Assembly and processing of avian retroviral gag polyproteins containing linked protease dimers

Finding, Conducting, and Nurturing Science: A Virologist's Memoir

My laboratory investigations have been driven by an abiding interest in understanding the consequences of genetic rearrangement in evolution and disease, and in using viruses to elucidate fundamental mechanisms in biology. Starting with bacteriophages and moving to the retroviruses, my use of the tools of genetics, molecular biology, biochemistry, and biophysics has spanned more than half a century-from the time when DNA structure was just discovered to the present day of big data and epigenetics. Both riding and contributing to the successive waves of technology, my laboratory has elucidated fundamental mechanisms in DNA replication, repair, and recombination. We have made substantial contributions in the area of retroviral oncogenesis, delineated mechanisms that control retroviral gene expression, and elucidated critical details of the structure and function of the retroviral enzymes-reverse transcriptase, protease, and integrase-and have had the satisfaction of knowing that the fundamental knowledge gained from these studies contributed important groundwork for the eventual development of antiviral drugs to treat AIDS. While pursuing laboratory research as a principal investigator, I have also been a science administrator-moving from laboratory head to department chair and, finally, to institute director. In addition, I have undertaken a number of community service, science-related "extracurricular" activities during this time. Filling all of these roles, while being a wife and mother, has required family love and support, creative management, and, above all, personal flexibility-with not too much long-term planning. I hope that this description of my journey, with various roles, obstacles, and successes, will be both interesting and informative, especially to young female scientists.

Retroviral proteases and their roles in virion maturation

Proteolytic processing of viral polyproteins is essential for retrovirus infectivity. Retroviral proteases (PR) become activated during or after assembly of the immature, non-infectious virion. They cleave viral polyproteins at specific sites, inducing major structural rearrangements termed maturation. Maturation converts retroviral enzymes into their functional form, transforms the immature shell into a metastable state primed for early replication events, and enhances viral entry competence. Not only cleavage at all PR recognition sites, but also an ordered sequence of cleavages is crucial. Proteolysis is tightly regulated, but the triggering mechanisms and kinetics and pathway of morphological transitions remain enigmatic. Here, we outline PR structures and substrate specificities focusing on HIV PR as a therapeutic target. We discuss design and clinical success of HIV PR inhibitors, as well as resistance development towards these drugs. Finally, we summarize data elucidating the role of proteolysis in maturation and highlight unsolved questions regarding retroviral maturation.

Induced degradation of Tat by nucleocapsid (NC) via the proteasome pathway and its effect on HIV transcription

Human Immunodeficiency Virus type 1 (HIV-1) is a retrovirus that causes acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). HIV-1 Tat protein upregulates transcriptional transactivation. The nucleocapsid protein NC of HIV-1 is a component of virion and plays a key role in genome packaging. Herein, we have demonstrated the interaction between NC and Tat by means of a yeast two-hybrid assay, GST pull-down analysis, co-immunoprecipitation and subcellular colocalization analysis. We observed that the level of Tat was significantly reduced in the presence of NC. But NC did not affect mRNA expression level of Tat. The level of Tat in the presence of NC was increased by treating cells with a proteasome inhibitor, MG132. The ubiquitination state of Tat was not seen to increase in the presence of NC, suggesting the proteasomal degradation was independent of ubiquitination. Lowered level of Tat in the presence of NC led to a decrease in Tat-mediated transcriptional transactivation.

The initial step in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 GagProPol processing can be regulated by reversible oxidation

Background

Maturation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) occurs upon activation of HIV-1 protease embedded within GagProPol precursors and cleavage of Gag and GagProPol polyproteins. Although reversible oxidation can regulate mature protease activity as well as retrovirus maturation, it is possible that the effects of oxidation on viral maturation are mediated in whole, or part, through effects on the initial intramolecular cleavage event of GagProPol. In order assess the effect of reversible oxidation on this event, we developed a system to isolate the first step in protease activation involving GagProPol.

Methodology/Principal Findings

To determine if oxidation influences this step, we created a GagProPol plasmid construct (pGPfs-1C) that encoded mutations at all cleavage sites except p2/NC, the initial cleavage site in GagProPol. pGPfs-1C was used in an in vitro translation assay to observe the behavior of this initial step without interference from subsequent processing events. Diamide, a sulfhydral oxidizing agent, inhibited processing at p2/NC by >60% for pGPfs-1C and was readily reversed with the reductant, dithiothreitol. The ability to regulate processing by reversible oxidation was lost when the cysteines of the embedded protease were mutated to alanine. Unlike mature protease, which requires only oxidation of cys95 for inhibition, both cysteines of the embedded protease contributed to this inhibition.

Conclusions/Significance

We developed a system that can be used to study the first step in the cascade of HIV-1 GagProPol processing and show that reversible oxidation of cysteines of HIV-1 protease embedded in GagProPol can block this initial GagProPol autoprocessing. This type of regulation may be broadly applied to the majority of retroviruses.

