Evaluation of tyrosinase mRNA as a tumor marker in the blood of melanoma patients

Relationship between erb-B2 mRNA Expression in Blood and Tissue of Invasive Ductal Carcinoma Breast Cancer Patients and Clinicopathological Characteristics of the Tumors

Molecular detection methods such as RT-PCR for detecting breast cancer-associated gene expression in the peripheral blood have the potential to modify breast cancer (BC) staging and therapy. In this regard, we evaluated the potential of erb-B2 molecular marker in BC detection and analyzed the expression of erb-B2 mRNA in the peripheral blood and fresh tissue samples of 50 pretreated female BC patients and 50 healthy females by reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) method. We also assessed the correlation of erb-B2 mRNA marker positivity in peripheral blood and tumor tissue samples with clinical and pathological factors in BC patients in order to evaluate its prognostic value. It was shown that there is a significant difference between healthy females and BC patients with expression of the erb-B2 molecular marker (p<0.01). A significant difference between the expression of erb-B2 in the peripheral blood and tissue samples of BC patients (p<0.01) and the frequency of circulating erb-B2 mRNA expression in peripheral blood and in tissue was detected by RT-PCR. No correlation was found between erb-B2 mRNA expression in blood or tumor tissue samples and lymph node, tumor grade, tumor stage, tumor size, patient's age, ki67, estrogen receptor (ER), progesterone receptor (PGR), P53, and HER-2 status. However, in a small subset of 31 BC patients we found that expression of erb-B2 in peripheral blood or in both peripheral blood and tumor tissue was directly correlated with lympho-vascular invasion and perineural invasion as poor prognostic features. The highest rates of erb-B2 expression in peripheral blood or tumor tissue were in the ER and PR negative and HER-2 positive group. This study suggests that the application of the RT-PCR and immunohistochemical methods for erb-B2 molecular marker detection would provide a higher detection rate, especially in early stage BC.

Detection methods of circulating tumor cells in cutaneous melanoma: a systematic review

The vast majority of melanoma-related deaths are due to disseminated malignancy. Many treated patients who are clinically disease-free will go on to relapse. Therefore, new prognostic tools must be developed to better assess metastatic potential and assist in patient management. Circulating tumor cells are a widely studied metastatic biomarker with promising prognostic utility, as the shedding of cells from the primary tumor into peripheral blood is a necessary step in disease dissemination. An assortment of technologies and techniques has been developed to isolate and detect circulating melanoma cells (CMCs), but a standardized method is yet to be established. It is the aim of this study to systematically review the diverse enrichment and detection methods of circulating tumor cells in cutaneous melanoma. A literature search yielded 351 articles, of which 74 were deemed eligible according to inclusion criteria, the primary requirement being the reporting of patient CMC positivity status stratified by the stage of melanoma. Pertinent studies were used to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each method. Additionally, we calculated the sensitivity and specificity of seven common melanoma-associated markers based on the available literature.

Assessment of prognostic circulating tumor cells in a phase III trial of adjuvant immunotherapy after complete resection of stage IV melanoma

OBJECTIVE

To verify circulating tumor cell (CTC) prognostic utility in stage IV resected melanoma patients in a prospective international phase III clinical trial.

BACKGROUND

Our studies of melanoma patients in phase II clinical trials demonstrated prognostic significance for CTCs in patients with AJCC stage IV melanoma. CTCs were assessed to determine prognostic utility in follow-up of disease-free stage IV patients pre- and during treatment.

METHODS

After complete metastasectomy, patients were prospectively enrolled in a randomized trial of adjuvant therapy with a whole-cell melanoma vaccine, Canvaxin, plus Bacille Calmette-Guerin (BCG) versus placebo plus BCG. Blood specimens obtained pretreatment (n = 244) and during treatment (n = 214) were evaluated by quantitative real-time reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) for expression of MART-1, MAGE-A3, and PAX3 mRNA biomarkers. Univariate and multivariate Cox analyses examined CTC biomarker expression with respect to clinicopathological variables.

RESULTS

CTC biomarker(s) (≥ 1) was detected in 54% of patients pretreatment and in 86% of patients over the first 3 months. With a median follow-up of 21.9 months, 71% of patients recurred and 48% expired. CTC levels were not associated with known prognostic factors or treatment arm. In multivariate analysis, pretreatment CTC (> 0 vs. 0 biomarker) status was significantly associated with disease-free survival (DFS; HR 1.64, P = 0.002) and overall survival (OS; HR 1.53, P = 0.028). Serial CTC (>0 vs. 0 biomarker) status was also significantly associated with DFS (HR 1.91, P = 0.02) and OS (HR 2.57, P = 0.012).

CONCLUSION

CTC assessment can provide prognostic discrimination before and during adjuvant treatment for resected stage IV melanoma patients.

Circulating tumor cells in uveal melanoma

Despite advances in the diagnosis and local tumor control, the overall mortality rate for uveal melanoma remains high because of the development of metastatic disease. The clinical and histopathological systems currently being used to classify patients are not sufficiently accurate to predict metastasis. Tumor genotyping has demonstrated significant promise but obtaining tumor tissue can be problematic. Furthermore, assessment of tumor tissue does not indicate whether tumor cells have actually been shed and cannot indicate whether treatment is reducing metastasis. The detection of circulating tumor cells in blood has been shown to be a prognostic biomarker that can be used to monitor the effectiveness of therapy in patients with metastatic carcinoma. Uveal melanoma disseminates hematogenously, and the detection of circulating melanoma cells may potentially be useful for diagnosis, risk stratification, and the monitoring of disease progression and treatment efficacy. PCR-based and immunomagnetic cell isolation techniques, derived from studies in patients with cutaneous melanoma, have been tested. For various biological and technical reasons, they have not demonstrated the accuracy and reproducibility required for an effective prognostic assay in patients with uveal melanoma. Assessments have been confounded by false positives and negatives and thus, correlations between circulating melanoma cells and survival have not yet been established. Circulating melanoma cell detection is a valuable tool for investigating metastasis in uveal melanoma and also has the potential to become a standard part of uveal melanoma management. However, more research on the biology of uveal melanoma as well as improvements upon the current technologies are needed.

Prognostic molecular biomarkers for cutaneous malignant melanoma

Molecular signatures of melanoma have propelled new approaches to early diagnosis, monitoring of treatment response, and targeted therapy. This review discusses messenger RNA (mRNA), genomic, and epigenomic melanoma biomarkers in blood and tissue specimens. The major focus is on tissue-based molecular assays to upstage sentinel lymph nodes (SLNs), and blood-based assays to detect melanoma progression by monitoring levels of circulating tumor cells (CTC) and circulating DNA.

Global gene expression profiling and validation in esophageal squamous cell carcinoma and its association with clinical phenotypes

PURPOSE

Esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) is an aggressive tumor with poor prognosis. Understanding molecular changes in ESCC will enable identification of molecular subtypes and provide potential targets for early detection and therapy.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

We followed up a previous array study with additional discovery and confirmatory studies in new ESCC cases by using alternative methods. We profiled global gene expression for discovery and confirmation, and validated selected dysregulated genes with additional RNA and protein studies.

RESULTS

A total of 159 genes showed differences with extreme statistical significance (P < E-15) and 2-fold differences or more in magnitude (tumor/normal RNA expression ratio, N = 53 cases), including 116 upregulated and 43 downregulated genes. Of 41 genes dysregulated in our prior array study, all but one showed the same fold change directional pattern in new array studies, including 29 with 2-fold changes or more. Alternative RNA expression methods validated array results: more than two thirds of 51 new cases examined by real-time PCR (RT-PCR) showed 2-fold differences or more for all seven genes assessed. Immunohistochemical protein expression results in 275 cases which were concordant with RNA for five of six genes.

