Regulation and transfer of a murine model of thyrotropin receptor antibody mediated Graves' disease

In Graves' disease, thyroid autoantibodies and ultrasound features correlate with distinctive histological features

PURPOSE

Laboratory, imaging, and pathological features of Graves' disease (GD), although well characterized, have been barely correlated each other. Aim of the study was to link laboratory and ultrasound characteristics of GD with its pathological features.

METHODS

We correlated laboratory and ultrasound data at the time of diagnosis in 28 consecutive GD patients who underwent thyroidectomy with their pathological features, i.e., lymphocytic infiltration and follicular hyperplasia (both classified as mild or severe).

RESULTS

Thyroid volume correlated positively with the levels of FT4 (P = 0.002, r² = 0.42), FT3 (P = 0.011, r² = 0.22), autoantibodies to thyroglobulin (TgAbs) (P = 0.016, r² = 0.32), autoantibodies to thyroid peroxidase (TPOAbs) (P = 0.011, r² = 0.34) and the extent of lymphocytic infiltration (P = 0.006 comparing mild to severe lymphocytic infiltration) but not with the levels of autoantibodies to the thyrotropin receptor (TRAbs) and to follicular hyperplasia. Compared to subjects with mild lymphocytic infiltration, those with severe lymphocytic infiltration showed higher levels of TgAbs (316 vs 0.0 IU/mL, P < 0.0001) and TPOAbs (295 IU/mL vs 14 IU/mL, P < 0.0001) and similar levels of TRAbs (7.5 vs 13 IU/mL, P = 0.68). Compared to patients with mild, those with severe follicular hyperplasia had similar levels of TgAbs (76 vs 30 IU/mL, P = 0.31) and TPOAbs (251 IU/mL vs 45 IU/mL, P = 0.26) but higher levels of TRAbs (39 vs 7.2 IU/mL, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

In GD, TgAbs and TPOAbs levels correlate with the extent of lymphocytic infiltration, TRAbs levels with the degree of follicular hyperplasia. Thyroid volume, the main factor influencing the severity of hyperthyroidism, is related to lymphocytic infiltration and not to follicular hyperplasia.

Insight Into Mouse Models of Hyperthyroidism

Hyperthyroidism is characterized by an increase in the synthesis and secretion of thyroid hormones in the thyroid gland, and the most common cause of overproduction of thyroid hormones is Graves' disease (GD). Long-term disease models of hyperthyroidism have been established. In general, methods to induce GD include transfection of fibroblasts, injecting plasmids or adenovirus containing thyroid stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR) or TSHR subunit, and exogenous artificial thyroid hormone supplementation. Fortunately, in mouse studies, novel treatments for GD and Graves' orbitopathy (GO) were discovered. It has been reported that prophylactic administration of TSHR A subunit protein in genetically susceptible individuals could induce immune tolerance and provide protection for the future development of GD. Biologically active monoclonal antibody against intracellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1 mAb) and siRNA targeting TSHR can also be used to treat GD. Moreover, new potential therapeutic targets have been identified in GO mouse models, and these targets could present novel therapeutic approaches. Besides, human placental mesenchymal stem cells (hPMSCs) into the orbit, fucoxanthin and icariin may be new alternative therapies that could be used in addition to the existing drugs, although further research is needed.

Spotlight on vitamin D receptor, lipid metabolism and mitochondria: Some preliminary emerging issues

Transcriptional control and modulation of calcium fluxes underpin the differentiating properties of vitamin D (1,25(OH)₂D₃). In the latest years however few studies have pointed out the relevance of the mitochondrial effects of the hormone. It is now time to focus on the metabolic results of vitamin D receptor (VDR) action in mitochondria, which can explain the pleiotropic effects of 1,25(OH)₂D₃ and may elucidate few contrasting aspects of its activity. The perturbation of lipid metabolism described in VDR knockout mice and vitamin D deficient animals can be revisited based on the newly identified mechanism of action of 1,25(OH)₂D₃ in mitochondria. From the same point of view, the controversial role of 1,25(OH)₂D₃ in adipogenesis can be better interpreted.

Critical Differences between Induced and Spontaneous Mouse Models of Graves' Disease with Implications for Antigen-Specific Immunotherapy in Humans

Graves' hyperthyroidism, a common autoimmune disease caused by pathogenic autoantibodies to the thyrotropin (TSH) receptor (TSHR), can be treated but not cured. This single autoantigenic target makes Graves' disease a prime candidate for Ag-specific immunotherapy. Previously, in an induced mouse model, injecting TSHR A-subunit protein attenuated hyperthyroidism by diverting pathogenic TSHR Abs to a nonfunctional variety. In this study, we explored the possibility of a similar diversion in a mouse model that spontaneously develops pathogenic TSHR autoantibodies, NOD.H2^h4 mice with the human (h) TSHR (hTSHR) A-subunit transgene expressed in the thyroid and (shown in this article) the thymus. We hypothesized that such diversion would occur after injection of "inactive" hTSHR A-subunit protein recognized only by nonpathogenic (not pathogenic) TSHR Abs. Surprisingly, rather than attenuating the pre-existing pathogenic TSHR level, in TSHR/NOD.H2^h4 mice inactive hTSHR Ag injected without adjuvant enhanced the levels of pathogenic TSH-binding inhibition and thyroid-stimulating Abs, as well as nonpathogenic Abs detected by ELISA. This effect was TSHR specific because spontaneously occurring autoantibodies to thyroglobulin and thyroid peroxidase were unaffected. As controls, nontransgenic NOD.H2^h4 mice similarly injected with inactive hTSHR A-subunit protein unexpectedly developed TSHR Abs, but only of the nonpathogenic variety detected by ELISA. Our observations highlight critical differences between induced and spontaneous mouse models of Graves' disease with implications for potential immunotherapy in humans. In hTSHR/NOD.H2^h4 mice with ongoing disease, injecting inactive hTSHR A-subunit protein fails to divert the autoantibody response to a nonpathogenic form. Indeed, such therapy is likely to enhance pathogenic Ab production and exacerbate Graves' disease in humans.

