Consequences of partial and total plantar fascia release: a finite element study

Effects of plantar fascia stiffness on the internal mechanics of idiopathic pes cavus by finite element analysis: implications for metatarsalgia

Metatarsalgia occurring in individuals with pes cavus is typically associated with abnormal loading patterns in the forefoot resulting from structural alterations. Simultaneously, the frequent overstress of the plantar fascia (PF) caused by the persistence of this foot deformity may further exacerbate the chronic pain induced by metatarsal overload. We aimed to investigate and quantify the effects of PF stiffness on the internal biomechanics of pes cavus using a computational modelling approach. A patient-specific finite element model of the foot-ankle complex using the actual three-dimensional geometry of idiopathic pes cavus bones and soft tissues was reconstructed. A sensitivity study was conducted to evaluate the effects of varying elastic modulus (0-700 MPa) of the PF on the metatarsal stress distribution, and force transmission through the metatarsophalangeal (MTP) and tarsometatarsal (TMT) joints in the pes cavus. The results indicated that variations in PF stiffness led to stress redistribution in the metatarsal region. Peak stress gradually reduced with decreasing stiffness until the PF was released, eventually resulting in a reduction of 22.39% compared to the reference value of 350 MPa. Furthermore, adjusting the PF stiffness to twice the reference value (700 MPa) increased the contact forces through the TMT and MTP joints by up to 23% and 116%, respectively. The reduction of PF stiffness alleviated focal metatarsal loading, and therefore, surgical fascia release can be considered to alleviate metatarsalgia in patients with pes cavus.

Disease-Specific Finite element Analysis of the Foot and Ankle

Finite-element analysis is a computational modeling technique that can be used to quantify parameters that are difficult or impossible to measure externally in a geometrically complex structure such as the foot and ankle. It has been used to improve our understanding of pathomechanics and to evaluate proposed treatments for several disorders, including progressive collapsing foot deformity, ankle arthritis, syndesmotic injury, ankle fracture, plantar fasciitis, diabetic foot ulceration, hallux valgus, and lesser toe deformities. Parameters calculated from finite-element models have been widely used to make predictions about their biomechanical correlates.

An investigation into the hammer toe effects on the lower extremity mechanics and plantar fascia tension: A case for a vicious cycle and progressive damage

Hammer toes are one of the common deformities of the forefoot that can lead to compensatory changes during walking in individuals with this condition. Predicting the adverse effects of tissue damage on the performance of other limbs is very important in the prevention of progressive damage. Finite element (FE) and musculoskeletal modeling can be helpful by allowing such effects to be studied in a way where the internal stresses in the tissue could be investigated. Hence, this study aims to investigate the effects of the hammer toe deformity on the lower extremity, especially on the plantar fascia functions. To compare the joint reactions of the hammer toe foot (HTF) and healthy foot (HF), two musculoskeletal models (MSM) of the feet of a healthy individual and that of a participant with hammer toe foot were developed based on gait analysis. A previously validated 3D finite element model which was constructed using Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) of the diabetic participant with the hammer toe deformity was processed at five different events during the stance phase of gait. It was found that the hammer toe deformity makes dorsiflexion of the toes and the windlass mechanism less effective during walking. Specifically, the FE analysis results showed that plantar fascia (PF) in HTF compared to HF played a less dominant role in load bearing with both medial and lateral parts of PF loaded. Also, the results indicated that the stored elastic energy in PF was less in HTF than the HF, which can indicate a higher metabolic cost during walking. Internal stress distribution shows that the majority of ground reaction forces are transmitted through the lateral metatarsals in hammer toe foot, and the probability of fifth metatarsal fracture and also progressive deformity was subsequently increased. The MSM results showed that the joint reaction forces and moments in the hammer toe foot have deviated from normal, where the metatarsophalangeal joint reactions in the hammer toe were less than the values in the healthy foot. This can indicate a vicious cycle of foot deformity, leading to changes in body weight force transmission line, and deviation of joint reactions and plantar fascia function from normal. These in turn lead to increased internal stress concentration, which in turn lead to further foot deformities. This vicious cycle cause progressive damage and can lead to an increase in the risk of ulceration in the diabetic foot.

Design feature combinations effects of running shoe on plantar pressure during heel landing: A finite element analysis with Taguchi optimization approach

Large and repeated impacts on the heel during running are among the primary reasons behind runners’ injuries. Reducing plantar pressure can be conducive to reducing running injury and improving running performance and is primarily achieved by modifying the design parameters of running shoes. This study examines the effect of design parameters of running shoes (i.e., heel-cup, insole material, midsole material, and insole thickness) on landing peak plantar pressure and determines the combination of different parameters that optimize cushion effects by employing the Taguchi method. We developed the foot–shoe finite element (FE) model through reverse engineering. Model assembly with different design parameters was generated in accordance with the Taguchi method orthogonal table. The effectiveness of the model was verified using the static standing model in Ansys. The significance and contribution of different design parameters, and the optimal design to reduce plantar pressure during landing, were determined using the Taguchi method. In the descending order of percentage contribution was a conforming heel-cup (53.18%), insole material (25.89%), midsole material (7.81%), and insole thickness (2.69%). The more conforming heel-cup (p < 0.001) and softer insole (p = 0.001) reduced the heel pressure during landing impact. The optimal design of running shoe in this study was achieved with a latex insole, a 6 mm insole thickness, an Asker C-45 hardness midsole, and a 100% conforming heel-cup. The conforming heel-cup and the insole material significantly affected the peak plantar pressure during heel landing. The implementation of a custom conforming heel-cup is imperative for relieving high plantar pressure for long-distance heel-strike runners.

Comparison of the Isolated Plantar Fascia Release Versus Plantar Fascia Release Combined With Calcaneal Decompression in Management of the Patients With Resistant Heel Pain

We aimed to compare isolated percutaneous plantar fascia release by using a needle versus percutaneous plantar fascia release combined with calcaneal decompression in treatment of the patients with resistant heel pain. We reviewed the prospectively recorded data of patients who treated and follow-up for resistant heel pain (treated more than 6 months with other treatment modalities) with a minimum 1-year follow-up. Twenty patients were treated with plantar fascia release using a needle (group 1) and 21 patients were treated with a similar percutaneous release combined with calcaneal decompression (group 2). Functional outcomes were evaluated using visual analog scale (VAS) and Foot Function Index (FFI) pre- and postoperatively. No significant differences were observed between both groups in terms of age (44.3 years in group 1 vs 46.8 years in group 2), gender (18 females and 2 males in group 1 vs 19 females and 3 males in group 2), body mass index (25.1 in group 1 vs 26.3 in group 2), and follow-up (14.6 months in group 1 vs 15.7 months in group 2). The decrease in postoperative FFI and VAS scores compared with preoperative VAS scores was statistically significant in both groups. However, improvement of FFI and VAS score was significantly higher in group 2 than group 1. Although both methods are very effective in the treatment of persistent heel pain, the group 2 has a better improvement in functional scores than group 1 with a mean 15 months following the procedure.

