Isolation and preliminary characterization of temperature-sensitive mutants of Newcastle disease virus

Temperature-sensitive phenotype of the human parainfluenza virus type 3 candidate vaccine strain (cp45) correlates with a defect in the L gene

We have previously demonstrated that the temperature sensitivity of a human parainfluenza virus type 3 (HPIV-3) candidate vaccine strain (cp45), which is currently under evaluation in humans, is associated with poor transcriptional activity of the virus at the nonpermissive temperature (R. Ray, K. Meyer, F. Newman, and R. B. Belshe, J. Virol. 69:1959-1963, 1995). In this study, the temperature sensitivity of cp45 virus was further investigated by the complementation of a specific gene function. CV-1 cells were transfected with cloned genes from wild-type HPIV-3 encoding the large protein (L), phosphoprotein (P), and nucleocapsid protein (NP), alone or together, for the expression of biologically active proteins. Only cells expressing the L gene were able to rescue cp45 replication when incubated at the nonpermissive temperature (39.5 degrees C), whereas cells transiently expressing NP or P were incapable of rescuing the virus. The virus titers obtained following complementation of the L protein were 190 to 2,300 PFU/ml of culture medium, compared with the undetectable growth of the cp45 temperature-sensitive mutant at the nonpermissive temperature. Rescued progeny virus still maintained the temperature-sensitive phenotype. Results from this study suggest that the temperature sensitivity of the cp45 candidate vaccine strain is associated primarily with L-protein function and that the defect can be complemented by transient expression of the wild-type protein. This study underscores the importance of the L protein in RNA polymerase activity and its critical role in virus replication.

Characterization of a live, attenuated human parainfluenza type 3 virus candidate vaccine strain

Characterization of a temperature-sensitive and live, attenuated human parainfluenza type 3 virus strain (cp45) grown at a permissive temperature (32 degrees C) suggested that the virus efficiently multiplies in cell lines and retains antigenic and functional properties of the envelope glycoproteins. When grown at a nonpermissive temperature (39.5 degrees C), the cp45 virus exhibited poor replication; however, shifting to a permissive temperature allowed virus growth. Although at a nonpermissive temperature virus polypeptide synthesis was significantly reduced, the hemagglutinin-neuraminidase and fusion glycoproteins were transported to cell surfaces and retained their characteristic biologic activities. Studies on mRNA synthesis from the P protein gene suggested a poor transcriptional activity of the cp45 virus at a nonpermissive temperature. Results from this study indicate that the temperature sensitivity of cp45 virus is related to altered transcriptional activity and a marked reduction in virus polypeptide synthesis.

Intracellular processing of the paramyxovirus F protein: critical role of the predicted amphipathic alpha helix adjacent to the fusion domain

At a nonpermissive temperature, the group D temperature-sensitive mutants of Newcastle disease virus strain Australia-Victoria (AV) are defective in plaque formation, in inducing infected cells to fuse, and in incorporating the cleaved fusion glycoprotein, F1 + F2, into virus particles. In this study, the F protein of AV, expressed in chicken embryo cells, was able to complement these mutants in a plaque assay, identifying the F gene as the gene containing the group D temperature-sensitive lesions. The F genes of mutants D1, D2, and D3 were found to contain single mutations relative to the AV sequence, clustered within a predicted amphipathic alpha helix (AAH) adjacent to the hydrophobic amino terminus of F1. These mutant F proteins were inefficiently processed at the permissive temperature, a problem that was exacerbated at the nonpermissive temperature. Surprisingly, the AV F protein was also found to be partially temperature sensitive in processing. Its AAH is predicted to contain a break in the helix close to the D mutation sites, which are themselves predicted to further weaken the helix at this point. Interestingly, six revertants of the group D mutants were found to have an additional lesion in the AAH, repairing both the AV and mutant helices, resulting in a predicted perfect helix. The F protein of these revertants had overcome both the processing defects of the mutants and the temperature sensitivity of AV, indicating that the AAH region is critical for F protein processing. The lesions of a second group of revertants were localized within F2, suggesting an interaction with the F1 AAH region containing the original lesion.