Excessive Cytosolic DNA Fragments as a Potential Trigger of Graves' Disease: An Encrypted Message Sent by Animal Models

Graves' hyperthyroidism is caused by autoantibodies directed against the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR) that mimic the action of TSH. The establishment of Graves' hyperthyroidism in experimental animals has proven to be an important approach to dissect the mechanisms of self-tolerance breakdown that lead to the production of thyroid-stimulating TSHR autoantibodies (TSAbs). "Shimojo's model" was the first successful Graves' animal model, wherein immunization with fibroblasts cells expressing TSHR and a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecule, but not either alone, induced TSAb production in AKR/N (H-2^k) mice. This model highlights the importance of coincident MHC class II expression on TSHR-expressing cells in the development of Graves' hyperthyroidism. These data are also in agreement with the observation that Graves' thyrocytes often aberrantly express MHC class II antigens via mechanisms that remain unclear. Our group demonstrated that cytosolic self-genomic DNA fragments derived from sterile injured cells can induce aberrant MHC class II expression and production of multiple inflammatory cytokines and chemokines in thyrocytes in vitro, suggesting that severe cell injury may initiate immune responses in a way that is relevant to thyroid autoimmunity mediated by cytosolic DNA signaling. Furthermore, more recent successful Graves' animal models were primarily established by immunizing mice with TSHR-expressing plasmids or adenovirus. In these models, double-stranded DNA vaccine contents presumably exert similar immune-activating effect in cells at inoculation sites and thus might pave the way toward successful Graves' animal models. This review focuses on evidence suggesting that cell injury-derived self-DNA fragments could act as Graves' disease triggers.

Modeling Graves' Orbitopathy in Experimental Graves' Disease

Graves' orbitopathy (GO), also known as thyroid eye disease is an inflammatory disease of the orbital tissue of the eye that arises as a consequence of autoimmune thyroid disease. The central feature of the disease is the production of antibodies to the thyrotropin hormone receptor (TSHR) that modulate the function of the receptor leading to autoimmune hyperthyroidism and GO. Over the years, all viable preclinical models of Graves' disease have been incomplete and singularly failed to progress in the treatment of orbital complications. A new mouse model of GO based upon immunogenic presentation of human TSHR A-subunit plasmid by close field electroporation is shown to lead to induction of prolonged functional antibodies to TSHR resulting in chronic disease with subsequent progression to GO. The stable preclinical GO model exhibited pathologies reminiscent of human disease characterized by orbital remodeling by inflammation and adipogenesis. Inflammatory lesions characterized by CD3+ T cells and macrophages were localized in the orbital muscle tissue. This was accompanied by extensive adipogenesis of orbital fat in some immune animals. Surprisingly, other signs of orbital involvement were reminiscent of eyelid inflammation involving chemosis, with dilated and congested orbital blood vessels. More recently, the model is replicated in the author's independent laboratories. The pre-clinical model will provide the basis to study the pathogenic and regulatory roles of immune T and B cells and their subpopulations to understand the initiation, pathophysiology, and progression of GO.

Autoimmune thyroid disorders

Purpose of Review. Studies have been published in the field of autoimmune thyroid diseases since January 2005. The review is organized into areas of etiology, autoimmune features, autoantibodies, mechanism of thyroid cell injury, B-cell responses, and T-cell responses. Also it reviews the diagnosis and the relationship between autoimmune thyroid disease, neoplasm, and kidney disorders. Recent Findings. Autoimmune thyroid diseases have been reported in people living in different parts of the world including North America, Europe, Baalkans, Asia, Middle East, South America, and Africa though the reported figures do not fully reflect the number of people infected per year. Cases are unrecognized due to inaccurate diagnosis and hence are treated as other diseases. However, the most recent studies have shown that the human autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITDs) affect up to 5% of the general population and are seen mostly in women between 30 and 50 years. Summary. Autoimmune thyroid disease is the result of a complex interaction between genetic and environmental factors. Overall, this review has expanded our understanding of the mechanism involved in pathogenesis of AITD and the relationship between autoimmune thyroid disease, neoplasm, and kidney disease. It has opened new lines of investigations that will ultimately result in a better clinical practice.

Animal Models of Graves' Hyperthyroidism

An animal model of Graves' disease (GD) will help us to clearly understand the role of thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR)-specific T cells and TSHR-Abs during the development of GD and to develop TSHR-specific immunotherapy. This review focuses on four different recent approaches towards the development of an animal model of GD. These approaches are: (1) Immunization of AKR/N mice with fibroblasts coexpressing syngeneic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II and TSHR. (2) Immunization of selected strains of mice with an expression vector containing TSHR cDNA. (3) Immunization of BALB/c mice with syngeneic M12 cells or xenogenic HEK-293 cells expressing full-length or extracellular domain of TSHR (ETSHR). (4) Injection of adenovirus-expressing TSHR into BALB/c mice.

New insights into antibody-mediated hyperthyroidism

The most common cause of hyperthyroidism is Graves' disease, which represents a typical example of an organ-specific autoimmune condition. The exact triggers for the disease remain unknown, but are likely to involve a complex interaction between multiple environmental factors in a genetically predisposed individual. The main feature of the condition is the presence of thyroid-stimulating antibodies, which activate the thyroid- stimulating hormone receptor, resulting in hyperthyroidism. These antibodies may also be involved in the extrathyroidal complications of the disease. The recent generation of thyroid-stimulating antibodies in animal models and the isolation of monoclonal thyroid-stimulating antibodies from a patient with Graves' disease should allow the detailed study of thyroid-stimulating antibodies-thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor interactions. This will help to shed more light on disease pathogenesis and may offer new treatment strategies in difficult cases, particularly in patients with extrathyroidal complications.

