Embryogenesis of transposition of the great arteries: a lesson from the heart

Development of the human heart

In 2014, an extensive review discussing the major steps of cardiac development focusing on growth, formation of primary and chamber myocardium and the development of the cardiac electrical system, was published. Molecular genetic lineage analyses have since furthered our insight in the developmental origin of the various component parts of the heart, which currently can be unambiguously identified by their unique molecular phenotype. Moreover, genetic, molecular and cell biological analyses have driven insights into the mechanisms underlying the development of the different cardiac components. Here, we build on our previous review and provide an insight into the molecular mechanistic revelations that have forwarded the field of cardiac development. Despite the enormous advances in our knowledge over the last decade, the development of congenital cardiac malformations remains poorly understood. The challenge for the next decade will be to evaluate the different developmental processes using newly developed molecular genetic techniques to further unveil the gene regulatory networks operational during normal and abnormal cardiac development.

Deficiency of the Wnt receptor Ryk causes multiple cardiac and outflow tract defects

Ryk is a member of the receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK) family of proteins that control and regulate cellular processes. It is distinguished by binding Wnt ligands and having no detectable intrinsic protein tyrosine kinase activity suggesting Ryk is a pseudokinase. Here, we show an essential role for Ryk in directing morphogenetic events required for normal cardiac development through the examination of Ryk-deficient mice. We employed vascular corrosion casting, vascular perfusion with contrast dye, and immunohistochemistry to characterize cardiovascular and pharyngeal defects in Ryk^-/- embryos. Ryk^-/- mice exhibit a variety of malformations of the heart and outflow tract that resemble human congenital heart defects. This included stenosis and interruption of the aortic arch, ventriculoarterial malalignment, ventricular septal defects and abnormal pharyngeal arch artery remodelling. This study therefore defines a key intersection between a subset of growth factor receptors involved in planar cell polarity signalling, the Wnt family and mammalian cardiovascular development.

Impaired development of left anterior heart field by ectopic retinoic acid causes transposition of the great arteries

Background

Transposition of the great arteries is one of the most commonly diagnosed conotruncal heart defects at birth, but its etiology is largely unknown. The anterior heart field (AHF) that resides in the anterior pharyngeal arches contributes to conotruncal development, during which heart progenitors that originated from the left and right AHF migrate to form distinct conotruncal regions. The aim of this study is to identify abnormal AHF development that causes the morphology of transposition of the great arteries.

Methods and Results

We placed a retinoic acid–soaked bead on the left or the right or on both sides of the AHF of stage 12 to 14 chick embryos and examined the conotruncal heart defect at stage 34. Transposition of the great arteries was diagnosed at high incidence in embryos for which a retinoic acid–soaked bead had been placed in the left AHF at stage 12. Fluorescent dye tracing showed that AHF exposed to retinoic acid failed to contribute to conotruncus development. FGF8 and Isl1 expression were downregulated in retinoic acid–exposed AHF, and differentiation and expansion of cardiomyocytes were suppressed in cultured AHF in medium supplemented with retinoic acid.

Conclusions

The left AHF at the early looped heart stage, corresponding to Carnegie stages 10 to 11 (28 to 29 days after fertilization) in human embryos, is the region of the impediment that causes the morphology of transposition of the great arteries.

The trabecula septomarginalis (Leonardo's cord) in abnormal ventriculo-arterial connections: anatomic and morphogenetic implications

Background

The abnormal ventriculo-arterial connections in atrio-ventricular concordance and situs solitus with two well developed ventricles include the range from tetralogy of Fallot throughout the different forms of double outlet right ventricle to transposition of great arteries.

The infundibular septum and the trabecula septomarginalis are the fundamental anatomical landmarks for the segmental analysis.

In these abnormalities there is a pathological progressive counter-clockwise rotation of the infundibular septum which divorces from the antero-superior limb of the trabecula septomarginalis and achieves his identity. Is there any anatomical evidence of a simultaneous abnormal counter-clockwise rotation of the trabecula septomarginalis?

Methods

Malposition of great arteries is a generic term since all relationships have to be expected.

