Fetal origins of adult vascular dysfunction in mice lacking endothelial nitric oxide synthase

Fetoplacental endothelial dysfunction in gestational diabetes mellitus and maternal obesity: A potential threat for programming cardiovascular disease

Gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) and maternal obesity (MO) increase the risk of adverse fetal outcomes, and the incidence of cardiovascular disease later in life. Extensive research has been conducted to elucidate the underlying mechanisms by which GDM and MO program the offspring to disease. This review focuses on the role of fetoplacental endothelial dysfunction in programming the offspring for cardiovascular disease in GDM and MO pregnancies. We discuss how pre-existing maternal health conditions can lead to vascular dysfunction in the fetoplacental unit and the fetus. We also examine the role of fetoplacental endothelial dysfunction in impairing fetal cardiovascular system development and the involvement of nitric oxide and hydrogen sulfide in mediating fetoplacental vascular dysfunction. Furthermore, we suggest that the L-Arginine-Nitric Oxide and the Adenosine-L-Arginine-Nitric Oxide (ALANO) signaling pathways are pertinent targets for research. Despite significant progress in this area, there are still knowledge gaps that need to be addressed in future research.

Animal Models of Preeclampsia: Causes, Consequences, and Interventions

Preeclampsia is a common pregnancy complication, affecting 2% to 8% of pregnancies worldwide, and is an important cause of both maternal and fetal morbidity and mortality. Importantly, although aspirin and calcium are able to prevent preeclampsia in some women, there is no cure apart from delivery of the placenta and fetus, often necessitating iatrogenic preterm birth. Preclinical models of preeclampsia are widely used to investigate the causes and consequences of preeclampsia and to evaluate safety and efficacy of potential preventative and therapeutic interventions. In this review, we provide a summary of the published preclinical models of preeclampsia that meet human diagnostic criteria, including the development of maternal hypertension, together with new-onset proteinuria, maternal organ dysfunction, and uteroplacental dysfunction. We then discuss evidence from preclinical models for multiple causal factors of preeclampsia, including those implicated in early-onset and late-onset preeclampsia. Next, we discuss the impact of exposure to a preeclampsia-like environment for later maternal and progeny health. The presence of long-term impairment, particularly cardiovascular outcomes, in mothers and progeny after an experimentally induced preeclampsia-like pregnancy, implies that later onset or reduced severity of preeclampsia will improve later maternal and progeny health. Finally, we summarize published intervention studies in preclinical models and identify gaps in knowledge that we consider should be targets for future research.

Vascular and metabolic profiles in offspring born to pregnant mice with metabolic syndrome treated with inositols

BACKGROUND

Inositols (INOs) supplementation during pregnancy, specifically the combination of myo-inositol (MI) and D-chiro-inositol (DCI), has been reported to improve vascular parameters in women with gestational diabetes mellitus. We demonstrated previously that offspring born to pregnant mice lacking the endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS+/-) gene have hypertension (HTN) as adults and, when fed a high-fat diet (HFD), develop a metabolic syndrome (MS) phenotype.

OBJECTIVE

Our aim was to evaluate whether INOs treatment in pregnancy complicated by MS improves the vascular and metabolic profile in mice offspring programmed in utero to develop HTN and MS.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Heterozygous eNOS+/- mice fed an HFD manifest a MS phenotype. Female eNOS+/- mice with MS were bred with a wild-type (WT) male. On gestational day 1, pregnant females were randomly allocated to receive either a mixture of INOs (MI/DCI: 7.2/0.18 mg/mL) or water as placebo until delivery. The female offspring obtained were genotyped and categorized as: WT (genetically normal, with eNOS gene) and eNOS+/- offspring (genetically modified, heterozygous for eNOS gene). Both offspring developed in an abnormal uterine environment due to maternal MS. At 9-10 weeks of age, the offspring underwent a glucose tolerance test (GTT) and systolic blood pressure (SBP) measurement. The mice were then sacrificed, and the carotid arteries were isolated for evaluation of vascular responses. Responses to phenylephrine (PE), in the presence and absence of a nonspecific nitric oxide inhibitor (N-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester [L-NAME]), the vasodilator acetylcholine (ACh), and sodium nitroprusside (SNP) were assessed.

RESULTS

The GTT showed lower glucose levels in both eNOS+/-INOs (P = .03) and WT-INOs (P = .05) offspring born to MS dams on INOs supplementation compared to offspring born to untreated dams. SBP was higher in eNOS+/- offspring compared to WT (169 ± 7 vs 142 ± 9 mm Hg, respectively, P = .04) and INOs treatment decreased SBP in WT-INOs (110 ± 10 mm Hg, P = .01) but not in eNOS+/-INOs offspring. Maximal (%Max) contractile response to PE was higher in eNOS+/- offspring born to MS dams and was decreased in those born to MS dams treated with INOs (%Max, eNOS+/-, 123 ± 7 vs eNOS+/-INOs, 82 ± 11 mm Hg, P = .007). No differences were seen in PE contractile responses in WT offspring born to MS dams treated or not treated with INOs (WT, 92 ± 4 vs WT-INOs, 75 ± 7). The L-NAME response was decreased in eNOS+/-INOs and WT-INOs offspring compared to untreated ones. The ACh vasorelaxation was impaired in eNOS+/- and WT offspring born to MS dams, and maternal INOs treatment improved offspring vascular relaxation in both offspring (P = .01 and P = .03, respectively). No differences were seen in response to SNP.

CONCLUSION

Inositols supplementation improved glucose tolerance, SBP, and vascular responses in adult eNOS+/- and WT offspring born to dams with MS. Interestingly, WT born to MS dams show an altered vascular profile similar to eNOS+/- offspring and exhibit an improved response to INOs treatment. Our findings suggest that the benefits of INOs treatment are more pronounced in offspring exposed to environmental factors in utero, and less likely in those due to genetic factors.

