Genetic or Other Causation Should Not Change the Clinical Diagnosis of Cerebral Palsy

Potential clinical applications of advanced genomic analysis in cerebral palsy

Cerebral palsy (CP) has historically been attributed to acquired insults, but emerging research suggests that genetic variations are also important causes of CP. While microarray and whole-exome sequencing based studies have been the primary methods for establishing new CP-gene relationships and providing a genetic etiology for individual patients, the cause of their condition remains unknown for many patients with CP. Recent advancements in genomic technologies offer additional opportunities to uncover variations in human genomes, transcriptomes, and epigenomes that have previously escaped detection. In this review, we outline the use of these state-of-the-art technologies to address the molecular diagnostic challenges experienced by individuals with CP. We also explore the importance of identifying a molecular etiology whenever possible, given the potential for genomic medicine to provide opportunities to treat patients with CP in new and more precise ways.

Supported standing and stepping device use in young children with cerebral palsy, gross motor function classification system III, IV and V: A descriptive study

This study described and compared use of supported-standing and stepping devices by young children with cerebral palsy, Gross-Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) levels III-V following power mobility introduction. Data was collected at two time-points, 5-6 months apart, for 42 participants, aged 18-80 months, using the Home Use of Technology for CHildren (HUTCH). Supported-standing and stepping device choice and time in each device remained stable over 6 months. Associations between device use and three functional classifications were examined. Children with more impaired motor, postural and manual abilities were more likely to use a supine stander rather than a prone/upright stander or no stander. Children at GMFCS V tended to use hands-free stepping devices, while support-arms stepping devices were more common for children at GMFCS IV. Only children at GMFCS III used convertible stepping devices. Using power mobility, standers and supported-stepping devices was feasible and 19/34 classified at GMFCS IV/V used all three devices over 6 months. A key finding was that introduction of power mobility did not reduce use of supported-stepping devices at any GMFCS level. Use of multiple upright positioning and mobility devices may assist children with limited mobility to be actively engaged and participate in daily life.

Cerebral Palsy Phenotypes in Genetic Epilepsies

BACKGROUND

Although there are established connections between genetic epilepsies and neurodevelopmental disorders like intellectual disability, the presence of cerebral palsy (CP) in genetic epilepsies is undercharacterized. We performed a retrospective chart review evaluating the motor phenotype of patients with genetic epilepsies.

METHODS

Patients were ascertained through a research exome sequencing study to identify genetic causes of epilepsy. We analyzed data from the first 100 individuals with molecular diagnoses. We determined motor phenotype by reviewing medical records for muscle tone and motor function data. We characterized patients according to CP subtypes: spastic diplegic, spastic quadriplegic, spastic hemiplegic, dyskinetic, hypotonic-ataxic.

RESULTS

Of 100 individuals with genetic epilepsies, 14% had evidence of possible CP, including 5% characterized as hypotonic-ataxic CP, 5% spastic quadriplegic CP, 3% spastic diplegic CP, and 1% hemiplegic CP. Presence of CP did not correlate with seizure onset age (P = 0.63) or seizure control (P = 0.07). CP occurred in 11% (n = 3 of 27) with focal epilepsy, 9% (n = 5 of 54) with generalized epilepsy, and 32% (n = 6 of 19) with combined focal/generalized epilepsy (P = 0.06).

CONCLUSIONS

In this retrospective analysis of patients with genetic epilepsies, we identified a substantial portion with CP phenotypes, representing an under-recognized comorbidity. These findings underscore the many neurodevelopmental features associated with neurogenetic conditions, regardless of the feature for which they were ascertained for sequencing. Detailed motor phenotyping is needed to determine the prevalence of CP and its subtypes among genetic epilepsies. These motor phenotypes require clinical management and represent important targeted outcomes in trials for patients with genetic epilepsies.

Etiology and Ontogeny of Cerebral Palsy: Implications for Practice and Research

Cerebral palsy (CP) has been recognized as a group of neurologic disorders with varying etiologies and ontogenies. While a percentage of CP cases arises during labor, the expanded use of electronic fetal monitoring (EFM) to include prevention of CP has resulted in decades of vastly increased interventions that have not significantly reduced the incidence of CP for infants born at term in the USA. Litigation alleging that poor obstetrical practice caused CP in most of these affected children has led to contentious arguments regarding the actual etiologies of this condition and often resulted in substantial monetary awards for plaintiffs. Recent advances in genetic testing using whole exome sequencing have revealed that at least one-third of CP cases in term infants are genetic in origin and therefore not labor-related. Here, we will present and discuss previous attempts to sort out contributing etiologies and ontogenies of CP, and how these newer diagnostic techniques are rapidly improving our ability to better detect and understand such cases. In light of these developments, we present our vision for an overarching spectrum for proper categorization of CP cases into that the following groups: (1) those begun at conception from genetic causes (nonpreventable); (2) those stemming from adverse antenatal/pre-labor events (possibly preventable with heightened antepartum assessment); (3) Those arising from intrapartum events (potentially preventable by earlier interventions); (4) Those occurring shortly after birth (possibly preventable with closer neonatal monitoring); (5) Those that appear later in the postnatal period from non-labor-related causes such as untreated infections or postnatal intracranial hemorrhages.

Histological chorioamnionitis and pathological stages on very preterm infant outcomes

AIMS

Histological chorioamnionitis (HCA) is a condition linked to preterm birth and neonatal infection and its relationship with various pathological stages in extremely preterm neonates, and with their associated short- and long-term consequences, remains a subject of research. This study investigated the connection between different pathological stages of HCA and both short-term complications and long-term outcomes in preterm infants born at or before 32 weeks of gestational age.

METHODS

Preterm infants born at ≤ 32 weeks of gestation who underwent placental pathology evaluation and were followed-up at 18-24 months of corrected age were included. Neonates were classified based on their exposure to HCA and were further subdivided into different groups according to maternal inflammatory responses (MIR) and fetal inflammatory responses (FIR) stages. We compared short-term complications during their hospital stay between the HCA-exposed and -unexposed groups and examined the influence of HCA stages on long-term outcomes.

RESULTS

The HCA group exhibited distinct characteristics such as higher rates of premature rupture of membranes > 18 h, reduced amniotic fluid, early-onset sepsis, bronchopulmonary dysplasia and intraventricular haemorrhage (IVH) grades III-IV (P < 0.05). The moderate-severe HCA group displayed lower gestational age, lower birth weight and higher incidence of IVH (grades III-IV) and preterm sepsis compared with the mild HCA group (P < 0.05). After adjusting for confounders, the MIR stages 2-3 group showed associations with cognitive impairment and cerebral palsy (P < 0.05), and the FIR stages 2-3 group also showed poor long-term outcomes and cognitive impairment (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Moderate-severe HCA was associated with increased early-onset sepsis, severe IVH and poor long-term outcomes, including cognitive impairment and cerebral palsy. Vigilant prevention strategies are warranted for severe HCA cases in order to mitigate poorer clinical outcomes.

Clinical Characteristics Suggestive of a Genetic Cause in Cerebral Palsy: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a clinical diagnosis and was long categorized as an acquired disorder, but more and more genetic etiologies are being identified. This review aims to identify the clinical characteristics that are associated with genetic CP to aid clinicians in selecting candidates for genetic testing.

METHODS

The PubMed database was systematically searched to identify genes associated with CP. The clinical characteristics accompanying these genetic forms of CP were compared with published data of large CP populations resulting in the identification of potential indicators of genetic CP.

RESULLTS

Of 1930 articles retrieved, 134 were included. In these, 55 CP genes (described in two or more cases, n = 272) and 79 candidate genes (described in only one case) were reported. The most frequently CP-associated genes were PLP1 (21 cases), ARG1 (17 cases), and CTNNB1 (13 cases). Dyskinesia and the absence of spasticity were identified as strong potential indicators of genetic CP. Presence of intellectual disability, no preterm birth, and no unilateral distribution of symptoms were classified as moderate genetic indicators.

CONCLUSIONS

Genetic causes of CP are increasingly identified. The clinical characteristics associated with genetic CP can aid clinicians regarding to which individual with CP to offer genetic testing. The identified potential genetic indicators need to be validated in large CP cohorts but can provide the first step toward a diagnostic algorithm for genetic CP.

