Myogenic specification in somites: induction by axial structures

An in vitro model of region-specific rib formation in chick axial skeleton: Intercellular interaction between somite and lateral plate cells

The axial skeleton is divided into different regions based on its morphological features. In particular, in birds and mammals, ribs are present only in the thoracic region. The axial skeleton is derived from a series of somites. In the thoracic region of the axial skeleton, descendants of somites coherently penetrate into the somatic mesoderm to form ribs. In regions other than the thoracic, descendants of somites do not penetrate the somatic lateral plate mesoderm. We performed live-cell time-lapse imaging to investigate the difference in the migration of a somite cell after contact with the somatic lateral plate mesoderm obtained from different regions of anterior-posterior axis in vitro on cytophilic narrow paths. We found that a thoracic somite cell continues to migrate after contact with the thoracic somatic lateral plate mesoderm, whereas it ceases migration after contact with the lumbar somatic lateral plate mesoderm. This suggests that cell-cell interaction works as an important guidance cue that regulates migration of somite cells. We surmise that the thoracic somatic lateral plate mesoderm exhibits region-specific competence to allow penetration of somite cells, whereas the lumbosacral somatic lateral plate mesoderm repels somite cells by contact inhibition of locomotion. The differences in the behavior of the somatic lateral plate mesoderm toward somite cells may confirm the distinction between different regions of the axial skeleton.

Genome-wide analysis of circular RNAs in prenatal and postnatal muscle of sheep

Circular RNAs (circRNAs), a type of non-coding RNA with circular structure, were generated by back splicing and widely expressed in animals and plants. Recent studies have shown that circRNAs extensively participate in cell proliferation, cell differentiation, cell autophagy and other biological processes. However, the role and expression of circRNAs in the development and growth of muscle have not been studied in sheep. In our study, we first used RNA-seq to study the circRNAs in prenatal and postnatal longissimus dorsi muscle of sheep. A total of 6113 circRNAs were detected from the RNA-seq data. Several circRNAs were identified using reverse transcription PCR, DNA sequencing and RNase R digestion experiments. The expression levels of several circRNAs in prenatal and postnatal muscle were confirmed by Real-Time RT-PCR. The gene ontology (GO) and KEGG enrichment analysis of the host gene of the circRNAs showed that these circRNAs were mainly involved in the growth and development of muscle related signaling pathways. These circRNAs might sponge microRNAs (miRNAs) in predicted circRNA-miRNA-mRNA networks. The circRNAs expression profiles in muscle provided an important reference for the study of circRNAs in sheep.

Sclerotome-derived Slit1 drives directional migration and differentiation of Robo2-expressing pioneer myoblasts

Pioneer myoblasts generate the first myotomal fibers and act as a scaffold to pattern further myotome development. From their origin in the medial epithelial somite, they dissociate and migrate towards the rostral edge of each somite, from which differentiation proceeds in both rostral-to-caudal and medial-to-lateral directions. The mechanisms underlying formation of this unique wave of pioneer myofibers remain unknown. We show that rostrocaudal or mediolateral somite inversions in avian embryos do not alter the original directions of pioneer myoblast migration and differentiation into fibers, demonstrating that regulation of pioneer patterning is somite-intrinsic. Furthermore, pioneer myoblasts express Robo2 downstream of MyoD and Myf5, whereas the dermomyotome and caudal sclerotome express Slit1. Loss of Robo2 or of sclerotome-derived Slit1 function perturbed both directional cell migration and fiber formation, and their effects were mediated through RhoA. Although myoblast specification was not affected, expression of the intermediate filament desmin was reduced. Hence, Slit1 and Robo2, via RhoA, act to pattern formation of the pioneer myotome through the regulation of cytoskeletal assembly.

Identification of differentially regulated secretome components during skeletal myogenesis

Myogenesis is a well-characterized program of cellular differentiation that is exquisitely sensitive to the extracellular milieu. Systematic characterization of the myogenic secretome (i.e. the ensemble of secreted proteins) is, therefore, warranted for the identification of novel secretome components that regulate both the pluripotency of these progenitor mesenchymal cells, and also their commitment and passage through the differentiation program. Previously, we have successfully identified 26 secreted proteins in the mouse skeletal muscle cell line C2C12 (1). In an effort to attain a more comprehensive picture of the regulation of myogenesis by its extracellular milieu, quantitative profiling employing stable isotope labeling by amino acids in cell culture was implemented in conjunction with two parallel high throughput online reverse phase liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry systems. In summary, 34 secreted proteins were quantified, 30 of which were shown to be differentially expressed during muscle development. Intriguingly, our analysis has revealed several novel up- and down-regulated secretome components that may have critical biological relevance for both the maintenance of pluripotency and the passage of cells through the differentiation program. In particular, the altered regulation of secretome components, including follistatin-like protein-1, osteoglycin, spondin-2, and cytokine-induced apoptosis inhibitor-1, along with constitutively expressed factors, such as fibulin-2, illustrate dynamic changes in the secretome that take place when differentiation to a specific lineage occurs.

Extrinsic versus intrinsic cues in avian paraxial mesoderm patterning and differentiation

Somitic and head mesoderm contribute to cartilage and bone and deliver the entire skeletal musculature. Studies on avian somite patterning and cell differentiation led to the view that these processes depend solely on cues from surrounding tissues. However, evidence is accumulating that some developmental decisions depend on information within the somitic tissue itself. Moreover, recent studies established that head and somitic mesoderm, though delivering the same tissue types, are set up to follow their own, distinct developmental programmes. With a particular focus on the chicken embryo, we review the current understanding of how extrinsic signalling, operating in a framework of intrinsically regulated constraints, controls paraxial mesoderm patterning and cell differentiation.

Chromatin modification and muscle differentiation

Skeletal muscle differentiation is a multistep process, which begins with the commitment of multi-potent mesodermal precursor cells to the muscle fate. These committed cells, the myoblasts, then differentiate and fuse into multinucleated myotubes. The final step of muscle differentiation is the maturation of differentiated myotubes into myofibres. Skeletal muscle development requires the coordinated expression of various transcription factors like the members of the myocyte enhancer binding-factor 2 family and the muscle regulatory factors. These transcription factors, in collaboration with chromatin-remodelling complexes, act in specific combinations and within complex transcriptional regulatory networks to achieve skeletal myogenesis. Additional factors involved in the epigenetic regulation of this process continue to be discovered. In this review, the authors discuss the recent discoveries in the epigenetic regulation of myogenesis. They also summarise the role of chromatin-modifying enzymes regulating muscle gene expression. These different factors are often involved in multiple steps of muscle differentiation and have redundant activities. Altogether, the recent findings have allowed a better understanding of myogenesis and have raised new hopes for the pharmacological development of new therapies aimed at muscle degeneration diseases, such as myotonic dystrophy or Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

Amniote somite derivatives

Somites are segments of paraxial mesoderm that give rise to a multitude of tissues in the vertebrate embryo. Many decades of intensive research have provided a wealth of data on the complex molecular interactions leading to the formation of various somitic derivatives. In this review, we focus on the crucial role of the somites in building the body wall and limbs of amniote embryos. We give an overview on the current knowledge on the specification and differentiation of somitic cell lineages leading to the development of the vertebral column, skeletal muscle, connective tissue, meninges, and vessel endothelium, and highlight the importance of the somites in establishing the metameric pattern of the vertebrate body.

