DNA ligase-based strategy for quantifying heterogeneous DNA methylation without sequencing

Precise Differentiation of Wobble-Type Allele via Ratiometric Design of a Ligase Chain Reaction-Based Electrochemical Biosensor for CYP2C19*2 Genotyping of Clinical Samples

Due to the comparable stability between the perfect-base pair and the wobble-base pair, a precise differentiation of the wobble-type allele has remained a challenge, often leading to false results. Herein, we proposed a ligase chain reaction (LCR)-based ratiometric electrochemical DNA sensor, namely, R-eLCR, for a precise typing of the wobble-type allele, in which the traditionally recognized "negative" signal of wobble-base pair-mediated amplification was fully utilized as a "positive" one and a ratiometric readout mode was employed to ameliorated the underlying potential external influence and improved its detection accuracy in the typing of the wobble-type allele. The results showed that the ratio between current of methylene blue (IMB) and current of ferrocene (IFc) was partitioned in three regions and three types of wobble-type allele were thus precisely differentiated (AA homozygote: IMB/IFc > 2; GG homozygote: IMB/IFc < 1; GA heterozygote: 1 < IMB/IFc < 2); the proposed R-eLCR successfully discriminated the three types of CYP2C19*2 allele in nine cases of human whole blood samples, which was consistent with those of the sequencing method. These results evidence that the proposed R-eLCR can serve as an accurate and robust alternative for the identification of wobble-type allele, which lays a solid foundation and holds great potential for precision medicine.

Electrochemical biosensing to move forward in cancer epigenetics and metastasis: A review

Early detection and effective treatment are crucial to reduce the physical, emotional, and financial pressure exerted by growing cancer burden on individuals, families, communities, and health systems. Currently, it is clear that the accurate analysis of emerging cancer epigenetic and metastatic-related biomarkers at different molecular levels is envisaged as an exceptional solution for early and reliable diagnosis and the improvement of therapy efficiency through personalized treatments. Within this field, electrochemical biosensing has demonstrated to be competitive over other emerging and currently used methodologies for the determination of these biomarkers accomplishing the premises of user-friendly, multiplexing ability, simplicity, reduced costs and decentralized analysis, demanded by clinical oncology, thus priming electrochemical biosensors to spark a diagnostic revolution for cancer prediction and eradication. This review article critically discusses the main characteristics, opportunities and versatility exhibited by electrochemical biosensing, through highlighting representative examples published during the last two years, for the reliable determination of these emerging biomarkers, with great diagnostic, predictive and prognostic potential. Special attention is paid on electrochemical affinity biosensors developed for the single or multiplexed determination of methylation events, non-coding RNAs, ctDNA features and metastasis-related protein biomarkers both in liquid and solid biopsies of cancer patients. The main challenges to which further work must be addressed and the impact of these advances should have in the clinical acceptance of these emerging biomarkers are also discussed which decisively will contribute to understand the molecular basis involved in the epigenetics and metastasis of cancer and to apply more efficient personalized therapies.

Ultra-low level detection of hepatocellular carcinoma global methylation using a AuNP modified carbon fiber microelectrode

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is one of the most common cancerous diseases, with a low 5 year survival rate. Global hypomethylation drives genomic instability, which is regarded as one biomarker for early diagnosis. Long interspersed nucleotide element-1 (LINE-1) makes up around 17% of the genome, and could be regarded as a surrogate marker for global DNA methylation. In this work, a gold nanoparticle (AuNP) modified carbon fiber microelectrode (CFME) with a diameter of 7 μm was applied for the first time to detect the methylation level of LINE-1, by distinguishing adsorption affinities between different DNA bases and AuNPs. Several parameters, including AuNP electrodeposition time, sample adsorption time, and DNA concentration have been analyzed and optimized. The detection limit of our assay was 0.1 nM with only 2 μL sample solution. And the CFME had an excellent sensitivity of 10% methylation change and had the capacity to distinguish only one methylated CpG site. The global DNA methylation level of real samples including cell lines and clinical tissues was tested. Higher signals of HCC cell lines and cancer tissues were observed respectively, compared with normal hepatic cell lines and normal tissues. This work provides a promising approach for HCC early diagnosis and prognosis.

