Effects of obesity and foot arch height on gait mechanics: A cross-sectional study

Effects of overweight and obesity on lower limb walking characteristics from joint kinematics to muscle activations

BACKGROUND

Obesity is a crucial factor that increases the risk of initiating and advancing knee osteoarthritis. However, it remains unclear how obesity directly impacts the biomechanical experience of the lower limb joints, potentially triggering or exacerbating joint degeneration. This study investigated the interactive effects of BMI augmentation on lower limb kinematics, kinetics, and muscle activations during walking.

METHODOLOGY

A group of 60 participants underwent a three-dimensional gait analysis. These individuals were categorized into three groups based on their body mass index (BMI): those with a BMI below 25 were classified as having a healthy weight, those with a BMI between 25 and 30 were categorized as overweight, and those with a BMI exceeding 30 were considered obese. This study analyzed the gait of 60 participants categorized by BMI. During walking trials, they recorded ground reaction forces electromyography of leg muscles like the gastrocnemii, hamstrings, and quadriceps. Lower limb joint angles and net moments were also calculated. Statistical mapping identified variations in kinematic, kinetic, and muscle activation patterns across the stance phase between BMI groups.

RESULTS

The results displayed distinct biomechanical patterns in obese individuals. Notably, there was a significant increase in flexion observed in the hip and knee joints (P < 0.001) during the initial stance phase and an increase in hip and knee adduction angles and moments throughout the entire stance phase (P < 0.001). Additionally, muscle activations underwent significant changes (P < 0.01), with a positive correlation noted with the BMI factor. This correlation was most pronounced during the early stance phase for the quadriceps and hamstring muscles and the late stance phase for the gastrocnemius.

CONCLUSION

These findings represent a comprehensive picture that contributes to understanding how excess weight and obesity influence joint biomechanics, highlighting the associated risk of joint osteoarthritis.

Effect of patient specificity on predicting knee cartilage degeneration in obese adults: Musculoskeletal finite-element modeling of data from the CAROT trial

Obesity is a known risk factor for development of osteoarthritis (OA). Numerical tools like finite-element (FE) models combined with degenerative algorithms have been developed to understand the interplay between OA and obesity. In this study, we aimed to predict knee cartilage degeneration in a cohort of obese adults to investigate the importance of patient-specific information on degeneration predictions. We used a validated FE modeling approach and three different age-dependent functions (step-wise, exponential, and linear) to simulate cartilage degradation under overloading in the knee joint. Gait motion analysis and magnetic resonance imaging data from 115 obese individuals with knee OA were used for musculoskeletal and FE modeling. Cartilage degeneration predictions were contrasted with Kellgren-Lawrence (KL) and Boston-Leeds Osteoarthritis Knee Score (BLOKS) grades. The findings show that overall, the similarities between numerical predictions and clinical measures were better for the medial (average area under the curve (AUC) = 0.62) compared to the lateral compartment (average AUC = 0.52) of the knee. Classification results for KL grades, full patient-specific models and patient-specific geometry with generic gait data showed higher AUC values (AUC = 0.71 and AUC = 0.68, respectively) compared to generic geometry and patient-specific gait (AUC = 0.48). For BLOKS grades, AUC values for both full patient-specific models and for patient-specific geometry with generic gait locomotion were higher (AUC  = 0.66 and AUC = 0.64, respectively) compared to when the generic geometry and patient-specific gait were used (AUC = 0.53). In summary, our study highlights the importance of considering individual information in knee OA prediction. Nevertheless, our findings suggest that personalized gait play a smaller role in the OA prediction and classification capacity than personalized joint geometry.

Center of mass motion and plantar pressure distribution during walking in overweight individuals

BACKGROUND

Gait imbalance has been reported in overweight individuals and could further impair their mobility and quality of life. As the feet are the most distal part of the body and sensitively interface with external surroundings, evaluating the plantar pressure distribution can provide critical insights into their roles in regulating gait balance control. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of body weight and different gait speeds on the plantar pressure distribution and whole-body center of mass (COM) motion during walking.