Identification of amino acid residues important to the neuraminidase activity of the HN glycoprotein of Newcastle disease virus

Monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to three overlapping antigenic sites (designated 12, 2, and 23) on the hemagglutinin-neuraminidase glycoprotein (HN) of Newcastle disease virus (NDV) were previously shown to inhibit neuraminidase activity (NA) on neuraminlactose (R. M. Iorio and M. A. Bratt, 1984a, J. Immunol. 133, 2215-2219; R. M. Iorio et al., 1989, Virus Res. 13, 245-262). However, a competitive inhibitor of NA blocks the binding of only MAbs to site 23, suggesting that the domain they recognize may be closely related to the NA site. Antigenic variants selected with site 23 MAbs have single amino acid substitutions at HN residues 192, 193, or 200. Virions of variants, which have a substitution at residue 193 or 200, have alterations in NA which are not attributable to a commensurate change in HN content. A revertant of a temperature-sensitive mutant, which has markedly diminished NA relative to the wild type, has an amino acid substitution at residue 175. A second step revertant having partially restored NA has an additional substitution at residue 192 identical to that in one of the site 23 variants, which, in turn, also makes the revertant resistant to neutralization by site 23 MAbs. Thus, an amino acid substitution at residue 175, 193, or 200 of the HN of NDV can have marked effects on the NA of the protein. The amino acids in the region around residue 175 are highly conserved between the HNs of NDV and other paramyxoviruses, suggesting that this domain is important to the integrity of the NA site in this group of viruses.

Temperature-sensitive mutants of Newcastle disease virus altered in HN glycoprotein size, stability, or antigenic maturity

It has been suggested that the 11 group B, C, and BC temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of Newcastle disease virus (NDV), strain Australia-Victoria (AV-WT), have lesions in the gene for the hemagglutinin/neuraminidase glycoprotein (HN), and that complementation between groups B and C is intracistronic. Virions produced by these mutants even at permissive temperature contain greatly reduced amounts of HN, and the accompanying hemagglutinating and neuraminidase functions. To explore the basis for decreased HN incorporation into virions and the temperature sensitivity of these mutants, infected chick embryo cells were examined for changes in HN characteristics. The HN of two of the mutants was clearly altered in electrophoretic migration rates in both virions and infected cells. The migrational differences were not due to differences in glycosylation because altered migration rates were also observed in the presence of tunicamycin. In all cases, cells infected by these mutants produced as much HN as did AV-WT-infected cells, but the HN of six of these mutants was metabolically unstable. All of the mutants, including those with metabolically stable HN, exhibited greatly restricted ability to convert HN to an antigenically reactive form, indicating an early block in processing. For most of these mutants, the neuraminidase activities of infected cells were somewhat temperature sensitive, but the production of hemadsorbing activities on cell surfaces was not temperature sensitive. In contrast, the hemadsorbing and neuraminidase activities of cells infected by one mutant, BC2, were temperature sensitive, probably a reflection of the previously described extreme thermolability of the HN of this mutant. The relationship between these mutant characteristics, their temperature sensitivity and the virion phenotypes, is discussed. The data presented here confirm the assignment of these 11 group B, C, and BC mutants to defects in HN and begin to separate them into groups with different characteristics.

Mutation in the matrix protein of Newcastle disease virus can result in decreased fusion glycoprotein incorporation into particles and decreased infectivity