CONCLUSION

We identified an expanded panel of genes dysregulated in ESCC and confirmed previously identified differentially expressed genes. Microarray-based gene expression results were confirmed by RT-PCR and protein expression studies. These dysregulated genes will facilitate molecular categorization of tumor subtypes and identification of their risk factors, and serve as potential targets for early detection, outcome prediction, and therapy.

Old and new serological biomarkers in melanoma: where we are in 2009

Biomarkers play an important role in the diagnosis and prognostic classification of various cancers and can be useful in monitoring the patient's clinical course of disease and response to therapy. Generally, biomarkers are proteins and their expressions are associated with malignant disease. In the majority of cases, the marker molecules are expressed by the tumour cells themselves or by the tumour microenvironment cells. Thus, most biomarkers can primarily be found in malignant tissues, but after active secretion or passive release at tumour destruction, they become detectable in body fluids such as blood. Besides morphological and histopathological biomarkers (anatomic site, type of the primary tumour, tumour size, invasion depth, vascular invasion and ulceration), an increasing variety of serological markers have been identified, providing the possibility of a more detailed diagnostic and prognostic subgrouping of tumour entities, up to and even changing existing classification systems. The goal of this review is to provide an overview of old and more recent serological biomarkers in malignant melanoma. We will first focus on confirmed and nonconfirmed serum tumour markers, followed by proteomic profiling, an innovative approach to identify new and better serological biomarkers in melanoma, and ending with the predictive factors for treatments in this pathology.

New Developments in the Staging of Melanoma

As the incidence of melanoma increases, so does the search for new staging techniques that may provide important prognostic information and aid in the detection of early metastatic disease. The application of molecular techniques may provide powerful new tools in this search. This review summarizes recent findings obtained by means of conventional RT-PCR, cDNA arrays, and proteomics in the investigation of human melanoma. The molecular tools discussed in this review demonstrate how global transcript and protein analysis might contribute not only to the staging of melanoma, but may hold great promise in improving the diagnosis and treatment of this disease.

Prognostic relevance of occult nodal micrometastases and circulating tumor cells in colorectal cancer in a prospective multicenter trial

PURPOSE

Nodal micrometastasis and circulating tumor cells detected by multimarker quantitative real-time reverse transcription-PCR (qRT-PCR) may have prognostic importance in patients with colorectal cancer.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Paraffin-embedded sentinel lymph nodes from 67 patients and blood from 34 of these patients were evaluated in a prospective multicenter trial of sentinel lymph node mapping in colorectal cancer. Sentinel lymph nodes were examined by H&E staining and cytokeratin immunohistochemistry. Sentinel lymph nodes and blood were examined by a four-marker qRT-PCR assay (c-MET, melanoma antigen gene-A3 family, beta1-->4-N-acetylgalactosaminyltransferase, and cytokeratin-20); qRT-PCR results were correlated with disease stage and outcome.

RESULTS

In H&E-negative sentinel lymph node patients that recurred, cytokeratin immunohistochemistry and qRT-PCR detected metastasis in 30% and 60% of patients, respectively. Disease-free survival differed significantly by multimarker qRT-PCR upstaged sentinel lymph node (P = 0.014). qRT-PCR analysis of blood for circulating tumor cells correlated with overall survival (P = 0.040).

CONCLUSION

Molecular assessment for micrometastasis in sentinel lymph node and blood specimens may help identify patients at high risk for recurrent colorectal cancer, who could benefit from adjuvant therapy.

Molecular and biochemical testing in stage III melanoma: multimarker reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction assay of lymph fluid after lymph node dissection and preoperative serum lactate dehydrogenase level

BACKGROUND

There is a need for biomarkers to identify patients at risk for disease progression after resection of melanoma regional lymph node metastasis.

OBJECTIVES

This study assessed the prognostic value of multimarker reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assay in lymphatic drainage (LY) after lymph node dissection (LND) and of preoperative serum lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) levels in American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) stage III melanoma patients.

METHODS

We collected 24-h LY from 255 stage III melanoma patients after radical LND [114, completion LND after positive sentinel node biopsy (CLND); 141, therapeutic LND for clinically/cytologically detected regional nodal metastases (TLND)]. For detection of melanoma cells, RT-PCR assays with primers specific for tyrosinase, MART1 (MelanA) and uMAGE mRNA were conducted. The LY sample was deemed positive if at least one marker was detected. In 244 patients, the preoperative serum LDH level was available. Median follow-up time was 25 months (range 5-60).

RESULTS

The LY multimarker RT-PCR assay results were positive in 82 of 255 patients (32%). A significantly higher rate of melanoma recurrence was observed in patients with positive LY multimarker RT-PCR results (P = 0.01). Significant relationships were observed between positive LY multimarker RT-PCR results and shorter 3-year overall survival (OS) and disease-free survival (DFS), both in univariate and multivariate analyses (P = 0.007). Preoperative serum LDH level was increased in 79 of 244 patients (32%) [40.5% in TLND group and 23.0% in CLND group (P = 0.003)]. There were significant differences in OS between patients with normal and high preoperative LDH levels (P = 0.007), and these differences were seen mainly in patients in the TLND group.

CONCLUSIONS

The multimarker RT-PCR assay detected melanoma cells in approximately 32% of LY after LND, which correlated significantly with early melanoma recurrence and shorter survival. Increased pre-LND serum LDH level had an additional negative impact on OS of melanoma patients with palpable nodal metastases after TLND.

Early detection of melanoma progression by quantitative real-time RT-PCR analysis for multiple melanoma markers

Standard screening of melanoma patients is a useful tool for predicting outcome of patients, however, an instant methodology for exact detection of subclinical disease or monitoring treatment response is under investigation. Detection of circulating melanoma cells is, therefore, a possible novel promising staging method. However, inconsistent data on method sensitivity and on the predicted patient outcome has been shown repeatedly. Recently, a multimarker real-time RT-PCR methodology for quantification of five melanoma markers Melan-A, gp 100, MAGE-3, MIA and tyrosinase was described by our group. In the current prospective trial, blood specimens of 65 patients with AJCC stage IIB-III cutaneous melanoma after surgery were periodically examined. In the above group, 27 % of subjects relapsed during the study. Prior to the disease progression we could observe a statistically significant tumor marker elevation in previous 0 to 9 months in all patients with clinical relapse. MAGE-3 became the most sensitive progression marker. During progression, three concordant positive markers were seen in 39 % of patients, followed by two concordant positive markers in 28 % and 1 marker in 33 %. This study supports the use of a multimarker real-time RT-PCR as a disease progression predictor. The dynamic assessment of serially obtained blood specimens represents a useful method for early metastasis detection and treatment response of melanoma patients.

Multimarker real-time reverse transcription-PCR for quantitative detection of melanoma-associated antigens: a novel possible staging method

BACKGROUND

Detection of melanoma cells in peripheral blood is a promising method for monitoring haematogenous spread of melanoma cells. It enables us to detect early metastasis and to better stratify candidates for adjuvant immunotherapy. Inconsistent data on the sensitivity and clinical relevance of this method have been reported.

STUDY DESIGN

We developed a multimarker real-time reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) for quantification of five melanoma markers: Melan-A, gp100, MAGE-3, MIA and tyrosinase. In this prospective study, 65 patients with resected cutaneous melanoma stage IIB-III were screened. Peripheral blood samples were collected every 3 months for the following 18 months, and circulating melanoma cells were examined and compared with clinical staging results.

RESULTS

Eighteen patients relapsed during the trial and showed different types of melanoma progression. All these patients experienced statistically significant tumour marker elevation in the period from 0 to 9 months before the disease progression. MAGE-3 was the most sensitive progression marker. In patients with progression, we observed three concordant positive markers in 39% of cases, two concordant positive markers in 28%, and finally one marker in 33%.

CONCLUSIONS

This report describes a multiple-marker real-time RT-PCR, which is able to provide quantitative data on melanoma markers in the peripheral blood of melanoma patients. Measurement of the studied molecular markers in our hands represents a prognostic factor and a useful method for early detection of metastasis and treatment response of melanoma patients.

