Precise A•T to G•C base editing in the zebrafish genome

Cytosine base editors with increased PAM and deaminase motif flexibility for gene editing in zebrafish

Cytosine base editing is a powerful tool for making precise single nucleotide changes in cells and model organisms like zebrafish, which are valuable for studying human diseases. However, current base editors struggle to edit cytosines in certain DNA contexts, particularly those with GC and CC pairs, limiting their use in modelling disease-related mutations. Here we show the development of zevoCDA1, an optimized cytosine base editor for zebrafish that improves editing efficiency across various DNA contexts and reduces restrictions imposed by the protospacer adjacent motif. We also create zevoCDA1-198, a more precise editor with a narrower editing window of five nucleotides, minimizing off-target effects. Using these advanced tools, we successfully generate zebrafish models of diseases that were previously challenging to create due to sequence limitations. This work enhances the ability to introduce human pathogenic mutations in zebrafish, broadening the scope for genomic research with improved precision and efficiency.

Improving precision base editing of the zebrafish genome by Rad51DBD-incorporated single-base editors

Single-base editors, including cytosine base editors (CBEs) and adenine base editors (ABEs), facilitate accurate C•G to T•A and A•T to G•C, respectively, holding promise for the precise modeling and treatment of human hereditary disorders. Efficient base editing and expanded base conversion range have been achieved in human cells through base editors fusing with Rad51 DNA binding domain (Rad51DBD) such as hyA3A-BE4max. Here, we show that hyA3A-BE4max catalyzes C-to-T substitution in the zebrafish genome and extends editing positions (C12-C16) proximal to the protospacer adjacent motif. We develop the codon-optimized counterpart zhyA3A-CBE5, which exhibits substantially high C-to-T conversion with 1.59- to 3.50-fold improvement compared to the original hyA3A-BE4max. With these tools, disease-relevant hereditary mutations can be more efficaciously generated in zebrafish. We introduce human genetic mutation rpl11Q42* and abcc6aR1463C by zhyA3A-CBE5 in zebrafish, mirroring Diamond-Blackfan anemia and Pseudoxanthoma Elasticum, respectively. Our study expands the base editing platform targeting the zebrafish genomic landscape and the application of single-base editors for disease modeling and gene function study.

Standardizing CRISPR-Cas13 knockdown technique to investigate the role of cdh2 gene in pituitary development through growth hormone expression and transcription factors

Introduction

Congenital hypopituitarism (CH) is characterized by the deficiency of pituitary hormones. Among CH patients, 85% lack a molecular diagnosis. Whole Exome Sequencing (WES) identified a homozygous variant (c.865G>A, p.Val289Ile) in the CDH2 gene, responsible for N-Cadherin production, crucial for cell-cell adhesion. Predicted to be likely pathogenic, the variant was found in a patient deficient in GH, TSH, ACTH, and LH/FSH. Its impact on cell adhesion was confirmed in L1 fibroblast cell lines.

Objective

Create a cdh2 knockdown in zebrafish for investigating its role in pituitary development through growth hormone and transcription factors expression.

Methods

Utilized pET28B-RfxCas13d-His plasmid for Cas13 mRNA production via in vitro transcription, guiding Cas13 to cdh2 with three RNAs. Injected the complex into single-cell embryos for analysis up to 96 hpf. Assessed gene expression of cdh2, prop1, pit1, and gh1 using RT-qPCR. Evaluated cdh2 protein expression through the western blot technique.

Results

Knockdown animals displayed developmental delay. The cdh2 expression decreased by 75% within 24 hours, rebounded by 48 hours, and reached wild-type levels by 96 hpf. gh1 expression decreased at 48h but increased by 96 hpf, aligning with WT. No significant differences in prop1 and pit1 expression were observed.

Conclusion

Our findings underscore cdh2's role in pituitary development and hormonal regulation, offering insights for developmental biology research.