Insight into Graves' hyperthyroidism from animal models

Graves' hyperthyroidism can be induced in mice or hamsters by novel approaches, namely injecting cells expressing the TSH receptor (TSHR) or vaccination with TSHR-DNA in plasmid or adenoviral vectors. These models provide unique insight into several aspects of Graves' disease: 1) manipulating immunity toward Th1 or Th2 cytokines enhances or suppresses hyperthyroidism in different models, perhaps reflecting human disease heterogeneity; 2) the role of TSHR cleavage and A subunit shedding in immunity leading to thyroid-stimulating antibodies (TSAbs); and 3) epitope spreading away from TSAbs and toward TSH-blocking antibodies in association with increased TSHR antibody titers (as in rare hypothyroid patients). Major developments from the models include the isolation of high-affinity monoclonal TSAbs and analysis of antigen presentation, T cells, and immune tolerance to the TSHR. Studies of inbred mouse strains emphasize the contribution of non-MHC vs. MHC genes, as in humans, supporting the relevance of the models to human disease. Moreover, other findings suggest that the development of Graves' disease is affected by environmental factors, including infectious pathogens, regardless of modifications in the Th1/Th2 balance. Finally, developing immunospecific forms of therapy for Graves' disease will require painstaking dissection of immune recognition and responses to the TSHR.

Animal models of Graves' hyperthyroidism

Graves' disease is a common organ-specific autoimmune disease characterized by overstimulation of the thyroid gland with agonistic anti-thyrotropin (TSH) receptor autoantibodies, which leads to hyperthyroidism and diffuse hyperplasia of the thyroid gland. Several groups including us have recently established several animal models of Graves' hyperthyroidism using novel immunization approaches, such as in vivo expression of the TSH receptor by injecting syngeneic living cells co-expressing the TSH receptor, the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II antigen and a costimulatory molecule, or genetic immunization using plasmid or adenovirus vectors coding the TSH receptor. This breakthrough has made it possible for us to study the pathogenesis of Graves' disease in more detail and has provided important insights into our understanding of disease pathogenesis. The important new findings that have emerged include: (i) the shed A subunit being the major autoantigen for TSAb, (ii) the significant role played by dendritic cells (DCs) as professional antigen-presenting cells in initiating disease development, (iii) contribution of MHC and particularly non-MHC genetic backgrounds in disease susceptibility, and (iv) influence of some particular infectious pathogens on disease development. However, the data regarding Th1/Th2 balance of TSH receptor-specific immune response or the association of Graves' hyperthyroidism with intrathyroidal lymphocytic infiltration are rather inconsistent. Future studies with these models will hopefully lead to better understanding of disease pathogenesis and help develop novel strategies for treatment and ultimately prevention of Graves' disease in humans.

Susceptibility rather than resistance to hyperthyroidism is dominant in a thyrotropin receptor adenovirus-induced animal model of Graves' disease as revealed by BALB/c-C57BL/6 hybrid mice

We investigated why TSH receptor (TSHR) adenovirus immunization induces hyperthyroidism more commonly in BALB/c than in C57BL/6 mice. Recent modifications of the adenovirus model suggested that using adenovirus expressing the TSHR A subunit (A-subunit-Ad), rather than the full-length TSHR, and injecting fewer viral particles would increase the frequency of hyperthyroidism in C57BL/6 mice. This hypothesis was not fulfilled; 65% of BALB/c but only 5% of C57BL/6 mice developed hyperthyroidism. TSH binding inhibitory antibody titers were similar in each strain. Functional TSHR antibody measurements provided a better indication for this strain difference. Whereas thyroid-stimulating antibody activity was higher in C57BL/6 than BALB/c mice, TSH blocking antibody activity was more potent in hyperthyroid-resistant C57BL/6 mice. F(1) hybrids (BALB/c x C57BL/6) responded to A-subunit-Ad immunization with hyperthyroidism and TSHR antibody profiles similar to those of the hyperthyroid-susceptible parental BALB/c strain. In contrast, ELISA of TSHR antibodies revealed that the IgG subclass distribution in the F(1) mice resembled the disease-resistant C57BL/6 parental strain. Because the IgG subclass distribution is dependent on the T helper 1/T helper 2 cytokine balance, this paradigm can likely be excluded as an explanation for susceptibility to hyperthyroidism. In summary, our data for BALB/c, C57BL/6, and F(1) strains suggest that BALB/c mice carry a dominant gene(s) for susceptibility to induction of a thyroid-stimulating antibody/TSH blocking antibody balance that results in hyperthyroidism. Study of this genetic influence will provide useful information on potential candidate genes in human Graves' disease.

Induction of hyperthyroidism in mice by intradermal immunization with DNA encoding the thyrotropin receptor

Intramuscular injection with plasmid DNA encoding the human thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) has been known to elicit symptoms of Graves' disease (GD) in outbred but not inbred mice. In this study, we have examined, firstly, whether intradermal (i.d.) injection of TSHR DNA can induce hyperthyroidism in BALB/c mice and, secondly, whether coinjection of TSHR- and cytokine-producing plasmids can influence the outcome of disease. Animals were i.d. challenged at 0, 3 and 6 weeks with TSHR DNA and the immune response was assessed at the end of the 8th or 10th week. In two experiments, a total of 10 (67%) of 15 mice developed TSHR-specific antibodies as assessed by flow cytometry. Of these, 4 (27%) mice had elevated thyroxine (TT4) levels and goitrous thyroids with activated follicular epithelial cells but no evidence of lymphocytic infiltration. At 10 weeks, thyroid-stimulating antibodies (TSAb) were detected in two out of the four hyperthyroid animals. Interestingly, in mice that received a coinjection of TSHR- and IL-2- or IL-4-producing plasmids, there was no production of TSAbs and no evidence of hyperthyroidism. On the other hand, coinjection of DNA plasmids encoding TSHR and IL-12 did not significantly enhance GD development since two out of seven animals became thyrotoxic, but had no goitre. These results demonstrate that i.d. delivery of human TSHR DNA can break tolerance and elicit GD in inbred mice. The data do not support the notion that TSAb production is Th2-dependent in murine GD but they also suggest that codelivery of TSHR and Th1-promoting IL-12 genes may not be sufficient to enhance disease incidence and/or severity in this model.

