Burden of adult neurofibromatosis 1: development and validation of a burden assessment tool

The RaDiCo information system for rare disease cohorts

BACKGROUND

Rare diseases (RDs) clinical care and research face several challenges. Patients are dispersed over large geographic areas, their number per disease is limited, just like the number of researchers involved. Current databases as well as biological collections, when existing, are generally local, of modest size, incomplete, of uneven quality, heterogeneous in format and content, and rarely accessible or standardised to support interoperability. Most disease phenotypes are complex corresponding to multi-systemic conditions, with insufficient interdisciplinary cooperation. Thus emerged the need to generate, within a coordinated, mutualised, secure and interoperable framework, high-quality data from national or international RD cohorts, based on deep phenotyping, including molecular analysis data, notably genotypic. The RaDiCo program objective was to create, under the umbrella of Inserm, a national operational platform dedicated to the development of RD e-cohorts. Its Information System (IS) is presented here.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Constructed on the cloud computing principle, the RaDiCo platform was designed to promote mutualization and factorization of processes and services, for both clinical epidemiology support and IS. RaDiCo IS is based on an interoperability framework combining a unique RD identifier, data standardisation, FAIR principles, data exchange flows/processes and data security principles compliant with the European GDPR.

RESULTS

RaDiCo IS favours a secure, open-source web application in order to implement and manage online databases and give patients themselves the opportunity to collect their data. It ensures a continuous monitoring of data quality and consistency over time. RaDiCo IS proved to be efficient, currently hosting 13 e-cohorts, covering 67 distinct RDs. As of April 2024, 8063 patients were recruited from 180 specialised RD sites spread across the national territory.

DISCUSSION

The RaDiCo operational platform is equivalent to a national infrastructure. Its IS enables RD e-cohorts to be developed on a shared platform with no limit on size or number. Compliant with the GDPR, it is compatible with the French National Health Data Hub and can be extended to the RDs European Reference Networks (ERNs).

CONCLUSION

RaDiCo provides a robust IS, compatible with the French Data Hub and RDs ERNs, integrated on a RD platform that enables e-cohorts creation, monitoring and analysis.

Neurofibromatosis type 1 adult surveillance form for Austria

BACKGROUND

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is a rare autosomal dominant tumor predisposition syndrome with a birth prevalence of approximately 1 in 2000-3000 individuals. Management of both benign and malignant tumors arising in individuals with NF1 is demanding and tumors may be difficult to treat. Both standardized and individual surveillance programs are therefore highly important to prevent morbidity and mortality in patients with NF1.

METHODS

The guidelines for the clinical management of NF1 recently proposed by the European Reference Network for Genetic Tumor Risk Syndromes provide the cornerstone of the present surveillance form and were discussed through three rounds of voting and a final consensus meeting involving experts from five Austrian and one German clinical NF1 centers for adults and one patient organization representative. Subsequently, 31 items within 4 categories were integrated into the proposed surveillance form for Austria. All recommendations, unless otherwise specified, pertain to primarily asymptomatic patients in routine follow-up.

RECOMMENDATIONS

At healthcare transition from pediatric to adult surveillance or the initial visit in adulthood, we suggest a thorough clinical, laboratory and radiological examination to obtain a baseline for future diagnostics. To comply with the general screening recommendations in Austria, we suggest extending the frequency of clinical visits from annual to biennial at 50 years of age. In cases of clinical dynamics, early follow-up is recommended to facilitate early detection of potential complications. Particular emphasis should be placed on preventive patient education.

Impact of neurofibromatosis type 1 on quality of life using the Skindex-29 questionnaire quality of life in NF1

BACKGROUND

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is one of the most common RASopathies predisposing affected patients to melanic lesions and benign tumors. NF1 is associated with considerable esthetic and functional burden negatively affecting the patient's quality of life (QoL). This study aims to assess the clinical features of NF1 patients and evaluate their impact on QoL. We identified NF1 patients from a public health database of a region in Spain. All patients underwent clinical and ophthalmological evaluation for NF1 features. We measured QoL using the Spanish version of the Skindex-29.