ABE-ultramax for high-efficiency biallelic adenine base editing in zebrafish

Advancements in CRISPR technology, particularly the development of base editors, revolutionize genetic variant research. When combined with model organisms like zebrafish, base editors significantly accelerate and refine in vivo analysis of genetic variations. However, base editors are restricted by protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) sequences and specific editing windows, hindering their applicability to a broad spectrum of genetic variants. Additionally, base editors can introduce unintended mutations and often exhibit reduced efficiency in living organisms compared to cultured cell lines. Here, we engineer a suite of adenine base editors (ABEs) called ABE-Ultramax (Umax), demonstrating high editing efficiency and low rates of insertions and deletions (indels) in zebrafish. The ABE-Umax suite of editors includes ABEs with shifted, narrowed, or broadened editing windows, reduced bystander mutation frequency, and highly flexible PAM sequence requirements. These advancements have the potential to address previous challenges in disease modeling and advance gene therapy applications.

Genome editing: An insight into disease resistance, production efficiency, and biomedical applications in livestock

One of the primary concerns for the survival of the human species is the growing demand for food brought on by an increasing global population. New developments in genome-editing technology present promising opportunities for the growth of wholesome and prolific farm animals. Genome editing in large animals is used for a variety of purposes, including biotechnology to improve food production, animal health, and pest management, as well as the development of animal models for fundamental research and biomedicine. Genome editing entails modifying genetic material by removing, adding, or manipulating particular DNA sequences from a particular locus in a way that does not happen naturally. The three primary genome editors are CRISPR/Cas 9, TALENs, and ZFNs. Each of these enzymes is capable of precisely severing nuclear DNA at a predetermined location. One of the most effective inventions is base editing, which enables single base conversions without the requirement for a DNA double-strand break (DSB). As reliable methods for precise genome editing in studies involving animals, cytosine and adenine base editing are now well-established. Effective zygote editing with both cytosine and adenine base editors (ABE) has resulted in the production of animal models. Both base editors produced comparable outcomes for the precise editing of point mutations in somatic cells, advancing the field of gene therapy. This review focused on the principles, methods, recent developments, outstanding applications, the advantages and disadvantages of ZFNs, TALENs, and CRISPR/Cas9 base editors, and prime editing in diverse lab and farm animals. Additionally, we address the methodologies that can be used for gene regulation, base editing, and epigenetic alterations, as well as the significance of genome editing in animal models to better reflect real disease. We also look at methods designed to increase the effectiveness and precision of gene editing tools. Genome editing in large animals is used for a variety of purposes, including biotechnology to improve food production, animal health, and pest management, as well as the development of animal models for fundamental research and biomedicine. This review is an overview of the existing knowledge of the principles, methods, recent developments, outstanding applications, the advantages and disadvantages of zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs), transcription-activator-like endonucleases (TALENs), and clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats associated protein 9 (CRISPR/Cas 9), base editors and prime editing in diverse lab and farm animals, which will offer better and healthier products for the entire human race.

Mutation Knock-in Methods Using Single-Stranded DNA and Gene Editing Tools in Zebrafish

Introduction or knock-in of precise genomic modifications remains one of the most important applications of CRISPR/Cas9 in all model systems including zebrafish. The most widely used type of donor template containing the desired modification is single-stranded DNA (ssDNA), either in the form of single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides (ssODN) (<150 nucleotides (nt)) or as long ssDNA (lssDNA) molecules (up to about 2000 nt). Despite the challenges posed by DNA repair after DNA double-strand breaks, knock-in of precise mutations is relatively straightforward in zebrafish. Knock-in efficiency can be enhanced by careful donor template design, using lssDNA as template or tethering the donor template DNA to the Cas9-guide RNA complex. Other point mutation methods such as base editing and prime editing are starting to be applied in zebrafish and many other model systems. However, these methods may not always be sufficiently accessible or may have limited capacity to perform all desired mutation knock-ins which are possible with ssDNA-based knock-in methods. Thus, it is likely that there will be complementarity in the technologies used for generating precise mutants. Here, we review and describe a suite of CRISPR/Cas9 knock-in procedures utilizing ssDNA as the donor template in zebrafish, point out the potential challenges and suggest possible approaches for their solution ultimately leading to successful generation of precise mutant lines.

