Chronic carbon monoxide inhalation during pregnancy augments uterine artery blood flow and uteroplacental vascular growth in mice

Nature's marvels endowed in gaseous molecules I: Carbon monoxide and its physiological and therapeutic roles

Nature has endowed gaseous molecules such as O2, CO2, CO, NO, H2S, and N2 with critical and diverse roles in sustaining life, from supplying energy needed to power life and building blocks for life's physical structure to mediating and coordinating cellular functions. In this article, we give a brief introduction of the complex functions of the various gaseous molecules in life and then focus on carbon monoxide as a specific example of an endogenously produced signaling molecule to highlight the importance of this class of molecules. The past twenty years have seen much progress in understanding CO's mechanism(s) of action and pharmacological effects as well as in developing delivery methods for easy administration. One remarkable trait of CO is its pleiotropic effects that have few parallels, except perhaps its sister gaseous signaling molecules such as nitric oxide and hydrogen sulfide. This review will delve into the sophistication of CO-mediated signaling as well as its validated pharmacological functions and possible therapeutic applications.

Haem oxygenases play a pivotal role in placental physiology and pathology

BACKGROUND

Haem oxygenases (HO) catabolise haem, which is the prosthetic group of numerous haemoproteins. Thus, multiple primary cellular pathways and functions rely on haem availability. HO exists in two isoforms, both expressed in the placenta, namely HO-1 and HO-2, the first being inducible. Haem oxygenases, particularly HO-1, have garnered specific interest in the field of physiological and pathological placental function. These enzymes mediate haem degradation by cleaving the alpha methene bridge to produce biliverdin, which is subsequently converted to bilirubin, carbon monoxide and iron. HO-1 has anti-inflammatory and antioxidant activities.

SEARCH METHODS

An initial literature analysis was performed using PubMed on 3 October 2018 using key terms such as 'haem oxygenase and pregnancy', 'haem oxygenase and placenta', 'HO-1 and pregnancy', 'HO-1 and placenta', 'HO and placenta', 'HO and pregnancy', 'genetic variant and HO', 'CO and pregnancy', 'CO and placenta', 'Bilirubin and pregnancy', 'Iron and pregnancy' and 'PPAR and Haem', selecting consensus conferences, recommendations, meta-analyses, practical recommendations and reviews. A second literature analysis was performed, including notable miscarriages, foetal loss and diabetes mellitus, on 20 December 2019. The three authors studied the publications independently to decipher whether they should be included in the manuscript.

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

This review aimed to summarise current pieces of knowledge of haem oxygenase location, function and regulation in the placenta, either in healthy pregnancies or those associated with miscarriages and foetal loss, pre-eclampsia, foetal growth restriction and diabetes mellitus.

OUTCOMES

HO-1 exerts some protective effects on the placentation, probably by a combination of factors, including its interrelation with the PGC-1α/PPAR pathway and the sFlt1/PlGF balance, and through its primary metabolites, notably carbon monoxide and bilirubin. Its protective role has been highlighted in numerous pregnancy conditions, including pre-eclampsia, foetal growth restriction, gestational diabetes mellitus and miscarriages.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

HO-1 is a crucial enzyme in physiological and pathological placentation. This protective enzyme is currently considered a potential therapeutic target in various pregnancy diseases.

Estrogen Receptors and Estrogen-Induced Uterine Vasodilation in Pregnancy

Normal pregnancy is associated with dramatic increases in uterine blood flow to facilitate the bidirectional maternal–fetal exchanges of respiratory gases and to provide sole nutrient support for fetal growth and survival. The mechanism(s) underlying pregnancy-associated uterine vasodilation remain incompletely understood, but this is associated with elevated estrogens, which stimulate specific estrogen receptor (ER)-dependent vasodilator production in the uterine artery (UA). The classical ERs (ERα and ERβ) and the plasma-bound G protein-coupled ER (GPR30/GPER) are expressed in UA endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells, mediating the vasodilatory effects of estrogens through genomic and/or nongenomic pathways that are likely epigenetically modified. The activation of these three ERs by estrogens enhances the endothelial production of nitric oxide (NO), which has been shown to play a key role in uterine vasodilation during pregnancy. However, the local blockade of NO biosynthesis only partially attenuates estrogen-induced and pregnancy-associated uterine vasodilation, suggesting that mechanisms other than NO exist to mediate uterine vasodilation. In this review, we summarize the literature on the role of NO in ER-mediated mechanisms controlling estrogen-induced and pregnancy-associated uterine vasodilation and our recent work on a “new” UA vasodilator hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) that has dramatically changed our view of how estrogens regulate uterine vasodilation in pregnancy.