Using a AuNP modified carbon fiber microelectrode to detect hepatocellular carcinoma global methylation with an ultra-low concentration of DNA samples.

DNA Methylation-Based Point-of-Care Cancer Detection: Challenges and Possibilities

Eukaryotic cell DNA conserves a distinct genomic methylation pattern, which acts as a molecular switch to control the transcriptional machinery of the cell. However, pathological processes can alter this methylation pattern, leading to the onset of diseases such as cancer. Recent advances in methylation analysis provide a more precise understanding of the consequence of DNA methylation changes towards cancer progression. Consequently, the discoveries of numerous methylation-based biomarkers have inspired the development of simple tests for cancer detection. In this opinion article, we systematically discuss the benefits and challenges associated with the promising methylation-based approaches and develop a point-of-care index to evaluate their potential in terms of point-of-care cancer diagnostics.

Detection of KRAS mutation via ligation-initiated LAMP reaction

KRAS mutations are abnormalities widely found in genomic DNA and circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) of various types of cancers. Thus, highly sensitive detection of KRAS mutations in genomic DNA is of great significance in disease diagnosis and personalized medicine. Here, we developed a ligation-initiated loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assaying method for ultrasensitive detection of KRAS mutation. In the presence of mutant KRAS DNA (mutDNA), the dumbbell-shaped structure (DSS) is formed by the specific ligation of two substrates (SLS1 and SLS2), which act as a template to initiate the following LAMP amplification. Making use of the outstanding specificity of ligation reaction and superior amplification of LAMP, 10 aM mutDNA can be accurately determined. In addition, as low as 0.1% mutDNA can be detected in the presence of a large excess of wild-type KRAS DNA (wtDNA), indicating the high sensitivity and specificity of the method. Furthermore, this strategy has been successfully applied for detection of a KRAS mutation from tissue samples of colorectal cancer patients. Thus, the developed ligation-initiated LAMP fluorescence assaying strategy presents a promising prospect for ultrasensitive detection of mutations.

Improved locus-specific unmethylated controls for MS-HRM analysis derived from 5-aza-2-deoxycytidine-treated DNA

We report two restriction enzyme-based approaches for generating clean locus-specific unmethylated controls for methylation-sensitive high-resolution melting (MS-HRM) analyses. These unmethylated standards are derived from DNA treated with the demethylating agent 5-aza-2-deoxycytidine (5-Aza-dc). By using them, we overcome a limitation of 5-Aza-dc treatment – incomplete demethylation at various genomic regions. When 5-Aza-dc-treated DNA is used directly as unmethylated MS-HRM standard, partially demethylated DNA can give false methylation results. MS-HRM assay differentiates between methylated and unmethylated bisulfite-treated DNA based on the different melting profiles of PCR products amplified from them. To estimate test sample methylation levels, test sample melting profiles are compared to those of methylation standards. With our pure unmethylated controls, adequate standards of known methylation levels can be prepared for single-locus MS-HRM.

Electrochemical Biosensor for DNA Methylation Detection through Hybridization Chain-Amplified Reaction Coupled with a Tetrahedral DNA Nanostructure

DNA methylation is a key factor in the pathogenesis of gene expression diseases or malignancies. Thus, it has become a significant biomarker for the diagnosis and prognosis of these diseases. In this paper, we designed an ultrasensitive and specific electrochemical biosensor for DNA methylation detection. The platform consisted of stem-loop-tetrahedron composite DNA probes anchoring at a Au nanoparticle-coated gold electrode, a restriction enzyme digestion of HpaII, and signal amplification procedures including electrodeposition of Au nanoparticles, hybridization chain reaction, and horseradish peroxidase enzymatic catalysis. Under optimal conditions, the design showed a broad dynamic range from 1 aM to 1 pM and a detection limit of about 0.93 aM. The approach also showed ideal specificity, repeatability, and stability. The recovery test demonstrated that the design is a promising platform for DNA methylation detection under clinical circumstances and could meet the need for cancer diagnosis.