Comprehensive whole-genome sequence analyses provide insights into the genomic architecture of cerebral palsy

We performed whole-genome sequencing (WGS) in 327 children with cerebral palsy (CP) and their biological parents. We classified 37 of 327 (11.3%) children as having pathogenic/likely pathogenic (P/LP) variants and 58 of 327 (17.7%) as having variants of uncertain significance. Multiple classes of P/LP variants included single-nucleotide variants (SNVs)/indels (6.7%), copy number variations (3.4%) and mitochondrial mutations (1.5%). The COL4A1 gene had the most P/LP SNVs. We also analyzed two pediatric control cohorts (n = 203 trios and n = 89 sib-pair families) to provide a baseline for de novo mutation rates and genetic burden analyses, the latter of which demonstrated associations between de novo deleterious variants and genes related to the nervous system. An enrichment analysis revealed previously undescribed plausible candidate CP genes (SMOC1, KDM5B, BCL11A and CYP51A1). A multifactorial CP risk profile and substantial presence of P/LP variants combine to support WGS in the diagnostic work-up across all CP and related phenotypes.

A comparison of cohorts of children with cerebral palsy from a population register and hospital admission data: A data linkage study

BACKGROUND

Administrative health data, such as hospital admission data, are often used in research to identify children/young people with cerebral palsy (CP).

OBJECTIVES

To compare sociodemographic, clinical details and mortality of children/young people identified as having CP in either a CP population registry or hospital admission data.

METHODS

We identified two cohorts of children/young people (birth years 2001-2010, age at study end or death 2 months to 19 years 6 months) with a diagnosis of CP from either (i) the New South Wales (NSW)/Australian Capital Territory (ACT) CP Register or (ii) NSW hospital admission data (2001-2020). Using record linkage, these data sources were linked to each other and NSW Death, Perinatal, and Disability datasets. We determined the sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV) of CP diagnosis in hospital admission data compared with the NSW/ACT CP Register (gold standard). We then compared the sociodemographic and clinical characteristics and mortality of the two cohorts available through record linkage using standardised mean difference (SMD).

RESULTS

There were 1598 children/young people with CP in the NSW/ACT CP Register and 732-2439 children/young people with CP in hospital admission data, depending on the case definition used. The sensitivity of hospital admission data for diagnosis of CP ranged from 0.40-0.74 and PPV 0.47-0.73. Compared with children/young people with CP identified in the NSW/ACT CP Register, a greater proportion of those identified in hospital admission data (one or more admissions with G80 case definition) were older, lived in major cities, had comorbidities including epilepsy, gastrostomy use, intellectual disability and autism, and died during the study period (SMD > 0.1).

CONCLUSIONS

Sociodemographic and clinical characteristics differ between cohorts of children/young people with CP identified using a CP register or hospital admission data. Those identified in hospital admission data have higher rates of comorbidities and death, suggesting some may have progressive conditions and not CP. These differences should be considered when planning and interpreting research using various data sources.

Redefining cerebral palsies as a diverse group of neurodevelopmental disorders with genetic aetiology

Cerebral palsy is a clinical descriptor covering a diverse group of permanent, non-degenerative disorders of motor function. Around one-third of cases have now been shown to have an underlying genetic aetiology, with the genetic landscape overlapping with those of neurodevelopmental disorders including intellectual disability, epilepsy, speech and language disorders and autism. Here we review the current state of genomic testing in cerebral palsy, highlighting the benefits for personalized medicine and the imperative to consider aetiology during clinical diagnosis. With earlier clinical diagnosis now possible, we emphasize the opportunity for comprehensive and early genomic testing as a crucial component of the routine diagnostic work-up in people with cerebral palsy.

Prevalence of cerebral palsy and factors associated with cerebral palsy subtype: A population-based study in Belgium

AIM

To report on the prevalence, neuroimaging patterns, and function of children with cerebral palsy (CP) in Belgium for birth years 2007-2012, and identify distinctive risk indicators and differences in outcome between CP subtypes.

METHODS

Antenatal and perinatal/neonatal factors, motor and speech function, associated impairments, and neuroimaging patterns were extracted from the Belgian Cerebral Palsy Register. Prevalence was estimated per 1000 (overall, ante/perinatal, spastic, dyskinetic CP) or 10,000 (post-neonatal, ataxic CP) live births. Multinomial logistic regression analyses were performed to ascertain the effects of antenatal/perinatal/neonatal factors and neuroimaging patterns on the likelihood of dyskinetic or ataxic CP relative to spastic CP, and test the likelihood of the occurrence of impaired motor and speech function and associated impairments in dyskinetic or ataxic CP relative to spastic CP.

RESULTS

In total, 1127 children with CP were identified in Belgium. The birth prevalence of overall CP was 1.48 per 1000 live births. The likelihood of dyskinetic CP increases if the child was born to a mother aged ≥35 years, mechanically ventilated, and had predominant grey matter injury, while an increased likelihood of ataxic CP is associated with ≥2 previous deliveries. Children with dyskinetic and ataxic CP are more likely to function with impairments in motor, speech, and intellectual abilities.

CONCLUSION

Distinctive risk indicators and differences in outcome between CP subtypes were identified. These factors can be incorporated into clinical practice to facilitate early, accurate, and reliable classification of CP subtype, and may lead to individually tailored neonatal care and other (early) intervention options.

Uncertainties regarding cerebral palsy diagnosis: opportunities to operationalize the consensus definition

Background and Objectives

Cerebral palsy (CP), the most common motor disability of childhood, is variably diagnosed. We hypothesized that child neurologists and neurodevelopmentalists, often on the frontlines of CP diagnosis in North America, harbor uncertainties regarding the practical application of the most recent CP consensus definition from 2006.

Methods

We conducted a cross-sectional survey of child neurologists and neurodevelopmentalists at the 2022 Child Neurology Society Annual Meeting. Attendees were provided the 2006 CP consensus definition and asked whether they had any uncertainties about the practical application of the definition across four hypothetical clinical vignettes.

Results

Of 230 attendees, 164 responded to the closing survey questions (71%). 145/164 (88%) expressed at least one uncertainty regarding the clinical application of the 2006 definition. Overwhelmingly, these areas of uncertainty focused on: 1) Age, both with regards to the minimum age of diagnosis and the maximum age of brain disturbance or motor symptom onset, (67/164, 41%), and 2) Interpretation of the term "non-progressive" (48/164, 29%). The vast majority of respondents (157/164, 96%) answered 'Yes' to the question: Do you think we should revise the 2006 consensus definition of CP?

Discussion

We propose that the uncertainties we identified could be addressed by operationalizing the 2006 consensus definition to support a more uniform CP diagnosis. To address the most common CP diagnostic uncertainties we identified, we propose 3 points of clarification based on the available literature: 1) Motor symptoms/signs should be present by 2 years old; 2) CP can and should be diagnosed as early as possible, even if activity limitation is not yet present, if motor symptoms/signs can be reasonably predicted to yield activity limitation (e.g. by using standardized examination instruments, Brain MRI, and a suggestive clinical history); and 3) The clinical motor disability phenotype should be non-progressive through 5 years old. We anticipate that operationalizing the 2006 definition of CP in this manner could clarify the uncertainties we identified among child neurologists and neurodevelopmentalists and reduce the diagnostic variability that currently exists.