Carbon monoxide increases utero-placental angiogenesis without impacting pregnancy specific adaptations in mice

BACKGROUND

Cigarette smokers have a reduced risk of developing preeclampsia, possibly attributed to an increase in carbon monoxide (CO) levels. Carbon monoxide is a gasotransmitter that has been implicated in maintaining vascular tone, increasing angiogenesis, and reducing inflammation and apoptosis at physiological concentrations. Moderately increasing CO concentrations may have therapeutic potential to prevent or treat preeclampsia; however, the effects of CO on pregnancy are under studied. Our objective was to investigate the effect of CO on major angiogenic and inflammatory markers in pregnancy, and to evaluate the effect of CO on indicators of placental health.

FINDINGS

Pregnant CD-1 mice were constantly exposed to either ambient air or 250 ppm CO from conception until gestation day (GD)10.5 or GD16.5. Using a qRT-PCR array, we identified that CO increased expression of major angiogenic genes at the implantation site on GD10.5, but not GD16.5. Pro-inflammatory cytokines in the plasma and tissue lysates from implantation sites in treated mice were not significantly different compared to controls. Additionally, CO did not alter the implantation site phenotype, in terms of proliferative capacity, invasiveness of trophoblasts, or abundance of uterine natural killer cells.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that CO exposure is pro-angiogenic at the maternal-fetal interface, and is not associated with demonstrable concerns during murine pregnancy. Future studies are required to validate safety and efficacy of CO as a potential therapeutic for vascular insufficiency diseases such as preeclampsia and intrauterine growth restriction.

Effects of maternal smoking on human placental vascularization: A systematic review

The abnormal development of placental vascularization leads to placental insufficiency, which further reduces the nutrient and trace exchange between maternal circulation and fetal circulation. These changes cause maternal and fetal complications. The objective of our systematic review was to explore the effects of maternal smoking on placental vascularization. The eligibility criteria were: articles with experimental, quasi-experimental or observational design, performed on human subjects, that study the association, correlation or causation between maternal smoking and changes in placental vascular network. A total of 33 full-text papers were assessed for eligibility, resulting in 12 original articles that were included in the systematic review. Doppler studies confirm reductions in blood flow velocity waveforms and increase in RI in the uterine, umbilical and fetal middle cerebral arteries. These findings are confirmed by morphometric measurements of fetal capillaries in villi that were shown to be smaller in smoke exposure groups.

Maternal disease and gasotransmitters

The three known gasotransmitters, nitric oxide, carbon monoxide, and hydrogen sulfide are involved in key processes throughout pregnancy. Gasotransmitters are known to impact on smooth muscle tone, regulation of immune responses, and oxidative state of cells and their component molecules. Failure of the systems that tightly regulate gasotransmitter production and downstream effects are thought to contribute to common maternal diseases such as preeclampsia and preterm birth. Normal pregnancy-related changes in uterine blood flow depend heavily on gasotransmitter signaling. In preeclampsia, endothelial dysfunction is a major contributor to aberrant gasotransmitter signaling, resulting in hypertension after 20 weeks gestation. Maintenance of pregnancy to term also requires gasotransmitter-mediated uterine quiescence. As the appropriate signals for parturition occur, regulation of gasotransmitter signaling must work in concert with those endocrine signals in order for appropriate labor and delivery timing. Like preeclampsia, preterm birth may have origins in abnormal gasotransmitter signaling. We review the evidence for the involvement of gasotransmitters in preeclampsia and preterm birth, as well as mechanistic and molecular signaling targets.