Identification and Quantification of Heterogeneously-methylated DNA Fragments Using Epiallele-sensitive Droplet Digital Polymerase Chain Reaction (EAST-ddPCR)

BACKGROUND/AIM

DNA methylation plays an important role in the initiation and propagation of carcinogenesis; however, the role of heterogeneously methylated epialleles is currently not well studied, also due to the lack of sensitive, unbiased and high throughput methods. Here, a newly developed droplet digital PCR (ddPCR)-based method was evaluated regarding its ability to quantify such heterogeneously methylated epialleles with sufficient analytical sensitivity and specificity.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Genomic DNA from blood leukocytes and bone marrow aspirate of an 8-year old male with B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (B-ALL) and from normal and malignant prostate cell lines were analysed using ddPCR.

RESULTS

By using these DNA samples, the specificity of an applied set of fluorescence-labeled probes was demonstrated as a proof of concept.

CONCLUSION

All individual heterogeneously-methylated epialleles were quantifiable by a set of fluorescence-labeled probes with complementary sequences to epialleles in a closed-tube and high-throughput manner. The new method named epiallele-sensitive droplet digital PCR (EAST-ddPCR) may give new insights in the generation and regulation of epialleles and may help in finding new biomarkers for the diagnosis of benign und malignant diseases.

Quantification of gene-specific DNA methylation in oesophageal cancer via electrochemistry

Development of simple and inexpensive method for the analysis of gene-specific DNA methylation is important for the diagnosis and prognosis of patients with cancer. Herein, we report a relatively simple and inexpensive electrochemical method for the sensitive and selective detection of gene-specific DNA methylation in oesophageal cancer. The underlying principle of the method relies on the affinity interaction between DNA bases and unmodified gold electrode. Since the affinity trend of DNA bases towards the gold surface follows as adenine (A) > cytosine (C) > guanine (G)> thymine (T), a relatively larger amount of bisulfite-treated adenine-enriched unmethylated DNA adsorbs on the screen-printed gold electrodes (SPE-Au) in comparison to the guanine-enriched methylated sample. The methylation levels were (i.e., different level of surface attached DNA molecules due to the base dependent differential adsorption pattern) quantified by measuring saturated amount of charge-compensating [Ru(NH₃)₆]³⁺ molecules in the surface-attached DNAs by chronocoulometry as redox charge of the [Ru(NH₃)₆]³⁺ molecules quantitatively reflects the amount of the adsorbed DNA confined at the electrode surface. The assay could successfully distinguish methylated and unmethylated DNA sequences at single CpG resolution and as low as 10% differences in DNA methylation. In addition, the assay showed fairly good reproducibility (% RSD= <5%) with better sensitivity and specificity by analysing various levels of methylation in two cell lines and eight fresh tissues samples from patients with oesophageal squamous cell carcinoma. Finally, the method was validated with methylation specific-high resolution melting curve analysis and Sanger sequencing methods.

Electrochemical biosensing strategies for DNA methylation analysis

DNA methylation is one of the key epigenetic modifications of DNA that results from the enzymatic addition of a methyl group at the fifth carbon of the cytosine base. It plays a crucial role in cellular development, genomic stability and gene expression. Aberrant DNA methylation is responsible for the pathogenesis of many diseases including cancers. Over the past several decades, many methodologies have been developed to detect DNA methylation. These methodologies range from classical molecular biology and optical approaches, such as bisulfite sequencing, microarrays, quantitative real-time PCR, colorimetry, Raman spectroscopy to the more recent electrochemical approaches. Among these, electrochemical approaches offer sensitive, simple, specific, rapid, and cost-effective analysis of DNA methylation. Additionally, electrochemical methods are highly amenable to miniaturization and possess the potential to be multiplexed. In recent years, several reviews have provided information on the detection strategies of DNA methylation. However, to date, there is no comprehensive evaluation of electrochemical DNA methylation detection strategies. Herein, we address the recent developments of electrochemical DNA methylation detection approaches. Furthermore, we highlight the major technical and biological challenges involved in these strategies and provide suggestions for the future direction of this important field.