Germline Editing of Drosophila Using CRISPR-Cas9-Based Cytosine and Adenine Base Editors

Target-AID, BE3, and ABE7.10 base editors fused to the catalytically modified Cas9 and xCas9(3.7) were tested for germline editing of the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster. We developed a guide RNA-expressing construct, white-4gRNA, targeting splice sites in the white gene, an X-chromosome located gene. Using white-4gRNA flies and transgenic lines expressing Target-AID, BE3, and ABE7.10 base editors, we tested the efficiency of stable germline gene editing at three different temperatures. Classical Cas9 generating insertions/deletions by non-homologous end joining served as a reference. Our data indicate that gene editing is most efficient at 28°C, the highest temperature suitable for fruit flies. Finally, we created a new allele of the core circadian clock gene timeless using Target-AID. This base edited mutant allele timSS308-9FL had a disrupted circadian clock with a period of ∼29 h. The white-4gRNA expressing fly can be used to test new generations of base editors for future applications in Drosophila.

Precise mutagenesis in zebrafish using cytosine base editors

Base editing is a powerful CRISPR-based technology for introducing precise substitutions into the genome. This technology greatly advances mutagenesis possibilities in vivo, particularly in zebrafish, for which the generation of precise point mutations is still challenging. Zebrafish have emerged as an important model for genetic studies and in vivo disease modeling. With the development of different base editor variants that recognize protospacer-adjacent motifs (PAMs) other than the classical 5'-NGG-3' PAM, it is now possible to design and test several guide RNAs to find the most efficient way to precisely introduce the desired substitution. Here, we describe the experimental design strategies and protocols for cytosine base editing in zebrafish, from guide RNA design and selection of base editor variants to generation of the zebrafish mutant line carrying the substitution of interest. By using co-selection by introducing a loss-of-function mutation in genes necessary for the formation of pigments, injected embryos with highly efficient base editing can be directly analyzed to determine the phenotypic impact of the targeted substitution. The generation of mutant embryos after base editor injections in zebrafish can be completed within 2 weeks.

Base editors: development and applications in biomedicine

Base editor (BE) is a gene-editing tool developed by combining the CRISPR/Cas system with an individual deaminase, enabling precise single-base substitution in DNA or RNA without generating a DNA double-strand break (DSB) or requiring donor DNA templates in living cells. Base editors offer more precise and secure genome-editing effects than other conventional artificial nuclease systems, such as CRISPR/Cas9, as the DSB induced by Cas9 will cause severe damage to the genome. Thus, base editors have important applications in the field of biomedicine, including gene function investigation, directed protein evolution, genetic lineage tracing, disease modeling, and gene therapy. Since the development of the two main base editors, cytosine base editors (CBEs) and adenine base editors (ABEs), scientists have developed more than 100 optimized base editors with improved editing efficiency, precision, specificity, targeting scope, and capacity to be delivered in vivo, greatly enhancing their application potential in biomedicine. Here, we review the recent development of base editors, summarize their applications in the biomedical field, and discuss future perspectives and challenges for therapeutic applications.

Improving adenine and dual base editors through introduction of TadA-8e and Rad51DBD

Base editors, including dual base editors, are innovative techniques for efficient base conversions in genomic DNA. However, the low efficiency of A-to-G base conversion at positions proximal to the protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) and the A/C simultaneous conversion of the dual base editor hinder their broad applications. In this study, through fusion of ABE8e with Rad51 DNA-binding domain, we generate a hyperactive ABE (hyABE) which offers improved A-to-G editing efficiency at the region (A₁₀-A₁₅) proximal to the PAM, with 1.2- to 7-fold improvement compared to ABE8e. Similarly, we develop optimized dual base editors (eA&C-BEmax and hyA&C-BEmax) with markedly improved simultaneous A/C conversion efficiency (1.2-fold and 1.5-fold improvement, respectively) compared to A&C-BEmax in human cells. Moreover, these optimized base editors catalyze efficiently nucleotide conversions in zebrafish embryos to mirror human syndrome or in human cells to potentially treat genetic diseases, indicating their great potential in broad applications for disease modeling and gene therapy.

