COLD-PCR: improving the sensitivity of molecular diagnostics assays

Integrative analysis of multi-omics data for liquid biopsy

The innovation of liquid biopsy holds great potential to revolutionise cancer management through early diagnosis and timely treatment of cancer. Integrative analysis of different tumour-derived omics data (such as genomics, epigenetics, fragmentomics, and proteomics) from body fluids for cancer detection and monitoring could outperform the analysis of single modality data alone. In this review, we focussed on the discussion of early cancer detection and molecular residual disease surveillance based on multi-omics data of blood. We summarised diverse types of tumour-derived components, current popular platforms for profiling cancer-associated signals, machine learning approaches for joint analysis of liquid biopsy data, as well as multi-omics-based early detection of cancers, molecular residual disease monitoring, and treatment response surveillance. We also discussed the challenges and future directions of multi-omics-based liquid biopsy. With the development of both experimental protocols and computational methods dedicated to liquid biopsy, the implementation of multi-omics strategies into the clinical workflow will likely benefit the clinical management of cancers including decision-making guidance and patient outcome improvement.

Enzymatic Methods for Mutation Detection in Cancer Samples and Liquid Biopsies

Low-level tumor somatic DNA mutations in tissue and liquid biopsies obtained from cancer patients can have profound implications for development of metastasis, prognosis, choice of treatment, follow-up, or early cancer detection. Unless detected, such low-frequency DNA alterations can misinform patient management decisions or become missed opportunities for personalized medicine. Next-generation sequencing technologies and digital-PCR can resolve low-level mutations but require access to specialized instrumentation, time, and resources. Enzymatic-based approaches to detection of low-level mutations provide a simple, straightforward, and affordable alternative to enrich and detect such alterations and is broadly available to low-resource laboratory settings. This review summarizes the traditional uses of enzymatic mutation detection and describes the latest exciting developments, potential, and applications with specific reference to the field of liquid biopsy in cancer.

Nuclease Enrichment and qPCR Detection of Rare Nucleotide Variants

The emergence of circulating DNA analysis in blood during the past decade has responded to the need for noninvasive alternatives to classical tissue biopsies. This has coincided with the development of techniques that allow the detection of low-frequency allele variants in clinical samples that typically carry very low amounts of fragmented DNA, such as plasma or FFPE samples. Enrichment of rare variants by nuclease-assisted mutant allele enrichment with overlapping probes (NaME-PrO) enables a more sensitive detection of mutations in tissue biopsy samples alongside standard qPCR detection assays. Such sensitivity is normally achieved by other more complex PCR methods, such as TaqMan qPCR and digital droplet PCR (ddPCR). Here we describe a workflow of mutation-specific nuclease-based enrichment combined with a SYBR Green real-time quantitative PCR detection method that provides comparable results to ddPCR. Using a PIK3CA mutation as an example, this combined workflow enables detection and accurate prediction of initial variant allele fraction in samples with a low mutant allele frequency (<1%) and could be applied flexibly to detect other mutations of interest.

Single-tube Multiplex Nested PCR System for Efficient Detection of Pathogenic Microorganisms in SPF Rodents

PCR testing is increasingly important for microbial control in SPF facilities. However, most current PCR methods are timeconsuming and require compromise between high sensitivity and high multiplexing. We developed a one-tube multiplex nested PCR strategy (MN-PCR) for simultaneous direct (that is, without culturing) detection of multiple pathogens. We first aligned sequences for the 16S rDNA genes of selected target bacteria and a panel of closely related organisms. From these data, we designed a pair of universal primers and multiple sets of species-specific PCR primers to amplify the target sequences; the universal primers were modified to include various degenerate bases and locked nucleic acids. In a single tube, 16S rDNA sequences were amplified by using the nested PCR primers under high temperature (that is, above 65°C) during the first stage of the MN-PCR procedure, when the target-species-specific PCR primers do not support amplification due to their short length. In addition, the concentration of the nested PCR primers during the first stage was adjusted to ensure that they were consumed and did not yield visible bands themselves. During the second stage, the enriched 16S rDNA sequences then served as templates for amplification of the species-specific fragments by using the multiple PCR primers at low annealing temperatures (that is, below 60°C). The results showed that our MN-PCR method detected as little as 1 fg of target bacterial DNA in a 20-μL reaction volume, whereas conventional multiplex PCR detected a minimum of 1 pg only. Compared with traditional multiplex PCR assays, our MN-PCR system is an effective and efficient culture-free process.

