BRCA1 can modulate RNA polymerase II carboxy-terminal domain phosphorylation levels

Saccharomyces cerevisiae as a research tool for RNA-mediated human disease

The budding yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, has been used for decades as a powerful genetic tool to study a broad spectrum of biological topics. With its ease of use, economic utility, well-studied genome, and a highly conserved proteome across eukaryotes, it has become one of the most used model organisms. Due to these advantages, it has been used to study an array of complex human diseases. From broad, complex pathological conditions such as aging and neurodegenerative disease to newer uses such as SARS-CoV-2, yeast continues to offer new insights into how cellular processes are affected by disease and how affected pathways might be targeted in therapeutic settings. At the same time, the roles of RNA and RNA-based processes have become increasingly prominent in the pathology of many of these same human diseases, and yeast has been utilized to investigate these mechanisms, from aberrant RNA-binding proteins in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis to translation regulation in cancer. Here we review some of the important insights that yeast models have yielded into the molecular pathology of complex, RNA-based human diseases. This article is categorized under: RNA in Disease and Development > RNA in Disease.

BRCA1 mutations in high-grade serous ovarian cancer are associated with proteomic changes in DNA repair, splicing, transcription regulation and signaling

Despite recent advances in the management of BRCA1 mutated high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSC), the physiology of these tumors remains poorly understood. Here we provide a comprehensive molecular understanding of the signaling processes that drive HGSC pathogenesis with the addition of valuable ubiquitination profiling, and their dependency on BRCA1 mutation-state directly in patient-derived tissues. Using a multilayered proteomic approach, we show the tight coordination between the ubiquitination and phosphorylation regulatory layers and their role in key cellular processes related to BRCA1-dependent HGSC pathogenesis. In addition, we identify key bridging proteins, kinase activity, and post-translational modifications responsible for molding distinct cancer phenotypes, thus providing new opportunities for therapeutic intervention, and ultimately advance towards a more personalized patient care.

Trans-activation-based risk assessment of BRCA1 BRCT variants with unknown clinical significance

Background

Deleterious variants in the tumour suppressor BRCA1 are known to cause hereditary breast and ovarian cancer syndrome (HBOC). Missense variants in BRCA1 pose a challenge in clinical care, as their effect on protein functionality often remains unknown. Many of the pathogenic missense variants found in BRCA1 are located in the BRCA1 C-terminal (BRCT) domains, domains that are known to be vital for key functions such as homologous recombination repair, protein-protein interactions and trans-activation (TA). We investigated the TA activity of 12 BRCA1 variants of unknown clinical significance (VUSs) located in the BRCT domains to aid in the classification of these variants.

Results

Twelve BRCA1 VUSs were investigated using a modified version of the dual luciferase TA activity assay (TA assay) that yielded increased sensitivity and sample throughput. Variants were classified according to American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) criteria using TA assay results and available data. In combining our TA-assay results and available data, in accordance with the ACMG guidelines for variant classification, we proposed the following variant classifications: c.5100A>G, c.5326C>T, c.5348T>C and c.5477A>T as likely benign (class 2) variants. c.5075A>C, c.5116G>A and c.5513T>G were likely pathogenic (class 4), whereas c.5096G>A likely represents a likely pathogenic variant with moderate penetrance. Variants c.5123C>T, c.5125G>A, c.5131A>C and c.5504G>A remained classified as VUSs (class 3).

Conclusions

The modified TA assay provides efficient risk assessment of rare missense variants found in the BRCA1 BRCT-domains. We also report that increased post-transfection incubation time yielded a significant increase in TA assay sensitivity.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s40246-018-0183-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

BRCA1 and Oxidative Stress

The breast cancer susceptibility gene 1 (BRCA1) has been well established as a tumor suppressor and functions primarily by maintaining genome integrity. Genome stability is compromised when cells are exposed to oxidative stress. Increasing evidence suggests that BRCA1 regulates oxidative stress and this may be another mechanism in preventing carcinogenesis in normal cells. Oxidative stress caused by reactive oxygen species (ROS) is implicated in carcinogenesis and is used strategically to treat human cancer. Thus, it is essential to understand the function of BRCA1 in oxidative stress regulation. In this review, we briefly summarize BRCA1's many binding partners and mechanisms, and discuss data supporting the function of BRCA1 in oxidative stress regulation. Finally, we consider its significance in prevention and/or treatment of BRCA1-related cancers.