METHODS

Eleven overweight individuals (OB) and 13 non-overweight individuals (NB) walked on a 10-meter walkway at three speed conditions (preferred, 80% and 120% of preferred speed). Gait balance was quantified by the mediolateral COM sway. Plantar pressure data were obtained using wireless pressure-sensing insoles that were inserted into a pair of running shoes. Analysis of variance models were used to examine the effect of body size, gait speeds, or their interactions on peak mediolateral COM and peak plantar pressure during walking.

RESULTS

Significant group effects of peak plantar pressure under the lateral forefoot (P = 0.03), lateral midfoot (P = 0.02), and medial heel (P = 0.02) were observed. However, the mediolateral COM motion and spatiotemporal gait parameters only revealed significant speed effects.

SIGNIFICANCE

Findings from this study indicated that overweight individuals exhibited increased plantar pressure under the lateral aspect of the foot, particularly during the late stance phase of walking, in an effort to maintain a comparable mediolateral COM motion to that of non-overweight individuals. Such elevated pressure in overweight individuals may potentially increase the risk of musculoskeletal pathology in the long term. The identified patterns are noteworthy as they have practical implications for designing targeted interventions and improving the overall health of individuals with a high BMI.

Tibiofemoral Load Magnitude and Distribution During Load Carriage

Chronic exposure to high tibiofemoral joint (TFJ) contact forces can be detrimental to knee joint health. Load carriage increases TFJ contact forces, but it is unclear whether medial and lateral tibiofemoral compartments respond similarly to incremental load carriage. The purpose of our study was to compare TFJ contact forces when walking with 15% and 30% added body weight. Young healthy adults (n = 24) walked for 5 minutes with no load, 15% load, and 30% load on an instrumented treadmill. Total, medial, and lateral TFJ contact peak forces and impulses were calculated via an inverse dynamics informed musculoskeletal model. Results of 1-way repeated measures analyses of variance (α = .05) demonstrated total, medial, and lateral TFJ first peak contact forces and impulses increased significantly with increasing load. Orthogonal polynomial trends demonstrated that the 30% loading condition led to a curvilinear increase in total and lateral TFJ impulses, whereas medial first peak TFJ contact forces and impulses responded linearly to increasing load. The total and lateral compartment impulse increased disproportionally with load carriage, while the medial did not. The medial and lateral compartments responded differently to increasing load during walking, warranting further investigation because it may relate to risk of osteoarthritis.

Numerical Simulation of the Effect of Different Footwear Midsole Structures on Plantar Pressure Distribution and Bone Stress in Obese and Healthy Children

The foot, as the foundation of the human body, bears the vast majority of the body's weight. Obese children bear more weight than healthy children in the process of walking and running. This study compared three footwear midsole structures (solid, lattice, and chiral) based on plantar pressure distribution and bone stress in obese and healthy children through numerical simulation. The preparation for the study included obtaining a thin-slice CT scan of a healthy 9-year-old boy's right foot, and this study distinguished between a healthy and an obese child by applying external loadings of 25 kg and 50 kg in the finite element models. The simulation results showed that the plantar pressure was mainly concentrated in the forefoot and heel due to the distribution of gravity (first metatarsal, fourth metatarsal, and heel bone, corresponding to plantar regions M1, M4, and HM and HL) on the foot in normal standing. Compared with the lattice and solid EVA structures, in both healthy and obese children, the percentage reduction in plantar pressure due to the chiral structure in the areas M1, M4, HM, and HL was the largest with values of 38.69%, 34.25%, 64.24%, and 54.03% for an obese child and 33.99%, 28.25%, 56.08%, and 56.96% for a healthy child. On the other hand, higher pressures (15.19 kPa for an obese child and 5.42 kPa for a healthy child) were observed in the MF area when using the chiral structure than when using the other two structures, which means that this structure can transfer an amount of pressure from the heel to the arch, resulting in a release in the pressure at the heel region and providing support at the arch. In addition, the study found that the chiral structure was not highly sensitive to the external application of body weight. This indicates that the chiral structure is more stable than the other two structures and is minimally affected by changes in external conditions. The findings in this research lay the groundwork for clinical prevention and intervention in foot disorders in obese children and provide new research ideas for shoe midsole manufacturers.

