Activation of a nonexpressed hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase allele in mutant H23 HeLa cells by agents that inhibit DNA methylation

Can the L5178Y Tk+/- mouse lymphoma assay detect epigenetic silencing?

The mouse lymphoma L5178Y Tk(+/-) assay is broadly used in toxicology to assess genotoxicity because of its known sensitivity to genotoxicants that act through a variety of mechanisms, which may include epigenetic DNA methylation. This brief article highlights the studies that have contributed to this conjecture and suggests an addition to the experimental design that could identify if the test substance is a potential epimutagen acting via hypermethylation.

Site-specific methylation in gene coding region underlies transcriptional silencing of the Phytochrome A epiallele in Arabidopsis thaliana

DNA methylation in cytosine residues plays an important role in regulating gene expression. Densely methylated transgenes are often silenced. In contrast, several eukaryotic genomes express moderately methylated genes. These methylations are found in the CG context within the coding region (gene body). The role of gene body methylation in gene expression, however, is not clear. The Arabidopsis Phytochrome A epiallele, phyA', carries hypermethylation in several CG sites resident to the coding region. As a result, phyA' is transcriptionally silenced and confers strong mutant phenotype. Mutations in chromatin modification factors and RNAi genes failed to revert the mutant phenotype, suggesting the involvement of a distinct epigenetic mechanism associated with phyA' silencing. Using the forward genetics approach, a suppressor line, termed as suppressor of p hyA' silencing 1 (sps1), was isolated. Genetic and molecular analysis revealed that sps1 mutation reactivates the phyA' locus without altering its methylation density. However, hypomethylation at a specific CG site in exon 1 was consistently associated with the release of phyA' silencing. While gene underlying sps1 mutation is yet to be identified, microarray analysis suggested that its targets are the expressed genes or euchromatic loci in Arabidopsis genome. By identifying the association of phyA' silencing with the methylation of a specific CG site in exon 1, the present work shows that site-specific methylation confers greater effect on transcription than the methylation density within gene-body. Further, as the identified site (exon 1) is not critical for the promoter activity, transcription elongation rather than transcription initiation is likely to be affected by this site-specific CG methylation.

Heritable alterations at the adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT) locus in human lymphoblastoid cell lines

Human lymphoblastoid cell lines derived from WI-L2 exhibit unexpected frequencies of diaminopurine (DAP) resistant mutants. The background mutant fractions of 10(-7) to 10(-8) in untreated cultures are much lower than the frequencies expected for loss of a heterozygous autosomal locus (10(-5) to 10(-6), yet much higher than expected for a homozygous locus (10(-10) to 10(-12). We used aminopterin, adenine and thymidine (AAT) to select DAP-sensitive (DAPS) revertants from one resistant line. The background frequency of DAPR in these revertant cell lines ranged from 3.5 to 6.5 x 10(-4), approximately the square root of 10(-7). Thus these data suggest that both alleles of aprt are inactivated at similarly high frequencies. They also indicate that the DAPS revertants were heterozygotes (aprt +/-) or hemizygotes (aprt +/0) and that WI-L2 was homozygous (aprt+/+). Mutational dose-response studies with X-rays, ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), and ICR-191 were conducted in 4 of these revertant cell lines. EMS and ICR-191, which induce mainly point mutations, did not induce an increase in mutant fraction. A dose of 200 cGy X-rays, however, induced a frequency of 10(-3). Treatment of DAPR cells with 5-azacytidine induced a significant increase in reversion to DAPS. Southern blot analysis of the aprt gene after digestion with MspI or HpaII also suggests that differential methylation changes may play a major role in the generation of DAP sensitivity and resistance.

Mutations and epimutations in mammalian cells

Early studies on heritable variation in cultured mammalian cells suggested that both mutation and epigenetic events might be involved. The importance of mutations has subsequently been fully documented, but only recently has an alternative form of inheritance been uncovered. This is based on the post-synthetic methylation of cytosine in regulatory regions of genes. The pattern of methylation is heritable, and in almost all cases studied, methylation of a region is associated with lack of gene expression. Such silent genes can be reactivated by the powerful demethylating agent 5-azacytidine (5-aza-CR). Changes in heritable DNA methylation which alter phenotype are referred to as epimutations. It now seems very likely that the well known 'functional hemizygosity' in CHO cells and other near diploid cell lines is due to the existence of one active and one silent gene at many autosomal loci. It is clear that permanent cell lines inactivate genes by de novo methylation, whereas normal diploid cells do not have this activity. This has important implications for our understanding of cellular transformation, tumor progression, and the increase in chromosome number frequently associated with these cellular changes. It is likely that both mutations and epimutations are important in the emergence of fully transformed tumorigenic cells. Agents which increase or reduce DNA methylation in cells can be regarded as epimutagens, although in many cases the mechanisms of inducing hypo- or hyper-methylation are not understood. Two exceptions are 5-aza-CR which inhibits the normal DNA maintenance methylase activity, and 5-methyldeoxycytidine triphosphate which is incorporated into cellular DNA following electroporation and has been shown to silence genes.