We present specimens with anatomical evidence of a progressive counter-clockwise rotation from 0° to about 180°of the plane passing throughout the trabecula septomarginalis’s limbs.

Results

We can observe sequentially:

1. Malformations in which the posterior limb of the trabecula septomarginalis is committed to the ventriculo infundibular fold: (tetralogy of Fallot, double outlet right ventricle with sub-aortic ventricular septal defect, truncus arteriosus and doubly committed ventricular septal defect);

2. Malformations in which the posterior limb of the trabecula septomarginalis is committed to the infundibular septum (double outlet right ventricle with sub-pulmonary ventricular septal defect, transposition of great arteries).

Conclusions

1. The sequential-segmental analysis identify all the morphologies.

2. The trabecula septomarginalis plane presents a progressive counter-clockwise twist on the long axis.

3. Since the trabeculated portions of the ventricles are the oldest developmental components, our observations support the hypothesis that the abnormal ventriculo-arterial connections could be in relation with a pathological myocardial process during early cardio-genesis.

We are promoting new studies to investigate our anatomical observations.

Role of connexins in human congenital heart disease: the chicken and egg problem

Inborn cardiac diseases are among the most frequent congenital anomalies and are the main cause of death in infants within the first year of age in industrialized countries when not adequately treated. They can be divided into simple and complex cardiac malformations. The former ones, for instance atrial and ventricular septal defects, valvular or subvalvular stenosis or insufficiency account for up to 80% of cardiac abnormalities. The latter ones, for example transposition of the great vessels, Tetralogy of Fallot or Shone’s anomaly often do not involve only the heart, but also the great vessels and although occurring less frequently, these severe cardiac malformations will become symptomatic within the first months of age and have a high risk of mortality if the patients remain untreated. In the last decade, there is increasing evidence that cardiac gap junction proteins, the connexins (Cx), might have an impact on cardiac anomalies. In the heart, mainly three of them (Cx40, Cx43, and Cx45) are differentially expressed with regard to temporal organogenesis and to their spatial distribution in the heart. These proteins, forming gap junction channels, are most important for a normal electrical conduction and coordinated synchronous heart muscle contraction and also for the normal embryonic development of the heart. Animal and also some human studies revealed that at least in some cardiac malformations alterations in certain gap junction proteins are present but until today no particular gap junction mutation could be assigned to a specific cardiac anomaly. As gap junctions have often been supposed to transmit growth and differentiation signals from cell to cell it is reasonable to assume that they are somehow involved in misdirected growth present in many inborn heart diseases playing a primary or contributory role. This review addresses the potentional role of gap junctions in the development of inborn heart anomalies like the conotruncal heart defects.

Potential implications of the helical heart in congenital heart defects

The anatomic and functional observations made by Francisco Torrent-Guasp, in particular his discovery of the helical ventricular myocardial band (HVMB), have challenged what has been taught to cardiologists and cardiac surgeons over centuries. A literature debate is ongoing, with interdependent articles and comments from supporters and critics. Adequate understanding of heart structure and function is obviously indispensable for the decision-making process in congenital heart defects. The HVMB described by Torrent-Guasp and the potential impact on the understanding and treatment of congenital heart defects has been analyzed in the following settings: embryology, ventriculo-arterial discordance (transposition of great arteries), Ebstein's anomaly, pulmonary valve regurgitation after repair of tetralogy of Fallot, Ross operation, and other congenital heart defects. The common structural spiral feature is only one of the elements responsible for the functional interaction of right and left ventricles, and understanding the form/function relationship in congenital heart defects is more difficult than for acquired heart disease because of the variety and complexity of congenital heart defects. Individuals involved in the care of patients with congenital heart defects have to be stimulated to consider further investigations and alternative surgical strategies.

A multiple retinoic acid antagonist induces conotruncal anomalies, including transposition of the great arteries, in mice

BACKGROUND

The morphogenetic mechanisms that are responsible for the transposition of the great arteries are still largely unknown, mainly because this malformation is very difficult to experimentally reproduce. The aim of the present study was to test the effect of BMS-189453, a retinoic acid antagonist, on murine heart morphogenesis.

