Mosaicism and incomplete penetrance of PCDH19 mutations

Seizure course of PCDH19 clustering epilepsy in female children: A multicentre cohort study in China

AIM

To investigate the seizure course of PCDH19 clustering epilepsy (PCDH19-CE) in a cohort of female children in China.

METHOD

This ambidirectional cohort study examined 113 female patients with PCDH19-CE through multicentre collaboration. Prognostic factors for seizure freedom were evaluated by multivariate Cox regression analysis.

RESULTS

The median seizure course period from seizure onset was 6 years 6 months. Of 113 patients, 78% and 56% experienced seizure freedom for at least 1 year and at least 2 years respectively. In patients younger than 5 years (n = 30), 5 to 10 years (n = 52), and older than 10 years (n = 31), 57%, 81%, and 94% experienced at least 1 year of seizure freedom, and 32%, 52%, and 84% experienced at least 2 years of seizure freedom, respectively. However, 58% (65 out of 113) relapsed at least once after more than 1 year of seizure freedom without trigger exposure (40%) or because of common triggers, including fever (43%) and antiseizure medication (ASM) reduction (29%). There was an 84% risk of seizure relapse after ASM reduction attempts. The likelihood of seizure freedom decreased with early age at seizure onset and developmental delay.

INTERPRETATION

Patients with PCDH19-CE exhibit increasing seizure freedom with age, but there is a risk of relapse. ASM reduction in children younger than 10 years old requires caution. Patients with early seizure onset and developmental delay have a reduced chance of seizure freedom.

WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS

The seizure freedom rate in PCDH19 clustering epilepsy gradually increases with age. The disease course is characterized by relapsing-remitting seizures. Antiseizure medication reduction requires caution for patients younger than 10 years of age. Patients with early seizure onset and developmental delay are less likely to achieve seizure freedom.

NGS-Based Identification of Two Novel PCDH19 Mutations in Female Patients with Early-Onset Epilepsy

Developmental and epileptic encephalopathy-9 (DEE9) is characterized by seizure onset in infancy, mild to severe intellectual impairment, and psychiatric features and is caused by a mutation in the PCDH19 gene on chromosome Xq22. The rare, unusual X-linked type of disorder affects heterozygous females and mosaic males; transmitting males are unaffected. In our study, 165 patients with epilepsy were tested by Next Generation Sequencing (NGS)-based panel and exome sequencing using Illumina technology. PCDH19 screening identified three point mutations, one indel, and one 29 bp-long deletion in five unrelated female probands. Two novel mutations, c.1152_1180del (p.Gln385Serfs*6) and c.830_831delinsAA (p.Phe277*), were identified and found to be de novo pathogenic. Moreover, among the three inherited mutations, two originated from asymptomatic mothers and one from an affected father. The PCDH19 c.1682C>T and c.1711G>T mutations were present in the DNA samples of asymptomatic mothers. After targeted parental testing, X chromosome inactivation tests and Sanger sequencing were carried out for mosaicism examination on maternal saliva samples in the two asymptomatic PCDH19 mutation carrier subjects. Tissue mosaicism and X-inactivation tests were negative. Our results support the opportunity for reduced penetrance in DEE9 and contribute to expanding the genotype-phenotype spectrum of PCDH19-related epilepsy.

[Sperm Mosaic Variants and Their Influence on the Offspring]

Genomic mosaicism arising from mosaic variants is a phenomenon that describes the presence of a cell or cell populations with different genome compositions from the germline cells of an individual. It comprises all types of genetic variants. A large proportion of childhood genetic disorders are defined as being de novo, meaning that the disease-causing mutations are only detected in the proband, not in any of the parents. Population studies show that 80% of the de novo mutations arise from the paternal haplotype, that is, from paternal sperm mosaicism. This review provides a summary of the types and detection strategies of sperm mosaicism. In addition, it provides discussions on how recent studies demonstrated that genomic mosaic mutations in parents, especially those in the paternal sperms, could be inherited by the offspring and cause childhood disorders. According to the previous findings of the author's research team, sperm mosaicism derived from early embryogenesis and primordial germ cell stages can explain 5% to 20% of the de novo mutations related to clinical phenotypes and can serve as an important predictor of both rare and complex disorders. Sperm mosaicism shows great potential for clinical genetic diagnosis and consultations. Based on the published literature, the author suggests that, large-scale screening for de novo sperm mosaic mutations and population-based genetic screening should be conducted in future studies, which will greatly enhance the risk assessment in the offspring and effectively improve the genetic health at the population level. Implementation of direct sperm detection for de novo mutations will significantly increase the efficiency of the stratification of patient cohorts and improve recurrence risk assessment for future births. Future research in the field should be focused on the impact of environmental and lifestyle factors on the health of the offspring through sperms and their modeling of mutation signatures. In addition, targeted in vitro modeling of sperm mutations will also be a promising direction.

PCDH19-clustering epilepsy, pathophysiology and clinical significance

PCDH19 clustering epilepsy (PCDH19-CE) is an X-linked epilepsy disorder associated with intellectual disability (ID) and behavioral disturbances, which is caused by PCDH19 gene variants. PCDH19 pathogenic variant leads to epilepsy in heterozygous females, not in hemizygous males and the inheritance pattern is unusual. The hypothesis of cellular interference was described as a key pathogenic mechanism. According to that, males do not develop the disease because of the uniform expression of PCDH19 (variant or wild type) unless they have a somatic variation. We conducted a literature review on PCDH19-CE pathophysiology and concluded that other significant mechanisms could contribute to pathogenesis including: asymmetric cell division and heterochrony, female-related allopregnanolone deficiency, altered steroid gene expression, decreased Gamma-aminobutyric acid receptor A (GABAA) function, and blood-brain barrier (BBB) dysfunction. Being aware of these mechanisms helps us when we should decide which therapeutic option is more suitable for which patient.

A Male Child with Infantile Epilepsy due to a Mosaic Missense Variant of PCDH19

Background

Pathogenic variants of PCDH19, located on the X-chromosome (Xq22.1), cause a rare epileptic encephalopathy with speech and development delay, seizures, behavioral and psychiatric problems. The specific underlying pathogenic mechanism is known as "cellular interference" that results in affected heterozygous females, normal hemizygous males and affected mosaic males but its functioning is not yet clear.