Thyrotropin receptor autoantibodies (TSHRAbs): epitopes, origins and clinical significance

Epitopes for > 95% stimulating thyrotropin receptor autoantibodies (TSHRAbs) causally implicated in Graves' disease (Basedow's disease or primary hyperthyroidism) have been identified on on the N-terminal portion of the TSHR extracellular domain, residues 8-165. If the stimulating TSHRAb activity is solely dependent on this region, it is termed homogeneous; if its activity is only largely related to this region, it is termed heterogeneous. The presence of a heterogeneous stimulating TSHRAb in a patient is associated with rapid responses to propylthiouracil or methimazole and may be predictive of long term remission with these oral immunosuppressives. Epitopes for two different Graves' autoantibodies that inhibit TSH binding, TSH binding inhibition immunoglobulins or TBIIs, have also been identified on this region of the TSHR. They do not increase cAMP levels, although one may activate the inositol phosphate, Ca++, arachidonate release signal system. The epitope of blocking TSHRAbs with the ability to inhibit TSH binding (TBII activity), TSH activity, and stimulating TSHRAb activity, and that are causally implicated in the primary hypothyroidism of patients with idiopathic myxedema or some patients with Hashimoto's disease have, in contrast, been largely identified largely on the C-terminal portion of the TSHR extracellular domain, residues 270-395. They have been implicated as important in pregnancy where they attenuate the signs and symptoms of Graves' hyperthyroidism. The appearance of these blocking TSHRAbs during pregnancy in Graves' patients might cause overt or occult hypothyroidism, with resultant effects on fetal development and postnatal intelligence levels. The different TSHRAbs can exist in the same patient at any moment in time, potentially making disease expression a sum of their activities. Assays taking advantage of the epitope mapping findings enable us to detect individual TSHRAbs within a single patient and to better understand their clinical significance.

The contribution of immune regulatory and thyroid specific genes to the etiology of Graves' and Hashimoto's diseases

The autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD) are complex diseases which are caused by an interaction between susceptibility genes and environmental triggers. Genetic susceptibility in combination with external factors (e.g. dietary iodine) are believed to initiate the autoimmune response to thyroid antigens. Abundant epidemiological data, including family and twin studies, point to a strong genetic influence on the development of AITD. Various techniques have been employed to identify the genes contributing to the etiology of AITD, including candidate gene analysis and whole genome screening. These studies have enabled the identification of several loci (genetic regions) that are linked with AITD, and in some of these loci putative AITD susceptibility genes have been identified. Some of these genes/loci are unique to Graves' disease (GD) and Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT) and some are common to both diseases, indicating that there is a shared genetic susceptibility to GD and HT. The putative GD and HT susceptibility genes include both immune modifying genes (e.g. HLA, CTLA-4) and thyroid specific genes (e.g. TSHR, Tg). Most likely these loci interact and their interactions may influence disease phenotype and severity.

Graves' hyperthyroidism and thyroiditis in HLA-DRB1*0301 (DR3) transgenic mice after immunization with thyrotropin receptor DNA

Familial and twin studies in Caucasians have established that the MHC class II allele HLA-DRB1*0301 (DR3) is a strong susceptibility gene in Graves' hyperthyroid disease (GD). To determine if a DR3 transgene could help establish an animal model for GD, we expressed DR3 molecules in class II-knockout NOD mice (H2Ag7-). DR3+g7- mice were given cardiotoxin prior to immunization on weeks 0, 3 and 6 with plasmid DNA encoding human thyrotropin receptor (TSHR). Two groups of mice were also coimmunized with plasmid DNA for IL-4 or GM-CSF. Serial bleeds on weeks 8, 11 and 14 showed that approximately 20% of mice produced thyroid-stimulating antibodies (Abs), and approximately 25% had elevated T4 levels. In particular, a subset displayed both signs of hyperthyroidism, resulting in approximately 30% with some aspect of GD syndrome. Additional mice had thyroid-stimulating blocking Abs and/or TSH-binding inhibitory immunoglobulins, while most mice showed strong labelling of TSHR+ cells by flow cytometry. Interestingly, lymphocytic infiltration with thyroid damage and Abs to mouse thyroglobulin were also noted. Vector controls were uniformly negative. Thus, DR3 transgenic mice can serve as a model for GD, similar to our earlier reports that this allele is permissive for the Hashimoto's thyroiditis model induced with human thyroglobulin.

Low-dose immunization with adenovirus expressing the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor A-subunit deviates the antibody response toward that of autoantibodies in human Graves' disease

Immunization with adenovirus expressing the TSH receptor (TSHR) induces hyperthyroidism in 25-50% of mice. Even more effective is immunization with a TSHR A-subunit adenovirus (65-84% hyperthyroidism). Nevertheless, TSHR antibody characteristics in these mice do not mimic accurately those of autoantibodies in typical Graves' patients, with a marked TSH-blocking antibody response. We hypothesized that this suboptimal antibody response was consequent to the standard dose of TSHR-adenovirus providing too great an immune stimulus. To test this hypothesis, we compared BALB/c mice immunized with the usual number (10(11)) and with far fewer viral particles (10(9) and 10(7)). Regardless of viral dose, hyperthyroidism developed in a similar proportion (68-80%) of mice. We then examined the qualitative nature of TSHR antibodies in each group. Sera from all mice had TSH binding-inhibitory (TBI) activity after the second immunization, with TBI values in proportion to the viral dose. After the third injection, all groups had near-maximal TBI values. Remarkably, in confirmation of our hypothesis, immunization with progressively lower viral doses generated TSHR antibodies approaching the characteristics of autoantibodies in human Graves' disease as follows: 1) lower TSHR antibody titers on ELISA and 2) lower TSH-blocking antibody activity without decrease in thyroid-stimulating antibody activity. In summary, low-dose immunization with adenovirus expressing the free TSHR A-subunit provides an induced animal model with a high prevalence of hyperthyroidism as well as TSHR antibodies more closely resembling autoantibodies in Graves' disease.