Effect of Normal Pregnancy Followed by Lactation on Long-Term Maternal Health in a Mouse Model

Although it has been widely accepted that pregnancies with complications are associated with increased maternal cardiovascular risk later in life, there is no consensus if noncomplicated pregnancy followed by lactation plays a protective role or is a risk factor. The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of normal pregnancy and lactation on long-term maternal health in a mouse model. CD-1 mice were allocated to breeding (primigravid [PG]) and nonbreeding (nulligravid [NG]) groups. The PG group proceeded through normal pregnancy and delivery. Using a telemetry system, blood pressure (BP) was analyzed in the PG group at 6 months postpartum and in age-matched NG mice. Serum analytes, gene expressions, and protein levels were determined using appropriate analysis methods. Primigravid mice had significantly lower systolic and diastolic BP and fasting glucose levels. Circulating oxytocin (OXT) levels were significantly higher in PG mice. Oxt gene expression was significantly higher in the heart and aorta and lower in visceral adipose tissue (VAT) from PG mice. The oxytocin receptor ( Oxtr) gene expression was significantly higher in the heart, aorta, and VAT from PG animals. The level of Oxtr DNA hypermethylation and the expression of mmu-miR-29a were significantly lower in the hearts of PG mice. In PG VAT, glucose transporter-4 expression was significantly higher. Our study demonstrates that a history of normal pregnancy followed by lactation was associated with lower maternal cardiovascular risk factors later in life in female mouse.

Adverse Effect of High-Fat Diet on Metabolic Programming in Offspring Born to a Murine Model of Maternal Hypertension

BACKGROUND

We previously reported that offspring heterozygous mice partially lacking endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) gene, and born to hypertensive eNOS-/- Knockout mother, are hypertensive. We hypothesized that those offspring when placed on high-fat diet (HFD) will undergo altered metabolic programming increasing their risk for developing metabolic syndrome.

METHODS

eNOS-/-KO and wild-type mice (eNOS+/+WT) were cross-bred to produce heterozygous offspring: maternal heterozygous (Mat, eNOS-/+), born from hypertensive eNOS-/-KO mothers; and paternal heterozygous (Pat, eNOS-/+), born from normotensive WT mothers. Mat, eNOS-/+ and Pat, eNOS-/+ female were allocated to HFD or control diet (CD) until 8 weeks of age. Then a metabolic profile was obtained: weight, glucose/insulin tolerance test (GTT, ITT), systolic blood pressure (SBP), serum fasting levels of insulin, adiponectin, leptin, and a lipid panel.

RESULTS

Weight was not different between all offspring within each diet. GTT curve was higher in Mat, eNOS-/+ vs. Pat, eNOS-/+ offspring on both diet (P < 0.001). In ITT, glucose level at 15 minutes was higher in Mat, eNOS-/+ on HFD. Insulin level was increased in Mat, eNOS-/+ vs. Pat, eNOS-/+ on either diet. SBP was elevated in Mat, eNOS-/+ vs. Pat, eNOS-/+ on CD and was further raised in Mat, eNOS-/+ offspring on HFD (P < 0.001). No other differences were seen except for lower high-density lipoprotein levels in Mat, eNOS-/+ fed HFD (P < 0.003).

CONCLUSIONS

Mat, eNOS-/+ offspring exposed in utero to maternal hypertension and fed HFD postnatally have increased susceptibility for metabolic abnormalities. Thus, maternal HTN is a risk factor for altered fetal metabolic programming.

Fetal programming of blood pressure in a transgenic mouse model of altered intrauterine environment

KEY POINTS

Nitric oxide is essential in the vascular adaptation to pregnancy, as knockout mice lacking nitric oxide synthase (NOS3) have abnormal utero-placental perfusion, hypertension and growth restriction. We previously showed with ex vivo studies on transgenic animals lacking NOS3 that adverse intrauterine environment alters fetal programming of vascular reactivity in adult offspring. The current research shows that altered vascular reactivity correlates with higher blood pressure in vivo. Our data suggest that higher blood pressure depends on both genetic background (NOS3 deficiency) and uterine environment, becomes more evident with age (> 7 postnatal weeks), activity and stress, is gender specific (preponderant among males), and can be affected by the sleep-awake cycle. In utero or early postnatal life (< 7 weeks), before onset of hypertension, may represent a potential window for intervention to prevent future cardiovascular disorders.

ABSTRACT

Nitric oxide is involved in the vascular adaptation to pregnancy. Using transgenic animals, we previously showed that adverse intrauterine environment alters vascular reactivity in adult offspring. The aim of our study was to determine if altered vascular programming is associated with abnormal blood pressure (BP) profiles in vivo. Mice lacking a functional endothelial nitric oxide synthase (KO, NOS3-/- ) and wild-type mice (WT, NOS3+/+ ) were crossbred to generate homozygous NOS3-/- (KO), maternally derived heterozygous NOS3+/- (KOM: mother with adverse intrauterine environment from NOS3 deficiency), paternally derived heterozygous NOS3+/- (KOP: mother with normal in utero milieu) and NOS3+/+ (WT) litters. BP was measured in vivo at 7, 14 and 21 weeks of age. After univariate analysis, multivariate population-averaged linear regression models were used to identify factors affecting BP. When compared to WT offspring, systolic (SBP), diastolic (DBP) and mean (MAP) BP progressively increased from KOP, to KOM, and peaked among KO (P < 0.001), although significance was not reached for KOP. Higher BP was also associated with male gender, older age (> 7 postnatal weeks), higher locomotor activity, daytime recordings, and recent blood pressure transducer insertion (P < 0.001). Post hoc analysis showed that KOM had higher SBP than KOP (P < 0.05). Our study indicates that adverse intrauterine environment contributes, along with multiple other factors, to account for hypertension; moreover, in utero or early postnatal life may represent a possible therapeutic window for prevention of cardiovascular disease later in life.

