A novel hypomorphic allele of Spag17 causes primary ciliary dyskinesia phenotypes in mice

Novel homozygous SPAG17 variants cause human male infertility through multiple morphological abnormalities of spermatozoal flagella related to axonemal microtubule doublets

ABSTRACT

Male infertility can result from impaired sperm motility caused by multiple morphological abnormalities of the flagella (MMAF). Distinct projections encircling the central microtubules of the spermatozoal axoneme play pivotal roles in flagellar bending and spermatozoal movement. Mammalian sperm-associated antigen 17 (SPAG17) encodes a conserved axonemal protein of cilia and flagella, forming part of the C1a projection of the central apparatus, with functions related to ciliary/flagellar motility, skeletal growth, and male fertility. This study investigated two novel homozygous SPAG17 mutations (M1: NM_206996.2, c.829+1G>T, p.Asp212_Glu276del; and M2: c.2120del, p.Leu707*) identified in four infertile patients from two consanguineous Pakistani families. These patients displayed the MMAF phenotype confirmed by Papanicolaou staining and scanning electron microscopy assays of spermatozoa. Quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of patients' spermatozoa also revealed a significant decrease in SPAG17 mRNA expression, and immunofluorescence staining showed the absence of SPAG17 protein signals along the flagella. However, no apparent ciliary-related symptoms or skeletal malformations were observed in the chest X-rays of any of the patients. Transmission electron microscopy of axoneme cross-sections from the patients showed incomplete C1a projection and a higher frequency of missing microtubule doublets 1 and 9 compared with those from fertile controls. Immunofluorescence staining and Western blot analyses of spermatogenesis-associated protein 17 (SPATA17), a component of the C1a projection, and sperm-associated antigen 6 (SPAG6), a marker of the spring layer, revealed disrupted expression of both proteins in the patients' spermatozoa. Altogether, these findings demonstrated that SPAG17 maintains the integrity of spermatozoal flagellar axoneme, expanding the phenotypic spectrum of SPAG17 mutations in humans.

A comprehensive study of common and rare genetic variants in spermatogenesis-related loci identifies new risk factors for idiopathic severe spermatogenic failure

STUDY QUESTION

Can genome-wide genotyping data be analysed using a hypothesis-driven approach to enhance the understanding of the genetic basis of severe spermatogenic failure (SPGF) in male infertility?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Our findings revealed a significant association between SPGF and the SHOC1 gene and identified three novel genes (PCSK4, AP3B1, and DLK1) along with 32 potentially pathogenic rare variants in 30 genes that contribute to this condition.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

SPGF is a major cause of male infertility, often with an unknown aetiology. SPGF can be due to either multifactorial causes, including both common genetic variants in multiple genes and environmental factors, or highly damaging rare variants. Next-generation sequencing methods are useful for identifying rare mutations that explain monogenic forms of SPGF. Genome-wide association studies (GWASs) have become essential approaches for deciphering the intricate genetic landscape of complex diseases, offering a cost-effective and rapid means to genotype millions of genetic variants. Novel methods have demonstrated that GWAS datasets can be used to infer rare coding variants that are causal for male infertility phenotypes. However, this approach has not been previously applied to characterize the genetic component of a whole case-control cohort.

STUDY DESIGN SIZE DURATION

We employed a hypothesis-driven approach focusing on all genetic variation identified, using a GWAS platform and subsequent genotype imputation, encompassing over 20 million polymorphisms and a total of 1571 SPGF patients and 2431 controls. Both common (minor allele frequency, MAF > 0.01) and rare (MAF < 0.01) variants were investigated within a total of 1797 loci with a reported role in spermatogenesis. This gene panel was meticulously assembled through comprehensive searches in the literature and various databases focused on male infertility genetics.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS SETTING METHODS

This study involved a European cohort using previously and newly generated data. Our analysis consisted of three independent methods: (i) variant-wise association analyses using logistic regression models, (ii) gene-wise association analyses using combined multivariate and collapsing burden tests, and (iii) identification and characterisation of highly damaging rare coding variants showing homozygosity only in SPGF patients.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

The variant-wise analyses revealed an association between SPGF and SHOC1-rs12347237 (P = 4.15E-06, odds ratio = 2.66), which was likely explained by an altered binding affinity of key transcription factors in regulatory regions and the disruptive effect of coding variants within the gene. Three additional genes (PCSK4, AP3B1, and DLK1) were identified as novel relevant players in human male infertility using the gene-wise burden test approach (P < 5.56E-04). Furthermore, we linked a total of 32 potentially pathogenic and recessive coding variants of the selected genes to 35 different cases.