Objectives

Reporting new cases of affected males is considered useful to a deeper insight.

Subject and Method

We present the case of a three-year-old boy with early-onset seizures at 3 months of age, mild cognitive impairment, partial control of seizures with levetiracetam, normal brain imaging.

Results

The patient has a mosaic pathogenic variant c.698A>G (p.Asp233Gly) in PCDH19 assessed by Next Generation Sequencing analysis. We have compared his characteristics with the genotypes and phenotypes of 34 PCDH19 mosaic males earlier reported in the literature. Finally, we have summarized today's knowledge about phenotype-genotype correlation and pharmacological response in these patients.

Conclusions

Our report confirms that the clinical picture of mosaic affected males, resembling that of females, can show a wide variability in severity of disease and underlines a stringent need to improve therapeutic approaches and to collect data on long-term follow-up.

Identification of Two Variants c.2697A > C and c.3305A > C in USP7 by Analysis of Whole-Exome Sequencing in Chinese Patients with Hao-Fountain Syndrome

Background  Variants of ubiquitin-specific protease 7 ( USP7 ) gene in humans are associated with a neurodevelopmental disorder-Hao-Fountain syndrome, its core symptoms including developmental delay, intellectual disability, and speech delay. Other variable symptoms can affect multiple systems. In present study, we report two patients with core features from two unrelated consanguineous families originating from the Tianjin Children's Hospital. Methods and Results  Genomic DNA was extracted from the peripheral blood samples collected from the probands with their family members and whole-exome sequencing (WES) was used to detect the pathogenic genes in the probands. Suspected variants were subsequently validated by Sanger sequencing. In family 1, WES revealed that the proband carried the de novo variant c.2697A > C (p.Leu899Phe) in USP7 (NM_003470.3). In family 2, WES identified the variant c.3305A > C (p.Asn1102Thr) in USP7 (NM_003470.3) from the proband. Conclusion  We reported two cases of Hao-Fountain syndrome caused by novel USP7 variants. In addition, we report the first case of mosaicism with a USP7 variant in Chinese family. Our findings demonstrate the importance of WES in diagnosis of genetic diseases and expands the USP7 variants spectrum in Hao-Fountain syndrome. Moreover, we summarize the cases caused by USP7 variants in the literature. Our study can provide a vital reference for the diagnosis of future cases.

Maternal mosaicism in SSBP1 causing optic atrophy with retinal degeneration: implications for genetic counseling

BACKGROUND

Optic atrophy-13 with retinal and foveal abnormalities (OPA13) (MIM #165510) is a mitochondrial disease in which apparent bilateral optic atrophy is present and sometimes followed by retinal pigmentary changes or photoreceptors degeneration. OPA13 is caused by heterozygous mutation in the SSBP1 gene, associated with variable mitochondrial dysfunctions.

RESULTS

We have previously reported a 16-year-old Taiwanese male diagnosed with OPA13 and SSBP1 variant c.320G>A (p.Arg107Gln) was identified by whole exon sequence (WES). This variant was assumed to be de novo since his parents were clinically unaffected. However, WES and Sanger sequencing further revealed the proband's unaffected mother carrying the same SSBP1 variant with a 13% variant allele frequency (VAF) in her peripheral blood. That finding strongly indicates the maternal gonosomal mosaicism contributing to OPA13, which has not been reported before.

CONCLUSIONS

In summary, we described the first case of OPA13 caused by maternal gonosomal mosaicism in SSBP1. Parental mosaicism could be a serious issue in OPA13 diagnosis, and appropriate genetic counseling should be considered.

Maternal Mosaicism in SSBP1 Causing Optic Atrophy with Retinal Degeneration: Implications for Genetic Counseling

Background: Optic atrophy-13 with retinal and foveal abnormalities (OPA13) (MIM #165510) is a mitochondrial disease in which apparent bilateral optic atrophy is present and sometimes followed by retinal pigmentary changes or photoreceptors degeneration. OPA13 is caused by heterozygous mutation in the SSBP1 gene, associated with variable mitochondrial dysfunctions. Results: We have previously reported a 16-year-old Taiwanese male diagnosed with OPA13 and SSBP1 variant c.320G>A (p.Arg107Gln) was identified by whole exon sequence (WES). This variant was assumed to be de novo since his parents were clinically unaffected. However, WES and Sanger sequencing further revealed the proband’s unaffected mother carrying the same SSBP1 variant with a 13% variant allele frequency (VAF) in her peripheral blood. That finding strongly indicates the maternal gonosomal mosaicism contributing to OPA13, which has not been reported before. Conclusions: In summary, we described the first case of OPA13 caused by maternal gonosomal mosaicism in SSBP1 . Parental mosaicism could be a serious issue in OPA13 diagnosis, and appropriate genetic counseling should be considered.

Detecting genomic mosaicism in "de novo" genetic epilepsy by amplicon-based deep sequencing

AIM

To investigate the occurrence of mosaicism in epilepsy probands and their parents using amplicon-based deep sequencing (ADS).

METHODS

Patients were recruited from the outpatient of Peking University First Hospital. Two hundred and sixty-four probands with pathogenic variants tested by next-generation sequencing (NGS) were enrolled.

RESULTS

Mosaic variants were detected in seventeen disease-associated genes from 20 probands, 5 paternal, and 6 maternal parents. The frequency of mosaicism was 11.74% (31/264). Mosaicism in 11 genes was identified from 20 probands with the mutant allelic fractions (MAFs) of 12.95-38.00% in autosomal dominant genes. Five paternal mosaicisms were identified in genes with a MAF of 6.30-20.99%, and six maternal mosaic individuals with a MAF of 2.07-21.90%. Only four mosaic parents had milder seizure history. The affected sibling had the same phenotype consistent with that of the proband, who inherited the variant of SLC1A2 or STXBP1 from their unaffected mosaic mothers, respectively.