Delineating clinical and developmental outcomes in STXBP1-related disorders

STXBP1-related disorders are among the most common genetic epilepsies and neurodevelopmental disorders. However, the longitudinal epilepsy course and developmental endpoints have not yet been described in detail, which is a critical prerequisite for clinical trial readiness. Here, we assessed 1,281 cumulative patient-years of seizure and developmental histories in 162 individuals with STXBP1-related disorders and established a natural history framework. STXBP1-related disorders are characterized by a dynamic pattern of seizures in the first year of life and high variability in neurodevelopmental trajectories in early childhood. Epilepsy onset differed across seizure types, with 90% cumulative onset for infantile spasms by 6 months and focal-onset seizures by 27 months of life. Epilepsy histories diverged between variant subgroups in the first 2 years of life, when individuals with protein-truncating variants and deletions in STXBP1 (n=39) were more likely to have infantile spasms between 5 and 6 months followed by seizure remission, while individuals with missense variants (n=30) had an increased risk for focal seizures and ongoing seizures after the first year. Developmental outcomes were mapped using milestone acquisition data in addition to standardized assessments including the Gross Motor Function Measure-66 Item Set and the Grasping and Visual-Motor Integration subsets of the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales. Quantification of endpoints revealed high variability during the first five years of life, with emerging stratification between clinical subgroups, most prominently between individuals with and without infantile spasms. We found that individuals with neonatal seizures or early infantile seizures followed by seizure offset by 12 months of life had more predictable seizure trajectories in early to late childhood than compared to individuals with more severe seizure presentations, including individuals with refractory epilepsy throughout the first year. Characterization of anti-seizure medication response revealed age-dependent response over time, with phenobarbital, levetiracetam, topiramate, and adrenocorticotropic hormone effective in reducing seizures in the first year of life, while clobazam and the ketogenic diet were effective in long-term seizure management. Virtual clinical trials using seizure frequency as the primary outcome resulted in wide range of trial success probabilities across the age span, with the highest probability in early childhood between 1 year and 3.5 years. In summary, we delineated epilepsy and developmental trajectories in STXBP1-related disorders using standardized measures, providing a foundation to interpret future therapeutic strategies and inform rational trial design.

Epilepsy syndromes in cerebral palsy: varied, evolving and mostly self-limited

Seizures occur in approximately one-third of children with cerebral palsy. This study aimed to determine epilepsy syndromes in children with seizures and cerebral palsy due to vascular injury, anticipating that this would inform treatment and prognosis. We studied a population-based cohort of children with cerebral palsy due to prenatal or perinatal vascular injuries, born 1999-2006. Each child's MRI was reviewed to characterize patterns of grey and white matter injury. Children with syndromic or likely genetic causes of cerebral palsy were excluded, given their inherent association with epilepsy and our aim to study a homogeneous cohort of classical cerebral palsy. Chart review, parent interview and EEGs were used to determine epilepsy syndromes and seizure outcomes. Of 256 children, 93 (36%) had one or more febrile or afebrile seizures beyond the neonatal period and 87 (34%) had epilepsy. Children with seizures were more likely to have had neonatal seizures, have spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy and function within Gross Motor Function Classification System level IV or V. Fifty-six (60%) children with seizures had electroclinical features of a self-limited focal epilepsy of childhood; we diagnosed these children with a self-limited focal epilepsy-variant given the current International League Against Epilepsy classification precludes a diagnosis of self-limited focal epilepsy in children with a brain lesion. Other epilepsy syndromes were focal epilepsy-not otherwise specified in 28, infantile spasms syndrome in 11, Lennox-Gastaut syndrome in three, genetic generalized epilepsies in two and febrile seizures in nine. No epilepsy syndrome could be assigned in seven children with no EEG. Twenty-one changed syndrome classification during childhood. Self-limited focal epilepsy-variant usually manifested with a mix of autonomic and brachio-facial motor features, and occipital and/or centro-temporal spikes on EEG. Of those with self-limited focal epilepsy-variant, 42/56 (75%) had not had a seizure for >2 years. Favourable seizure outcomes were also seen in some children with infantile spasms syndrome and focal epilepsy-not otherwise specified. Of the 93 children with seizures, at last follow-up (mean age 15 years), 61/91 (67%) had not had a seizure in >2 years. Children with cerebral palsy and seizures can be assigned specific epilepsy syndrome diagnoses typically reserved for normally developing children, those syndromes commonly being age-dependent and self-limited. Compared to typically developing children with epilepsy, self-limited focal epilepsy-variant occurs much more commonly in children with cerebral palsy and epilepsy. These findings have important implications for treatment and prognosis of epilepsy in cerebral palsy, and research into pathogenesis of self-limited focal epilepsy.

Abnormal Activity of Masticatory Muscles in Patients with Diagnosis of Cerebral Palsy. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies

AIMS

to map and synthesize the results from studies that assessed whether individuals diagnosed with cerebral palsy (CP) have abnormal masseter and temporal muscles activation during the masticatory cycle.

METHODS

Six databases were searched for comparative observational studies assessing masticatory muscles activation in individuals with CP through electromyography analysis. Methodological quality was evaluated using the Joanna Briggs Critical Appraisal Checklist. Outcome data were combined in meta-analysis using the Review Manager software.

RESULTS

We included five cross-sectional studies with an overall low risk of bias. Meta-analyses showed no difference between CP and healthy individuals regarding maximum voluntary isometric contraction: right masseter (Standard mean difference [SMD] - 0.95; 95% CI -2.03 to 0.13); left masseter (SMD -0.92; 95% CI -1.93 to 0.09); right temporal (SMD -0.72; 95% CI -1.63 to 0.18); and left temporal (SMD -0.68; 95% CI -1.76 to 0.40). Electrical activity amplitude in the inactive period was superior in the CP group, and maximum bite pressure presented higher values in the control group (Mean difference [MD] - 17.38; CI 95% -26.62 to -10.15).

CONCLUSIONS

Based on observational studies with a lower level of evidence, individuals with CP seem to present difficulties activating masticatory muscles. Future prospective cohort studies with rigorous methodology are still necessary to support these findings. PROSPERO register CRD42020208444.

Supported-standing interventions for children and young adults with non-ambulant cerebral palsy: A scoping review

AIM

To describe the evidence, outcomes, and lived experience of supported standing for children and young adults with cerebral palsy aged 25 years or younger, classified in Gross Motor Function Classification System levels IV and V.

METHOD

This scoping review included searches in eight electronic databases and manual searching from database inception to May 2020 and updated on 21st February 2022. Two of three reviewers independently screened titles and abstracts and extracted and appraised data. Methodological quality and risk of bias were appraised using tools appropriate to study type. Content analysis and frequency effect sizes were calculated for qualitative and descriptive evidence.

RESULTS

From 126 full-text references, 59 citations (one study was reported over two citations) were included: 16 systematic reviews, 17 intervention studies reporting over 18 citations, eight analytical cross-sectional studies, five descriptive cross-sectional/survey studies, five qualitative studies, and one mixed-methods study were identified, along with six clinical guidelines. Maintenance of bone mineral density and contracture prevention outcomes were supported by the most experimental studies and evidence syntheses, while evidence supporting other outcomes was primarily quasi-experimental or descriptive. Qualitative evidence suggests that programmes are influenced by attitudes, device, child, and environmental factors.

INTERPRETATION

Individualized assessment and prescription are essential to match personal and environmental needs. Although experimental evidence is limited due to many factors, lived-experience and cohort data suggest that successful integration of standing programmes into age-appropriate and meaningful activities may enhance function, participation, and overall health.

Genetic counseling considerations in cerebral palsy

Genome-wide sequencing (exome and whole genome) has transformed our ability to diagnose patients with suspected genetic disorders. Cerebral palsy (CP), although historically thought to be due to birth injury (perinatal hypoxia), represents a clinical spectrum of disorders, many of which have been attributed to a genetic cause. GWS has elucidated the underlying single gene cause for many patients with CP and has important implications for the customization of treatment, management, and genetic counseling. International guidelines recommend genetic counseling for all families considering genome-wide sequencing. Genetic counselors educate and support families and help them to make testing decisions based on their values. They can help families adapt to, and understand the implications of a genomic diagnosis. Here, we review advances in sequencing for CP, clinical features suggestive of a genetic etiology of CP, practice guidelines for GWS, and a practical approach to the genetic counseling of these families. This includes: the content to be addressed in pre-test and post-test genetic counseling sessions, the benefits of a establishing a genetic cause and importantly, the need for ongoing support.

Measuring the inch stones for progress: Gross motor function in the developmental and epileptic encephalopathies

OBJECTIVE

Developmental and epileptic encephalopathies (DEE) entail moderate to profound impairments in gross motor skills and mobility, which are poorly quantified with clinical outcomes assessments (COA) used in neuro-typical populations. We studied the motor domain of the Adaptive Behavior Assessment System-3 for ages 0-5 years (ABAS) used outside of its intended age range with a focus on raw scores.

