The Physical Health of Caregivers of Children With Life-Limiting Conditions: A Systematic Review

Non-invasive respiratory support in children and young adults with complex medical conditions in pediatric palliative care

OBJECTIVE

Dyspnoea and sleep-disordered breathing (SDB) are common in children with life-limiting conditions but studies on treatment with non-invasive ventilation (NIV) or continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) are scarce. The aim of the study was to describe children treated with long-term NIV/CPAP within a paediatric palliative care programme in France.

METHODS

Cross-sectional survey on children and young adults with complex medical conditions treated within the French paediatric NIV network with long-term NIV/CPAP. Characteristics of the patients were analysed and patient-related outcome measures of NIV/CPAP benefit were reported.

RESULTS

The data of 50 patients (68% boys), median age 12 (0.4-21) years were analysed. Twenty-three (46%) patients had a disorder of the central nervous system and 5 (10%) a chromosomal anomaly. Thirty-two (64%) patients were treated with NIV and 18 (36%) with CPAP. NIV/CPAP was initiated on an abnormal Apnoea-Hypopnoea Index in 18 (36%) of the patients, an abnormal nocturnal gas exchange alone in 28 (56%), and after an acute respiratory failure in 11 (22%) of the patients. Mean objective NIV/CPAP adherence was 9.3±3.7 hours/night. NIV/CPAP was associated with a decrease in dyspnoea in 60% of patients, an increase in sleep duration in 60% and in sleep quality in 74%, and an improvement in parents' sleep in 40%.

CONCLUSIONS

In children with life-limiting conditions, long-term NIV/CPAP may be associated with relief of dyspnoea, an improvement of SDB and an improvement in parents' sleep.

Caring for the child with a tracheostomy through the eyes of their caregiver: A photovoice study

PURPOSE

This qualitative descriptive study aimed to explore the daily experiences of caregivers of children with medical complexity with a tracheostomy at home.

METHODS

This study used photovoice, a participatory action research methodology. Adult English-speaking caregivers of children with a tracheostomy, living in Texas, with access to a smartphone were recruited. Photographs taken by participants and an interview guide were used to guide semi-structured interviews with caregivers.

RESULTS

Eight participants were recruited. After analyzing photographs and caregiver interviews, four main themes were identified: role transition, daily challenges, finding support, and thriving in the new normal.

CONCLUSIONS

Caregivers take on multiple roles, including providing medical care, advocating for their children, and educating others. While facing emotional challenges such as guilt, fear, and exhaustion, caregivers rely on external support systems, emphasizing the need for nurses and healthcare providers to provide comprehensive support and improve the accessibility of home nursing services.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

The findings of this study can inform nurse-led interventions and advocacy efforts aimed at supporting marginalized children with medical complexity with a tracheostomy and their families. These efforts may include enhancing communication and collaboration between families, healthcare workers, and the public, providing comprehensive, proactive support for caregivers, and improving access to home nursing services.

Mental health of caregivers of children with medical complexity: group-based trajectory modelling

OBJECTIVE

To describe the mental health trajectories of caregivers of children with medical complexity (CMC) and explore child characteristics associated with below-average caregiver mental health.

DESIGN

A secondary analysis of prospectively collected data from 123 caregivers of children aged <16 years with medical complexity from a multicentre randomised trial conducted from December 2016 to June 2021.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

The Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System Global Mental Health Scale was used to measure caregivers' self-reported mental health well-being. Group-based trajectory analysis was used to identify clusters of caregivers with similar changes in mental health across 24 months. Logistic regression was used to identify child-related predictors of mental health among caregivers.

RESULTS

A final model with three distinct groups was selected, corresponding to caregivers with average (n=39), moderately below-average (n=65) and severely below-average (n=19) mental health scores, all with stable trajectories and high posterior probabilities (>90%). Moderately and severely below-average caregiver mental health groups, merged into one group, were associated with a greater number of child medical technology devices (adjusted OR (aOR) 1.44, 95% CI 1.01 to 2.04), gross motor difficulties (aOR 3.51, 95% CI 1.02 to 12.05) and worse child emotional (aOR 0.93, 95% CI 0.87 to 0.99) and psychological well-being (aOR 0.93, 95% CI 0.88 to 0.99).