Pre-PCR Mutation-Enrichment Methods for Liquid Biopsy Applications

Liquid biopsy is having a remarkable impact on healthcare- and disease-management in the context of personalized medicine. Circulating free DNA (cfDNA) is one of the most instructive liquid-biopsy-based biomarkers and harbors valuable information for diagnostic, predictive, and prognostic purposes. When it comes to cancer, circulating DNA from the tumor (ctDNA) has a wide range of applications, from early cancer detection to the early detection of relapse or drug resistance, and the tracking of the dynamic genomic make-up of tumor cells. However, the detection of ctDNA remains technically challenging, due, in part, to the low frequency of ctDNA among excessive circulating cfDNA originating from normal tissues. During the past three decades, mutation-enrichment methods have emerged to boost sensitivity and enable facile detection of low-level mutations. Although most developed techniques apply mutation enrichment during or following initial PCR, there are a few techniques that allow mutation selection prior to PCR, which provides advantages. Pre-PCR enrichment techniques can be directly applied to genomic DNA and diminish the influence of PCR errors that can take place during amplification. Moreover, they have the capability for high multiplexity and can be followed by established mutation detection and enrichment technologies without changes to their established procedures. The first approaches for pre-PCR enrichment were developed by employing restriction endonucleases directly on genomic DNA in the early 1990s. However, newly developed pre-PCR enrichment methods provide higher sensitivity and versatility. This review describes the available pre-PCR enrichment methods and focuses on the most recently developed techniques (NaME-PrO, UVME, and DEASH/MAESTRO), emphasizing their applications in liquid biopsies.

Recent Developments in Mutation Enrichment and Detection Technologies

BACKGROUND

Presence of excess unaltered, wild-type DNA (wtDNA) providing information of little clinical value may often mask low-level mutations containing important diagnostic or therapeutic clues. This is a recurring hurdle in biotechnology and medicine, including cancer, prenatal diagnosis, infectious diseases, and organ transplantation. Mutation enrichment techniques that allow reduction of unwanted DNA to enable the detection of low-level mutations have emerged since the early 1990s. They are continuously being refined and updated with new technologies. The burgeoning interest in liquid biopsies for residual cancer monitoring, detection of resistance to therapy, and early cancer detection has driven an expanded interest in new and improved methodologies for practical and effective mutation enrichment and detection of low-level mutations of clinical relevance.

CONTENT

Newly developed mutation enrichment technologies are described and grouped according to the main principle of operation, PCR-blocking technologies, enzymatic methods, and physicochemical approaches. Special emphasis is given to technologies enabling pre-PCR blockage of wtDNA to bypass PCR errors [nuclease-assisted minor-allele enrichment assay with overlapping probes (NaME-PrO) and UV-mediated cross-linking minor allele enrichment (UVME)] or providing high multiplexity followed by next-generation sequencing [Minor allele enriched sequencing through recognition oligonucleotides (MAESTRO)].

SUMMARY

This review summarizes technological developments in rare mutation enrichment over the last 12 years, complementing pre-2010 reviews on this topic. The expanding field of liquid biopsy calls for improved limits of detection (LOD) and highly parallel applications, along with the traditional requirements for accuracy, speed, and cost-effectiveness. The current technologies are reviewed with regards to these new requirements.

The Integration of Gold Nanoparticles with Polymerase Chain Reaction for Constructing Colorimetric Sensing Platforms for Detection of Health-Related DNA and Proteins

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is the standard tool in genetic information analysis, and the desirable detection merits of PCR have been extended to disease-related protein analysis. Recently, the combination of PCR and gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) to construct colorimetric sensing platforms has received considerable attention due to its high sensitivity, visual detection, capability for on-site detection, and low cost. However, it lacks a related review to summarize and discuss the advances in this area. This perspective gives an overview of established methods based on the combination of PCR and AuNPs for the visual detection of health-related DNA and proteins. Moreover, this work also addresses the future trends and perspectives for PCR-AuNP hybrid biosensors.