LARGE SCALE DATA

Publicly available via GWAS catalog (accession number: GCST90239721).

LIMITATIONS REASONS FOR CAUTION

The analysis of low-frequency variants presents challenges in achieving sufficient statistical power to detect genetic associations. Consequently, independent studies with larger sample sizes are essential to replicate our results. Additionally, the specific roles of the identified variants in the pathogenic mechanisms of SPGF should be assessed through functional experiments.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

Our findings highlight the benefit of using GWAS genotyping to screen for both common and rare variants potentially implicated in idiopathic cases of SPGF, whether due to complex or monogenic causes. The discovery of novel genetic risk factors for SPGF and the elucidation of the underlying genetic causes provide new perspectives for personalized medicine and reproductive counselling.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTERESTS

This work was supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation through the Spanish National Plan for Scientific and Technical Research and Innovation (PID2020-120157RB-I00) and the Andalusian Government through the research projects of 'Plan Andaluz de Investigación, Desarrollo e Innovación (PAIDI 2020)' (ref. PY20_00212) and 'Proyectos de Investigación aplicada FEDER-UGR 2023' (ref. C-CTS-273-UGR23). S.G.-M. was funded by the previously mentioned projects (ref. PY20_00212 and PID2020-120157RB-I00). A.G.-J. was funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and FSE 'El FSE invierte en tu futuro' (grant ref. FPU20/02926). IPATIMUP integrates the i3S Research Unit, which is partially supported by the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology (FCT), financed by the European Social Funds (COMPETE-FEDER) and National Funds (projects PEstC/SAU/LA0003/2013 and POCI-01-0145-FEDER-007274). S.S. is supported by FCT funds (10.54499/DL57/2016/CP1363/CT0019), ToxOmics-Centre for Toxicogenomics and Human Health, Genetics, Oncology and Human Toxicology, and is also partially supported by the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology (UIDP/00009/2020 and UIDB/00009/2020). S. Larriba received support from Instituto de Salud Carlos III (grant: DTS18/00101), co-funded by FEDER funds/European Regional Development Fund (ERDF)-a way to build Europe) and from 'Generalitat de Catalunya' (grant 2021SGR052). S. Larriba is also sponsored by the 'Researchers Consolidation Program' from the SNS-Dpt. Salut Generalitat de Catalunya (Exp. CES09/020). All authors declare no conflict of interest related to this study.

Multiciliated ependymal cells: an update on biology and pathology in the adult brain

Mature multiciliated ependymal cells line the cerebral ventricles where they form a partial barrier between the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and brain parenchyma and regulate local CSF microcirculation through coordinated ciliary beating. Although the ependyma is a highly specialized brain interface with barrier, trophic, and perhaps even regenerative capacity, it remains a misfit in the canon of glial neurobiology. We provide an update to seminal reviews in the field by conducting a scoping review of the post-2010 mature multiciliated ependymal cell literature. We delineate how recent findings have either called into question or substantiated classical views of the ependymal cell. Beyond this synthesis, we document the basic methodologies and study characteristics used to describe multiciliated ependymal cells since 1980. Our review serves as a comprehensive resource for future investigations of mature multiciliated ependymal cells.

Exogenous nitric oxide delivery protects against cardiopulmonary bypass-associated acute kidney injury: Histologic and serologic evidence from an ovine model

OBJECTIVE

Several human studies have associated nitric oxide administration via the cardiopulmonary bypass circuit with decreased incidence of cardiopulmonary bypass-associated acute kidney injury, but histopathologic and serologic evidence of nitric oxide efficacy for acute kidney injury attenuation are lacking.

METHODS

By using a survival ovine model (72 hours), acute kidney injury was induced by implementing low-flow cardiopulmonary bypass for 2 hours, followed by full-flow cardiopulmonary bypass for 2 hours. The nitric oxide cohort (n = 6) received exogenous nitric oxide through the cardiopulmonary bypass circuit via the oxygenator, and the control group (n = 5) received no nitric oxide. Serial serologic biomarkers and renal histopathology were obtained.