Virus particles produced in eggs by the group D ts mutants of Newcastle disease virus at permissive temperature display low infectious and hemolytic activities (M.E. Peeples and M. A. Bratt , J. Virol. 42:440-446, 1982). These lower activities correlate with a decreased incorporation of F1+2 (fusion glycoprotein) into virus particles, compared with that for wild type. The incorporation of F1+2 into virus particles of the group D mutants is also lower than that for wild type when grown in chicken embryo cells in culture at either permissive or nonpermissive temperature. The infectivity of virions from these mutants correlates with the amounts of F1+2 in the virus particles, below a certain concentration, indicating that the quantity of F1+2 in virus particles is a determining factor in the infectivity of those particles. In addition, one of these mutants, D1, produces an M (matrix protein) which migrates at a faster rate in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Three of four revertants of D1 have coreverted to wild-type M electrophoretic mobility, associating M with the ts lesion and the other observed phenotypes. In each of these revertants, as well as in three revertants each from D2 and D3, there has been coreversion from the low specific infectious and hemolytic activities to greater, and often wild-type, activities. There is also a coreversion for F1+2 incorporation into virions. All of the revertants incorporate F1+2 into virions more efficiently than their mutant parents. The coreversions associate those phenotypes with the ts lesion and, in the case of D1, with the M lesion as well.

Biological consequences of neuraminidase deficiency in Newcastle disease virus

A second-step revertant (L1) of a temperature-sensitive mutant (C1) of Newcastle disease virus agglutinated erythrocytes normally but had less than 3% of the wild-type (strain AV) levels of neuraminidase activity. Revertant L1 had seven times more virion-associated N-acetylneuraminic acid (NANA) than strain AV. NANA residues on purified virions were specifically labeled with periodate and tritiated borohydride. Analyses of radiolabeled L1 virions on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels showed that most of the virion-associated NANA was in a high-molecular-weight component with an electrophoretic mobility different from that of any known viral protein. NANA was also detected in molecules with the electrophoretic mobility of the viral glycoproteins HN and F1. Revertant L1 had a twofold lower rate constant of attachment to HeLa cells than that of the wild-type. Treatment of L1 virions with Vibrio cholerae neuraminidase removed the excess NANA and returned L1 attachment kinetics to normal. Revertant N1, which has 10-fold more neuraminidase activity than L1, penetrated host cells at the same rate as L1. L1 was impaired in elution from erythrocytes. Removal of virion-associated NANA exacerbated this defect. Despite a small disadvantage in attachment and a major defect in elution relative to strain AV, revertant L1 enjoyed a slight advantage over the wild-type during a single reproductive cycle in cultured chicken embryo cells.

Thermostabilities of virion activities of Newcastle disease virus: evidence that the temperature-sensitive mutants in complementation groups B, BC, and C have altered HN proteins

Four virion activities of Newcastle disease virus (hemagglutinating, neuraminidase, hemolytic, and infectious activities) were examined before and after heat stress in low-salt buffer and physiological salt buffer (phosphate-buffered saline). The hemagglutinating and neuraminidase activities of the Australia-Victoria wild-type (AV-WT) strain were thermostable at both salt concentrations tested, whereas the thermostabilities of the hemolytic and infectious activities were salt dependent (thermostable in phosphate-buffered saline but not in low-salt buffer). Virions of RNA(+) temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of AV-WT were tested for the stabilities of the four activities. Some mutants in groups B, BC, and C were as stable as AV-WT in all functions, but others were much less stable in all functions. The unstable mutants in groups B, BC, and C affirmed the assignment of the ts lesions of these mutants to the hemagglutinin/neuraminidase (HN) protein gene because HN function(s) are required for all four activities. The instability of these ts mutants was not related to their decreased virion HN protein content and was not due to physical loss of the HN protein from the virions. Three of four ts(+) plaque-forming revertants of the least stable mutant, BC2, coreverted for stability, confirming that the unstable phenotype is indeed the result of the mutation responsible for the ts phenotype. Group D mutants were approximately as stable as AV-WT in hemagglutinating, neuraminidase, and hemolytic activities; this is consistent with this group representing a lesion in a gene other than the HN protein gene. However, the infectivities of two of the three group D mutants were less stable than the infectivity of AV-WT in low-salt buffer.