CONCLUSION

Most caregivers of CMC reported persistently below-average mental health. The intensity of caregiving, as indicated by medical technology and child functional needs, is a potential risk factor for below-average caregiver mental health. Future design and evaluation of interventions focused on support for caregivers of CMC are warranted.

Comparing Physical Activity and Quality of Life of Caregivers of Children With Physical Disabilities and Typically Developing Children

There are conflicting reports of the level of physical activity (PA) and its relationship to quality of life (QoL) among caregivers of children with physical disabilities (CwPD). In this cross-sectional study, we aimed to compare the PA levels and QoL of two groups of caregivers - a CwPD group and caregivers of typically developing children (CwTD). We included 32 family caregivers in the CwPD group (22 women, 10 men; M age = 42.1, SD = 6.2 years) and 32 caregivers in the CwTD group (24 women, 8 men; M age = 42.3, SD = 6.1 years). We assessed PA with the International Physical Activity Scale-Short Form (IPAQ-SF) and self-reported activity diaries, and we assessed QoL with the Short-Form 36 (SF-36) questionnaire. Although the IPAQ scores and sitting times of caregivers in these two groups were not statistically different (p > .05), many parameters of self-reported activity diary data and total energy expenditure were significantly higher in the CwPD than the CwTD group (p < .05, effect size = .53-1.10). The CwPD group reported a lower QoL according to the SF-36 and its sub-scores (p < .05, effect size = .54-.77), and higher PA levels than those in the CwTD group. In the CwPD group, moderate, vigorous, and total PA scores were mildly to moderately associated with the total Qol score, and many of its subscores (r = .36 to .60, p < .05). The lower quality of life observed in CwPD, despite high-intensity physical activity levels, suggested that investigators and care providers should consider QoL in the CwPD group to be multifactorial and that here is a need for caregiver interventions to enhance QoL in this underserved population.

Psychological, behavioural, and physical aspects of caregiver strain in autism-caregivers: a cohort study

Background

People who give care to autistic individuals (autism-caregivers) experience higher levels of caregiver strain than people who provide care for individuals with other chronic conditions (non-autism-caregivers). This places them at higher risk for psychological, behavioural and physical health concerns. The aim of this study is to delineate psychological, behavioural, and physical aspects of caregiver strain in autism-caregivers compared to non-autism-caregivers.

Methods

We included 3354 adult caregivers from the general population in the Netherlands participating in the second assessment (January, 1, 2014-December, 31, 2017) of the Lifelines Cohort. In this cohort study, using multivariable regression adjusted for age, sex, and socioeconomic status, we analysed psychological (anxiety and depression based on a Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview, and self-reported stress and perceived health), behavioural (questionnaire-assessed physical activity, alcohol use, and smoking), and physical aspects (body mass index, waist circumference, and leukocyte-counts) of caregiver strain in autism-caregivers (n = 722) compared with non-autism-caregivers (n = 2632).

Findings

Autism-caregivers reported more stress (OR 3.61, 95% CI 2.60-4.99). Both anxiety (OR 1.85, 95% CI 1.37-2.49) and depressive disorders (OR 1.83, 95% CI 1.17-2.86) were more common in autism-caregivers than in non-autism-caregivers. Perceived health, physical activity, alcohol use, and smoking were not different between autism- and non-autism-caregivers. In autism-caregivers, lymphocyte- and monocyte-counts were lower than in non-autism-caregivers.

Interpretation

In this large cohort, autism-caregivers had worse psychological health than non-autism-caregivers. Moreover, autism-caregiving might be associated with an altered immune balance. These findings underline the higher caregiver strain in autism-caregivers compared to other caregivers. This calls for increased support to autism-caregivers.

Funding

Lifelines has been funded by the Dutch government.