RESULTS

Baseline characteristics (age, weight) and intraoperative parameters (cardiopulmonary bypass time, urine output, heart rate, arterial pH, and lactate) were equivalent (P > .10) between groups. Postoperatively, urine output, heart rate, respiratory rate, and peripheral arterial saturation were equivalent (P > .10) between groups. Post-cardiopulmonary bypass creatinine elevations from baseline were significantly greater in the control group versus the nitric oxide group at 16, 24, and 48 hours (all P < .05). Histopathologic evidence of moderate/severe acute kidney injury (epithelial necrosis, tubular slough, cast formation, glomerular edema) occurred in 60% (3/5) of the control group versus 0% (0/6) of the nitric oxide group. Cortical tubular epithelial cilia lengthening (a sensitive sign of cellular injury) was significantly greater in the control group than in the nitric oxide group (P = .012).

CONCLUSIONS

In a survival ovine cardiopulmonary bypass model, nitric oxide administered with cardiopulmonary bypass demonstrated serologic and histologic evidence of renal protection from acute kidney injury. These results provide insight into 1 potential mechanism for cardiopulmonary bypass-associated acute kidney injury and supports continued study of nitric oxide via cardiopulmonary bypass circuit for prevention of acute kidney injury.

Reduced SPAG17 Expression in Systemic Sclerosis Triggers Myofibroblast Transition and Drives Fibrosis

Systemic sclerosis (SSc) is a clinically heterogeneous fibrotic disease with no effective treatment. Myofibroblasts are responsible for unresolving synchronous skin and internal organ fibrosis in SSc, but the drivers of sustained myofibroblast activation remain poorly understood. Using unbiased transcriptome analysis of skin biopsies, we identified the downregulation of SPAG17 in multiple independent cohorts of patients with SSc, and by orthogonal approaches, we observed a significant negative correlation between SPAG17 and fibrotic gene expression. Fibroblasts and endothelial cells explanted from SSc skin biopsies showed reduced chromatin accessibility at the SPAG17 locus. Remarkably, mice lacking Spag17 showed spontaneous skin fibrosis with increased dermal thickness, collagen deposition and stiffness, and altered collagen fiber alignment. Knockdown of SPAG17 in human and mouse fibroblasts and microvascular endothelial cells was accompanied by spontaneous myofibroblast transformation and markedly heightened sensitivity to profibrotic stimuli. These responses were accompanied by constitutive TGF-β pathway activation. Thus, we discovered impaired expression of SPAG17 in SSc and identified, to our knowledge, a previously unreported cell-intrinsic role for SPAG17 in the negative regulation of fibrotic responses. These findings shed fresh light on the pathogenesis of SSc and may inform the search for innovative therapies for SSc and other fibrotic conditions through SPAG17 signaling.

Alterations of the Primary Cilia Gene SPAG17 and SOX9 Locus Noncoding RNAs Identified by RNA-Sequencing Analysis in Patients With Systemic Sclerosis

OBJECTIVE

Systemic sclerosis (SSc) is characterized by immune activation, vasculopathy, and unresolving fibrosis in the skin, lungs, and other organs. We performed RNA-sequencing analysis on skin biopsy samples and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from SSc patients and unaffected controls to better understand the pathogenesis of SSc.

METHODS

We analyzed these data 1) to test for case/control differences and 2) to identify genes whose expression levels correlate with SSc severity as measured by local skin score, modified Rodnan skin thickness score (MRSS), forced vital capacity (FVC), or diffusing capacity for carbon monoxide (DLco).

RESULTS

We found that PBMCs from SSc patients showed a strong type I interferon signature. This signal was found to be replicated in the skin, with additional signals for increased extracellular matrix (ECM) genes, classical complement pathway activation, and the presence of B cells. Notably, we observed a marked decrease in the expression of SPAG17, a cilia component, in SSc skin. We identified genes that correlated with the MRSS, DLco, and FVC in SSc PBMCs and skin using weighted gene coexpression network analysis. These genes were largely distinct from the case/control differentially expressed genes. In PBMCs, type I interferon signatures negatively correlated with the DLco. In SSc skin, ECM gene expression positively correlated with the MRSS. Network analysis of SSc skin genes that correlated with clinical features identified the noncoding RNAs SOX9-AS1 and ROCR, both near the SOX9 locus, as highly connected, "hub-like" genes in the network.