INTERPRETATION

Mosaic phenomenon is not rare in families with epilepsy. Phenotypes of mosaic parents were milder or normal. Mosaicism detection is helpful to identify the mutation origin and it provides a theoretical basis for prenatal diagnosis of family reproduction. ADS is a reliable way of mosaicism detection for clinical application.

PCDH19-related epilepsy in mosaic males: The phenotypic implication of genotype and variant allele frequency

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the genotypes and phenotypes of mosaic male patients with PCDH19-related epilepsy (PCDH19-RE) and explore the correlation between genotype, variant allele frequency (VAF), and phenotypic severity.

METHODS

Clinical data and peripheral blood samples of 11 male mosaic patients were collected and analyzed in our study. The VAF of the PCDH19 gene from peripheral blood was quantified using amplicon-based deep sequencing. Additional 20 mosaic male patients with PCDH19-RE were collected from the published literature, with 10 patients whose VAFs of the PCDH19 gene were available for analytic purposes.

RESULTS

In our cohort of 11 patients, 10 variants were identified, and four were novel. The VAF of the PCDH19 gene from peripheral blood ranged from 27 to 90%. The median seizure onset age was 6 months (range: 4-9 months). Clinical manifestations included cluster seizures (100%), fever sensitivity (73%), focal seizures (91%), developmental delay/intellectual disability (DD/ID, 82%), and autistic features (45%). Thirty-one mosaic male patients collected from our cohort and the literature developed seizures mostly (87%) within one year of age. Variant types included missense variants (42%), truncating variants (52%), splice variants (3%), and whole PCDH19 deletion (3%). Among 21 patients with a definite VAF from our cohort and the literature, nine had a low VAF ( ≤ 50%) and 12 had a high VAF (> 50%). Seventy-five percent of variants from the high VAF group were missense, whereas 89% of those from the low VAF group were truncations. The median seizure onset age was 6 months in the low VAF group and 9 months in the high VAF group (p = 0.018). Forty-four percent (4/9) of patients from the low VAF group achieved seizure-free for ≥1 year, whereas none of the 12 patients from the high VAF group did (p = 0.021). DD/ID was present in 83% (10/12) of the high VAF group and 56% (5/9) of the low VAF group (p = 0.331).

CONCLUSION

The predominant variant types were truncating and missense variants. Missense variants tended to have higher VAFs. Patients with a high VAF were more likely to have a more severe epileptic phenotype. Our findings shed light on the phenotypic implications of VAF in mosaic males with PCDH19-RE.

Case report: A novel mosaic nonsense mutation of PCDH19 in a Chinese male with febrile epilepsy

The clinical features of the PCDH19 gene mutation include febrile epilepsy ranging from mild to severe, with or without intellectual disability, cognitive impairment, and psych-behavioral disorders, but there has been little research on males with the mosaic mutation of PCDH19. This study reported a novel, de novo, and mosaic PCDH19 nonsense mutation (NM_001184880: c.840C > A, p. Tyr280^*) from a Chinese male in early middle childhood by trio whole-exome sequence (Trio-WES) and confirmed by Sanger sequence. The proportion of the mosaic mutation (c.840C > A, p. Tyr280^*) in PCDH19 was 27.9% in, buccal mucosal cells, 48.3% in exfoliated cells in the urine, and 50.6% in peripheral blood of proband. He had the first onset of seizures in toddlerhood with febrile epilepsy, mild impaired cognitive psychological, and behavioral abnormalities. The electroencephalography (EEG) exhibited sharp waves and sharp slow complex waves in the bilateral parietal, occipital, and posterior temporal regions during the interictal period. Pinpoint white matter lesions in the periventricular white matter and slightly bulging bilateral ventricles appeared on cranial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). With Depakine and Keppra he gained good control over his epilepsy. This study might expand the genotypes and broaden the spectrums.

Detection of Very Low-Level Somatic Mosaic COL4A5 Splicing Variant in Asymptomatic Female Using Droplet Digital PCR

Background

Alport syndrome is a hereditary glomerulopathy featured by haematuria, proteinuria, and progressive renal failure. X-linked Alport syndrome (XLAS) due to COL4A5 disease-causing variants is the most common form. In the case of XLAS resulting from 10–18% presumed de novo COL4A5 disease-causing variants, there are only a few studies for mosaicism in the probands or parents. Very low-level (<1.0%) somatic mosaicism for COL4A5 disease-causing variants has not been published.

Materials and Methods

Chinese XLAS families with suspected parental mosaicism were enrolled in the present study to evaluate the forms of mosaicism, to offer more appropriate genetic counseling. PCR and direct sequencing were used to detect COL4A5 disease-causing variants harbored by the affected probands in parental multi-tissue DNAs (peripheral blood, urine sediments, saliva, hair), and droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) was used to quantify the mutant COL4A5 allelic fractions in parental different samples such as peripheral blood, saliva, and urine sediments.

Results

A Chinese asymptomatic female with suspected somatic and germline mosaicism was enrolled in the present study. She gave birth to two boys with XLAS caused by a hemizygous disease-causing variant c. 2245-1G>A in COL4A5 (NM_033380) intron 28, whereas this disease-causing variant was not detected in genomic DNA extracted from peripheral blood leukocytes in the woman using Sanger sequencing. She had multiple normal urine test results, and continuous linear immunofluorescence staining of α2 (IV) and α5 (IV) chains of skin tissue. Sanger sequencing demonstrated that COL4A5 disease-causing variant c. 2245-1G>A was not detected in her genomic DNAs isolated from urine sediments, saliva, and hair roots. Using ddPCR, the wild-type and mutant-type (c.2245-1G>A) COL4A5 was identified in the female's genomic DNAs isolated from peripheral blood, saliva, and urine sediments. The mutant allelic fractions in these tissues were 0.26% (peripheral blood), 0.73% (saliva), and 1.39% (urine), respectively.

Conclusions

Germline and very low-level somatic mosaicism for a COL4A5 splicing variant was detected in an asymptomatic female, which highlights that parental mosaicism should be excluded when a COL4A5 presumed de novo disease-causing variant is detected.