RNA synthesis by Newcastle disease virus temperature-sensitive mutants in two RNA-negative complementation groups

The temperature-sensitive RNA-negative mutants of Newcastle disease virus comprise two complementation groups, group A (seven members) and group E (one member). The RNA-synthesizing activities of four representative members of group A and the single member of group E were compared with the activity of the wild type. These mutants were defective to varying extents in primary transcription at the nonpermissive temperature, ranging from mutant A1, which had no activity, to mutant E1, which lost only 50% of its activity. All of the mutants were also defective in a postprimary transcriptive process since after preincubation at the permissive temperature in the presence of cycloheximide, there was no subsequent RNA synthesis at the nonpermissive temperature upon removal of the cycloheximide. Similarly, in experiments in which cycloheximide was not used, shifts from the permissive temperature to the nonpermissive temperature before 3 h postinfection did not result in RNA synthesis. However, later shifts to the nonpermissive temperature did allow RNA synthesis. With the exception of mutant A1, all of the mutants maintained this RNA-synthetic ability for at least 3 h, suggesting that RNA synthesis from progeny genomes was not the major postprimary transcriptive defect in these mutants. In contrast, the RNA-synthetic ability of mutant A1 rapidly decayed at the nonpermissive temperature, suggesting that the A gene product is involved in RNA synthesis from progeny genomes. The postprimary transcriptive defect(s) of the other mutants may be in the processing or stability of a protein, in the processing of mRNA, or in replication. Plaque-forming revertants (ts+) of all of the mutants coreverted for RNA synthesis. This finding strengthens the relationship between temperature sensitivity for plaquing and both the primary and postprimary RNA-negative phenotypes.

Virion functions of RNA+ temperature-sensitive mutants of Newcastle disease virus

Virions from Newcastle disease virus mutants in four temperature-sensitive RNA+ groups were grown in embryonated hen eggs at the permissive temperature, purified, and then analyzed for biological properties at both the permissive and nonpermissive temperatures. At the permissive temperature, virions of mutants in groups B, C, and BC (11 mutants) were all lower in specific (per milligram of protein) hemagglutination, neuraminidase, and hemolysis activities compared with the wild type. These deficiencies were related to decreased amounts of hemagglutinin-neuraminidase glycoprotein in the virions. Activities of these mutant virions at both the permissive and nonpermissive temperatures were similar, indicating that hemagglutinin-neuraminidase synthesized at the permissive temperature was not temperature sensitive in function. The three group D mutants displayed a different pattern. At the permissive temperature, they had wild-type hemagglutination and neuraminidase activities but were deficient compared with the wild type in hemolysis. Again, functions were similar at both temperatures. Most of the B, C, and BC mutants had specific infectivities similar to that of the wild type despite lower hemagglutination, neuraminidase, and hemolysis functions. However, the D mutants were all less infectious. This evidence is consistent with a shared hemagglutinin-neuraminidase defect in the B, C, and BC mutants and a defect in either the F glycoprotein or the M protein in the D mutants.

Revertant analysis of a temperature-sensitive mutant of Newcastle disease virus with defective glycoproteins: implication of the fusion glycoprotein in cell killing and isolation of a neuraminidase-deficient hemagglutinating virus

Biological and molecular properties of a temperature-sensitive mutant (C1) of Newcastle disease virus and its revertants were analyzed. C1 exhibited three temperature-sensitive alterations (plaque formation, virion assembly, and cytopathogenicity) and several defects which were also present at the permissive temperature. C1 virions contained low amounts of hemagglutinin-neuraminidase glycopeptides and consequently were deficient in hemagglutinating and neuraminidase activities. These virions also contained defective fusion glycoproteins which rendered them poorly hemolytic and slow to penetrate cultured chicken embryo cells. The biological activities of the membrane glycoproteins were recovered sequentially in a series of plaque-forming revertants. The coreversion of hemolysis, membrane-penetrating activities, and cytopathogenicity in the first-step revertant (S1) suggested that fusion glycoproteins were major contributors to cellular destruction. This revertant also provided evidence of a role for fusion glycoproteins in virion assembly. From S1 we isolated a large-plaque-forming revertant (L1) that assembled wild-type amounts of biologically active hemagglutinin-neuraminidase glycoproteins into virions. Although it was normal for hemagglutination, L1 had less than 3% of the neuraminidase activity of the wild type, demonstrating that these two activities can be uncoupled genetically. The neuraminidase deficiency of L1 did not impair its virulence in ovo or its reproduction in cultured cells.