A Systematic Review of the Influence of Overweight and Obesity across the Lifespan on Obstacle Crossing during Walking

This study aimed to systematically review and summarize the available data regarding the influence of overweight and obesity across the lifespan on obstacle crossing during walking. Four databases were systematically searched with no limitation on publication date following the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews and PRISMA guidelines. Only full-text English-language articles published in a peer-reviewed journal were eligible. They had to compare obstacle crossing during walking by overweight or obese individuals with individuals of normal body weight. Five studies were considered eligible. All the studies assessed kinematics; only one assessed kinetics, but none investigated muscle activity or obstacle contact. Compared to normal individuals crossing obstacles, overweight or obese individuals exhibited lower velocity, shorter step length, lower cadence, and less time spent in single-limb support. They also exhibited increased step width, more time spent in double support, and greater trailing leg ground force reaction and centre of mass acceleration. Overall, the small number of included studies did not allow us to draw any conclusions. However, being overweight or obese seems to have a potentially negative influence on the kinematics of gait parameters due to a tendency to trip, fall, and suffer severe fall-related injuries when negotiating obstacles on foot in real-life environments.

Technological Solutions for Human Movement Analysis in Obese Subjects: A Systematic Review

Obesity has a critical impact on musculoskeletal systems, and excessive weight directly affects the ability of subjects to realize movements. It is important to monitor the activities of obese subjects, their functional limitations, and the overall risks related to specific motor tasks. From this perspective, this systematic review identified and summarized the main technologies specifically used to acquire and quantify movements in scientific studies involving obese subjects. The search for articles was carried out on electronic databases, i.e., PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. We included observational studies performed on adult obese subjects whenever reporting quantitative information concerning their movement. The articles must have been written in English, published after 2010, and concerned subjects who were primarily diagnosed with obesity, thus excluding confounding diseases. Marker-based optoelectronic stereophotogrammetric systems resulted to be the most adopted solution for movement analysis focused on obesity; indeed, wearable technologies based on magneto-inertial measurement units (MIMUs) were recently adopted for analyzing obese subjects. Further, these systems are usually integrated with force platforms, so as to have information about the ground reaction forces. However, few studies specifically reported the reliability and limitations of these approaches due to soft tissue artifacts and crosstalk, which turned out to be the most relevant problems to deal with in this context. In this perspective, in spite of their inherent limitations, medical imaging techniques-such as Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) and biplane radiography-should be used to improve the accuracy of biomechanical evaluations in obese people, and to systematically validate less-invasive approaches.

Exploring the impact of body mass change on fatigue and activity of the muscular system during daily routine

BACKGROUND

Correct body weight is one of the factors that allows you to maintain a properly functioning body. Abnormal body weight can cause muscle tissue remodelling, affecting activity and muscle fatigue. Changes in the muscular system can cause occurrence of functional limitations.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effect of weight change on fatigue and activity of the muscular system during daily activities.

METHODS

The evaluation of musculoskeletal functioning was based on the results of computer simulations conducted in the AnyBody Modeling System. The following activities were analysed: standing, sitting down and getting up from a chair, holding and lifting an object, and walking. The simulations of the activities were carried out using averaged kinematic data, and by changing body mass in the range of 50 kg to 100 kg by increments of 2 kg, to map different nutritional status from excessive thinness to extreme obesity. Identification of loads in the musculoskeletal system was based on solving an inverse dynamics problem and then the estimation of muscle force values using static optimization. The simulation results allowed to determine the value of muscle fatigue and the level of muscle activity.

RESULTS

For activities (i.e., standing, walking, sitting down and getting up from a chair) it was observed that the value of muscle fatigue increases with increasing body mass. However, for activities that cause more load on the musculoskeletal system, i.e. lifting and holding an object, the highest value of muscle fatigue was observed in underweight individuals.

CONCLUSION

The change in body weight alters the functioning of the muscular system and thus the ability to perform activities. It was shown that in case of underweight, overweight or obese people, abnormal body weight can be the reason for occurrence of difficulties in performing the activities of lifting and holding a 20 kg object, as well as walking.

