Should this systematic review and meta-analysis change my practice? Part 1: exploring treatment effect and trustworthiness

Visual analysis of trustworthiness studies: based on the Web of Science database

Trustworthiness is the most significant predictor of trust and has a significant impact on people's levels of trust. Most trustworthiness-related research is empirical, and while it has a long history, it is challenging for academics to get insights that are applicable to their fields of study and to successfully transfer fragmented results into practice. In order to grasp their dynamic development processes through the mapping of network knowledge graphs, this paper is based on the Web of Science database and uses CiteSpace (6.2.R4) software to compile and visualize the 1,463 publications on trustworthy studies over the past 10 years. This paper aims to provide valuable references to theoretical research and the practice of Trustworthiness. The findings demonstrate that: over the past 10 years, trustworthiness-related research has generally increased in volume; trustworthiness research is concentrated in industrialized Europe and America, with American research findings having a bigger global impact; The University of California System, Harvard University, and Yale University are among the high-production institutions; the leading figures are represented by Alexander Todorov, Marco Brambilla, Bastian Jaeger, and others; the core authors are distinguished university scholars; however, the level of cooperation of the core author needs to be improved. The primary journal for publishing research on trustworthiness is the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology and Biology Letters. In addition, the study focuses on three distinct domains, involving social perception, facial clues, and artificial intelligence.

Conditioned Pain Modulation Does Not Differ Between People With Lower-Limb Tendinopathy and Nontendinopathy Controls: A Systematic Review With Individual Participant Data Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE: To explore whether people with lower-limb tendinopathy have reduced relative conditioned pain modulation (CPM) when compared to nontendinopathy controls. DESIGN: Systematic review with individual participant data (IPD) meta-analysis. LITERATURE SEARCH: Eight databases were searched until August 29, 2022. STUDY SELECTION CRITERIA: Cross-sectional studies comparing the magnitude of the CPM effect in people with lower-limb tendinopathy to nontendinopathy controls in a case-control design. DATA SYNTHESIS: Included studies provided IPD, which was reported using descriptive statistics. Generalized estimating equations (GEEs) determined between-group differences in the relative CPM effect, when adjusting for co-variables. Study quality was assessed using a Joanna Briggs Institute checklist, and certainty of the evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluations. RESULTS: Five records were included, IPD were provided for 4 studies (n = 219 with tendinopathy, n = 226 controls). The principal GEE (model 1) found no significant relative CPM effects for tendinopathy versus controls (B = -1.73, P = .481). Sex (B = 4.11, P = .160), age (B = -0.20, P = .109), and body mass index (B = 0.28, P = .442) did not influence relative CPM effect. The Achilles region had a reduced CPM effect (B = -22.01, P = .009). In model 2 (adjusting for temperature), temperature (B = -2.86, P = .035) and female sex (B = 21.01, P = .047) were associated with the size of the relative CPM effect. All studies were low-quality, and the certainty of the evidence was moderate. CONCLUSION: There were no between-group differences in the magnitude of the CPM effect, suggesting clinicians should manage lower-limb tendinopathy using interventions appropriate for peripherally dominant pain (eg, tendon loading exercises such as heavy slow resistance). Based on the "moderate"-certainty evidence, future studies are unlikely to substantially change these findings. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2023;54(1):1-10. Epub 19 October 2023. doi:10.2519/jospt.2023.11940.

Injury Profiles of Police Recruits Undergoing Basic Physical Training: A Prospective Cohort Study

Purpose A lack of published epidemiological data among police recruits presents a major challenge when designing appropriate prevention programs to reduce injury burden. We aimed to report the injury epidemiology of Western Australian (WA) Police Force recruits and examine sex and age as injury risk factors. Methods Retrospective analyses were conducted of prospectively collected injury data from WA Police Force recruits between 2018-2021. Injury was defined as 'time-loss' and injury incidence rate per 1000 training days (Poisson exact 95% confidence intervals) was calculated. For each region and type of injury, the incidence, severity, and burden were calculated. The association between age, sex, and injury occurrence were assessed using Cox regression time-to-event analysis. Results A total of 1316 WA Police Force recruits were included, of whom 264 recruits sustained 304 injuries. Injury prevalence was 20.1% and the incidence rate was 2.00 (95%CI 1.78-2.24) injuries per 1000 training days. Lower limb injuries accounted for most of the injury burden. Ligament/ joint injuries had the highest injury tissue/pathology burden. The most common activity injuring recruits was physical training (31.8% of all injuries). Older age (Hazard Ratio = 1.5, 95%CI = 1.2 to 1.9, p = 0.002) and female sex (Hazard Ratio = 1.4, 95%CI = 1.3 to 1.6, p < 0.001) increased risk of injury. Conclusion Prevention programs targeting muscle/tendon and ligament/joint injuries to the lower limb and shoulder should be prioritised to reduce the WA Police Force injury burden. Injury prevention programs should also prioritise recruits who are over 30 years of age or of female sex, given they are a higher risk population.