Current perspective on the pathogenesis of Graves' disease and ophthalmopathy

Graves' disease (GD) is a very common autoimmune disorder of the thyroid in which stimulatory antibodies bind to the thyrotropin receptor and activate glandular function, resulting in hyperthyroidism. In addition, some patients with GD develop localized manifestations including ophthalmopathy (GO) and dermopathy. Since the cloning of the receptor cDNA, significant progress has been made in understanding the structure-function relationship of the receptor, which has been discussed in a number of earlier reviews. In this paper, we have focused our discussion on studies related to the molecular mechanisms of the disease pathogenesis and the development of animal models for GD. It has become apparent that multiple factors contribute to the etiology of GD, including host genetic as well as environmental factors. Studies in experimental animals indicate that GD is a slowly progressing disease that involves activation and recruitment of thyrotropin receptor-specific T and B cells. This activation eventually results in the production of stimulatory antibodies that can cause hyperthyroidism. Similarly, significant new insights have been gained in our understanding of GO that occurs in a subset of patients with GD. As in GD, both environmental and genetic factors play important roles in the development of GO. Although a number of putative ocular autoantigens have been identified, their role in the pathogenesis of GO awaits confirmation. Extensive analyses of orbital tissues obtained from patients with GO have provided a clearer understanding of the roles of T and B cells, cytokines and chemokines, and various ocular tissues including ocular muscles and fibroblasts. Equally impressive is the progress made in understanding why connective tissues of the orbit and the skin in GO are singled out for activation and undergo extensive remodeling. Results to date indicate that fibroblasts can act as sentinel cells and initiate lymphocyte recruitment and tissue remodeling. Moreover, these fibroblasts can be readily activated by Ig in the sera of patients with GD, suggesting a central role for them in the pathogenesis. Collectively, recent studies have led to a better understanding of the pathogenesis of GD and GO and have opened up potential new avenues for developing novel treatments for GD and GO.

Searching for the autoimmune thyroid disease susceptibility genes: from gene mapping to gene function

The autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD) are complex diseases that are caused by an interaction between susceptibility genes and environmental triggers. Genetic susceptibility, in combination with external factors (e.g., dietary iodine), is believed to initiate the autoimmune response to thyroid antigens. Abundant epidemiological data, including family and twin studies, point to a strong genetic influence on the development of AITD. Various techniques have been used to identify the genes contributing to the etiology of AITD, including candidate gene analysis and whole genome screening. These studies have enabled the identification of several loci (genetic regions) that are linked with AITD, and in some of these loci putative AITD susceptibility genes have been identified. Some of these genes/loci are unique to Graves' disease (GD) and Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), and some are common to both diseases, indicating that there is a shared genetic susceptibility to GD and HT. The putative GD and HT susceptibility genes include both immune modifying genes (e.g., human leukocyte antigen, cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen-4) and thyroid-specific genes (e.g., TSH receptor, thyroglobulin). Most likely these loci interact, and their interactions may influence disease phenotype and severity. It is hoped that in the near future additional AITD susceptibility genes will be identified and the mechanisms by which they induce AITD will be unraveled.

The thyrotropin receptor autoantigen in Graves disease is the culprit as well as the victim

Graves disease, a common organ-specific autoimmune disease affecting humans, differs from all other autoimmune diseases in being associated with target organ hyperfunction rather than organ damage. Clinical thyrotoxicosis is directly caused by autoantibodies that activate the thyrotropin receptor (TSHR). The etiology of Graves disease is multifactorial, with nongenetic factors playing an important role. Of the latter, there is the intriguing possibility that the molecular structure of the target antigen contributes to the development of thyroid-stimulatory autoantibodies (TSAb's). Among the glycoprotein hormone receptors, only the TSHR undergoes intramolecular cleavage into disulfide-linked subunits with consequent shedding of some of the extracellular, autoantibody-binding A subunits. Functional autoantibodies do not arise to the noncleaving glycoprotein hormone receptors. Recently, TSAb's were found to preferentially recognize shed, rather than attached, A subunits. Here we use a new adenovirus-mediated animal model of Graves disease to show that goiter and hyperthyroidism occur to a much greater extent when the adenovirus expresses the free A subunit as opposed to a genetically modified TSHR that cleaves minimally into subunits. These data show that shed A subunits induce or amplify the immune response leading to hyperthyroidism and provide new insight into the etiology of Graves disease.

Insight into antibody responses induced by plasmid or adenoviral vectors encoding thyroid peroxidase, a major thyroid autoantigen

Plasmid and adenoviral vectors have been used to generate antibodies in mice that resemble human autoantibodies to the thyrotrophin receptor. No such studies, however, have been performed for thyroid peroxidase (TPO), the major autoantigen in human thyroiditis. We constructed plasmid and adenovirus vectors for in vivo expression of TPO. BALB/c mice were immunized directly by intramuscular injection of TPO-plasmid or TPO-adenovirus, as well as by subcutaneous injection of dendritic cells (DC) infected previously with TPO-adenovirus. Intramuscular TPO-adenovirus induced the highest, and TPO-plasmid the lowest, TPO antibody titres. Mice injected with TPO-transfected DC developed intermediate levels. Antibodies generated by all three approaches had similar affinities (Kd approximately 10(-9)M) and recognized TPO expressed on the cell-surface. Their epitopes were analysed in competition assays using monoclonal human autoantibodies that define the TPO immunodominant region (IDR) recognized by patients with thyroid autoimmune disease. Surprisingly, high titre antibodies generated using adenovirus interacted with diverse TPO epitopes largely outside the IDR, whereas low titre antibodies induced by DNA-plasmid recognized restricted epitopes in the IDR. This inverse relationship between antibody titre and restriction to the IDR is likely to be due to epitope spreading following strong antigenic stimulation provided by the adenovirus vector. However, TPO antibody epitope spreading does not occur in Hashimoto's thyroiditis, despite high autoantibody levels. Consequently, these data support the concept that in human thyroid autoimmunity, factors besides titre must play a role in shaping an autoantibody epitopic profile.