Ty3 capsid mutations reveal early and late functions of the amino-terminal domain

The Ty3 retrotransposon assembles into 50-nm virus-like particles that occur in large intracellular clusters in the case of wild-type (wt) Ty3. Within these particles, maturation of the Gag3 and Gag3-Pol3 polyproteins by Ty3 protease produces the structural proteins capsid (CA), spacer, and nucleocapsid. Secondary and tertiary structure predictions showed that, like retroviral CA, Ty3 CA contains a large amount of helical structure arranged in amino-terminal and carboxyl-terminal bundles. Twenty-six mutants in which alanines were substituted for native residues were used to study CA subdomain functions. Transposition was measured, and particle morphogenesis and localization were characterized by analysis of protein processing, cDNA production, genomic RNA protection, and sedimentation and by fluorescence and electron microscopy. These measures defined five groups of mutants. Proteins from each group could be sedimented in a large complex. Mutations in the amino-terminal domain reduced the formation of fluorescent Ty3 protein foci. In at least one major homology region mutant, Ty3 protein concentrated in foci but no wt clusters of particles were observed. One mutation in the carboxyl-terminal domain shifted assembly from spherical particles to long filaments. Two mutants formed foci separate from P bodies, the proposed sites of assembly, and formed defective particles. P-body association was therefore found to be not necessary for assembly but correlated with the production of functional particles. One mutation in the amino terminus blocked transposition after cDNA synthesis. Our data suggest that Ty3 proteins are concentrated first, assembly associated with P bodies occurs, and particle morphogenesis concludes with a post-reverse transcription, CA-dependent step. Particle formation was generally resistant to localized substitutions, possibly indicating that multiple domains are involved.

The Role of the S-S Bridge in Retroviral Protease Function and Virion Maturation

Retroviral proteases are translated as a part of Gag-related polyproteins, and are released and activated during particle release. Mason-Pfizer monkey virus (M-PMV) Gag polyproteins assemble into immature capsids within the cytoplasm of the host cells; however, their processing occurs only after transport to the plasma membrane and subsequent release. Thus, the activity of M-PMV protease is expected to be highly regulated during the replication cycle. It has been proposed that reversible oxidation of protease cysteine residues might be responsible for such regulation. We show that cysteine residues in M-PMV protease can form an intramolecular S-S bridge. The disulfide bridge shifts the monomer/dimer equilibrium in favor of the dimer, and increases the proteolytic activity significantly. To investigate the role of this disulfide bridge in virus maturation and replication, we engineered an M-PMV clone in which both protease cysteine residues were replaced by alanine (M-PMV(PRC7A/C106A)). Surprisingly, the cysteine residues were dispensable for Gag polyprotein processing within the virus, indicating that even low levels of protease activity are sufficient for polyprotein processing during maturation. However, the long-term infectivity of M-PMV(PRC7A/C106A) was noticeably compromised. These results show clearly that the proposed redox mechanism does not rely solely on the formation of the stabilizing S-S bridge in the protease. Thus, in addition to the protease disulfide bridge, reversible oxidation of cysteine and/or methionine residues in other domains of the Gag polyprotein or in related cellular proteins must be involved in the regulation of maturation.

Effects of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transframe protein p6* mutations on viral protease-mediated Gag processing

The proteolytic processing of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) particles mediated by the viral pol-encoded protease (PR) is essential for viral infectivity. The pol coding sequence partially overlaps with the gag coding sequence and is translated as a Gag-Pol polyprotein precursor. Within Gag-Pol, the C-terminal p6(gag) domain is replaced by a transframe peptide referred to as p6*, which separates the Gag nucleocapsid domain from PR. Several previous in vitro studies have ascribed a PR-suppression regulatory function to p6*. Here, it was demonstrated that an HIV-1 Gag-Pol lacking p6* is efficiently incorporated into virions when coexpressed with HIV-1 Gag precursor. However, the released virions are not processed appropriately and show a greatly reduced viral infectivity. This suggests that the p6* is indispensable during the process of PR-mediated virus particle maturation.

Investigation by atomic force microscopy of the structure of Ty3 retrotransposon particles

Ty3, a member of the Metaviridiae family of long-terminal-repeat retrotransposons found in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, encodes homologs of retroviral Gag and Gag-Pol proteins, which, together with genomic RNA, assemble into virus-like particles (VLPs) that undergo processing and reverse transcription. The Ty3 structural proteins, capsid and nucleocapsid, contain major homology and nucleocapsid motifs similar to retrovirus capsid and nucleocapsid proteins, but Ty3 lacks a matrix-like structural domain amino terminal to capsid. Mass spectrometry analysis of Ty3 Gag3 processing products defined an acetylated Ser residue as the amino terminus of Gag3/p34, p27, and CA/p24 species and supported a model where p34 and p27 occur in phosphorylated forms. Using atomic force microscopy, VLPs were imaged from cells producing wild-type and protease and reverse transcriptase mutant Ty3. Wild-type VLPs were found to have a broad range of diameters, but the majority, if not all of the particles, exhibited arrangements of capsomeres on their surfaces which were consistent with icosahedral symmetry. Wild-type particles were in the range of 25 to 52 nm in diameter, with particles in the 42- to 52-nm diameter range consistent with T=7 symmetry. Both classes of mutant VLPs fell into a narrower range of 44 to 53 nm in diameter and appeared to be consistent with T=7 icosahedral symmetry. The smaller particles in the wild-type population likely correspond to VLPs that have progressed to reverse transcription or later stages, which do not occur in the protease and reverse transcriptase mutants. Ty3 VLPs did not undergo major external rearrangements during proteolytic maturation.