Riboflavin and pyrroloquinoline quinone generate carbon monoxide in the presence of tissue microsomes or recombinant human cytochrome P-450 oxidoreductase: implications for possible roles in gasotransmission

Carbon monoxide (CO), an endogenously produced gasotransmitter, regulates inflammation and vascular tone, suggesting that delivery of CO may be therapeutically useful for pathologies like preeclampsia where CO insufficiency is implicated. Our strategy is to identify chemicals that increase the activity of endogenous CO-producing enzymes, including cytochrome P-450 oxidoreductase (CPR). Realizing that both riboflavin and pyrroloquinoline quinone (PQQ) are relatively nontoxic, even at high doses, and that they share chemical properties with toxic CO activators that we previously identified, our goal was to determine whether riboflavin or PQQ could stimulate CO production. Riboflavin and PQQ were incubated in sealed vessels with rat and human tissue extracts and CO generation was measured with headspace-gas chromatography. Riboflavin and PQQ increased CO production ∼60% in rat spleen microsomes. In rat brain microsomes, riboflavin and PQQ increased respective CO production approximately fourfold and twofold compared to baseline. CO production by human placenta microsomes increased fourfold with riboflavin and fivefold with PQQ. In the presence of recombinant human CPR, CO production was threefold greater with PQQ than with riboflavin. These observations demonstrate for the first time that riboflavin and PQQ facilitate tissue-specific CO production with significant contributions from CPR. We propose a novel biochemical role for these nutrients in gastransmission.

Endogenous carbon monoxide production by menadione

INTRODUCTION

Smokers have a significantly decreased risk of pre-eclampsia (PE), possibly attributed to an increase in blood carbon monoxide (CO) concentrations. At physiological concentrations, CO has been demonstrated to have placental vasodilatory and anti-inflammatory properties. Increasing endogenous CO production may have therapeutic potential to either prevent or treat PE. Menadione (MD), synthetic vitamin K3, increases CO in rat microsomes. Our objective was to investigate MD's ability to increase endogenous CO concentrations in pregnancy.

METHODS

Three experiments were completed. First, in vitro CO production was measured using isolated GD15 placentas. Second, non-pregnant normotensive mice received no, 1.5, 4.0 or 6.5 g/L MD for 7 days. Lastly, pregnant normotensive mice received either no or 6.5 g/L MD in water from GD10.5 to GD17.5. Consumption was measured as average daily water intake per gram of body weight. Maternal and fetal CO levels in the blood and tissue were quantified using headspace gas chromatography.

RESULTS

MD significantly increased CO production in isolated GD15 placentas. In both pregnant and non-pregnant experiments, splenic CO, hepatic CO, and splenic mass were higher in treated mice compared to controls (all p < 0.05). Maternal %COHb and Hb in treated dams were not significantly different compared to controls. The fetal:placental mass ratio was significantly lower in the treatment group (p = 0.002).

DISCUSSION

Placental CO production was observed in GD15 placentas after co-incubation with MD. MD administration increased CO in the liver and spleens of pregnant mice. Further investigation into different doses of MD is required to identify one without demonstrable fetal/placental effects.

Selective Targeting of a Novel Vasodilator to the Uterine Vasculature to Treat Impaired Uteroplacental Perfusion in Pregnancy

Fetal growth restriction (FGR) in pregnancy is commonly caused by impaired uteroplacental blood flow. Vasodilators enhance uteroplacental perfusion and fetal growth in humans and animal models; however, detrimental maternal and fetal side effects have been reported. We hypothesised that targeted uteroplacental delivery of a vasodilator would enhance drug efficacy and reduce the risks associated with drug administration in pregnancy. Phage screening identified novel peptides that selectively accumulated in the uteroplacental vasculature of pregnant mice. Following intravenous injection, the synthetic peptide CNKGLRNK selectively bound to the endothelium of the uterine spiral arteries and placental labyrinth in vivo; CNKGLRNK-decorated liposomes also selectively bound to these regions. The nitric oxide donor 2-[[4-[(nitrooxy)methyl]benzoyl]thio]-benzoic acid methyl ester (SE175) induced significant relaxation of mouse uterine arteries and human placental arteries in vitro; thus, SE175 was encapsulated into these targeted liposomes and administered to healthy pregnant C57BL/6J mice or endothelial nitric oxide synthase knockout (eNOS-/-) mice, which exhibit impaired uteroplacental blood flow and FGR. Liposomes containing SE175 (0.44mg/kg) or PBS were administered on embryonic (E) days 11.5, 13.5, 15.5 and 17.5; fetal and placental weights were recorded at term and compared to mice injected with free PBS or SE175. Targeted uteroplacental delivery of SE175 had no effect on fetal weight in C57BL/6J mice, but significantly increased fetal weight and mean spiral artery diameter, and decreased placental weight, indicative of improved placental efficiency, in eNOS-/- mice; free SE175 had no effect on fetal weight or spiral artery diameter. Targeted, but not free SE175 also significantly reduced placental expression of 4-hydroxynonenal, cyclooxygenase-1 and cyclooxygenase-2, indicating a reduction in placental oxidative stress. These data suggest that exploiting vascular targeting peptides to selectively deliver SE175 to the uteroplacental vasculature may represent a novel treatment for FGR resulting from impaired uteroplacental perfusion.