Issues affecting molecular staging in the management of patients with melanoma

Prediction of metastatic potential remains one of the main goals to be pursued in order to better assess the risk subgroups of patients with melanoma. Detection of occult melanoma cells in peripheral blood (circulating metastatic cells [CMC]) or in sentinel lymph nodes (sentinel node metastatic cells [SNMC]), could significantly contribute to better predict survival in melanoma patients. An overview of the numerous published studies indicate the existence of several drawbacks about either the reliability of the approaches for identification of occult melanoma cells or the clinical value of CMC and SNMC as prognostic factors among melanoma patients. In this sense, characterization of the molecular mechanisms involved in development and progression of melanoma (referred to as melanomagenesis) could contribute to better classify the different subsets of melanoma patients. Increasing evidence suggest that melanoma develops as a result of accumulated abnormalities in genetic pathways within the melanocytic lineage. The different molecular mechanisms may have separate roles or cooperate during all evolutionary phases of melanocytic tumourigenesis, generating different subsets of melanoma patients with distinct aggressiveness, clinical behaviour, and response to therapy. All these features associated with either the dissemination of occult metastatic cells or the melanomagenesis might be useful to adequately manage the melanoma patients with different prognosis as well as to better address the different melanoma subsets toward more appropriate therapeutic approaches.

Serial detection of circulating tumour cells by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction assays is a marker for poor outcome in patients with malignant melanoma

Background

Detection of circulating malignant cells (CMCs) through a reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assay seems to be a demonstration of systemic disease. We here evaluated the prognostic role of RT-PCR assays in serially-taken peripheral blood samples from patients with malignant melanoma (MM).

Methods

One hundred forty-nine melanoma patients with disease stage ranging from I to III were consecutively collected in 1997. A multi-marker RT-PCR assay was used on peripheral blood samples obtained at time of diagnosis and every 6 months during the first two years of follow-up (total: 5 samples). Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed after 83 months of median follow-up.

Results

Detection of at least one circulating mRNA marker was considered a signal of the presence of CMC (referred to as PCR-positive assay). A significant correlation was found between the rate of recurrences and the increasing number of PCR-positive assays (P = 0.007). Presence of CMC in a high number (≥2) of analysed blood samples was significantly correlated with a poor clinical outcome (disease-free survival: P = 0.019; overall survival: P = 0.034). Multivariate analysis revealed that presence of a PCR-positive status does play a role as independent prognostic factors for overall survival in melanoma patients, adding precision to the predictive power of the disease stage.

Conclusion

Our findings indicated that serial RT-PCR assay may identify a high risk subset of melanoma patients with occult cancer cells constantly detected in blood circulation. Prolonged presence of CMCs seems to act as a surrogate marker of disease progression or a sign of more aggressive disease.

Association of circulating tumor cells with serum tumor-related methylated DNA in peripheral blood of melanoma patients

Although previous studies have separately shown the utility of circulating tumor cells (CTC) or cell-free tumor-related DNA in blood of cancer patients, there has been no investigation of their association and/or the prognostic value of combining these assessments. To date, the true source of tumor-related DNA in serum remains unknown. We hypothesized that CTC is a possible origin of serum tumor-related methylated DNA and their combination can predict disease outcome. To test this hypothesis, we obtained matched pairs of peripheral blood lymphocytes and serum specimens simultaneously from 50 American Joint Committee on Cancer stage IV melanoma patients before administration of biochemotherapy. Peripheral blood leukocytes were analyzed for three mRNA markers of CTC: MART-1, GalNAc-T, and MAGE-A3. Sera were analyzed for two methylated DNA markers: RASSF1A and RAR-beta2. CTC were detected in 13 of 15 (86%) patients with serum tumor-related methylated DNA and only in 13 of 35 (37%) patients without methylated DNA (P = 0.001). The number of CTC markers detected significantly correlated with methylated DNA (P = 0.008). CTC and methylated DNA were significantly correlated with biochemotherapy-treated patients' outcome. Patients with both CTC and methylated DNA showed significantly poorer response to biochemotherapy (P = 0.02) and worse time to progression and overall survival (P = 0.009 and 0.02, respectively). The correlation between CTC and serum tumor-related methylated DNA and the significant effect of this correlation on disease outcome indicate that a composite molecular assessment in blood may be a useful determinant of disease status and efficacy of systemic therapy for melanoma.

The prognostic value of circulating tumor cells in patients with melanoma: a systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

The detection of circulating tumor cells (CTC) in patients with melanoma represents an appealing prognostic tool, but no consensus exists on this topic. We aimed to comprehensively and quantitatively summarize the evidence for the use of CTC to predict patients' clinical outcome.

METHODS

Fifty-three studies enrolling 5,433 patients were reviewed. Correlation of CTC status with tumor-node-metastasis disease stage and patients' overall (OS) and progression-free (PFS) survival was assessed by means of association statistics and meta-analysis, respectively.

RESULTS

CTC status correlated with both tumor-node-metastasis stage (stage I, 32%; stage II, 41.7%; stage III, 41.1%; stage IV, 47.4%; P(trend) < 0.0001) and survival (OS: hazard ratio, 2.42; 95% confidence interval, 1.7-3.45, P < 0.0001; PFS: hazard ratio, 2.45; 95% confidence interval, 1.78-3.38; P < 0.0001). However, statistical heterogeneity was significant for both OS and PFS, likely underscoring the wide variability in study design. Furthermore, CTC positivity rates in early stages were higher and in the metastatic setting were lower than expected, which indicates an unsatisfactory accuracy of currently available CTC detection assays.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest that CTC might have a clinically valuable prognostic power in patients with melanoma. However, the heterogeneity of the studies thus far published warrants caution not to overestimate the favorable results of pooled data.

Serial monitoring of circulating melanoma cells during neoadjuvant biochemotherapy for stage III melanoma: outcome prediction in a multicenter trial

PURPOSE

Circulating tumor cells (CTCs) in blood may be important in assessing tumor progression and treatment response. We hypothesized that quantitative real-time reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction using multimarker mRNA assays could detect CTCs and be used as a surrogate predictor of outcome in patients receiving neoadjuvant biochemotherapy (BC) for melanoma.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Blood specimens were collected at four sampling points from 63 patients enrolled on a prospective multicenter phase II trial of BC before and after surgical treatment of American Joint Committee on Cancer stage III melanoma. Each specimen was assessed by quantitative real-time reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction for expression of four melanoma-associated markers: melanoma antigen recognized by T cells 1; beta1 --> 4-N-acetylgalactosaminyltransferase; paired box homeotic gene transcription factor 3; and melanoma antigen gene-A3 family, and the changes of CTCs during treatment and prognostic effect of CTCs after overall treatment on recurrence and survival were investigated.

RESULTS

At a median postoperative follow-up time of 30.4 months, 44 (70%) patients were clinically disease free. In relapse-free patients, the number of detected markers significantly decreased during preoperative BC (P = .036), during postoperative BC (P = .002), and during overall treatment (P < .0001). Marker detection after overall treatment was associated with significant decreases in relapse-free and overall survival (P < .0001). By multivariate analysis using a Cox proportional-hazards model, the number of markers detected after overall treatment was a significant independent prognostic factor for overall survival (risk ratio, 12.6; 95% CI, 3.16 to 50.5; P = .0003).

CONCLUSION

Serial monitoring of CTCs in blood may be useful for indicating systemic subclinical disease and predicting outcome of patients receiving neoadjuvant BC for metastatic melanoma.

Multimarker quantitative real-time PCR detection of circulating melanoma cells in peripheral blood: relation to disease stage in melanoma patients

BACKGROUND

Detection of melanoma cells in circulation may be important in assessing tumor progression. The objective of this study was to develop a specific, reliable multimarker quantitative real-time reverse transcription-PCR (qRT) assay for detecting melanoma cells in patients' blood.

