Autoimmunity induced by syngeneic splenocyte membranes carrying irreversibly adsorbed paramyxovirus

Endocochlear inflammation in cochlear implant users: case report and literature review

OBJECTIVES

Cochlear implantation is a relatively safe procedure with a low complication rate. The overall rate of complications among cochlear implant patients ranges from 6% to 20%. Major complications are those that are life-threatening or require surgery, whereas minor complications are those that can be medically treated. Nonetheless, certain complications, even if highly rare, may require specific investigations and treatments. Among these rare complications are those with endocochlear involvement, such as cochleitis or labyrinthitis, with fibrosis or ossification that could lead to explantation. The aims of the present study were to report a particular case of post-operative cochleitis and to review the rate of complications after cochlear implantation, emphasising those conditions with proven endocochlear involvement.

METHODS

We refer to the case of an eight-year-old Italian boy affected by the sudden onset of headache, ipsilateral otalgia and facial paresis, who presented to our clinic for inexplicable worsening of the performance of his implant and his residual hearing, six years after surgery. A complete investigation including (clinical history, routine, autoimmune and serological blood tests, electrophysiological measurements from the cochlear implant and neuroimaging) was performed and is herein described. Additionally, a comprehensive review of the literature was conducted using internet search engines; 274 papers were selected, 88 of which were best suited to our purposes.

RESULTS

In our case, the progression of the symptoms and the performance decrement required explantation, followed by a complete recovery. Reviewing the literature revealed only three reports concerning cases of proven endocochlear phlogosis that required revision surgery. Wound swelling/infection and vertigo remain the two most common complications of cochlear implantation. Failure of the device is the third most frequent complication (10.06% of all complications and 1.53% of cochlear implantations). Other rare conditions (such as granulating labyrinthitis with cochlear fibrosis, ossification and erosion, silicone allergy and the formation of a biofilm around the internal device) are possible and unpredictable. Although rare (approximately 1%), such cases may require explantation.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite efforts by both surgeons and manufacturers, device-related and surgical complications still occur. These and other rare conditions demand specific management, and their frequency may be underestimated. Further studies are needed to assess more realistic rates of complications and devise more efficient strategies for early diagnosis and treatment.

Exacerbation of autoantibody-mediated hemolytic anemia by viral infection

Strong enhancement of the pathogenicity of an antierythrocyte monoclonal antibody was observed after infection of mice with lactate dehydrogenase-elevating virus. While injection of the antierythrocyte antibody alone induced only moderate anemia, concomitant infection with this virus, which is harmless in most normal mice, led to a dramatic drop in the hematocrit and to death of infected animals. In vitro and in vivo analyses showed a dramatic increase in the ability of macrophages from infected mice to phagocytose antibody-coated erythrocytes. These results indicate that viruses can trigger the onset of autoimmune disease by enhancing the pathogenicity of autoantibodies. They may explain how unrelated viruses could be implicated in the etiology of autoantibody-mediated autoimmune diseases.

Coxsackievirus-induced chronic inflammatory myopathy: virus variants distinguish between acute cytopathic effects and pathogenesis of chronic disease

Infection with the Tucson strain of coxsackievirus B1 (CVB1T) causes the development of chronic inflammatory myopathy (CIM) and hind limb weakness in susceptible strains of mice. In this study, a panel of six plaque-purified viruses exhibiting either small or large plaque phenotypes was derived from parental CVB1T and parental CVB1T that had been passaged through monkey kidney cells. All six variants caused similar acute histopathology in muscle, but three of four passaged viruses (AMP1, AMP2, and AMP3) did not induce CIM while the fourth (MP3) caused some hind limb weakness but without associated muscle inflammation. In contrast, both viruses (MP1 and MP2) isolated directly from the parental CVB1T stock were myopathic. Large plaque MP2 caused higher mortality and more rapid inhibition of host cell biosynthesis, but both MP1 and MP2 induced CIM that was comparable to that induced by parental CVB1T. Plaque size was a stable characteristic of the variants but did not correlate with their ability to induce CIM. Five of the six variants showed equivalent levels of replication in muscle, monkey kidney cells, and GB myoblasts while one, AMP3, was selectively impaired for replication. Receptor binding and virus-induced inhibition of host cell transcription and translation were not linked to myopathogenicity. Thus, most of the passaged variants are robust infectious viruses, suggesting that viral induction of CIM does not depend solely on cytopathogenicity during the acute infection.