Pax3 and Pax7 expression and regulation in the avian embryo

Satellite cells are essential for postnatal growth and repair of skeletal muscle. The paired-box transcription factors Pax3 and Pax7 are expressed in emerging muscle precursors. Recent studies have traced the origin of satellite cells to the embryonic dermomyotome, however, their developmental regulation throughout embryogenesis remains unclear. We show the overlying surface ectoderm and lateral plate are essential for Pax3 expression, and that the overlying surface ectoderm and neural tube are necessary for Pax7 expression within the dorsal somite. Furthermore we show that the notochord acts to down regulate the expression of both genes. Moreover, we identify diffusible factors within these tissues that act to maintain expression of Pax3 ( + ) and Pax7 (+) muscle precursors. We show that Wnt1, 3a, 4 and 6 proteins are able to up regulate and expand the expression of Pax3 and Pax7 within the dorsal somite. Finally, we show that Wnt6 can mimic the effect of the dorsal ectoderm to maintain Pax3 and Pax7 expression.

Muscle function and dysfunction in health and disease

Skeletal muscles of the trunk and limbs developmentally originate from the cells of the dermomyotomal compartment of the somite. A wealth of knowledge has been accumulated with regard to understanding the molecular regulation of embryonic skeletal myogenesis. Myogenic induction is controlled through a complex series of spatiotemporal dependent signaling cascades. Secreted signaling molecules from surrounding structures not only initiate the myogenic program, but also influence proliferation and differentiation decisions. The proper coordination of these molecular events is thus critical for the formation of physiologically functional skeletal muscles. Hereditary congenital skeletal muscle defects arise due to genetics lesions in myogenic specific components. Understanding the mechanistic routes of congenital skeletal muscle disease therefore requires a comprehensive knowledge of the developmental system. Ultimately, the application of this knowledge will improve the diagnostic and therapeutic methodologies for such diseases. The aim of this review is to overview our current understanding of skeletal muscle development and associated human congenital diseases.

Regulation of vertebrate myotome development by the p38 MAP kinase-MEF2 signaling pathway

Biochemical and cell culture studies have characterized the myocyte enhancer factor 2 (MEF2) transcriptional regulatory proteins as obligatory partners for the myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs) in the differentiation of myogenic cells in culture. However, the role of MEF2 activation in somitic myogenesis has not been fully characterized. Here, we report a critical interaction between the p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase (p38 MAPK) and MEF2 in the developing somite myotome. We document expression of MEF2A and p38 MAPK proteins in the somite of 9.5 dpc mouse embryos concurrent with Myf 5 protein expression. We also observed that abrogation of p38 MAPK signaling blocks MEF2 activation using a MEF2 transgenic 'sensor' mouse. Inhibition of p38 MAPK signaling concurrently inhibited myogenic differentiation in somite cultures and in embryos in vivo using transplacental injection of a p38 inhibitor (SB203580). Finally, we document that commitment to the myogenic lineage is not appreciably affected by p38 MAPK inhibition since the activation of an early marker of myogenic commitment (Myf 5) occurs normally when p38 MAPK signaling is inhibited. Thus, we present novel evidence indicating a crucial role for p38 MAPK signaling to the MEF2 transcriptional regulators during early mammalian somite development and myotome formation.

The nuclear orphan receptor COUP-TFII is required for limb and skeletal muscle development

The nuclear orphan receptor COUP-TFII is widely expressed in multiple tissues and organs throughout embryonic development, suggesting that COUP-TFII is involved in multiple aspects of embryogenesis. Because of the early embryonic lethality of COUP-TFII knockout mice, the role of COUP-TFII during limb development has not been determined. COUP-TFII is expressed in lateral plate mesoderm of the early embryo prior to limb bud formation. In addition, COUP-TFII is also expressed in the somites and skeletal muscle precursors of the limbs. Therefore, in order to study the potential role of COUP-TFII in limb and skeletal muscle development, we bypassed the early embryonic lethality of the COUP-TFII mutant by using two methods. First, embryonic chimera analysis has revealed an obligatory role for COUP-TFII in limb bud outgrowth since mutant cells are unable to contribute to the distally growing limb mesenchyme. Second, we used a conditional-knockout approach to ablate COUP-TFII specifically in the limbs. Loss of COUP-TFII in the limbs leads to hypoplastic skeletal muscle development, as well as shorter limbs. Taken together, our results demonstrate that COUP-TFII plays an early role in limb bud outgrowth but not limb bud initiation. Also, COUP-TFII is required for appropriate development of the skeletal musculature of developing limbs.

Calcineurin signaling in avian cardiovascular development

Experiments were initiated in avian embryos to determine the embryonic expression of calcineurin protein phosphatase isoforms as well as to identify developmental processes affected by inhibition of calcineurin signal transduction. Chicken calcineurin A alpha (CnAalpha) and calcineurin A beta (CnAbeta) are differentially expressed in the developing cardiovascular system, including primitive heart tube and valve primordia. Inhibition of calcineurin signaling by cyclosporin A (CsA) treatment in ovo resulted in distinct cardiovascular malformations, depending on the timing and localization of treatment. Initial formation of the heart tube was apparently normal in embryos treated with CsA from embryonic day (E)1 to E2, but hallmarks of heart failure were apparent with treatment from E2 to E3. Vascular defects were apparent in whole embryos treated on either day, but local administration of CsA directly to the forming vessels on E2 did not inhibit blood vessel formation. This observation supports an indirect effect of calcineurin inhibition on angiogenic remodeling as a result of compromised heart development. Together these studies are consistent with multiple roles for calcineurin signaling in the developing cardiovascular system.

