Pavlovian conditioning of CNS drug effects: a critical review and new experimental design

Temporal Factors Modulate Haloperidol-Induced Conditioned Catalepsy

Repeated pairings of a neutral context and the effects of haloperidol give rise to conditioned catalepsy when the context is subsequently presented in a drug-free test. In order to confirm whether this response is based on Pavlovian processes, we conducted two experiments involving two manipulations that affect conditioning intensity in classical conditioning procedures: time of joint exposure to the conditioned and the unconditioned stimulus, and the length of the inter-stimulus interval (ISI). The results revealed that both an increase in the length of context-drug pairings during conditioning and a reduced ISI between drug administration and context exposure increased conditioned catalepsy. These results are discussed in terms of the temporal peculiarities of those procedures that involve drugs as the unconditioned stimulus along with the role of Pavlovian conditioning in context-dependent catalepsy.

Morphine administered post-trial induces potent morphine conditioned effects if the context is novel but not if the context is familiar

Morphine administered shortly after exposure to a novel environment induces potent locomotor stimulant conditioning. Environmental novelty is important as pre-exposure (PE) to a stimulus can attenuate the capacity to acquire conditioned stimulus (CS). Here, the importance of environmental novelty for the efficacy of an open-field to become a CS for elicitation of a morphine conditioned response was assessed by comparing the effects of morphine administered post-trial following a 5 min exposure to a novel environment versus a PE environment. Four groups of rats (2 vehicle and 2 morphine groups) were used. Two groups received ten daily 5 min non-drug PEs to an open-field arena and the other two groups were not pre-exposed to the environment. Subsequently, all groups received post-trial injections of either vehicle or morphine immediately after each of five daily 5 min sessions in the open-field. Importantly, on the first day of testing prior to the first post-test morphine administration, the locomotor activity of the novel and PE groups was not different. Over the 5 post-trial morphine treatments, the activity of the PE morphine group, the PE vehicle and the novel environment vehicle groups did not change and were equivalent. In contrast, in the novel environment morphine group, a conditioned hyper-activity response increased with repeated post-trial morphine treatments. For the morphine group it is suggested that the novel environment initiated a post-trial stimulus trace that occurred in temporal contiguity with the post-trial drug response and enabled the trace to become a CS for the morphine unconditioned response. In contrast, PE induced a latent inhibition effect in the PE morphine group, thus the post-trial CS trace was insufficient to become associated to the morphine response and no conditioning occurred. In addition to conventional drug induced Pavlovian delay conditioning, the findings are suggestive of drug induced Pavlovian trace conditioning.

Conditioned increase of locomotor activity induced by haloperidol

Dopamine antagonist drugs have profound effects on locomotor activity. In particular, the administration of the D2 antagonist haloperidol produces a state that is similar to catalepsy. In order to confirm whether the modulation of the dopaminergic activity produced by haloperidol can act as an unconditioned stimulus, we carried out two experiments in which the administration of haloperidol was repeatedly paired with the presence of distinctive contextual cues that served as a Conditioned Stimulus. Paradoxically, the results revealed a dose-dependent increase in locomotor activity following conditioning with dopamine antagonist (Experiments 1) that was susceptible of extinction when the conditioned stimulus was presented repeatedly by itself after conditioning (Experiment 2). These data are interpreted from an associative perspective, considering them as a result of a classical conditioning process.

Effects of ketamine on the unconditioned and conditioned locomotor activity of preadolescent and adolescent rats: impact of age, sex, and drug dose

RATIONALE

Ketamine is used by preadolescent and adolescent humans for licit and illicit purposes.

OBJECTIVE

The goal of the present study was to determine the effects of acute and repeated ketamine treatment on the unconditioned behaviors and conditioned locomotor activity of preadolescent and adolescent rats.

METHODS

To assess unconditioned behaviors, female and male rats were injected with ketamine (5-40 mg/kg), and distance traveled was measured on postnatal day (PD) 21-25 or PD 41-45. To assess conditioned activity, male and female rats were injected with saline or ketamine in either a novel test chamber or the home cage on PD 21-24 or PD 41-44. One day later, rats were injected with saline and conditioned activity was assessed.

