Subcortical modulation of high-frequency (gamma band) oscillating potentials in auditory cortex

Network resonance and the auditory steady state response

The auditory steady state response (ASSR) arises when periodic sounds evoke stable responses in auditory networks that reflect the acoustic characteristics of the stimuli, such as the amplitude of the sound envelope. Larger for some stimulus rates than others, the ASSR in the human electroencephalogram (EEG) is notably maximal for sounds modulated in amplitude at 40 Hz. To investigate the local circuit underpinnings of the large ASSR to 40 Hz amplitude-modulated (AM) sounds, we acquired skull EEG and local field potential (LFP) recordings from primary auditory cortex (A1) in the rat during the presentation of 20, 30, 40, 50, and 80 Hz AM tones. 40 Hz AM tones elicited the largest ASSR from the EEG acquired above auditory cortex and the LFP acquired from each cortical layer in A1. The large ASSR in the EEG to 40 Hz AM tones was not due to larger instantaneous amplitude of the signals or to greater phase alignment of the LFP across the cortical layers. Instead, it resulted from decreased latency variability (or enhanced temporal consistency) of the 40 Hz response. Statistical models indicate the EEG signal was best predicted by LFPs in either the most superficial or deep cortical layers, suggesting deep layer coordinators of the ASSR. Overall, our results indicate that the recruitment of non-uniform but more temporally consistent responses across A1 layers underlie the larger ASSR to amplitude-modulated tones at 40 Hz.

Cortical gamma oscillations: the functional key is activation, not cognition

Cortical oscillatory synchrony in the gamma range has been attracting increasing attention in cognitive neuroscience ever since being proposed as a solution to the so-called binding problem. This growing literature is critically reviewed in both its basic neuroscience and cognitive aspects. A physiological "default assumption" regarding these oscillations is introduced, according to which they signal a state of physiological activation of cortical tissue, and the associated need to balance excitation with inhibition in particular. As such these oscillations would belong among a variety of generic neural control operations that enable neural tissue to perform its systems level functions, without implementing those functions themselves. Regional control of cerebral blood flow provides an analogy in this regard, and gamma oscillations are tightly correlated with this even more elementary control operation. As correlates of neural activation they will also covary with cognitive activity, and this typically suffices to account for the covariation between gamma activity and cognitive task variables. A number of specific cases of gamma synchrony are examined in this light, including the original impetus for attributing cognitive significance to gamma activity, namely the experiments interpreted as evidence for "binding by synchrony". This examination finds no compelling reasons to assign functional roles to oscillatory synchrony in the gamma range beyond its generic functions at the level of infrastructural neural control.

How different are the local field potentials and spiking activities? Insights from multi-electrodes arrays

Simultaneous recording of multiple neurons, or neuron groups, offers new promise for investigating fundamental questions about the neural code. We used arrays of 16 electrodes in the tonotopic, primary, auditory cortex of guinea pigs and we extracted LFP- and spike-based spectro-temporal receptive fields (STRFs). We confirm here that LFP signals provide broadly tuned activity which lacks frequency resolution compared to multiunit signals and, therefore, lead to large redundancy in neural responses even between recording sites far apart. Thanks to the use of multi-electrode arrays which allows simultaneous recordings, we also focused on functional relationships between neuronal discharges (through cross-correlations) and between LFPs (through coherence). Since the LFP is composed of distinct brain rhythms, the LFP results were split into three frequency bands from the slowest to the fastest components of LFPs. For driven as well as spontaneous activity, we show that components >70 Hz in LFPs are much less coherent between recording sites than slower components. In general, coherence between LFPs from two recordings sites is positively correlated with the degree of frequency overlap between the two corresponding STRFs, similar to cross-correlation between multiunit activities. However, coherence is only weakly correlated with cross-correlation in all frequency ranges. Altogether, these results suggest that LFPs reflect global functional connectivity in the thalamocortical auditory system whereas spiking activities reflect more independent local processing.