Induction of thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor autoimmunity in hamsters

Female Chinese hamsters (n = 10) were immunized with Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells that expressed the human TSH receptor (TSHR) to generate a model of Graves' disease. TSHR-autoantibodies (TSHR-Ab) were determined by CHO-TSHR. Two hamsters with stimulating TSHR-Ab showed thyrocyte hypertrophy associated with a focal lymphocytic infiltration. CHO-TSHR were then stimulated with interferon gamma to enhance major histocompatibility complex class II expression. However, after immunization no stimulating TSHR-Ab were detected, but blocking TSHR-Ab were found in three of five animals. The thyroid glands from these hamsters showed marked thinning of thyroid epithelial cells, indicative of early thyroid atrophy consistent with a TSHR blocking antibody, but no lymphocytic infiltration. Lastly, female Armenian hamsters were immunized with an adenovirus construct incorporating wild-type TSHR. High titers of TSHR-Ab were induced effectively, but the thyroid hypertrophy observed was not associated with a lymphocyte infiltration. In summary, we demonstrated that the hamster could serve as a model of TSHR autoimmunity and that an adenoviral vector produced higher levels of TSHR-Ab than more conventional immunization with cells. The data also indicated that the intrathyroidal cellular immunity in this model was not related to TSHR-Ab formation and was an independent reflection of the T-cell immune response to TSHR antigen.

Dendritic cells infected with adenovirus expressing the thyrotrophin receptor induce Graves' hyperthyroidism in BALB/c mice

Dendritic cells (DCs) are the most potent antigen-presenting cells and a prerequisite for the initiation of primary immune response. This study was performed to investigate the contribution of DCs to the initiation of Graves' hyperthyroidism, an organ-specific autoimmune disease in which the thyrotrophin receptor (TSHR) is the major autoantigen. DCs were prepared from bone marrow precursor cells of BALB/c mice by culturing with granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor and interleukin-4. Subcutaneous injections of DCs infected with recombinant adenovirus expressing the TSHR (but not beta-galactosidase) in syngeneic female mice induced Graves'-like hyperthyroidism (8 and 35% of mice after two and three injections, respectively) characterized by stimulating TSHR antibodies, elevated serum thyroxine levels and diffuse hyperplasitc goiter. TSHR antibodies determined by ELISA were of both IgG1 (Th2-type) and IgG2a (Th1-type) subclasses, and splenocytes from immunized mice secreted interferon-gamma (a Th1 cytokine), not interleukin-4 (a Th2 cytokine), in response to TSHR antigen. Surprisingly, IFN-gamma secretion, and induction of antibodies and disease were almost completely suppressed by co-administration of alum/pertussis toxin, a Th2-dominant adjuvant, whereas polyriboinosinic polyribocytidylic acid, a Th1-inducer, enhanced splenocyte secretion of IFN-gamma without changing disease incidence. These observations demonstrate that DCs efficiently present the TSHR to naive T cells to induce TSHR antibodies and Graves'-like hyperthyroidism in mice. In addition, our results challenge the previous concept of Th2 dominance in Graves' hyperthyroidism and provide support for the role of Th1 immune response in disease pathogenesis.

Contrasting activities of thyrotropin receptor antibodies in experimental models of Graves' disease induced by injection of transfected fibroblasts or deoxyribonucleic acid vaccination

The development of experimental models of autoimmune hyperthyroid Graves' disease has proved a difficult challenge, but recently two novel methods have led to their successful development in mice. We describe our studies on replicating the adjuvant modified, human TSH receptor (TSHR) and major histocompatibility complex class II transfected fibroblast injection system, and the plasmid DNA vaccination method as models resembling the human disorder. The fibroblast injection model in female AKR/N (H-2k) mice led to 70% of the animals developing thyroid-stimulating antibodies and their thyroid glands showed large goiters with histological features of thyroid cell activation characteristic of Graves' glands. Consistent with the clinical homolog, there was no inflammatory cell infiltrate of the thyroid gland. Detailed studies on the anti-TSHR antibodies such as thyroid-stimulating blocking antibody, antibodies to the native TSHR by flow cytometry, and TSH-binding inhibiting Ig showed that they were heterogeneous and did not correlate with disease activity, thus resembling those present in patients with Graves' disease. In contrast, the plasmid DNA vaccination model in female BALB/c (H-2d) mice led to the generation of low levels of anti-TSHR antibodies by flow cytometry, which were undetectable for thyroid-stimulating antibodies, TSH-stimulating blocking antibodies, and TSH-binding inhibiting Ig activity. Moreover, this model too was not accompanied by lymphocytic cell infiltration. The data demonstrate the high incidence of hyperthyroid disease induced in the adjuvant modified, transfected fibroblast model in AKR/N mice to allow pathological mechanisms of disease to be studied.

Autoimmune thyroid disease: new models of cell death in autoimmunity

Autoimmunity to thyroid antigens leads to two distinct pathogenic processes with opposing clinical outcomes: hypothyroidism in Hashimoto's thyroiditis and hyperthyroidism in Graves' disease. The high frequency of these diseases and easy accessibility of the thyroid gland has allowed the identification of key pathogenic mechanisms in organ-specific autoimmune diseases. In early investigations, antibody- and T-cell-mediated death mechanisms were proposed as being responsible for autoimmune thyrocyte depletion. Later, studies on apoptosis have provided new insights into autoimmune target destruction, indicating the involvement of death receptors and cytokine-regulated apoptotic pathways in the pathogenesis of thyroid autoimmunity.