Clinical next generation sequencing in developmental and epileptic encephalopathies: Diagnostic relevance of data re-analysis and variants re-interpretation

Developmental and epileptic encephalopathies (DEE) are complex pediatric epilepsies, in which heterogeneous pathogenic factors play an important role. Next-generation-sequencing based tools have shown excellent effectiveness. The constant increase in the number of new genotype-phenotype associations suggests the periodic need for re-interpretation and re-analysis of genetic studies without positive results. In this study, we report the diagnostic utility of targeted gene panel sequencing and whole exome sequencing in 55 Argentine subjects with DEE, focusing on the utility of re-interpretation and re-analysis of undetermined and negative genetic diagnoses. The new information in biomedical literature and databases was used for the re-interpretation. For re-analysis, sequencing data processing was repeated using updated bioinformatics tools. Initially, pathogenic variants were detected in 21 subjects (38%). After an average time of 29 months, 25% of the subjects without a genetic diagnosis were re-categorized as diagnosed. Finally, the overall diagnostic yield increased to 53% (29 subjects). In consequence of the re-interpretation and re-analysis, we identified novel variants in the genes: CHD2, COL4A1, FOXG1, GABRA1, GRIN2B, HNRNPU, KCNQ2, MECP2, PCDH19, SCN1A, SCN2A, SCN8A, SLC6A1, STXBP1 and WWOX. Our results expand the diagnostic yield of this subgroup of infantile and childhood seizures and demonstrate the importance of re-evaluation of genetic tests in subjects without an identified causative etiology.

Sperm mosaicism: implications for genomic diversity and disease

While sperm mosaicism has few consequences for men, the offspring and future generations are unwitting recipients of gonadal cell mutations, often yielding severe disease. Recent studies, fueled by emergent technologies, show that sperm mosaicism is a common source of de novo mutations (DNMs) that underlie severe pediatric disease as well as human genetic diversity. Sperm mosaicism can be divided into three types: Type I arises during sperm meiosis and is non-age dependent; Type II arises in spermatogonia and increases as men age; and Type III arises during paternal embryogenesis, spreads throughout the body, and contributes stably to sperm throughout life. Where Types I and II confer little risk of recurrence, Type III may confer identifiable risk to future offspring. These mutations are likely to be the single largest contributor to human genetic diversity. New sequencing approaches may leverage this framework to evaluate and reduce disease risk for future generations.

Developmental and temporal characteristics of clonal sperm mosaicism

Throughout development and aging, human cells accumulate mutations resulting in genomic mosaicism and genetic diversity at the cellular level. Mosaic mutations present in the gonads can affect both the individual and the offspring and subsequent generations. Here, we explore patterns and temporal stability of clonal mosaic mutations in male gonads by sequencing ejaculated sperm. Through 300× whole-genome sequencing of blood and sperm from healthy men, we find each ejaculate carries on average 33.3 ± 12.1 (mean ± SD) clonal mosaic variants, nearly all of which are detected in serial sampling, with the majority absent from sampled somal tissues. Their temporal stability and mutational signature suggest origins during embryonic development from a largely immutable stem cell niche. Clonal mosaicism likely contributes a transmissible, predicted pathogenic exonic variant for 1 in 15 men, representing a life-long threat of transmission for these individuals and a significant burden on human population health.

X-chromosome inactivation and PCDH19-associated epileptic encephalopathy: A novel PCDH19 variant in a Chinese family

BACKGROUND

Developmental and epileptic encephalopathy 9 (DEE9, MIM #300088) is an early onset seizure disorder associated with cognitive impairment and behavioral disturbances. It is caused by mutation in protocadherin 19 with an unusual X-linked inheritance selectively involving heterozygous females or mosaic hemizygous males, while hemizygous males are unaffected. Cellular interference was the postulated mechanism underlying the unusual inheritance pattern.

CASE REPORT

We report a Chinese girl who presented with severe treatment refractory seizures at 26 months of age and was found heterozygous for a novel likely pathogenic missense variant NM_001184880.2:c.488T>A p.(Val163Glu) in PCDH19. Her younger sister, who was also heterozygous for the variant, was asymptomatic with normal development at the time of reporting at 37 months of age. X-chromosome inactivation study by androgen receptor gene methylation assay in DNA from peripheral leukocytes was performed which demonstrated somewhat skewed X-chromosome inactivation in the proband and extremely skewed X-chromosome inactivation in the asymptomatic younger sibling.

CONCLUSION

PCDH19-related seizure disorder has incomplete penetrance and variable expressivity. Further studies are required to determine the potential role of X-chromosome inactivation on the phenotypic variability and patient outcomes. Liberal referral for PCDH19 testing among female patients with early-onset seizures should be considered to enhance case detection.

PCDH19-Related Epilepsies

Protocadherin-19 (PCDH19) is considered one of the most relevant genes related to epilepsy. To date, more than 150 mutations have been identified as causative for PCDH19-female epilepsy (also known as early infantile epileptic encephalopathy-9, EIEE9), which is characterized by early onset epilepsy, intellectual disabilities, and behavioral disturbances. More recently, mosaic-males (i.e., exhibiting the variants in less than 25% of their cells) have been described as affected by infant-onset epilepsy associated with intellectual disability, as well as compulsive or aggressive behavior and autistic features. Although little is known about the physiological role of PCDH19 protein and the pathogenic mechanisms that lead to EIEE9, many reports and clinical observation seem to suggest a relevant role of this protein in the development of cellular hyperexcitability. However, a genotype–phenotype correlation is difficult to establish. The main feature of EIEE9 consists in early onset of seizures, which generally occur in clusters lasting 1 to 5 minutes and repeating up to 10 times a day for several days. Seizures tend to present during febrile episodes, similarly to the first phases of Dravet syndrome and PCDH19 variants have been found in ∼25% of females who present with features of Dravet syndrome and testing negative for SCN1A variants. There is no “standardized” treatment for PCDH19-related epilepsy and most of the patients receiving a combination of several drugs. In this review, we focus on the latest researches on these aspects, with regard to protein expression, its known functions, and the mechanisms by which the protein acts. The clinical phenotypes related to PCDH19 mutations are also discussed.