A proliferative role for Wnt-3a in chick somites

The proper patterning of somites to give rise to sclerotome, dermomyotome, and myotome involves the coordination of many different cellular processes, including lineage specification, cell proliferation, cell death, and differentiation, by intercellular signals. One such family of secreted signaling proteins known to influence somite patterning is the Wnt family. Although the participation of Wnt-3a in the patterning of dorsal structures in the somite is well established, no clear consensus has emerged about the cellular processes that are governed by Wnt-3a in the somite. The recent demonstration that Wnt-3a has a proliferative role in the neural tube [Development 129 (2002) 2087] suggested that Wnt-3a might also act to regulate proliferation in somites. To test this hypothesis, we first analyzed the effects of Wnt-3a on segmental plate and somite explants (from Hamburger and Hamilton stage 10 chick embryos) grown in culture. These studies indicate that Wnt-3a is capable of maintaining and/or inducing expression of both Pax-3 and Pax-7, transcription factors that have been implicated in proliferation. To directly test for a role in proliferation, explants were immunostained with antibodies against phospho-histone H3. Explants treated with Wnt-3a show an increase in the percentage of cells expressing phospho-histone H3 as compared to controls. To test the proliferative effect of Wnt-3a in vivo, we ectopically expressed Wnt-3a in chick neural tubes via electroporation. Consistent with previous studies, ectopic expression of Wnt-3a in vivo results in a mediolateral expansion of the dermomyotome and myotome. We now show that proliferation of dorsal/dermomyotomal cells is significantly enhanced by ectopic Wnt-3a. Collectively, our explant and in vivo studies indicate that an increase in proliferation plays an important role in the expansion of the dermomyotome and myotome in Wnt-3a-treated embryos. Furthermore, our results demonstrate that small changes in proliferation can dramatically influence patterning and morphogenesis.

Precocious terminal differentiation of premigratory limb muscle precursor cells requires positive signalling

The timing of myogenic differentiation of hypaxial muscle precursor cells in the somite lags behind that of epaxial precursors. Two hypotheses have been proposed to explain this delay. One attributes the delay to the presence of negative-acting signals from the lateral plate mesoderm adjacent to the hypaxial muscle precursor cells located in the ventrolateral lip of the somitic dermomyotome (Pourquié et al. [1995] Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 92:3219-3223). The second attributes the delay to an absence of positive-acting inductive signals, similar to those from the axial structures that induce epaxial myotome development (Pownall et al. [1996] Development 122:1475-1488). Because both studies relied principally upon changes in the expression pattern of mRNAs specific to early muscle precursor cell markers, we revisited these experiments using two methods to assess muscle terminal differentiation. First, injection of fluorescent dyes before surgery was used to determine whether ventrolateral lip cells transform from epithelial cells to elongated myocytes. Second, an antibody to a terminal differentiation marker and a new monoclonal antibody that recognises avian and mammalian Pax3 were used for immunohistochemistry to assess the transition from precursor cell to myocyte. The results support both hypotheses and show further that placing axial structures adjacent to the somite ventrolateral lip induces an axial pattern of myocyte terminal differentiation and elongation.

Influence of the neural tube/notochord complex on MyoD expression and cellular proliferation in chicken embryos

Important advances have been made in understanding the genetic processes that control skeletal muscle formation. Studies conducted on quails detected a delay in the myogenic program of animals selected for high growth rates. These studies have led to the hypothesis that a delay in myogenesis would allow somitic cells to proliferate longer and consequently increase the number of embryonic myoblasts. To test this hypothesis, recently segmented somites and part of the unsegmented paraxial mesoderm were separated from the neural tube/notochord complex in HH12 chicken embryos. In situ hybridization and competitive RT-PCR revealed that MyoD transcripts, which are responsible for myoblast determination, were absent in somites separated from neural tube/notochord (1.06 and 0.06 10(-3) attomol MyoD/1 attomol beta-actin for control and separated somites, respectively; P<0.01). However, reapproximation of these structures allowed MyoD to be expressed in somites. Cellular proliferation was analyzed by immunohistochemical detection of incorporated BrdU, a thymidine analogue. A smaller but not significant (P = 0.27) number of proliferating cells was observed in somites that had been separated from neural tube/notochord (27 and 18 for control and separated somites, respectively). These results confirm the influence of the axial structures on MyoD activation but do not support the hypothesis that in the absence of MyoD transcripts the cellular proliferation would be maintained for a longer period of time.

Slow myosins in muscle development

Myogenesis has been a system central to investigations on mechanisms of diversification within groups of differentiating cells. Diversity among cell types has been well described in striated muscle tissue at the protein and enzymatic-function levels for decades, but it is only in recent years that some understanding of the molecular mechanisms responsible for this diversity has begun to emerge. Study of the expression of the slow isoforms of the myosin heavy chain has contributed to our understanding of how cell diversity arises within skeletal and cardiac muscle. Slow MyHc isoforms are developmentally responsive to a number of cues provided by the nervous systems, the endocrine system and, later in development, to functional demands on these developing tissues. Perhaps most informative have been studies on the mechanism for regulation of slow MyHc expression in mammals and birds where studies on the calcineurin-NF-AT pathways and nuclear hormone action have been shown to control MyHC gene expression in skeletal muscle and in the developing heart. The mechanisms involved in cell diversification in myogenesis are undoubtedly more varied and complex than those currently offered to explain cell diversification, but these recent studies have broadened our understanding of the interplay between the nervous system, the endocrine system and cell lineages in controlling cell diversification. Greater focus on the first fibers and cardiomyocytes to form in the embryo are likely to bring additional insights into the mechanism crucial for establishing the patterns of diversity required for successful formation of embryonic tissues.

Pax3 is essential for skeletal myogenesis and the expression of Six1 and Eya2

Pax3 is a paired box transcription factor expressed during somitogenesis that has been implicated in initiating the expression of the myogenic regulatory factors during myogenesis. We find that Pax3 is necessary and sufficient to induce myogenesis in pluripotent stem cells. Pax3 induced the expression of the transcription factor Six1, its cofactor Eya2, and the transcription factor Mox1 prior to inducing the expression of MyoD and myogenin. Overexpression of a dominant negative Pax3, engineered by fusing the active transcriptional repression domain of mouse EN-2 in place of the Pax3 transcriptional activation domain, completely abolished skeletal myogenesis without inhibiting cardiogenesis. Expression of the dominant negative Pax3 resulted in a loss of expression of Six1, Eya2, and endogenous Pax3 as well as a down-regulation in the expression of Mox1. No effect was found on the expression of Gli2. These results indicate that Pax3 activity is essential for skeletal muscle development, the expression of Six1 and Eya2, and is involved in regulating its own expression. In summary, the combined approach of expressing both a wild type and dominant negative transcription factor in stem cells has identified a cascade of transcriptional events controlled by Pax3 that are necessary and sufficient for skeletal myogenesis.