Effectiveness of radiofrequency ablation for treatment of plantar fasciitis

ABSTRACT

Plantar fasciitis is the most common cause of heel pain. Pain can be persistent in some patients and interrupt daily activities and sportive activities. There are a lot of treatment options available for plantar fasciitis. We hypothesized that patients with chronic persistent plantar fasciitis can be successfully treated with radiofrequency nerve ablation (RFNA).Two hundred sixty-one patients with plantar fasciitis (378 feet) treated with RFNA from February 2017 to January 2019 were retrospectively assessed. All the patients had plantar heel pain for at least 6months. Based on their body mass index (BMI), the enrolled patients were divided into obese (BMI ≥ 30kg/m2) and non-obese (BMI < 30kg/m2) groups. The patients were asked to complete a questionnaire just before and after the procedure and during the final follow-up. The BNS Radiofrequency Lesion Generator was used during a single session. The patients' information, including their visual analogue scale (VAS) score and American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, was assessed. During their final follow-up, the patients were asked to rate the success of their treatment by choosing one of the following options: completely successful, very successful, moderately successful, marginally successful, or not successful.The VAS and AOFAS scores of all the patients were evaluated pre-procedure, in the first month after procedure, and during the final follow-up (8-24 months). There was a statistically significant difference between the pre-procedure and postprocedure VAS scores (P < .001), there was no statistically significant difference between the VAS scores in the first month postprocedure and during the final follow-up.There was a statistically significant difference between the pre-procedure and postprocedure AOFAS scores (P < .001), there was no statistically significant difference between the AOFAS scores in the first month postprocedure and during the final follow-up.RFNA can be used as an alternative method to surgical procedures for treating plantar fasciitis because it is safe and effective. The advantages of RFNA are that patients can quickly return to their work and resume weight-bearing activities.

Biomechanical Effects of Graft Shape for the Evans Lateral Column Lengthening Procedure: A Patient-Specific Finite Element Investigation

BACKGROUND

The Evans calcaneal lengthening osteotomy procedure is widely used for correcting progressive collapsing foot deformity. However, it can result in overcorrection and degenerations of the calcaneocuboid joint. Different shapes of graft have been used in the Evans calcaneal osteotomy, but potential differences in their biomechanical effects is still unclear. The present study was designed to explore the biomechanical effects of graft shape and improve the Evans procedure to avoid or minimize detrimental effects.

METHODS

Twelve patient-specific finite element models were established and validated. A triangular or rectangular wedge of varying size was inserted at the lateral edge of calcaneus, and the degree of correction was quantified. The stress in spring ligaments and plantar fascia and the contact characteristics of the talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints were calculated and compared accordingly.

RESULTS

The rectangular graft provided a much higher degree of correction than triangular grafts did. However, the contact characteristics of the calcaneocuboid joint and talonavicular joint were abnormal, with clear sensitivity to increased graft size, and the modeled strain of the spring ligament increased.

CONCLUSION

The finite element analysis predicts that the rectangular grafts provide a higher degree of correction, but risks overcorrection compared with triangular grafts. The triangular graft may have a lower degree of disturbance to the biomechanical behaviors of the midtarsal joint.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The model shows that both the shape and size of an Evans osteotomy bone wedge can have effects on the contiguous joints and ligamentous structures. Those effects should be considered when selecting a bone wedge for an Evans calcaneal osteotomy.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, case-control study.

Perforating Fat Injections for Chronic Plantar Fasciitis: A Randomized, Crossover Clinical Trial

SUMMARY

Plantar fasciitis affects 2 million patients per year. Ten percent of cases are chronic, with thickened plantar fascia. Treatment may lead to prolonged recovery, foot instability, and scar. The authors hypothesized that perforating fat injections would decrease plantar fascia thickness, reduce pain, and improve quality of life. Adults with plantar fascia greater than 4 mm for whom standard treatment had failed were included in a prospective, randomized, crossover pilot study. Group 1 (intervention) was followed for 12 months. Group 2 was observed for 6 months, injected, and then followed for 6 months. Validated patient reported outcome measures, ultrasound, and complications were assessed. Group 1 had nine female patients and group 2 had five patients. A total of 2.6 ± 1.6 ml of fat was injected per foot at one to two sites. In group 1, plantar fascia thickness decreased from screening at 6 and 12 months (p < 0.05). Group 2 had decreased plantar fascia thickness from screening to 6 months after injection (p < 0.05). Group 1 had pain improvements at 6 and 12 months compared with screening (p < 0.01). Group 2 reported no pain difference after injections (p > 0.05). Group 1 had improved activities of daily living and sports activity at 6 and 12 months compared with screening (p < 0.003). Group 2 noted increased sports activity 6 months after injection compared with screening (p < 0.03). In conclusion, perforating fat injections for chronic plantar fasciitis demonstrate significant improvement in pain, function, and plantar fascia thickness.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, II.

A Review of Finite Element Models of Ligaments in the Foot and Considerations for Practical Application

PURPOSE

Finite element (FE) modeling has been used as a research tool for investigating underlying ligaments biomechanics and orthopedic applications. However, FE models of the ligament in the foot have been developed with various configurations, mainly due to their complex 3D geometry, material properties, and boundary conditions. Therefore, the purpose of this review was to summarize the current state of finite element modeling approaches that have been used in the ?eld of ligament biomechanics, to discuss their applicability to foot ligament modeling in a practical setting, and also to acknowledge current limitations and challenges.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search was performed. Each article was analyzed in terms of the methods used for: (a) ligament geometry, (b) material property, (c) boundary and loading condition related to its application, and (d) model verification and validation.

RESULTS

Of the reviewed studies, 80% of the studies used simplified representations of ligament geometry, the non-linear mechanical behavior of ligaments was taken into account in only 19.2% of the studies, 33% of included studies did not include any kind of validation of the FE model.

CONCLUSION

Further refinement in the functional modeling of ligaments, the micro-structure level characteristics, nonlinearity, and time-dependent response, may be warranted to ensure the predictive ability of the models.

A Cadaveric Study of the Plantar Fascia for the In-Step Plantar Fasciotomy

The in-step plantar fasciotomy has remained a viable option for treatment of plantar fasciitis. The level of the in-step procedure has previously been described as 1.5 cm distal to the anterior heel fat pad. The authors are unaware of any study defining mean width and thickness of the plantar fascia at specific distances from its insertion. The authors performed a standardized cadaveric dissection of 25 fresh frozen cadaveric specimens from a local region in Pennsylvania. Each fascial band width and thickness of the plantar fascia was measured at the fascial insertion, 2 cm distal from insertion, and 3 cm distal from insertion. The mean (± standard deviation) width of the medial, central, and lateral band of the plantar fascia 3 cm from its insertion was 25.3 ± 5.3, 25 ± 3.41, and 23.3 ± 4.49 mm, respectively. At the same anatomic distance, the band thicknesses were 1.5 ± 0.82, 3.3 ± 0.85, and 1.9 ± 0.33 mm, respectively. The literature describes 2 techniques. The first is transecting between one-third to two-thirds of the plantar fascia during a fasciotomy from medial to lateral. The second is identifying, isolating, and releasing the central band. Our study allows to further quantify this, equating to 24.5 to 49 mm in total medial to lateral transection at 3 cm distal from insertion and an isolated central band equating to 25 ± 3.41 mm. With quantitative measurements of transection length, the surgeon will avoid having to estimate and potentially overtransect. This may help in preventing postoperative sequela related to overcorrection.