Morbidity and healthcare use among mothers of children with cancer: A population-based study

BACKGROUND

The impact of a child's cancer diagnosis on subsequent maternal physical health is unclear.

METHODS

We identified all Ontario children diagnosed less than 18 years with cancer between 1992 and 2017. Linkage to administrative databases identified mothers who were matched to population controls. We identified physical health conditions, acute healthcare use, and preventive healthcare use through validated algorithms using healthcare data, and compared them between exposed (child with cancer) and unexposed mothers. Predictors of health outcomes were assessed among exposed mothers.

RESULTS

We identified 5311 exposed mothers and 19,516 matched unexposed mothers. For exposed mothers, median age at last follow-up was 48 years, (interquartile range: 42-53). Exposed mothers had an increased risk of cancer (hazard ratio [HR] 1.2, 95% confidence interval [95% CI]: 1.0-1.5, p = .03), but not of any other adverse physical outcomes or of increased acute healthcare use. Exposed mothers were more likely to receive influenza vaccinations (odds ratio 1.4, 95% CI: 1.3-1.5, p < .0001), and underwent cancer screening at the same rate as unexposed mothers. Among exposed mothers, bereavement was associated with a subsequent increased risk of cancer (HR 1.7, 95% CI: 1.2-2.5, p = .004) and death (HR 2.2, 95% CI: 1.2-4.1, p = .01).

CONCLUSION

Mothers of children with cancer are at increased risk of developing cancer, but not of other adverse physical health outcomes, and were equally or more likely to be adherent to preventive healthcare practices. Bereaved mothers were at increased risk of subsequent cancer and death. Interventions targeting specific subpopulations of mothers of children with cancer or focused on screening for specific cancers may be warranted.

Prevalence and predictors of depressive symptoms among caregivers of patients with epilepsy in Hong Kong

STUDY AIM

To estimate the prevalence of high caregiving burden and depressive symptoms among caregivers (CG) of patients with epilepsy (PWEs) in Hong Kong and identify risk and protective factors for both outcomes after the Model of Stress and Carer Burden (MSCB).

METHODS

This cross-sectional study recruited participants from local epilepsy clinics to complete a 15-minute survey on a tablet. Caregiving burden (CB) was assessed using the 4-item Zarit Caregiver Burden Interview. Depressive symptoms were assessed using the 2-item Patient Health Questionnaire. Family functioning was assessed using the Short-Form Family Assessment Device General Functioning Subscale. Sociodemographic data of the caregivers and clinical data of the PWE they cared for were described. Hierarchical logistic regression models were used to analyze the factors associated with the outcomes.

RESULTS

A hundred and fifty-one CGs of PWEs were recruited for this study. The prevalence of high caregiving burden (ZBI-4 > 7) for CGs of PWEs was 58.9% (n = 89), whereas the prevalence of high depressive symptoms (PHQ2 > 2) was 23.8% (n = 36). Hierarchical logistic regression analysis revealed that entering patient characteristics and care situations did not enhance the model's predictability. In the full model, a high perceived CB was a risk factor for elevated depressive symptoms. Good physical health protects against depressive symptoms.

CONCLUSIONS

Among caregivers of PWE in Hong Kong, a high perceived caregiving burden was a risk factor for elevated depressive symptoms; however, the clinical characteristics of the PWEs were not. Self-reported physical health is a protective factor against increased depressive symptoms.

Frequency, Characteristics, and Outcomes of Patients Requiring Early PICU Readmission

OBJECTIVES

Readmission to the PICU is associated with worse outcomes, but factors associated with PICU readmission within the same hospitalization remain unclear. We sought to describe the prevalence of, and identify factors associated with, early PICU readmission.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of PICU admissions for patients aged 0 to 26 years in 48 tertiary care children's hospitals between January 1, 2016 and December 31, 2019 in the Pediatric Health Information System. We defined early readmission as return to the PICU within 2 calendar days of floor transfer during the same hospitalization. Generalized linear mixed models were used to analyze associations between patient and clinical variables, including complex chronic conditions (CCC) and early PICU readmission.