METHODS

We developed qRT assays for the mRNA of four melanoma-associated markers: MART-1, GalNAc-T, PAX-3, and MAGE-A3. In optimization studies, we tested 17 melanoma cell lines and 49 peripheral blood leukocyte (PBL) samples from volunteers. We performed RNA and melanoma cell dilution studies to assess the detection limits and imprecision of the assays. We measured the mRNAs in blood specimens from 94 melanoma patients [American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) stage I, n = 20; II, n = 20; III, n = 32; IV, n = 22].

RESULTS

All markers were frequently detected in melanoma cell lines, whereas none of the markers was detected in PBLs from volunteers. The qRT assay could detect 1 melanoma cell in 10(7) PBLs in the melanoma cell-dilution studies. Markers were detected in 15%, 30%, 75%, and 86% of melanoma patients with AJCC stage I, II, III, and IV disease, respectively. The number of positive markers and AJCC stage were significantly correlated (Spearman correlation coefficient = 0.58; P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Multimarker qRT can detect circulating melanoma cells in blood. Measurement of the studied molecular markers in blood may be useful in detection of metastasis and monitoring treatment response of melanoma patients.

Lack of Prognostic Importance of Reverse-Transcriptase Polymerase Chain Reaction Detection of Circulating Messenger RNA in Patients with Melanoma

BACKGROUND

Molecular serologic markers for detecting early melanoma metastases have been described. The objective of this study was to determine whether reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction detection of circulating tyrosinase messenger RNA (mRNA) can identify the presence of subclinical metastases and predict subsequent clinical recurrence in surgically treated melanoma patients who are at significant risk for relapse.

METHODS

Preoperative peripheral blood samples of disease-free melanoma patients, disease stage ranging from I to IV, were analyzed for the presence of tyrosinase mRNA by semiquantitative reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction as a putative marker for circulating melanoma cells. Multivariate analysis was performed to evaluate the prognostic value of tyrosinase mRNA in the blood and in the correlating pathologic stage of disease with recurrence and survival.

RESULTS

The study group consisted of 96 patients. The mean age was 54 years (range, 24 to 83 years). The mean Breslow thickness was 3 mm (range, 0.9 to 21 mm). Circulating melanoma cells were detected in 66 patients (69 percent). Blood polymerase chain reaction positivity by American Joint Committee on Cancer stage was as follows: stage I, 19 of 28 patients (68 percent); stage II, 17 of 25 patients (68 percent); stage III, 28 of 41 patients (68 percent); and stage IV, two of two patients (100 percent). Tyrosinase detection was not associated with stage of disease (p = 0.77). At a median follow-up of 30 months, disease recurred in 21 patients (22 percent), and 15 patients (16 percent) died. Disease stage of the patients correlated with recurrence (p < 0.0001) and death (p < 0.0001). The finding of mRNA tyrosinase in peripheral blood samples was not associated with recurrence (p = 0.1) or death (p = 0.77).

CONCLUSIONS

The use of polymerase chain reaction to detect circulating tyrosinase mRNA in peripheral blood does not correlate with traditional prognostic indicators in patients with cutaneous melanoma and does not appear to be an effective prognostic tool.

Molecular Staging in Stage II and III Melanoma Patients and Its Effect on Long-Term Survival

Purpose

To assess the prognostic value of serial reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) -based measurements of tyrosinase mRNA in peripheral blood of stage II and III melanoma patients.

Patients and Methods

During routine follow-up of American Joint Committee on Cancer stage II and III melanoma patients, serial testing for tyrosinase transcripts in peripheral blood was performed by RT-PCR. The PCR results were compared with the clinical data collected during the follow-up.

Results

Over a period of 3 years, 111 patients (78 stage II and 33 stage III patients) were enrolled, and tyrosinase determinations were carried out. The 6-year disease-specific survival probability was 97% for patients always showing negative RT-PCR results and 67% for patients who tested positive at least once. In a Cox proportional hazards model, the prognostic value of sex, age, site of primary tumor, histologic subtype, stage, Breslow's tumor thickness, Clark level, and the time-dependent variable PCR result was assessed. Patients with a positive RT-PCR test had a distinctly higher risk of dying from melanoma, with a hazard ratio of 12.6 (95% CI, 3.4 to 46.3; P < .001).

Conclusion

Our study shows a strong association between PCR and disease-specific survival time. Detection of tyrosinase mRNA in peripheral blood may be of similar importance for the clinical course of melanoma as the detection of micrometastatic disease in the sentinel lymph node. Whether a combination of these two factors leads to a better definition of the prognosis of melanoma patients is under investigation in current studies.

Quantification of melanoma mRNA markers in sentinel nodes: pre-clinical evaluation of a single-step real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction assay

Although reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analysis of melanocyte-associated mRNA can detect sentinel node melanoma metastases, most published assays are semi-quantitative methods of unknown sensitivity and precision, unsuitable for clinical use. We describe a single-step real-time quantitative RT-PCR assay for MART-1 and tyrosinase mRNAs, suitable for sentinel node analysis in a clinical setting. Using serial dilutions of melanoma cell line SK-MEL-28 RNA in water as a calibrator, we obtained linear calibration curves covering the range 0.5 to 10,000 arbitrary units (SK-MEL-28 melanoma cell equivalents). The sensitivity limit was 0.32 (MART-1) and 5 (tyrosinase) arbitrary units. Analytical imprecision was between 11% and 34%. MART-1 PCR efficiency was unaffected when samples were diluted with negative lymph node RNA rather than water, whereas tyrosinase PCR efficiency was halved. To evaluate the clinical suitability of our assay, we quantified melanocyte mRNAs in sentinel nodes with histologically verified micrometastases (n = 10) and benign nevus inclusions (n = 10), and in sentinel nodes without evidence of intranodal melanocytes (n = 10). We found significant differences in median melanocyte-derived mRNA levels comparing the three types of lymph nodes, suggesting that this quantitative molecular protocol may increase assay precision and be useful for the clinical evaluation of sentinel nodes.

The history and future of melanoma staging

The evolution and progressive refinement of an internationally accepted melanoma staging system over the last 50 years has resulted in much greater accuracy and increased utility, but the staging process has become more complex and less intuitive. This raises the question of whether melanoma staging should continue to develop with ever-increasing levels of complexity, or whether attempts should be made to produce an alternative system that is simpler and more intuitive. The current, TNM-based American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging system for melanoma incorporates only some of the prognostic factors of proven significance. However, the information that is now available about these and other, well-documented prognostic factors allows accurate prediction of an individual melanoma patient's prognosis using a computer-generated estimate. Thus an alternative staging strategy that could be considered in the future would be to use such an estimate to obtain a numerical score for each patient, based on all available information agreed to be of prognostic relevance. A stage grouping could then be assigned on the basis of that score, according to previously determined score ranges for each stage and substage. The advantages of such a system would be that it would allow more reliable comparison of treatment results within and between institutions, and would provide more equivalent stratification groups for patients entering clinical trials of new therapies and those entering adjuvant therapy trials. A further advantage would be that because there would be a direct link between staging and prognostic estimate, such a system would be more readily able to be understood in an intuitive fashion.

Detection of tyrosinase and tyrosinase-related protein 1 sequences from peripheral blood of melanoma patients using reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction

BACKGROUND

malignant melanoma has one of the highest rates of metastasis. Unlike other solid cancers, no sensitive tumor markers or laboratory tests that can provide information of the risk of metastasis and predict the prognosis have yet been established.

OBJECTIVE

the study was done to establish a RT-PCR sensitive and specific enough to detect melanocyte-specific transcripts from peripheral blood cells.

METHODS

peripheral white blood cells were collected from 30 healthy donors and 43 melanoma patients. Melanocyte-specific tyrosinase (TYR) and tyrosinase-related protein 1 (TYRP1) were selected as targets of RT-PCR. The sensitivity of detection using SK-mel-23 melanoma cells and rates of false-positiveness using non-melanoma blood were compared between single-step PCR and nested PCR. Analysis of melanoma blood samples was carried out by the single-step PCR.