Staples and locking plates provide comparable outcomes for fixation of first metatarsal dorsiflexion osteotomies in pes cavovarus

BACKGROUND

One commonly encountered deformity within the cavovarus foot is plantarflexion of the first metatarsal which may be a primary or secondary deformity. Correcting the plantarflexion may be achieved through a dorsiflexion osteotomy although the optimal fixation device for this osteotomy has not been determined. This clinical study compared the outcomes using staples and locking plates.

METHODS

A retrospective evaluation was performed of 52 feet that had undergone dorsiflexion osteotomy of the first metatarsal as part of a cavovarus foot correction with a minimum follow-up of two years. Data was collected on deformity correction, complications and cost-analysis.

RESULTS

As a cohort, Meary's angle improved from 13.4° to 7.72° (p < 0.001), Hibbs' angle improved from 117.1° to 124.2° (p < 0.001) and navicular height dropped from 52.7 mm to 47.7 mm (p < 0.001) while calcaneal inclination changed from 20.9° to 21.2° but this did not reach significance (p = 0.66). These indices and the number of complications were not significantly different between the staple and locking plate group. The overall cost of using staples was less than using locking plates.

CONCLUSIONS

Both staples and locking plates are effective devices for fixation of the first metatarsal after a dorsiflexion osteotomy in cavovarus foot surgery. They were both able to provide comparable fixation, although staples were less expensive to use in our study.

A novel closed technique for ultrasound-guided plantar fascia release with a needle: review of 107 cases with a minimum follow-up of 24 months

BACKGROUND

This study aims to analyze the clinical outcome of a new ultrasound-guided surgery for partial plantar fasciotomy performed with a needle for treatment of plantar fasciitis.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective review of 107 patients diagnosed with plantar fasciitis who underwent ultrasound-guided release of the plantar fascia. The series included 62 males (57.9%) and 45 females (42.1%) treated between April 2014 and February 2018, with a mean follow-up of 21.05 ± 10.96 months (7-66) and a minimum follow-up of 24 months. The mean age was 48.10 ± 10.27 years (27-72). Clinical assessments and ultrasound examination were carried out before treatment, after 1 week, and then after 1, 3, 12, and 24 months. The clinical assessment was based on a visual analog scale and the Foot and Ankle Disability Index.

RESULTS

Heel pain improved in 92.5% (99) of patients, but not in 7.4% (8 patients). In the group of patients whose heel pain improved, 9 experienced overload on the lateral column and dorsum of the foot, which improved with the use of plantar orthoses and a rehabilitation program. We recorded no nerve complications (e.g., paresthesia), vascular injuries, or wound-related problems.

CONCLUSION

Ultrasound-guided partial plantar fasciotomy with a needle is safe, since structures are under direct visualization of the surgeon and the risk of damage is minimal. Stitches are not necessary, and recovery is fast. Consequently, costs are low, and the patient can return to work quickly. This technique may represent a valid option for treatment of plantar fasciitis.

Finite element method based parametric study of Gastrocnemius-soleus recession: implications to the treatment of midfoot-forefoot overload syndrome

Gastrocnemius-soleus recession has been used to treat midfoot-forefoot overload syndrome and plantar fasciitis induced by equinus of the ankle joint. A controlled and selective amount of recession is imperative to maintain muscle strength and stability. The objective of this study was to conduct a parametric study to quantify the relationship between the level of recession and plantar fascia stress. A finite element model of the foot-ankle-shank complex was reconstructed from magnetic resonance and computed tomography images of a 63-year-old normal female. The model was validated by comparing modeled stresses to the measured plantar pressure distribution of the model participant during balanced standing. The midstance and push-off instants of walking stance were simulated with different levels and combinations of gastrocnemius-soleus recession resembled by different amounts of muscle forces. Halving the muscle forces at midstance reduced the average plantar fascia stress by a quarter while reducing two-third of the muscle forces at push-off reduced the average fascia stress by 18.2%. While the first ray of the plantar fascia experienced the largest stress among the five fasciae, the stress was reduced by 77.8% and 16.9% when the load was halved and reduced by two-third at midstance and push-off instants, respectively. Reduction in fascia stress implicates a lower risk of plantar fasciitis and other midfoot-forefoot overload syndromes. The outcome of this study can aid physicians to determine the amount of gastrocnemius-soleus recession towards patients with vdifferent levels of plantar fascia overstress. A detailed three-dimensional modelling on the plantar fascia is warranted in future study.

Treatment of "plantar fasciitis"/Plantar Heel Pain Syndrome with botulinum toxin - A novel injection paradigm pilot study

Randomized controlled trials over the last two decades, although promising with favorable results, have shown varied efficacy in treatment of "plantar fasciitis" with botulinum toxin injection¹. One reason may be due to conflating the variabilities of plantar heel conditions solely as plantar fasciitis. Plantar Heel Pain Syndrome can be of one or more etiologies and symptoms which refutes the mistaken tendency to categorize all plantar heel pain singularly as either plantar fasciitis or fasciosis. Recognizing that there is likely an interplay of inflammatory, degenerative, and neuropathic etiologic conditions of this often-difficult malady to treat, a novel injection paradigm of botulinum toxin is explored in the treatment of 4 distinct presentations of Plantar Heel Pain Syndrome with encouraging results. Botulinum toxin injection into two intrinsic foot muscles; Abductor Hallucis and Quadratus Plantae at their origins with electrical stimulation is presented as novel method to treat four distinct etiologies of Plantar Heel Pain Syndrome. This method of botulinum toxin injection resulted in significant prolonged improvement of patient function and pain reduction in four variations of Plantar Heel Pain Syndrome. A precise injection paradigm facilitated with direct intrinsic muscle stimulation of the Abductor Hallucis and Quadratus Plantae at their origins may prove to be effective in reducing the disabilities of Plantar Heel Pain Syndrome and its associated pain.

Biomechanical comparison of tenodesis reconstruction for subtalar instability: a finite element analysis

Background

There are several types of tenodesis reconstruction designed for subtalar instability. However, no comprehensive comparison has been conducted among these procedures in terms of their correcting power so far. The objective of this study is to evaluate the biomechanical behaviors of 5 representative procedures through finite element analysis.

Methods

Finite element models were established and validated based on one of our previous studies. The Pisani interosseous talocalcaneal ligament (ITCL) reconstruction, Schon cervical ligament (CL) reconstruction and Choisne calcaneofibular ligament (CFL) reconstruction were compared on the model with the CFL, ITCL and CL sectioned. The Schon triligamentous reconstruction and Mann triligamentous reconstruction were compared on the model with the CFL, ITCL and CL, as well as the ATFL sectioned. The inversion and external/internal rotation were quantified at different ankle positions based on the rotational moment. Then, the stress in ligaments and reconstructed grafts and the contact characteristics of the subtalar joint under inversional stress test were calculated and compared accordingly.

Results

For single ligament reconstruction, the Choisne CFL reconstruction provided the greatest degree of correction for subtalar instability, followed by the Schon CL reconstruction and then the Pisani ITCL reconstruction. For triligamentous reconstruction, the Mann procedure outperformed the Schon procedure in alleviating the subtalar instability.