RESULTS

Forty patients fulfilled the NF1 National Institute of Health criteria when we recruited patients. The median age was 42.00 years (IQR 26.5 -53.75). The median total Skindex-29 score was 12.3 (IQR 5.9-22.4); (emotion: 15.0, IQR 5.0-37.5; symptoms 8.9, IQR 0.0-17.9 and functioning 8.3; IQR 0.5-18.3). Women and NF1 patients with lower educational levels were associated with poorer QoL scores. We identified itching and sleep troubles to influence NF1 patients' QoL negatively.

CONCLUSION

NF1 considerably influences the psychological well-being of NF1 patients. We observed that female and low-educated patients scored higher on the emotional dimension of the Skindex-29 and could, therefore, be more at risk of depression. We also pointed out some "minor symptoms" that negatively impact NF1 patients' QoL such, as itching and sleep troubles which doctors could treat if sought by doctors.

cNF-Skindex in Adults Living with Neurofibromatosis 1: Severity Strata in France and Validation in United States Adults

Cutaneous neurofibromas (cNF) contribute to the impairment of QOL in individuals with neurofibromatosis 1. The cNF-Skindex, validated in a French population, specifically assesses the cNF-related QOL. In this study, we first defined severity strata using an anchoring approach on the basis of patient's burden. In total, 209 patients answered the anchor question and the cNF-Skindex. We tested the agreement among the three strata, generated by all potential couples of cut-off values of the cNF-Skindex and the three strata defined in the anchor question. The cut-off values 12 and 49 provided the highest Kappa value (κ = 0.685, 95% confidence interval = 0.604-0.765). Second, we validated the score and the strata in a United States population using the answers provided by 220 French and 148 United States adults. In the multivariable linear regression analysis, the country of origin was not a factor associated with the score (P = 0.297). The number of cNF along the different severity strata was similar between the French and the United States populations. In conclusion, stratification constitutes a powerful tool to better interpret the cNF-Skindex in daily practice and in clinical trials. This study validates its use in two populations that together constitute a large cohort of patients willing to participate in clinical research.

Burden of adult neurofibromatosis 1 questionnaire: translation and psychometric properties of the Persian version

BACKGROUND

The notion of "burden" has taken a key place in the evaluation of care, particularly in the case of rare diseases. The aim of this study was to evaluate the psychometric properties of the burden of neurofibromatosis 1 questionnaire (BoN) and to determine the perceived disease burden.

RESULTS

The 15-item BoN was translated into Persian, and no items were removed based on content validity. The adequacy of the sample was acceptable (KMO = 0.902), and Bartlett's test of sphericity revealed statistically significant results (P < 0.001). Exploratory factor analysis revealed three factors. The reliability of the scale was good (Cronbach's alpha: 0.90), and the intraclass coefficient was 0.85. The severity of the burden of neurofibromatosis was moderate, and the total mean burden score was 33.12 ± 16.12.

CONCLUSIONS

The Persian version of the BoN is an acceptable tool in terms of structure and content, and it specifically assesses the practical aspects of daily activities for patients with neurofibromatosis.

Development and calibration data for the Illness Burden item bank: a new computer adaptive test for persons with type 2 diabetes mellitus

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to develop a new measure, the Re-Engineered Discharge for Diabetes Computer Adaptive Test (REDD-CAT) Illness Burden item bank, to evaluate the impact that a chronic condition has on independent living, the ability to work (including working at home), social activities, and relationships.

METHODS

Semi-structured interviews were used to inform the development of an item pool (47 items) that captured patients' beliefs about how a diagnosis of type 2 diabetes interferes with different aspects of their lives. The Illness Burden item bank was developed and tested in 225 people with type 2 diabetes mellitus.

RESULTS

No items had sparse response option cells or problems with monotonicity; two items were deleted due to low item-rest correlations. Factor analyses supported the retention of 29 items. With those 29 remaining items, a constrained (common slope) graded response model fit assessment indicated that two items had misfit; they were excluded. No items displayed differential item functioning by age, sex, education, or socio-economic status. The final item bank is comprised of 27 items. Preliminary data supported the reliability (internal consistency and test-retest reliability) and validity (convergent, discriminant, and known-groups) of the new bank.

CONCLUSION

The Illness Burden item bank can be administered as a computer adaptive test or a 6-item short form. This new measure captures patients' perceptions of the impact that having type 2 diabetes has on their daily lives; it can be used in conjunction with the REDD-CAT measurement system to evaluate important social determinants of health in persons with type 2 diabetes mellitus.