Mutagenic treatments result in inactivation of expression of a transfected bacterial gene integrated into a human cell line

The cell line E2 is a SV40-transformed human fibroblast cell line containing a single integrated copy of the bacterial guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (gpt) gene. Treatment of E2 with ultraviolet light (UV) or ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS) induced the formation of Gpt- derivatives. Several induced derivatives have been isolated, and the structure, expression and revertibility of the gpt gene have been analysed. In the majority of cases the Gpt- phenotype resulted from switching off the gpt gene, in most instances by methylation, but in a few cases by phenotypic switching. Thus mutagenic treatment can result in the inactivation of gene expression in human cells. In a small proportion of Gpt- derivatives the gpt sequences were deleted.

DNA methylation and differentiation

The methylation of specific cytosine residues in DNA has been implicated in regulating gene expression and facilitating functional specialization of cellular phenotypes. Generally, the demethylation of certain CpG sites correlates with transcriptional activation of genes. 5-Azacytidine is an inhibitor of DNA methylation and has been widely used as a potent activator of suppressed genetic information. Treatment of cells with 5-azacytidine results in profound phenotypic alterations. The drug-induced hypomethylation of DNA apparently perturbs DNA-protein interactions that may consequently alter transcriptional activity and cell determination. The inhibitory effect of cytosine methylation may be exerted via altered DNA-protein interactions specifically or may be transduced by a change in the conformation of chromatin. Recent studies have demonstrated that cytosine methylation also plays a central role in parental imprinting, which in turn determines the differential expression of maternal and paternal genomes during embryogenesis. In other words, methylation is the mechanism whereby the embryo retains memory of the gametic origin of each component of genetic information. A memory of this type would probably persist during DNA replication and cell division as methylation patterns are stable and heritable.

Effect of cholesterol epoxides on the inhibition of intercellular communication and on mutation induction in Chinese hamster V79 cells

Cholesterol, cholesterol-5 alpha, 6 alpha-epoxide, cholesterol-5 beta, 6 beta-epoxide and cholestane-3 beta,5 alpha,6 beta-triol were tested for their ability to induce mutations at the Na+/K+-ATPase loci of the Chinese hamster V79 cells. None of these compounds induced ouabain-resistant mutations compared to the background mutation frequency in the control cells. These compounds were further tested for their ability to inhibit intercellular communication, using the Chinese hamster V79 cell metabolic cooperation assay. The diastereomeric epoxides and cholestane-triol, but not cholesterol, were found to be inhibitors of intercellular communication in a manner similar to other known tumor promoters.

Do trifluorothymidine-resistant mutants of L5178Y mouse lymphoma cells re-express thymidine kinase activity following 5-azacytidine treatment?

TFT is an effective selective agent for TK-deficient mutants of L5178Y TK+/- -3.7.2C mouse lymphoma cells. Mutants can be classified by colony size into small colonies (many of which show readily observable chromosome abnormalities associated with chromosome 11--the location of the TK gene) and large colonies (which may represent events affecting only the expression of the TK gene). The precise nature of the induced damage causing the loss of the TK-enzyme activity for both mutant type is not known and is currently under investigation. The hypomethylating agent 5-azacytidine can be utilized to investigate the possibility that mutants might be the result of a suppressed rather than an altered TK gene. Mutant cell lines are treated with 5-azacytidine and then evaluated for re-expression of the TK enzyme as measured by resistance to THMG. In these studies, 11 mutants have been evaluated. None of the 11, including 10 small-colony mutants (6 with chromosome 11 translocations) and 1 large-colony mutant, show a high conversion to TK competency following 5-azacytidine treatment.

Activation of endogeneous retroviruses in mouse cells by thermal neutrons

The effect of thermal neutrons on the induction of murine endogenous viruses from a mouse fibroblast cell line was investigated. Thermal neutrons were more effective than X-rays in induction of endogenous virus as well as in killing of the cells. However, when measured as a function of cell killing, both radiations had similar efficiency of induction. The RBEs of thermal neutrons alone were calculated on the assumption that the contribution of contaminating gamma-rays was additive. It was 4.2 for the killing effect and 4-5 for virus induction.