The effect of combined inositol supplementation on maternal metabolic profile in pregnancies complicated by metabolic syndrome and obesity

BACKGROUND

Myoinositol and D-chiroinositol improve insulin resistance in women with obesity and gestational diabetes and in postmenopausal women with metabolic syndrome. We previously reported that offspring born to hypertensive dams lacking endothelial nitric oxide synthase and fed a high-fat diet develop metabolic-like syndrome phenotype.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to investigate the effect of a mixture of myoinositol/D-chiroinositol supplementation during pregnancy on the maternal metabolic profile in pregnancies complicated by the metabolic-like syndrome and obesity using a pregnant mouse model.

STUDY DESIGN

Female heterozygous endothelial nitric oxide synthase(-/+) mice with moderate hypertension were placed on a high-fat diet for 4 weeks to induce a metabolic-like syndrome phenotype. Similarly, wild-type C57BL/6 mice were placed on a high-fat diet for 4 weeks to induce a murine obesity model. Mice were then bred with wild-type males. On gestational day 1, dams were randomly allocated to receive either a mixture of myoinositol/D-chiroinositol in water (7.2/0.18 mg/mL, respectively) or water as control (placebo). At term (gestational day 18), maternal weights, systolic blood pressure, and a glucose tolerance test were obtained. Dams were then killed; pups and placentas were weighed and maternal blood collected. Serum levels of metabolic biomarkers relevant to diabetes and obesity (ghrelin, gastric inhibitory peptide, glucagon-like peptide 1, glucagon, insulin, leptin, resistin) were measured by a multiplex enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Analysis was done comparing metabolic-like syndrome-myoinositol/D-chiroinositol-treated vs metabolic-like syndrome-nontreated mice and obese-myoinositol/D-chiroinositol-treated vs obese nontreated mice.

RESULTS

Mean systolic blood pressure was lower in metabolic-like syndrome pregnant mice treated with myoinositol/D-chiroinositol compared with placebo (P = .04), whereas there was no difference in systolic blood pressure between treated and placebo-treated obese pregnant mice. Pregnant metabolic-like syndrome mice treated with myoinositol/D-chiroinositol showed lower glucose values during the glucose tolerance test and in the area under the curve (myoinositol/D-chiroinositol: 17512.5 ± 3984.4 vs placebo: 29687.14 ± 8258.7; P = .003), but no differences were seen in the obese pregnant mice. Leptin serum levels were lower in the metabolic-like syndrome-myoinositol/D-chiroinositol-treated mice compared with the placebo group (myoinositol/D-chiroinositol: 16985 ± 976.4 pg/dL vs placebo: 24181.9 ± 3128.2 pg/dL, P = .045). No other differences were seen in any of the remaining serum metabolic biomarkers studied in metabolic-like syndrome and in obese pregnant mice. Maternal weight gain was not different in the pregnant metabolic-like syndrome dams, whereas it was lower in the obese myoinositol/D-chiroinositol-treated dams compared with the placebo group (myoinositol/D-chiroinositol: 10.9 ± 0.5 g vs 12.6 ± 0.6 g, P = .04). Fetal and placental weights did not differ between myoinositol/D-chiroinositol-treated and nontreated pregnant dams with metabolic-like syndrome and obesity.

CONCLUSION

Combined inositol treatment during pregnancy improves blood pressure, glucose levels at the glucose tolerance test, and leptin levels in pregnant dams with metabolic-like syndrome phenotype but not in obese pregnant dams. In addition, inositol treatment was associated with lower gestational weight gain in the obese but not in the metabolic-like syndrome pregnant dams.

Sildenafil treatment in a nonsevere hypertensive murine model lowers blood pressure without reducing fetal growth

BACKGROUND

Treatment of nonsevere hypertension during pregnancy is controversial. Sildenafil is a phosphodiesterase inhibitor that potentiates nitric oxide by promoting vasodilation. Nitric oxide plays a vital role in mediating the vascular adaptations during pregnancy.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to determine whether treatment with sildenafil during pregnancy would lower maternal systolic blood pressure without adversely affecting fetal growth.

STUDY DESIGN

Females with nonsevere hypertension (endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-)) were cross-bred with normotensive wild-type males. At gestational day 1, pregnant dams were randomized to either sildenafil (0.4 mg/mL per day, comparable dose used in human pregnancy) or water for 3 weeks. Four groups were then generated: wild type (n = 7), wild type-sildenafil (n = 11), endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) (n = 8), and endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-)sildenafil (n = 7). On gestational day 18, systolic blood pressure was measured. Dams were killed, fetal and placental weights were obtained, and carotid arteries were dissected to measure in vitro vascular reactivity with a wire-myography system. Responses to phenylephrine, L-NG-nitroarginine methyl ester, acetylcholine, and sodium nitroprusside were studied.

RESULTS

Mean systolic blood pressure was elevated in the endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) dams compared with wild-type controls (P = .03). Treatment with sildenafil decreased systolic blood pressure in the endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-)-treated dams compared with nontreated endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) dams (P = .03). No differences were seen in the wild-type dams with or without sildenafil (P = .47). Fetuses from endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) dams were smaller compared with wild-type controls (P < .001); however, when these endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) dams were treated with sildenafil, fetal weight increased compared with the nontreated endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) group (P < .001). No difference were seen in wild-type groups treated or not treated with sildenafil (P = .41). Placental weights were not significantly different among groups (endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-)sildenafil vs endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) [P = .48]; wild-type-sildenafil vs wild type [P = .52]). Maximal vascular contraction induced by phenylephrine was blunted in endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) dams treated with sildenafil compared with nontreated endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) dams (P < .01). No change in contractile response was seen in wild-type groups treated or not treated (P = .53). When vessels were preincubated with L-NG-nitroarginine methyl ester, the contractile responses were similar among all groups (P = .54). In addition, maximal vascular relaxation induced by acetylcholine was improved in the endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) dams treated with sildenafil compared with endothelial nitric oxide synthase(+/-) nontreated dams (P < .01). No change in relaxation response was seen in wild-type groups treated or not treated (P = .62). Sodium nitroprusside did not change the contractile response in any of the groups (P = .31).