Genetically engineered zebrafish as models of skeletal development and regeneration

Zebrafish (Danio rerio) are aquatic vertebrates with significant homology to their terrestrial counterparts. While zebrafish have a centuries-long track record in developmental and regenerative biology, their utility has grown exponentially with the onset of modern genetics. This is exemplified in studies focused on skeletal development and repair. Herein, the numerous contributions of zebrafish to our understanding of the basic science of cartilage, bone, tendon/ligament, and other skeletal tissues are described, with a particular focus on applications to development and regeneration. We summarize the genetic strengths that have made the zebrafish a powerful model to understand skeletal biology. We also highlight the large body of existing tools and techniques available to understand skeletal development and repair in the zebrafish and introduce emerging methods that will aid in novel discoveries in skeletal biology. Finally, we review the unique contributions of zebrafish to our understanding of regeneration and highlight diverse routes of repair in different contexts of injury. We conclude that zebrafish will continue to fill a niche of increasing breadth and depth in the study of basic cellular mechanisms of skeletal biology.

DNA base editing in nuclear and organellar genomes

Genome editing continues to revolutionize biological research. Due to its simplicity and flexibility, CRISPR/Cas-based editing has become the preferred technology in most systems. Cas nucleases tolerate fusion to large protein domains, thus allowing combination of their DNA recognition properties with new enzymatic activities. Fusion to nucleoside deaminase or reverse transcriptase domains has produced base editors and prime editors that, instead of generating double-strand breaks in the target sequence, induce site-specific alterations of single (or a few adjacent) nucleotides. The availability of protein-only genome editing reagents based on transcription activator-like effectors has enabled the extension of base editing to the genomes of chloroplasts and mitochondria. In this review, we summarize currently available base editing methods for nuclear and organellar genomes. We highlight recent advances with improving precision, specificity, and efficiency and discuss current limitations and future challenges. We also provide a brief overview of applications in agricultural biotechnology and gene therapy.

SpG and SpRY variants expand the CRISPR toolbox for genome editing in zebrafish

Precise genetic modifications in model organisms are essential for biomedical research. The recent development of PAM-less base editors makes it possible to assess the functional impact and pathogenicity of nucleotide mutations in animals. Here we first optimize SpG and SpRY systems in zebrafish by purifying protein combined with synthetically modified gRNA. SpG shows high editing efficiency at NGN PAM sites, whereas SpRY efficiently edit PAM-less sites in the zebrafish genome. Then, we generate the SpRY-mediated cytosine base editor SpRY-CBE4max and SpRY-mediated adenine base editor zSpRY-ABE8e. Both target relaxed PAM with up to 96% editing efficiency and high product purity. With these tools, some previously inaccessible disease-relevant genetic variants are generated in zebrafish, supporting the utility of high-resolution targeting across genome-editing applications. Our study significantly improves CRISPR-Cas targeting in the genomic landscape of zebrafish, promoting the application of this model organism in revealing gene function, physiological mechanisms, and disease pathogenesis.

Precise in vivo functional analysis of DNA variants with base editing using ACEofBASEs target prediction

Single nucleotide variants (SNVs) are prevalent genetic factors shaping individual trait profiles and disease susceptibility. The recent development and optimizations of base editors, rubber and pencil genome editing tools now promise to enable direct functional assessment of SNVs in model organisms. However, the lack of bioinformatic tools aiding target prediction limits the application of base editing in vivo. Here, we provide a framework for adenine and cytosine base editing in medaka (Oryzias latipes) and zebrafish (Danio rerio), ideal for scalable validation studies. We developed an online base editing tool ACEofBASEs (a careful evaluation of base-edits), to facilitate decision-making by streamlining sgRNA design and performing off-target evaluation. We used state-of-the-art adenine (ABE) and cytosine base editors (CBE) in medaka and zebrafish to edit eye pigmentation genes and transgenic GFP function with high efficiencies. Base editing in the genes encoding troponin T and the potassium channel ERG faithfully recreated known cardiac phenotypes. Deep-sequencing of alleles revealed the abundance of intended edits in comparison to low levels of insertion or deletion (indel) events for ABE8e and evoBE4max. We finally validated missense mutations in novel candidate genes of congenital heart disease (CHD) dapk3, ube2b, usp44, and ptpn11 in F0 and F1 for a subset of these target genes with genotype-phenotype correlation. This base editing framework applies to a wide range of SNV-susceptible traits accessible in fish, facilitating straight-forward candidate validation and prioritization for detailed mechanistic downstream studies.