Mutation enrichment in human DNA samples via UV-mediated cross-linking

Detection of low-level DNA mutations can reveal recurrent, hotspot genetic changes of clinical relevance to cancer, prenatal diagnostics, organ transplantation or infectious diseases. However, the high excess of wild-type (WT) alleles, which are concurrently present, often hinders identification of salient genetic changes. Here, we introduce UV-mediated cross-linking minor allele enrichment (UVME), a novel approach that incorporates ultraviolet irradiation (∼365 nm UV) DNA cross-linking either before or during PCR amplification. Oligonucleotide probes matching the WT target sequence and incorporating a UV-sensitive 3-cyanovinylcarbazole nucleoside modification are employed for cross-linking WT DNA. Mismatches formed with mutated alleles reduce DNA binding and UV-mediated cross-linking and favor mutated DNA amplification. UV can be applied before PCR and/or at any stage during PCR to selectively block WT DNA amplification and enable identification of traces of mutated alleles. This enables a single-tube PCR reaction directly from genomic DNA combining optimal pre-amplification of mutated alleles, which then switches to UV-mediated mutation enrichment-based DNA target amplification. UVME cross-linking enables enrichment of mutated KRAS and p53 alleles, which can be screened directly via Sanger sequencing, high-resolution melting, TaqMan genotyping or digital PCR, resulting in the detection of mutation allelic frequencies of 0.001–0.1% depending on the endpoint detection method. UV-mediated mutation enrichment provides new potential for mutation enrichment in diverse clinical samples.

A novel xenonucleic acid-mediated molecular clamping technology for early colorectal cancer screening

BACKGROUND

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is one of the leading causes of cancer-related death. Early detection is critical to reduce CRC morbidity and mortality. In order to meet this need, we developed a molecular clamping assay called the ColoScape TM assay for early colorectal cancer diagnostics.

METHODS

Nineteen mutations in four genes (APC, KRAS, BRAF and CTNNB1) associated with early events in CRC pathogenesis are targeted in the ColoScapeTM assay. Xenonucleic Acid (XNA)-mediated qPCR clamping technology was applied to minimize the wild-type background amplification in order to improve assay sensitivity of CRC mutation detection. The assay analytical performance was verified and validated, cfDNA and FFPE CRC patient samples were evaluated, and an ROC curve was applied to evaluate its performance.

RESULTS

The data showed that the assay analytical sensitivity was 0.5% Variant Allele Frequency, corresponding to ~7-8 copies of mutant DNA with 5 ng total DNA input per test. This assay is highly reproducible with intra-assay CV of <3% and inter-assay CV of <5%. We have investigated 380 clinical samples including plasma cfDNA and FFPE samples from patients with precancerous and different stages of CRC. The preliminary assay clinical specificity and sensitivity for CRC cfDNA were: 100% (95% CI, 80.3-97.5%) and 92.2% (95% CI, 94.7-100%), respectively, with AUC of 0.96; 96% specificity (95% CI, 77.6-99.7%) and 92% sensitivity (95% CI, 86.1-95.6%) with AUC of 0.94 for CRC FFPE; 95% specificity (95% CI, 82.5%-99.1%) and 62.5% sensitivity (95% CI, 35.8%-83.7%) with AUC of 0.79 for precancerous lesions cfDNA.

CONCLUSIONS

The XNA-mediated molecular clamping assay is a rapid, precise, and sensitive assay for the detection of precancerous lesions cfDNA and CRC cfDNA or FFPE samples.

One-Step Polymerase Chain Reaction-Free Nanowire-Based Plasma Cell-Free DNA Assay to Detect EML4-ALK Fusion and to Monitor Resistance in Lung Cancer

BACKGROUND

Next-generation sequencing has mostly been used for genotyping cell-free DNA (cfDNA) in plasma. However, this assay has several clinical limitations. We evaluated the clinical utility of a novel polymerase chain reaction-free nanowire (NW)-based plasma cfDNA assay for detecting ALK fusion and mutations.

PATIENTS, MATERIALS, AND METHODS

We consecutively enrolled 99 patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer undergoing a fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) test for ALK fusion; ALK-positive (n = 36). The NW-based assay was performed using 50-100 μL of plasma collected at pretreatment and every 8 weeks during ALK inhibitor treatment.