CONCLUSION

Pregnant dams deficient in endothelial nitric oxide synthase, a nonsevere hypertensive murine model, treated with sildenafil had lower maternal systolic blood pressure, increased fetal growth, and improvement in vascular reactivity. Treatment with sildenafil may be beneficial in pregnancies complicated by nonsevere hypertension.

In Utero Origins of Hypertension: Mechanisms and Targets for Therapy

The developmental origins of health and disease theory is based on evidence that a suboptimal environment during fetal and neonatal development can significantly impact the evolution of adult-onset disease. Abundant evidence exists that a compromised prenatal (and early postnatal) environment leads to an increased risk of hypertension later in life. Hypertension is a silent, chronic, and progressive disease defined by elevated blood pressure (>140/90 mmHg) and is strongly correlated with cardiovascular morbidity/mortality. The pathophysiological mechanisms, however, are complex and poorly understood, and hypertension continues to be one of the most resilient health problems in modern society. Research into the programming of hypertension has proposed pharmacological treatment strategies to reverse and/or prevent disease. In addition, modifications to the lifestyle of pregnant women might impart far-reaching benefits to the health of their children. As more information is discovered, more successful management of hypertension can be expected to follow; however, while pregnancy complications such as fetal growth restriction, preeclampsia, preterm birth, etc., continue to occur, their offspring will be at increased risk for hypertension. This article reviews the current knowledge surrounding the developmental origins of hypertension, with a focus on mechanistic pathways and targets for therapeutic and pharmacologic interventions.

Translational value of mechanical and vasomotor properties of mouse isolated mesenteric resistance-sized arteries

Mice are increasingly used in vascular research for studying perturbations and responses to vasoactive agents in small artery preparations. Historically, small artery function has preferably been studied in rat isolated mesenteric resistance-sized arteries (MRA) using the wire myograph technique. Although different mouse arteries have been studied using the wire myograph no establishment of optimal settings has yet been performed. Therefore, the purposes of this study were firstly to establish the optimal settings for wire myograph studies of mouse MRA and compare them to those of rat MRA. Second, by surveying the literature, we aimed to evaluate the overall translatability of observed pharmacological vasomotor responses of mouse MRA to those obtained in rat MRA as well as corresponding and different arteries in terms of vessel size and species origin. Our results showed that the optimal conditions for maximal active force development in mouse MRA were not significantly different to those determined in rat MRA. Furthermore, we found that the observed concentration-dependent vasomotor responses of mouse MRA to noradrenaline, phenylephrine, angiotensin II, sarafotoxin 6c, 5-hydroxytryptamine, carbachol, sodium nitroprusside, and retigabine were generally similar to those described in rat MRA as well as arteries of different sizes and species origin. In summary, the results of this study provide a framework for evidence-based optimization of the isometric wire myograph setup to mouse MRA. Additionally, in terms of translational value, our study suggests that mouse MRA can be applied as a useful model for studying vascular reactivity.

Endothelial NO Synthase Augments Fetoplacental Blood Flow, Placental Vascularization, and Fetal Growth in Mice

It is not known whether eNOS deficiency in the mother or the conceptus (ie, placenta and fetus) causes fetal growth restriction in mice lacking the endothelial NO synthase gene (eNOS knockout [KO]). We hypothesized that eNOS sustains fetal growth by maintaining low fetoplacental vascular tone and promoting fetoplacental vascularity and that this is a conceptus effect and is independent of maternal genotype. We found that eNOS deficiency blunted fetal growth, and blunted the normal increase in umbilical blood flow and umbilical venous diameter and the decrease in umbilical arterial Resistance Index in late gestation (14.5–17.5 days) in eNOS KO relative to C57Bl/6J controls. On day 17.5, fetoplacental capillary lobule length and capillary density in vascular corrosion casts were reduced in eNOS KO placentas. Reduced vascularization may be a result of decreased vascular endothelial growth factor mRNA and protein expression in eNOS KO placentas at this stage. These factors, combined with significant anemia found in eNOS KO fetuses, would be anticipated to reduce fetal oxygen delivery and contribute to the fetal tissue hypoxia that was detected in the heart, lung, kidney, and liver by immunohistochemistry using pimonidazole. Although maternal eNOS deficiency impairs uteroplacental adaptations to pregnancy, maternal genotype was not a significant factor affecting growth in heterozygous conceptuses. This indicates that fetal growth restriction was primarily caused by conceptus eNOS deficiency. In mice, placental hemodynamic and vascular changes with gestation and growth restriction showed strong parallels with human pregnancy. Thus, the eNOS KO model could provide insights into the pathogenesis of human intrauterine growth restriction.

Pre-eclampsia and offspring cardiovascular health: mechanistic insights from experimental studies

Pre-eclampsia is increasingly recognized as more than an isolated disease of pregnancy. Women who have had a pregnancy complicated by pre-eclampsia have a 4-fold increased risk of later cardiovascular disease. Intriguingly, the offspring of affected pregnancies also have an increased risk of higher blood pressure and almost double the risk of stroke in later life. Experimental approaches to identify the key features of pre-eclampsia responsible for this programming of offspring cardiovascular health, or the key biological pathways modified in the offspring, have the potential to highlight novel targets for early primary prevention strategies. As pre-eclampsia occurs in 2–5% of all pregnancies, the findings are relevant to the current healthcare of up to 3 million people in the U.K. and 15 million people in the U.S.A. In the present paper, we review the current literature that concerns potential mechanisms for adverse cardiovascular programming in offspring exposed to pre-eclampsia, considering two major areas of investigation: first, experimental models that mimic features of the in utero environment characteristic of pre-eclampsia, and secondly, how, in humans, offspring cardiovascular phenotype is altered after exposure to pre-eclampsia. We compare and contrast the findings from these two bodies of work to develop insights into the likely key pathways of relevance. The present review and analysis highlights the pivotal role of long-term changes in vascular function and identifies areas of growing interest, specifically, response to hypoxia, immune modification, epigenetics and the anti-angiogenic in utero milieu.