Non-invasive evaluation of placental blood flow: lessons from animal models

In human obstetrics, placental vascularisation impairment is frequent as well as linked to severe pathological events (preeclampsia and intrauterine growth restriction), and there is a need for reliable methods allowing non-invasive evaluation of placental blood flow. Uteroplacental vascularisation is complex, and animal models are essential for the technical development and safety assessment of these imaging tools for human clinical use; however, these techniques can also be applied in the veterinary context. This paper reviews how ultrasound-based imaging methods such as 2D and 3D Doppler can provide valuable insight for the exploration of placental blood flow both in humans and animals and how new approaches such as the use of ultrasound contrast agents or ultrafast Doppler may allow to discriminate between maternal (non-pulsatile) and foetal (pulsatile) blood flow in the placenta. Finally, functional magnetic resonance imaging could also be used to evaluate placental blood flow, as indicated by studies in animal models, but its safety in human pregnancy still requires to be confirmed.

Targeting STOX1 in the therapy of preeclampsia

INTRODUCTION

Preeclampsia is a major pregnancy disease, explained partly by genetic predispositions. STOX1, a transcription factor discovered in 2005, was the first gene directly associated with genetic forms of the disease. Alterations of STOX1 expression as well as STOX1 variants have also been associated to Alzheimer's disease. These observations make of this gene a putative therapeutic target. Area covered: Two major isoforms (STOX1A and STOX1B) are encoded by the gene and are theoretically able to compete for the same binding site, while only the most complete (STOX1A) is supposed to be able to activate gene expression. This makes the ratio between STOX1A and STOX1B as well as their position inside the cell (nucleus or cytoplasm) crucial to understand how STOX1 functions. STOX1 appears to have multiple gene targets, especially in pathways connected to inflammation, oxidative stress, and cell cycle. Expert opinion: STOX1-directed therapies, could be directed either towards its targets (genes or pathways), or directly at STOX1. For this the addressing of STOX1 to various cell compartments could theoretically be modified; also it could be possible of altering the balance between the two isoforms, through selectively inhibiting one of them, possibly improving the outcomes in severe preeclampsia.

Quantification of Gestational Changes in the Uteroplacental Vascular Tree Reveals Vessel Specific Hemodynamic Roles During Pregnancy in Mice

The purpose of this study was to establish the time course and hemodynamic significance of de novo formed and enlarged uteroplacental arteries during pregnancy. Using x-ray microcomputed tomography (n = 4–7 placentas from 2–4 dams/gestational group), uteroplacental arterial vascular dimensions were measured at individual implantation sites. Dimensions and topology were used to compute total and vessel-specific resistances and cross-sectional areas. Diameter enlargement of the uterine artery (+55% by Embryonic Day 5.5 [E5.5]) and preplacental radial arteries (+30% by E8.5) was significant only in early gestation. Formation of spiral arteries (E9.5–E11.5), maternal canals, and canal branches (E11.5–E13.5) during midgestation was followed by enlargement of these vessels such that, from E9.5 to E17.5 (near term), spiral artery resistance dropped 9-fold, and canal resistance became negligible. A 12-fold increase in terminal vessel cross-sectional area was nearly sufficient to offset known increases in flow so that blood velocity entering the exchange region was predicted to increase by only 2-fold. The calculated 47% decrease in total resistance downstream of the uterine artery, determined from vascular geometry, was in accord with prior uterine blood flow data in vivo and was due to enlarging spiral artery diameters. Interestingly, radial artery resistance was unchanged after E9.5 so that radial arteries accounted for 91% of resistance and pressure drop in the uteroplacental arterial network by E17.5. These findings led us to propose functional roles for the three morphologically defined vessel types: radial arteries to reduce pressure, spiral artery enlargement to increase flow with gestation, and maternal canal elaboration and enlargement to maintain low exit velocities into the exchange region.