UV irradiation analysis of complementation between, and replication of, RNA-negative temperature-sensitive mutants of Newcastle disease virus

Random UV irradiation-induced lesions destroy the infectivity of Newcastle disease virus (NDV) by blocking downstream transcription from the single viral promoter. The nucleocapsid-associated polypeptides most likely to be involved in RNA synthesis are located at the extreme ends of the genome: NP and P are promoter proximal genes, and L is the most distal gene. We attempted to order the two temperature-sensitive (ts) RNA-negative (RNA-) mutant groups of NDV by determining the UV target sizes for the complementing abilities of mutants A1 and E1. After UV irradiation, E1 was unable to complement A1, a result compatible with the A mutation lying in the L gene. In contrast, after UV irradiation, A1 was able to complement E1 for both virus production and viral protein synthesis, with a target size most consistent with the E mutation lying in the P gene. UV-irradiated virus was unable to replicate as indicated by its absence in the yields of multiply infected cells, either as infectious virus or as particles with complementing activity. After irradiation, ts mutant B1 delta P, with a non-ts mutation affecting the electrophoretic mobility of the P protein, complemented E1 in a manner similar to A1, but it did not amplify the expression of delta P in infected cells. This too is consistent with irradiated virus being unable to replicate despite the presence of the components needed for replication of E1. At high UV doses, A1 was able to complement E1 in a different, UV-resistant manner, probably by direct donation of input polypeptides. Multiplicity reactivation has previously been observed at high-multiplicity infection by UV-irradiation paramyxoviruses. In this case, virions which are noninfectious because they lack a protein component may be activated by a protein from irradiation virions.

Relationships among virus spread, cytopathogenicity, and virulence as revealed by the noncytopathic mutants of Newcastle disease virus

We have studied protein synthesis in cultured cells infected with the six noncytopathic (nc) mutants of the Australia-Victoria strain (AV-WT) of Newcastle disease virus and their plaque-forming revertants. Virus-specific polypeptides accumulated at 30 to 63% of wild-type levels in nc mutant-infected cells and between 66 and 175% of wild-type levels in revertant-infected cells. An exception was the L polypeptide, which accumulated in nc mutant-infected cells at only 5 to 20% of the levels found in wild-type infection. The reduced accumulation of the L polypeptide did not appear to be due to increased degradation of that polypeptide. A new polypeptide (X) accumulated instead of polypeptide P in cells infected with mutants nc4 or nc16 and in virions released from them. Peptide mapping identified X as an altered form of P. A revertant of mutant nc4 (nc4S1), which forms larger hemadsorbing spots, but still does not form plaques, accumulated P instead of the X polypeptide. Thus, a lesion in P can affect virus spread without affecting cytopathogenicity. Virions of mutant nc7 and two naturally occurring avirulent strains of Newcastle disease virus (NJ LaSota and B1-Hitchner) contained polypeptides (F(7) and F(A), respectively) related to, but migrating more rapidly than, F(0) in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels. As previously reported for avirulent strains, a brief treatment of nc7 virions with trypsin converted F(7) to F and increased infectivity. Similarly, culturing nc7-infected cells in the presence of trypsin facilitated fusion from within and viral spread from cell to cell. A plaque-forming revertant of nc7 still accumulated F(7) in virions, indicating that the lesions responsible for the F(7) and noncytopathic phenotypes are genetically separable. The virulent parental strain, AV-WT, exhibited a mean embryo death time of 42 h. Both the larger-spot-forming revertant of nc4 (nc4S1) and the small-plaque-forming revertant of nc7 exhibited a decrease in mean embryo death time (increase in virulence) from 74 to 63 h. A second-step, plaque-forming revertant derived from nc4S1 (nc4S1R1) exhibited a further decrease in mean embryo death time from 63 to 44 h. The results suggest that the F(A)-F(7) and X lesions affect the ability of virus to spread from cell to cell. In addition, these lesions appear to be genetically separable from those responsible for the noncytopathic phenotype. However, both types of lesions cause an extension of mean embryo death time and, thus, may be relevant to virulence in vivo.