Kinetics of the dimerization of retroviral proteases: the "fireman's grip" and dimerization

All retroviral proteases belong to the family of aspartic proteases. They are active as homodimers, each unit contributing one catalytic aspartate to the active site dyad. An important feature of all aspartic proteases is a conserved complex scaffold of hydrogen bonds supporting the active site, called the "fireman's grip," which involves the hydroxyl groups of two threonine (serine) residues in the active site Asp-Thr(Ser)-Gly triplets. It was shown previously that the fireman's grip is indispensable for the dimer stability of HIV protease. The retroviral proteases harboring Ser in their active site triplet are less active and, under natural conditions, are expressed in higher enzyme/substrate ratio than those having Asp-Thr-Gly triplet. To analyze whether this observation can be attributed to the different influence of Thr or Ser on dimerization, we prepared two pairs of the wild-type and mutant proteases from HIV and myeloblastosis-associated virus harboring either Ser or Thr in their Asp-Thr(Ser)-Gly triplet. The equilibrium dimerization constants differed by an order of magnitude within the relevant pairs. The proteases with Thr in their active site triplets were found to be approximately 10 times more thermodynamically stable. The dimer association contributes to this difference more than does the dissociation. We propose that the fireman's grip might be important in the initial phases of dimer formation to help properly orientate the two subunits of a retroviral protease. The methyl group of threonine might contribute significantly to fixing such an intermediate conformation.

Coding sequences upstream of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcriptase domain in Gag-Pol are not essential for incorporation of the Pr160(gag-pol) into virus particles

Incorporation of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Gag-Pol into virions is thought to be mediated by the N-terminal Gag domain via interaction with the Gag precursor. However, one recent study has demonstrated that the murine leukemia virus Pol can be incorporated into virions independently of Gag-Pol expression, implying a possible interaction between the Pol and Gag precursor. To test whether the HIV-1 Pol can be incorporated into virions on removal of the N-terminal Gag domain and to define sequences required for the incorporation of Gag-Pol into virions in more detail, a series of HIV Gag-Pol expression plasmids with various extensive deletions in the region upstream of the reverse transcriptase (RT) domain was constructed, and viral incorporation of the Gag-Pol deletion mutants was examined by cotransfecting 293T cells with a plasmid expressing Pr55(gag). Analysis indicated that deletion of the N-terminal two-thirds of the gag coding region did not significantly affect the incorporation of Gag-Pol into virions. In contrast, Gag-Pol proteins with deletions covering the capsid (CA) major homology regions and the adjacent C-terminal CA regions were impaired with respect to assembly into virions. However, Gag-Pol with sequences deleted upstream of the protease, or of the RT domain but retaining 15 N-terminal gag codons, could still be rescued into virions at a level about 20% of the wild-type level. When assayed in a nonmyristylated Gag-Pol context, all of the Gag-Pol deletion mutants were incorporated into virions at a level comparable to their myristylated counterparts, suggesting that the incorporation of the Gag-Pol deletion mutants into virions is independent of the N-terminal myristylation signal.

Activation of the Mason-Pfizer monkey virus protease within immature capsids in vitro

For all retroviruses, the completion of the viral budding process correlates with the activation of the viral protease by an unknown mechanism, and, as the structural (Gag) polyproteins are cleaved by the viral protease, maturation of the immature virus-like particle into an infectious virion. Unlike most retroviruses, the Mason-Pfizer monkey virus Gag polyproteins assemble into immature capsids within the cytoplasm of the cell before the viral budding event. The results reported here describe a unique experimental system in which Mason-Pfizer monkey virus immature capsids are removed from the cell, and the protease is activated in vitro by the addition of a reducing agent. The cleavage of the protease from the precursor form is a primary event, which proceeds with a half time of 14 min, and is followed by authentic processing of the Gag polyproteins. Activity of the viral protease in vitro depends on pH, with an increase in catalytic rates at acidic and neutral pH. The initiation of protease activity within immature capsids in vitro demonstrates that viral protease activity is sensitive to oxidation-reduction conditions, and that the viral protease can be activated in the absence of viral budding.