eNOS knockout mouse as a model of fetal growth restriction with an impaired uterine artery function and placental transport phenotype

Fetal growth restriction (FGR) is the inability of a fetus to reach its genetically predetermined growth potential. In the absence of a genetic anomaly or maternal undernutrition, FGR is attributable to "placental insufficiency": inappropriate maternal/fetal blood flow, reduced nutrient transport or morphological abnormalities of the placenta (e.g., altered barrier thickness). It is not known whether these diverse factors act singly, or in combination, having additive effects that may lead to greater FGR severity. We suggest that multiplicity of such dysfunction might underlie the diverse FGR phenotypes seen in humans. Pregnant endothelial nitric oxide synthase knockout (eNOS(-/-)) dams exhibit dysregulated vascular adaptations to pregnancy, and eNOS(-/-) fetuses of such dams display FGR. We investigated the hypothesis that both altered vascular function and placental nutrient transport contribute to the FGR phenotype. eNOS(-/-) dams were hypertensive prior to and during pregnancy and at embryonic day (E) 18.5 were proteinuric. Isolated uterine artery constriction was significantly increased, and endothelium-dependent relaxation significantly reduced, compared with wild-type (WT) mice. eNOS(-/-) fetal weight and abdominal circumference were significantly reduced compared with WT. Unidirectional maternofetal (14)C-methylaminoisobutyric acid (MeAIB) clearance and sodium-dependent (14)C-MeAIB uptake into mouse placental vesicles were both significantly lower in eNOS(-/-) fetuses, indicating diminished placental nutrient transport. eNOS(-/-) mouse placentas demonstrated increased hypoxia at E17.5, with elevated superoxide compared with WT. We propose that aberrant uterine artery reactivity in eNOS(-/-) mice promotes placental hypoxia with free radical formation, reducing placental nutrient transport capacity and fetal growth. We further postulate that this mouse model demonstrates "uteroplacental hypoxia," providing a new framework for understanding the etiology of FGR in human pregnancy.

The role of oxidative stress in the developmental origin of adult hypertension

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether oxidative stress plays a role in the development of hypertension using a mouse model of fetal programming induced by endothelial nitric oxide synthase deficiency.

STUDY DESIGN

Homozygous nitric oxide synthase knockout and wild type mice were cross-bred producing maternal (endothelial nitric oxide synthase+pat/-mat) and paternal (endothelial nitric oxide synthase+mat/-pat) heterozygous offspring. RNA from liver and kidney tissues of female pups were obtained at 14 weeks of age. Relative expression of the heat shock protein-B6, peroxiredoxin-3, superoxide dismutase-1, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma, nitric oxide synthase-1 and -2 were determined.

RESULTS

In the kidneys, expression of nitric oxide synthase-2, peroxiredoxin-3, heat shock protein-B6, and superoxide dismutase-1 was up-regulated in endothelial nitric oxide synthase+pat/-mat but not in endothelial nitric oxide synthase+mat/-pat compared with wild type offspring. In the liver, there were no significant differences in the expression of nitric oxide synthase-1, nitric oxide synthase-2, peroxiredoxin, superoxide dismutase-1, or peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma; however, heat shock protein-B6 was down-regulated in both heterozygotes offspring compared with wild type.

CONCLUSION

The intrauterine environment alters oxidative pathways gene expression in the kidneys of offspring, which may be a mechanism in the development of adult hypertension.

Effect of age and gender on the progression of adult vascular dysfunction in a mouse model of fetal programming lacking endothelial nitric oxide synthase

The objective of this study was to investigate vascular function at different ages in a transgenic murine model of fetal vascular programming using a model of uteroplacental insufficiency induced by lack of endothelial nitric oxide synthase. Homozygous NOS3 knockout (KO) and wild-type (WT) mice were cross bred to produce WT, KO, and heterozygous that developed in WT (KOP) or KO (KOM) mothers. Male/female offspring from the four groups were killed at 7, 14, and 21 wk of age (n = 5-10/group), and carotid arteries were used for in vitro vascular studies. Responses to phenylephrine (PE), with/without N(G)-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester (L-NAME), angiotensin (ANG), acetylcholine (ACh), sodium nitroprusside, and isoproterenol (ISO) were studied. At 7 wk, only KO offspring showed higher contractile response to PE, whereas, at 14 and 21 wk, both KO and KOM had a higher response. Incubation with L-NAME abolished these differences. ANG contraction was higher in male KO in all age groups and in 21-wk-old females. Relaxation to ACh and ISO was absent in KO, and significantly decreased in KOM offspring in all age groups compared with KOP and WT, independent of gender. Sodium nitroprusside was not different between groups. The effect of the altered intrauterine environment on the development of abnormal vascular function was limited at 7 wk of age and most evident at 14 wk; further deterioration was limited to ANG-mediated vascular contractility in KO offspring. Our findings provide some hope that at least the first seven postnatal weeks may be an appropriate therapeutic window to prevent cardiovascular disease later in life.