Cortical state and attention

The brain continuously adapts its processing machinery to behavioural demands. To achieve this, it rapidly modulates the operating mode of cortical circuits, controlling the way that information is transformed and routed. This article will focus on two experimental approaches by which the control of cortical information processing has been investigated: the study of state-dependent cortical processing in rodents and attention in the primate visual system. Both processes involve a modulation of low-frequency activity fluctuations and spiking correlation, and are mediated by common receptor systems. We suggest that selective attention involves processes that are similar to state change, and that operate at a local columnar level to enhance the representation of otherwise non-salient features while suppressing internally generated activity patterns.

ECoG gamma activity during a language task: differentiating expressive and receptive speech areas

Electrocorticographic (ECoG) spectral patterns obtained during language tasks from 12 epilepsy patients (age: 12-44 years) were analysed in order to identify and characterize cortical language areas. ECoG from 63 subdural electrodes (500 Hz/channel) chronically implanted over frontal, parietal and temporal lobes were examined. Two language tasks were performed. During the first language task, patients listened to a series of 50 words preceded by warning tones, and were asked to repeat each word. During a second memory task, subjects heard the 50 words from the first task randomly mixed with 50 new words and were asked to repeat the word only if it was a new word. Increases in ECoG gamma power (70-100 Hz) were observed in response to hearing tones (primary auditory cortex), hearing words (posterior temporal and parietal cortex) and repeating words (lateral frontal and anterior parietal cortex). These findings were compared to direct electrical stimulation and separate analysis of ECoG gamma changes during spontaneous inter-personal conversations. The results indicate that high-frequency ECoG reliably differentiates cortical areas associated with receptive and expressive speech processes for individual patients. Compared to listening to words, greater frontal lobe and decreased temporal lobe gamma activity was observed while speaking. The data support the concept of distributed functionally specific language modules interacting to serve receptive and expressive speech, with frontal lobe 'corollary discharges' suppressing low-level receptive cortical language areas in the temporal lobe during speaking.

Frequency Domain Analysis of Human Subdural Recordings

SUMMARY

It is possible to localize many aspects of cortical function and dysfunction without the use of direct electrical stimulation of cortex. This study explores the degree to which information can be obtained about functional cortical organization relative to epileptogenic regions through analysis of electrocorticographic recordings in the frequency domain. Information about the extent of seizure regions and the location of the normal sensory and motor homunculus and some higher language and memory related areas can be obtained through the analysis of task-related power spectrum changes and changes in lateral interelectrode coherence patterns calculated from interictal and ictal recordings.

The level of cholinergic nucleus basalis activation controls the specificity of auditory associative memory

Learning involves not only the establishment of memory per se, but also the specific details of its contents. In classical conditioning, the former concerns whether an association was learned while the latter discloses what was learned. The neural bases of associativity have been studied extensively while neural mechanisms of memory specificity have been neglected. Stimulation of the cholinergic nucleus basalis (NBs) paired with a preceding tone induces CS-specific associative memory. As different levels of acetylcholine may be released naturally during different learning situations, we asked whether the level of activation of the cholinergic neuromodulatory system can control the degree of detail that is encoded and retrieved. Adult male rats were tested pre- and post-training for behavioral responses (interruption of ongoing respiration) to tones of various frequencies (1-15 kHz, 70 dB, 2 s). Training consisted of 200 trials/day of tone (8.0 kHz, 70 dB, 2 s) either paired or unpaired with NBs (CS-NBs = 1.8 s) at moderate (65.7+/-9.0 microA, one day) or weak (46.7+/-12.1 microA, three training days) levels of stimulation, under conditions of controlled behavioral state (pre-trial stable respiration rate). Post-training (24 h) responses to tones revealed that moderate activation induced both associative and CS-specific behavioral memory, whereas weak activation produced associative memory lacking frequency specificity. The degree of memory specificity 24 h after training was positively correlated with the magnitude of CS-elicited increase in gamma activity within the EEG during training, but only in the moderate NBs group. Thus, a low level of acetylcholine released by the nucleus basalis during learning is sufficient to induce associativity whereas a higher level of release enables the storage of greater experiential detail. gamma waves, which are thought to reflect the coordinated activity of cortical cells, appear to index the encoding of CS detail. The findings demonstrate that the amount of detail in memory can be directly controlled by neural intervention.