Conclusion

The finite element analysis showed that the Choisne CFL reconstruction and Mann triligamentous reconstruction provided the greatest degree of immediate postoperative subtalar stability. However, both procedures could not restore the biomechanical behaviors of the subtalar joint to normal. The long-term efficacy of these procedures warrants further investigation using a substantially larger sample of clinical cases.

Comparison of midterm results of Platelet Rich Plasma (PRP) versus Steroid for plantar fasciitis: A randomized control trial of 118 patients

BACKGROUND

Plantar fasciitis, which is a common cause of heel pain, often results in significant morbidity. In cases who are not responsive to initial conservative treatment, invasive procedures, often in the form of local infiltration of steroid are required. These procedures are associated with significant complications. Local Platelet Rich Plasma (PRP) infiltration is an emerging addition to these treatments. However, whether it is more effective in reducing pain and improving function than other treatments (such as steroid injections or whole blood) remains controversial.

METHODS

Skeletally mature patients with plantar fasciitis who had failed conservative therapy were randomized using envelope method into 2 groups: PRP and Steroid group. The participants were assessed for pain using Visual Analog Scale on the day of presentation, and then after therapy at 2 weeks, 4 weeks, 3 months, and 6 months. They were additionally assessed on final follow-up using AOFAS hind-foot Score.

RESULTS

118 patients were randomized into 2 groups: 58 patients to the PRP group and 60 to the Steroid group. PRP was associated with greater improvement in VAS score and resulted in superior AOFAS score at 6 months as compared to steroid injection. The authors did not find any local or systemic complications in any of the groups. The result and difference were more pronounced as the time from injection increased and maximal benefit was observed at 6 months follow-up. None of the patients needed a repeat injection at 6 months.

CONCLUSION

Our study expands on the previous studies to provide a better evidence for superiority of PRP over local injection of steroid in plantar fasciitis, and the authors conclude that PRP provides better pain relief and function as compared to steroid injection.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 1 Prospective Randomized Control Trial (RCT).

Surgical Repair of Complete Plantar Fascia Ruptures in High-Demand Power Athletes: An Alternative Treatment Option

Surgical repair of complete plantar fascia ruptures has not yet been reported in the literature. Operative technique and outcome are described in 2 gymnasts with heavy plyometric demands who received surgical repair compared with 3 athletes treated nonoperatively. Biomechanics and clinical implications are discussed. In the last 8 years, we have seen 5 high-demand athletes with total rupture of the plantar fascia. This is a retrospective clinical evaluation 1.5 to 8 years postinjury of all 5 patients using dynamic ultrasound, Foot Function Index, sports-specific questions, Foot Posture Index, and foot length. The operated gymnasts returned to the same level of performance within 12 months. None of the conservatively treated athletes returned to preinjury plyometric sports levels but reached a foot load capacity of distance running with the injured foot as limiting factor. Ultrasound with simultaneous dorsiflexion of the toes showed a normal fascia in the operated patients, but a slack fascia that tightened up only at terminal toe dorsiflexion in the conservatively treated group. According to the Foot Function Index, the operated patients reported no complaints, whereas the nonoperative group had clinical relevant impairments in activities of daily life. The Foot Posture Index in all nonoperated patients showed a relative shift toward pronation with increased foot length compared with the noninjured foot. The operated patients showed no difference in foot length but minimal shift into supination with a slightly altered arch contour. Surgical repair of plantar fascia ruptures is technically feasible to restore normal foot load capability with return to high-demand plyometric sports within 12 months.

Does the minimally invasive complete plantar fasciotomy result in deformity of the Plantar arch? A prospective study

BACKGROUND

Complete plantar fasciotomy has been associated with changes in foot loading, leading to medial longitudinal arch collapse. The purpose of this study is to analyse our clinical experience with percutaneous complete plantar fasciotomy and quantify the possible changes in foot loading measured by the calcaneal pitch angle.

METHODS

A prospective case series study with patients operated between 2005-2012 was conducted, where AOFAS, Maryland Foot Score (MFS), VAS and radiological calcaneal pitch (CP) were recorded. Postoperative data were collected, where the surgeon evaluated the presence of complications, and an independent investigator performed radiological and scale evaluations follow-up: AOFAS, MFS, VAS and Benton-Weil questionnaire.

RESULTS

A total of 60 patients, 62 feet, with a mean follow-up of 57 months (range 13-107) were studied. The MFS increased a mean of 21 points (p=.001), the AOFAS score a mean of 25 points (p=.001), and the VAS decreased a mean of 8.89 points (p=.001). A total of fifty-seven feet (91.9%) were pain-free at the end of follow-up. The mean CP dropped from 20.2° (range 11-34) preoperatively to 19.3° (range 11-34) at the end of follow-up (p=.05). In 25 feet (40.3%) there were no changes in the calcaneus pitch angle, in 21 feet dropped 1° (33.9%), in 11 dropped 2° (17.8%), 3 feet 3° (4.8%) and 2 feet (3.2%) 4°. Postoperative complications were noted in 4 feet (6.4%), with lateral column pain. The surgery meets the expectations of all patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Percutaneous total fascia release is safe and does not produce a significant drop in arch height based on the radiological finding. Lack of success after surgery may be explained by other pathologies that might appear like plantar fasciitis. Further studies with gait analysis after total plantar fascia release in patients are needed.

Endoscopic plantar fasciotomy for plantar fasciitis: A systematic review and network meta-analysis of the English literature

BACKGROUND

Currently, there is limited evidence on outcomes for endoscopic plantar fasciotomy.

OBJECTIVES

An evidence-based literature review for outcomes of endoscopic plantar fasciotomy for the treatment of plantar fasciitis is provided.

METHODS

A comprehensive evidence-based literature review of PubMed and Cochrane databases was conducted on 9th March 2019, which identified 12 relevant articles assessing the efficacy of endoscopic plantar fasciotomy. The studies were then assigned to a level of evidence (I-IV). Individual studies were reviewed to provide a grade of recommendation (A-C, I) according to the Wright classification in support of or against endoscopic plantar fascia release.

RESULTS

Based on the results of this evidence-based review, there is poor evidence (grade C) to support endoscopic plantar fascia release. Release of the medial 2/3 of the plantar fascia in endoscopic plantar fasciotomy was associated with higher AOFAS score.

CONCLUSION

Although the majority of the level of evidence was low (level IV) and grade of recommendation was poor (grade C), there seemed to be good outcomes for endoscopic plantar fasciotomy. There is a need for more high quality level I randomized controlled trials with validated outcome measures to allow for stronger recommendations to be made.

The Receptive and Propulsive Behavior of Human Foot Joints During Running With Different Striking Strategies

Foot structure and kinematics have long been considered as risk factors for foot and lower-limb running injuries. The authors aimed at investigating foot joint kinetics to unravel their receptive and propulsive characteristics while running barefoot, both with rearfoot and with midfoot striking strategies. Power absorption and generation occurring at different joints of the foot in 6 asymptomatic adults were calculated using both a 3-segment and a 4-segment kinetic model. An inverse dynamic approach was used to quantify mechanical power. Major power absorption and generation characteristics were observed at the ankle joint complex as well as at the Chopart joint in both the rearfoot and the midfoot striking strategies. The power at the Lisfranc joint, quantified by the 4-segment kinetic model, was predominantly generated in both strategies, and at the toes, it was absorbed. The overall results show a large variability in the receptive and propulsive characteristics among the analyzed joints in both striking strategies. The present study may provide novel insight for clinical decision making to address foot and lower-limb injuries and to guide athletes in the adoption of different striking strategies during running.