METHODS

In a cross-sectional survey, 117 parents of children with a variety of DEEs (ages 1-35 years, median = 9) completed the motor domain section of the ABAS. Floor and ceiling effects and associations with epilepsy-related factors were assessed with appropriate parametric and nonparametric statistical techniques. The sensitivity of the ABAS and additional measures of mobility borrowed from the cerebral palsy literature (Functional Activities Questionnaire (FAQ-22) walking level (FAQ-WL)) to different levels of the Functional Mobility Scale was determined.

RESULTS

ABAS motor scores corresponded to a median age equivalent of 20.5 months (Inter-Quartile Range (IQR) 8-34). Most raw scores corresponded to standardized scores > 2 standard deviations below the ABAS standardization sample mean. ABAS raw scores demonstrated minimal floor and ceiling effects (<5%). In linear regression models, scores increased with age under 6 years (p < 0.0001) but flattened out thereafter. Scores varied substantially by DEE group (p < 0.001) and decreased with higher convulsive seizure frequency (<0.0001) and number of seizure medications (p < 0.001). ABAS and other motor scores were sensitive to important differences in mobility as represented by the FMS at 5 yards. Further, they correlated with declines in mobility function from 5 to 500 yards.

SIGNIFICANCE

An out-of-range COA with raw scores may provide a measure of motor ability and mobility sensitive within the range of moderate to profound impairment seen in patients with DEE. This approach could shorten the time to appropriate COA development and ensure timely clinical trial readiness for novel therapies for rare DEEs.

Molecular Diagnostic Yield of Exome Sequencing and Chromosomal Microarray in Cerebral Palsy: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Importance

There are many known acquired risk factors for cerebral palsy (CP), but in some cases, CP is evident without risk factors (cryptogenic CP). Early CP cohort studies report a wide range of diagnostic yields for sequence variants assessed by exome sequencing (ES) and copy number variants (CNVs) assessed by chromosomal microarray (CMA).

Objective

To synthesize the emerging CP genetics literature and address the question of what percentage of individuals with CP have a genetic disorder via ES and CMA.

Data Sources

Searched articles were indexed by PubMed with relevant queries pertaining to CP and ES/CMA (query date, March 15, 2022).

Study Selection

Inclusion criteria were as follows: primary research study, case series with 10 or more nonrelated individuals, CP diagnosis, and ES and/or CMA data used for genetic evaluation. Nonblinded review was performed.

Data Extraction and Synthesis

Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses guidelines were used for assessing data quality and validity. Data were extracted by a single observer.

Main Outcomes and Measures

A separate meta-analysis was performed for each modality (ES, CMA). The primary outcome was proportion/molecular diagnostic yield (number of patients with a discovered genetic disorder divided by the total number of patients in the cohort), evaluated via meta-analysis of single proportions using random-effects logistic regression. A subgroup meta-analysis was conducted, using risk factor classification as a subgroup. A forest plot was used to display diagnostic yields of individual studies.

Results

In the meta-analysis of ES yield in CP, the overall diagnostic yield of ES among the cohorts (15 study cohorts comprising 2419 individuals from 11 articles) was 23% (95% CI, 15%-34%). The diagnostic yield across cryptogenic CP cohorts was 35% (95% CI, 27%-45%), compared with 7% (95% CI, 4%-12%) across cohorts with known risk factors (noncryptogenic CP). In the meta-analysis of CMA yield in CP, the diagnostic yield of CMA among the cohorts (5 study cohorts comprising 294 individuals from 5 articles) was 5% (95% CI, 2%-12%).

Conclusions and Relevance

Results of this systematic review and meta-analysis suggest that for individuals with cryptogenic CP, ES followed by CMA to identify molecular disorders may be warranted.

Cerebral palsy and related neuromotor disorders: Overview of genetic and genomic studies

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a debilitating condition characterized by abnormal movement or posture, beginning early in development. Early family and twin studies and more recent genomic investigations clearly demonstrate that genetic factors of major effect contribute to the etiology of CP. Most copy number variants and small alterations of nucleotide sequence that cause CP arise as a result of de novo mutations, so studies that estimate heritability on basis of recurrence frequency within families substantially underestimate genetic contributions to the etiology. At least 4% of patients with typical CP have disease-causing CNVs, and at least 14% have disease-causing single nucleotide variants or indels. The rate of pathogenic genomic lesions is probably more than twice as high among patients who have atypical CP, i.e., neuromotor dysfunction with additional neurodevelopmental abnormalities or malformations, or with MRI findings and medical history that are not characteristic of a perinatal insult. Mutations of many different genetic loci can produce a CP-like phenotype. The importance of genetic variants of minor effect and of epigenetic modifications in producing a multifactorial predisposition to CP is less clear. Recognizing the specific cause of CP in an affected individual is essential to providing optimal clinical management. An etiological diagnosis provides families an "enhanced compass" that improves overall well-being, facilitates access to educational and social services, permits accurate genetic counseling, and, for a subset of patients such as those with underlying inherited metabolic disorders, may make precision therapy that targets the pathophysiology available. Trio exome sequencing with assessment of copy number or trio genome sequencing with bioinformatics analysis for single nucleotide variants, indels, and copy number variants is clinically indicated in the initial workup of CP patients, especially those with additional malformations or neurodevelopmental abnormalities.

Common data elements and minimum data sets in cerebral palsy: Start small to grow big

This commentary is on the original article by Wilson et al. on pages 1470–1476 of this issue.

Making waves: The changing tide of cerebral palsy

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a broad diagnosis unbound by aetiology and is based on a clinical examination demonstrating abnormalities of movement or posture. CP represents a static neurological condition, provided that neurodegenerative conditions, leukoencephalopathies and neuromuscular disorders are excluded. In paediatrics, the genetic conditions associated with CP are rapidly increasing, with primary and overlapping neurodevelopmental conditions perhaps better categorised by the predominant clinical feature such as CP, intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorder or epilepsy. Progress in molecular genetics may challenge what constitutes CP, but a genetic diagnosis does not negate the CP diagnosis. As clinicians working in the field, we discuss the changing tide of CP. Neuroimaging provides essential information through pattern recognition and demonstration of static brain changes. We present examples of children where a layered clinical diagnosis or dual aetiologies are appropriate. We also present examples of children with genetic causes of CP to highlight the challenges and limitations of neuroimaging to provide an aetiological diagnosis. In consultation with a geneticist, access to genomic testing (exome or genome sequencing) is now available in Australia under Medicare billing for children under the age of 10 with dysmorphic features, one or more major structural organ anomalies, (an evolving) intellectual disability or global developmental delay. We encourage the uptake of genomic testing in CP, because it can be difficult to tell whether a child has an environmental or genetic cause for CP. A specific genetic diagnosis may change patient management, reduce guilt and enable more distinctive research in the future to assist with understanding disease mechanisms.

Cerebral palsy diagnosis and the impact on hip surveillance enrollment

AIM

To investigate the diagnosis at enrollment in the Child Health British Columbia Hip Surveillance Program for Children with Cerebral Palsy (CP) and review the etiologies of children enrolled without a CP diagnosis.

METHOD

Data from 959 children (543 males, 416 females; mean [SD] age at enrollment 6 years 8 months [4 years 2 months]) enrolled in the program between September 2015 and December 2019 were retrospectively reviewed. Enrollment diagnosis, Gross Motor Function Classification System level, migration percentage, and age at enrollment were included. Chart reviews were completed to confirm diagnoses for all children. Etiologies were compared to a list of conditions that are included and excluded from CP registries.

RESULTS

Diagnosis at enrollment was CP for 612 (64%), possible CP for 120 (13%), and 'other' for 220 (23%). No diagnosis was provided for seven (<1%). CP was confirmed for 700 (73%), including 106 (11.1%) enrolled as 'possible CP' or 'other'; 56 (5.8%) did not have CP due to progressive conditions. Migration percentage was similar across all groups at enrollment.

INTERPRETATION

One in four children were enrolled in hip surveillance without a diagnosis of CP or possible CP. Encouraging participation in hip surveillance when children meet the clinical criteria for CP but do not have a confirmed CP diagnosis can improve access to care.