Can we really say getting stronger makes your tendon feel better? No current evidence of a relationship between change in Achilles tendinopathy pain or disability and changes in triceps Surae structure or function when completing rehabilitation: a systematic review

OBJECTIVES

Determine if improvements in pain and disability in patients with mid-portion Achilles tendinopathy relate to changes in muscle structure and function whilst completing exercise rehabilitation.

DESIGN

A systematic review exploring the relationship between changes in pain/disability and muscle structure/function over time, following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines.

METHODS

Six online databases and the grey literature were searched from database inception to 16th December 2022 whereas clinical trial registries were searched from database inception to 11th February 2020. We included clinical studies where participants received exercise rehabilitation (±placebo interventions) for mid-portion Achilles tendinopathy if pain/disability and Triceps Surae structure/function were measured. We calculated Cohen's d (95 % confidence intervals) for changes in muscle structure/function over time for individual studies. Data were not pooled due to heterogeneity. Study quality was assessed using a modified Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.

RESULTS

Seventeen studies were included for synthesis. No studies reported the relationship between muscle structure/function and pain/disability changes. Twelve studies reported muscle structure/function outcome measures at baseline and at least one follow-up time-point. Three studies reported improvements in force output after treatment; eight studies demonstrated no change in structure or function; one study did not provide a variation measure, precluding within group change over time calculation. All studies were low quality.

CONCLUSIONS

No studies explored the relationship between changes in tendon pain and disability and changes in muscle structure and function. It is unclear whether current exercise-based rehabilitation protocols for mid-portion Achilles tendinopathy improve muscle structure or function.

SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION

PROSPERO (registration number: CRD42020149970).

The Benefits to Bone Health in Children and Pre-School Children with Additional Exercise Interventions: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

Determine if exercise interventions, beyond what is already provided to children and preschool children, improve bone health and reduce fracture incidence.

DESIGN

Systematic review and meta-analysis reported using the PRISMA guidelines. Certainty of evidence was assessed using GRADE recommendations.

DATA SOURCES

Five electronic databases were searched for records: PUBMED; CINAHL; CENTRAL; SPORTDiscus; Web of Science.

ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES

Randomised, quasi-randomised and non-randomised controlled trials (including cluster-randomised) assessing the impact of additional exercise interventions (e.g., increased physical education classes or specific jumping programs) on bone health in children (6-12 years) and pre-school children (2-5 years) without dietary intervention.

RESULTS

Thirty-one records representing 16 distinct clinical trials were included. Dual-energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DXA) and/or peripheral Quantitative Computed Tomography (pQCT) were used to quantify bone health. Increased femoral neck bone mineral content in children with additional exercise interventions (n = 790, SMD = 0.55, 95% CI = 0.01 to 1.09) was reported, however this was not significant following sensitivity analysis. Other DXA and pQCT measures, as well as fracture incidence, did not appear to significantly differ over time between intervention and control groups. No studies reported adverse events. Studies failed to report all domains within the TIDieR checklist. All studies were at high risk of bias using the Cochrane RoB Tool 2.0. The certainty of the evidence was very low.

CONCLUSIONS

The addition of exercise interventions, beyond what is provided to children, does not appear to improve DXA and pQCT measures of bone health. The effect of additional exercise interventions on bone health in pre-school children is largely unknown. Future trials should ensure adherence is clearly reported and controlled for within analysis as well as including reports of adverse events (e.g., apophysitis) that occur due to increased exercise interventions.