Genome-wide analysis reveals a role for BRCA1 and PALB2 in transcriptional co-activation

Breast and ovarian cancer susceptibility genes BRCA1 and PALB2 have enigmatic roles in cellular growth and mammalian development. While these genes are essential for growth during early developmental programs, inactivation later in adulthood results in increased growth and formation of tumors, leading to their designation as tumor suppressors. We performed genome-wide analysis assessing their chromatin residence and gene expression responsiveness using high-throughput sequencing in breast epithelial cells. We found an intimate association between BRCA1 and PALB2 chromatin residence and genes displaying high transcriptional activity. Moreover, our experiments revealed a critical role for BRCA1 and, to a smaller degree, PALB2 in transcriptional responsiveness to NF-κB, a crucial mediator of growth and inflammatory response during development and cancer. Importantly, we also uncovered a vital role for BRCA1 and PALB2 in response to retinoic acid (RA), a growth inhibitory signal in breast cancer cells, which may constitute the basis for their tumor suppressor activity. Taken together, our results highlight an important role for these breast cancer proteins in the regulation of diverse growth regulatory pathways.

The expanding role of yeast in cancer research and diagnosis: insights into the function of the oncosuppressors p53 and BRCA1/2

When the glucose supply is high, despite the presence of oxygen, Saccharomyces cerevisiae uses fermentation as its main metabolic pathway and switches to oxidative metabolism only when this carbon source is limited. There are similarities between glucose-induced repression of oxidative metabolism of yeast and metabolic reprogramming of tumor cells. The glucose-induced repression of oxidative metabolism is regulated by oncogene homologues in yeast, such as RAS and Sch9p, the yeast homologue of Akt. Yeast also undergoes an apoptosis-like programmed cell death process sharing several features with mammalian apoptosis, including oxidative stress and a major role played by mitochondria. Evasion of apoptosis and sustained proliferative signaling are hallmarks of cancer. This, together with the possibility of heterologous expression of human genes in yeast, has allowed new insights to be obtained into the function of mammalian oncogenes/oncosuppressors. Here, we elaborate on the similarities between tumor and yeast cells underpinning the use of this model organism in cancer research. We also review the achievements obtained through heterologous expression in yeast of p53, BRCA1, and BRCA2, which are among the best-known cancer-susceptibility genes, with the aim of understanding their role in tumorigenesis. Yeast-cell-based functional assays for cancer genetic testing will also be dealt with.

Rrd1 isomerizes RNA polymerase II in response to rapamycin

Background

In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the immunosuppressant rapamycin engenders a profound modification in the transcriptional profile leading to growth arrest. Mutants devoid of Rrd1, a protein possessing in vitro peptidyl prolyl cis/trans isomerase activity, display striking resistance to the drug, although how Rrd1 activity is linked to the biological responses has not been elucidated.

Results

We now provide evidence that Rrd1 is associated with the chromatin and it interacts with RNA polymerase II. Circular dichroism revealed that Rrd1 mediates structural changes onto the C-terminal domain (CTD) of the large subunit of RNA polymerase II (Rpb1) in response to rapamycin, although this appears to be independent of the overall phosphorylation status of the CTD. In vitro experiments, showed that recombinant Rrd1 directly isomerizes purified GST-CTD and that it releases RNA polymerase II from the chromatin. Consistent with this, we demonstrated that Rrd1 is required to alter RNA polymerase II occupancy on rapamycin responsive genes.

Conclusion

We propose as a mechanism, that upon rapamycin exposure Rrd1 isomerizes Rpb1 to promote its dissociation from the chromatin in order to modulate transcription.

The ubiquitin-proteasome system in cancer, a major player in DNA repair. Part 2: transcriptional regulation

DNA repair is an indispensable part of a cell’s defence system against the devastating effects of DNA-damaging conditions. The regulation of this function is a really demanding situation, particularly when the stressing factors persist for a long time. In such cases, the depletion of existing DNA repair proteins has to be compensated by the induction of the analogous gene products. In addition, the arrest of transcription, which is another result of many DNA-damaging agents, needs to be overcome through regulation of transcription-specific DNA repair pathways. The involvement of the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS) in cancer- and chemotherapy-related DNA-damage repair relevant to the above transcriptional modification mechanisms are illustrated in this review. Furthermore, the contribution of UPS to the regulation of localization and accessibility of DNA repair proteins to chromatin, in response to cellular stress is discussed.