Bistable network behavior of layer I interneurons in auditory cortex

GABAergic interneurons in many areas of the neocortex are mutually connected via chemical and electrical synapses. Previous computational studies have explored how these coupling parameters influence the firing patterns of interneuronal networks. These models have predicted that the stable states of such interneuronal networks will be either synchrony (near zero phase lag) or antisynchrony (phase lag near one-half of the interspike interval), depending on network connectivity and firing rates. In certain parameter regimens, the network can be bistable, settling into either stable state depending on the initial conditions. Here, we investigated how connectivity parameters influence spike patterns in paired recordings from layer I interneurons in brain slices from juvenile mice. Observed properties of chemical and electrical synapses were used to simulate connections between uncoupled cells via dynamic clamp. In uncoupled pairs, action potentials induced by constant depolarizing currents had randomly distributed phase differences between the two cells. When coupled with simulated chemical (inhibitory) synapses, however, these pairs exhibited a bimodal firing pattern, tending to fire either in synchrony or in antisynchrony. Combining electrical with chemical synapses, prolonging tau(Decay) of inhibitory connections, or increasing the firing rate of the network all resulted in enhanced stability of the synchronous state. Thus, electrical and inhibitory synaptic coupling constrain the relative timing of spikes in a two-cell network to, at most, two stable states, the stability and precision of which depend on the exact parameters of coupling.

Phase shift detection in thalamocortical oscillations using magnetoencephalography in humans

Magnetoencephalography was used to investigate exogenously stimulated oscillatory activity between cortex and thalamus resulting from clicks presented binaurally at the rate of 40 Hz. Analysis of the responses demonstrated activation of left and right auditory cortex, medial parietal cortex, thalamus, and cerebellum. Cross-correlations of the source waveforms revealed synchronicity between the auditory cortex sources (r > 0.9), auditory cortex and thalamic sources (r > 0.7), and thalamic and parietal sources (r > 0.7). The 40 Hz response in auditory cortex occurred 6 ms after thalamic activation. Supporting earlier findings, the results demonstrate the networks involved in the maintenance of 40 Hz auditory steady-state response and will prove useful for the interrogation of dysfunction in disorders demonstrating thalamocortical dysrhythmia, such as schizophrenia, Parkinson's disease, and depression.

Encoding for computation: recognizing brief dynamical patterns by exploiting effects of weak rhythms on action-potential timing

Many stimuli have meaning only as patterns over time. Most auditory and many visual stimuli are of this nature and can be described as multidimensional, time-dependent vectors. A simple neuron can encode a single component of the vector in a firing rate. The addition of a small subthreshold oscillatory current perturbs the action-potential timing, encoding the signal also in a timing relationship, with little effect on the coexisting firing rate representation. When the subthreshold signal is common to a group of neurons, the timing-based information is significant to neurons receiving inputs from the group. This information encoding allows simple implementation of computations not readily done with rate coding. These ideas are examined by using speech to provide a realistic input signal to a biologically inspired model network of spiking neurons. The output neurons of the two-layer system are shown to specifically encode short linguistic elements of speech.