Evaluation of SS-31 as a Potential Strategy for Tendinopathy Treatment: An In Vitro Model

BACKGROUND

Studies in our laboratory have demonstrated mitochondrial dysfunction in human and animal models of supraspinatus tendinopathy. SS-31 (elamipretide) has been reported to improve mitochondrial function and to be effective in clinical trials for several diseases. The potential of SS-31 in treating tendinopathy has not been explored.

HYPOTHESIS

SS-31 would improve mitochondrial function in human tenocytes sampled from patients with tendinopathy.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

Healthy tenocytes were obtained from normal hamstring tendon biopsy specimens in 9 patients undergoing anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, and tenocytes were collected from degenerative supraspinatus tendon biopsy specimens in 9 patients undergoing rotator cuff repair. Tenocytes were cultured, used at passage 1, and assigned to 4 groups: healthy tenocytes, healthy tenocytes with 1μM SS-31 treatment for 72 hours, degenerative tenocytes, and degenerative tenocytes with 1μM SS-31 treatment for 72 hours. The outcomes included measurements of mitochondrial potential, mitochondrial morphology by transmission electron microscopy imaging, reactive oxygen species and superoxidative dismutase activity, gene expression, and cell viability.

RESULTS

An increase in the cell fraction with depolarized mitochondria was found in degenerative tenocytes (P = .014), followed by a decrease after SS-31 treatment (P = .018). Transmission electron microscopy images demonstrated morphological changes with a decreased number and size of mitochondria per cell in the degenerative tenocytes (P = .018) and with improvement after SS-31 treatment. There was no significant difference in the level of reactive oxygen species between healthy and degenerative tenocytes in culture, but superoxidative dismutase activity was significantly decreased in the degenerative group (P = .006), which then increased after SS-31 treatment (P = .012). These findings suggested that mitochondrial dysfunction may be reversed by SS-31 treatment. The gene expression of matrix metalloproteinase-1 (matrix remodeling, P = .029) and fatty acid-binding protein 4 (fatty infiltration, P = .046) was significantly upregulated in the degenerative tenocytes and reduced by SS-31 treatment (P = .048; P = .007). Gene expression for hypoxia-inducible factor1 α and the proapoptotic regulator Bcl-2-associated X protein was increased in the degenerative tenocytes. There was a significant decrease in cell viability in degenerative tenocytes as compared with the healthy tenocytes, with small improvement after treatment with SS-31.

CONCLUSION

There are changes in mitochondrial structure and function in tenocytes derived from degenerative tendons, and SS-31, as a mitochondrial protectant, could improve mitochondrial function and promote the healing of tendinopathy.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Mitochondrial dysfunction appears to play a role in the development of tendinopathy, and SS-31, as a mitochondrial protective agent, may be a therapeutic agent in the treatment of tendinopathy.

Musculoskeletal injury epidemiology in law enforcement and firefighter recruits during physical training: a systematic review

Objectives

Report the injury epidemiology of law enforcement and firefighter recruits.

Design

A systematic epidemiological review following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses 2020 guidelines was completed.

Data sources

Five online databases were searched from database inception to 5 May 2021.

Eligibility criteria for selecting studies

Prospective and retrospective studies that reported data on musculoskeletal injuries sustained by law enforcement or firefighter recruits were included. We reported on all components of injury where data were available. All injury incidence rates were calculated as per 1000 training days (Poisson 95% CI) to allow comparisons between studies. Study quality was assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute Quality Assessment Checklist for Prevalence Studies.

Results

No studies reporting firefighter recruits were identified. Eight published studies that reported on injuries to law enforcement recruits were identified. The studies were all low quality, and the credibility of the evidence was assessed as very low. Seven studies reported medical attention injuries, and one study reported the number of medical withdrawals from a recruit training programme. The prevalence of law enforcement recruits with medical attention injuries ranged from 13.7% to 24.5%. The overall medical attention injury incidence rate for law enforcement recruits ranged from 1.67 injuries per 1000 training days (Poisson 95% CI 1.00 to 2.34 injuries per 1000 training days) to 4.24 injuries per 1000 training days (Poisson 95% CI 2.97 to 5.51 injuries per 1000 training days).

Conclusion

This review reported the prevalence and incidence rates for musculoskeletal injuries in law enforcement officers. However, the credibility of the evidence is very low.

PROSPERO registration number

CRD42021251084.