Quality of life in neurofibromatosis 1: development and validation of a tool dedicated to cutaneous neurofibromas in adults

BACKGROUND

Cutaneous neurofibromas (cNF), present in 95% of individuals with neurofibromatosis 1 (NF1), are considered as one of the greatest medical burden because of physical disfigurement. No specific score evaluates their impact on quality of life (QoL).

OBJECTIVE

To develop a specific score assessing cNF-related QoL.

METHODS

Through a multidisciplinary workshop including 10 patients, 3 expert-in-NF1 physicians, 3 health care workers (nurses and psychologist) and 1 methodologist, the French version of the Skindex-16 was modified by adding 3 items. The new cNF-Skindex was validated among patients with NF1 recruited in the ComPaRe online cohort, in France (N=284). Construct validity was assessed by comparing it with the EQ-5D-5L, its visual analog scale and the MYMOP2 and by assessing its association with patients' characteristics. Reliability was assessed by a test-retest. An English version of the tool was developed using a back forward translation.

RESULTS

A total of 228 individuals with NF1, with cNF answered the 19-item questionnaire. These items fitted into 3 domains: emotions, symptoms, functioning. One was dropped during analysis because >90% responders were not concerned. The cNF-Skindex significantly correlated with the EQ-5D-5L (N=193) and MYMOP2 (N=210) indicating good external validity: rs 0.38 (p<0.001), and 0.58 (p<0.001) respectively. Having >50 cNF was the only independent variable associated with the total score cNF-Skindex (β=15.88, 95%CI 6.96 - 24.81, p=0.001), and with the 3 sub-scores: "functioning" (β=2.65, 95%CI 0.71 - 4.59, p=0.008), "emotions" (β=17.03, 95%CI 4.11 - 29.96, p=0.010) and "symptoms" (β=3.90, 95%CI 1.95 - 5.85, p<0.001). Test-retest reliability (N=133) found an ICC at 0.96 demonstrating good reproducibility.

CONCLUSION

The cNF-Skindex demonstrated excellent psychometric properties. The global and sub-scores were increased with higher number of cNF arguing for its use in further trials aiming to reduce their number or prevent their development. Cross-cultural validation and evaluation of its responsiveness are the next steps.

Impact of neurofibromatosis type 1 in an adult community population

Background

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is a common tumor predisposition syndrome with varying manifestations and severity. Adult NF1 patients often experience fragmented care, so we sought to characterize the health and demographic features of a community-based population of adults with NF1 and hypothesized that lack of a specialty clinic for adult NF1 patients correlates with unmet needs.

Methods

Retrospective case-control study of all adult cases of NF1 among 4.06 million medical records in a Pacific Northwest population. 122 case charts were reviewed to ascertain NF1 disease features, comorbidities, and severity of disease. A 1:1 control cohort was selected by matching case/control by age, sex, and ZIP code to compare demographic features and health status.

Results

Adult NF1 patients were less likely to have private insurance, be employed, and have children, but were equally likely to be married. One half of cases had disease features compromising health and well-being, and care involved 26 different specialties. Excluding neurofibromas, 43% of cases had cancer compared to 10% of controls [P < .0001, OR 5.38 (2.53-11.4)]. Only 27% of women ages 30-50 had undergone age-appropriate enhanced breast cancer surveillance. Behavioral health problems were found in 60% of NF1 patients compared to 37% of controls [P < .001, OR 2.61 (1.52-4.50)]. 93% of cases referred to a NF1 specialty center underwent a change in management upon establishing care.

Conclusions

NF1 patients may benefit from coordinated management of care in a specialty center.

How do people with neurofibromatosis type 1 (the forgotten victims) live? A grounded theory study

Background

Neurofibromatosis type I (NF1) is a rare genetic disorder, associated with some physical symptoms including spots and tiny bumps on the skin, and internal organ involvement. People suffering from neurofibromatosis face various challenges in their daily lives. However, there is little understanding on how patients deal with neurofibromatosis. This study aimed to investigate the life challenges of patients with NF1.

Methods

This qualitative study was performed by implementing a grounded theory with the cooperation of the Society for Neurofibromatosis Patients over the course of 15 months in 2019 across 4 provinces in Iran. Twenty‐four patients with NF1 were interviewed. An analysis was performed using the constant comparative method.