Regulation of Epha4 expression in paraxial and lateral plate mesoderm by ectoderm-derived signals

Somitogenesis in all vertebrates involves a mesenchymal to epithelial transition of segmental plate cells. Such a transition involves cells altering their morphology and their adhesive properties. The Eph family of receptor tyrosine kinases has been postulated to regulate cytoskeletal organization. In this study, we show that a receptor belonging to this family, EphA4, is expressed in the segmental plate in a region where cells are undergoing changes in cell shape as a prelude to epithelialization. We have identified the ectoderm covering the somites and the midline ectoderm as sources of signals capable of inducing EphA4. Loss of EphA4 results in cells of irregular morphology and somites fail to form. We also show that when somites fail to develop, expression of EphA4 in the lateral plate is also lost. We suggest that signaling occurs between the somites and the lateral plate mesoderm and provide evidence that retinoic acid is involved in this communication.

Compartmentalization of the somite and myogenesis in chick embryos are influenced by wnt expression

Muscles of the body and bones of the axial skeleton derive from specialized regions of somites. Somite development is influenced by adjacent structures. In particular, the dorsal neural tube and the overlying ectoderm have been shown to be necessary for the induction of myogenic precursor cells in the dermomyotome. Members of the Wnt family of signaling molecules, which are expressed in the dorsal neural tube and the ectoderm, are postulated to be responsible for this process. It is shown here that ectopically implanted Wnt-1-, -3a-, and -4-expressing cells alter the process of somite compartmentalization in vivo. An enlarged dorsal compartment results from the implantation of Wnt-expressing cells ventrally between the neural tube/notochord and epithelial somites, at the expense of the ventral compartment, the sclerotome. Thus, ectopic Wnt expression is able to override the influence of ventralizing signals arising from notochord and floor plate. This shift of the border between the two compartments was identified by an increase in the domain of Pax-3 expression and a complete loss of Pax-1 expression in somites close to the ectopic Wnt signal. The expanded expression of MyoD and desmin provides evidence that it is the myotome which increases as a result of Wnt signaling. Paraxis expression is also drastically amplified after implantation of Wnt-expressing cells indicating that Wnts are involved in the formation and maintenance of somite epithelium and suggesting that Paraxis is activated through Wnt signaling pathways. Taken together these results suggest that ectopic Wnts disturb the normal balance of signaling molecules within the somite, resulting in an enhanced recruitment of somitic cells into the myogenic lineage.

Wnt signaling regulates the function of MyoD and myogenin

The myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs), MyoD and myogenin, can induce myogenesis in a variety of cell lines but not efficiently in monolayer cultures of P19 embryonal carcinoma stem cells. Aggregation of cells expressing MRFs, termed P19[MRF] cells, results in an approximately 30-fold enhancement of myogenesis. Here we examine molecular events occurring during P19 cell aggregation to identify potential mechanisms regulating MRF activity. Although myogenin protein was continually present in the nuclei of >90% of P19[myogenin] cells, only a fraction of these cells differentiated. Consequently, it appears that post-translational regulation controls myogenin activity in a cell lineage-specific manner. A correlation was obtained between the expression of factors involved in somite patterning, including Wnt3a, Wnt5b, BMP-2/4, and Pax3, and the induction of myogenesis. Co-culturing P19[Wnt3a] cells with P19[MRF] cells in monolayer resulted in a 5- to 8-fold increase in myogenesis. Neither BMP-4 nor Pax3 was efficient in enhancing MRF activity in unaggregated P19 cultures. Furthermore, BMP-4 abrogated the enhanced myogenesis induced by Wnt signaling. Consequently, signaling events resulting from Wnt3a expression but not BMP-4 signaling or Pax3 expression, regulate MRF function. Therefore, the P19 cell culture system can be used to study the link between somite patterning events and myogenesis.

Expression of (beta)-catenin in the developing chick myotome is regulated by myogenic signals

The developmental signals that govern cell specification and differentiation in vertebrate somites are well understood. However, little is known about the downstream signalling pathways involved. We have shown previously that a combination of Shh protein and Wnt1 or Wnt3a-expressing fibroblasts is sufficient to activate skeletal muscle-specific gene expression in somite explants. Here, we have examined the molecular mechanisms by which the Wnt-mediated signal acts on myogenic precursor cells. We show that chick frizzled 1 (Fz1), beta-catenin and Lef1 are expressed during somitogenesis. Lef1 and beta-catenin transcripts become restricted to the developing myotome. Furthermore, beta-catenin is expressed prior to the time at which MyoD transcripts can be detected. Expression of beta-catenin mRNA is regulated by positive and negative signals derived from neural tube, notochord and lateral plate mesoderm. These signals include Bmp4, Shh and Wnt1/Wnt3a itself. In somite explants, Fz1, beta-catenin and Lef1 are expressed prior to activation of myogenesis in response to Shh and Wnt signals. Thus, our data show that a combination of Shh and Wnt1 upregulates expression of Wnt pathway components in developing somites prior to myogenesis. Thus, Wnt1 could act through beta-catenin on cells in the myotome.

The expression of Myf5 in the developing mouse embryo is controlled by discrete and dispersed enhancers specific for particular populations of skeletal muscle precursors

The development of skeletal muscle in vertebrate embryos is controlled by a transcriptional cascade that includes the four myogenic regulatory factors Myf5, Myogenin, MRF4 and MyoD. In the mouse embryo, Myf5 is the first of these factors to be expressed and mutational analyses suggest that this protein acts early in the process of commitment to the skeletal muscle fate. We have therefore analysed the regulation of Myf5 gene expression using transgenic technology and find that its control is markedly different from that of the other two myogenic regulatory factor genes previously analysed, Myogenin and MyoD. We show that Myf5 is regulated through a number of distinct and discrete enhancers, dispersed throughout 14 kb spanning the MRF4/Myf5 locus, each of which drives reporter gene expression in a particular subset of skeletal muscle precursors. This region includes four separate enhancers controlling expression in the epaxial muscle precursors of the body, some hypaxial precursors of the body, some facial muscles and the central nervous system. These elements separately or together are unable to drive expression in the cells that migrate to the limb buds and in some other muscle subsets and to correctly maintain expression at late times. We suggest that this complex mechanism of control has evolved because different inductive signals operate in each population of muscle precursors and thus distinct enhancers, and cognate transcription factors, are required to interpret them.