Slow oscillation in non-lemniscal auditory thalamus

In the present study, we investigated the oscillatory behavior of the auditory thalamic neurons through in vivo intracellular and extracellular recordings in anesthetized guinea pigs. Repeated acoustic stimulus and cortical electrical stimulation were applied to examine their modulatory effects on the thalamic oscillation. The time course of the spike frequency over each trial was obtained by summing all spikes in the onset period and/or the last time period of 100 or 200 msec in the raster display. Spectral analysis was made on the time course of the spike frequency. A slow-frequency oscillation ranging from 0.03 to 0.25 Hz (mean +/- SD, 0.11 +/- 0.05 Hz) was found in the medial geniculate body (MGB) together with a second rhythm of 5-10 Hz. The oscillation neurons had a mean auditory response latency of 17.3 +/- 0.3 msec, which was significantly longer than that of the non-oscillation neurons in lemniscal MGB (9.0 +/- 1.5 msec, p < 0.001, ANOVA) and similar to the non-oscillation neurons in the non-lemniscal MGB (17.6 +/- 5.4 msec, p = 0.811). They were located in the non-lemniscal nuclei of the auditory thalamus. Cortical stimulation altered the thalamic oscillation, leading to termination of the oscillation or to acceleration of the rhythm of the oscillation (the average rhythm changed from 0.07 +/- 0.03 to 0.11 +/- 0.04 Hz, n = 8, p = 0.066, t test). Acoustic stimulation triggered a more regular rhythm in the oscillation neurons. The present results suggest that only the non-lemniscal auditory thalamus is involved in the slow thalamocortical oscillation. The auditory cortex may control the oscillation of the auditory thalamic neurons.

CS-specific gamma, theta, and alpha EEG activity detected in stimulus generalization following induction of behavioral memory by stimulation of the nucleus basalis

Tone paired with stimulation of the nucleus basalis (NB) induces behavioral memory that is specific to the frequency of the conditioned stimulus (CS), assessed by cardiac and respiration behavior during post-training stimulus generalization testing. This paper focuses on CS-specific spectral and temporal features of conditioned EEG activation. Adult male Sprague-Dawley rats, chronically implanted with a stimulating electrode in the NB and a recording electrode in the ipsilateral auditory cortex, received either tone (6kHz, 70dB, 2s) paired with co-terminating stimulation of the nucleus basalis (0.2s, 100Hz, 80-105 microA, ITI approximately 45s) or unpaired presentation of the stimuli (approximately 200 trials/day for approximately 14 days). CS-specificity was tested 24h post-training by presenting test tones to obtain generalization gradients for the EEG, heart rate, and respiration. Behavioral memory was evident in cardiac and respiratory responses that were maximal to the CS frequency of 6kHz. FFT analyses of tone-elicited changes of power in the delta, theta, alpha, beta1, beta2, and gamma bands in the paired group revealed that conditioned EEG activation (shift from lower to higher frequencies) was differentially spectrally and temporally specific: theta, and alpha to a lesser extent, decreased selectively to 6kHz during and for several seconds following tone presentation while gamma power increased transiently during and after 6kHz. Delta exhibited no CS-specificity and the beta bands showed transient specificity only after several seconds. The unpaired group exhibited neither CS-specific behavioral nor EEG effects. Thus, stimulus generalization tests reveal that conditioned EEG activation is not unitary but rather reflects CS-specificity, with band-selective markers for specific, associative neural processes in learning and memory.

Mechanisms of human attention: event-related potentials and oscillations

Electrophysiological and hemodynamical responses of the brain allow investigation of the neural origins of human attention. We review attention-related brain responses from auditory and visual tasks employing oddball and novelty paradigms. Dipole localization and intracranial recordings as well as functional magnetic resonance imaging reveal multiple areas involved in generating and modulating attentional brain responses. In addition, the influence of brain lesions of circumscribed areas of the human cortex onto attentional mechanisms are reviewed. While it is obvious that damaged brain tissue no longer functions properly, it has also been shown that functions of non-lesioned brain areas are impaired due to loss of modulatory influence of the lesioned area. Both early (P1 and N1) and late (P3) event-related potentials are modulated by excitatatory and inhibitory mechanisms. Oscillatory EEG-correlates of attention in the alpha and gamma frequency range also show attentional modulation.

Cellular mechanisms of thalamically evoked gamma oscillations in auditory cortex

The purpose of this study was to clarify the neurogenesis of thalamically evoked gamma frequency (approximately 40 Hz) oscillations in auditory cortex by comparing simultaneously recorded extracellular and intracellular responses elicited with electrical stimulation of the posterior intralaminar nucleus of the thalamus (PIL). The focus of evoked gamma activity was located between primary and secondary auditory cortex using a 64-channel epipial electrode array, and all subsequent intracellular recordings and single-electrode field potential recordings were made at this location. These data indicate that PIL stimulation evokes gamma oscillations in auditory cortex by tonically depolarizing pyramidal cells in the supra- and infragranular layers. No cells revealed endogenous membrane properties capable of producing activity in the gamma frequency band when depolarized individually with injected current, but all displayed both sub- and supra-threshold responses time-locked to extracellular fast oscillations when the population was depolarized by PIL stimulation. We propose that cortical gamma oscillations may be produced and propagated intracortically by network interactions among large groups of neurons when mutually excited by modulatory input from the intralaminar thalamus and that these oscillations do not require specialized pacemaker cells for their neurogenesis.