CONCLUSION

These results identify noncoding RNAs and SPAG17 as novel factors potentially implicated in the pathogenesis of SSc.

Quantifying cilia beat frequency using high-speed video microscopy: Assessing frame rate requirements when imaging different ciliated tissues

Motile cilia are found in numerous locations throughout our body and play a critical role in various physiological processes. The most commonly used method to assess cilia motility is to quantify cilia beat frequency (CBF) via video microscopy. However, a large heterogeneity exists within published literature regarding the framerate used to image cilia motility for calculating CBF. The aim of this study was to determine the optimal frame rate required to image cilia motility for CBF assessment, and if the Nyquist theorem may be used to set this rate. One‐second movies of cilia were collected at >600 fps from mouse airways and ependyma at room‐temperature or 37°C. Movies were then down‐sampled to 30–300 fps. CBF was quantified for identical cilia at different framerates by either manual counting or automated MATLAB script. Airway CBF was significantly impaired in 30 fps movies, while ependymal CBF was significantly impaired in both 60 and 30 fps movies. Pairwise comparison showed that video framerate should be at least 150 fps to accurately measure CBF, with minimal improvement in CBF accuracy in movies >150 fps. The automated script was also found to be less accurate for measuring CBF in lower fps movies than manual counting, however, this difference disappeared in higher framerate movies (>150 fps). In conclusion, our data suggest the Nyquist theorem is unreliable for setting sampling rate for CBF measurement. Instead, sampling rate should be 3–4 times faster than CBF for accurate CBF assessment. Especially if CBF calculation is to be automated.

Ccdc103 promotes myeloid cell proliferation and migration independent of motile cilia

The pathology of primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) is predominantly attributed to impairment of motile cilia. However, PCD patients also have perplexing functional defects in myeloid cells, which lack motile cilia. Here, we show that coiled-coil domain-containing protein 103 (CCDC103), one of the genes that, when mutated, is known to cause PCD, is required for the proliferation and directed migration of myeloid cells. CCDC103 is expressed in human myeloid cells, where it colocalizes with cytoplasmic microtubules. Zebrafish ccdc103/schmalhans (smh) mutants have macrophages and neutrophils with reduced proliferation, abnormally rounded cell morphology and an inability to migrate efficiently to the site of sterile wounds, all of which are consistent with a loss of cytoplasmic microtubule stability. Furthermore, we demonstrate that direct interactions between CCDC103 and sperm associated antigen 6 (SPAG6), which also promotes microtubule stability, are abrogated by CCDC103 mutations from PCD patients, and that spag6 zebrafish mutants recapitulate the myeloid defects observed in smh mutants. In summary, we have illuminated a mechanism, independent of motile cilia, to explain functional defects in myeloid cells from PCD patients. This article has an associated First Person interview with the first author of the paper.

Central Apparatus, the Molecular Kickstarter of Ciliary and Flagellar Nanomachines

Motile cilia and homologous organelles, the flagella, are an early evolutionarily invention, enabling primitive eukaryotic cells to survive and reproduce. In animals, cilia have undergone functional and structural speciation giving raise to typical motile cilia, motile nodal cilia, and sensory immotile cilia. In contrast to other cilia types, typical motile cilia are able to beat in complex, two-phase movements. Moreover, they contain many additional structures, including central apparatus, composed of two single microtubules connected by a bridge-like structure and assembling numerous complexes called projections. A growing body of evidence supports the important role of the central apparatus in the generation and regulation of the motile cilia movement. Here we review data concerning the central apparatus structure, protein composition, and the significance of its components in ciliary beating regulation.

First person – Zakia Abdelhamed

First Person is a series of interviews with the first authors of a selection of papers published in Disease Models & Mechanisms, helping early-career researchers promote themselves alongside their papers. Zakia Abdelhamed is first author on ‘A novel hypomorphic allele of Spag17 causes primary ciliary dyskinesia phenotypes in mice’, published in DMM. Zakia is a research associate in the lab of Dr Rolf Stottmann at Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH, USA, investigating animal models that recapitulate a human condition for understanding disease pathogenesis.