IGFs, insulin, Shh, bFGF, and TGF-beta1 interact synergistically to promote somite myogenesis in vitro

Studies from our group and others have shown that in vitro somite myogenesis is regulated by neural tube and notochord factors including Wnt, Sonic hedgehog (Shh), and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) together with transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1). In this study we report that insulin and insulin-like growth factors I and II (IGF-I and -II) also promote myogenesis in explant cultures containing single somites or somite-sized pieces of segmental plate mesoderm from 2-day (stage 10-14) chicken embryos and that the combination of insulin/IGFs with bFGF plus TGF-beta1 promotes even higher levels of myogenesis. We also found that Shh promotes myogenesis in this in vitro system and that Shh interacts synergistically with insulin/IGFs to promote high levels of myogenesis. RT-PCR analysis detected insulin, IGF-II, insulin receptor, and IGF receptor mRNAs in both the neural tube and the somites, whereas IGF-I transcripts were detected in entire embryos but not in the neural tube or somites. Treatment of somite-neural tube cocultures with anti-insulin, anti-IGF-II, anti-insulin receptor, or anti-IGF receptor blocking antibodies caused a significant decrease in myogenesis. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that systemic IGF-I as well as insulin and IGF-II secreted by the neural tube act as additional early myogenic signals during embryogenesis. Further studies indicate that insulin, IGFs, bFGF, and Shh also stimulate somite cell proliferation and influence apoptosis.

Somite formation and patterning

As a consequence of their segmented arrangement and the diversity of their tissue derivatives, somites are key elements in the establishment of the metameric body plan in vertebrates. This article aims to largely review what is known about somite development, from the initial stages of somite formation through the process of somite regionalization along the three major body axes. The role of both cell intrinsic mechanisms and environmental cues are evaluated. The periodic and bilaterally synchronous nature of somite formation is proposed to rely on the existence of a developmental clock. Molecular mechanisms underlying these events are reported. The importance of an antero-posterior somitic polarity with respect to somite formation on one hand and body segmentation on the other hand is discussed. Finally, the mechanisms leading to the regionalization of somites along the dorso-ventral and medio-lateral axes are reviewed. This somitic compartmentalization is believed to underlie the segregation of dermis, skeleton, and dorsal and appendicular musculature.

Shh and Wnt signaling pathways converge to control Gli gene activation in avian somites

The regulation of the Gli genes during somite formation has been investigated in quail embryos. The Gli genes are a family encoding three related zinc finger transcription factors, Gli1, Gli2 and Gli3, which are effectors of Shh signaling in responding cells. A quail Gli3 cDNA has been cloned and its expression compared with Gli1 and Gli2. These studies show that Gli1, Gli2 and Gli3 are co-activated at the time of somite formation, thus providing a mechanism for regulating the initiation of Shh signaling in somites. Embryo surgery and paraxial mesoderm explant experiments show that each of the Gli genes is regulated by distinct signaling mechanisms. Gli1 is activated in response to Shh produced by the notochord, which also controls the dorsalization of Gli2 and Gli3 following their activation by Wnt signaling from the surface ectoderm and neural tube. This surface ectoderm/neural tube Wnt signaling has both negative and positive functions in Gli2 and Gli3 regulation: these signals repress Gli3 in segmental plate mesoderm prior to somite formation and then promote somite formation and the somite-specific activation of Gli2 and Gli3. These studies, therefore, establish a role for Wnt signaling in the control of Shh signal transduction through the regulation of Gli2 and Gli3, and provide a mechanistic basis for the known synergistic actions of surface ectoderm/neural tube and notochord signaling in somite cell specification.

Mouse-chick chimera: an experimental system for study of somite development

As the mammalian embryo is implanted in the uterus and not readily accessible to direct observation or manipulation, much of our understanding of mammalian somite development is based on findings in lower vertebrates. One means of overcoming the difficulties raised by intrauterine development is to engraft mouse tissue in ovo. The experiments described in this chapter relate to the unilateral replacement of somites in chick embryo with those from mouse fetus. Mouse somites differentiate in ovo in dermis, cartilage, and skeletal muscle and are able to migrate into chick host limb. A LacZ transgenic mouse strain was used to ascertain the role of the implanted somites in forming epaxial and hypaxial muscle in the chick embryo. Myogenesis occurred normally in in ovo developing mouse somites, and muscle cells from mouse myotome formed neuromuscular contacts with chick motor axons. After fragments of fetal mouse neural primordium were transplanted into chick embryo, mouse neural tube contributed to the mechanism maintaining myogenesis in the somites of the host embryo. A recently developed double-grafting procedure involving neural tube and somites from knockout mouse strains should elucidate the molecular events involved in early somitogenesis.

Genetics of muscle determination and development

Skeletal muscles in vertebrates develop from somites as the result of patterning and cell type specification events. Here, we review the current knowledge of genes and signals implicated in these processes. We discuss in particular the role of the myogenic determination genes as deduced from targeted gene disruptions in mice and how their expression may be controlled. We also refer to other transcription factors which collaborate with the myogenic regulators in positive or negative ways to control myogenesis. Moreover, we review experiments that demonstrate the influence of tissues surrounding the somites on the process of muscle formation and provide model views on the underlying mechanisms. Finally, we present recent evidence on genes that play a role in regeneration of muscle in adult organisms.

Evolution and development of distinct cell lineages derived from somites

In the vertebrate embryo, the somites arise from the paraxial mesoderm as paired mesodermal units in a craniocaudal sequence. Segmentation is also the underlying principle of the body plan in annelids and arthropods. Genes controlling segmentation have been identified that are highly conserved in organisms belonging to different phyla. Segmentation facilitates movement and regionalization of the vertebrate body. Its traces in humans are, for example, vertebral bodies, intervertebral disks, ribs, and spinal nerves. Somite research has a history of at least three centuries. Detailed morphological data have accumulated on the development of the avian somite. Especially in connection with the quailchick interspecific marker system, progress was made toward an understanding of underlying mechanisms. At first each somite consists of an outer epithelium and a mesenchymal core. Later, the ventral portion of the somite undergoes de-epithelialization and gives rise to the sclerotome, whereas the dorsal portion forms the dermomyotome. The dermomyotome is the source of myotomal muscle cells and the dermis of the back. It also yields the hypaxial muscle buds at flank level and the myogenic cells invading the limb buds. The dorsal and ventral somitic domains express different sets of developmental control genes, for example, those of the Pax family. During later stages of development, the sclerotomes undergo a new arrangement called "resegmentation" leading to the fusion of the caudal half of one sclerotome with the cranial half of the following sclerotome. Further somitic derivatives include fibroblasts, smooth muscle, and endothelial cells. While sclerotome formation is controlled by the notochord, signals from the dorsal neural tube and ectoderm support the development of the dermomyotome. Myogenic precursor cells for the limb bud are recruited from the dermomyotome by the interaction of c-met with its ligand scatter factor (SF/HGF). In the evolution of metamerism in vertebrates, the first skeletal elements were primitive parts of neural arches, while axial elements developed only later in teleosts as pleurocentra and hypocentra.