What does an aetiological diagnosis actually mean?

This commentary is on the original article by Aravamuthan et al. on pages 723–733 of this issue.

Diagnostic preferences include discussion of etiology for adults with cerebral palsy and their caregivers

AIM

To determine the views of individuals with cerebral palsy (CP) and their caregivers (CP community members) about carrying a CP diagnosis, an etiological diagnosis, or both diagnoses together.

METHOD

We surveyed CP community members across two registries querying their views on carrying a CP diagnosis, one type of etiological diagnosis (specifically, a genetic diagnosis), or both. Open-ended responses were analyzed using a conventional content analysis approach.

RESULTS

Of 197 respondents (108 adults with CP and 89 caregivers), most (75%) valued knowing the cause of their CP. Of those with a diagnostic preference, most preferred carrying both CP and etiological diagnoses together (68%). When compared with carrying an etiological diagnosis alone, significantly more respondents felt a CP diagnosis helped anticipate symptom evolution (84% vs 54%), explain symptoms to others (86% vs 48%), access services (86% vs 48%), and join support communities (78% vs 50%) (p <  0.01, χ² test).

INTERPRETATION

Most CP community members surveyed want to know the cause of their CP and would prefer carrying both CP and etiological diagnoses together. Clinical practice should evolve to meet these community needs.

Genetic Spectrum Identified by Exome Sequencing in a Chinese Pediatric Cerebral Palsy Cohort

OBJECTIVE

To explore the genetic spectrum of cerebral palsy (CP) in a Chinese pediatric cohort.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a retrospective observational study of patients with CP from the Children's Hospital of Fudan University between June 2015 and December 2019. Their clinical data and exome sequencing data were collected and analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 217 patients with CP were enrolled, and genetic variants were identified in 78 subjects (35.9%): 65 patients with single-nucleotide variants (SNVs), 12 patients with copy number variants, and 1 patient with both an SNV and a copy number variant. The genetic diagnosis rates were significantly greater in patients without clinical risk factors than in patients with clinical risk factors (χ² = 21.705, P = .000) and were significantly greater in patients with a family history than in those without a family history (χ² = 4.493, P = .034). Variants in genes related to neurologic disorders were the most commonly detected variants, affecting 41 patients (62.1%, 41/66). Among the patients with SNVs detected, the top 12 genes were found to cover 62.1% (41/66) of cases, and 39.4% (26/66) of patients with SNVs had medically actionable genetic findings.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall genetic diagnostic rate in this study was 35.9%, and patients without any clinical risk factors or with a family history were more likely to have genetic risk factors. The top 12 genes detected in this study as well as genes related to neurologic disorders or other medically actionable disorders should be noted in the analysis of genetic testing results in patients with CP.

Paralytic dislocation of the hip in children

Despite the progress made in the past decades, hip disorders are one of the most common orthopedic problems in the context of paralysis. The etiology can be congenital (malformation such as myelomeningoceles, genetic neuromuscular disorders) or acquired (cerebral palsy, post-traumatic). In these conditions, the orthopedic deformities are minimal at birth. They can develop as the child grows, at different ages, depending on the etiology, severity of the neuromuscular disorder and functional potential. Hip subluxation and dislocation can compromise standing and walking capacities, but also the quality of the seated position and the personal care. Daily life activities and participation are restricted and influence the disabled person's quality of life. Paralytic dislocation of the hip is the orthopedic deformity that has be biggest impact on day-to-day life, general health and the overall orthopedic result in adulthood. Neuro-orthopedic care is challenging. However, there are basic principles that one must know to ensure good long-term quality of life in patients suffering from paralytic dislocations of the hip. When planning the treatment strategy, it is essential to take into consideration the day-to-day life and to integrate the patient's experiences and needs, along with those of their caretakers. The objective of this review is to outline the differences in paralytic dislocations of the hip of diverse etiology, to present evaluation principles useful in daily clinical practice and to help practitioners in choosing a treatment strategy.

Mendelian etiologies identified with whole exome sequencing in cerebral palsy

Objectives

Cerebral palsy (CP) is the most common childhood motor disability, yet its link to single‐gene disorders is under‐characterized. To explore the genetic landscape of CP, we conducted whole exome sequencing (WES) in a cohort of patients with CP.

Methods

We performed comprehensive phenotyping and WES on a prospective cohort of individuals with cryptogenic CP (who meet criteria for CP; have no risk factors), non‐cryptogenic CP (who meet criteria for CP; have at least one risk factor), and CP masqueraders (who could be diagnosed with CP, but have regression/progressive symptoms). We characterized motor phenotypes, ascertained medical comorbidities, and classified brain MRIs. We analyzed WES data using an institutional pipeline.

Results

We included 50 probands in this analysis (20 females, 30 males). Twenty‐four had cryptogenic CP, 20 had non‐cryptogenic CP, five had CP masquerader classification, and one had unknown classification. Hypotonic‐ataxic subtype showed a difference in prevalence across the classification groups (p = 0.01). Twenty‐six percent of participants (13/50) had a pathogenic/likely pathogenic variant in 13 unique genes (ECHS1, SATB2, ZMYM2, ADAT3, COL4A1, THOC2, SLC16A2, SPAST, POLR2A, GNAO1, PDHX, ACADM, ATL1), including one patient with two genetic disorders (ACADM, PDHX) and two patients with a SPAST‐related disorder. The CP masquerader category had the highest diagnostic yield (n = 3/5, 60%), followed by the cryptogenic CP category (n = 7/24, 29%). Fifteen percent of patients with non‐cryptogenic CP (n = 3/20) had a Mendelian disorder on WES.

Interpretation

WES demonstrated a significant prevalence of Mendelian disorders in individuals clinically diagnosed with CP, including in individuals with known CP risk factors.

Genetic testing in individuals with cerebral palsy

AIM To determine which patients with cerebral palsy (CP) should undergo genetic testing, we compared the rate of likely causative genetic variants from whole-exome sequencing in individuals with and without environmental risk factors. METHOD Patients were part of a convenience and physician-referred cohort recruited from a single medical center, and research whole-exome sequencing was completed. Participants were evaluated for the following risk factors: extreme preterm birth, brain bleed or stroke, birth asphyxia, brain malformations, and intrauterine infection. RESULTS A total of 151 unrelated individuals with CP (81 females, 70 males; mean age 25y 7mo [SD 17y 5mo], range 3wks-72y) participated. Causative genetic variants were identified in 14 participants (9.3%). There was no significant difference in diagnostic rate between individuals with risk factors (10 out of 123; 8.1%) and those without (4 out of 28; 14.3%) (Fisher's exact p=0.3). INTERPRETATION While the rate of genetic diagnoses among individuals without risk factors was higher than those with risk factors, the difference was not statistically significant at this sample size. The identification of genetic diagnoses in over 8% of cases with risk factors suggests that these might confer susceptibility to environmental factors, and that further research should include individuals with risk factors. What this paper adds There is no significant difference in diagnostic rate between individuals with and without risk factors. Genetic variants may confer susceptibility to environmental risk factors. Six causative variants were identified in genes not previously associated with cerebral palsy. Global developmental delay/intellectual disability is positively associated with a genetic etiology. Extreme preterm birth, stroke/brain hemorrhage, and older age are negatively associated with a genetic etiology.

Computer-Aided Diagnosis of Children with Cerebral Palsy under Deep Learning Convolutional Neural Network Image Segmentation Model Combined with Three-Dimensional Cranial Magnetic Resonance Imaging

In this paper, we analyzed the application value and effect of deep learn-based image segmentation model of convolutional neural network (CNN) algorithm combined with 3D brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in diagnosis of cerebral palsy in children. 3D brain model was segmented based on CNN algorithm to obtain the segmented MRI images of brain tissue, and the validity was verified. Then, 70 children with cerebral palsy were rolled into the observation group (n = 35), which received MRI for diagnosis after segmentation of brain tissue, and control group (n = 35), which were diagnosed by computed tomography (CT). The diagnosis results of the two groups were compared. The validity experiment verified that the image segmentation method based on CNN algorithm can obtain effective style graphics. In clinical trials, the diagnostic accuracy of 88.6% in the observation group was evidently superior to that of 80% in the control group (P < 0.05). In the observation group, one patient was diagnosed as normal, four patients had white matter lesions, 17 patients had corpus callosum lesions, and five patients had basal ganglia softening foci. In the control group, two patients were diagnosed as normal, two patients had white matter lesions, 19 patients had corpus callosum lesions, and four patients had basal ganglia softening foci. No notable difference was found between the two groups (P > 0.05). According to the research results, in the diagnosis of cerebral palsy in children, the image segmentation of brain 3D model based on CNN to obtain the MRI image of segmented brain tissue can effectively improve the detection accuracy. Moreover, the specific symptoms can be diagnosed clearly. It can provide the corresponding diagnostic basis for clinical diagnosis and treatment and was worthy of clinical promotion.