RESULTS

There was high concordance between the NW-based assay and the FISH test for identification of ALK fusion (94.9% with a kappa coefficient value of 0.892, 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.799-0.984). There was no difference in the response rate to the first anaplastic lymphoma kinase inhibitor between the ALK-positive patients identified by the NW-based assay and by the FISH test (73.5% vs. 72.2%, p = .931). In the ALK variant analysis, variants 1 and 3 subgroups were detected in 27 (75.0%) and 8 (22.2%) patients, respectively. Among 24 patients treated with crizotinib, variant 3 subgroup was associated with worse median overall survival than variant 1 subgroup (36.5 months; 95% CI, 0.09-87.6 vs. 19.8 months; 95% CI, 9.9-not reached, p = .004]. A serial assessment identified that ALK L1196M resistance mutation emerged before radiologic progression during crizotinib treatment.

CONCLUSION

The newly developed simple NW-based cfDNA assay may be clinically applicable for rapid diagnosis of ALK fusion with its variant forms and early detection of resistance.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

The authors developed a novel one-step polymerase chain reaction-free nanowire (NW)-based plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) assay. This study evaluated the clinical utility of this novel method for the diagnosis of EML4-ALK fusion in advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). The NW-based assay and FISH test showed high concordance rate in 99 patients with advanced NSCLC. Serial cfDNA assessment demonstrated this method provided early detection of resistance before radiologic progression during crizotinib treatment. Taken together, plasma cfDNA genotyping by the NW-based cfDNA assay may be useful for the rapid diagnosis of ALK fusion, classifying variants, and early detection of resistance.

cfDNA Sequencing: Technological Approaches and Bioinformatic Issues

In the era of precision medicine, it is crucial to identify molecular alterations that will guide the therapeutic management of patients. In this context, circulating tumoral DNA (ctDNA) released by the tumor in body fluids, like blood, and carrying its molecular characteristics is becoming a powerful biomarker for non-invasive detection and monitoring of cancer. Major recent technological advances, especially in terms of sequencing, have made possible its analysis, the challenge still being its reliable early detection. Different parameters, from the pre-analytical phase to the choice of sequencing technology and bioinformatic tools can influence the sensitivity of ctDNA detection.

Establishment of multiplex allele-specific blocker PCR for enrichment and detection of 4 common EGFR mutations in non-small cell lung cancer

Background

Lung cancer is one of the most severe cancers and the majority of patients miss the best timing for surgery when diagnosed, thus having to rely on radiotherapy, chemotherapy or target therapy. Epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) upregulation occurs in a large percentage of patients, who can then benefit from tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKI). However, the EGFR mutations they carry will vary the effectiveness of TKI. Circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) contains genetic information from cancer tissue that can be used as a liquid biopsy by non-invasive sampling. This study aimed to provide a solution for minor allele detection from ctDNA.

Methods

Our novel method, named multiplex allele-specific blocker PCR (MAB PCR), combines amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS), blocker PCR and fluorescent-labeled probes for better discrimination and higher throughput. MAB PCR was specially designed for low-quality samples such as ctDNA. A sensitive assay based on MAB PCR was developed for enriching and detecting four common EGFR mutations. This assay was optimized and evaluated with manufactured plasmids, and validated with 34 tissue samples and 94 plasma samples.

Results

The limit of detection of this assay was 10² copies and the detection sensitivity reached 0.1% mutant allele fraction (MAF). The results of clinical sample testing had 100% accordance with sequencing, which proved that this assay was accurate and applicable in clinical settings.

Conclusions

This assay could accomplish low-cost and rapid detection of 4 common EGFR mutations sensitively and accurately, which has huge potential in clinical usage for guiding medication. Furthermore, this design could be used to detect other mutations.