RESULTS

Ketamine produced a dose-dependent increase in the locomotor activity of preadolescent and adolescent rats. Preadolescent rats did not exhibit sex differences, but ketamine-induced locomotor activity was substantially stronger in adolescent females than males. Repeated ketamine treatment neither caused a day-dependent increase in locomotor activity nor produced conditioned activity in preadolescent or adolescent rats.

CONCLUSIONS

The activity-enhancing effects of ketamine are consistent with the actions of an indirect dopamine agonist, while the inability of ketamine to induce conditioned activity is unlike what is observed after repeated cocaine or amphetamine treatment. This dichotomy could be due to ketamine's ability to both enhance DA neurotransmission and antagonize N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors. Additional research will be necessary to parse out the relative contributions of DA and NMDA system functioning when assessing the behavioral effects of ketamine during early ontogeny.

Age-dependent differences in the strength and persistence of psychostimulant-induced conditioned activity in rats: effects of a single environment-cocaine pairing

The aim of the present study was to determine the strength and persistence of cocaine-induced conditioned activity in young and adult rats. A one-trial protocol has proven useful for studying the ontogeny of psychostimulant-induced behavioral sensitization; therefore, a similar procedure was used to examine conditioned activity. On postnatal day (PD) 19 or PD 80, rats were injected with saline or cocaine in either a novel test chamber or the home cage. After various drug abstinence intervals (1-21 days), rats were injected with saline and returned to the test chamber, where conditioned activity was assessed. In a separate experiment, we examined whether cocaine-induced conditioned activity was a consequence of Pavlovian conditioning or a failure to habituate to the test environment. The results indicated that adult rats showed strong one-trial conditioned activity that persisted for at least 21 days, whereas young rats did not show a conditioned locomotor response. The conditioned activity shown by adult rats did not result from a failure to habituate to the cocaine-paired environment. These results indicate that cocaine-paired contextual stimuli differentially affect behavior depending on the age of the animal. The data obtained from adult rats have potential translational relevance for humans because a single environment-drug pairing caused long-term alterations in behavior.

Cocaine-conditioned behavioral effects: a role for habituation processes

Cocaine has potent locomotor stimulant effects in rodents, which seemingly can become conditioned to test environment cues. In two experimental protocols, we measured the effects of cocaine on locomotor activity and grooming behavior, and subsequently tested whether these cocaine effects became conditioned to contextual cues. In the first experiment, three groups of rats received 14 injections of either saline or cocaine (10 mg/kg) paired or unpaired to the test environment. Cocaine increased locomotion and decreased grooming during treatment and on the conditioning test. Over the course of the treatment phase, however, the saline- and cocaine-unpaired groups but not the cocaine paired group developed progressively lower locomotion and higher grooming scores indicative of substantial habituation effects. To examine whether the cocaine may have impaired the acquisition of habituation effects rather than induce a Pavlovian cocaine conditioned response, an additional experiment was conducted in which two additional non-habituation saline and cocaine control groups were added to the experimental design. On a conditioning test, the two non-habituation control groups were equivalent in activity and grooming behavior to the cocaine-paired group. The findings were consistent with a failure by cocaine-paired animals to acquire habituation effects, which could transfer to the non-cocaine state. The connection between cocaine and novelty/habituation may have substantial importance for understanding cocaine effects.

Anticipatory responding, exclusive drug-context pairing and conditioned effects in sensitization to apomorphine-induced climbing in mice

1. The conditioning aspects of contextual sensitization were examined in the case of apomorphine-induced wall-climbing in mice, measuring onset latencies of the pharmacological response and controlling differential habituation to the test context during drug treatment. 2. Sensitization was generated in male out-bred mice which received intermittent i.p. injections of 0.4 mg/kg apomorphine over 9 daily sessions. On day 10, they were tested for contextual sensitization (all mice under apomorphine). On day 14, after 3 sessions of reinstatement, mice were tested for conditioned climbing (all mice under saline). 3. It was found that simultaneous exposure to both apomorphine and the test context facilitated the expression of a full-blown contextual sensitization (some non-contextual sensitization emerging too); importantly, sensitization was accompanied by a progressive shortening of the latencies to climb (before injections); conditioned climbing appeared only in mice pairing the drug with the test context, that response being absent in mice treated outside the context or never exposed to the context. 4. It is likely that contextual sensitization to apomorphine-induced climbing relies on Pavlovian conditioning processes rather than on habituation-related processes.