A multiplex microplatform for the detection of multiple DNA methylation events using gold–DNA affinity

We report a new multiplexed strategy for the electrochemical detection of regional DNA methylation across multiple regions.

Tracking the evolution of epialleles during neural differentiation and brain development: D-Aspartate oxidase as a model gene

We performed ultra-deep methylation analysis at single molecule level of the promoter region of developmentally regulated D-Aspartate oxidase (Ddo), as a model gene, during brain development and embryonic stem cell neural differentiation. Single molecule methylation analysis enabled us to establish the effective epiallele composition within mixed or pure brain cell populations. In this framework, an epiallele is defined as a specific combination of methylated CpG within Ddo locus and can represent the epigenetic haplotype revealing a cell-to-cell methylation heterogeneity. Using this approach, we found a high degree of polymorphism of methylated alleles (epipolymorphism) evolving in a remarkably conserved fashion during brain development. The different sets of epialleles mark stage, brain areas, and cell type and unravel the possible role of specific CpGs in favoring or inhibiting local methylation. Undifferentiated embryonic stem cells showed non-organized distribution of epialleles that apparently originated by stochastic methylation events on individual CpGs. Upon neural differentiation, despite detecting no changes in average methylation, we observed that the epiallele distribution was profoundly different, gradually shifting toward organized patterns specific to the glial or neuronal cell types. Our findings provide a deep view of gene methylation heterogeneity in brain cell populations promising to furnish innovative ways to unravel mechanisms underlying methylation patterns generation and alteration in brain diseases.

Detection of regional DNA methylation using DNA-graphene affinity interactions

We report a new method for the detection of regional DNA methylation using base-dependent affinity interaction (i.e., adsorption) of DNA with graphene. Due to the strongest adsorption affinity of guanine bases towards graphene, bisulfite-treated guanine-enriched methylated DNA leads to a larger amount of the adsorbed DNA on the graphene-modified electrodes in comparison to the adenine-enriched unmethylated DNA. The level of the methylation is quantified by monitoring the differential pulse voltammetric current as a function of the adsorbed DNA. The assay is sensitive to distinguish methylated and unmethylated DNA sequences at single CpG resolution by differentiating changes in DNA methylation as low as 5%. Furthermore, this method has been used to detect methylation levels in a collection of DNA samples taken from oesophageal cancer tissues.

MethPat: a tool for the analysis and visualisation of complex methylation patterns obtained by massively parallel sequencing

BACKGROUND

DNA methylation at a gene promoter region has the potential to regulate gene transcription. Patterns of methylation over multiple CpG sites in a region are often complex and cell type specific, with the region showing multiple allelic patterns in a sample. This complexity is commonly obscured when DNA methylation data is summarised as an average percentage value for each CpG site (or aggregated across CpG sites). True representation of methylation patterns can only be fully characterised by clonal analysis. Deep sequencing provides the ability to investigate clonal DNA methylation patterns in unprecedented detail and scale, enabling the proper characterisation of the heterogeneity of methylation patterns. However, the sheer amount and complexity of sequencing data requires new synoptic approaches to visualise the distribution of allelic patterns.