Base editing and prime editing in laboratory animals

Genome editing by programmable RNA-dependent Cas endonucleases has revolutionised the field of genome engineering, achieving targeted genomic change at unprecedented efficiencies with considerable application in laboratory animal research. Despite its ease of use and wide application, there remain concerns about the precision of this technology and a number of unpredictable consequences have been reported, mostly resulting from the DNA double-strand break (DSB) that conventional CRISPR editing induces. In order to improve editing precision, several iterations of the technology been developed over the years. Base editing is one of most successful developments, allowing for single base conversions but without the need for a DSB. Cytosine and adenine base editing are now established as reliable methods to achieve precise genome editing in animal research studies. Both cytosine and adenine base editors have been applied successfully to the editing of zygotes, resulting in the generation of animal models. Similarly, both base editors have achieved precise editing of point mutations in somatic cells, facilitating the development of gene therapy approaches. Despite rapid progress in optimising these tools, base editing can address only a subset of possible base conversions within a relatively narrow window and larger genomic manipulations are not possible. The recent development of prime editing, originally defined as a simple 'search and replace' editing tool, may help address these limitations and could widen the range of genome manipulations possible. Preliminary reports of prime editing in animals are being published, and this new technology may allow significant advancements for laboratory animal research.

Human cell based directed evolution of adenine base editors with improved efficiency

Adenine base editors (ABE) are genome-editing tools that have been harnessed to introduce precise A•T to G•C conversion. However, the low activity of ABE at certain sites remains a major bottleneck that precludes efficacious applications. Here, to address it, we develop a directional screening system in human cells to evolve the deaminase component of the ABE, and identify three high-activity NG-ABEmax variants: NG-ABEmax-SGK (R101S/D139G/E140K), NG-ABEmax-R (Q154R) and NG-ABEmax-K (N127K). With further engineering, we create a consolidated variant [NG-ABEmax-KR (N127K/Q154R)] which exhibit superior editing activity both in human cells and in mouse disease models, compared to the original NG-ABEmax. We also find that NG-ABEmax-KR efficiently introduce natural mutations in gamma globin gene promoters with more than four-fold increase in editing activity. This work provides a broadly applicable, rapidly deployable platform to directionally screen and evolve user-specified traits in base editors that extend beyond augmented editing activity.

Progress in Gene-Editing Technology of Zebrafish

As a vertebrate model, zebrafish (Danio rerio) plays a vital role in the field of life sciences. Recently, gene-editing technology has become increasingly innovative, significantly promoting scientific research on zebrafish. However, the implementation of these methods in a reasonable and accurate manner to achieve efficient gene-editing remains challenging. In this review, we systematically summarize the development and latest progress in zebrafish gene-editing technology. Specifically, we outline trends in double-strand break-free genome modification and the prospective applications of fixed-point orientation transformation of any base at any location through a multi-method approach.

Genome Editing in Zebrafish by ScCas9 Recognizing NNG PAM

The CRISPR/Cas9 system has been widely used for gene editing in zebrafish. However, the required NGG protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) of Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) notably restricts the editable range of the zebrafish genome. Recently, Cas9 from S. canis (ScCas9), which has a more relaxed 5'-NNG-3' PAM, was reported to have activities in human cells and plants. However, the editing ability of ScCas9 has not been tested in zebrafish. Here we characterized and optimized the activity of ScCas9 in zebrafish. Delivered as a ribonucleoprotein complex, ScCas9 can induce mutations in zebrafish. Using the synthetic modified crRNA:tracrRNA duplex instead of in vitro-transcribed single guide RNA, the low activity at some loci were dramatically improved in zebrafish. As far as we know, our work is the first report on the evaluation of ScCas9 in animals. Our work optimized ScCas9 as a new nuclease for targeting relaxed NNG PAMs for zebrafish genome editing, which will further improve genome editing in zebrafish.

Progression and application of CRISPR-Cas genomic editors

Base editing technology is an efficient tool for genome editing, particularly in the correction of base mutations. Diverse base editing systems were developed according to the dCas9 or nCas9 linked with different deaminase or reverse transcriptase in the editors, including ABEs, CBEs, PEs and dual-functional of base editor (such as CGBE1, A&C-BEmax, ACBE, etc.). Currently, Base editing technology has been widely applied to various fields such as microorganisms, plants, animals and medicine for basic research and therapeutics. Here, we reviewed the advancement of base editing technology. We also discussed the application of base editors in different areas in the future.