Drug conditioning induced by intrastriatal apomorphine administration

The present study examined (1) whether the neostriatum is involved in a drug-induced conditioned locomotor response and; (2) whether this structure participates in the development of behavioral sensitization. Moreover, the present study addressed the question whether the development of behavioral sensitization is necessary for the induction of conditioning. Rats received injections of either apomorphine (2 microg) or vehicle (solution of 0.1% ascorbate/saline) into the dorsal neostriatum daily for 7 days. These treatments were performed immediately prior to (apomorphine-paired group and vehicle group) or 30 min following (apomorphine-unpaired group) 10-min placement in an open field which served as the test environment. After a 3-day drug withdrawal period, the animals were given a 10-min non-drug vehicle test trial in the test environment. Three days later, a drug test with apomorphine was administered to the animals of the paired and unpaired treatment groups; the vehicle group again received an injection of vehicle. The analysis of locomotor activity in the open field (measured as the distance traversed) revealed that locomotor activity in the apomorphine-paired group was higher than in the other groups. There were no indications for behavioral sensitization to intrastriatal apomorphine, since the locomotor response in the apomorphine-paired group did not increase, but rather decreased with daily repeated injections of apomorphine. Furthermore, only the apomorphine-paired animals showed a higher locomotor response when tested after an intrastriatal injection of vehicle in the previously apomorphine-paired environment, which is indicative of a conditioned drug effect. These results suggest that the neostriatum is directly involved in the development of drug-induced conditioning of locomotor behavior but not in the establishment of behavioral sensitization.

Amphetamine-induced conditioned activity does not result from a failure of rats to habituate to novelty

Psychostimulant-induced conditioned activity is characterized by the presence of a hyperactivity in drug-free rats exposed to an environment previously paired with the effects of a psychostimulant. According to the habituation hypothesis, conditioned activity arises not through a Pavlovian conditioning process but rather because rats under the effects of the psychostimulant would be unable to habituate normally to the environment paired with these effects. This hypothesis predicts that conditioned activity should not develop in a previously habituated environment. This prediction was tested using a within-subject design. In this design, conditioned activity is evidenced when a group of rats, following a vehicle injection, was more active in a previously amphetamine-paired environment than in a previously vehicle-paired environment. The drug-environment pairing involved administering rats with d-amphetamine (1.25 mg/kg; SC) immediately prior to their placement in one of two distinctive environments. On alternate days, the rats received the vehicle and were placed in the other environment. With this design, it was found that: a) conditioned activity developed in a previously habituated environment; b) its magnitude was independent of the number of amphetamine-environment pairings (two, four or eight pairings); c) this development of conditioned activity did not result from a forgetting of the habituated environment due to a state-dependent retention of the habituation. Taken together, these results do not support the habituation hypothesis of psychostimulant-induced conditioned activity.

A new method to assess Pavlovian conditioning of psychostimulant drug effects

Experimental studies of psychoactive drugs by pavlovian drug-conditioning methods, which originally began with investigations of drug-induced responses mediated by the autonomic nervous system, have now been expanded to include drug-induced response effects expressed as modulations of spontaneous motoric behaviors. In the latter application, however, equivalent behavioral response outcomes in post-treatment tests for conditioning can occur following a psychostimulant drug treatment either through drug interference effects on habituation processes, drug-induced stress effects and/or by pavlovian conditioning of the drug-induced motoric activation effect. Current methodologies for the study of pavlovian conditioned drug effects and/or drug sensitization cannot distinguish among these possibilities. This methodological inadequacy was addressed by a modification of the conventional paired-unpaired treatment protocol. In the new protocol, the animal is sequentially placed into two test compartments with the drug treatment administered in conjunction with placement into the second test compartment. This design permits a differentiation of a pavlovian conditioned drug responses from non-conditioned drug effects through continuous measurement of the non-drug behavioral baseline in both the drug and non-drug control treatment groups combined with multiple response measurements and post-treatment tests for conditioning at variable post-conditioning intervals. The present study details the use of the new modified pavlovian protocol with repeated cocaine (10 mg/kg) treatment. A cocaine conditioned response at 1, 7, and 21 days post-conditioning was identified and distinguished from habituation and stress effects.