Maternal low-protein diet during mouse pre-implantation development induces vascular dysfunction and altered renin–angiotensin-system homeostasis in the offspring

Environmental perturbations during early mammalian development can affect aspects of offspring growth and cardiovascular health. We have demonstrated previously that maternal gestational dietary protein restriction in mice significantly elevated adult offspring systolic blood pressure. Therefore, the present study investigates the key mechanisms of blood pressure regulation in these mice. Following mating, female MF-1 mice were assigned to either a normal-protein diet (NPD; 18 % casein) or an isocaloric low-protein diet throughout gestation (LPD; 9 % casein), or fed the LPD exclusively during the pre-implantation period (3·5 d) before returning to the NPD for the remainder of gestation (Emb-LPD). All offspring received standard chow. At 22 weeks, isolated mesenteric arteries from LPD and Emb-LPD males displayed significantly attenuated vasodilatation to isoprenaline (P = 0·04 and P = 0·025, respectively), when compared with NPD arteries. At 28 weeks, stereological analysis of glomerular number in female left kidneys revealed no significant difference between the groups. Real-time RT-PCR analysis of type 1a angiotensin II receptor, Na+/K+ ATPase transporter subunits and glucocorticoid receptor expression in male and female left kidneys revealed no significant differences between the groups. LPD females displayed elevated serum angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) activity (P = 0·044), whilst Emb-LPD males had elevated lung ACE activity (P = 0·001), when compared with NPD offspring. These data demonstrate that elevated offspring systolic blood pressure following maternal gestational protein undernutrition is associated with impaired arterial vasodilatation in male offspring, elevated serum and lung ACE activity in female and male offspring, respectively, but kidney glomerular number in females and kidney gene expression in male and female offspring appear unaffected.

Effect of intrauterine fetal programming on response to postnatal shaker stress in endothelial nitric oxide knockout mouse model

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether the intrauterine environment affects the postnatal vascular response to stress in a model of fetal programming induced by endothelial nitric oxide synthase deficiency.

STUDY DESIGN

Homozygous nitric oxide synthase knockout and wild-type controls were crossbred to obtain maternally and paternally derived heterozygous offspring. At 14 weeks of age, in vivo blood pressure measurements by telemetry, and in vitro carotid arteries vascular reactivity studies were performed in male offspring after subjecting them to shaker stress.

RESULTS

Maternally derived heterozygous offspring, compared with paternally derived heterozygous offspring, had significantly higher systolic blood pressure, mean arterial blood pressure, and pulse pressure before, as well as after introduction of the shaker stress. The difference in the latter between maternally and paternally derived heterozygous offspring was accentuated after stress. Maternally derived heterozygous offspring also had significantly higher contractile responses to phenylephrine when compared with paternally derived heterozygous offspring, and this was abolished after incubation with L-NAME.

CONCLUSION

The adverse uterine environment affects the postnatal vascular response to stress.

Gestational programming of offspring obesity/hypertension

The intrauterine milieu impacts fetal growth directly during gestation. It is now clear, however, that postnatal phenotype is also influenced by prenatal conditions. A variety of disorders in the adult have been linked to fetal size at birth; these include glucose intolerance, cardiovascular disease, and the subjects of this review, obesity and hypertension. We will review recent data regarding these associations and the pathophysiologic mechanisms underlying them in humans as well as in animal models.

Animal models for the study of the developmental origins of health and disease

Human epidemiological studies have indicated that the risk of developing non-communicable diseases in later life may be related to exposures during the developmental period. Developmental life is a vulnerable period of the lifespan during which adverse environmental factors have the potential to disturb the processes of cell proliferation and differentiation or to alter patterns of epigenetic remodelling. Animal models have been instrumental in demonstrating the biological plausibility of the associations observed in human populations, providing proof of principle to the theory of the developmental origins of health and disease (DOHaD). A variety of large- and small-animal models have made important contributions to the field, providing strong evidence of a causal relationship between early-life exposures and metabolic risk factors in later life. Studies of animal models are continuing to contribute to improving the understanding of the mechanisms of the developmental origins of disease. All models have their advantages and disadvantages, and the model that is most appropriate for any particular study is hypotheses dependent. The present review aims to briefly summarise the contributions that animal models have made to the DOHaD field, before reviewing the strengths and weaknesses of these animal models. It is proposed that the integration of evidence from a variety of different models is required for the advancement of understanding within the field.

Transgenerational effect of fetal programming on vascular phenotype and reactivity in endothelial nitric oxide synthase knockout mouse model

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to investigate the transgenerational effect of fetal vascular programming

STUDY DESIGN

Homozygous NOS3 knockout and wild type controls (NOS3+/+WT) were cross-bred to obtain heterozygous offspring that developed in (KO-/-) mothers lacking a functional NOS3 (KOM) vs wild-type control mothers (KOP). The first-generation KOM(+/-) and KOP(+/-) female mice were then bred with WT(+/+) males to obtain a second generation (F2). F2 offspring were genotyped and WT(+/+)-F2 mice were then used for in vivo blood pressure and in vitro vascular reactivity studies.

RESULTS

WT-F2 mice born to KOM mothers (KOM-F2WT) had significantly higher systolic blood pressure, mean arterial pressure, and pulse pressure, compared with WT-F2 born to KOP mothers. Male KOM-F2WT offspring had significantly increased response to phenylephrine (PE), compared with male KOP-F2WT. Male offspring had increased contractile responses to PE when compared with female. Acetylcholine responses were decreased in female KOM-F2WT, compared with female KOP-F2WT, but the difference was not statistically significant

CONCLUSION

Our findings support a transgenerational effect of fetal programming on the vascular phenotype and suggest possible gender specific adaptation.

Intrauterine growth restriction: fetal programming of hypertension and kidney disease

The etiology of hypertension historically includes 2 components: genetics and lifestyle. However, recent epidemiologic studies report an inverse relationship between birth weight and hypertension suggesting that a suboptimal fetal environment may also contribute to increased disease in later life. Experimental studies support this observation and indicate that cardiovascular/kidney disease originates in response to fetal adaptations to adverse conditions during prenatal life.