Case Report: Low-Level Maternal Mosaicism of a Novel CREBBP Variant Causes Recurrent Rubinstein-Taybi Syndrome in Two Siblings of a Chinese Family

Familial Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome (RSTS) with recurrent RSTS siblings and apparently unaffected parents is rare; such cases might result from parental somatic and/or germline mosaicism. Parental low-level (<10%) germline mosaicism in the CREBBP-associated RSTS family has not been reported. Here, we present our studies of a Chinese family with two RSTS siblings and apparently unaffected parents. We detected the apparent de novo variant (DNV) c.3235C>T (p.Gln1079^*) in CREBBP in the siblings via trio whole-exome sequencing. High-depth next-generation sequencing (NGS) for the parents revealed a low-level (<10%) mosaic variant in both the peripheral blood (3.64%) and buccal mucosa (1.94%) of the unaffected mother, indicating maternal somatic and germline mosaicism. Peripheral blood RNA-sequencing analysis for the patients and normal individuals indicated that the c.3235C>T (p.Gln1079^*) non-sense variant did not trigger nonsense-mediated mRNA decay to reduce CREBBP mRNA levels. Transcriptome analysis revealed 151 downregulated mRNAs and 132 upregulated mRNAs between the patients and normal individuals. This study emphasizes that high-depth NGS using multiple specimens might be applied for a family with an affected sibling caused by an apparent CREBBP DNV to identify potential low-level parental mosaicism and provide an assessment of recurrence risk.

Optimization and Validation of Multimodular, Long-Range PCR-Based Next-Generation Sequencing Assays for Comprehensive Detection of Mutation in Tuberous Sclerosis Complex

The genetic diagnosis of tuberous sclerosis complex is difficult because of its broad spectrum of mutations. In addition to point mutations in coding regions, intragenic or chromosomal-level large deletions, deep intronic splicing mutations, and mosaic mutations represent a significant proportion of the mutations. In this study, multimodular, long-range PCR-based next-generation sequencing assays were optimized and validated using >100 samples with known TSC1 and TSC2 variants. Multiplex, long-range PCR covering the entire genomic region of both genes detected all 138 known variants; however, it also yielded false-positive results. Intragenic large deletions were detected with accurate breakpoint sequences. Chromosomal-level deletions were estimated by discordant allele segregation in the family and confirmed by DNA microarray. Deep intronic mutations were verified using a combination of long-range DNA PCR and full-length mRNA sequencing. DNA samples were mixed to simulate mosaic mutations, and most variants were detected but could not be distinguished from equivalently detected false-positive results. Repeated false-positive results were classified, and the strategy of selecting the common variants detected in the duplicate analysis and eliminating known false-positive results improved the sensitivity (85.2%) and positive predictive value (96.6%) of a 10% mosaic simulation. Long-range PCRbased next-generation sequencing is a highly versatile genetic test; however, confirmation tests remain necessary for clinical use because false-positive results cannot be completely eliminated from single experiments.

Clinical and genetic characteristics and prenatal diagnosis of patients presented GDD/ID with rare monogenic causes

Background

Global developmental delay/intellectual disability (GDD/ID), used to be named as mental retardation (MR), is one of the most common phenotypes in neurogenetic diseases. In this study, we described the diagnostic courses, clinical and genetic characteristics and prenatal diagnosis of a cohort with patients presented GDD/ID with monogenic causes, from the perspective of a tertiary genetic counseling and prenatal diagnostic center.

Method

We retrospectively analyzed the diagnostic courses, clinical characteristics, and genetic spectrum of patients presented GDD/ID with rare monogenic causes. We also conducted a follow-up study on prenatal diagnosis in these families. Pathogenicity of variants was interpreted by molecular geneticists and clinicians according to the guidelines of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG).

Results

Among 81 patients with GDD/ID caused by rare monogenic variants it often took 0.5–4.5 years and 2–8 referrals to obtain genetic diagnoses. Devlopmental delay typically occurred before 3 years of age, and patients usually presented severe to profound GDD/ID. The most common co-existing conditions were epilepsy (58%), microcephaly (21%) and facial anomalies (17%). In total, 111 pathogenic variants were found in 62 different genes among the 81 pedigrees, and 56 variants were novel. The most common inheritance patterns in this outbred Chinese population were autosomal dominant (AD; 47%), following autosomal recessive (AR; 37%), and X-linked (XL; 16%). SCN2A, SHANK3 and STXBP1 were important causal genes. Hot-spot variants were rarely found. By the follow-up, 33 affected families, including 15, 13 and 5 families inherited in AR, AD and XL modes respectively, had undergone prenatal diagnosis. And the recurrence rates are 26.7%, 15.4% and 20% for families inherited in AR, AD, and XL patterns.

Conclusion

Patients presented with GDD/ID caused by rare single gene variants are characterized by early onset, relatively severe symptoms and great clinical variability and genetic heterogeneity. Timely referrals to genetic counseling and prenatal diagnostic laboratories are important for affected families planning to have additional children.

Two novel PCDH19 mutations in Russian patients with epilepsy with intellectual disability limited to females: a case report

Background

Epilepsy with intellectual disability limited to females (Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 9; EIEE9) is a rare early infantile epileptic encephalopathy characterized by an unusual X-linked inheritance: females with heterozygous mutations are affected, while hemizygous males are not.

Case presentation

We describe the clinical and molecular characteristics of 2 Russian patients with EIEE9 (females, ages 3 years and 7 years). In these patients seizures developed at the age of 3 years. Additionally, for our patients and for cases described in the literature we searched for a possible relationship between the type and localization of the mutation and the EIEE9 clinical phenotype.

Conclusions

We identified two novel PCDH19 mutations in EIEE9 patients: a missense mutation in exon 1 (c.1236C > A, p.Asp412Glu) and a frameshift in exon 3 (c.2386_2387insGTCT, p.Thr796fs). We conclude that the age of seizure onset and the presence of intellectual disability may depend not on the type and localization of PCDH19 mutations, but on the X-inactivation status. The study also highlights the need to screen for EIEE9 among young female epilepsy patients.