Oligomerization of the human thyrotropin receptor: fluorescent protein-tagged hTSHR reveals post-translational complexes

To examine thyrotropin (TSH) receptor homophilic interactions we fused the human TSH receptor (hTSHR) carboxyl terminus to green fluorescent protein (GFP) and the corresponding chimeric cDNA was expressed in Chinese hamster ovary cells. Fluorescent TSH receptors on the plasma membrane were functional as assessed by TSH-induced cAMP synthesis. The binding of TSH, as well as TSHR autoantibodies, induced time- and dose-dependent receptor capping. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer between receptors differentially tagged with GFP variants (RFP and YFP) provided evidence for the close proximity of individual receptor molecules. This was consistent with previous studies demonstrating the presence of TSHR dimers and oligomers in thyroid tissue. Co-immunoprecipitation of GFP-tagged and Myc-tagged receptor complexes was performed using doubly transfected cells with Myc antibody. Western blotting of the immunoprecipitated complex revealed the absence of noncleaved TSH holoreceptors. This further suggested that cleavage of the holoreceptor into its two-subunit structure, comprising disulfide-linked TSHR-alpha and TSHR-beta subunits, was required for the formation of TSHR dimers and higher order complexes.

Graves' disease: a host defense mechanism gone awry

In this report we summarize evidence to support a model for the development of Graves' disease. The model suggests that Graves' disease is initiated by an insult to the thyrocyte in an individual with a normal immune system. The insult, infectious or otherwise, causes double strand DNA or RNA to enter the cytoplasm of the cell. This causes abnormal expression of major histocompatibility (MHC) class I as a dominant feature, but also aberrant expression of MHC class II, as well as changes in genes or gene products needed for the thyrocyte to become an antigen presenting cell (APC). These include increased expression of proteasome processing proteins (LMP2), transporters of antigen peptides (TAP), invariant chain (Ii), HLA-DM, and the co-stimulatory molecule, B7, as well as STAT and NF-kappaB activation. A critical factor in these changes is the loss of normal negative regulation of MHC class I, class II, and thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) gene expression, which is necessary to maintain self-tolerance during the normal changes in gene expression involved in hormonally-increased growth and function of the cell. Self-tolerance to the TSHR is maintained in normals because there is a population of CD8- cells which normally suppresses a population of CD4+ cells that can interact with the TSHR if thyrocytes become APCs. This is a host self-defense mechanism that we hypothesize leads to autoimmune disease in persons, for example, with a specific viral infection, a genetic predisposition, or even, possibly, a TSHR polymorphism. The model is suggested to be important to explain the development of other autoimmune diseases including systemic lupus or diabetes.

A novel mouse model of Graves' disease: implications for a role of aberrant MHC class II expression in its pathogenesis

Mice immunized with fibroblasts expressing an MHC class II molecule and human thyrotropin receptor (TSHR), but not either alone, develop major features characteristic of Graves' disease (GD), such as thyroid-stimulating autoantibodies directed against TSHR, increased serum thyroid hormone levels, and enlarged thyroid glands. The results indicate the need for the simultaneous expression of a class II molecule and the TSHR on the surface of the fibroblasts to develop stimulating anti-TSHR antibodies and full-blown GD in our model. A T cell line established from a mouse with hyperthyroidism proliferates in response to fibroblasts expressing a class II molecule and TSHR, but not to the fibroblasts expressing only TSHR, indicating that the class II molecules on the fibroblasts present TSHR-derived peptide(s) to T cells. These results strongly suggest that the acquisition of antigen-presenting ability by thyrocytes can lead to the induction or progression of GD. We identified a T cell epitope of TSHR by the proliferative response of spleen cells from mice immunized with fibroblasts expressing a class II molecule and TSHR to 80 overlapping peptides spanning the extracellular domain of human TSHR. The identification of a major T cell epitope provides an important clue to a novel therapy of GD.

Cytokines, IgG subclasses and costimulation in a mouse model of thyroid autoimmunity induced by injection of fibroblasts co-expressing MHC class II and thyroid autoantigens

AKR/N mice injected with fibroblasts expressing MHC class II (RT4.15HP cells) and the TSH receptor (TSHR) develop antibodies similar to those in Graves' disease. We were unable to analyse the subclass of these antibodies because of unexpectedly high non-specific binding by ELISA or flow cytometry. The non-specific binding reflected generalized immune activation which occurred even when the fibroblasts did not express the TSHR. However, the IgG subclasses were determined for thyroid peroxidase (TPO) antibodies induced using TPO-expressing RT4.14HP cells and found to be IgG2a > IgG1. This Thl pattern is consistent with spontaneous secretion of interferon-gamma (but not IL-4 or IL-10) by splenocytes from injected mice. The Th1 bias was related to fibroblast injection because conventional immunization of the same mouse strain with purified TPO and adjuvant induced a Th2 response (IgG1 >> IgG2a). Further, untransfected fibroblasts themselves induced powerful, non-specific proliferative responses when used as antigen-presenting cells (APC) in vitro. Flow cytometry revealed that the RT4.15HP fibroblasts (and TSHR- and TPO-transfected derivatives) expressed B7-1. Unexpected constitutive expression of this key molecule may bypass the requirement for up-regulation of other costimulatory molecules involved in T cell stimulation. Our data support the concept that RT4.15HP fibroblasts present the TSHR (or TPO), at least for initiating the immune response. However, the accompanying generalized immune stimulation creates difficulties for analysis of TSHR-specific T and B lymphocytes. On the other hand, extension of the model to TPO, an easier antigen to study, will facilitate analysis of murine T cell responses likely to resemble those in human thyroid autoimmunity.