An attenuated variant of Coxsackievirus B3 preferentially induces immunoregulatory T cells in vivo

BALB/c mice infected with the Woodruff variant of coxsackievirus group B type 3 (CVB3W) develop myocarditis mediated by autoimmune cytolytic T lymphocytes. A variant of CVB3W (designated H3-10A1) which infects the myocardium but induces minimal mortality of myocarditis compared to the parental virus was selected. Although H3-10A1 infections stimulate normal CTL responses to CVB3-infected myocytes, the autoimmune response to myocardial antigens is absent. Treatment of H3-10A1-infected mice with 50 mg of cyclophosphamide per kg of body weight, a treatment which preferentially eliminates suppressor cells, allows both the development of the autoimmune cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response and the expression of myocarditis. Similar treatment of CVB3W-infected mice had no effect on the disease. The presence of the immunoregulatory cells was confirmed by adoptive transfer of T lymphocytes from either H3-10A1 or CVB3W-infected donor mice into syngeneic CVB3W-infected recipients. Animals given H3-10A1-immune cells had minimal myocardial inflammation, while animals given CVB3W-immune lymphocytes developed enhanced cardiac disease. Elimination of the T-lymphocyte population from the donor cells prior to transfer abrogated suppression with the H3-10A1-immune population, showing that immunoregulation depended upon T lymphocytes. Both H3-10A1 and CVB3W have cross-reactive epitopes between the adenine translocator protein and the virion which are indicative of antigenic mimicry and may be the basis for the autoimmunity to cardiac antigens. These results suggest that immunoregulatory T cells may be primarily responsible for the nonpathogenicity of the H3-10A1 variant.

Role of viruses in the pathogenesis of IDDM

Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), also known as type I diabetes, results from the destruction of pancreatic beta cells. During the past few decades, genetic factors, autoimmunity and viral infections have been extensively studied as the possible cause of beta cell destruction. The evidence for virus-induced diabetes comes largely from experiments in animals, but several studies in humans also point to viruses as a trigger of this disease in some cases. There are at least two possible mechanisms for the involvement of viruses in the pathogenesis of IDDM: (a) cytolytic infection of beta cells may result in destruction of the cells without the induction of autoimmunity, or may be a final insult leading to the clinical onset of diabetes in individuals with an already decreased beta cell mass resulting from an autoimmune process; and (b) persistent viral infection (e.g. retrovirus, rubella virus, cytomegalovirus) may result in the triggering of autoimmune IDDM in certain circumstances. Regarding the latter possibility, viruses may insert, expose, or alter antigens in the plasma membrane of the beta cell, which may initiate autoimmunity leading to the destruction of the cells.

Paramyxovirus membrane protein enhances antibody production to new antigenic determinants in the actin molecule: a model for virus-induced autoimmunity

Paramyxovirus membrane (M) protein specifically binds to cellular actin but not to bovine serum albumin or myoglobin, as determined by affinity chromatography and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The binding site for M protein on actin is different from the binding sites for antiactin antibodies. The interaction of M protein with actin resulted in production of antibodies to several new antigenic sites on the actin molecule. Five rabbits immunized with actin alone produced antibodies against the N-terminal sequence (residues 1 to 39). Another five rabbits immunized with a mixture of M protein and actin produced antibodies against a C-terminal fragment and a central region as well as the N-terminal fragment. By immunoblotting with proteolytic fragments of actin, the new antigenic sites were located between amino acid residues 40 to 113, 114 to 226, and 227 to 375. Antisera taken from some patients with recent measles virus infections demonstrated antiactin antibodies to sites other than the N-terminal fragment of actin (amino acids 1 to 39). The interaction of paramyxovirus M protein with actin and the subsequent production of antibodies to new antigenic sites may serve as a model for one of the mechanisms of virus-induced autoimmunity.

The role of viruses and environmental factors in the induction of diabetes

The development of IDDM results from the destruction of pancreatic beta cells. Genetic factors, various immune system alterations, and environmental factors have been studied as the possible causes of IDDM. The concordance rate for developing IDDM between monozygotic twins approaches 50%, suggesting that genetic factors are necessary, but nongenetic factors such as various immune system alterations and environmental factors also influence the clinical expression of genetic susceptibility. Environmental factors (e.g., viruses, chemicals, and diet) affecting the induction of diabetes may act as primary injurious agents which damage pancreatic beta cells or as triggering agents of autoimmunity. Certain viruses including EMC-D and Mengo virus 2T can directly infect pancreatic beta cells and replicate in the cells. The replication of viruses in the beta cells results in the destruction of the cells within 3 days, and the infected mice develop a diabeteslike syndrome in 3-4 days without the involvement of autoimmunity. In contrast, rubella virus appears to be somewhat weakly associated with autoimmune IDDM in hamsters. In addition, endogenous retrovirus expressed in pancreatic beta cells is clearly associated with the development of insulitis and diabetes in NOD mice. In man, there appears to be no correlation between the detection of islet cell autoantibodies and anti-Coxsackie B viral antibodies in newly diagnosed IDDM. In contrast, persistent infection of CMV and rubella virus appears to be associated with the presence of autoantibodies in newly diagnosed IDDM patients. It is particularly noteworthy that human CMV can induce islet cell autoantibodies that react specifically with a 38 kDa islet cell protein which may represent islet cell-specific antigens in a proportion of CMV-associated IDDM cases. These observations suggest that the association of diabetes with Coxsackie B viruses might be due to cytolytic infection of the beta cells with no link to autoimmunity, while both rubella virus and CMV are probably associated with autoimmune IDDM. A number of structurally diverse chemicals including alloxan, streptozotocin, chlorozotocin, Vacor, and cyproheptadine are diabetogenic mainly in rodents and sometimes in man. Possible mechanisms for beta cell destruction by these chemicals include (a) generation of oxygen free radicals and alteration of endogenous scavengers of these reactive species; (b) breakage of DNA and a consequent increase in the activity of poly-ADP-ribose synthetase, an enzyme depleting nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide in beta cells; and (c) inhibition of active calcium transport and calmodulin-activated protein kinase activity. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Coxsackievirus-induced disease. CD4+ cells initiate both myocarditis and pancreatitis in DBA/2 mice