Importance of the N terminus of rous sarcoma virus protease for structure and enzymatic function

All retrovirus proteases (PRs) are homodimers, and dimerization is essential for enzymatic function. The dimer is held together largely by a short four-stranded antiparallel beta sheet composed of the four or five N-terminal amino acid residues and a similar stretch of residues from the C terminus. We have found that the enzymatic and structural properties of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) PR are exquisitely sensitive to mutations at the N terminus. Deletion of one or three residues, addition of one residue, or substitution of alanine for the N-terminal leucine reduced enzymatic activity on peptide and protein substrates 100- to 1,000-fold. The purified mutant proteins remained monomeric up to a concentration of about 2 mg/ml, as determined by dynamic light scattering. At higher concentrations, dimerization was observed, but the dimer lacked or was deficient in enzymatic activity and thus was inferred to be structurally distinct from a wild-type dimer. The mutant protein lacking three N-terminal residues (DeltaLAM), a form of PR occurring naturally in virions, was examined by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and found to be folded at concentrations where it was monomeric. This result stands in contrast to the report that a similarly engineered monomeric PR of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 is unstructured. Heteronuclear single quantum coherence spectra of the mutant at concentrations where either monomers or dimers prevail were nearly identical. However, these spectra differed from that of the dimeric wild-type RSV PR. These results imply that the chemical environment of many of the amide protons differed and thus that the three-dimensional structure of the DeltaLAM PR mutant is different from that of the wild-type PR. The structure of this mutant protein may serve as a model for the structure of the PR domain of the Gag polyprotein and may thus give clues to the initiation of proteolytic maturation in retroviruses.

Membrane targeting properties of a herpesvirus tegument protein-retrovirus Gag chimera

The retroviral Gag protein is capable of directing the production and release of virus-like particles in the absence of all other viral components. Budding normally occurs after Gag is transported to the plasma membrane by its membrane-targeting and -binding (M) domain. In the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) Gag protein, the M domain is contained within the first 86 amino acids. When M is deleted, membrane association and budding fail to occur. Budding is restored when M is replaced with foreign membrane-binding sequences, such as that of the Src oncoprotein. Moreover, the RSV M domain is capable of targeting heterologous proteins to the plasma membrane. Although the solution structure of the RSV M domain has been determined, the mechanism by which M specifically targets Gag to the plasma membrane rather than to one or more of the large number of internal membrane surfaces (e.g., the Golgi apparatus, endoplasmic reticulum, and nuclear, mitochondrial, or lysosomal membranes) is unknown. To further investigate the requirements for targeting proteins to discrete cellular locations, we have replaced the M domain of RSV with the product of the unique long region 11 (U(L)11) gene of herpes simplex virus type 1. This 96-amino-acid myristylated protein is thought to be involved in virion transport and envelopment at internal membrane sites. When the first 100 amino acids of RSV Gag (including the M domain) were replaced by the entire UL11 sequence, the chimeric protein localized at and budded into the Golgi apparatus rather than being targeted to the plasma membrane. Myristate was found to be required for this specific targeting, as were the first 49 amino acids of UL11, which contain an acidic cluster motif. In addition to shedding new light on UL11, these experiments demonstrate that RSV Gag can be directed to internal cellular membranes and suggest that regions outside of the M domain do not contain a dominant plasma membrane-targeting motif.

Systematic mutational analysis of the active-site threonine of HIV-1 proteinase: rethinking the "fireman's grip" hypothesis

Aspartic proteinases share a conserved network of hydrogen bonds (termed "fireman's grip"), which involves the hydroxyl groups of two threonine residues in the active site Asp-Thr-Gly triplets (Thr26 in the case of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) PR). In the case of retroviral proteinases (PRs), which are active as symmetrical homodimers, these interactions occur at the dimer interface. For a systematic analysis of the "fireman's grip," Thr26 of HIV-1 PR was changed to either Ser, Cys, or Ala. The variant enzymes were tested for cleavage of HIV-1 derived peptide and polyprotein substrates. PR(T26S) and PR(T26C) showed similar or slightly reduced activity compared to wild-type HIV-1 PR, indicating that the sulfhydryl group of cysteine can substitute for the hydroxyl of the conserved threonine in this position. PR(T26A), which lacks the "fireman's grip" interaction, was virtually inactive and was monomeric in solution at conditions where wild-type PR exhibited a monomer-dimer equilibrium. All three mutations had little effect when introduced into only one chain of a linked dimer of HIV-1 PR. In this case, even changing both Thr residues to Ala yielded residual activity suggesting that the "fireman's grip" is not essential for activity but contributes significantly to dimer formation. Taken together, these results indicate that the "fireman's grip" is crucial for stabilization of the retroviral PR dimer and for overall stability of the enzyme.