PIK3CA mutation enrichment and quantitation from blood and tissue

PIK3CA is one of the two most frequently mutated genes in breast cancers, occurring in 30–40% of cases. Four frequent ‘hotspot’ PIK3CA mutations (E542K, E545K, H1047R and H1047L) account for 80–90% of all PIK3CA mutations in human malignancies and represent predictive biomarkers. Here we describe a PIK3CA mutation specific nuclease-based enrichment assay, which combined with a low-cost real-time qPCR detection method, enhances assay detection sensitivity from 5% for E542K and 10% for E545K to 0.6%, and from 5% for H1047R to 0.3%. Moreover, we present a novel flexible prediction method to calculate initial mutant allele frequency in tissue biopsy and blood samples with low mutant fraction. These advancements demonstrated a quick, accurate and simple detection and quantitation of PIK3CA mutations in two breast cancer cohorts (first cohort n = 22, second cohort n = 25). Hence this simple, versatile and informative workflow could be applicable for routine diagnostic testing where quantitative results are essential, e.g. disease monitoring subject to validation in a substantial future study.

Enrichment and Analysis of ctDNA

ctDNA provided by liquid biopsy offers a promising alternative to tumor biopsy as it gives a non-invasive and «real-time» access to the cancer genome and reflects tumor intra and extra heterogeneity. ctDNA has shown growing clinical interest for cancer diagnosis, prognosis, theragnostics, therapeutic monitoring, and clonal evolution tracking. A major technical limit for ctDNA analysis from body fluids is the extremely low proportion of ctDNA compared to non-malignant cell-free DNA, underscoring the need for highly sensitive and specific detection techniques. The control of pre-analytical procedures appears essential for optimal ctDNA analysis and need to be standardized for clinical research applications. This chapter provides insights into major current technologies for ctDNA detection. Overall, PCR-based techniques are able to detect limited molecular alterations and have a high sensitivity suitable for monitoring purposes while NGS-based approaches are broad range molecular screening assays more specifically indicated for treatment selection. We briefly reviewed new technical innovations that are now available for ctDNA detection.

DNA Methylation Cancer Biomarkers: Translation to the Clinic

Carcinogenesis is accompanied by widespread DNA methylation changes within the cell. These changes are characterized by a globally hypomethylated genome with focal hypermethylation of numerous 5’-cytosine-phosphate-guanine-3’ (CpG) islands, often spanning gene promoters and first exons. Many of these epigenetic changes occur early in tumorigenesis and are highly pervasive across a tumor type. This allows DNA methylation cancer biomarkers to be suitable for early detection and also to have utility across a range of areas relevant to cancer detection and treatment. Such tests are also simple in construction, as only one or a few loci need to be targeted for good test coverage. These properties make cancer-associated DNA methylation changes very attractive for development of cancer biomarker tests with substantive clinical utility. Across the patient journey from initial detection, to treatment and then monitoring, there are several points where DNA methylation assays can inform clinical practice. Assays on surgically removed tumor tissue are useful to determine indicators of treatment resistance, prognostication of outcome, or to molecularly characterize, classify, and determine the tissue of origin of a tumor. Cancer-associated DNA methylation changes can also be detected with accuracy in the cell-free DNA present in blood, stool, urine, and other biosamples. Such tests hold great promise for the development of simple, economical, and highly specific cancer detection tests suitable for population-wide screening, with several successfully translated examples already. The ability of circulating tumor DNA liquid biopsy assays to monitor cancer in situ also allows for the ability to monitor response to therapy, to detect minimal residual disease and as an early biomarker for cancer recurrence. This review will summarize existing DNA methylation cancer biomarkers used in clinical practice across the application domains above, discuss what makes a suitable DNA methylation cancer biomarker, and identify barriers to translation. We discuss technical factors such as the analytical performance and product-market fit, factors that contribute to successful downstream investment, including geography, and how this impacts intellectual property, regulatory hurdles, and the future of the marketplace and healthcare system.

A review of methods for the detection of pathogenic microorganisms

The testing and rapid detection of pathogenic organisms is a crucial protocol in the prevention and identification of crises related to health, safety and wellbeing. Pathogen detection has become one of the most challenging aspects in the food and water industries, because of the rapid spread of waterborne and foodborne diseases in the community and at significant costs. With the prospect of inevitable population growth, and an influx of tourism to certain water bodies testing will become a requirement to control and prevent possible outbreaks of potentially fatal illnesses. The legislation is already particularly rigorous in the food industry, where failure to detect pathogenic materials represents a catastrophic event, particularly for the elderly, very young or immune-compromised population types. In spite of the need and requirement for rapid analytical testing, conventional and standard bacterial detection assays may take up to seven days to yield a result. Given the advent of new technologies, biosensors, chemical knowledge and miniaturisation of instrumentation this timescale is not acceptable. This review presents an opportunity to fill a knowledge gap for an extremely important research area; discussing the main techniques, biology, chemistry, miniaturisation, sensing and the emerging state-of-the-art research and developments for detection of pathogens in food, water, blood and faecal samples.

