to current models of decreased biofilm formation with decreased diguanylate cyclase activity, early biofilm formation increased dramatically for the deletions of yeaI (30-fold), yedQ (12-fold), and yfiN (18-fold). Our results indicate that YeaI, YedQ, and YfiN are active diguanylate cyclases that reduce motility, eDNA, and early biofilm formation and contrary to the current paradigm, the results indicate that c-di-GMP levels should be reduced, not increased, for initial biofilm formation so c-di-GMP levels must be regulated in a temporal fashion in biofilms.