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Vif-derived peptides inhibit the viral protease and arrest virus production

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Vif protein is required for productive HIV-1 infection of peripheral blood lymphocytes and macrophages in cell culture and for pathogenesis in the SCID-hu mouse model of HIV-1 infection. Vif inhibits the viral protease (PR)-dependent autoprocessing of truncated HIV-1 Gag-Pol precursors expressed in bacterial cells and efficiently inhibits the PR-mediated hydrolysis of peptides in cell-free systems. The obstructive activity of Vif has been assigned to the 92 amino acids residing at its N'-terminus (N-Vif). To determine the minimal Vif sequence required to inhibit PR, we synthesized overlapping peptides derived from N-Vif. These peptides were then assessed, using two in vitro and two in vivo systems: (i) inhibition of purified PR, (ii) binding of PR, (iii) inhibition of the autoprocessing of the Gag-Pol polyprotein expressed by a vaccinia virus vector, and (iv) inhibition of mature virus production in human cells. The peptides derived from two regions of N-Vif encompassing residues Tyr-30-Val-65 and Asp-78-Val-98, inhibited PR activity in both the in vitro and the in vivo assays. Thus, these peptides can be used as lead compounds to design new PR inhibitors.

A bipartite membrane-binding signal in the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 matrix protein is required for the proteolytic processing of Gag precursors in a cell type-dependent manner

It is unclear whether proteolytic processing of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Gag protein is dependent on virus assembly at the plasma membrane. Mutations that prevent myristylation of HIV-1 Gag proteins have been shown to block virus assembly and release from the plasma membrane of COS cells but do not prevent processing of Gag proteins. In contrast, in HeLa cells similar mutations abolished processing of Gag proteins as well as virus production. We have now addressed this issue with CD4(+) T cells, which are natural target cells of HIV-1. In these cells, myristylation of Gag proteins was required for proteolytic processing of Gag proteins and production of extracellular viral particles. This result was not due to a lack of expression of the viral protease in the form of a Gag-Pol precursor or a lack of interaction between unmyristylated Gag and Gag-Pol precursors. The processing defect of unmyristylated Gag was partially rescued ex vivo by coexpression with wild-type myristylated Gag proteins in HeLa cells. The cell type-dependent processing of HIV-1 Gag precursors was also observed when another part of the plasma membrane binding signal, a polybasic region in the matrix protein, was mutated. The processing of unmyristylated Gag precursors was inhibited in COS cells by HIV-1 protease inhibitors. Altogether, our findings demonstrate that the processing of HIV-1 Gag precursors in CD4(+) T cells occurs normally at the plasma membrane during viral morphogenesis. The intracellular environment of COS cells presumably allows activation of the viral protease and proteolytic processing of HIV-1 Gag proteins in the absence of plasma membrane binding.

Plasma membrane targeting of chimeric intracisternal A-type particle polyproteins leads to particle release and specific activation of the viral proteinase

Retrovirus morphogenesis involves assembly of structural Gag polyproteins with subsequent budding from the plasma membrane, followed by proteolytic cleavage by the viral proteinase (PR) and extracellular maturation to the infectious virion. Intracisternal A-type particles (IAPs) are defective retroviruses that assemble and bud at the membranes of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), where they remain as immature particles consisting exclusively of uncleaved polyproteins. To analyze requirements for intracellular polyprotein transport and PR activation, we constructed deletion and substitution mutations in the IAP gag gene, including the putative ER-targeting signal. Mutant polyproteins were transported to various intracellular locations, including the nucleus, the cytoplasm, the ER, and the plasma membrane. Interestingly, assembly of capsid-like particle structures occurred at almost all sites. However, only those polyproteins transported to the plasma membrane were efficiently and specifically cleaved by viral PR, with cleavage occurring predominantly within the virus particle. Thus, at least in the experimental system presented here, retroviral particle assembly can occur at almost any location within the cell, while polyprotein processing and, consequently, virion maturation are confined to a specific cellular site. These results suggest that a factor restricted to the plasma membrane is required to trigger PR activation and maturation of infectious retroviruses.

Altered Rous sarcoma virus Gag polyprotein processing and its effects on particle formation

Proteolytic processing of the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) Gag precursor was altered in vivo through the introduction of amino acid substitutions into either the polyprotein cleavage junctions or the PR coding sequence. Single amino acid substitutions (V(P2)S and P(P4)G), which are predicted from in vitro peptide substrate cleavage data to decrease the rate of release of PR from the Gag polyprotein, were placed in the NC portion of the NC-PR junction. These substitutions do not affect the efficiency of release of virus-like particles from COS cells even though recovered particles contain significant amounts of uncleaved Pr76gag in addition to mature viral proteins. Single amino acid substitutions (A(P3)F and S(P1)Y), which increase the rate of PR release from Gag, also do not affect budding of virus-like particles from cells. Substitution of the inefficiently cleaved MA-p2 junction sequence in Gag by eight amino acids from the rapidly cleaved NC-PR sequence resulted in a significant increase in cleavage at the new MA-p2 junction, but again without an effect on budding. However, decreased budding was observed when the A(P3)F or S(P1)Y substitution was included in the NC-PR junction sequence between the MA and p2 proteins. A budding defect was also caused by substitution into Gag of a PR subunit containing three amino acid substitutions (R105P, G106V, and S107N) in the substrate binding pocket that increase the catalytic activity of PR. The defect appears to be the result of premature proteolytic processing that could be rescued by inactivating PR through substitution of a serine for the catalytic aspartic acid residue. This budding defect was also rescued by single amino acid substitutions in the NC-PR cleavage site which decrease the rate of release of PR from Gag. A similar budding defect was caused by replacing the Gag PR with two PR subunits covalently linked by four glycine residues. In contrast to the defect caused by the triply substituted PR, the budding defect observed with the linked PR dimer could not be rescued by NC-PR cleavage site mutations, suggesting that PR dimerization is a limiting step in the maturation process. Overall, these results are consistent with a model in which viral protein maturation occurs after PR subunits are released from the Gag polyprotein.