Fast Temperature-Gradient COLD PCR for the enrichment of the paternally inherited SNPs in cell free fetal DNA; an application to non-invasive prenatal diagnosis of β-thalassaemia

Objective

To develop a sensitive, specific, simple, cost-effective and reproducible platform for the non-invasive prenatal detection of paternally inherited alleles for β-thalassaemia. The development of such an assay is of major significance in order to replace currently-applied invasive methods containing inherent fetal loss risks.

Methods

We present a fast Temperature-Gradient Co-amplification at Lower Denaturation Temperature Polymerase Chain Reaction (fast TG COLD PCR) methodology for the detection of the paternally-inherited fetal alleles in maternal plasma. Two single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), rs7480526 (G/T) and rs968857 (G/A) that are located on the β-globin gene cluster and exhibit a high degree of heterozygosity in the Cypriot population were selected for evaluation. Seventeen maternal plasma samples from pregnancies at risk for β-thalassemia were analysed for the selected SNPs using the novel fast TG COLD PCR assay.

Results

Using fast TG COLD PCR, the paternally inherited allele in cell free fetal DNA was correctly determined for all the 17 maternal plasma samples tested, showing full agreement with the Chorionic Villus Sampling (CVS) analysis.

Conclusions

Our findings are encouraging and demonstrate the efficiency and sensitivity of fast TG COLD PCR in detecting the minor paternally-inherited fetal alleles in maternal plasma for the development of a NIPD assay for β-thalassaemia.

Enhanced detection of microsatellite instability using pre-PCR elimination of wild-type DNA homo-polymers in tissue and liquid biopsies

Detection of microsatellite-instability in colonoscopy-obtained polyps, as well as in plasma-circulating DNA, is frequently confounded by sensitivity issues due to co-existing excessive amounts of wild-type DNA. While also an issue for point mutations, this is particularly problematic for microsatellite changes, due to the high false-positive artifacts generated by polymerase slippage (stutter-bands). Here, we describe a nuclease-based approach, NaME-PrO, that uses overlapping oligonucleotides to eliminate unaltered micro-satellites at the genomic DNA level, prior to PCR. By appropriate design of the overlapping oligonucleotides, NaME-PrO eliminates WT alleles in long single-base homopolymers ranging from 10 to 27 nucleotides in length, while sparing targets containing variable-length indels at any position within the homopolymer. We evaluated 5 MSI targets individually or simultaneously, NR27, NR21, NR24, BAT25 and BAT26 using DNA from cell-lines, biopsies and circulating-DNA from colorectal cancer patients. NaME-PrO enriched altered microsatellites and detected alterations down to 0.01% allelic-frequency using high-resolution-melting, improving detection sensitivity by 500-1000-fold relative to current HRM approaches. Capillary-electrophoresis also demonstrated enhanced sensitivity and enrichment of indels 1-16 bases long. We anticipate application of this highly-multiplex-able method either with standard 5-plex reactions in conjunction with HRM/capillary electrophoresis or massively-parallel-sequencing-based detection of MSI on numerous targets for sensitive MSI-detection.

Extending Circulating Tumor DNA Analysis to Ultralow Abundance Mutations: Techniques and Challenges

Liquid biopsies that analyze circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) hold great promise in the guidance of clinical treatment for various cancers. However, the innate characteristics of ctDNA make it a difficult target: ctDNA is highly fragmented, and found at very low concentrations, both in absolute terms and relative to wildtype species. Clinically relevant target sequences often differ from the wildtype species by a single DNA base pair. These characteristics make analyzing mutant ctDNA a uniquely difficult process. Despite this, techniques have recently emerged for analyzing ctDNA, and have been used in pilot studies that showed promising results. These techniques each have various drawbacks, either in their analytical capabilities or in practical considerations, which restrict their application to many clinical situations. Many of the most promising potential applications of ctDNA require assay characteristics that are not currently available, and new techniques with these properties could have benefits in companion diagnostics, monitoring response to treatment and early detection. Here we review the current state of the art in ctDNA detection, with critical comparison of the analytical techniques themselves. We also examine the improvements required to expand ctDNA diagnostics to more advanced applications and discuss the most likely pathways for these improvements.