RESULTS

the nested RT-PCR amplified the TYR and TYRP1 sequences from 14 and 2 of the 30 healthy bloods, respectively. However, the single-step RT-PCR did not amplify TYR or TYRP1 sequences from any of the healthy controls. Our single-step RT-PCR detected 1.7 and 0.8 SK-mel-23 melanoma cells per ml blood for TYR and TYRP1, respectively. Overall, TYR mRNA was detected in 15 of the 43 melanoma patients (34.9%), and TYRP1 mRNA in 16 of the 43 (37.2%). The specificities of detection of TYR and TYRP1 were 83.3 and 88.9%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

our single-step RT-PCR for TYR and TYRP1 mRNAs is more specific than the previous nested RT-PCR for TYR and applicable to detect circulating melanoma cells.

Prognostic value of multiple reverse transcription-PCR tyrosinase testing for circulating neoplastic cells in malignant melanoma

BACKGROUND

The reverse transcription-PCR tyrosinase assay (TYR test) cannot reliably detect malignant melanoma (MM) cells in blood as the cells often circulate at low concentrations. We evaluated the prognostic value of multiple TYR testing, the prognostic significance of individual positive TYR test results (TYR+) in asymptomatic melanoma patients, and whether statistical analysis could help in the interpretation of results of a test that measures phenomena that typically occur below its detection threshold.

METHODS

MM patients in stages I-IV (n = 150) underwent multiple testing with the TYR test during the course of their disease. TYR testing was performed as described by Smith et al. (Lancet 1991;38:1227-9). Statistical analyses were performed with the logistic function and t-test procedures.

RESULTS

The relationship between MM stage and the frequency of TYR+ was statistically significant (P = 0.011). Higher frequency of TYR+ in clinically asymptomatic patients after complete resection of the primary tumor was associated with an increased risk of recurrence of MM (prognostic sensitivity, 62%; specificity, 78%).

CONCLUSIONS

A single positive TYR test provides a warning for disease relapse, suggesting that multiple TYR testing might provide more reliable predictions of disease progression. Multiple testing and statistical analysis using a logistic function might allow for the interpretation of apparently inconsistent results of tests for very rare cells.

The role of molecular staging in malignant melanoma

AIMS

To review the role of tyrosinase RT-PCR in the detection of clinically occult metastatic disease, both within the regional lymph nodes and peripheral blood of patients with malignant melanoma. Secondly, to assess whether the detection of such minimal disease has clinical implications for patients with melanoma.

METHODS

A review of the literature was undertaken by searching the MEDLINE database for the period 1966-2002 without any language restrictions. Keywords included 'Molecular staging of melanoma', 'Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction', 'Malignant melanoma' and 'Tyrosinase'.

CONCLUSIONS

Detection of tyrosinase RT-PCR positive cells within the peripheral blood correlates with the clinical stage of malignant melanoma, the primary tumour thickness and other known prognostic indicators. Positive tyrosinase RT-PCR is associated with a reduction of disease-free survival and overall survival. Current studies demonstrate a higher rate of recurrence in RT-PCR positive patients with clinical stage II and III disease. Implications of a positive result within the regional lymph nodes are less well defined. A significant correlation has been demonstrated between positive results and increasing primary melanoma thickness. However, a large number of false-positive results have been demonstrated, due to benign naevi and schwann cells, which may hamper any statistically significant conclusions being reached.

Detection of multiple melanoma-associated markers in melanoma cell lines by RT in situ PCR

New surgical oncology techniques, such as lymphatic mapping and sentinel node biopsy, require precise identification of the presence of even very small numbers of tumor cells. The gold standard for such analysis remains microscopic assessment of tissue sections, stained conventionally or by immunohistochemistry for appropriate tumor markers. This approach is limited by sampling constraints and requires a high degree of expertise from the microscopist. Recent studies have demonstrated a subgroup of patients whose sentinel nodes are negative on microscopy, but whose nodes yield an enhanced signal for melanoma markers when evaluated by RT-PCR. These enhanced signals reflect a mixture of signal sources, including small numbers of melanoma cells and cells other than melanoma cells that express the relevant markers(s). Because the preparative techniques for RT-PCR destroy the structural integrity of the tissues and disrupt individual cells, the exact cellular source of enhanced signal from a tissue cannot be demonstrated by conventional RT-PCR. RT in situ PCR, in which the RT-PCR technique is applied on a tissue section, does identify the cells that are the source of signal. We have attempted to optimize this interesting approach and have applied it to the detection of relevant melanoma markers in tissue culture lines.

Prognostic value of circulating melanoma cells detected by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction

PURPOSE

Factors that are predictive of prognosis in patients who are diagnosed with malignant melanoma (MM) are widely awaited. Detection of circulating melanoma cells (CMCs) by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) has recently been postulated as a possible negative prognostic factor. Two main questions were addressed: first, whether the presence of CMCs, defined as the patient being positive for any of the three markers, had a prognostic role; and second, what the predictive value of each individual marker was.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A consecutive series of 200 melanoma patients observed between January 1997 and December 1997, with stage of disease ranging from I to IV, was analyzed by semiquantitative RT-PCR. Tyrosinase, p97, and MelanA/MART1 were used as markers to CMCs on baseline peripheral blood samples. Progression-free survival (PFS) was used as a unique end point and was described by the product limit method. Multivariable analysis was applied to verify whether the auspicated prognostic value of these markers was independent of the stage of disease, and a subgroup analysis was performed that excluded patients with stage IV disease.

RESULTS

Overall, 32% (64 of 200) of patients progressed, and a median PFS of 52 months in the whole series was observed. The presence of CMCs and the markers individually or combined was predictive of prognosis in the univariate analysis but did not provide additional prognostic information to the stage of disease in multivariable models. In the subgroup analysis of stage (ie, I-III subgroup), similar results were observed.

CONCLUSION

Detection of CMCs in peripheral blood samples at the time of MM diagnosis by semiquantitative RT-PCR does not add any significant predictive value to the stage of disease. Thus, this approach should not be used in clinical practice, and further studies are required to determine its usefulness.

Tyrosinase mRNA in blood of patients with melanoma treated with adjuvant interferon

PURPOSE

To evaluate the clinical significance of the detection of circulating melanoma cells in patients treated with adjuvant interferon and to determine their potential value as a marker of interferon response.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We prospectively analyzed 616 peripheral-blood samples from 120 melanoma patients with stage IIA (n = 33), IIB (n = 22), III (n = 50), or IV (surgically resected) (n = 15) disease receiving adjuvant interferon alfa-2b therapy. Tyrosinase mRNA was assayed by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) as a marker of circulating melanoma cells before the start of interferon and every 2 to 3 months thereafter.

RESULTS

With a median follow-up time of 32.3 months (range, 7.1 to 77.5 months), 47 patients (39.8%) relapsed and 31 (26%) died. During adjuvant interferon treatment, 76 patients (64%) had undetected circulating melanoma cells and 44 patients (36%) had a positive RT-PCR result in at least one sample. Actuarial 5-year disease-free survival was 62% in patients with persistently negative RT-PCR during interferon treatment and 38% for patients with positive RT-PCR during interferon (P =.02). Actuarial 5-year overall survival was 75% and 50%, respectively (P =.03).

CONCLUSION

Patients with melanoma and tyrosinase mRNA detected in the blood during adjuvant interferon therapy had a worse prognosis compared with patients with undetected tyrosinase mRNA during treatment. Further investigation into the detection of circulating melanoma cells as a surrogate marker of response to adjuvant interferon therapy is warranted.