Human U2 snRNA genes exhibit a persistently open transcriptional state and promoter disassembly at metaphase

In mammals, small multigene families generate spliceosomal U snRNAs that are nearly as abundant as rRNA. Using the tandemly repeated human U2 genes as a model, we show by footprinting with DNase I and permanganate that nearly all sequences between the enhancer-like distal sequence element and the initiation site are protected during interphase whereas the upstream half of the U2 snRNA coding region is exposed. We also show by chromatin immunoprecipitation that the SNAPc complex, which binds the TATA-like proximal sequence element, is removed at metaphase but remains bound under conditions that induce locus-specific metaphase fragility of the U2 genes, such as loss of CSB, BRCA1, or BRCA2 function, treatment with actinomycin D, or overexpression of the tetrameric p53 C terminus. We propose that the U2 snRNA promoter establishes a persistently open state to facilitate rapid reinitiation and perhaps also to bypass TFIIH-dependent promoter melting; this open state would then be disassembled to allow metaphase chromatin condensation.

Yeast screens identify the RNA polymerase II CTD and SPT5 as relevant targets of BRCA1 interaction

BRCA1 has been implicated in numerous DNA repair pathways that maintain genome integrity, however the function responsible for its tumor suppressor activity in breast cancer remains obscure. To identify the most highly conserved of the many BRCA1 functions, we screened the evolutionarily distant eukaryote Saccharomyces cerevisiae for mutants that suppressed the G1 checkpoint arrest and lethality induced following heterologous BRCA1 expression. A genome-wide screen in the diploid deletion collection combined with a screen of ionizing radiation sensitive gene deletions identified mutants that permit growth in the presence of BRCA1. These genes delineate a metabolic mRNA pathway that temporally links transcription elongation (SPT4, SPT5, CTK1, DEF1) to nucleopore-mediated mRNA export (ASM4, MLP1, MLP2, NUP2, NUP53, NUP120, NUP133, NUP170, NUP188, POM34) and cytoplasmic mRNA decay at P-bodies (CCR4, DHH1). Strikingly, BRCA1 interacted with the phosphorylated RNA polymerase II (RNAPII) carboxy terminal domain (P-CTD), phosphorylated in the pattern specified by the CTDK-I kinase, to induce DEF1-dependent cleavage and accumulation of a RNAPII fragment containing the P-CTD. Significantly, breast cancer associated BRCT domain defects in BRCA1 that suppressed P-CTD cleavage and lethality in yeast also suppressed the physical interaction of BRCA1 with human SPT5 in breast epithelial cells, thus confirming SPT5 as a relevant target of BRCA1 interaction. Furthermore, enhanced P-CTD cleavage was observed in both yeast and human breast cells following UV-irradiation indicating a conserved eukaryotic damage response. Moreover, P-CTD cleavage in breast epithelial cells was BRCA1-dependent since damage-induced P-CTD cleavage was only observed in the mutant BRCA1 cell line HCC1937 following ectopic expression of wild type BRCA1. Finally, BRCA1, SPT5 and hyperphosphorylated RPB1 form a complex that was rapidly degraded following MMS treatment in wild type but not BRCA1 mutant breast cells. These results extend the mechanistic links between BRCA1 and transcriptional consequences in response to DNA damage and suggest an important role for RNAPII P-CTD cleavage in BRCA1-mediated cancer suppression.

Corepressor CtBP and nuclear speckle protein Pnn/DRS differentially modulate transcription and splicing of the E-cadherin gene

CtBP is a transcriptional corepressor with tumorigenic potential that targets the promoter of the tumor suppressor gene E-cadherin. Pnn/DRS (Pnn) is a "nuclear speckle"-associated protein involved in mRNA processing as well as transcriptional regulation of E-cadherin via its binding to CtBP. Here, we show that CtBP can recruit Pnn to CtBP-associated complexes, resulting in Pnn-dependent chromatin remodeling at the E-cadherin promoter. In addition, CtBP and Pnn can differentially modulate E-cadherin mRNA splicing, with polymerase II serving as an interface in this event. Therefore, the Pnn/CtBP functional interplay represents a novel mechanism linking the corepressor CtBP and Pnn to the transcription-coupled mRNA splicing of a major tumor suppressor gene. Our findings implicate the existence of the molecular switches involved in tumorigenesis, which coordinate promoter-specific events and mRNA processing, by serving as bridging elements between the regulatory complexes both at gene promoters and within the mRNA splicing machineries.