Mechanisms underlying developmental programming of elevated blood pressure and vascular dysfunction: evidence from human studies and experimental animal models

Cardiovascular-related diseases are the leading cause of death in the world in both men and women. In addition to the environmental and genetic factors, early life conditions are now also considered important contributing elements to these pathologies. The concept of 'fetal' or 'developmental' origins of adult diseases has received increased recognition over the last decade, yet the mechanism by which altered perinatal environment can lead to dysfunction mostly apparent in the adult are incompletely understood. This review will focus on the mechanisms and pathways that epidemiological studies and experimental models have revealed underlying the adult cardiovascular phenotype dictated by the perinatal experience, as well as the probable key causal or triggering elements. Programmed elevated blood pressure in the adult human or animal is characterized by vascular dysfunction and microvascular rarefaction. Developmental mechanisms that have been more extensively studied include glucocorticoid exposure, the role of the kidneys and the renin-angiotensin system. Other pathophysiological pathways have been explored, such as the role of the brain and the sympathetic nervous system, oxidative stress and epigenetic changes. As with many complex diseases, a unifying hypothesis linking the perinatal environment to elevated blood pressure and vascular dysfunction in later life cannot be presumed, and a better understanding of those mechanisms is critical before clinical trials of preventive or 'deprogramming' measures can be designed.

Gender-specific effect of overexpression of sFlt-1 in pregnant mice on fetal programming of blood pressure in the offspring later in life

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to determine whether fetal programming of adult blood pressure is altered in a previously characterized mouse model of preeclampsia that was induced by sFlt-1.

STUDY DESIGN

CD-1 mouse mothers at day 8 of gestation were injected with an adenovirus carrying Flt 1-3 (10(9) plaque-forming units) or with an adenovirus carrying mFc as control (10(9) plaque-forming units). The resulting pups were followed until 6 months of age, at which time blood pressure (BP) was recorded continuously for 6 days. The offspring weight was also recorded from weaning until adulthood.

RESULTS

BP was significantly higher in the male offspring that were born to sFlt-1-treated mothers compared with the controls. Male offspring from sFlt-1-treated mothers were significantly smaller from weaning until adulthood. However, there were no significant differences in BP and postweaning weight in female offspring between the 2 groups.

CONCLUSION

Our findings highlight the role of the intrauterine environment in the developmental origin of adult disease.

Naturally occurring perinatal growth restriction in mice programs cardiovascular and endocrine function in a sex- and strain-dependent manner

Perinatal growth restriction (PGR) is associated with type 2 diabetes and hypertension. Identification of an isogenic mouse model of fetal programming will facilitate mechanistic understanding. We sought to test the hypotheses that 1) PGR impairs glucose tolerance and induces hypertension; and 2) the programming phenotype is more severe in an inbred mouse strain susceptible to diabetes (C57BL/6) than in a strain without such genetic predisposition (DBA/2). PGR pups were paired at weaning with same sex normally grown littermates. Glucose and insulin tolerance tests were performed at 17 wk, and systolic blood pressure (SBP) was measured at 20 wk. Impaired glucose tolerance was evident only among female PGR mice from both strains. While PGR did not alter insulin sensitivity in either strain, female DBA/2 mice had significantly decreased insulin levels during glucose tolerance testing. SBP was increased in PGR male C57BL/6 mice (p<0.01), while heart rate was decreased in PGR male DBA/2 mice (p<0.05). These studies indicate that in isogenic mice, PGR alters endocrine and cardiovascular physiology in female and male mice, respectively. Strain-and sex-specific genetic susceptibilities emphasize the need to consider genetic predisposition when evaluating the role of the perinatal environmental in the inception of adult disease.

Effect of a previous pregnancy on vascular function in endothelial nitric oxide synthase 3 knockout mice

OBJECTIVE

Nitric oxide deficiency has been implicated in adverse pregnancy outcomes. Mice that lack endothelial nitric oxide synthase (NOS3) have abnormal in vitro vascular reactivity. Our objective was to assess the effect of a previous pregnancy on the abnormal vascular function of NOS3 knockout mice.

STUDY DESIGN

Carotid arteries from pregnant NOS3 knockout (NOS3(-/-KO)) and wild-type control mice (NOS3(+/+WT)) from first and second pregnancy were obtained for in vitro vascular reactivity studies. Vascular responses to cumulative concentrations of the vasoconstrictors phenylephrine, serotonin, and thromboxane and the vasorelaxants acetylcholine, sodium nitroprusside, and isoproterenol were determined.

RESULTS

In the first pregnancy, contractile responses were exaggerated in the knockout animals, compared with the wild-type animals. However, the second pregnancy in knockout animals was associated with normalization of responses to phenylephrine and serotonin and increased responses to the endothelium-independent relaxants.

CONCLUSION

The vascular function of NOS3 knockout mice improves with subsequent pregnancy becoming comparable to wild-type animals.

Aquaporin-2 water channel in developing quail kidney: possible role in programming adult fluid homeostasis

Avian kidneys have loopless and looped nephrons; a countercurrent multiplier mechanism operates in the latter by NaCl recycling. We identified an aquaporin-2 (AQP2) homolog in apical/subapical regions of cortical and medullary collecting duct (CD) cells in kidneys of Japanese quail (q), Coturnix japonica. We investigated whether undernutrition during the embryonic/maturation period retards kidney and AQP2 development in quail and programs impaired volume regulation in adults. Protocols included 1) time course and 2) effects of 5-10% egg white withdrawal (EwW) or 48-h post-hatch food deprivation (FD) on nephron growth and qAQP2 mRNA expression, and 3) effects of EwW and FD on qAQP2 mRNA responses to 72-h water deprivation in adults. In metanephric kidneys, qAQP2 mRNA is expressed in medullary CDs at embryonic day 10; distribution and intensity increase during maturation. The number and size of glomeruli continue to increase after birth, whereas nephrogenic zones decrease. In EwW embryos, qAQP2 mRNA expression is initially delayed, then restored; birth weight and hatching rate are lower than in controls. Adults from EwW embryos and FD chicks have fewer (P < 0.01) glomeruli. Water deprivation reduces body weight more in EwW birds than in controls. The results suggest that qAQP2 evolved in metanephric kidneys and that undernutrition may retard nephrogenesis, leading to impaired adult water homeostasis.