Magnetic bead RT-PCR: establishment of a new method for detecting circulating melanoma cells

This study was performed to detect circulating melanoma cells in peripheral blood using a novel method based on magnetic-activated cell separation (MACS) followed by a nested reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) for tyrosinase and MART-1 mRNA. Samples to be tested were enriched for tumour cells either by isolating melanoma cells using two anti-melanoma antibodies (MART-1 and HMB-45) or by CD45 depletion of the non-melanoma cell fraction. The tumour cell-enriched fractions were subjected to mRNA isolation using oligo-deoxythymidylate (oligo-dT) magnetic beads followed by a nested RT-PCR. Sensitivity was assessed by spiking experiments and compared with a commonly used total RNA isolation system previously established in our department. Positive isolation of melanoma cells showed insufficient sensitivity, whereas negative isolation by depletion of leukocytes showed a detection limit of at least one melanoma cell per millilitre of whole blood. In further experiments, the depletion assay was applied to 25 peripheral blood samples of melanoma patients. The preliminary data obtained from the new method indicate a comparable detection rate to the established total RNA extraction method. However, not all the results were concordant. Therefore, future experiments need to be performed with a statistically greater number of patients.

Prognostic significance of the sequential detection of circulating melanoma cells by RT-PCR in high-risk melanoma patients receiving adjuvant interferon

The purpose of this study was to address the prognostic significance of circulating melanoma cells by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction in the peripheral blood of stage IIB and III melanoma patients on high-dose adjuvant interferon at multiple sequential time points from initiation of treatment. Tyrosinase mRNA in peripheral blood from these patients was assayed by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction prior to initiation of adjuvant interferon, at completion of 1 month of intravenous interferon and at 3 monthly intervals until progression. Four hundred and eighteen blood samples from 60 melanoma patients were analysed. The median follow-up time calculated from the time of inclusion in the study was 23 months (range 2-38 months). Tyrosinase mRNA in blood was detected in 42 (70%) of 60 patients: 16 (76%) of 21 stage IIB patients and 26 (66% ) of 39 stage III patients. The presence of tyrosinase mRNA in blood was correlated with a shorter disease-free survival (P : 0.03) and in multivariante analysis was an independent prognostic factor for relapse. Patients who seroconverted to a negative reverse-transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction after induction treatment had a significantly lower probability of recurrence. The presence of circulating melanoma cells is a marker of a high relapse risk and shorter disease-free survival whether detected postoperatively or during follow-up. Tyrosinase mRNA amplification by reverse-transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction may be a useful tool for monitoring the efficacy of adjuvant treatment in stage IIB and III melanoma patients.

PCR detection of circulating tumor cells in nasopharyngeal carcinoma patients with distant metastasis: effect of enzyme and sampling

BACKGROUND

Nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) has a high potential to develop distant metastasis after radiotherapy. Cytokeratin 19 (CK-19) mRNA has been frequently used as a marker in the detection of circulating tumor cells of epithelial origin, but has rarely been investigated in NPC. This study was performed to evaluate the effect of blood sampling and different Taq DNA polymerase on the results of nested reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assay.

METHODS

Peripheral blood samples from a total of 37 NPC patients with well-documented distant metastasis (M1) were collected before treatment. Eighteen patients had more than one blood sampling. Five different Taq DNA polymerases were used to test the blood from 17 patients. Peripheral blood of 37 nonmetastatic (M0) NPC patients was tested by the same nested RT-PCR system using multiple Taq DNA polymerases to evaluate the impact of multienzyme assay in the prediction of subsequent distant metastasis.

RESULTS

Among M1 NPC patients, the accumulative positive rates of CK-19 mRNA were 22.2%, 44.4%, 70.6%, 75.0%, and 80.0% when one, two, three, four, or five blood sampling were taken, respectively. The accumulative positive rates increased as the numbers of different enzymes increased-from 35.5% by one enzyme to 82.4% by five enzymes. Six of 37 M0 patients had distant metastasis develop after a median follow-up time of 20 months. The detection sensitivity for four-enzyme test (5 of 6 = 83.3%) is better than that of one-enzyme test (2 of 6 = 33.3%).

CONCLUSIONS

Our data demonstrate that multiple blood sampling or using multiple enzymes for nested RT-PCR assay significantly enhances the sensitivity in the molecular diagnosis of NPC metastasis.

Reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction detection of circulating tumor cells in patients with melanoma: correlation with clinical stage, tumor thickness and histological type

The aim of this study was to evaluate the correlation between the detection of circulating melanoma cells and prognostic criteria for malignant melanoma such as clinical stage, tumor thickness and histological type of the primary tumor. Using a reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) technique, melanoma cells were identified by detecting tyrosinase mRNA in peripheral blood from 58 patients with malignant melanoma classified according to the American Joint Committee on Cancer guidelines. The results of the RT-PCR assay for tyrosinase were related to two prognostic markers typically used to evaluate these tumors: clinical stage and thickness. Positive PCR results were more frequent in primary tumors measuring > 4 mm (83%) than in thinner tumors (1.1-4.0 mm, 74%; < or = 1.0 mm, 23%) (P = 0.005). No statistical correlation was found between the PCR results and histological appearance of the primary tumor. Although further studies are necessary, our results suggest the possible application of the PCR assay for tyrosinase mRNA in clinical evaluation of the prognosis of malignant melanoma.

Minimal residual disease in melanoma

A number of specific genes encoding for melanosomal proteins are selectively expressed in melanocytes and melanomas. For detection of circulating melanoma cells, the expression of the tyrosinase gene is most widely used. Several cohorts of melanoma patients from single institutions have been analyzed by various research groups for the presence of circulating melanoma cells in all stages of disease. The percentage of patients with evidence of occult tumor dissemination has been correlated with stage of disease in several, but not all, reports. Two prospective analyses suggest that the PCR result is of prognostic value in melanoma. Several laboratories have found PCR evidence for circulating melanoma cells in the vast majority of untreated patients with stage IV disease, although other groups have reported much lower frequencies. Taken together, there is a wide range of results. Methodological differences likely account for this discrepancy. With the availability of true quantitative RT-PCR systems, such as the Light Cycler system, accurate quantification of tyrosinase transcripts over a range of 1-10,000 tumor cells per ml of blood is possible. Quantitative RT-PCR systems also dramatically improve quality control, since exact quantitation of housekeeping gene mRNA facilitates determination of sample quality.

Evaluation of standard tyrosinase RT-PCR in melanoma patients by the use of the LightCycler system

BACKGROUND

Haematogenous spread influences outcome in melanoma patients. The clinical relevance of detecting circulating melanoma cells in peripheral blood by tyrosinase mRNA RT-PCR is, however, questioned as rates of positivity considerably vary between studies. Standard tyrosinase-nested RT-PCR was here compared with a real-time PCR technique.

METHODS

Forty-three blood samples from 20 stage III--IV melanoma patients were analyzed. Mononuclear cells were isolated using a Ficoll Hypaque gradient technique. Total RNA extracted by the acid guanidinum thiocyanate-phenol-chloroform method was reverse transcribed using random hexamers or specific primers. Standard tyrosinase-nested PCR was performed on Touchdown machine (Hybaid) and real-time PCR on a LightCycler instrument (Roche).

RESULTS

Only two samples from stage IV patients (one from random hexamers, one from antisense primers) were found tyrosinase positive with a 100% agreement between the two PCR techniques. A 10-fold dilution of the first-round products improved the PCR kinetic and the final amount of amplified product of positive samples, but not the rate of positivity.

CONCLUSIONS

Efficiency of the PCR reaction can be monitored in an online fashion by the LightCycler instrument allowing technical improvements. However, tyrosinase mRNA RT-PCR cannot be yet considered as a useful technique in the monitoring of melanoma patients.