Expression pattern of GDNF, c-ret, and GFRalphas suggests novel roles for GDNF ligands during early organogenesis in the chick embryo

We have cloned a partial cDNA of chicken glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) and systematically examined its expression pattern as well as that of GDNF-binding components (GDNF family receptor alpha-1 and 2: GFRalpha-1 and 2) and a common signal transduction receptor (c-ret protooncogene: RET) during very early developmental stages. In addition, we also examined the expression pattern of an apparent avian-specific binding component, GFRalpha-4. The cloned chicken cDNA for GDNF had approximately 80% homology to mammalian counterparts. The expression of GDNF mRNA occurred in many spatially and temporally discrete regions such as the intermediate mesoderm, the floor plate of the spinal cord, pharyngeal endoderm contacting the epibranchial placodes, distal ganglia of cranial nerves, subpopulations of mesenchyme cells in the craniofacial region, and in the mesodermal wall of the digestive tract. Both a GDNF receptor signal transduction component (RET) and a binding component (GFRalpha-1 or GFRalpha-2) were independently expressed in nearby interacting tissues such as the somites, peripheral and central nervous system, and mesenchyme cells in the craniofacial region. These observations suggest that possible combinations of novel unidentified receptors acting with RET or with GFRalphas may mediate GDNF-derived signals and indicate that GDNF or other family members may have previously unidentified actions in early organogenesis in the chick embryo.

The origin and morphogenesis of amphibian somites

The origin and development of the amphibian somitic mesoderm is summarized and reviewed with the goal of identifying issues most profitably pursued in these organisms. The location of the prospective somitic mesoderm as well as the cell movements bringing this tissue into its definitive position varies among amphibians. These variations have implications for the tissue interactions patterning the embryo, the design of the gastrulation movements, the role of the somitic mesoderm in early patterning and morphogenic processes, and the nature of the developmental pathway leading to somites. The presegmentation morphogenesis, the process of segmentation, and the subsequent, postsegmentation morphogenesis of the somitic mesoderm also varies considerably among amphibians. Although segmentation in amphibians shares what may be highly conserved and general patterning mechanisms with other vertebrates, the somitic developmental pathway as a whole is not conservative and has been capable of accommodating the use of a number of quite different morphogenic processes, all leading to very similar ends. The major challenges in studying amphibian somitogenesis are to develop molecular markers for major components of the somite, to determine the derivatives of the somite with better cell tracing experiments, and learning to work with the small dermatomal and sclerotomal cell populations found in most species. A potential advantage is that the diversity of somitogenesis among the amphibians makes this group ideal for studying the evolution of developmental processes. In addition, many amphibians allow direct observation of somitogenesis with great resolution and permit biomechanical analysis of tissues participating in morphogenesis, thus making it possible to analyze cellular mechanisms of morphogenesis in ways not possible in most other systems.

Early development of the myotome in the mouse

The structure and development of the myotome has been extensively studied in birds and amphibians but few studies have systematically addressed its development in mammals. We have used a transgenic mouse carrying an nLacZ marker coupled to a myosin light chain 3F promoter to describe the structure of the developing mammalian myotome. Through studies of transgene expression pattern, coupled with immunohistochemistry for the muscle structural proteins desmin and slow myosin heavy chain we describe a gradient of maturity for the cells within the developing myotome. Our results show that the earliest myocytes of the mammalian myotome span the rostrocaudal extent of the somite and have single large nuclei which localise centrally within the myotome. Throughout the period of study the myotome is more mature ventrally than dorsally and cells comprising the medial aspect of the myotome are younger than those lying laterally. Immunohistochemistry for the earliest expressed muscle regulatory factor (myf-5) is used to define areas of the myotome contributing new myogenic cells. In the early myotome small, round, myf-5-expressing cells are found extensively within the dorsomedial aspect of the dermamyotome and also within the entire rostral and caudal dermamyotomal lips. They subsequently appear within the central zone of the myotome, adjacent to the medially curled rostral and caudal dermamyotomal lips, and there begin to elongate symmetrically. As the myotome enlarges, myf-5 expression is always restricted to the most medial aspect of the myotome, adjacent to the least mature myocytes, marking the site of addition of new myogenic cells. Together, these results allow development of a model of mammalian myotome formation where growth occurs medially by addition of new cells from both rostral and caudal dermamyotome lips, while more mature myocytes are displaced laterally. Furthermore, early myotomal myocytes differentiate in the absence of MyoD expression, unlike later myotomal myocytes. This, along with their distinct morphology, suggests these cells may form a separate lineage of pioneer myogenic cells.

Temperature and neuromuscular development in embryos of the trout (Salmo trutta L.)

Myogenesis and neural development were examined in the myotomes of trout (Salmo trutta L.) embryos reared at 2, 6 and 10 degrees C. The relative timings of myotube and muscle fibre formation were similar, with respect to somite stage, at all three temperatures. Myogenesis was seen to begin medially, adjacent to the notochord, and also in separate zones located near the outer surface of the myotomes, believed to be the sites of formation of future slow muscle fibres. Temperature did not affect the relative timings of most aspects of neural development, including HNK-1-immunoreactivity of myosepta, primary motor neuron axonogenesis, Rohon-Beard dendrite outgrowth, and expression of acetylcholinesterase in the spinal chord and at the myosepta. The posterior progression of the lateral line primordium was slightly but significantly delayed relative to somite stage in embryos reared at 10 degrees C compared to 6 and 2 degrees C, while formation of vacuoles in the notochord occurred relatively earlier at higher temperatures. No significant differences in neuromuscular development were observed between offspring of migratory and of non-migratory females.

A distinct developmental programme for the cranial paraxial mesoderm in the chick embryo

Cells of the cranial paraxial mesoderm give rise to parts of the skull and muscles of the head. Some mesoderm cells migrate from locations close to the hindbrain into the branchial arches where they undergo muscle differentiation. We have characterised these migratory pathways in chick embryos either by DiI-labelling cells before migration or by grafting quail cranial paraxial mesoderm orthotopically. These experiments demonstrate that depending on their initial rostrocaudal position, cranial paraxial mesoderm cells migrate to fill the core of specific branchial arches. A survey of the expression of myogenic genes showed that the myogenic markers Myf5, MyoD and myogenin were expressed in branchial arch muscle, but at comparatively late stages compared with their expression in the somites. Pax3 was not expressed by myogenic cells that migrate into the branchial arches despite its expression in migrating precursors of limb muscles. In order to test whether segmental plate or somitic mesoderm has the ability to migrate in a cranial location, we grafted quail trunk mesoderm into the cranial paraxial mesoderm region. While segmental plate mesoderm cells did not migrate into the branchial arches, somitic cells were capable of migrating and were incorporated into the branchial arch muscle mass. Grafted somitic cells in the vicinity of the neural tube maintained expression of the somitic markers Pax3, MyoD and Pax1. By contrast, ectopic somitic cells located distal to the neural tube and in the branchial arches did not express Pax3. These data imply that signals in the vicinity of the hindbrain and branchial arches act on migrating myogenic cells to influence their gene expression and developmental pathways.