Findings

The results of the analyses indicated that the major concern of the NF1 patients was feelings of failure and falling behind in life. In the face of failure in life in such a context, patients used the main strategy of “unsuccessful struggle to escape” the disease and its complications, which was represented itself in the forms of ‘hopelessness and impatience’, ‘suicidal thoughts and unsuccessful suicide attempts’, ‘isolation and seclusion’, ‘expressing complaints and grievances to God’, ‘hiding the disease’ and ‘hopelessness and refusing to receive care’. The implementation of such strategies helped patients reduce tension and achieve a temporary, though vulnerable and fragile, sense of relief and peace.

Conclusion

Given an unfavourable life condition, NF1 patients turned to a harmful passive strategy in the face of the challenges posed by the disease.

Patient or Public Contribution

Public contributors were active partners throughout, and co‐authored the paper.

RaDiCo, the French national research program on rare disease cohorts

BACKGROUND

Rare diseases (RDs) affect nearly 3 million people in France and at least 26-30 million people in Europe. These diseases, which represent a major medical concern, are mainly of genetic origin, often chronic, progressive, degenerative, life threatening and disabling, accounting for more than one third of all deaths occurring during infancy. In this context, there are needs for coordinated information on RDs at national/international levels, based on high quality, interoperable and sharable data. The main objective of the RaDiCo (Rare Disease Cohorts) program, coordinated by Inserm, was the development of RD e-cohorts via a national platform. The cohort projects were selected through a national call in 2014. The e-cohorts are supported by an interoperable platform, equivalent to an infrastructure, constructed on the "cloud computing" principle and in compliance with the European General Data Protection Regulation. It is dedicated to allow a continuous monitoring of data quality and consistency, in line with the French Health Data Hub.

RESULTS

Depending on cohorts, the objectives are to describe the natural history of the studied RD(s), identify the underlying disease genes, establish phenotype-genotype correlations, decipher their pathophysiology, assess their societal and medico-economic impact, and/or identify patients eligible for new therapeutic approaches. Inclusion of prevalent and incident cases started at the end of 2016. As of April 2021, 5558 patients have been included within 13 RD e-cohorts covering 67 diseases integrated in 10 European Reference Networks and contributing to the European Joint Program on RDs. Several original results have been obtained in relation with the secondary objectives of the RaDiCo cohorts. They deal with discovery of new disease genes, assessment of treatment management, deciphering the underlying pathophysiological mechanisms, diagnostic approaches, genotype-phenotype relationships, development and validation of questionnaires relative to disease burden, or methodological aspects.

CONCLUSION

RaDiCo currently hosts 13 RD e-cohorts on a sharable and interoperable platform constructed on the "cloud computing" principle. New RD e-cohorts at the European and international levels are targeted.

Complications of Neurofibromatosis 1 (NF1) in an Adult With Multiple Comorbidities

Neurofibromatosis (NF) is an autosomal genetic disorder with three types, including NF1, NF2, and schwannomatosis. It is characterized by bulging and deforming masses arising from multiple nerves involving skin folds and connective tissues. Prompt diagnosis and provision of care for NF1 patients by clinicians aware of the diverse clinical features of this disorder are needed for optimum patient care and management. A 65-year-old African American female with a past medical history significant for multiple neurofibromas covering more than 95% of her total body surface area (TBSA), presented to a primary care clinic with an enlarged ulcerated neurofibroma of the right elbow. She reported associated pulsating, sharp pain, which was radiating to her entire right upper extremity. For most of her adult life, the lesion has been present and began as the rest of the neurofibromas on her body but gradually enlarged with eventual ulceration three months before the visit. The patient reported a failed surgical resection for the same neurofibroma several years ago. She also reported diffuse tenderness of the lesion, which severely impaired her daily living activities and limited her sleep ability. She acknowledged using multiple over-the-counter analgesics, prescription hydrocodone/acetaminophen 5/325 mg as needed, and gabapentin 300 mg orally twice daily but denied significant symptom alleviation. The patient was started on oral clindamycin hydrochloride 300 mg every six hours for 10 days and a topical mupirocin ointment 2% three times daily for five days. Subsequent visits showed no improvement of the ulcer, which necessitated a referral to wound care. After multiple wound care visits without progress, the patient was referred to a plastic surgeon for evaluation for repeat ulcer resection. NF1 patients develop multiple tumors (neurofibromas); approximately 8%-15% percent of them present with malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors (MPNST) within the patient's lifetime. Tumor ulceration is a rare but possible complication of NF1. Due to the acute ulcerated fibromas' complications, previous unsuccessful cosmetic management, and ambiguity about NF1 disorder, the patient's quality of life was impaired. The physical and emotional pain the patient experienced impacted her activities of daily living and likely contributed to or exacerbated her diagnoses of substance use disorder and major depressive disorder. NF1 is incurable and can be associated with complications that deteriorate the quality of life, depending on symptom severity. The condition impacts patients' bodies, minds, and spirits, as seen in this patient who had diagnoses of substance use disorder and major depressive disorder, as well as a history of suicidal ideation and suicide attempts. The treatment of conditions related to NF1 is best managed in centers equipped with doctors experienced in treating patients with NF1. A multidisciplinary management approach is ideal. Preferably, for the management of chronic pain and beyond, the osteopathic holistic approach, targeting the body, mind, and spirit, in combination with other innovative non-pharmacotherapies and pharmacotherapy methods, would be beneficial.