Cortical coordination dynamics and cognition

New imaging techniques in cognitive neuroscience have produced a deluge of information correlating cognitive and neural phenomena. Yet our understanding of the inter-relationship between brain and mind remains hampered by the lack of a theoretical language for expressing cognitive functions in neural terms. We propose an approach to understanding operational laws in cognition based on principles of coordination dynamics that are derived from a simple and experimentally verified theoretical model. When applied to the dynamical properties of cortical areas and their coordination, these principles support a mechanism of adaptive inter-area pattern constraint that we postulate underlies cognitive operations generally.

Tone-evoked oscillations in the rat auditory cortex result from interactions between the thalamus and reticular nucleus

This study investigates the origins of tone-evoked oscillations (5-13 Hz) in the thalamo-cortical auditory system of anaesthetized rats. In three separate experiments, the auditory sector of the reticular nucleus (RE), the auditory cortex and the auditory thalamus were inactivated by local applications of muscimol (1 mg/mL). To assess the efficacy of this procedure, recordings were performed in the inactivated structure in each experiment; and to determine the extent of the drug diffusion autoradiographic experiments were carried out. The evolution of the strength of the oscillations was followed using power spectra during the whole recording session. In the first experiment, muscimol injection in the auditory RE totally suppressed the tone-evoked oscillations in the auditory thalamus and cortex. In the second experiment, inactivation of the auditory cortex did not interfere with the presence of tone-evoked oscillations in the auditory RE. In the third experiment, inactivation of the auditory thalamus impaired the oscillations produced by cortical stimulation in the auditory RE. From these results, it appears that both the auditory thalamus and the auditory sector of the RE, but not the auditory cortex, are involved in the generation of stimulus-evoked oscillations in the thalamo-cortical auditory system.

Stimulus-specific oscillatory responses of the brain: a time/frequency-related coding process

OBJECTIVES

To review the coherent, rhythmic oscillations above approximately 20 Hz that occur in response to sensory inputs in the firing rate and membrane or local field potentials of distributed neuron aggregates of CNS layered structures.

RESULTS

Oscillatory activity at approximately 20-80 Hz occurs in response to either olfactory, auditory and visual (contrast) stimuli; oscillations at frequencies centered on 100-120 Hz or 600 Hz are recorded, respectively, from the visual system (luminance stimulation) and from the somatosensory cortex. Experimental evidence suggests sources/mechanisms of generation that depend on inhibitory interneurons and pyramidal cells and are partially independent from those of conventional (broadband) evoked responses. In the olfactory and visual systems, the oscillatory responses reflect the global stimulus properties. A time/phase correlation between firing rate, spiking coincidence and oscillatory field responses has been documented. The oscillatory responses are postsynaptic both in cortex and in precortical structures (e.g. retina; LGN). Evidence indicates intracortical and thalamocortical interacting mechanisms of regulation as well as GABAergic and cholinergic modulation. In the visual cortex the oscillatory responses are driven by oscillations in the synaptic input. Oscillatory potentials are dependent on resonance phenomena and produce narrow-band synchronization of activated neurons. They may have a role in the 'binding' of separate neuronal aggregates into sensory units.

CONCLUSIONS

Oscillatory responses contribute as a time/frequency coding mechanism to pacing neurons selectively for the physical properties of stimulus and are involved in sensory information processing.