CRISPR base editing applications for identifying cancer-driving mutations

CRISPR base editing technology is a promising genome editing tool as (i) it does not require a DNA template to introduce mutations and (ii) it avoids creating DNA double-strand breaks, which can lead to unintended chromosomal alterations or elicit an unwanted DNA damage response. Given many cancers originate from point mutations in cancer-driving genes, the application of base editing for either modelling tumour development, therapeutic editing, or functional screening is of great promise. In this review, we summarise current DNA base editing technologies and will discuss recent advancements and existing hurdles for its usage in cancer research.

Precision genome editing using cytosine and adenine base editors in mammalian cells

Genome editing has transformed the life sciences and has exciting prospects for use in treating genetic diseases. Our laboratory developed base editing to enable precise and efficient genome editing while minimizing undesired byproducts and toxicity associated with double-stranded DNA breaks. Adenine and cytosine base editors mediate targeted A•T-to-G•C or C•G-to-T•A base pair changes, respectively, which can theoretically address most human disease-associated single-nucleotide polymorphisms. Current base editors can achieve high editing efficiencies-for example, approaching 100% in cultured mammalian cells or 70% in adult mouse neurons in vivo. Since their initial description, a large set of base editor variants have been developed with different on-target and off-target editing characteristics. Here, we describe a protocol for using base editing in cultured mammalian cells. We provide guidelines for choosing target sites, appropriate base editor variants and delivery strategies to best suit a desired application. We further describe standard base-editing experiments in HEK293T cells, along with computational analysis of base-editing outcomes using CRISPResso2. Beginning with target DNA site selection, base-editing experiments in mammalian cells can typically be completed within 1-3 weeks and require only standard molecular biology techniques and readily available plasmid constructs.

Drug Screening with Genetically Encoded Fluorescent Sensors: Today and Tomorrow

Genetically-encoded fluorescent sensors have been actively developed over the last few decades and used in live imaging and drug screening. Real-time monitoring of drug action in a specific cellular compartment, organ, or tissue type; the ability to screen at the single-cell resolution; and the elimination of false-positive results caused by low drug bioavailability that is not detected by in vitro testing methods are a few of the obvious benefits of using genetically-encoded fluorescent sensors in drug screening. In combination with high-throughput screening (HTS), some genetically-encoded fluorescent sensors may provide high reproducibility and robustness to assays. We provide a brief overview of successful, perspective, and hopeful attempts at using genetically encoded fluorescent sensors in HTS of modulators of ion channels, Ca2+ homeostasis, GPCR activity, and for screening cytotoxic, anticancer, and anti-parasitic compounds. We discuss the advantages of sensors in whole organism drug screening models and the perspectives of the combination of human disease modeling by CRISPR techniques with genetically encoded fluorescent sensors for drug screening.

An optimized base editor with efficient C-to-T base editing in zebrafish

Background

Zebrafish is a model organism widely used for the understanding of gene function, including the fundamental basis of human disease, enabled by the presence in its genome of a high number of orthologs to human genes. CRISPR/Cas9 and next-generation gene-editing techniques using cytidine deaminase fused with Cas9 nickase provide fast and efficient tools able to induce sequence-specific single base mutations in various organisms and have also been used to generate genetically modified zebrafish for modeling pathogenic mutations. However, the editing efficiency in zebrafish of currently available base editors is lower than other model organisms, frequently inducing indel formation, which limits the applicability of these tools and calls for the search of more accurate and efficient editors.

Results

Here, we generated a new base editor (zAncBE4max) with a length of 5560 bp following a strategy based on the optimization of codon preference in zebrafish. Our new editor effectively created C-to-T base substitution while maintaining a high product purity at multiple target sites. Moreover, zAncBE4max successfully generated the Twist2 p.E78K mutation in zebrafish, recapitulating pathological features of human ablepharon macrostomia syndrome (AMS).

Conclusions

Overall, the zAncBE4max system provides a promising tool to perform efficient base editing in zebrafish and enhances its capacity to precisely model human diseases.