DBA/2 male mice inoculated intraperitoneally with 1.8 X 10(5) plaque-forming units (PFU) coxsackievirus B-3 (CVB3) showed extensive inflammatory cell infiltration of the myocardium and acinar tissue of the pancreas in 7 days. Selective depletion of T lymphocyte subpopulations indicated that CD4 cells were either completely or partially responsible for cell damage in both organs. Other organs such as the liver were infected and contained virus titers equivalent to those seen in the heart and pancreas but showed no apparent tissue injury. The role of the CD4 cell was confirmed by positive selection of either T cell subpopulation from CVB3-immune lymphocytes in vitro and adoptive transfer of these cells into T cell-deficient (thymectomized, irradiated, bone marrow reconstituted, TXBM) DBA/2 recipients. Lymphocytes from CVB3-infected donor mice were adsorbed to myocyte, skin fibroblast, or liver vascular endothelial cell (VEC) monolayers. The adherent population was retrieved and adoptively transferred into uninfected syngeneic recipients. When killed 7 days later, the animals receiving unfractionated immune lymphocytes or cells eluted from heart monolayers developed both myocarditis and pancreatitis. Anti-Thy 1.2 and C' treatment of the unfractionated cells completely abrogated transfer of disease. Cells eluted from either fibroblast or liver VEC monolayers showed no pathogenicity. Adsorption of immune cells to heart monolayers in the presence of anti-IAd (class II major histocompatibility complex antigen, MHC) inhibited attachment of the pathogenic T cell, whereas anti KdDd (a class I MHC antigen) had no effect.

Clinical and experimental aspects of viral myocarditis

Picornaviruses are frequently implicated as the etiological agents of acute myocarditis. This association is based historically on serological evidence of rising antibody titers to specific pathogens and more recently on identification of viral genomic material in endocardial biopsy specimens through in situ hybridization. Only rarely is infectious virus isolated from either the patient or the heart during periods of maximum myocardial inflammation and injury. Thus, despite a probable viral etiology, much interest centers on the role of the immune system in cardiac damage and the likelihood that the infection triggers an autoimmune response to heart-specific antigens. Heart-reactive antibodies and T cells are found in most myocarditis patients, and immunosuppressive therapy has proven beneficial in many, though not all, cases. Furthermore, murine models of coxsackievirus group B type 3-induced myocarditis also demonstrate that virus infection initiates autoimmunity and that these autoimmune effectors are predominately responsible for tissue injury. How virus-host interactions overcome presumed self-tolerance to heart antigens is discussed, and evidence supporting various theories of virus-initiated autoimmunity and disease pathogenesis are delineated.

Secondary immune amplification following live poliovirus immunization in humans

Eight subjects inoculated orally with live attenuated poliovirus were investigated to study the effects of live virus infection on human T-cell responses. Proliferation to poliovirus and unrelated recall antigens were measured serially over a 3-week period. Five of eight subjects inoculated demonstrated a clear anamnestic response to poliovirus, but three did not. Only the five subjects demonstrating an anamnestic response to poliovirus were found to have augmented secondary immune responses to two unrelated recall antigens (tetanus toxoid and reovirus) and in the autologous mixed lymphocyte response (AMLR). No consistent changes were found in circulating T-cell surface activation antigens whether or not the subjects responded to poliovirus. These studies suggest that an asymptomatic poliovirus infection associated with immunization in humans can induce nonspecific secondary immune amplification as measured by in vitro T-cell proliferative response. This amplification pathway is a potential mechanism for immune responses against antigens other than those of the infecting virus.

Virus-related pathology: is the continued presence of the virus necessary?

This chapter examines the effect of viruses in inducing modifications in chromosomes, immune system interactions, and cell metabolism to support such a hypothesis that virus may no longer be present when the pathology appears. When vaccines were available to protect the population against the major epidemics, then chronic, recurrent, or persistent infections came into focus. Viruses are everywhere and all organisms are permanently exposed to them. The result of this contact depends on the particular moment a t which a given cell is exposed to the virus. Rubella, for example, provokes a very benign disease in adults, but can induce abnormalities in the differentiating fetus. Although interferon is active against virus aggression, excess interferon has a toxic effect and can block differentiation. The capacity of several viruses to act as cellular mutagens by modifying chromosomes is well established, whatever the molecular mechanism may be. Mutations at the cellular level were carefully analyzed for their tumorigenic potential.