METHODS

We administered this drug at 5 mg/kg body weight (twice, at a 12-h interval) to pregnant mice on 6.25/6.75 days postcoitum (dpc) (Group A), 6.75/7.25 dpc (Group B), 7.25/7.75 dpc (Group C), 7.75/8.25 dpc (Group D), or 8.25/8.75 dpc (Group E). At birth, the anatomical features of fetuses were evaluated by stereomicroscopic examination.

RESULTS

In Group A (18 fetuses), cardiovascular anatomy was normal in 10 (56%) cases, and 8 (44%) fetuses presented with transposition of the great arteries. In Group B, no fetuses were obtained. In Group C (78 fetuses), cardiovascular anatomy was normal in 19 (24%) cases, while 59 (76%) mice presented with various types of cardiac defects, including 48 transpositions of the great arteries (61%). In Group D (80 fetuses), cardiac defects were seen in 22 (27%) mice: 14 of these (17%) were transpositions of the great arteries. In Group E (72 fetuses), cardiovascular anatomy was normal in all cases. Of 248 fetuses analyzed, 87% presented with thymic aplasia or hypoplasia, and 20% presented with meroanencephalia and/or rachischisis.

CONCLUSIONS

Transposition of the great arteries can be consistently reproduced in mice by administration of a retinoic acid competitive antagonist on 7.5 dpc.

Development Gone Awry

Significant advances in the understanding of the molecular and genetic basis of congenital heart disease have emerged from gene inactivation studies in mice and from human genetic investigations. However, the ability to utilize information gleaned from animal models to inform clinical care of patients depends on an accurate anatomic analysis and presentation in terms that are meaningful to the clinical pediatric cardiologist. Likewise, the enormous depth and breadth of accumulated clinical experience can inform the developmental biologist and can highlight the importance and interrelationships of particular phenotypes. The explosion of potentially informative genetic tools demands that basic scientists and clinicians concerned with congenital cardiac disease enhance the ongoing bidirectional dialogue. In some cases, categories of congenital disease familiar to clinicians are not recognized by developmental biologists, and mechanisms accepted by the biologist seem inconsistent with clinical experience. In this review, we summarize some of the more clinically significant forms of congenital heart disease, and we highlight relevant genetic and developmental pathways.

Septation and separation within the outflow tract of the developing heart

The developmental anatomy of the ventricular outlets and intrapericardial arterial trunks is a source of considerable confusion. First, major problems exist because of the multiple names and definitions used to describe this region of the heart as it develops. Second, there is no agreement on the boundaries of the described components, nor on the number of ridges or cushions to be found dividing the outflow tract, and the pattern of their fusion. Evidence is also lacking concerning the role of the fused cushions relative to that of the so-called aortopulmonary septum in separating the intrapericardial components of the great arterial trunks. In this review, we discuss the existing problems, as we see them, in the context of developmental and postnatal morphology. We concentrate, in particular, on the changes in the nature of the wall of the outflow tract, which is initially myocardial throughout its length. Key features that, thus far, do not seem to have received appropriate attention are the origin, and mode of separation, of the intrapericardial portions of the arterial trunks, and the formation of the walls of the aortic and pulmonary valvar sinuses. Also as yet undetermined is the formation of the free-standing muscular subpulmonary infundibulum, the mechanism of its separation from the aortic valvar sinuses, and its differentiation, if any, from the muscular ventricular outlet septum.

Early events in valvulogenesis: a signaling perspective

The proper formation and function of the vertebrate heart requires a multitude of specific cell and tissue interactions. These interactions drive the early specification and assembly of components of the cardiovascular system that lead to a functioning system before the attainment of the definitive cardiac and vascular structures seen in the adult. Many of these adult structures are hypothesized to require both proper molecular and physical cues to form correctly. Unlike any other organ system in the embryo, the cardiovascular system requires concurrent function and formation for the embryo to survive. An example of this complex interaction between molecular and physical cues is the formation of the valves of the heart. Both molecular cues that regulate cell transformation, migration, and extracellular matrix deposition, and physical cues emanating from the beating heart, as well as hemodynamic forces, are required for valvulogenesis. This review will focus on molecules and emerging pathways that guide early events in valvulogenesis.