Noncytopathic mutants of Newcastle disease virus are defective in virus-specific RNA synthesis

We have studied virus-specific RNA synthesis in cells infected by six noncytopathic (nc) mutants of the Australia-Victoria wild-type strain (AV-WT) of Newcastle disease virus (NDV) (19). The rates of NDV-specific RNA synthesis in mutant infection were three to sevenfold lower than those observed in wild-type infection. Velocity sedimentation of this NDV-specific RNA revealed that the lower rates of synthesis in mutant infection correlated with reduced accumulation of 18S and 35S mRNA. Electrophoresis in polyacrylamide-urea gels showed that accumulation of all of the 18S mRNA species was reduced and no new species could be detected. Primary transcription appeared unaltered in mutant infection. Cells infected with two naturally occurring avirulent strains of NDV also showed less accumulation of 18S mRNA. Electrophoresis of this RNA resulted in patterns which differed from those obtained with RNA from either AV-WT or nc mutant infection. Complementation for RNA accumulation between the nc mutants and RNA- temperature-sensitive mutants of AV-WT (32) suggested a common defect in the nc mutants. Analysis of plaque-forming revertants of five of the nc mutants revealed that viral RNA synthetic capacity, cell killing, and plaque-forming ability correlated absolutely. These results suggest that viral RNA synthesis and cytopathogenicity may be causally related. In addition, several of the plaque-forming (and cell-killing) revertants were found to be unable to induce fusion from within in infected cell cultures. This result, coupled with the finding that several of the nc mutants are capable of wild-type levels of fusion from within, suggests that the ability to cause such fusion does not correlate with the ability to kill cells.

Isolation and characterization of temperature-sensitive mutants of Sendai virus

Sixteen temperature-sensitive mutants of Sendai virus were isolated from mutagenized stocks (10 mutants, designated numerically) and persistently infected cultures (6 mutants, designated alphabetically). Based on complementation tests, virion-associated activities, thermal inactivation, and viral RNA and hemadsorbing antigen synthesis as well as virion production in chick lung embryo cells at nonpermissive temperature, these mutants were divided into seven groups as follows. i) HANA group mutants (ts-5, -9, -10, -201), defective in hemagglutinin-neuraminidase protein, complementation group I. ii) F group mutants (ts-18, -108), defective in hemolytic and cell-fusing activity, complementation group II. iii) Ts-43, defective in RNA polymerase activity, complementation group III. iv) Ts-23, defective in RNA polymerase activity, interfered with the other mutants in complementation tests. v) Ts-25, defective in the incorporation of hemagglutinin-neuraminidase protein into the virion at the stage of virus assembly. vi) Ts-110, belongs to F group mutants on one hand, but is considered to carry another undetermined defect. vii) C group (carrier culture-borne group) mutants (ts-a, -b, -c, -d, -e, -f), defective lesion not yet determined and belong to neither complementation group I nor II. Assignment of mutants in groups iv), v), vi), and vii) to complementation groups could not be achieved.

Noncytopathic mutants of Newcastle disease virus

We have isolated a novel class of mutants of Newcastle disease virus which are less cytopathic than their virulent parent but are still capable of infectious virus production. Unlike wild-type virus, the mutants did not form plaques after 2 days of incubation; they did, however, make hemadsorbing spots. The mutants range in production of infectious virus from 10 to 200% of that of the wild type. They were less cytopathic in a single cycle of infection by light microscopy, loss of protein from the plate, and inhibition of total protein accumulation. All of the mutants exhibited extended mean embryo death times, a correlate of virulence in the adult animal.

Complementation analysis of measles virus temperature-sensitive mutants

Two sets of independently isolated measles virus temperature-sensitive mutants were quantitatively tested for complementation. Analysis of the nine possible combinations of representative mutants indicated that only one pair of mutants is noncomplementing. Thus, the measles virus mutants studied to date define five complementation groups.