Facts and pitfalls in the detection of tyrosinase mRNA in the blood of melanoma patients by RT-PCR

Reverse transcription (RT) of tyrosinase mRNA and specific cDNA amplification to facilitate the early detection of circulating tumor cells in melanoma patients have been reported. The significance and practical value of these procedures for the diagnosis of tumor dissemination in melanoma patients is, however, still unclear. We analyzed peripheral blood samples of melanoma patients of different clinical stages for the presence of tyrosinase mRNA by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). In addition to a nested RT-PCR-based system, we evaluated the new PCR enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay tyrosinase system for sensitivity and specificity in detecting circulating melanoma cells. Our results showed a high sensitivity and specificity for this system in detecting one melanoma cell in 1 ml of whole blood. Using different methods of detection, no tyrosinase mRNA was detectable in blood samples of patients with primary melanoma and regional lymph node metastases. In a small number of patients with visceral metastases (10-30%), we found tyrosinase mRNA-positive results. Analyses of different blood samples taken at 2-h intervals indicate that tumor cells persist only transiently in the peripheral blood. Successful establishment of melanoma cell growth from tyrosinase mRNA-positive samples indicates that viable tumor cells exist in melanoma patients' peripheral blood. Our results indicate a low amount of tyrosinase-specific transcripts in a small subset of stage IV patients and suggest that the analysis of tyrosinase mRNA in peripheral blood samples is not helpful as a prognostic marker or monitoring tool in melanoma patients.

Clinical significance of PCR-positive mRNA markers in peripheral blood and regional nodes of malignant melanoma patients. Melanoma Cooperative Group

Reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) with multiple markers has been demonstrated to be highly sensitive in detecting metastatic cells in peripheral blood of malignant melanoma (MM) patients, and the circulating MM cells to be significantly correlated with disease stages. We further evaluated the presence of specific PCR-positive mRNA markers in peripheral blood as well as in regional nodes as an expression of tumor progression. Peripheral blood samples from 317 MM patients with either localized (n = 219) or metastatic (n = 98) disease were processed to obtain total cellular RNA. RT-PCR was performed using tyrosinase (TYR), p97, and MelanA/MART1 as mRNA markers. PCR products were analyzed by gel electrophoresis and Southern blot hybridization. In addition, paraffin-embedded samples of histologically proven tumor-negative lymph nodes from the subset of patients with localized disease were analyzed by RT-PCR, using radiolabeled primers for TYR and MelanA/MART1. The presence of mRNA markers was significantly correlated with tumor burden with a good correlation between risk of recurrence (evaluated in stage I-III patients) and increasing number of PCR-positive markers (p = 0.0002). Currently, for each patient, PCR results obtained at different times during follow-up are being analyzed, and any variation in the number of PCR-positive markers is being correlated to the clinical status. Molecular screening of histologically negative nodes for the presence of metastatic MM cells is also under evaluation. Preliminary assessment of a subset of MM patients with higher risk of recurrence will require longer follow-up in order to define the role of RT-PCR in monitoring these patients.

Polymerase chain reaction in the detection of circulating tumour cells in peripheral blood of melanoma patients

Conflicting results were obtained by various research groups using the tyrosinase reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) for detecting melanoma cells circulating in peripheral blood. Whereas 100% positivity was initially reported for stage IV patients, more recent investigations reported positive detection rates between 30% and 50% in patients with disseminated melanoma. While the high detection rate initially reported in metastatic melanoma may be explained by contamination problems, methodological differences in different steps of the technical procedure of RT-PCR may account for the differences reported in more recent examinations. Major differences may result from the kind of blood preparation, the RNA isolation method, the kind of RT enzyme used, and the gene targeted by PCR primers. In our experience, blood purification by a Ficoll gradient increased melanoma cell detection rates compared to RNA extraction from total blood or after erythrocyte lysis. Amplification of MelanA in addition to tyrosinase resulted in a 30% enhanced sensitivity of melanoma cell detection compared to amplification to tyrosinase alone, whereas gp100/pMel17 and MUC18 gene products were already detected in blood from nonmelanoma patients. These findings are in agreement with those of other groups. Currently, an increase in the sensitivity for detection of circulating tumour cells to more than 50% of patients with disseminated melanoma seems to be unlikely. It is interesting that between 15% and 30% positive results and sometimes more have already been obtained from patients with primary melanoma. So far, there is no data for judging the prognostic significance of the detection of circulating tumour cells in patients without clinically recognisable metastases. Our limited experience shows that staging examinations in these patients reveal no proof of macrometastasis. Therefore, it is presently unclear whether these positive findings are associated with long-term prognosis or if they merely reflect false positive findings in this highly sensitive RT-PCR technique.

Interlaboratory evaluation of a new reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for the detection of circulating melanoma cells: a multicenter study of the Dermatologic Cooperative Oncology Group

PURPOSE

Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR)-based detection of tyrosinase mRNA is the most frequently used laboratory method for the detection of circulating tumor cells in melanoma patients. However, previously published results showed considerable variability in the PCR positivity rates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We designed a collaborative study to assess the sensitivity, specificity, and clinical relevance of a new standardized RT-PCR-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the detection of circulating melanoma cells. Blood samples of healthy donors mixed with cells of a melanoma cell line were prepared in a blinded fashion, and aliquots were sent to seven participating laboratories experienced in RT-PCR.

RESULTS

The results demonstrate a high sensitivity (1 melanoma cell/mL blood) and specificity (no false-negatives and 7.4% [2 of 28] false-positives) of the assay and a satisfactory rate of interlaboratory reproducibility. The analysis of aliquots of blinded samples derived from 60 melanoma patients identified tyrosinase mRNA in 17 of 60 (28.3%): three (20%) of 15 stage I patients, two (13.3%) of 15 stage II patients, five (35.7%) of 14 stage III patients, and seven (43.8%) of 16 stage IV patients. The interlaboratory reproducibility of positive samples, however, was extremely low and indicates the presence of low amounts of target mRNA.

CONCLUSION

Reverse transcriptase-PCR ELISA has a high sensitivity and specificity for the detection of tyrosinase mRNA in peripheral blood cells. The low interlaboratory reproducibility for the detection of tumor cells in blood samples of melanoma patients, however, raises the question of relevance of this assay for clinical use.

Detection of occult melanoma cells in paraffin-embedded histologically negative sentinel lymph nodes using a reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction assay

PURPOSE

Detection of occult metastasis before the development of clinical disease could allow more accurate staging, appropriate follow-up procedures, and adjuvant therapies in patients with malignant melanoma (MM). The sentinel lymph node (SLN) has been proposed as a reliable predictor of metastatic disease in the lymphatic basin draining the primary melanoma. In this study, we screened both paraffin-embedded SLNs and peripheral-blood (PB) samples from MM patients at various stage of disease using a multimarker reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assay. The prognostic significance of the presence of PCR-positive markers was also evaluated.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Total RNA was obtained from paraffin-embedded SLN sections and PB samples of 75 MM patients. RT-PCR was performed using tyrosinase and MelanA/MART1 as melanoma-associated markers. Radiolabeled PCR products were analyzed on denaturing polyacrylamide gels.

RESULTS

Good sensitivity of the RT-PCR assay on archival tissues was demonstrated after comparison of RT-PCR results on frozen and paraffin-embedded SLNs from 16 MM patients. Significant correlation between the disease stage and marker expression in both PB and SLN samples was observed; the highest value was for patients who were positive for both markers in SLN (P =.006). Progression of disease was significantly associated with the total number of PCR-positive markers in both PB (P =.034) and SLN (P =.001) samples.

CONCLUSION

Although sensitivity is lowered by the use of paraffin-embedded specimens, our data indicate that RT-PCR analysis of serial sections from archival SLNs may be helpful in improving detection of occult micrometastases, thus improving staging of patients with melanoma.

Serum S-100b protein as a prognostic marker in malignant cutaneous melanoma

PURPOSE

To evaluate whether S-100B protein in serum is an independent prognostic marker in malignant melanoma.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

S-100B protein in serum was analyzed in 1,007 consecutive patients with histologically verified cutaneous malignant melanoma. At the time of blood sampling, 876 patients were in clinical stage I, 35 were in stage II, and 96 were in stage III. The serum concentrations of S-100B protein were measured by a luminescence immunoassay (LIA).