Characterization of seizure susceptibility in Pcdh19 mice

OBJECTIVE

PCDH19-related epilepsy is characterized by a distinctive pattern of X-linked inheritance, where heterozygous females exhibit seizures and hemizygous males are asymptomatic. A cellular interference mechanism resulting from the presence of both wild-type and mutant PCDH19 neurons in heterozygous patients or mosaic carriers of PCDH19 variants has been hypothesized. We aim to investigate seizure susceptibility and progression in the Pchd19 mouse model.

METHODS

We assessed seizure susceptibility and progression in the Pcdh19 mouse model using three acute seizure induction paradigms. We first induced focal, clonic seizures using the 6-Hz psychomotor test. Mice were stimulated with increasing current intensities and graded according to a modified Racine scale. We next induced generalized seizures using flurothyl or pentylenetetrazol (PTZ), both γ-aminobutyric acid type A receptor function inhibitors, and recorded latencies to myoclonic and generalized tonic-clonic seizures.

RESULTS

Pcdh19 knockout and heterozygous females displayed increased seizure susceptibility across all current intensities in the 6-Hz psychomotor test, and increased severity overall. They also exhibited shorter latencies to generalized seizures following flurothyl, but not PTZ, seizure induction. Hemizygous males showed comparable seizure incidence and severity to their wild-type male littermates across all paradigms tested.

SIGNIFICANCE

The heightened susceptibility observed in Pcdh19 knockout females suggests additional mechanisms other than cellular interference are at play in PCDH19-related epilepsy. Further experiments are needed to understand the variability in seizure susceptibility so that this model can be best utilized toward development of future therapeutic strategies for PCDH19-related epilepsy.

Complex Mosaicism of Two Distinct Mutations in a Female Patient With KCNA2-Related Encephalopathy: A Case Report

KCNA2 gene mutations were described to cause a new molecular entity within the developmental and epileptic or epileptic encephalopathies. Here, we firstly reported a patient with an unusual mosaicism for KCNA2, presenting two distinct mosaic missense mutations at the same loci. Clinical trio-based whole-exome sequencing using next-generation sequencing (NGS) revealed two novel mutations in KCNA2: c.1225A > T [p.(Ile409Phe)] and c.1225A > C [p.(Ile409Leu)]. Both missense mutations were in mosaic status and Sanger sequencing confirmed them as de novo. The affected 5-year-old girl presented as seizures with fever sensitivity, and mild cognitive and behavioral disorders. EEG showed focal centrotemporal epileptiform discharges accompanied by nocturnal focal seizures at the age of slightly older than 5 years, more likely carrying a loss-of-function mutation of KCNA2-related phenotype. Further NGS with a mean coverage of 6950 × showed 26% (mosaic mutation reads/total reads) of the c.1225A > T mutation and 23% of the c.1225A > C mutation. The sum of their allele fractions was close to 50%, approximately equal to a heterozygous variant. The patient had no seizures for 8 months on combination of levetiracetam (18.75 mg/kg/d) and valproate (20 mg/kg/d) till the last follow-up at the age of 5 years and 11 months. Our findings highlighted the two mosaic mutations responsible for the pathogenesis of KCNA2-related encephalopathy. The patient expanded the mutational spectrum of KCNA2-related encephalopathy and provided new insight into the complex genetic disorder.

Disruption of the sodium-dependent citrate transporter SLC13A5 in mice causes alterations in brain citrate levels and neuronal network excitability in the hippocampus

In addition to tissues such as liver, the plasma membrane sodium-dependent citrate transporter, NaCT (SLC13A5), is highly expressed in brain neurons, but its function is not understood. Loss-of-function mutations in the human SLC13A5 gene have been associated with severe neonatal encephalopathy and pharmacoresistant seizures. The molecular mechanisms of these neurological alterations are not clear. We performed a detailed examination of a Slc13a5 deletion mouse model including video-EEG monitoring, behavioral tests, and electrophysiologic, proteomic, and metabolomic analyses of brain and cerebrospinal fluid. The experiments revealed an increased propensity for epileptic seizures, proepileptogenic neuronal excitability changes in the hippocampus, and significant citrate alterations in the CSF and brain tissue of Slc13a5 deficient mice, which may underlie the neurological abnormalities. These data demonstrate that SLC13A5 is involved in brain citrate regulation and suggest that abnormalities in this regulation can induce seizures. The present study is the first to (i) establish the Slc13a5-knockout mouse model as a helpful tool to study the neuronal functions of NaCT and characterize the molecular mechanisms by which functional deficiency of this citrate transporter causes epilepsy and impairs neuronal function; (ii) evaluate all hypotheses that have previously been suggested on theoretical grounds to explain the neurological phenotype of SLC13A5 mutations; and (iii) indicate that alterations in brain citrate levels result in neuronal network excitability and increased seizure propensity.

A six-attribute classification of genetic mosaicism

Mosaicism denotes an individual who has at least two populations of cells with distinct genotypes that are derived from a single fertilized egg. Genetic variation among the cell lines can involve whole chromosomes, structural or copy number variants, small or single nucleotide variants, or epigenetic variants. The mutational events that underlie mosaic variants occur during mitotic cell divisions after fertilization and zygote formation. The initiating mutational event can occur in any types of cell at any time in development, leading to enormous variation in the distribution and phenotypic effect of mosaicism. A number of classification proposals have been put forward to classify genetic mosaicism into categories based on the location, pattern, and mechanisms of the disease. We here propose a new classification of genetic mosaicism that considers the affected tissue, the pattern and distribution of the mosaicism, the pathogenicity of the variant, the direction of the change (benign to pathogenic vs. pathogenic to benign), and the postzygotic mutational mechanism. The accurate and comprehensive categorization and subtyping of mosaicisms is important and has potential clinical utility to define the natural history of these disorders, tailor follow-up frequency and interventions, estimate recurrence risks, and guide therapeutic decisions.

The role of somatic mosaicism in brain disease

In this review we discuss the importance of genetic somatic mosaicism and its impact on brain diseases. We start from introducing the different types of somatic mutations, their frequencies and abundances across development and lifespan. We then describe how weakness in DNA repair mechanisms influences their prevalence. Finally, we address their functional consequences in the brain and review recent research showing their unsuspected importance in several neurodevelopmental, psychiatric, and neurodegenerative diseases.