Genetic immunization of outbred mice with thyrotropin receptor cDNA provides a model of Graves' disease

We performed genetic immunization of outbred NMRI mice, using a cDNA encoding the human thyrotropin receptor (TSHr). All mice produced antibodies capable of recognizing the recombinant receptor expressed at the surface of stably transfected Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells, and sera from most of the immunized mice blocked TSH-dependent stimulation of cAMP accumulation in cells expressing the TSHr. Five out of 29 female mice showed sign of hyperthyroidism including elevated total T4 and suppressed TSH levels. The serum of these mice contained thyroid-stimulating activity, as measured in a classic assay using CHO cells expressing recombinant TSHr. In contrast, only 1 male out of 30 had moderately elevated serum total T4 with undetectable TSH values. The hyperthyroid animals had goiters with extensive lymphocytic infiltration, characteristic of a Th2 immune response. In addition, these animals displayed ocular signs reminiscent of Graves' ophthalmopathy, including edema, deposit of amorphous material, and cellular infiltration of their extraocular muscles. Our results demonstrate that genetic immunization of outbred NMRI mice with the human TSHr provides the most convincing murine model of Graves' disease available to date.

Adjuvant effects of cholera toxin b subunit on immune response to recombinant thyrotropin receptor in mice

We had previously shown that BALB/c mice immunized with the extracellular domain of human thyrotropin receptor (ETSHR) developed moderate hyperthyroxinemia. The antibody responses in these mice were predominantly of the IgG1 subclass. Since cholera toxin B subunit (CT-B) has direct effects on the thyroid, and is known to activate B lymphocytes and cause enhanced IgG1 production, we tested the ability of CT-B to modulate the antibody response to ETSHR. CT-B is unique in that it not only elicits a strong immune response to itself, but more importantly, when given with other antigens acts as a potent adjuvant. In the present study, BALB/c mice given ETSHR with CFA or CT-B via ip route showed higher titers of antibodies to ETSHR when compared to mice similarly immunized with ETSHR alone, or with IFA. Antibodies in ETSHR+CT-B immunized mice were mostly of the IgG1 subclass and reacted predominantly with ETSHR peptides 1 (aa 22-41), 21 (aa 322-341), and 23 (352-371). In contrast, animals immunized with ETSHR+CFA showed IgG1, IgG2a and IgG2b responses and reacted with peptides 1 and 21. Furthermore, mice immunized with ETSHR along with CT-B showed significantly higher levels of thyrotropin (TSH) binding inhibitory immunoglobulins (TBII) compared to those that did not receive CT-B. None of the mice immunized with a control antigen showed antibody response to ETSHR. These results suggested that CT-B could enhance and modulate immune response to ETSHR.

Evidence for antigen presentation to sensitized T cells by thyroid peroxidase (TPO)-specific B cells in mice injected with fibroblasts co-expressing TPO and MHC class II

Injection of AKR/N mice with fibroblasts co-expressing MHC class II and TPO in the absence of adjuvant induces IgG-class TPO antibodies that resemble spontaneously arising human thyroid autoantibodies. We have used this model to examine the effect of iodide on TPO antibody induction as well as to analyse the interaction between T and B cells. Despite its importance as a major environmental factor in thyroid autoimmunity, variable iodide intake had no detectable effects on TPO antibody levels, lymphocytic infiltration of the thyroid or thyroid hormone levels. In terms of T cell responsiveness, splenocytes from TPO fibroblast-injected mice, but not from control mice, proliferated in response to TPO. Intriguingly, B cell-depleted splenocytes (mainly T cells without reduction of macrophages) proliferated in response to TPO only when co-cultured with irradiated autologous splenocytes from TPO fibroblast-injected mice but not from control mice. These data suggest that TPO-specific B cells are involved in antigen presentation to sensitized T cells and are supported by the ability of spleen cells from TPO cell-injected (but not control) mice to secrete TPO antibodies spontaneously in culture. In conclusion, we provide the first evidence for the presence of thyroid autoantigen-specific B cells and their ability to present their autoantigen to sensitized T cells in mice induced to develop TPO antibodies resembling autoantibodies in humans.

Induction of Experimental Autoimmune Graves’ Disease in BALB/c Mice

We immunized BALB/c mice with M12 cells (H-2d) expressing either mouse (mM12 cells) or human thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) (hM12 cells). Immunized mice developed autoantibodies to native TSHR by day 90 and, by day 180, showed considerable stimulatory Ab activity as measured by their ability to enhance cAMP production (ranging from 6.52 to 20.83 pmol/ml in different treatment groups relative to 1.83 pmol/ml for controls) by TSHR-expressing Chinese hamster ovary cells. These mice developed severe hyperthyroidism with significant elevations in both tetraiodothyronine and triiodothyronine hormones. Tetraiodothyronine levels in different experimental groups ranged from a mean of 8.66–12.4 μg/dl, relative to 4.8 μg/dl in controls. Similarly, mean triiodothyronine values ranged from 156.18 to 195.13 ng/dl, relative to 34.99 ng/dl for controls. Next, we immunized BALB/c mice with a soluble extracellular domain of human TSHR (TBP), or TBP expressed on human embryonic kidney cells (293 cells) (293-TBP cells). These mice showed severe hyperthyroidism in a manner very similar to that described above for mice immunized with the mouse TSHR or human TSHR, and exhibited significant weight loss, with average weight for treatment groups ranging from 20.6 to 21.67 g, while controls weighed 24.2 g. Early after onset of the disease, histopathological examination of thyroids showed enlargement of colloids and thinning of epithelial cells without inflammation. However, later during disease, focal necrosis and lymphocytic infiltration were apparent. Our results showed that conformationally intact ectodomain of TSHR is sufficient for disease induction. Availability of a reproducible model in which 100% of the animals develop disease should facilitate studies aimed at understanding the molecular pathogenesis of Graves’ disease.