Analysis of cleavage site mutations between the NC and PR Gag domains of Rous sarcoma virus

In retroviruses, the viral protease (PR) is released as a mature protein by cleavage of Gag, Gag-Pro, or Gag-Pro-Pol precursor polypeptides. In avian sarcoma and leukemia viruses (ASLV), PR forms the C-terminal domain of Gag. Based on the properties of a mutation (cs22) in the cleavage site between the upstream NC domain and the PR domain, the proteolytic liberation of PR previously was inferred to be essential for processing of Gag and Pol proteins. To study this process in more detail, we have analyzed the effects that several mutations at the NC-PR cleavage site have on proteolytic processing in virus-like particles expressed in COS and quail cells. Mutant Gag proteins carrying the same mutations also were synthesized in vitro and tested for processing with purified PR. In both types of studies, N-terminal sequencing of the liberated PR domain was carried out to exactly identify the site of cleavage. Finally, synthetic peptides corresponding to the mutant proteins were assessed for the ability to act as substrates for PR. The results were all consistent and led to the following conclusions. (i) In vivo, if normal processing between NC and PR is prevented by mutations, limited cleavage occurs at a previously unrecognized alternative site three amino acids downstream, i.e., in PR. This N-terminally truncated PR is inactive as an enzyme, as inferred from the global processing defect in cs22 and a similar mutant. (ii) In Gag proteins translated in vitro, purified PR cleaves this alternative site as rapidly as it does the wild-type site. (iii) Contrary to previously accepted rules describing retroviral cleavage sites, an isoleucine residue placed at the P1 position of the NC-PR cleavage site does not hinder normal processing. (iv) A proline residue placed at the P2 position in this cleavage site blocks normal processing.

Transport and processing of the Rous sarcoma virus Gag protein in the endoplasmic reticulum

The Gag proteins of replication-competent retroviruses direct budding at the plasma membrane and are cleaved by the viral protease (PR) just before or very soon after particle release. In contrast, defective retroviruses that bud into the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) have been found, and morphologically these appear to contain uncleaved Gag proteins. From this, it has been proposed that activation of PR may depend upon a host factor found only at the plasma membrane. However, if Gag proteins were cleaved by PR before the particle could pinch off the ER membrane, then the only particles that would remain visible are those that packaged smaller-than-normal amounts of PR, and these would have an immature morphology. To distinguish between these two hypotheses, we made use of the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) Gag protein, the PR of RSV IS included on each Gag molecule. To target Gag to the ER, a signal peptide was installed at its amino terminus in place of the plasma membrane-binding domain. An intervening, hydrophobic, transmembrane anchor was included to keep Gag extended into the cytoplasm. We found that PR-mediated processing occurred, although the cleavage products were rapidly degraded. When the anchor was removed, allowing the entire protein to be inserted into the lumen of the ER, Gag processing occurred with a high level of efficiency, and the cleavage products were quite stable. Thus, PR activation does not require targeting of Gag molecules to the plasma membrane. Unexpectedly, molecules lacking the transmembrane anchor were rapidly secreted from the cell in a nonmembrane-enclosed form and in a manner that was very sensitive to brefeldin A and monensin. In contrast, the wild-type RSV and Moloney murine leukemia virus Gag proteins were completely insensitive to these inhibitors, suggesting that the normal mechanism of transport to the plasma membrane does not require interactions with the secretory pathway.

An assembly domain of the Rous sarcoma virus Gag protein required late in budding

The Gag protein of Rous sarcoma virus has the ability to direct particle assembly at the plasma membrane in the absence of all the other virus-encoded components. An extensive deletion analysis has revealed that very large regions of this protein can be deleted without impairing budding and has suggested that the essential functions map to three discrete regions. In the studies reported here, we establish the location of assembly domain 2 (AD2) within the proline-rich p2b sequence of this Gag protein. AD2 mutants lacking the p2b sequence were completely defective for particle release even though their Gag proteins were tightly associated with the membrane fraction and exhibited high levels of protease activity. Mutations that inactivate the viral protease did not restore budding to wild-type levels for these mutants, indicating that the defect is not due simply to a loss of protease regulation. AD2 mutants could be rescued into dense particles in genetic complementation assays, indicating that their defect is not due to a gross alteration of the overall conformation of the protein and that the assembly function is not needed on every Gag molecule in the population. Several mutants with amino acid substitutions in the p2b sequence were found to have an intermediate capacity for budding. Inactivation of the protease of these mutants stabilized the Gag polyprotein within the cells and allowed an increase in particle release; however, the rate of budding remained slow. We favor the idea that AD2 is a dynamic region of movement, perhaps serving as a molecular hinge to allow the particle to emerge from the surface of the cell during budding.