Changes in dynamic balance control in adults with obesity across walking speeds

Adults with obesity have gait instability, leading to increased fall risks and decreased physical activity. Whole-body angular momentum (WBAM) is regulated over a gait cycle, essential to avoid a fall. However, how obese adults regulate WBAM during walking is unknown. The current study investigated changes in WBAM about the body's center of mass (COM) during walking in obese and non-obese adults across different walking speeds. Twenty-eight young adults with obesity and normal weight walked barefoot at a fixed walking speed (FWS, 1.25 m/s) and at five different speeds based on their preferred walking speed (PWS): 50, 75, 100, 125, and 150 % of PWS. Adults with obesity walked slower with shorter step length, wider step width, and longer double support time (p < 0.01). The ranges of frontal- and transverse-plane WBAM were greater in obese adults (p < 0.01). We also found that the range of frontal-plane WBAM did not significantly change with walking speed (p > 0.05), while the range of transverse-plane WBAM increased with walking speed (p < 0.01). The ranges of frontal- and transverse-plane WBAM increased with the mediolateral ground reaction force and mediolateral moment arm (p < 0.01), which may be most affected by lateral foot placement relative to the body's COM. Our findings suggest that controlling mediolateral stability during walking is more challenging in obese adults, independent of their slow walking speed. Understanding whole-body rotational dynamics observed in obese walking provides an insight into the biomechanical link between obesity and gait instability, which may help find a way to reduce fall risks and increase physical activity.

The Effects of Overweight and Obesity on Obstacle Crossing During Walking: Protocol for a Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Overweight and obesity are significant global health concerns that involve deficits in gait and balance that affect daily activities. Although much is reported about the effect of overweight and obesity on gait during unobstructed walking, not much is known about how overweight and obesity could impact gait under more challenging conditions, such as environments with obstacles.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to systematically review and synthesize the available data regarding the effects of overweight and obesity on obstacle crossing during walking.

METHODS

This review will follow the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses) guidelines. PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus, and SPORTDiscus will be systematically searched with no limitations on publication date. Only full-text English-language articles published in a peer-reviewed journal will be included. Included articles must have compared obstacle crossing during walking in individuals with overweight or obesity to individuals of normal body weight. A total of 2 independent reviewers will select the articles and extract the following 4 sets of data: (1) study characteristics, (2) sample description, (3) obstacle crossing task protocol, and (4) main results obtained. If a considerable number of homogeneous papers are included, a meta-analysis will be conducted. A preliminary search was conducted in November 2021.

RESULTS

The results will include the article selection flowchart as well as tables and figures synthesizing the extracted data on the effects of overweight and obesity on obstacle crossing during walking. The preliminary search identified 73 original records, of which 5 articles met the inclusion criteria.

CONCLUSIONS

This review will present researchers and clinicians with an overview of published studies that have compared the performance of obstacle crossing for individuals with overweight and obesity to those of normal body weight. Gaining insight into the control strategies adopted by individuals with overweight and obesity is critical for safe and successful obstacle crossing in this population. We therefore believe that our findings could be useful for identifying people at risk of falls and developing and implementing fall prevention programs for individuals with overweight and obesity.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

PROSPERO CRD42021269949; https://tinyurl.com/3yrwccu4.

INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID)

DERR1-10.2196/36234.

The effect of obesity on whole-body angular momentum during steady-state walking

BACKGROUND

Individuals with obesity demonstrate deficits in postural stability, leading to increased fall risks. Controlling whole-body angular momentum is essential for maintaining postural stability during walking and preventing falls. However, it is unknown how obesity impacts whole-body angular momentum during walking.

RESEARCH PURPOSE

To investigate the change in angular momentum about the body's COM during walking in individuals with different degrees of obesity.

METHODS

Thirty-eight young adults with different body mass index (BMI) scores walked barefoot at their preferred speed on a treadmill for 2 min. The whole-body angular momentum has been quantified from ground reaction force and moment data to capture the rotational behavior of walking in individuals with obesity without relying solely on placing markers on anatomical landmarks.

RESULTS

We found that adults with higher BMI scores walked slower with shorter step length, wider step width, and longer double support time (ps<.01). Ranges of the frontal- and transverse-plane angular momentum were greater in adults with higher BMI scores (ps<.01), while no difference was observed between BMI groups in the total sum of changes in whole-body angular momentum in any plane (ps>.05).

SIGNIFICANCE

Obesity not only decreased walking speed but also limited the ability to control mediolateral stability during walking. Investigating how obesity affects whole-body angular momentum may help better understand why adults with obesity have atypical gait with poor balance, address fall risk factors, and facilitate participation in physical activities.