DNA capture by a CRISPR-Cas9-guided adenine base editor

CRISPR-Cas-guided base editors convert A•T to G•C, or C•G to T•A, in cellular DNA for precision genome editing. To understand the molecular basis for DNA adenosine deamination by adenine base editors (ABEs), we determined a 3.2-angstrom resolution cryo-electron microscopy structure of ABE8e in a substrate-bound state in which the deaminase domain engages DNA exposed within the CRISPR-Cas9 R-loop complex. Kinetic and structural data suggest that ABE8e catalyzes DNA deamination up to ~1100-fold faster than earlier ABEs because of mutations that stabilize DNA substrates in a constrained, transfer RNA-like conformation. Furthermore, ABE8e's accelerated DNA deamination suggests a previously unobserved transient DNA melting that may occur during double-stranded DNA surveillance by CRISPR-Cas9. These results explain ABE8e-mediated base-editing outcomes and inform the future design of base editors.

CRISPR-Cas9 DNA Base-Editing and Prime-Editing

Many genetic diseases and undesirable traits are due to base-pair alterations in genomic DNA. Base-editing, the newest evolution of clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)-Cas-based technologies, can directly install point-mutations in cellular DNA without inducing a double-strand DNA break (DSB). Two classes of DNA base-editors have been described thus far, cytosine base-editors (CBEs) and adenine base-editors (ABEs). Recently, prime-editing (PE) has further expanded the CRISPR-base-edit toolkit to all twelve possible transition and transversion mutations, as well as small insertion or deletion mutations. Safe and efficient delivery of editing systems to target cells is one of the most paramount and challenging components for the therapeutic success of BEs. Due to its broad tropism, well-studied serotypes, and reduced immunogenicity, adeno-associated vector (AAV) has emerged as the leading platform for viral delivery of genome editing agents, including DNA-base-editors. In this review, we describe the development of various base-editors, assess their technical advantages and limitations, and discuss their therapeutic potential to treat debilitating human diseases.

AcrIIA5 Suppresses Base Editors and Reduces Their Off-Target Effects

The CRISPR/nCas9-based cytosine base editors (CBEs) and adenine base editors (ABEs) are capable of catalyzing C•G to T•A or A•T to G•C conversions, respectively, and have become new, powerful tools for achieving precise genetic changes in a wide range of organisms. These base editors hold great promise for correcting pathogenic mutations and for being used for therapeutic applications. However, the recognition of cognate DNA sequences near their target sites can cause severe off-target effects that greatly limit their clinical applications, and this is an urgent problem that needs to be resolved for base editing systems. The recently discovered phage-derived proteins, anti-CRISPRs, which can suppress the natural CRISPR nuclease activity, may be able to ameliorate the off-target effects of base editing systems. Here, we confirm for the first time that AcrIIA2, AcrIIA4, and AcrIIA5 efficiently inhibit base editing systems in human cells. In particular, AcrIIA5 has a significant inhibitory effect on all base editing variant systems tested in our study. We further show that the off-target effects of BE3 and ABE7.10 were significantly reduced in AcrIIA5 treated cells. This study suggests that AcrIIA5 should be widely used for the precise control of base editing and to thoroughly “shut off” nuclease activity of both CBE and ABE systems.

BE4max and AncBE4max Are Efficient in Germline Conversion of C:G to T:A Base Pairs in Zebrafish

The ease of use and robustness of genome editing by CRISPR/Cas9 has led to successful use of gene knockout zebrafish for disease modeling. However, it still remains a challenge to precisely edit the zebrafish genome to create single-nucleotide substitutions, which account for ~60% of human disease-causing mutations. Recently developed base editing nucleases provide an excellent alternate to CRISPR/Cas9-mediated homology dependent repair for generation of zebrafish with point mutations. A new set of cytosine base editors, termed BE4max and AncBE4max, demonstrated improved base editing efficiency in mammalian cells but have not been evaluated in zebrafish. Therefore, we undertook this study to evaluate their efficiency in converting C:G to T:A base pairs in zebrafish by somatic and germline analysis using highly active sgRNAs to twist and ntl genes. Our data demonstrated that these improved BE4max set of plasmids provide desired base substitutions at similar efficiency and without any indels compared to the previously reported BE3 and Target-AID plasmids in zebrafish. Our data also showed that AncBE4max produces fewer incorrect and bystander edits, suggesting that it can be further improved by codon optimization of its components for use in zebrafish.