Characteristics of reliable tone-evoked oscillations in the rat thalamo-cortical auditory system

Tone-evoked oscillations were studied from simultaneous recordings collected in the auditory cortex, auditory thalamus and auditory sector of the reticular nucleus in urethane anesthetized rats. These oscillations were precisely time-locked to tone onset and were easily observed on peristimulus time histograms (PSTHs). Visual inspection of PSTHs and rasters led us to distinguish between 'reliable' oscillations (which exhibited oscillatory patterns in more than 50% of the trials) and 'labile' oscillations (which exhibited oscillations in less than 50% of the trials). Systematic quantification of oscillations based on several indices derived from power spectra confirmed this distinction. 'Reliable' stimulus-locked oscillations were observed in 51/184 (28%) of the recordings from auditory cortex, 9/55 (17%) of the recordings from auditory thalamus and 11/26 (42%) of the recordings from the auditory sector of the reticular nucleus. The frequency range of these oscillations was the same in the three structures (5-14 Hz). Within the same animal, when one electrode exhibited oscillations, there was a high probability of detecting similar oscillations from electrodes located in the same structure, but not from electrodes located in the other structures. These oscillations were observed for pure tone frequency (or for clicks) whatever the tone duration (1 s, 100 ms, 10 ms). The inter-tone interval (ITI) was found to be the critical factor controlling the occurrence of these oscillations: they were present for ITIs of 2 s or longer, but were absent for ITIs of 1 s or less. In contrast, the occurrence of the oscillations was a function neither of the strength of the 'on' evoked response nor of the animal's temperature. However, lowering the animal's temperature from 37-38 degrees C to 35-36 degrees C systematically led to a decrease in the frequency and an increase in the duration of the tone-evoked oscillations. These results suggest that, even in well defined conditions (temperature, EEG, ITI, level of anesthesia), the oscillations triggered by presentation of the same stimulus can be stable or unstable. This temporal instability of stimulus-evoked oscillations has to be taken into account before stating percentages of oscillations in a given brain structure. They also suggest that some general factors such as the animals temperature or the inter-stimulus interval can considerably affect their characteristics and/or their occurrence.

Electrocorticographic coherence patterns

The availability of implantable subdural electrode arrays has made systematic studies of electrocorticographic (ECoG) coherence possible. Studies of coherence patterns recorded directly from human cortex are reviewed along with the presentation of original human clinical data, which reveal reliable and characteristic patterns of coherence. A data-driven technique for discriminating between reliable and unreliable coherence and phase values is described and used to reveal the relationship between coherence and cortical anatomy, such as in the region of the central sulcus, where low phase coherence declines and high phase-shifted coherence increases. Analysis of coherence magnitude and phase makes it possible to determine which signals likely arise from the cortical surface, and which arise from the depths of a sulcus. Alterations in coherence patterns caused by tumors or epilepsy are described and may be used to identify normal and pathological functional relationships between distant cortical areas. Some electrophysiologic/pathologic correlations indicate at least two types of epileptic abnormality, implying a sequence in breakdown of epileptic tissue. The relationship between coherence patterns and behavior and cognition is introduced and compared to similar studies of single-unit binding in animals.

Three-dimensional analysis of spontaneous and thalamically evoked gamma oscillations in auditory cortex

The purpose of this study was to investigate interactions among laminar cell populations producing spontaneous and evoked high-frequency (approximately 40 Hz) gamma oscillations in auditory cortex. Electrocortical oscillations were recorded using a 64-channel epipial electrode array and a 16-channel linear laminar electrode array while electrical stimulation was delivered to the posterior intralaminar (PIL) nucleus. Spontaneous gamma oscillations, and those evoked by PIL stimulation, are confined to a location overlapping primary and secondary auditory cortex. Current source-density and principal components analysis of laminar recordings at this site indicate that the auditory evoked potential (AEP) complex is characterized by a stereotyped asynchronous activation of supra- and infragranular cell populations. Similar analysis of spontaneous and evoked gamma waves reveals a close spatiotemporal similarity to the laminar AEP, indicating rhythmic interactions between supra- and infragranular cell groups during these oscillatory phenomena. We conclude that neural circuit interactions producing the laminar AEP onset in auditory cortex are the same as those generating evoked and spontaneous gamma oscillations.