Conditioned cocaine induced hyperactivity: an association with increased medial prefrontal cortex serotonin

Two sets of contextual stimuli, only one of which was associated with drug treatment, were employed in a new paradigm to assess the conditioned effects of ten cocaine (20 mg/kg) treatments on motoric behavior. Two matched groups of Sprague-Dawley rats were sequentially placed into two similar but distinct test compartments. The drug treatment was administered immediately prior to placement into the second test compartment in one group (paired group) but 2 h later in the other group (unpaired group). Changes in the non drug behavioral baseline were assessed in the non drug compartment immediately prior to each drug treatment and provided the referent baseline for determining stimulus specificity of the observed behavioral effects in the drug compartment. Both groups had equivalent activity levels in the non-drug compartment. In the drug compartment, however, the paired group showed an overall cocaine stimulant effect expressed as a marked increase in distance traversed in the drug box. Additionally, the repeated cocaine treatment induced a conditioned drug effect as revealed by the higher level of motor activity in the paired compared to the unpaired treatment group exclusively in the drug compartment in two post-treatment non-drug tests for conditioning after 1-day and 21-day withdrawal and non-testing intervals. The biochemical assay results showed no significant group differences in DA and dopamine metabolites, DOPAC, HVA and 3-MT, in striatal, limbic or cortical tissue. No differences were observed either in NE or plasma corticosterone levels. Importantly, the analysis for serotonin revealed higher levels of 5-HT and 5-HIAA selectively in the prefrontal cortex.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Activation of an apomorphine behavior pattern by cocaine: a new behavioral test for drug substitution

In current tests for drug substitution using the 2-choice operant bar press paradigm, an animal can be trained to respond differentially between an interoceptive drug state stimulus vs. saline. Despite the long history and extensive number of investigations, the interpretation of such test results, nevertheless, is limited by number of potential sources of stimulus drug effects which can occur with repeated drug administration but which cannot be distinguished by this paradigm: (1) local effects at the injection site; (2) peripheral effects; (3) central activity effects; and/or (4) sensory-motor dysfunctional effects. By using a video-image analysis of behavior in an intact animal model and a pavlovian drug treatment protocol, new, spontaneous but environmentally contingent and stable behavior patterns emerge selectively in the paired treatment group with repeated drug administration which can be used as a behavioral marker to assess dose-response effects and drug substitution test results with a novel drug. A study with repeated administration of the DA agonist apomorphine and with a drug substitution assessment by a cocaine drug test is presented as a reference example to illustrate the new response-based methodological approach to the study of central mechanisms mediating the stimulus and response effects of drugs. Additionally, the observed efficacy of cocaine to activate a complex acquired behavioral pattern unique to repeated apomorphine treatment supports a critical role for dopaminergic mechanisms in the mediation of cocaine induced stereotypy.

Opponent-process theory and drug conditioning: an assessment for conditioned stimulant-induced movement

Opponent-process theory occupies an important place in drug conditioning because it accounts for conditioned drug effects which are opposite to those induced by the drug itself. It has not been established, however, whether there is an opponent-process component to stimulant drug induced conditioned effects. In the present study the unilateral 6-hydroxydopamine (6-OHDA) rat model was used to examine this issue. Two groups of Sprague-Dawley rats with equivalent 6-OHDA lesions were administered five apomorphine treatments (0.05 mg/kg s.c.) either paired or unpaired to a 10-min test chamber placement. Apomorphine induced vigorous contralateral rotation and suppressed all ipsilateral rotation. While the apomorphine-induced contralateral rotation response can be conditioned to the test environment cues, the critical test of opponent-process theory in the present study was whether the opposite response of ipsilateral rotation would also become conditioned as a latent opponent-process response to the exteroceptive test environment cues associated with the apomorphine drug state. The postacquisition saline test for conditioning showed that the paired group exhibited higher rates of contralateral and ipsilateral rotation compared to the unpaired group. In addition, when the animals were subsequently tested with the dopaminergic receptor antagonist, haloperidol (0.5 mg/kg), unexpectedly, contralateral rotation was enhanced in the paired group, whereas, ipsilateral rotation was suppressed in both groups. While these findings are, in part, compatible with an opponent-process mechanism, the data supported a simpler explanation; namely, the mechanism of differential habituation in the two groups due to a blocking effect of apomorphine on habituation selectively in the paired group.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)