RESULTS

The mean serum concentration of S-100B protein was significantly related to clinical stage, with the lowest level in stage I and the highest in stage III. In a multivariate analysis, S-100B protein levels in serum showed the strongest prognostic impact of the factors analyzed with respect to disease-specific survival in clinical stages II to III, followed by clinical stage. Serum S-100B protein was not a significant independent prognostic factor in clinical stage I, where tumor thickness showed the strongest relation to melanoma-specific survival, followed by ulceration and satellites.

CONCLUSION

This investigation contains the largest material of patients so far analyzed with the new LIA assay of S-100B protein in serum and confirms that S-100B protein in serum is correlated with clinical stage and is an independent prognostic marker in clinical stages II and III.

Evaluation of the use of tyrosinase-specific and melanA/MART-1-specific reverse transcriptase-coupled--polymerase chain reaction to detect melanoma cells in peripheral blood samples from 299 patients with malignant melanoma

BACKGROUND

There is a current need for a reliable prognostic marker for melanoma patients, particularly those with stage 2 and stage 3 disease, so that adjuvant therapies can be directed appropriately.

OBJECTIVES

To establish whether or not the use of tyrosinase-specific or melanA/MART-1-specific reverse transcriptase-coupled-polymerase chain reaction (RT--PCR) of peripheral blood cells detects preclinical disease progression in patients with malignant melanoma.

METHODS

Two hundred and ninety-nine patients with melanoma in clinical stages 1--4 were observed in this study. Samples were obtained sequentially from 153 of these patients at 4-week intervals over a period of up to 2 years and correlated with clinical evidence of disease activity. Tyrosinase and melanA/MART-1 amplicons were analysed by agarose gel electrophoresis and Southern blot hybridization subsequent to a single round of amplification.

RESULTS

We demonstrated a statistically significant increase in tyrosinase RT--PCR positivity with advancing stage of melanoma progression. The percentage tyrosinase positivity in 910 samples tested was: stage 1, 135 samples, 34% positive; stage 2, 196 samples, 51% positive; stage 3, 423 samples, 50% positive; and stage 4, 156 samples, 65% positive. The positivity rate for individual patients tested sequentially was higher if only one positive test was required to label a patient positive, at 42%, 65%, 82% and 81% for patients in stages 1--4, respectively. However, we did not find a clear pattern of conversion from negativity to positivity in patients who progressed during the study from stage 2 to stage 3 or stage 3 to stage 4, and found no clear evidence of increased positivity rates in the 6-week period following melanoma-related surgery in patients with stage 3 and 4 disease. The positivity rate for melanA/MART-1 was lower for both patients and samples, and no melanA/MART-1-positive sample was negative for tyrosinase.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that the presence of circulating tyrosinase-positive cells as detected by this method appears to be a discontinuous rather than a continuous phenomenon, even in patients with stage 4 disease. For this reason the assay cannot be recommended as a method of sequentially monitoring individual patients in a clinical setting.

Quantification of Melanoma Cell-specific MART-1 mRNA in Peripheral Blood by a Calibrated Competitive Reverse Transcription-PCR

Background: Reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) amplification of melanoma cell-specific mRNA can detect melanoma cells in the peripheral blood of patients with malignant melanoma. We present a method to quantify mRNA coding for the melanoma-specific melanoma antigen recognized by T cells #1 (MART-1) in RNA isolated from peripheral blood.

Methods: To establish a calibration curve, we measured the concentration of MART-1 mRNA in SK-MEL-28 melanoma cells grown in vitro by competitive RT-PCR. Serial dilutions of these cells were used as calibrators in the assay. The assay was conducted by adding a fixed amount of a RNA internal standard to RNA isolated from either peripheral blood or the calibrators before RT-PCR amplification with MART-1 primers in a nested PCR design. The amount of MART-1 mRNA in blood samples was calculated from the calibration curve.

Results: Addition of melanoma cells grown in vitro to blood from healthy donors demonstrated that the method can detect a single SK-MEL-28 melanoma cell in 1 mL of blood (1.5 × 10−21 mol MART-1 mRNA/mL). MART-1 mRNA was observed in 4 of 12 blood samples from patients with malignant melanoma, at concentrations of 3–18 × 10−21 mol MART-1 mRNA/mL of blood. No MART-1 mRNA was detected in blood samples from 25 controls without malignant melanoma. Intra- and interassay CVs were 15% (n = 12; mean = 44 × 10−21 mol MART-1 mRNA/mL) and 33% (15 samples analyzed in two different analytical runs; mean = 30 × 10−21 mol MART-1 mRNA/mL), respectively.

Conclusions: Our method is the first competitive RT-PCR assay for quantification of melanoma cells in blood samples that compensates for the variation of both the reverse transcription and PCR reactions. The method allows the inclusion of control samples for continuous quality assessment.

Serological markers for melanoma

We present a review of current literature concerning the significance of serological markers in melanoma patients. Results for cytokines, cytokine receptors, cell adhesion molecules, S100 protein, melanoma inhibitory activity, tissue-specific reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction, neurone-specific enolase, lipid-bound sialic acid and melanin metabolites such as 5-S-cysteinyldopa and 6-hydroxy-5-methoxyindole-2-carboxylic acid are discussed. For most of these substances, serum levels are more pronounced in the more advanced stages of disease. Therefore, these markers seem to have no place in the early detection of melanoma. On the other hand, sensitivity in the advanced stages of disease seems to be < 100%, compromising their use as a new staging procedure. Some markers show promising results as a possible prognostic factor in the early detection of disease progression or in the prediction of therapy outcome. If confirmed by further studies, this could direct future therapeutic strategies and could help to select patients who would benefit most from more aggressive (adjuvant) therapies. In addition, the study of some of these substances could add to the knowledge of tumour biology and immunology.

Limitations of the nested reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction on tyrosinase for the detection of malignant melanoma micrometastases in lymph nodes

The specificity and sensitivity of the nested reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) on tyrosinase was studied, for the detection of micrometastases of malignant melanoma. The specificity was assessed in the blood of six healthy donors, four patients with non-melanoma cancers of which one patient was treated with granulocyte-colony stimulating factor. Lymph nodes of nine patients without malignant melanoma were tested and four cell lines of various other tumours. Six of the nine non-melanoma lymph nodes were positive in this assay. The sensitivity was tested in a spike experiment in vitro, using a melanoma cell line. The detection limit was ten melanoma cells per 10(7) peripheral blood lymphocytes.

gp100 mRNA is more sensitive than tyrosinase mRNA for RT-PCR amplification to detect circulating melanoma cells in peripheral blood of melanoma patients

Two different melanocyte-specific mRNAs are studied as markers for circulating melanoma cells in vitro using the human melanoma cell line G361 and in vivo using blood samples from Japanese melanoma patients at different clinical stages. These mRNAs encode tyrosinase, the most essential enzyme for melanin synthesis, and gp100, a melanosomal matrix glycoprotein recognized by monoclonal antibody HMB-45. We used reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) to detect tyrosinase mRNA and gp100 mRNA in peripheral blood. Since melanocytes would not normally be present in peripheral blood, the detection of those transcripts should indicate the presence of circulating melanoma cells. RT-PCR detection of these two mRNAs was highly sensitive and specific. Our in vitro study showed that as few as 10 melanoma cells in 0.125 ml normal blood could be detected. In in vivo study, 130 blood samples from 55 melanoma patients gave positive and variably sensitive results, whereas no samples from healthy controls or patients with other cancers gave positive results. Tyrosinase mRNA was not detected in any of the melanoma patients. gp100 mRNA was detected in 12 of 55 melanoma patients, in none of five stage I patients (0%), in four of 26 stage II patients (15.4%), in one of six stage III patients (16. 7%) and in seven of 18 stage IV patients (38.9%). Thus gp100 mRNA is a more sensitive marker for detecting circulating melanoma cells compared with tyrosinase mRNA.