Nonanatomic versus anatomic techniques in spring ligament reconstruction: biomechanical assessment via a finite element model

Background

Several approaches to spring ligament reconstruction have been reported. However, a comparative study of nonanatomic and anatomic techniques with respect to biomechanical responses, such as kinematics and contact characteristics, has not been previously performed via a finite element analysis. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the biomechanical results of such spring ligament reconstructions via a finite element analysis.

Methods

A three-dimensional finite element model of the foot was developed and validated, and four reconstruction methods were simulated. The talonavicular dorsiflexion and abduction, hindfoot valgus, and contact characteristics in the Chopart joints were quantified in each model.

Results

Nonanatomic reconstructions corrected the talonavicular and hindfoot deformities to a greater extent than the anatomic reconstructions. The anatomic techniques also corrected the abduction and dorsiflexion deformities, although they presented insufficient power to correct for hindfoot valgus. None of the procedures restored the contact characteristics of the talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints to those of a normal condition.

Conclusion

Nonanatomic reconstruction of the spring ligament complex provided the greatest correction for midfoot and hindfoot misalignments in flatfoot. Severe deformities with large amounts of midfoot pronation and hindfoot valgus may be better treated with nonanatomic reconstruction methods. The spring ligament reconstruction method may mitigate the need for nonanatomic bony procedures associated with complications and allows for the preservation of the triple joint complex.

Endoscopic Plantar Fasciotomy Through Two Medial Portals for the Treatment of Recalcitrant Plantar Fasciopathy

Plantar fasciopathy is a common cause of heel pain. Endoscopic plantar fasciotomy has the advantage of less surgical trauma and rapid recovery. The aim of the present prospective study was to delineate the results of endoscopic plantar fascia release through 2 medial portals. The present study included 2 groups. The first group included 27 feet in 25 patients that had undergone endoscopic plantar fascia release followed up for 19.7 (range 12 to 33) months. The second group, the control group, included 20 feet in 16 patients treated conservatively and followed up for 16.4 (range 12 to 24) months. The results of endoscopic plantar fascia release were superior to the conservative methods. The surgically treated group experienced significantly less pain, activity limitations, and gait abnormality. The presence of a calcaneal spur had no effect on the final postoperative score. In conclusion, endoscopic plantar fascia release through 2 medial portals is an effective procedure for treatment of resistant plantar fasciopathy that fails to respond to conservative management options.

Effects of platelet-rich plasma in the treatment of plantar fasciitis: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

BACKGROUND

Plantar fasciitis is a common cause of heel pain, which often results in significant morbidity. There have been several treatment options that are used for plantar fasciitis, including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, orthoses, physical therapy, and steroid injections.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this meta-analysis was to compare the effects of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) and other treatments in patients with plantar fasciitis.

SEARCH METHODS

Medline, Web of Science, and Embase were systematically searched to identify relevant trials.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that compared the effects of PRP and other treatments on plantar fasciitis were included.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

The main outcomes included changes from baseline in visual analog scale (VAS) score, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society Score (AOFAS), and Roles-Maudsley score (RMS). Results were expressed as weight mean difference (WMD) with 95% confidence interval (95% CI). The meta-analysis was performed using a fixed-effects or random-effects model according to heterogeneity.

MAIN RESULTS

Ten RCTs involving a total of 445 patients with plantar fasciitis were included. Among these studies, 9 compared PRP with steroid, and 1 compared PRP with whole blood.Four studies were categorized as being at low risk of bias, and the remaining 6 as being at unclear risk of bias.Pooled estimates suggested that PRP had greater changes in VAS and AOFAS scores than other treatments. However, it had no benefit effect in the RMS.Subgroup analysis for VAS and AOFAS showed that PRP had superior effect than other treatments at 12 months, but not at the 1, 3, 6 months.Subgroup analysis based on treatment regimens demonstrated that PRP was more effective than steroid in the change from baseline in AOFAS, but not in VAS and RMS scores.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSION

PRP was as effective as other treatments in reducing pain and improving function in patients with plantar fasciitis. Subgroup analysis indicated that PRP had better effect than steroid in AOFAS Score and its effect was durable in a long term. However, considering the potential limitations in this study, more large-scale RCTs are needed to confirm the current findings.

Towards patient-specific medializing calcaneal osteotomy for adult flatfoot: a finite element study

Clinically in medializing calcaneal osteotomy (MCO), foot and ankle surgeons are facing difficulties in choosing appropriate surgical parameters due to the individual differences in deformities among flatfoot patients. Traditional cadaveric studies have provided important information regarding the biomechanical effects of tendons, ligaments, and plantar fascia, but limitations have been reached when dealing with individual differences and tailoring patient-specific surgeries. Therefore, this study aimed at implementing the finite element (FE) method to investigate the effect of different MCO parameters to help foot and ankle surgeons performing patient-specific surgeries. This study constructed FE models of a flatfoot and a healthy foot based on computed tomography (CT) images. After validating the FE models with experimental measurements, differences in plantar stress were compared between two models and a criterion was established for evaluating the performance of surgical simulations. Four MCO parameters were then studied through FE simulations. Results suggested that the transverse angle, β, and translation distance, d, affected surgical performance. Therefore, special attentions may be recommended when choosing these two parameters clinically. However, the sagittal angle, α, and osteotomy position, p, were found to have less effect on the MCO performance.

Mid-Sole Release of the Plantar Fascia Combined With Percutaneous Drilling of the Calcaneus for Treatment of Resistant Heel Pain

BACKGROUND

Heel pain with or without calcaneal spur is a challenging problem. Once conservative measures have failed, surgery may be indicated; there has been debate about the best surgical procedure. Two standard operative procedures have been either releasing the plantar fascia or removing the spur with drilling of the calcaneus. In this study, we evaluated the results of percutaneous drilling of the calcaneus combined with mid-sole release of the plantar fascia for treatment of resistant heel pain.

METHODS

This study included 20 cases with resistant heel pain after failure of conservative measures for 6 months. Clinical, radiological evaluation and scoring patients' conditions according to the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) Ankle-Hindfoot scale was done preoperatively and postoperatively. Percutaneous drilling of the calcaneus combined with mid-sole release of the plantar fascia was done in all cases, and the functional results were evaluated through the follow-up period that extended from 9 to 16 months with a mean duration of 12 ± 2.3 months.

RESULTS

There was statistically significant improvement in the mean AOFAS Ankle-Hindfoot scale score from 50.8 ± 7.5 preoperatively to 91.6 ± 7 postoperatively at the last follow-up. There were no surgery-related complications, and the mean time for full recovery was 8 ± 3.7 weeks with no recurrence of pain by the last follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

The results were very satisfactory with using this minimally invasive and simple technique for treatment for resistant heel pain.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, retrospective case series.