Expansion of the Genotypic and Phenotypic Spectrum of WASF1-Related Neurodevelopmental Disorder

In humans, de novo truncating variants in WASF1 (Wiskott–Aldrich syndrome protein family member 1) have been linked to presentations of moderate-to-profound intellectual disability (ID), autistic features, and epilepsy. Apart from one case series, there is limited information on the phenotypic spectrum and genetic landscape of WASF1-related neurodevelopmental disorder (NDD). In this report, we describe detailed clinical characteristics of six individuals with WASF1-related NDD. We demonstrate a broader spectrum of neurodevelopmental impairment including more mildly affected individuals. Further, we report new variant types, including a copy number variant (CNV), resulting in the partial deletion of WASF1 in monozygotic twins, and three missense variants, two of which alter the same residue, p.W161. This report adds further evidence that de novo variants in WASF1 cause an autosomal dominant NDD.

Genetic Testing Contributes to Diagnosis in Cerebral Palsy: Aicardi-Goutières Syndrome as an Example

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a non-progressive neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by motor impairments, often accompanied by co-morbidities such as intellectual disability, epilepsy, visual and hearing impairment and speech and language deficits. Despite the established role of hypoxic–ischemic injury in some CP cases, several studies suggest that birth asphyxia is actually an uncommon cause, accounting for <10% of CP cases. For children with CP in the absence of traditional risk factors, a genetic basis to their condition is increasingly suspected. Several recent studies indeed confirm copy number variants and single gene mutations with large genetic heterogeneity as an etiology in children with CP. Here, we report three patients with spastic cerebral palsy and a genetically confirmed diagnosis of Aicardi-Goutières syndrome (AGS), with highly variable phenotypes ranging from clinically suggestive to non-specific symptomatology. Our findings suggest that AGS may be a rather common cause of CP, that frequently remains undiagnosed without additional genetic testing, as in only one case a clinical suspicion of AGS was raised. Our data show that a diagnosis of AGS must be considered in cases with spastic CP, even in the absence of characteristic brain abnormalities. Importantly, a genetic diagnosis of AGS may have significant therapeutic consequences, as targeted therapies are being developed for type 1 interferonopathies, the group of diseases to which AGS belongs. Our findings demonstrate the importance of next generation sequencing in CP patients without an identifiable cause, since targeted diagnostic testing is hampered by the often non-specific presentation.

Iatrogenic vs. Spontaneous Preterm Birth: A Retrospective Study of Neonatal Outcome Among Very Preterm Infants

Objective: Preterm birth is a leading contributor to childhood morbidity and mortality, and the incidence tends to increase and is higher in developing countries. The aim of this study was to analyze the potential impact of preterm birth in different etiology groups on neonatal complications and outcomes and to gain insight into preventive strategies.

Methods: We performed a retrospective cohort study of preterm infants less than 32 weeks' gestation in the Third Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University from 2014 to 2019. Preterm births were categorized as spontaneous or iatrogenic, and these groups were compared for maternal and neonatal characteristics, neonatal complications, and outcomes. All infants surviving at discharge were followed up at 12 months of corrected age to compare the neurodevelopmental outcomes.

Results: A total of 1,415 mothers and 1,689 neonates were included, and the preterm population consisted of 1,038 spontaneous preterm infants and 651 iatrogenic preterm infants. There was a significant difference in the incidence of small for gestational age between the two groups. Infants born following spontaneous labor presented with a higher risk of intraventricular hemorrhage, whereas iatrogenic preterm birth was associated with higher risk of necrotizing enterocolitis and coagulopathy and higher risk of pathoglycemia. There was no difference in mortality between the two groups. Follow-up data were available for 1,114 infants, and no differences in neurologic outcomes were observed between the two preterm birth subtypes.

Conclusions: Preterm births with different etiologies were associated with some neonatal complications, but not with neurodevelopmental outcomes at 12 months of corrected age.

Evidence that autosomal recessive spastic cerebral palsy-1 (CPSQ1) is caused by a missense variant in HPDL

A subset of individuals diagnosed with cerebral palsy will have an underlying genetic diagnosis. Previously, a missense variant in GAD1 was described as a candidate mutation in a single family diagnosed with autosomal recessive spastic cerebral palsy-1 (CPSQ1; OMIM 603513). Following the ascertainment of a further branch of the CPSQ1 kindred, we found that the previously reported GAD1 variant did not segregate with the neurological disease phenotype in the recently ascertained branch of the kindred. Following genetic linkage studies to map autozygous regions and whole-exome sequencing, a missense variant (c.527 T > C; p. Leu176Pro, rs773333490) in the HPDL gene was detected and found to segregate with disease status in both branches of the kindred. HPDL encodes a 371-amino acid protein (4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate Dioxygenase Like) that localizes to mitochondria but whose function is uncertain. Recently, biallelic loss of function variants and missense substitution-causing variants in HPDL were reported to cause a childhood onset progressive spastic movement disorder with a variable presentation. These findings suggest that HPDL-related neurological disease may mimic spastic cerebral palsy and that GAD1 should not be included in diagnostic gene panels for inherited cerebral palsy.

The Role of Neuroimaging and Genetic Analysis in the Diagnosis of Children With Cerebral Palsy

Cerebral magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is considered an important tool in the assessment of a child with cerebral palsy (CP), as it is abnormal in more than 80% of children with CP, disclosing the pathogenic pattern responsible for the neurological condition. MRI, therefore, is recommended as the first diagnostic step after medical history taking and neurological examination. With the advances in genetic diagnostics, the genetic contribution to CP is increasingly discussed, and the question arises about the role of genetic testing in the diagnosis of cerebral palsy. The paper gives an overview on genetic findings reported in CP, which are discussed with respect to the underlying brain pathology according to neuroimaging findings. Surveillance of Cerebral Palsy in Europe (SCPE) classifies neuroimaging findings in CP into five categories, which help to stratify decisions concerning genetic testing. Predominant white and gray matter injuries are by far predominant (accounting for around 50 and 20% of the findings). They are considered to be acquired. Here, predisposing genetic factors may play a role to increase vulnerability (and should especially be considered, when family history is positive and/or causative external factors are missing). In maldevelopments and normal findings (around 11% each), monogenic causes are more likely, and thus, genetic testing is clearly recommended. In the miscellaneous category, the precise nature of the MRI finding has to be considered as it could indicate a genetic origin.

Molecular Diagnostic Yield of Exome Sequencing in Patients With Cerebral Palsy

IMPORTANCE

Cerebral palsy is a common neurodevelopmental disorder affecting movement and posture that often co-occurs with other neurodevelopmental disorders. Individual cases of cerebral palsy are often attributed to birth asphyxia; however, recent studies indicate that asphyxia accounts for less than 10% of cerebral palsy cases.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the molecular diagnostic yield of exome sequencing (prevalence of pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants) in individuals with cerebral palsy.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS

A retrospective cohort study of patients with cerebral palsy that included a clinical laboratory referral cohort with data accrued between 2012 and 2018 and a health care-based cohort with data accrued between 2007 and 2017.

EXPOSURES

Exome sequencing with copy number variant detection.

MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES

The primary outcome was the molecular diagnostic yield of exome sequencing.