Sonic hedgehog is required for survival of both myogenic and chondrogenic somitic lineages

In vertebrates, the medial moieties of the somites give rise to the vertebrae and epaxial muscles, which develop in close relationship with the axial organs, neural tube and notochord. The lateral moieties contribute to the ribs and to limb and body wall muscles (hypaxial muscles) after a phase of lateral and ventral migration. Surgical ablation of the neural tube and notochord in the chick embryo during segmentation and early differentiation of the somites (day 2 of incubation) does not affect primary development of the hypaxial muscles, but leads to a complete absence of epaxial muscles, vertebrae and ribs, due to cell death in the somites. Here we demonstrate that cell death, which occurs within 24 hours of excision of the axial organs, affects both myogenic and chondrogenic cell lineages defined, respectively, by the expression of MyoD and Pax-1 genes. In contrast, Pax-3 transcripts, normally present in cells giving rise to hypaxial muscles, are preserved in the excised embryos. Backgrafting either the ventral neural tube or the notochord allows survival of MyoD- and Pax-1-expressing cells. Similarly, Sonic hedgehog-producing cells grafted in place of axial organs also rescue MyoD- and Pax-1-expressing cells from death and allow epaxial muscles, ribs and vertebrae to undergo organogenesis. These results demonstrate that the ventral neural tube and the notochord promote the survival of both myogenic and chondrogenic cell lineages in the somites and that this action is mediated by Sonic hedgehog.

The origin and fate of pioneer myotomal cells in the avian embryo

The ontogeny of the myotome was investigated using [3H]thymidine or Brdu treatment in conjunction with 1,1', di-octadecyl-3, 3, 3', 3',-tetramethylindo-carbocyanine perchlorate (DiI) labeling and expression of specific markers. We have identified a subset of early post-mitotic cells that is present in the dorsomedial aspect of epithelial somites and is homogeneously distributed along their entire rostrocaudal extent. The post-mitotic quality of this cell subset enabled us to trace their fate in time-course experiments. Following initial somite dissociation, this epithelial post-mitotic layer bends underneath the medial portion of the nascent dermomyotome. Then, these cells progressively lose epithelial arrangement and migrate in a rostral direction where they accumulate temporarily. Subsequently, these early post-mitotic precursors extend processes that reach both rostral and caudal edges of each segment. Medial somite-derived myofibers also fill the entire mediolateral extent of the segment and reach the dorsomedial lip of the dermomyotome, thus forming the primary myotome. During this process, their large nuclei localize to a narrow stripe in the middle of the nascent myotome. Consistent with the proliferation studies, DiI labeling of the medial epithelial somite cells gave rise to a primary myotomal structure, and continuous pulsing of the DiI-injected embryos with radioactive thymidine revealed that these fibers indeed developed from post-mitotic progenitors. As these early post-mitotic cells that arise prior to somite dissociation are the first wave of progenitors that constitutes the myotome, we have termed them avian muscle pioneers. We propose that the primary myotome formed by the muscle pioneers constitutes a longitudinal scaffold that serves as a substrate for the addition of subsequent waves of myotomal cells.

The role of stably committed and uncommitted cells in establishing tissues of the somite

Somites are blocks of embryonic mesoderm tissue that give rise to skeletal muscle, cartilage, and other connective tissues. The development of different tissues within the somite is influenced by adjacent structures, in particular, the neural tube and notochord. Results of experiments performed in vivo and in vitro suggest that somites contain populations of cells stably programmed to undergo either skeletal myogenesis or chondrogenesis and a population uncommitted to either pathway. The fate of the uncommitted cells would depend on a transfer of information from the committed cells. Communication between committed and uncommitted cells is regulated by cell and tissue interactions that either activate or inhibit this process.

The generation and interpretation of positional information within the vertebrate myotome

How somitic cells become restricted to the muscle fate has been investigated on a number of levels. Classical embryological manipulations have attempted to define the source of inductive signals that control the formation of the myotome. Recently, these studies have converged with others dissecting the role of secreted proteins in embryonic patterning to demonstrate a role for specific peptides in inducing individual cell types of the myotome. Collectively, these investigations have implicated the products of the Wnt, Hedgehog (Hh) and Bone morphogenetic protein (Bmp) gene families as key myogenic regulators; simultaneously controlling both the initiation of myogenesis and the fate of individual myoblasts.

Sonic Hedgehog induces proliferation of committed skeletal muscle cells in the chick limb

Myogenic Regulatory Factors (MRFs) are a family of transcription factors whose expression in a cell reflects the commitment of this cell to a myogenic fate before any cytological sign of muscle differentiation is detectable. Myogenic cells in limb skeletal muscles originate from the lateral half of the somites. Cells that migrate away from the lateral part of the somites to the limb bud do not initially express any member of the MRF family. Expression of MRFs in the muscle precursor cells starts after the migration process is completed. The extracellular signals involved in activating the myogenic programme in muscle precursor cells in the limb in vivo are not known. We wished to investigate whether Sonic Hedgehog (SHH) expressed in the posterior part of the limb bud could be involved in differentiation of the muscle precursor cells in the limb. We found that retrovirally overexpressed SHH in the limb bud induced the extension of the expression domain of the Pax-3 gene, then that of the MyoD gene and finally that of the myosin protein. This led to an hypertrophy of the muscles in vivo. Addition of SHH to primary cultures of myoblasts resulted in an increase in the proportion of myoblasts that incorporate bromodeoxyuridine, resulting in an increase of myotube number. These data show that SHH is able to activate myogenesis in vivo and in vitro in already committed myoblasts and suggest that the stimulation of the myogenic programme by SHH involves activation of cell proliferation.