RESULTS

The results included 389 219 PICU admissions; early PICU readmission rate was 2.5%. Factors with highest odds of early PICU readmission were CCC, with ≥4 CCCs (reference: no CCC[s]) as highest odds of readmission (adjusted odds ratio [95% confidence interval]: 4.2 [3.8-4.5]), parenteral nutrition (2.3 [2.1-2.4]), and ventriculoperitoneal shunt (1.9 [1.7-2.2]). Factors with decreased odds of PICU readmission included extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (0.4 [0.3-0.6]) and cardiopulmonary resuscitation (0.8 [0.7-0.9]). Patients with early PICU readmissions had longer overall length of stay (geometric mean [geometric SD]: 18.2 [0.9] vs 5.0 [1.1] days, P < .001) and increased odds of mortality (1.7 [1.5-1.9]).

CONCLUSIONS

Although early PICU readmissions within the same hospitalization are uncommon, they are associated with significantly worse clinical outcomes. Patients with medical complexity and technology dependence are especially vulnerable.

"The Key Is to Value Every Little Achievement": A Qualitative Study of the Psychological Experience of Parent Caregivers in Paediatric Palliative Care

In Europe, Portugal has been identified as the country with the most rapid evolution of paediatric palliative care provision, which is a highly complex experience for families. The present descriptive-exploratory study seeks to contribute to the understanding of the psychological experience of life-limiting conditions in parent caregivers. A total of 14 families completed a sociodemographic and clinical data sheet and answered a structured online interview based on an incomplete narrative resulting from the Unwanted Guest Metaphor. A thematic analysis of the various narratives was performed through an inductive-deductive process. The results provide a holistic view of 10 essential dimensions in the parental psychological experience and contribute to the design of intervention methodologies in an eco-systemic approach. The importance of clear communication with health professionals, an awareness of the unpredictability of the disease, the desire for more self-care, the difficulty in understanding their children's needs and the threat implicit in everyday life are some of the main findings. This research emphasizes the importance of having opportunities of emotional expression and psychoeducation about anxiety' management, enhancing the perception of positive characteristics in children with palliative needs and creating time for the couple. The study has some limitations, such as the small sample size, and suggests that further research should explore the father's experience.

An Analysis of John Bowlby's Mourning Stages in Family Art Therapy as a Way to Help the Family Mourning Process

Purpose

Pediatric palliative care is a rapidly developing multidisciplinary approach that supports children with life-limiting conditions and their families. However, there is limited evidence on how to effectively support bereaved parents and siblings. The purpose of this study is to explore the therapeutic impact of art therapy for bereaved families, in accordance with John Bowlby's four-stage theory of mourning.

Methods

This single-case study employed the consensual qualitative research method. Art therapy records of bereaved families were reviewed individually, and records from one case were selected. Verbal statements made during the art therapy sessions and photocopies of the artworks were analyzed to understand the mourning process of the family.

Results

A total of 113 statements and 12 artworks from 19 art therapy sessions were analyzed. As the art therapy progressed, each family member exhibited a pattern of engaging in more positive and healthy conversations in daily life, demonstrating the final stage of mourning reorganization and recovery. The family dynamics also revealed that they reconstructed their inner world and redefined the meaning of loss, which is the final stage of mourning. The art therapy provided a safe environment for the family, allowing them to fulfill their wishes and regain the strength needed for recovery.

Conclusion

This study suggests that art therapy supports bereaved families in alleviating their psychological difficulties, engaging in a healthy mourning process, and functioning as members of society. Further research is needed to better understand the effect of art therapy as a bereavement support tool in pediatric palliative care.