A Finite Element Model of the Foot/Ankle to Evaluate Injury Risk in Various Postures

The foot/ankle complex is frequently injured in many types of debilitating events, such as car crashes. Numerical models used to assess injury risk are typically minimally validated and do not account for ankle posture variations that frequently occur during these events. The purpose of this study was to evaluate a finite element model of the foot and ankle accounting for these positional changes. A model was constructed from computed tomography scans of a male cadaveric lower leg and was evaluated by comparing simulated bone positions and strain responses to experimental results at five postures in which fractures are commonly reported. The bone positions showed agreement typically within 6° or less in all anatomical directions, and strain matching was consistent with the range of errors observed in similar studies (typically within 50% of the average strains). Fracture thresholds and locations in each posture were also estimated to be similar to those reported in the literature (ranging from 6.3 kN in the neutral posture to 3.9 kN in combined eversion and external rotation). The least vulnerable posture was neutral, and all other postures had lower fracture thresholds, indicating that examination of the fracture threshold of the lower limb in the neutral posture alone may be an underestimation. This work presents an important step forward in the modeling of lower limb injury risk in altered ankle postures. Potential clinical applications of the model include the development of postural guidelines to minimize injury, as well as the evaluation of new protective systems.

Treatment of Plantar Fasciitis With Botulinum Toxin

BACKGROUND

This study examined the effect of botulinum toxin upon plantar fasciitis through a randomized, controlled, and blinded trial.

MATERIALS

Between 2012 and 2015, 50 patients presented with plantar fasciitis. Twenty-five patients each randomly received an IncobotulinumtoxinA (IBTA) or saline injection of their affected foot. Pre- and postinjection function and pain were graded with the Foot and Ankle Ability Measures (FAAM) and visual analog scale (VAS), respectively. All 50 study patients who randomly received either placebo or IBTA presented at 6 and 12 months after injection.

RESULTS

At 6 months, the mean FAAM increased from 35.9 to 40.9 of 100, and the mean pain score decreased from 8.4 to 7.9 of 10 within the placebo group. At 6 months, the mean FAAM increased from 36.3 to 73.8 of 100, and mean pain score decreased from 7.2 to 3.6 of 10 within the IBTA group. These postinjection scores were significantly better than the placebo group ( P = .01). At 12 months after injection, the IBTA group maintained significantly better function and pain than the placebo group ( P < .05). By that time, 0 (0%) and 3 (12%) patients who received IBTA and saline, respectively, underwent surgery for recalcitrant plantar fasciitis ( P < .005).

CONCLUSION

Compared with placebo saline injection, using IBTA to treat plantar fasciitis resulted in significantly better improvement in foot function and pain. IBTA also lessened the need for operative treatment of plantar fasciitis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

I, Randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled study.

Diagnosis and management of plantar fasciitis

Plantar fasciitis, a chronic degenerative process that causes medial plantar heel pain, is responsible for approximately 1 million physician visits each year. Individuals with plantar fasciitis experience pain that is most intense during their first few steps of the day or after prolonged standing. The authors provide an overview of the diagnosis and management of a common problem encountered in the primary care setting. Routine imaging is not initially recommended for the evaluation of plantar fasciitis but may be required to rule out other pathologic conditions. Overall, plantar fasciitis carries a good prognosis when patients use a combination of several conservative treatment modalities. Occasionally, referral to a specialist may be necessary.

Determination of the in situ mechanical behavior of ankle ligaments

The mechanical behavior of ankle ligaments at the structural level can be characterized by force-displacement curves in the physiologic phase up to the initiation of failure. However, these properties are difficult to characterize in vitro due to the experimental difficulties in replicating the complex geometry and non-uniformity of the loading state in situ. This study used a finite element parametric modeling approach to determine the in situ mechanical behavior of ankle ligaments at neutral foot position for a mid-sized adult foot from experimental derived bony kinematics. Nine major ankle ligaments were represented as a group of fibers, with the force-elongation behavior of each fiber element characterized by a zero-force region and a region of constant stiffness. The zero-force region, representing the initial tension or slackness of the whole ligament and the progressive fiber uncrimping, was identified against a series of quasi-static experiments of single foot motion using simultaneous optimization. A range of 0.33-3.84mm of the zero-force region was obtained, accounting for a relative length of 6.7±3.9%. The posterior ligaments generally exhibit high-stiffness in the loading region. Following this, the ankle model implemented with in situ ligament behavior was evaluated in response to multiple loading conditions and proved capable of predicting the bony kinematics accurately in comparison to the cadaveric response. Overall, the parametric ligament modeling demonstrated the feasibility of linking the gross structural behavior and the underlying bone and ligament mechanics that generate them. Determination of the in situ mechanical properties of ankle ligaments provides a better understanding of the nonlinear nature of the ankle joint. Applications of this knowledge include functional ankle joint mechanics and injury biomechanics.

A framework for parametric modeling of ankle ligaments to determine the in situ response under gross foot motion

Ligament sprains account for a majority of injuries to the foot and ankle complex, but ligament properties have not been understood well due to the difficulties in replicating the complex geometry, in situ stress state, and non-uniformity of the strain. For a full investigation of the injury mechanism, it is essential to build up a foot and ankle model validated at the level of bony kinematics and ligament properties. This study developed a framework to parameterize the ligament response for determining the in situ stress state and heterogeneous force-elongation characteristics using a finite element ankle model. Nine major ankle ligaments and the interosseous membrane were modeled as discrete elements corresponding functionally to the ligamentous microstructure of collagen fibers and having parameterized toe region and stiffness at the fiber level. The range of the design variables in the ligament model was determined from existing experimental data. Sensitivity of the bony kinematics to each variable was investigated by design of experiment. The results highlighted the critical role of the length of the toe region of the ligamentous fibers on the bony kinematics with the cumulative influence of more than 95%, while the fiber stiffness was statistically insignificant with an influence of less than 1% under the given variable range and loading conditions. With the flexibility of variable adjustment and high computational efficiency, the presented ankle model was generic in nature so as to maximize its applicability to capture the individual ligament behaviors in future studies.

Platelet rich plasma versus corticosteroid injection for plantar fasciitis: A comparative study

INTRODUCTION

Intractable plantar fasciitis can be a difficult condition to treat. Early results of platelet rich plasma (PRP) injection have been promising. We compared PRP to traditional cortisone injection in the treatment of chronic cases of plantar fasciitis resistant to traditional nonoperative management. The aim of the study was to compare the efficacy of PRP to that of Steroid at 3, 6 and 12 months after injection.

METHODS

60 heels with intractable plantar fasciitis who had failed conservative treatment were randomised to receive either PRP or Steroid injection. All patients were assessed with the Roles-Maudsley (RM) Score, Visual Analogue Score (VAS) for pain and the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score. Data was collected prospectively on the cohort, pre-treatment, at 3, 6 and 12 months post injection and the results were compared.