Emergence of determined myotome precursor cells in the somite

Myotome and sclerotome precursor cells are derived, respectively, from cells in the dorsomedial and ventromedial regions of the somite. To assay changes in the specification of myotomal precursor cells during somite maturation, we implanted dorsomedial quadrant fragments, from staged quail somites, next to the notochords of host chick embryos, and superimposed two additional notochords on these implants. In this notochord signalling environment, dorsomedial quadrant cells that are developmentally plastic are expected to differentiate as cartilage, while cells determined to a myogenic fate are expected to differentiate as skeletal muscle. Large numbers of differentiated chondrocytes developed from dorsomedial quadrant grafts of all stages of paraxial mesoderm development tested, indicating that persistent chondrogenic potential in cells fated to form muscle and dermis can be elicited by notochord signals. Differentiated myocytes, however, appeared in two somite-stage-dependent phases. In the first phase, dorsomedial quadrants from segmental plate and early stage somites (II and IV) form small, disorganized clusters of individual myocytes. The frequency of first-phase myocluster formation increases as myogenic factor expression begins in the dorsomedial quadrant, indicating that myogenic determination assayed by this method is closely linked to the expression of myogenic factors in the dorsomedial quadrant. In the second phase, dorsomedial quadrants from somite stages XI-XIII consistently form morphologically organized muscle tissue containing large numbers of parallel-oriented, multinucleated myotubes. Mitotic labelling demonstrated that muscle precursors were determined to the muscle phenotype prior to withdrawal from the cell cycle. Thus, myogenic determination in cells of the dorsomedial quadrant is acquired at earlier stages of somite maturation than the ability to proliferate and form muscle tissue. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that successive lineages of myotome precursor cells with different mitotic and morphogenetic properties arise in the dorsomedial quadrant during somite maturation.

P19 embryonal carcinoma cells: a model system for studying neural tube induction of skeletal myogenesis

A model experimental system for investigating myogenic induction signals has been devised with mouse P19 embryonal carcinoma cells. When cocultured with pieces of chick neural tube, aggregated P19 cells are induced to become skeletal muscle. The most potent inducing activity is localized to the dorsal neural tube. Less activity was found in the ventral neural tube, notochord, ectoderm, and lateral plate mesoderm, and none was detected in the neural retina. These results suggest that P19 cells may be a useful model system for investigating the mechanisms underlying induction of somite myogenesis.

Noggin acts downstream of Wnt and Sonic Hedgehog to antagonize BMP4 in avian somite patterning

In the vertebrate embryo, the lateral compartment of the somite gives rise to muscles of the limb and body wall and is patterned in response to lateral-plate-derived BMP4. Activation of the myogenic program distinctive to the medial somite, i.e. relatively immediate development of the epaxial muscle lineage, requires neutralization of this lateral signal. We have analyzed the properties of molecules likely to play a role in opposing lateral somite specification by BMP4. We propose that the BMP4 antagonist Noggin plays an important role in promoting medial somite patterning in vivo. We demonstrate that Noggin expression in the somite is under the control of a neural-tube-derived factor, whose effect can be mimicked experimentally by Wnt1. Wnt1 is appropriately expressed in the neural tube. Furthermore, we show that Sonic Hedgehog is able to activate ectopic expression of Noggin resulting in the blocking of BMP4 specification of the lateral somite. Our results are consistent with a model in which Noggin activation lies downstream of the SHH and Wnt signaling pathways.

Synergistic interactions between bFGF and a TGF-beta family member may mediate myogenic signals from the neural tube

Development of the myotome within somites depends on unknown signals from the neural tube. The present study tested the ability of basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1) and dorsalin-1 (dsl-1) to promote myogenesis in stage 10–14 chick paraxial mesoderm utilizing 72 hour explant cultures. Each of these factors alone and the combination of bFGF with dsl-1 had limited to no myogenic-promoting activity, but the combination of bFGF with TGF-beta1 demonstrated a potent dose-dependent effect. In addition, bFGF enhanced the survival/proliferation of somite cells. 98% of stage 10–11 caudal segmental plate explants treated with bFGF plus TGF-beta1, exhibited myosin heavy chain (MHC)-positive cells (avg.=60 per explant), whereas only 15% of similarly treated somites responded with an average of 5 MHC-positive cells. Thus at stage 10–11, there are rostrocaudal differences in myogenic responsiveness with the caudal (more ‘immature’) paraxial mesoderm being more myogenically responsive to these factors than are somites. It was also discovered that 17% of stage 10–11 caudal segmental plate explants exhibited several MHC-positive cells even when cultured without added growth factors, further demonstrating a different myogenic potential of the caudal paraxial mesoderm. Stage 13–14 paraxial mesoderm also exhibited a myogenic response to bFGF/TGF-beta1 but, unlike stage 10–11 embryos, both somites and segmental plate exhibited a strong response. A two-step mechanism for the bFGF/TGF-beta1 effect is suggested by the finding that only TGF-beta1 was required during the first 12 hours of culture, whereas bFGF plus a TGF-beta-like factor were required for the remainder of the culture. The biological relevance of the findings with bFGF is underscored by the observation that a monoclonal antibody to bFGF inhibited myogenic signaling from the dorsal neural tube. However, a monoclonal antibody that can neutralize the three factors TGF-beta1, TGF-beta2 and TGF-beta3 did not block myogenic signals from the neural tube, raising the possibility that another TGF-beta family member may be involved in vivo.

Mouse-chick chimera: a developmental model of murine neurogenic cells

Chimeras were prepared by transplanting fragments of neural primordium from 8- to 8.5- and 9-day postcoital mouse embryos into 1.5- and 2-day-old chick embryos at different axial levels. Mouse neuroepithelial cells differentiated in ovo and organized to form the different cellular compartments normally constituting the central nervous system.The graft also entered into the development of the peripheral nervous system through migration of neural crest cells associated with mouse neuroepithelium. Depending on the graft level, mouse crest cells participated in the formation of various derivatives such as head components, sensory ganglia, orthosympathetic ganglionic chain, nerves and neuroendocrine glands. Tenascin knockout mice, which express lacZ instead of tenascin and show no tenascin production (Saga, Y., Yagi, J., Ikawa, Y., Sakakura, T. and Aizawa, S. (1992) Genes and Development 6, 1821–1838), were specifically used to label Schwann cells lining nerves derived from the implant. Although our experiments do not consider how mouse neural tube can participate in the mechanism required to maintain myogenesis in the host somites, they show that the grafted neural tube behaves in the same manner as the chick host neural tube. Together with our previous results on somite development (Fontaine-Perus, J., Jarno, V., Fournier Le Ray, C., Li, Z. and Paulin, D. (1995) Development 121, 1705–1718), this study shows that chick embryo constitutes a privileged environment, facilitating access to the developmental potentials of normal or defective mammalian cells. It allows the study of the histogenesis and precise timing of a known structure, as well as the implication of a given gene at all equivalent mammalian embryonic stages.