Coregulators: transducing signal from transcription to alternative splicing

Cells respond to many external stimuli by modulating gene expression. A key step in this regulation is the control of transcription, which determines the concentrations of pre-mRNA that are produced. A second level of control involves maturation of pre-mRNAs; many are alternatively spliced, which changes the exon content of transcripts and therefore the 'message' of the genes. Recent data indicate that the two control levels are linked. Here, we describe how transcriptional regulators and coregulators influence alternative splicing, with a focus on genes that are controlled by steroid hormones. Recent technical advances that help to elucidate the impact of stimuli on the exon content of regulated gene transcripts are also discussed.

The role of BRCA1 in transcriptional regulation and cell cycle control

The exact functions of BRCA1 have not been fully described but it now seems apparent that it has roles in DNA damage repair, transcriptional regulation, cell cycle control and most recently in ubiquitylation. These functions of BRCA1 are most likely interdependent but this review will focus on the role of BRCA1 in relation to transcriptional regulation and in particular how this impacts upon cell cycle control. We will (i) describe the structure of BRCA1 and how it may contribute to its transcription function; (ii) describe the interaction of BRCA1 with the core transcriptional machinery (RNA polII); (iii) describe how BRCA1 may regulate transcription at an epigenetic level through chromatin modification; (iv) discuss the role of BRCA1 in modulating transcription through its association with sequence-specific transcription factors. Finally, we will discuss the possible effects of BRCA1 transcriptional regulation on downstream targets with known roles in cell cycle control.

Tax interacts with P-TEFb in a novel manner to stimulate human T-lymphotropic virus type 1 transcription

Human T-lymphotropic virus type 1 (HTLV-1) encodes a transcriptional activator, Tax, whose function is essential for viral transcription and replication. Tax transactivates the viral long-terminal repeat through a series of protein-protein interactions which facilitate CREB and CBP/p300 binding. In addition, Tax dissociates transcription repressor histone deacetylase 1 interaction with the CREB response element. The subsequent events through which Tax interacts and communicates with RNA polymerase II and cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) are not clearly understood. Here we present evidence that Tax recruits positive transcription elongation factor b (P-TEFb) (CDK9/cyclin T1) to the viral promoter. This recruitment likely involves protein-protein interactions since Tax associates with P-TEFb in vitro as demonstrated by glutathione S-transferase fusion protein pull-down assays and in vivo as shown by co-immunoprecipitation assays. Functionally, small interfering RNA directed toward CDK9 inhibited Tax transactivation in transient assays. Consistent with these findings, the depletion of CDK9 from nuclear extracts inhibited Tax transactivation in vitro. Reconstitution of the reaction with wild-type P-TEFb, but not a kinase-dead mutant, recovered HTLV-1 transcription. Moreover, the addition of the CDK9 inhibitor flavopiridol blocked Tax transactivation in vitro and in vivo. Interestingly, we found that Tax regulates CDK9 kinase activity through a novel autophosphorylation pathway.

The BRCA1 COOH-terminal region acts as an RNA polymerase II carboxyl-terminal domain kinase inhibitor that modulates p21WAF1/CIP1 expression

BRCA1 is involved both in positive and negative regulation of gene activity as well as in numerous other processes, such as DNA damage response and repair. We recently reported that BRCA1 inhibits RNA polymerase II carboxyl-terminal domain (CTD) phosphorylation by TFIIH and decreases serine 5 phosphorylation levels when introduced into a BRCA1(-/-) cell line. Regulation of CTD phosphorylation is crucial for proper gene expression and response to cellular stresses, such as DNA damage and transcription arrest. A key player in this process, P-TEFb, phosphorylates the CTD on serine 2 of transcriptionally engaged RNA polymerase II, and its kinase activity was shown to be up-regulated when cells are exposed to transcriptional stress such as UV irradiation. Here, we investigate the effect of BRCA1 on serine 2 phosphorylation and UV-activated P-TEFb kinase activity. We now show that BRCA1 inhibits immunoprecipitated P-TEFb kinase activity from UV-irradiated cells and preferentially decreases UV-induced serine 2 phosphorylation of soluble, rather than chromatin-bound, RNAPII. We further show that BRCA1 rescues the UV-mediated inhibition of transcriptional activity from nuclear extracts and stimulates endogenous p21 gene expression upon UV irradiation, a function that is dependent of the inhibition of CTD kinase activity. Our results suggest that BRCA1 could act as a CTD kinase inhibitor and, as such, contribute to the regulation of p21 gene expression.