Kinetics and mechanism of autoprocessing of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease from an analog of the Gag-Pol polyprotein

Upon renaturation, the polyprotein MBP-delta TF-Protease-delta Pol, consisting of HIV-1 protease and short native sequences from the trans-frame protein (delta TF) and the polymerase (delta Pol) fused to the maltose-binding protein (MBP) of Escherichia coli, undergoes autoprocessing to produce the mature protease in two steps. The initial step corresponds to cleavage of the N-terminal sequence to release the protein intermediate Protease-delta Pol, which has enzymatic activity comparable to that of the mature enzyme. Subsequently, the mature enzyme is formed by a slower cleavage at the C terminus. The rate of increase in enzymatic activity is identical to that of the appearance of MBP-delta TF and the disappearance of the MBP-delta TF-Protease-delta Pol. Initial rates are linearly dependent on the protein concentration, indicating that the N-terminal cleavage is first-order in protein concentration. The reaction is competitively inhibited by pepstatin A and has a pH rate profile similar to that of the mature enzyme. These results and molecular modeling studies are discussed in terms of a mechanism in which a dimeric full-length fusion protein must form prior to rate-limiting intramolecular cleavage of the N-terminal sequence that leads to an increase in enzymatic activity.

Engineering aspartic proteases to probe structure and function relationships

Recently, protein engineering has been used to interconvert homodimeric and homologous single-chain aspartic proteases, with some success. The independent folding of the domains of these proteases has also permitted the engineering of domain-rearranged protease zymogens and the use of individual domains as probes for structural denaturation. In addition, site-directed mutagenesis has provided insights into the catalytic mechanism and specificity of this family of proteases.

Expression of virus-encoded proteinases: functional and structural similarities with cellular enzymes

Many viruses express their genome, or part of their genome, initially as a polyprotein precursor that undergoes proteolytic processing. Molecular genetic analyses of viral gene expression have revealed that many of these processing events are mediated by virus-encoded proteinases. Biochemical activity studies and structural analyses of these viral enzymes reveal that they have remarkable similarities to cellular proteinases. However, the viral proteinases have evolved unique features that permit them to function in a cellular environment. In this article, the current status of plant and animal virus proteinases is described along with their role in the viral replication cycle. The reactions catalyzed by viral proteinases are not simple enzyme-substrate interactions; rather, the processing steps are highly regulated, are coordinated with other viral processes, and frequently involve the participation of other factors.

Functional chimeras of the Rous sarcoma virus and human immunodeficiency virus gag proteins

The Gag protein encoded by Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) is the only viral product required for the process of budding whereby virus particles are formed at the plasma membrane. Deletion analysis of this Gag molecule has revealed several regions (assembly domains) that are important for budding. One of these domains is located at the amino terminus and is needed for membrane binding. Another is located within the carboxy-terminal third of the protein. Though there is little sequence homology among the Gag proteins of unrelated retroviruses, it seemed possible that their assembly domains might be functionally conserved, and to explore this idea, numerous Gag chimeras were made. The results indicate that the first 10 amino acids of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) Gag protein can suppress the block to budding caused by deletions in the RSV MA sequence, much as described previously for the first 10 residues from the Src oncoprotein (J.W. Wills, R.C. Craven, R. A. Weldon, Jr., T. D. Nelle, and C.R. Erdie, J. Virol. 65:3804-3812, 1991). In addition, the carboxy-terminal half of the HIV Gag protein was fused to a truncated RSV Gag molecule, mutant Bg-Bs, which is unable to direct core assembly. This chimera was able to produce particles at a rate identical to that of RSV and of a density similar to that of authentic virions. Deletion analysis of the carboxy-terminal chimera revealed two small regions within the HIV NC protein that were sufficient for endowing mutant Bg-Bs with these properties. Chimeras lacking both regions produced particles of a low density, suggesting that these sequences may be involved in the tight packing of Gag molecules during assembly. In a related set of experiments, replacement of the RSV protease with that of HIV resulted in premature processing within the RSV sequence and a block to budding. Particle assembly was restored when the HIV PR activity was inactivated by mutagenesis. Collectively, the data presented here illustrate the functional similarities of Gag proteins from unrelated retroviruses.