PCDH19-Related Epilepsy in Early Onset of Chinese Male Patient: Case Report and Literature Review

Mutations in PCDH19 are associated with epilepsy, intellectual disability and behavioral disturbances, mostly related to females. The unique X-linked pattern of inheritance affects females predominantly, while usually is transmitted through asymptomatic males. Recently, new research has demonstrated that males with a mosaic pattern of inheritance could also be affected. As yet, PCDH19 mutations have been reported in hundreds of females; however, only 15 mosaic males were reported to exhibit epileptic seizures with the onset ranges between 6 and 31 months. These patients were usually reported to carry various mutations in the PCDH19. Here we describe a non-sense variant at the PCDH19 (c.498C>G; p.Y166^*) in the Chinese male that exhibited early developmental delay and frequent seizures starting from the age of 5 months. We aim that this case report, focusing on studying clinical seizures, therapeutic approaches, and the patient's prognosis, will contribute to the cumulative knowledge of this rare and complex genetic disorder.

[Clinical and genetic characteristics of epilepsy caused by mutations in the PCDH19 gene (OMIM: 300088)]

AIM

To analyze clinical and genetic characteristics of PCDH19-associated epilepsy in a sample of patients from the Russian population.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The sample of patients with early epileptic encephalopathies included 16 people aged 10 month to 30 years. All patients underwent neurological examination according to standard methods, exome sequencing and EEG monitoring.

RESULTS

Most of the identified mutations led to a shift in the reading frame or the formation of a termination codon. Six of them were duplications, four were deletions of one nucleotide, and three were nonsense mutations. Consistent with earlier studies, the authors identified the polymorphism of clinical manifestations of seizures that did not depend on the type of mutation and its localization.

CONCLUSION

Based on the study of the clinical and genetic characteristics of the patients, the authors conclude that the so-called 'hot spots' are present in the PCDH19 gene, which are more common in the group of patients with mutations in this gene, and that the clinical picture of early infantile epileptic encephalopathy type 9 is variable.

The role of somatic mutational events in the pathogenesis of epilepsy

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

There has been rapid progress in defining novel causative gene variants responsible for a large spectrum of human epilepsy syndromes and subtypes. Of particular interest is the discovery that somatic mutations, for example, noninherited mutations occurring in neuroglial progenitor cells during embryonic brain development, are highly linked to malformations of cortical development (MCD) such as focal cortical dysplasia (FCD) type II and hemimegalencephaly.

RECENT FINDINGS

Somatic gene variants have been identified in genes encoding regulatory proteins within the mechanistic target of rapamycin (mTOR) signaling cascade and have thus comprised the group classified as mTORopathies. FCD II and hemimegalencephaly often result from mutations in identical genes suggesting that these are spectrum disorders. An exciting recent development has been the identification of somatic mutations causing both FCD Ia and nonlesional neocortical epilepsy.

SUMMARY

Defining somatic gene mutations in brain tissue specimens has shed new light on how MCD form and the mechanisms of epileptogenesis associated with MCD. Trials of mTOR inhibitors in tuberous sclerosis complex have demonstrated that inhibition of mTOR activation in mTORopathies can reduce seizure frequency. New somatic mutations found for a variety of epilepsy syndromes may provide new targets for clinical therapeutics.

TSC patient-derived isogenic neural progenitor cells reveal altered early neurodevelopmental phenotypes and rapamycin-induced MNK-eIF4E signaling

Background

Tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC) is a neurodevelopmental disorder with frequent occurrence of epilepsy, autism spectrum disorder (ASD), intellectual disability (ID), and tumors in multiple organs. The aberrant activation of mTORC1 in TSC has led to treatment with mTORC1 inhibitor rapamycin as a lifelong therapy for tumors, but TSC-associated neurocognitive manifestations remain unaffected by rapamycin.

Methods

Here, we generated patient-specific, induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) from a TSC patient with a heterozygous, germline, nonsense mutation in exon 15 of TSC1 and established an isogenic set of heterozygous (Het), null and corrected wildtype (Corr-WT) iPSCs using CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene editing. We differentiated these iPSCs into neural progenitor cells (NPCs) and examined neurodevelopmental phenotypes, signaling and changes in gene expression by RNA-seq.

Results

Differentiated NPCs revealed enlarged cell size in TSC1-Het and Null NPCs, consistent with mTORC1 activation. TSC1-Het and Null NPCs also revealed enhanced proliferation and altered neurite outgrowth in a genotype-dependent manner, which was not reversed by rapamycin. Transcriptome analyses of TSC1-NPCs revealed differentially expressed genes that display a genotype-dependent linear response, i.e., genes upregulated/downregulated in Het were further increased/decreased in Null. In particular, genes linked to ASD, epilepsy, and ID were significantly upregulated or downregulated warranting further investigation. In TSC1-Het and Null NPCs, we also observed basal activation of ERK1/2, which was further activated upon rapamycin treatment. Rapamycin also increased MNK1/2-eIF4E signaling in TSC1-deficient NPCs.

Conclusion

MEK-ERK and MNK-eIF4E pathways regulate protein translation, and our results suggest that aberrant translation distinct in TSC1/2-deficient NPCs could play a role in neurodevelopmental defects. Our data showing upregulation of these signaling pathways by rapamycin support a strategy to combine a MEK or a MNK inhibitor with rapamycin that may be superior for TSC-associated CNS defects. Importantly, our generation of isogenic sets of NPCs from TSC patients provides a valuable platform for translatome and large-scale drug screening studies. Overall, our studies further support the notion that early developmental events such as NPC proliferation and initial process formation, such as neurite number and length that occur prior to neuronal differentiation, represent primary events in neurogenesis critical to disease pathogenesis of neurodevelopmental disorders such as ASD.