Children's complex health: Maternal experiences of care and decision making

An increasing number of children with complex life-limiting and life-threatening conditions are being cared for at home by their parents. Negative impacts on maternal health are now being recognised. This study sought to voice parental experiences to determine what matters most; explore day-to-day decision making and Advance Care Planning; and to inform local service development. Seven mothers from one community nursing service were interviewed using a semi-structured qualitative approach during the Coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. Seven data-driven themes were identified following six phase thematic analysis: cherishing normality; navigating the system; being proactive; meaningful connections; beginner to expert - and back; they're not any child - they're my child; and Coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. Practice implications include early discussion of what matters most and benefits of written plans to ensure fair access to treatment for children with complex health. Mothers highlighted that sharing their story enhanced their sense of coping and purpose. Increased support at times of vulnerability and permission to explore decisions were highly valued.

"What I Would Do to Take Away Your Pain": A Photovoice Project Conducted by Mothers of Children With Medical Complexity

Research identifies that families of children with medical complexities in the United States have diverse and complex needs. Despite research emphasizing that families demonstrate higher needs that are not being met, limited research focuses solely on mothers of children with medical complexities. Specifically, how mothers understand and identify themselves, understand and define their role in coordinating care, and how they view their own mental and physical health. As such, this study provides a better understanding of how mothers in San Diego, CA, navigate the day-to-day psychological, social, and physical realities of having a child with medical complexities. Through the use of the participatory action research method photovoice, mothers conducted a critical analysis of their daily lives. Findings identify mothers' main concerns about the conditions of their lives as well as the strengths they employ to care for themselves and their children successfully. Implications provide recommendations for hospitals working with mothers of children with medical complexities.

Building capability in paediatric palliative care and enhancing education through the voice of parents: the Quality of Care Collaborative Australia

Background

The greater proportion of children with a life-limiting condition (LLC) and their families want to remain at home as much as possible. Building capability in paediatric palliative care (PPC) for generalist health and social care professionals in nonmetropolitan regions through the Quality of Care Collaborative Australia (QuoCCA) has improved access to palliative care for families, regardless of where they live.

Aim

To understand the experience of families whose child has received specialist PPC, to ensure future service capability development is informed by lived experience.

Design

A retrospective, descriptive study in which parents participated in a semi-structured telephone interview guided by Discovery Interview methodology. Inductive thematic analysis identified the major learnings from participants.

Participants

Parents caring for a child referred to the specialist PPC service, who received a pop-up visit and whose child is stable or who are more than 6 months bereaved.

Results

Eleven parents (n = 9 mothers; n = 2 fathers) of children with an LLC (n = 5) or whose child had died (n = 6) participated in an interview. The overarching themes and subthemes were as follows: (1) burden of suffering, in which parents described grieving for the life once anticipated, confronting many life transitions and seeking quality of life for their child and (2) umbrella of support, in which parents built partnerships with professional support, activated a network of care around their family and sought responses to their whole family's needs.

Conclusion

Parents caring for a child with an LLC described significant personal, familial, social and existential adjustments. This study integrates a relational learning approach with QuoCCA education grounded in the relationships between children, families and professionals. Learning from lived experience in PPC education enhances the preparedness of generalist health and social care professionals to join a child and their family throughout their various life transitions and facilitates the goal to remain at home within their community for as long as possible. Education in PPC is an imperative component of service models, enabling regional services to gain confidence and capability in the context of a dying child and their family, empowered and informed through the voice of the family.

Plain Language Summary

Enhancing palliative care for children through education informed by the experience of families It is often the wish of many children/young people with a life-limiting condition to stay at home with their families as much as possible. It is important that specialist palliative care services provide training and mentoring to the family's local care professionals to support the delivery of good care, particularly those in rural and remote areas.This article aims to integrate the lived experience of families with palliative care education, so that the education reflects and addresses the needs that they express.Parents were interviewed by telephone using a method called Discovery Interviews. This is an open interview process, guided by a spine that describes the main points of palliative care. Parents can openly talk about their experience, focusing on the areas that are important to them. Interviews were studied by four researchers, and emerging themes were discussed and summarised.The study included parents whose child/young person was receiving support from specialist palliative care and bereaved parents whose child had died more than 6 months ago. In total, eleven parents (nine mothers and two fathers) were interviewed, five participants had children currently receiving palliative care and six were bereaved.The overarching themes were as follows:Burden of suffering, in which parents described grieving for the life they had expected, confronting transitions and seeking good quality of life for their child.Umbrella of support, in which parents built partnerships with care teams and activated a network of care to address the needs of their whole family.This study allowed the families' perspectives to be integrated into the palliative care education of care professionals in the family's local area. The lived experience of families prepared care professionals to support families with the care of their child/young person, allowing them to remain at home as long as possible.