Characterization of a small (25-kilodalton) derivative of the Rous sarcoma virus Gag protein competent for particle release

Retroviral Gag proteins have the ability to induce budding and particle release from the plasma membrane when expressed in the absence of all of the other virus-encoded components; however, the locations of the functional domains within the Gag protein that are important for this process are poorly understood. It was shown previously that the protease sequence of the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) Gag protein can be replaced with a foreign polypeptide, iso-1-cytochrome c from a yeast, without disrupting particle assembly (R. A. Weldon, Jr., C. R. Erdie, M. G. Oliver, and J. W. Wills, J. Virol. 64:4169-4179, 1990). An unexpected product of the chimeric gag gene is a small, Gag-related protein named p25C. This product was of interest because of its high efficiency of packaging into particles. The goal of the experiments described here was to determine the mechanism by which p25C is synthesized and packaged into particles. The results demonstrate that it is not the product of proteolytic processing of the Gag-cytochrome precursor but is derived from an unusual spliced mRNA. cDNA clones of the spliced mRNA were obtained, and each expressed a product of approximately 25 kDa, designated p25M1, which was released into the growth medium in membrane-enclosed particles that were much lighter than authentic retrovirions as measured in sucrose density gradients. DNA sequencing revealed that the clones encode the first 180 of the 701 amino acids of the RSV Gag protein and no residues from iso-1-cytochrome c. This suggested that a domain in the carboxy-terminal half of Gag is important for the packaging of Gag proteins into dense arrays within the particles. In support of this hypothesis, particles of the correct density were obtained when a small segment from the carboxy terminus of the RSV Gag protein (residues 417 to 584) was included on the end of p25.

Proteolytic processing of Ty3 proteins is required for transposition

Ty3 is a retroviruslike element found in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. It encodes GAG3 and GAG3-POL3 polyproteins which are processed into mature proteins found in the Ty3 viruslike particle. In this study, the region encoding a protease that is homologous to retroviral aspartyl proteases was identified and shown to be required for production of mature Ty3 proteins and transposition. The Ty3 protease has the Asp-Ser-Gly consensus sequence found in copia, Ty1, and Rous sarcoma virus proteases, rather than the Asp-Thr-Gly found in most retroviral proteases. The Asp-Ser-Gly consensus is flanked by residues similar to those which flank the active sites of cellular aspartyl proteases. Mutations were made in the Ty3 active-site sequence to examine the role of the protease in Ty3 particle maturation and to test the functional significance of the Ser active-site variant in the consensus sequence. Mutation of the active-site Asp blocked processing of Gag3 and Gag3-Pol3 and allowed identification of a GAG3-POL3 polyprotein. This protein was turned over rapidly in cells expressing the mutant Ty3. Changing the active-site Ser to Thr caused only a modest reduction in the levels of certain Ty3 proteins. Five putative cleavage sites of this protease in Ty3 GAG3 and GAG3-POL3 polyproteins were defined by amino-terminal sequence analysis. The existence of an additional protein(s) of unknown function, encoded downstream of the protease-coding region, was deduced from the positions of these amino termini and the sizes of known Ty3 proteins. Although Ty3 protease cleavage sites do not correspond exactly to known retroviral protease cleavage sites, there are similarities. Residues P3 through P2' in the regions encompassing each of the five sites are uncharged, and no P1 position is occupied by an amino acid with a branched beta carbon.

Proteolysis in the maturation of avian retroviruses does not require calcium

After budding from the plasma membrane, retrovirus particles undergo a process of maturation, which includes changes in morphology caused by several proteolytic cleavages of the precursor of the internal structural proteins, products of the gag gene. Cleavage is mediated by the viral protease, PR. The fact that in most systems cleavage appears to occur only after assembly is complete, suggests that PR may become enzymatically active as a consequence of release of the virion from the cell. Using avian leukosis virus as a model system, we tested the hypothesis that leakage of calcium ions into newly budded virions plays a role in their maturation. We found that in both quail Qt35 cells and monkey COS-1 cells, maturation occurred normally in calcium-free medium and in the presence of EGTA. A calcium ionophore also did not affect maturation. We conclude that calcium influx does not act as a trigger for PR-mediated maturation.

Processing of avian retroviral gag polyprotein precursors is blocked by a mutation at the NC-PR cleavage site

The avian sarcoma and leukosis viruses (ASLV) encode a protease (PR) at the C terminus of gag which in vivo catalyzes the processing of both gag and gag-pol precursors. The studies reported here were undertaken to determine whether PR is able to cleave these polyproteins while it is still part of the gag precursor or whether the release of its N terminus to form free PR is necessary for full proteolytic activity. To address this question, we created a mutation that disrupts the PR cleavage site between the NC and PR coding regions of the gag gene. This mutation was introduced into a eukaryotic vector that expresses only the gag precursor and into an otherwise infectious clone of ASLV that carries the neo gene as a selectable marker. These constructs were expressed in monkey COS cells or in quail QT35 cells, respectively. Processing was impaired in both systems. Mutant particles were formed, but they contained no mature processed gag proteins. We observed only the uncleaved gag precursor polypeptide Pr76 in one case or Pr76 and a cleaved product of about 60 kDa in the other. Processing of the mutant gag precursor could be complemented in trans by from a wild-type construct, suggesting that the mutation did not induce gross structural alterations in its precursor. Our results suggest that the PR first must be released from its precursor before it can attack other sites in the gag and gag-pol polyproteins and that cleavage at the NC-PR boundary is a prerequisite for the initiation of the PR-directed processing.