RESULTS

Pre-injection, the two groups were well matched with no statistically significant difference. At 3 months, all three outcome scores had significantly improved from their pretreatment level in both groups. The scores in the Steroid arm were marginally better than in the PRP arm, but this difference was not statistically significant. At 6 months, there was no statistically significant difference between the two groups, though there was a trend for the PRP scores to become better than the Steroid scores. At 12 months, the RM, VAS and AOFAS scores in the PRP arm (1.9, 3.3 and 88.5) were significantly better than the Steroid arm (2.6, 5.3 and 75) with P values of .013, .028 and .033, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

PRP is as effective as Steroid injection at achieving symptom relief at 3 and 6 months after injection, for the treatment of plantar fasciitis, but unlike Steroid, its effect does not wear off with time. At 12 months, PRP is significantly more effective than Steroid, making it better and more durable than cortisone injection.

Finite element modelling of radial shock wave therapy for chronic plantar fasciitis

Therapeutic use of high-amplitude pressure waves, or shock wave therapy (SWT), is emerging as a popular method for treating musculoskeletal disorders. However, the mechanism(s) through which this technique promotes healing are unclear. Finite element models of a shock wave source and the foot were constructed to gain a better understanding of the mechanical stimuli that SWT produces in the context of plantar fasciitis treatment. The model of the shock wave source was based on the geometry of an actual radial shock wave device, in which pressure waves are generated through the collision of two metallic objects: a projectile and an applicator. The foot model was based on the geometry reconstructed from magnetic resonance images of a volunteer and it comprised bones, cartilage, soft tissue, plantar fascia, and Achilles tendon. Dynamic simulations were conducted of a single and of two successive shock wave pulses administered to the foot. The collision between the projectile and the applicator resulted in a stress wave in the applicator. This wave was transmitted into the soft tissue in the form of compression-rarefaction pressure waves with an amplitude of the order of several MPa. The negative pressure at the plantar fascia reached values of over 1.5 MPa, which could be sufficient to generate cavitation in the tissue. The results also show that multiple shock wave pulses may have a cumulative effect in terms of strain energy accumulation in the foot.

Chronic Plantar Fasciitis is Mediated by Local Hemodynamics: Implications for Emerging Therapies

Plantar fasciitis (PF) is a common, disabling condition affecting millions of patients each year. With early diagnosis and timely application of traditional nonsurgical treatments, symptoms generally resolve over time. However, despite adequate treatment, 20% of patients will experience persistent symptoms. In these patients, minimally invasive therapies that augment local hemodynamics to initiate a regenerative tissue-healing cascade have the greatest potential to resolve long-standing symptoms. We performed a narrative review based on a best evidence evaluation of manuscripts published in Medline-indexed journals to determine the mechanisms involved in soft tissue injury and healing. This evaluation also highlights emerging minimally invasive therapies that exploit these mechanisms in recalcitrant PF.

An in vitro and finite element study of load redistribution in the midfoot

A good knowledge of midfoot biomechanics is important in understanding the biomechanics of the entire foot, but it has never been investigated thoroughly in the literature. This study carried out in vitro experiments and finite element analysis to investigate the midfoot biomechanics. A foot-ankle finite element model simulating the mid-stance phase of the normal gait was developed and the model validated in in vitro experimental tests. Experiments used seven in vitro samples of fresh human cadavers. The simulation found that the first principal stress peaks of all midfoot bones occurred at the navicular bone and that the tensile force of the spring ligament was greater than that of any other ligament. The experiments showed that the longitudinal strain acting on the medial cuneiform bone was -26.2±10.8 μ-strain, and the navicular strain was -240.0±169.1 μ-strain along the longitudinal direction and 65.1±25.8 μ-strain along the transverse direction. The anatomical position and the spring ligament both result in higher shear stress in the navicular bone. The load from the ankle joint to five branches of the forefoot is redistributed among the cuneiforms and cuboid bones. Further studies on the mechanism of loading redistribution will be helpful in understanding the biomechanics of the entire foot.

Optimization of nonlinear hyperelastic coefficients for foot tissues using a magnetic resonance imaging deformation experiment

Accurate prediction of plantar shear stress and internal stress in the soft tissue layers of the foot using finite element models would provide valuable insight into the mechanical etiology of neuropathic foot ulcers. Accurate prediction of the internal stress distribution using finite element models requires that realistic descriptions of the material properties of the soft tissues are incorporated into the model. Our investigation focused on the creation of a novel three-dimensional (3D) finite element model of the forefoot with multiple soft tissue layers (skin, fat pad, and muscle) and the development of an inverse finite element procedure that would allow for the optimization of the nonlinear elastic coefficients used to define the material properties of the skin muscle and fat pad tissue layers of the forefoot based on a Ogden hyperelastic constitutive model. Optimization was achieved by comparing deformations predicted by finite element models to those measured during an experiment in which magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) images were acquired while the plantar surface forefoot was compressed. The optimization procedure was performed for both a model incorporating all three soft tissue layers and one in which all soft tissue layers were modeled as a single layer. The results indicated that the inclusion of multiple tissue layers affected the deformation and stresses predicted by the model. Sensitivity analysis performed on the optimized coefficients indicated that small changes in the coefficient values (±10%) can have rather large impacts on the predicted nominal strain (differences up to 14%) in a given tissue layer.

STRESS DISTRIBUTION WITHIN THE PLANTAR APONEUROSIS DURING WALKING — A DYNAMIC FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS

Excessive and repeated loading of the plantar aponeurosis (PA) is believed to be the most likely risk factor for developing plantar fasciitis. This study provided a novel approach to investigate the biomechanical responses of the PA during the entire stance phase of gait. One healthy subject was recruited for all the experimental measurements to validate the approach in this study. A three-dimensional (3D) finite element (FE) foot model representing this individual, with emphasis on the PA as a transversely isotropic tissue, was constructed. Kinematic data of foot motions were collected during a walking trial to serve as input conditions for the model. A peak tensile force of 922 N on the PA was found during the terminal-stance phase rather than during the mid-stance phase. The maximal peak von Mises stresses in the PA from the medial to lateral regions of the foot measured 15.61, 14.98 and 11.4 MPa at 74%, 77% and 82% of the stance phase, respectively. These peak stresses all occurred near the proximal calcaneal bony insertion site of the PA and correspond closely with the location where plantar fasciitis develops. Future work should include more subjects and clinical trials before applying these findings to the treatment of plantar fasciitis.

Platelet-rich plasma efficacy versus corticosteroid injection treatment for chronic severe plantar fasciitis

BACKGROUND

Chronic plantar fasciitis is a common orthopedic condition that can prove difficult to successfully treat. In this study, autologous platelet-rich plasma (PRP), a concentrated bioactive blood component rich in cytokines and growth factors, was compared to traditional cortisone injection in the treatment of chronic cases of plantar fasciitis resistant to traditional nonoperative management.

METHODS

Forty patients (23 females and 17 males) with unilateral chronic plantar fasciitis that did not respond to a minimum of 4 months of standardized traditional nonoperative treatment modalities were prospectively randomized and treated with either a single ultrasound guided injection of 3 cc PRP or 40 mg DepoMedrol cortisone. American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) hindfoot scoring was completed for all patients immediately prior to PRP or cortisone injection (pretreatment = time 0) and at 3, 6, 12, and 24 months following injection treatment. Baseline pretreatment radiographs and MRI studies were obtained in all cases to confirm the diagnosis of plantar fasciitis.