The health of mothers of children with a life-limiting condition: A qualitative interview study

BACKGROUND

The number of children with a life-limiting condition is increasing. The mothers of these children commonly provide extensive care at home for their child and are at a higher risk of poor health than other mothers. The impact of this is rarely explored from mothers' perspectives.

AIM

To explore mothers' accounts of their physical and mental health, experiences of accessing healthcare and who they think should support their health.

DESIGN

Qualitative semi-structured interviews were conducted and analysed using thematic analysis.

SETTING/PARTICIPANTS

Thirty mothers of children with a life-limiting condition were recruited via three UK children's hospices and social media.

RESULTS

Mothers felt that their health concerns could be misunderstood by professionals, describing untimely and inappropriate support that failed to recognise the nature of caring for a child with a life-limiting condition. This led to mothers' reluctance in addressing these concerns. Mothers felt unable to prioritise their own needs, relative to those of their child and worried about who would look after their child if they did become unwell. They described stress as a result of battles with services rather than as a result of caregiving. Mothers valued feeling recognised as caregivers, which made it easier to look after their health alongside their child's. Hospice support was particularly valuable in this respect.

CONCLUSIONS

A more unified system that recognises not only the unique set of challenges presented to mothers caring for a child with a life-limiting condition, but the value of palliative care services in supporting these mothers, is required.

The Symptom Experience in Pediatric Cancer: Current Conceptualizations and Future Directions

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

We aimed to review the recent research on the childhood cancer symptom experience pertaining to socioeconomic factors, biology and genetics, growth and development, family psychosocial dynamics, and social and treating environments to begin to formulate recommendations for a personalized approach to symptom management.

RECENT FINDINGS

Cancer symptoms are common and distressing in children and negatively impact child and family quality of life. Many interacting factors influence children's cancer symptoms experiences, including the assessment and management of such symptoms. This paper highlights several gaps in the research related to the cancer symptom experience including routine symptom assessment, the impact of socioeconomic, biological, and genetic factors on symptoms, and the establishment of effective symptom management partnerships with families. Based on our findings, we provide recommendations related to that research which is ready to be implemented into clinical practice and areas for needed future efforts.

The Physical Health of Caregivers of Children With Life-Limiting Conditions: A Systematic Review

CONTEXT

Parental caregiving for a child with a life-limiting condition (LLC) is complex physical and mental work. The impact of this caregiving on parents' physical health is unknown.

OBJECTIVES

(1) To review existing evidence on the physical health of parents caring for a child with a LLC and (2) to determine how physical health of parents is measured.

DATA SOURCES

Medline, Embase, PsycINFO, and Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature were searched.

STUDY SELECTION

Peer-reviewed articles were included if they reported primary data on the physical health of a caregiver of a child with a LLC. Studies were excluded if they described only the caregiver's mental health or if the caregivers were bereaved at the time of data collection.

DATA EXTRACTION

Of 69 335 unique citations, 81 studies were included in the review.

RESULTS

Caregiver health was negatively impacted in 84% of studies. Pain and sleep disturbance were the most common problems. Ways of measuring the physical health of caregiver varied widely. We found an absence of in-depth explorations of the social and economic contexts, which could potentially mitigate the impact of caregiving. Furthermore, we find health interventions tailored to this group remain largely unexplored.

LIMITATIONS

Studies were heterogenous in methodology, making comparisons of results across studies difficult.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings support the need for improving access to interventions aimed at improving physical health in this population. The rate of health-seeking behaviors, preventive health care access and screening for health conditions is understudied and represent important directions for further research.