PCDH19 Pathogenic Variants in Males: Expanding the Phenotypic Spectrum

Protocadherin-19 (PCDH19) pathogenic variants cause an infantile onset epilepsy syndrome called Girls Clustering Epilepsy due to the vast majority of affected individuals being female. This syndromic name was developed to foster early recognition and diagnosis in infancy. It has, however, sparked debate, as, there are rare males with postzygotic somatic, and therefore, mosaic, PCDH19 pathogenic variants with similar clinical features to females. Conversely, "transmitting" males with germline inherited PCDH19 variants are considered asymptomatic. To date, there has been no standardized neuropsychiatric assessment of males with PCDH19 pathogenic variants. Here, we studied 15 males with PCDH19 pathogenic variants (nine mosaic and six transmitting) aged 2 to 70 years. Our families completed a survey including standardized clinical assessments: Social Responsiveness Scale, Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire, Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function, and Dimensional Obsessive-Compulsive Scale. We identified neuropsychiatric abnormalities in two males with germline PCDH19 possibly pathogenic variants. One had a prior history of a severe encephalopathic illness, which may have been unrelated. We also describe a non-penetrant somatic mosaic male with mosaicism confirmed in blood, but not identified in skin fibroblasts. Our data suggest that transmitting hemizygous males are generally unaffected, in contrast to males with postzygotic somatic mosaic variants who show a similar neuropsychiatric profile to females who are naturally mosaic, due to X-chromosome inactivation. The penetrance of PCDH19 pathogenic variants has been estimated to be 80%. Like females, not all mosaic males are affected. From our small sample, we estimate that males with mosaic PCHD19 pathogenic variants have a penetrance of 85%. With these insights into the male phenotypic spectrum of PCDH19 epilepsy, we propose the new term Clustering Epilepsy (CE). Both affected females and males typically present with infantile onset of clusters of seizures.

The role of PCDH19 in refractory status epilepticus

PCDH19-Girls Clustering Epilepsy (GCE) is an epileptic syndrome with infantile onset, characterized by clustered and fever-induced seizures, often associated with intellectual disability (ID) and autistic features. Seizures clusters could progress into status epilepticus (SE) with different semiology, both convulsive and nonconvulsive SE (NCSE), and often refractory to conventional antiepileptic drugs. We reviewed literature on PCDH19-GCE, in order to define prevalence, semiology, treatments, and outcome of SE. We conducted a comprehensive review of the PCDH19-GCE literature on the public databases PubMed and EMBASE from January 2008 to July 2019. An overall number of 59 full-text articles were selected, retrieved, and assessed for eligibility. We collected 269 cases with PCDH19-GCE, in 85 of them, a history of SE was reported. Prevalence of SE in all selected series of PCDH19-GCE series is 31.5%. Data on SE were fully exhaustive in 21 cases. There was no gender difference in SE occurrence. Median age at first SE occurrence was 12 months (6 months-11 years). Semiology of SE was reported in 17 cases: it was convulsive in 15 and nonconvulsive in 2. Status epilepticus was refractory in 15 out of 21 cases (71.4%). Benzodiazepine was the most commonly used drug for SE. Alternative treatments with steroids and ketogenic diet were reported as well. We found a high prevalence of ID and autism (19 out of 21 patients, 90%). Despite the relatively high frequency of SE in those patients, there are few specific descriptions of the semiology, EEG pattern, and treatment approach. We strongly believe that a multicenter study looking specifically at SE characteristics might improve the knowledge and consequently the overall outcome. This article is part of the Special Issue "Proceedings of the 7th London-Innsbruck Colloquium on Status Epilepticus and Acute Seizures".

A Novel CDH1 Mutation Causing Reduced E-Cadherin Dimerization Is Associated with Nonsyndromic Cleft Lip With or Without Cleft Palate

Aims: Cleft lip with or without cleft palate (CL/P) is a common birth defect with an average prevalence of 1/700 to 1/1000. Almost 70% of CL/P cases are nonsyndromic CL/P (NSCL/P). The aim of this study was to identify the underlying cause of a four-generation Chinese family with autosomal dominant NSCL/P. Methods: Genomic DNA was extracted from peripheral blood leukocytes, and whole-exome sequencing was carried out to identify the underlying genetic cause of the disorder. The mutation was confirmed by Sanger sequencing and polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism methods. Western blotting and coimmunoprecipitation were used to analyze the protein expression level and adhesive dimerization of the CDH1 mutants. Slow aggregation assays were conducted to investigate the cell-cell adhesion ability. Results: A novel missense mutation (c.468G>C/p.Trp156Cys) of CDH1 was identified in the proband and the mutation was shown to cosegregate with the phenotype in the family. Furthermore, we found that the p.Trp156Cys mutation led to decreased E-cadherin dimerization and cell-cell adhesion ability. Conclusions: Our findings identified a novel CDH1 variant (c.468G>C/p.Trp156Cys) responsible for NSCL/P in a Chinese family, which expanded the mutational spectrum of the CDH1 gene and may contribute to understanding the molecular basis of NSCL/P.

ATP1A3 mosaicism in families with alternating hemiplegia of childhood

Alternating hemiplegia of childhood (AHC) is a rare and severe neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by recurrent hemiplegic episodes. Most AHC cases are sporadic and caused by de novo ATP1A3 pathogenic variants. In this study, the aim was to identify the origin of ATP1A3 pathogenic variants in a Chinese cohort. In 105 probands including 101 sporadic and 4 familial cases, 98 patients with ATP1A3 pathogenic variants were identified, and 96.8% were confirmed as de novo. Micro-droplet digital polymerase chain reaction was applied for detecting ATP1A3 mosaicism in 80 available families. In blood samples, four asymptomatic parents, including two paternal and two maternal, and one proband with a milder phenotype were identified as mosaicism. Six (7.5%) parental mosaicisms were identified in multiple tissues, including four previously identified in blood and two additional cases identified from paternal sperms. Mosaicism was identified in multiple tissues with varied mutant allele fractions (MAFs, 0.03%-33.03%). The results suggested that MAF of mosaicism may be related to phenotype severity. This is the first systematic report of ATP1A3 mosaicism in AHC and showed mosaicism as an unrecognized source of previously considered "de novo" AHC. Identifying ATP1A3 mosaicism provides more evidence for estimating recurrence risk and has implications in genetic counseling of AHC.