Angiogenesis in the placenta: the role of reactive oxygen species signaling

Proper placental development and function are central to the health of both the mother and the fetus during pregnancy. A critical component of healthy placental function is the proper development of its vascular network. Poor vascularization of the placenta can lead to fetal growth restriction, preeclampsia, and in some cases fetal death. Therefore, understanding the mechanisms by which uterine stressors influence the development of the placental vasculature and contribute to placental dysfunction is of central importance to ensuring a healthy pregnancy. In this review we discuss how oxidative stress observed in maternal smoking, maternal obesity, and preeclampsia has been associated with aberrant angiogenesis and placental dysfunction resulting in adverse pregnancy outcomes. We also highlight that oxidative stress can influence the expression of a number of transcription factors important in mediating angiogenesis. Therefore, understanding how oxidative stress affects redox-sensitive transcription factors within the placenta may elucidate potential therapeutic targets for correcting abnormal placental angiogenesis and function.

Elevated carboxyhemoglobin in a marine mammal, the northern elephant seal

Low concentrations of endogenous carbon monoxide (CO), generated primarily through degradation of heme from heme-proteins, have been shown to maintain physiological function of organs and to exert cytoprotective effects. However, high concentrations of carboxyhemoglobin (COHb), formed by CO binding to hemoglobin, potentially prevent adequate O2 delivery to tissues by lowering arterial O2 content. Elevated heme-protein concentrations, as found in marine mammals, are likely associated with greater heme degradation, more endogenous CO production and, consequently, elevated COHb concentrations. Therefore, we measured COHb in elephant seals, a species with large blood volumes and elevated hemoglobin and myoglobin concentrations. The levels of COHb were positively related to the total hemoglobin concentration. The maximum COHb value was 10.4% of total hemoglobin concentration. The mean (± s.e.m.) value in adult seals was 8.7 ± 0.3% (N=6), while juveniles and pups (with lower heme-protein contents) had lower mean COHb values of 7.6 ± 0.2% and 7.1 ± 0.3%, respectively (N=9 and N=9, respectively). Serial samples over several hours revealed little to no fluctuation in COHb values. This consistent elevation in COHb suggests that the magnitude and/or rate of heme-protein turnover is much higher than in terrestrial mammals. The maximum COHb values from this study decrease total body O2 stores by 7%, thereby reducing the calculated aerobic dive limit for this species. However, the constant presence of elevated CO in blood may also protect against potential ischemia-reperfusion injury associated with the extreme breath-holds of elephant seals. We suggest the elephant seal represents an ideal model for understanding the potential cytoprotective effects, mechanisms of action and evolutionary adaptation associated with chronically elevated concentrations of endogenously produced CO.

Site-specific increases in utero- and fetoplacental arterial vascular resistance in eNOS-deficient mice due to impaired arterial enlargement

The sites of elevated vascular resistance that impede placental perfusion in pathological pregnancies are unknown. In the current study, we identified these sites in a knockout mouse model (eNOS(-/-)) with reduced uterine (-55%) and umbilical (-29%) artery blood flows caused by endothelial nitric oxide synthase deficiency. Uteroplacental and fetoplacental arterial vascular trees of pregnant mice near term were imaged using x-ray microcomputed tomography (n = 5-10 placentas from 3-5 dams/group). The resulting three-dimensional images were analyzed to assess vessel geometry and vascular resistance. In control and eNOS(-/-) trees, ∼90% of total uteroplacental vascular resistance was located in the radial arteries. Changes in eNOS(-/-) vessel geometry, including 30% reductions in uterine, radial, and spiral artery diameters, were calculated to increase arterial resistance downstream of the uterine artery by 2.3-fold, predicting a 57% decrease in uterine blood flow. Despite large reductions in eNOS(-/-) spiral arteries (-55% by volume) and maternal canals (-67% by volume), these vessels were relatively minor contributors to resistance. In the eNOS(-/-) fetoplacental tree, the number of arterioles (50-75 μm diameter) increased by 26%. Nevertheless, calculated resistance rose by 19%, predominantly because arteries near the periphery of the tree selectively exhibited a 7%-9% diameter reduction. We conclude that previously observed decreases in uterine and umbilical blood flows in eNOS(-/-) pregnancies are associated with markedly divergent structural changes in the uteroplacental versus fetoplacental circulations. Results showed the radial arteries were critical determinants of uteroplacental resistance in mice and therefore warrant greater attention in future studies in pathological human pregnancies.