RESULTS

Among 1345 patients from the clinical laboratory referral cohort, the median age was 8.8 years (interquartile range, 4.4-14.7 years; range, 0.1-66 years) and 601 (45%) were female. Among 181 patients in the health care-based cohort, the median age was 41.9 years (interquartile range, 28.0-59.6 years; range, 4.8-89 years) and 96 (53%) were female. The molecular diagnostic yield of exome sequencing was 32.7% (95% CI, 30.2%-35.2%) in the clinical laboratory referral cohort and 10.5% (95% CI, 6.0%-15.0%) in the health care-based cohort. The molecular diagnostic yield ranged from 11.2% (95% CI, 6.4%-16.2%) for patients without intellectual disability, epilepsy, or autism spectrum disorder to 32.9% (95% CI, 25.7%-40.1%) for patients with all 3 comorbidities. Pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants were identified in 229 genes (29.5% of 1526 patients); 86 genes were mutated in 2 or more patients (20.1% of 1526 patients) and 10 genes with mutations were independently identified in both cohorts (2.9% of 1526 patients).

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE

Among 2 cohorts of patients with cerebral palsy who underwent exome sequencing, the prevalence of pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants was 32.7% in a cohort that predominantly consisted of pediatric patients and 10.5% in a cohort that predominantly consisted of adult patients. Further research is needed to understand the clinical implications of these findings.

Variability in Cerebral Palsy Diagnosis

BACKGROUND

Cerebral palsy (CP) is the most common childhood motor disability. The emergence of genetic CP etiologies, variable inclusion of hypotonic CP in international registries, and involvement of different medical disciplines in CP diagnosis can promote diagnostic variability. This variability could adversely affect patients' understanding of their symptoms and access to care. Therefore, we sought to determine the presence and extent of practice variability in CP diagnosis.

METHODS

We surveyed physicians in the United States and Canada interested in CP on the basis of membership in the American Academy of Cerebral Palsy and Developmental Medicine or the Child Neurology Society Neonatal Neurology, Movement Disorders, or Neurodevelopmental Disabilities Special Interest Groups. The survey included the 2007 consensus definition of CP and 4 hypothetical case scenarios.

RESULTS

Of 695 contacted physicians, 330 (47%) completed the survey. Two scenarios yielded consensus: (1) nonprogressive spastic diplegia after premature birth with periventricular leukomalacia on brain MRI (96% would diagnose CP) and (2) progressive spastic diplegia (92% would not diagnose CP). Scenarios featuring genetic etiologies or hypotonia as the cause of nonprogressive motor disability yielded variability: only 46% to 67% of practitioners would diagnose CP in these settings.

CONCLUSIONS

There is practice variability in whether a child with a nonprogressive motor disability due to a genetic etiology or generalized hypotonia will be diagnosed with CP. This variability occurred despite anchoring questions with the 2007 consensus definition of CP. On the basis of these results, we have suggested ways to reduce diagnostic variability, including clarification of the consensus definition.

How Do Complications Within the First 30 days after Spinal Deformity Surgery in Children with Cerebral Palsy Affect Length of Stay?

BACKGROUND

Surgery for spinal deformity in patients with cerebral palsy is reported to have high perioperative complication rates. However, minor complications are not generally reported and the influence of the varied severity of complications on length of stay is not known. Understanding the risk factors for both minor and major perioperative complications and their effect on length of stay is important information for clinicians who seek to improve care for this group of children.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

(1) What is the prevalence of postoperative complications in the first 30 days after surgery for spinal deformity in a New Zealand national cohort of children with cerebral palsy using the Clavien-Dindo classification? (2) What are the patient and operative predictive risk factors for minor and major perioperative complications? (3) What is the effect of year of operation on risk of minor and major perioperative complications? (4) What is the effect of perioperative complications on length of stay?

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective cohort study, identifying all children in New Zealand with a confirmed diagnosis of cerebral palsy who had surgery for a spinal deformity from January 1997 to January 2018. Two hundred-three patients with cerebral palsy (102 boys) were surgically treated for a spinal deformity, at a mean age of 14 ± 3 years, at one of three centers in New Zealand. Six children had Gross Motor Function Classification System Level II or III, 66 had Gross Motor Function Classification System Level IV, and 131 had Gross Motor Function Classification System Level V. Thirty-day perioperative complications were extracted from the patients' health records and classified according to the Clavien-Dindo system. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to identify patient and operative risk factors for complications, and the effect on length of stay.

RESULTS

In all, 85% of patients experienced at least one perioperative complication. There were 300 Clavien-Dindo Grade I complications in 141 patients, 156 Clavien-Dindo Grade II complications in 102 patients, 25 Clavien-Dindo Grade III complications in 22 patients, 29 Clavien-Dindo Grade IV complications in 28 patients, and one Clavien-Dindo Grade V complication (death; 0.5%). Univariate analysis showed that multiple independent factors, Gross Motor Function Classification System Level V ability (odds ratio 2.13 [95% confidence interval 1.15 to 3.95]; p = 0.02), seizure disorder (OR 2.27 [95% CI 1.20 to 4.32]; p < 0.01), preoperative Cobb angle of greater than 70° (OR 2.40 [95% CI 1.20 to 4.78]; p < 0.01), and anterior approach to surgery (OR 3.29 [95% CI 1.21 to 8.90]; p = 0.02), were associated with Grade I complications but, of these factors, only the presence of a seizure disorder (OR 2.27 [95% CI 1.20 to 4.32]; p < 0.01) was associated with Grade I complications on multivariate analysis. Previous recurrent respiratory infections predicted an increased risk of Clavien-Dindo Grade II complications (OR 3.6 [95% CI 1.81 to 7.0]; p = 0.03). The presence of a feeding gastrostomy was associated with an increased risk of Clavien-Dindo Grade IV complications (OR 2.6 [95% CI 1.19 to 5.87]; p = 0.02). The year of operation did not influence the frequency of any grade of complication, but the presence of any complication led to an increased length of stay.

CONCLUSION

Overall, 85% of patients with cerebral palsy had at least one complication after spinal deformity surgery and 25% had major complications (Grades III, IV, and V), with proportionate increases in the postoperative length of stay. Patient-specific factors aid in the identification of complication risk.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II, prognostic study.

Insights From Genetic Studies of Cerebral Palsy

Cohort-based whole exome and whole genome sequencing and copy number variant (CNV) studies have identified genetic etiologies for a sizable proportion of patients with cerebral palsy (CP). These findings indicate that genetic mutations collectively comprise an important cause of CP. We review findings in CP genomics and propose criteria for CP-associated genes at the level of gene discovery, research study, and clinical application. We review the published literature and report 18 genes and 5 CNVs from genomics studies with strong evidence of for the pathophysiology of CP. CP-associated genes often disrupt early brain developmental programming or predispose individuals to known environmental risk factors. We discuss the overlap of CP-associated genes with other neurodevelopmental disorders and related movement disorders. We revisit diagnostic criteria for CP and discuss how identification of genetic etiologies does not preclude CP as an appropriate diagnosis. The identification of genetic etiologies improves our understanding of the neurobiology of CP, providing opportunities to study CP pathogenesis and develop mechanism-based interventions.

Physical Therapists Are Key to Hip Surveillance for Children with Cerebral Palsy: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Knowledge Translation to Support Program Implementation

AIMS

Physical and occupational therapists play a key role in the implementation of hip surveillance for children with cerebral palsy (CP) in British Columbia, Canada. We aimed to develop and assess a knowledge translation strategy to support the implementation of a provincial hip surveillance program.

METHODS

Pediatric therapists were invited to participate in an anonymous survey assessing hip surveillance knowledge and learning needs. Based on these results, educational materials were developed. Two years later, one year following the launch of the hip surveillance program, the survey was repeated to assess learning, knowledge use, and barriers to enrollment.

RESULTS

The initial survey was completed by 102 therapists; 74 therapists completed the second survey. Multifaceted educational strategies, including web-based learning, in-person education, email notifications, and print materials that targeted knowledge gaps were developed. Upon re-evaluation, knowledge increased on all questions. At follow-up, 45 therapists had enrolled a child, indicating knowledge use. Barriers to enrollment included lack of a CP diagnosis, parents or physicians not agreeing to enrollment, time requirements, and lack of space to complete the clinical exam.

CONCLUSIONS

Targeted knowledge translation strategies were successful in meeting the educational requirements of a large group of therapists in a vast geographic area.