The effect of the postnatal environment on altered fetal programming of adult vascular function in mice that lack endothelial nitric oxide synthase

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to investigate vascular reactivity in heterozygous and homozygous offspring with a genetic predisposition for hypertension after postnatal cross-fostering to mothers with the opposite genetic inheritance of the NOS3 knockout allele.

STUDY DESIGN

Homozygous NOS3 knockout (C57BL/6J-NOS3(-/-KO)) and wild-type mice (NOS3(+/+WT)) were bred to obtain heterozygous litters with a paternally derived (NOS3(+/-pat)) or maternally derived (NOS3(+/-mat)) knockout allele. After delivery, heterozygous and homozygous litters were cross-fostered to a mother with the opposite NOS3 gene status. Carotid arteries were placed in a wire myograph for isometric tension recording with the use of contractile and relaxant agents. Statistical analysis with 1-way analysis of variance and Neuman-Keuls post-hoc testing was performed.

RESULTS

Increased sensitivity to phenylephrine and absent relaxation to acetylcholine in NOS3(+/-mat) was reversed with cross-fostering, and vasorelaxation to isoproterenol was increased. Contraction to calcium was increased in the cross-fostered paternally derived and wild-type litters.

CONCLUSION

Postnatal interventions may alter the adult vascular profile favorably that is the result of an abnormal intrauterine environment.

Maternal Endothelial Nitric Oxide Synthase Genotype Influences Offspring Blood Pressure and Activity in Mice

Deficiencies in maternal endothelial NO synthase (eNOS) have been associated with pregnancy complications, intrauterine growth retardation, and altered vascular function in offspring. In the present study, we investigated the influence of the maternal eNOS genotype on offspring's blood pressure, heart rate, and locomotor activity. The effect of maternal eNOS genotype was made by comparing telemetered blood pressure and activity between 2 groups of 13- to 16-week-old male heterozygous eNOS knockout mice, 1 produced by a cross of eNOS knockout (eNOS-/-) mothers and wild-type (eNOS+/+) fathers (eNOS(+/-MAT) offspring, N=11), the other by a cross of eNOS+/+ mothers and eNOS-/- fathers (eNOS(+/-PAT) offspring, N=10). Data were also collected for homozygous eNOS-/- and eNOS+/+ mice (N=15 each). Heterozygous eNOS knockout mice exhibited blood pressures that were intermediate to the eNOS+/+ and eNOS-/- groups. Relative to eNOS(+/-PAT) mice, eNOS(+/-MAT) mice exhibited significant increases in nocturnal diastolic arterial pressure and diurnal variations (dark-light difference) in systolic, mean, and diastolic arterial pressure. In addition, indices of spontaneous nocturnal locomotor activity, including both the proportion of time spent active and the intensity of activity when active, were also significantly increased. Heart rate did not differ between the groups. Our results suggest that the maternal eNOS genotype influences both blood pressure and behavior of offspring, possibly as a consequence of developmental programming associated with intrauterine growth retardation.

Does estrogen affect the development of abnormal vascular function in offspring of rats fed a low-protein diet in pregnancy?

It is established that there are gender-related differences in the effects on offspring blood pressure induced by maternal protein restriction in animal studies. Since such effects may depend on estrogen levels, we hypothesized that lower estrogen would induce an earlier onset of hypertension caused by maternal under-nutrition. Wistar rats were fed a diet containing either 18% (C) or 9% (R) casein throughout pregnancy. Half of the offspring in both C and R groups were ovariectomized on day 50 (CX, RX), and the other half underwent a sham operation (CO, RO). On d 175, offspring were killed for small artery reactivity and histologic investigation. Birth weight and later growth were not significantly different between C and R. RX had higher systolic blood pressure than CX on d125, but no difference was seen between RO and CO. On d 175, systolic blood pressure was higher in R than in C, whether or not ovariectomized. Dilator responses to acetylcholine and bradykinin in small mesenteric arteries were significantly attenuated in RX, although responses to SNP and isoprenaline showed no attenuation in R. The ratio of coronary peri-vascular fibrosis to total vascular area was higher in R, and the fibrosis became prominent in ovariectomized rats. These findings suggest that estrogen plays an important role in limiting the elevation of offspring blood pressure induced by maternal under-nutrition, possibly via BK-mediated mechanisms. The processes may underlie gender and life course patterns of hypertension and also the developmental origins of this disease.

Inhibitory effect of erythropoietin on contractility of human chorionic plate vessels

OBJECTIVE

Placenta is a major source of erythropoietin production in the fetus; hypoxia is associated with elevated erythropoietin levels in the fetal circulation. We investigated fetoplacental vascular reactivity after exposure to erythropoietin in vitro.

STUDY DESIGN

Third-order chorionic plate arteries from human term placentae were incubated in culture medium with or without erythropoietin (3 U/mL) for 24 hours. Vessels were mounted in a myograph for isometric tension recording, and their responses to vasopressors and vasorelaxants were studied.

RESULTS

Contractile responses to endothelin-1 and the thromboxane analogue U46619 were decreased in erythropoietin-exposed vessels compared with controls. Relaxant responses to the nitric oxide donor sodium nitroprusside and the phosphodiesterase inhibitor papaverine were not influenced by erythropoietin.

CONCLUSION

Exposure to elevated levels of erythropoietin has an inhibitory effect on contractile responses in human placental chorionic plate arteries. We speculate that this may improve fetoplacental perfusion in hypoxic fetuses with elevated erythropoietin production.