Highly efficient generation of sheep with a defined FecBB mutation via adenine base editing

Base editing has the potential to improve important economic traits in agriculture and can precisely convert single nucleotides in DNA or RNA sequences into minimal double-strand DNA breaks (DSB). Adenine base editors (ABE) have recently emerged as a base editing tool for the conversion of targeted A:T to G:C, but have not yet been used in sheep. ABEmax is one of the latest versions of ABE, which consists of a catalytically-impaired nuclease and a laboratory-evolved DNA-adenosine deaminase. The Booroola fecundity (FecB^B) mutation (g.A746G, p.Q249R) in the bone morphogenetic protein receptor 1B (BMPR1B) gene influences fecundity in many sheep breeds. In this study, by using ABEmax we successfully obtained lambs with defined point mutations that result in an amino acid substitution (p.Gln249Arg). The efficiency of the defined point mutations was 75% in newborn lambs, since six lambs were heterozygous at the FecB^B mutation site (g.A746G, p.Q249R), and two lambs were wild-type. We did not detect off-target mutations in the eight edited lambs. Here, we report the validation of the first gene-edited sheep generated by ABE and highlight its potential to improve economically important traits in livestock.

Density functional theory studies on cytosine analogues for inducing double-proton transfer with guanine

To induce double-proton transfer (DPT) with guanine in a biological environment, 12 cytosine analogues (Ca) were formed by atomic substitution. The DPT reactions in the Watson-Crick cytosine-guanine model complex (Ca₀G) and 12 modified cytosine-guanine complexes (Ca_1-12G) were investigated using density functional theory methods at the M06-2X/def2svp level. The intramolecular proton transfers within the analogues are not facile due to high energy barriers. The hydrogen bond lengths of the Ca_1-12G complexes are shorter than those in the Ca₀G complex, which are conducive to DPT reactions. The DPT energy barriers of Ca_1-12G complexes are also lower than that of the Ca₀G complex, in particular, the barriers in the Ca₇G and Ca₁₁G complexes were reduced to -1.33 and -2.02 kcal/mol, respectively, indicating they are significantly more prone to DPT reactions. The DPT equilibrium constants of Ca_1-12G complexes range from 1.60 × 10⁰ to 1.28 × 10⁷, among which the equilibrium constants of Ca₇G and Ca₁₁G are over 1.0 × 10⁵, so their DPT reactions may be adequate. The results demonstrate that those cytosine analogues, especially Ca₇ and Ca₁₁, are capable of inducing DPT with guanine, and then the guanine tautomer will form mismatches with thymine during DNA replication, which may provide new strategies for gene therapy.

Development and Application of Base Editors

Base editing is emerging as a potent new strategy to achieve precise gene editing. By combining different nucleobase deaminases with Cas9 or Cpf1 proteins, several base editors have recently been developed to achieve targeted base conversions in different genomic contexts. Importantly, base editors have been successfully applied in animals, plants, and bacteria to induce precise substitutions at the single-base level with high efficiency. In this review, we summarize recent progress in the development and application of base editors and discuss some of the future directions of the technology.

Analysis and minimization of cellular RNA editing by DNA adenine base editors

Adenine base editors (ABEs) enable precise and efficient conversion of target A•T base pairs to G•C base pairs in genomic DNA with a minimum of by-products. While ABEs have been reported to exhibit minimal off-target DNA editing, off-target editing of cellular RNA by ABEs has not been examined in depth. Here, we demonstrate that a current ABE generates low but detectable levels of widespread adenosine-to-inosine editing in cellular RNAs. Using structure-guided principles to design mutations in both deaminase domains, we developed new ABE variants that retain their ability to edit DNA efficiently but show greatly reduced RNA editing activity, as well as lower off-target DNA editing activity and reduced indel by-product formation, in three mammalian cell lines. By decoupling DNA and RNA editing activities, these ABE variants increase the precision of adenine base editing by minimizing both RNA and DNA off-target editing activity.