Cellular splicing and transcription regulatory protein p32 represses adenovirus major late transcription and causes hyperphosphorylation of RNA polymerase II

The cellular protein p32 is a multifunctional protein, which has been shown to interact with a large number of cellular and viral proteins and to regulate several important activities like transcription and RNA splicing. We have previously shown that p32 regulates RNA splicing by binding and inhibiting the essential SR protein ASF/SF2. To determine whether p32 also functions as a regulator of splicing in virus-infected cells, we constructed a recombinant adenovirus expressing p32 under the transcriptional control of an inducible promoter. Much to our surprise the results showed that p32 overexpression effectively blocked mRNA and protein expression from the adenovirus major late transcription unit (MLTU). Interestingly, the p32-mediated inhibition of MLTU transcription was accompanied by an approximately 4.5-fold increase in Ser 5 phosphorylation and an approximately 2-fold increase in Ser 2 phosphorylation of the carboxy-terminal domain (CTD). Further, in p32-overexpressing cells the efficiency of RNA polymerase elongation was reduced approximately twofold, resulting in a decrease in the number of polymerase molecules that reached the end of the major late L1 transcription unit. We further show that p32 stimulates CTD phosphorylation in vitro. The inhibitory effect of p32 on MLTU transcription appears to require the CAAT box element in the major late promoter, suggesting that p32 may become tethered to the MLTU via an interaction with the CAAT box binding transcription factor.

BRCA1: a locus-specific "liaison" in gene expression and genetic integrity

Mutations in BRCA1 predominantly lead to elevated risks of breast and ovarian cancers. In contrast to the tissue-specific nature of BRCA1tumors, the normal BRCA1 gene product functions in diverse nuclear events including transcription, DNA repair, and DNA damage checkpoint. Recent findings of physical and functional associations between BRCA1 and the RNA polymerase II (RNAPII)-dependent transcription machinery may shed some light on this longstanding paradox of BRCA1 biology. Eukaryotic gene expression is now known to be a continuous process, whereby each step is physically and functionally connected to the next. In particular, RNAPII plays a pivotal role in coordinating transcription with various pre-mRNA processing events and stress response. Interestingly, BRCA1 preferentially interacts with the processive form of RNAPII and proteins that regulate RNAPII activity and movement during transcription elongation. In response to DNA damage, BRCA1 dissociates from RNAPII and localizes to DNA damage sites. We propose that BRCA1 may coordinate multiple steps in gene expression, including transcription initiation, elongation, and pre-mRNA processing via its interactions with the transcription machinery at selected gene loci. The same BRCA1-associated transcription apparatus may serve as a sensor for stress signals and facilitate the transition from a transcription state to checkpoint/DNA repair state. Such a coordinating role of BRCA1 in gene expression may ensure the appropriate quantity and quality of the mature transcripts for certain breast and ovarian cancer-related genes, as well as the genetic integrity of the breast and ovary tissues.

BRCA1 in breast and ovarian cancer predisposition

Women carrying one mutated BRCA1 allele are at increased risk of developing breast and ovarian cancer but tumor initiation requires the loss of the wild-type allele indicating that it is a tumor suppressor gene. In the 10 years since the cloning of BRCA1, a function for the gene product in the DNA damage response has been established. However, identifying the exact biochemical activities of BRCA1 has been a more difficult task. Our current understanding suggests that the molecular functions mediated by the terminal ends of BRCA1, which include an E3 ubiquitin ligase activity at the N-terminus and a protein-protein interaction surface at the C-terminus, are critical to the function of this protein in the response to DNA damage.

BRCA1 regulation of transcription

BRCA1, a tumor suppressor gene on chromosome 17q21, was identified in 1994 based on its linkage to hereditary breast and ovarian cancer syndromes. The BRCA1 gene encodes a 220 kDa nuclear phosphoprotein. Studies aimed at elucidating the mechanisms of its tumor suppressor activity have revealed, in part, that BRCA1 participates in the DNA damage response and acts to maintain the integrity of the genome. This activity is generic and does not account for the propensity of BRCA1 mutation carriers to develop specific tumor types rather than a broad spectrum of cancers. In addition to genome maintenance, BRCA1 has been found to broadly regulate gene transcription, even though it is not itself a sequence-specific DNA-binding transcription factor. The ability of BRCA1 to function as a coregulator of transcription may underlie some of its tumor suppressor activity and may explain the tissue-specific nature of this activity. This review will focus on how BRCA1 selectively regulates transcription and how this regulatory function may relate to tumor suppression.