Multi-Organ Dysfunction in Cerebral Palsy

Cerebral Palsy (CP) describes a heterogenous group of non-progressive disorders of posture or movement, causing activity limitation, due to a lesion in the developing brain. CP is an umbrella term for a heterogenous condition and is, therefore, descriptive rather than a diagnosis. Each case requires detailed consideration of etiology. Our understanding of the underlying cause of CP has developed significantly, with areas such as inflammation, epigenetics and genetic susceptibility to subsequent insults providing new insights. Alongside this, there has been increasing recognition of the multi-organ dysfunction (MOD) associated with CP, in particular in children with higher levels of motor impairment. Therefore, CP should not be seen as an unchanging disorder caused by a solitary insult but rather, as a condition which evolves over time. Assessment of multi-organ function may help to prevent complications in later childhood or adulthood. It may also contribute to an improved understanding of the etiology and thus may have an implication in prevention, interventional methods and therapies. MOD in CP has not yet been quantified and a scoring system may prove useful in allowing advanced clinical planning and follow-up of children with CP. Additionally, several biomarkers hold promise in assisting with long-term monitoring. Clinicians should be aware of the multi-system complications that are associated with CP and which may present significant diagnostic challenges given that many children with CP communicate non-verbally. A step-wise, logical, multi-system approach is required to ensure that the best care is provided to these children. This review summarizes multi-organ dysfunction in children with CP whilst highlighting emerging research and gaps in our knowledge. We identify some potential organ-specific biomarkers which may prove useful in developing guidelines for follow-up and management of these children throughout their lifespan.

Genetic Testing in Various Neurodevelopmental Disorders Which Manifest as Cerebral Palsy: A Case Study From Iran

Purpose: Cerebral palsy (CP) is a heterogeneous permanent disorder impacting movement and posture. Investigations aimed at diagnosing this disorder are expensive and time-consuming and can eventually inconclusive. This study aimed to determine the diagnostic yield of next generation sequencing in patients with atypical CP (ACP). Methods: Patient eligibility criteria included impaired motor function with onset at birth or within the first year of life, and one or more of the following conditions: severe intellectual disability, positive family history, brain imaging findings not typical for cerebral palsy, abnormal neurometabolic profile, intractable seizure, normal neuroimaging despite severe psychomotor disability, after pediatric neurologist assessment including neuroimaging and biochemical-metabolic study offered for genetic study. Results: Exome sequencing was done for 66 patients which revealed pathogenic, likely pathogenic, and variants of unknown significance in 36.2, 9, and 43.9%, respectively. We also found 10 new mutations and were able to suggest specific and personalized treatments for nine patients. We also found three different mutations with different phenotypical spectrum in one gene that have not been reported for cerebral palsy. Conclusion: An accurate history and physical examination and determination of patients with atypical cerebral palsy for doing exome sequencing result in improved genetic counseling and personalized management.

A retrospective review of the contribution of rare diseases to paediatric mortality in Ireland

Aims

To ascertain the number of paediatric deaths (0–14 years) with an underlying rare disease in the Republic of Ireland between the years 2006–2016, and to analyse bed usage by a paediatric cohort of rare disease inpatients prior to in-hospital death.

Background

Rare diseases are often chronically debilitating and sometimes life-threatening diseases, with the majority (69.9%) of rare diseases being of paediatric onset. The Orphanet database contains information on 6172 unique rare diseases. Under-representation of rare diseases in hospital healthcare coding systems leads to a paucity of rare disease epidemiological data required for healthcare planning. Studies have cited variable incidence rates for rare disease, however the burden of rare diseases to healthcare services still remains unclear. This study represents a thorough effort to identify the percentage of child mortality and paediatric bed usage attributable to rare diseases in the Republic of Ireland, thus addressing a major gap in the rare disease field.

Methods

Retrospective analysis of paediatric death registration details for the Republic of Ireland in the 11-year period 2006–2016 from the National Paediatric Mortality Register. Data was subcategorised as Neonatal (0–28 days), Post Neonatal (29 days < 1 year) and older (1–14 years). Bed usage data (ICD-10 code, narrative and usage) of paediatric inpatients who died during hospitalisation from January 2015 to December 2016 was extracted from the National Quality Assurance Improvement System of in-patient data. Orphacodes were assigned to rare disease cases from ICD-10 codes or diagnostic narrative of both datasets.

Results

There were 4044 deaths registered from 2006–2016, aged < 15 years, of these 2368 (58.6%) had an underlying rare disease. Stratifying by age group; 55.6% (1140/2050) of neonatal deaths had a rare disease, 57.8% (450/778) post-neonatal, and 64% (778/1216) of children aged 1–14 years. Mortality coding using ICD-10 codes identified 42% of rare disease cases with the remainder identified using death certificate narrative records. Rare disease patients occupied 87% of bed days used by children < 15 years who died during hospitalisation from January 2015 to December 2016.

Conclusion

Additional routine rare disease coding is necessary to identify rare diseases within Irish healthcare systems to enable better healthcare planning. Rare disease patients are overrepresented in paediatric mortality statistics and in-patient length of stay during hospital admission prior to death.

Monogenic variants in dystonia: an exome-wide sequencing study

BACKGROUND

Dystonia is a clinically and genetically heterogeneous condition that occurs in isolation (isolated dystonia), in combination with other movement disorders (combined dystonia), or in the context of multisymptomatic phenotypes (isolated or combined dystonia with other neurological involvement). However, our understanding of its aetiology is still incomplete. We aimed to elucidate the monogenic causes for the major clinical categories of dystonia.

METHODS

For this exome-wide sequencing study, study participants were identified at 33 movement-disorder and neuropaediatric specialty centres in Austria, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Poland, Slovakia, and Switzerland. Each individual with dystonia was diagnosed in accordance with the dystonia consensus definition. Index cases were eligible for this study if they had no previous genetic diagnosis and no indication of an acquired cause of their illness. The second criterion was not applied to a subset of participants with a working clinical diagnosis of dystonic cerebral palsy. Genomic DNA was extracted from blood of participants and whole-exome sequenced. To find causative variants in known disorder-associated genes, all variants were filtered, and unreported variants were classified according to American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines. All considered variants were reviewed in expert round-table sessions to validate their clinical significance. Variants that survived filtering and interpretation procedures were defined as diagnostic variants. In the cases that went undiagnosed, candidate dystonia-causing genes were prioritised in a stepwise workflow.

FINDINGS

We sequenced the exomes of 764 individuals with dystonia and 346 healthy parents who were recruited between June 1, 2015, and July 31, 2019. We identified causative or probable causative variants in 135 (19%) of 728 families, involving 78 distinct monogenic disorders. We observed a larger proportion of individuals with diagnostic variants in those with dystonia (either isolated or combined) with coexisting non-movement disorder-related neurological symptoms (100 [45%] of 222; excepting cases with evidence of perinatal brain injury) than in those with combined (19 [19%] of 98) or isolated (16 [4%] of 388) dystonia. Across all categories of dystonia, 104 (65%) of the 160 detected variants affected genes which are associated with neurodevelopmental disorders. We found diagnostic variants in 11 genes not previously linked to dystonia, and propose a predictive clinical score that could guide the implementation of exome sequencing in routine diagnostics. In cases without perinatal sentinel events, genomic alterations contributed substantively to the diagnosis of dystonic cerebral palsy. In 15 families, we delineated 12 candidate genes. These include IMPDH2, encoding a key purine biosynthetic enzyme, for which robust evidence existed for its involvement in a neurodevelopmental disorder with dystonia. We identified six variants in IMPDH2, collected from four independent cohorts, that were predicted to be deleterious de-novo variants and expected to result in deregulation of purine metabolism.

INTERPRETATION

In this study, we have determined the role of monogenic variants across the range of dystonic disorders, providing guidance for the introduction of personalised care strategies and fostering follow-up pathophysiological explorations.

FUNDING

Else Kröner-Fresenius-Stiftung, Technische Universität München, Helmholtz Zentrum München, Medizinische Universität Innsbruck, Charles University in Prague, Czech Ministry of Education, the Slovak Grant and Development Agency, the Slovak Research and Grant Agency.