RESULTS

We have developed a new analysis and visualisation software tool "Methpat", that extracts and displays clonal DNA methylation patterns from massively parallel sequencing data aligned using Bismark. Methpat was used to analyse multiplex bisulfite amplicon sequencing on a range of CpG island targets across a panel of human cell lines and primary tissues. Methpat was able to represent the clonal diversity of epialleles analysed at specific gene promoter regions. We also used Methpat to describe epiallelic DNA methylation within the mitochondrial genome.

CONCLUSIONS

Methpat can summarise and visualise epiallelic DNA methylation results from targeted amplicon, massively parallel sequencing of bisulfite converted DNA in a compact and interpretable format. Unlike currently available tools, Methpat can visualise the diversity of epiallelic DNA methylation patterns in a sample.

Colorimetric detection of both total genomic and loci-specific DNA methylation from limited DNA inputs

BACKGROUND

Aberrant DNA methylation marks are potential disease biomarkers, and detecting both total genomic and gene-specific DNA methylation can aid in clinical decisions. While a plethora of methods exist in research, simpler, more convenient alternatives are needed to enhance both routine diagnostics and research.

RESULTS

Herein, we describe colorimetric assays using methyl-binding domain (MBD) proteins for rapid and convenient evaluation of total genomic and gene-specific methylation from 50 ng or less DNA input in under 2 h. As little as 5 % methylation differences can be detected and are enhanced by a novel MBD protocol for improved specificity. Our assays could differentiate naïve from de-methylating drug-treated cells and detect the presence of a methylated prostate cancer biomarker in the urine. Finally, the assay was evolved onto disposable screen-printed electrodes for convenient detection of gene-specific methylation in urine.

CONCLUSIONS

Rapid MBD-based colorimetric and electrochemical approaches to detect DNA methylation from limited samples were successfully demonstrated and applied to clinical samples. We envision that the ease, low sample requirements and speed of these assays could have both clinical and research-wide applications.

Highly sensitive DNA methylation analysis at CpG resolution by surface-enhanced Raman scattering via ligase chain reaction

Highly sensitive DNA methylation analysis at CpG resolution is demonstrated by employing SERS nanotags via ligase chain reaction (LCR) and validated with sequencing.

Quantitative methodology is critical for assessing DNA methylation and impacts on correlation with patient outcome

BACKGROUND

DNA hypermethylation is reported as a frequent event and prognostic marker in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (HNSCC). Methylation has been commonly assessed with non-quantitative methodologies, such as methylation-specific PCR (MSP). We investigated previously reported hypermethylated genes with quantitative methodology in oral tongue squamous cell carcinomas (OTSCC).

RESULTS

The methylation status of 12 genes in 115 OTSCC samples was assessed by one or more of three quantitative analyses: methylation sensitive high resolution melting (MS-HRM), sensitive-melting analysis after real time-methylation specific PCR (SMART-MSP), and bisulfite pyrosequencing. In contrast to much of the literature, either no or infrequent locus-specific methylation was identified by MS-HRM for DAPK1, RASSF1A, MGMT, MLH1, APC, CDH1, CDH13, BRCA1, ERCC1, and ATM. The most frequently methylated loci were RUNX3 (18/108 methylated) and ABO (22/107 methylated). Interrogation of the Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) HNSCC cohort confirmed the frequency of significant methylation for the loci investigated. Heterogeneous methylation of RUNX3 (18/108) and ABO (22/107) detected by MS-HRM, conferred significantly worse survival (P = 0.01, and P = 0.03). However, following quantification of methylation levels using pyrosequencing, only four tumors had significant quantities (>15%) of RUNX3 methylation which correlated with a worse patient outcome (P <0.001), while the prognostic significance of ABO hypermethylation was lost. RUNX3 methylation was not prognostic for the TCGA cohort (P = 0.76).

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated the critical need for quantification of methylation levels and its impact on correlative analyses. In OTSCC, we found little evidence of significant or frequent hypermethylation of many loci reported to be commonly methylated. It is likely that previous reports have overestimated the frequency of significant methylation events as a consequence of the use of non-quantitative methodology.