RESULTS

The cortisone group had a pretreatment average AOFAS score of 52, which initially improved to 81 at 3 months posttreatment but decreased to 74 at 6 months, then dropped to near baseline levels of 58 at 12 months, and continued to decline to a final score of 56 at 24 months. In contrast, the PRP group started with an average pretreatment AOFAS score of 37, which increased to 95 at 3 months, remained elevated at 94 at 6 and 12 months, and had a final score of 92 at 24 months.

CONCLUSIONS

PRP was more effective and durable than cortisone injection for the treatment of chronic recalcitrant cases of plantar fasciitis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level I, prospective randomized comparative series.

Surgery for Patients With Recalcitrant Plantar Fasciitis: Good Results at Short-, Medium-, and Long-term Follow-up

BACKGROUND

Plantar fasciitis is a common cause of foot pain, and although many episodes are self-limiting with short duration, 10% leave chronic symptoms. Recalcitrant cases can be managed surgically, with studies demonstrating good results in the short term but uncertainties over longer term outcomes.

PURPOSE

To assess the outcome following surgical intervention for patients with plantar fasciitis.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

Seventy-nine patients were identified from operative diaries undergoing plantar fasciotomy surgery between 1993 and 2009. They were contacted to investigate long-term results using self-reported outcome measures.

RESULTS

Sixty-eight responses were received (86% response rate), with an average of 7 years (range, 1-15 years) of follow-up. Patients reported an average reduction in pain by visual analog scale of 79%, and 84% of patients were happy with the surgical results. Greater success was achieved in patients with shorter duration of symptoms preoperatively. No deterioration in success was seen over time.

CONCLUSION

Plantar fasciotomy surgery for plantar fasciitis remains controversial, with biomechanical arguments against surgery; however, this article reports good success following surgery over a long follow-up period. The results of current operative techniques need to be fully investigated for longer term success, as do the outcomes of newer nonoperative management strategies.

Validation of a population of patient-specific adult acquired flatfoot deformity models

Adult acquired flatfoot deformity (AAFD) is a degenerative disease resulting in malalignment of the mid- and hindfoot secondary to posterior tibial tendon dysfunction and increasing implication of ligament pathologies. Despite the complex 3D nature of AAFD, 2D radiographs are still employed to diagnose and stage the disease. Computer modeling techniques allow for accurate 3D recreations of musculoskeletal systems for the investigation of biomechanical factors contributing to disease. Following Institutional Review Board approval, the lower limbs of six diagnosed AAFD sufferers were imaged with MRI, photographs, and X-ray. Next, a radiologist graded the MRI attenuation of eight soft-tissues implicated in AAFD. Six patient-specific rigid-body models were then created and loaded according to patient weight, graded soft-tissues, and extrinsic muscles. Model function was validated using clinically relevant kinematic measures in three planes. Agreement varied depending on the measure, with average absolute deviations of < 7° for angles and <4 mm for distances. Additionally, the clinically favored AP talonavicular coverage angle, ML talo-1st metatarsal angle, and ML 1st cuneiform height showed strong correlations of R(2) = 0.63, 0.75, and 0.85, respectively. Thus, computer modeling offers a promising methodology for the non-invasive investigation of in vivo kinematic behavior in pathologic feet and, once validated, may further be used to investigate biomechanical parameters that are difficult to measure clinically.

Subcalcaneal bursitis with plantar fasciitis treated by arthroscopy

We report the successful arthroscopic treatment of a case of subcalcaneal bursitis with plantar fasciitis. To our knowledge, this is the first report on arthroscopic excision of a subcalcaneal bursa. Right heel pain developed in a 50-year-old woman, without any obvious cause. She reported that the heel pain occurred immediately after waking and that the heel ached when she walked. Magnetic resonance imaging showed an extra-articular, homogeneous, high-intensity lesion in the fat pad adjacent to the calcaneal tubercle on T2-weighted sagittal and coronal images and thickening of the plantar fascia on T2-weighted sagittal images. A diagnosis of a recalcitrant subcalcaneal bursitis with plantar fasciitis was made, and surgery was performed. The arthroscope was placed between the calcaneus and the plantar fascia. With the surgeon viewing from the lateral portal and working from the medial portal, the dorsal surface of the degenerative plantar fascia was debrided and the medial half of the plantar fascia was released, followed by debridement of the subcalcaneal bursal cavity through the incised plantar fascia. Full weight bearing and gait were allowed immediately after the operation. At the latest follow-up, the patient had achieved complete resolution of heel pain without a recurrence of the mass, confirmed by magnetic resonance imaging.

Endoscopic approach for plantar fasciopathy: a long-term retrospective study

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to report the long term effectiveness of endoscopic plantar fascia release for recalcitrant plantar fasciopathy.

MATERIALS

Twenty-three consecutive patients underwent endoscopically-assisted plantar fascia release for symptomatic plantar fasciopathy unresponsive to nonoperative measures. The clinical diagnosis was supported by imaging (plain radiographs and magnetic resonance imaging [MRI]) and the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score was administered to all patients. All patients underwent endoscopic plantar fascia release. Postoperatively, patients were assessed at clinical examination and the AOFAS score was administered.

RESULTS

Twenty-two (26 feet) of the 23 patients included in our original cohort returned to our clinic at an average final follow-up of 9.6 years. The mean preoperative AOFAS score of 51 (range, 41-63) improved to 89 (range, 41-97) at the last follow-up, with no statistically significant difference between patients with or without calcaneal bone spur (p = 0.43). At the last appointment, physically active patients reported significantly higher AOFAS scores than sedentary patients (p = .008).

CONCLUSIONS

This endoscopic plantar approach could be a viable alternative to more invasive procedures for management of recalcitrant plantar fasciopathy. Future randomised controlled trials are needed.

Open technique is more effective than percutaneous technique for TOPAZ radiofrequency coblation for plantar fasciitis

BACKGROUND

Microtenotomy coblation using a radiofrequency (RF) probe is a minimally invasive procedure for treating chronic tendinopathy. It has been described for conditions including tennis elbow and rotator cuff tendinitis. There have been no long term studies to show its effectiveness in plantar fasciitis.

METHODS

A prospective non-randomised trial was conducted on 48 patients who had failed conservative treatment for plantar fasciitis, between 2007 and 2009. The procedure was performed using the TOPAZ microdebrider device (ArthroCare, Sunnyvale, CA), either via an open or a percutaneous method. Fifty-nine feet were treated and followed up for up to 1 year thereafter. Preoperative, 3, 6 and 12 months post-operative VAS pain, American Orthopaedic Foot-Ankle Society (AOFAS) hindfoot and SF-36 scores, patient expectation and satisfaction scores were analysed.

RESULTS

VAS scores improved significantly in both groups at 1-year follow-up. The open group had a more significant improvement in the VAS score at 1-year follow-up. AOFAS hindfoot scores improve significantly for both groups pre- and post-operatively, but there was no significant difference between both groups at the 1-year mark. SF-36 scores showed equally significant improvement in both groups 1 year post-operatively. Expectation and satisfaction scores were equally high in both arms.

CONCLUSIONS

TOPAZ RF coblation is a good and effective method for the treatment of recalcitrant plantar fasciitis. Clinical results improve with time for up to 1-year post-operatively. The open method seems to have a more significant improvement in pain VAS scores at 1-year postoperatively.