The Patients' Experiences of Burden of Neurofibromatosis: A Qualitative Study

Background:

Neurofibromatosis Type 1 (NF1) is a common autosomal disorder; the criteria for the diagnosis of NF1 includes café au lait spots, freckling, and Neurofibromas (NF). Skin symptoms have a major impact on patients' Quality of Life (QOL) but little is known about the burden of the disease on patients. The aim of this study was to explore the experiences of patients with NF.

Materials and Methods:

Using purposive sampling, 20 participants were enrolled in this qualitative content analysis study. The study was carried out between 2019 and 2020. Unstructured interviews and field notes were used to gather data. Data collection was stopped when data saturation was achieved.

Results:

Data analysis revealed 14 subcategories and 4 categories including “failing and falling behind in life”, “deprivation and restriction”, “social isolation”, and “ineffective adaptation to the disease”, which indicate the perception of patients with NF.

Conclusions:

In addition to the physical burden due to physical complications and problems, NF imposes a high degree of psychological and social burden on patients causing mental conflicts, which in turn results in them failing and falling behind in life. These findings illustrate the need to develop strategies and use multidisciplinary approaches to support patients, and thus to reduce the burden of NF.

Identification of NF1 Frameshift Variants in Two Chinese Families With Neurofibromatosis Type 1 and Early-Onset Hypertension

Background: Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF-1) is a common autosomal dominant disorder caused by mutations in the NF1 gene. It is characterized by multiple café-au-lait macules, cutaneous neurofibromas, optic glioma, Lisch nodules, and axillary and inguinal freckling. The aim of this study was to investigate NF1 mutations in two Chinese families with NF-1 who presented with early-onset hypertension, and to determine the prevalence of hypertension associated with NF-1 to better understand this complication. Methods: Whole-exome sequencing was performed for the probands with NF-1 from two unrelated families. Possible pathogenic mutation was predicted by bioinformatic tools. Sanger sequencing was used to confirm candidate variants in all available individuals for familial co-segregation analysis. We also performed a systematic literature review of studies that reported the prevalence of hypertension in patients with NF-1. Results: In family 1, a recurrent mutation c.6789_6792delTTAC in NF1 was identified in the proband but in no other family members, indicating that this is a de novo mutation. In family 2, a novel mutation c.6934_6936delGCAinsTGCT in NF1 was detected in the proband and two other family members, which co-segregated with the disease phenotype within the family. Both mutations were predicted to be pathogenic by bioinformatic analysis. We found hypertension was a relatively common complication of NF-1, with a prevalence range of 6.1-23.4%. Ambulatory blood pressure monitoring is a stable method for detecting initial alterations of the blood pressure pattern, particularly for pre-hypertension. Conclusions: We identified one recurrent (c.6789_6792delTTAC) and one novel frame-shift mutation (c.6934_6936delGCAinsTGCT) in two unrelated families with NF-1 using whole-exome sequencing. In consideration of phenotypic heterogeneity in NF-1, genetic testing is a robust tool which helps early and accurate diagnosis. Because hypertension is not a rare complication of NF-1, routine screening for hypertension in patients with NF-1, especially children and adolescents, is important to avoid serious cardiovascular events.