Involvement of the Heme Oxygenase System in the Development of Preeclampsia and as a Possible Therapeutic Target

The enzyme heme oxygenase (HO) is an important regulatory molecule present in most nucleated mammalian cells which functions to break down the pro-oxidant molecule heme into three products, carbon monoxide (CO), biliverdin and free iron. The HO system has been associated with many physiologic functions, including vascular tone, regulation of inflammation and apoptosis, angiogenesis and antioxidant capabilities. Deficiencies in HO are associated with several pregnancy disorders, including preeclampsia. With no present cure, this disorder continues to affect 5–7% of all pregnancies worldwide, leading to maternal and fetal morbidity and mortality. Researchers continue to strive for therapeutic potentials and this review will outline the possible use of the HO/CO system as a target treatment/prevention of preeclampsia in the future.

Carbon monoxide prevents hypertension and proteinuria in an adenovirus sFlt-1 preeclampsia-like mouse model

Preeclampsia (PE) remains a leading cause of maternal and neonatal morbidity and mortality worldwide. Smoking cigarettes is associated with a decreased incidence of PE. Based on this observation and previous work, we hypothesize that women who smoke have a lower risk of developing PE because of elevated levels of carbon monoxide (CO) in their blood. The objective of this study was to determine if low-dose CO in ambient air could attenuate the late pregnancy hypertension (HTN) and proteinuria in the Adenovirus (Ad) sFlt-1 PE-like mouse model. Continuous low-dose CO treatment (250 ppm) was started on E10.5 and maintained until E17.5. Compared to control and Ad empty vector, AdsFlt-1 mice displayed late- gestation HTN (E14.5–17.5) (P<0.05), proteinuria (P<0.05) and reduced Bowman's space which were all prevented with CO treatment. Use of the Ad (with/without sFlt-1) or CO had no effect (p>0.05) on litter size, fetal resorption numbers and fetal or placental weights. This study shows that treatment with CO can prevent HTN and proteinuria in a mouse model of PE. It provides a possible mechanism for the reduced incidence of PE in smoking women, and supports the possibility of using CO as a future treatment for PE.

Characterization of the adverse effects of nicotine on placental development: in vivo and in vitro studies

In utero exposure to nicotine is associated with increased risk of numerous adverse fetal and neonatal outcomes, which suggests that it acts directly to affect placental development and the establishment of the fetomaternal circulation (FC). This study used both in vivo [Wistar rats treated with 1 mg/kg nicotine from 2 wk prior to mating until gestational day (GD) 15] and in vitro (RCHO-1 cell line; treated with 10(-9) to 10(-3)M nicotine) models to examine the effects of nicotine on these pathways. At GD 15, control and treated placentas were examined for the impact of nicotine on 1) trophoblast invasion, proliferation, and degree of hypoxia, 2) labyrinth vascularization, 3) expression of key genes of placental development, and 4) expression of placental angiogenic factors. The RCHO-1 cell line was used to determine the direct effects of nicotine on trophoblast differentiation. Our in vivo experiments show that nicotine inhibits trophoblast interstitial invasion, increases placental hypoxia, downregulates labyrinth vascularization as well as key transcription factors Hand1 and GCM1, and decreases local and circulating EG-VEGF, a key placental angiogenic factor. The in vitro experiments confirmed the inhibitory effects of nicotine on the trophoblast migration, invasion, and differentiation processes and demonstrated that those effects are most likely due to a dysregulation in the expression of nicotine receptors and a decrease in MMP9 activity. Taken together, these data suggest that adverse effects of maternal smoking on pregnancy outcome are due in part to direct and endocrine effects of nicotine on the main processes of placental development and establishment of FC.