Histone 3.3 mutations in giant cell tumor and giant cell-rich sarcomas of bone

Mutually exclusive histone 3.3 gene mutations have been recognized in chondroblastoma and giant cell tumor of bone (GCTB), which may be useful for differential diagnostic purposes in morphologically ambiguous cases. Although more than 90% of GCTBs present histone 3.3 variants exclusively in the H3F3A gene, chondroblastoma is mutated mainly in H3F3B. In this study, we examined a series of giant cell-rich primary bone tumors, aiming to evaluate the possible diagnostic role of histone 3.3 mutations in the differential diagnosis between GCTB and giant cell-rich sarcomas. Sixteen cases of nonmetastatic GCTB, 9 GCTBs with lung metastases, and 35 giant cell-rich sarcomas were selected from our institutional archives. Eight chondroblastomas were used as controls. Direct sequencing for the presence of H3F3A and H3F3B variants in coding region between codons 1 and 42, including the hotspot codons (28, 35, and 37), was performed on DNA extracted from formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue using conventional polymerase chain reaction and fast coamplification at lower denaturation temperature-polymerase chain reaction. Overall, 24 GCTBs (96%) presented a mutation in the H3F3A gene (15 of 16 nonmetastatic and 9 of 9 metastatic). Five sarcomas harbored an H3F3A mutation (3 p.G35W, 1 p.G35L, and 1 p.G35E), and these were all secondary malignant GCTBs. In conclusion, we confirm that H3F3A mutational testing may be a useful adjunct to differentiate GCTB from giant cell-rich sarcomas. Although the presence of H3F3A mutations does not exclude with certainty a diagnosis of sarcoma, the possibility of a malignant evolution of GCTB should also be considered.

Sensitive Detection of DNA Lesions by Bulge-Enhanced Highly Specific Coamplification at Lower Denaturation Temperature Polymerase Chain Reaction

Mutagenic modifications of nucleotides or DNA lesions that result from environmental stress have proven to be associated with a variety of diseases, particularly cancer. The method for accurately detecting the lesions is therefore of great importance for biomedical research and toxicity study. We develop a sensitive and low-cost bulge-enhanced coamplification at lower denaturation temperature polymerase chain reaction (COLD-PCR) method for detecting DNA lesions (uracil and 8-oxoguanine) by combining an in vitro base excision repair (BER) pathway and COLD-PCR. The modified bases are converted to bulge via the BER pathway involving converting modified bases to an apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) site, cleavage at the AP site, and break ligation. The presence of the bulge induces a large change of the hybridization thermodynamics of double-stranded DNA, eventually enhancing the specificity of COLD-PCR. Besides, we used the free energy of hybridization as a reference to optimize the critical denaturation temperature (T_c) of COLD-PCR obtaining more specific amplification than empirical T_c. Taking advantage of the proposed bulge-enhanced COLD-PCR, we are able to identify the presence of DNA lesion-containing strands at low abundance down to 0.01%. This method also exhibits high sensitivity for glycosylase with a detection limit of 10^-4 U/mL [3 S/N (signal-to-noise ratio)] that is superior than some recently reported methods. With the design of the repair guide probe, the level of oxidative damage in genomic DNA caused by chemicals and photodynamic therapy (PDT) can be evaluated, heralding more applications in clinical diagnosis and epigenetic study.

Diagnostics based on nucleic acid sequence variant profiling: PCR, hybridization, and NGS approaches

Nucleic acid sequence variations have been implicated in many diseases, and reliable detection and quantitation of DNA/RNA biomarkers can inform effective therapeutic action, enabling precision medicine. Nucleic acid analysis technologies being translated into the clinic can broadly be classified into hybridization, PCR, and sequencing, as well as their combinations. Here we review the molecular mechanisms of popular commercial assays, and their progress in translation into in vitro diagnostics.

Optimized Multiplex Detection of 7 KRAS Mutations by Taqman Allele-Specific qPCR

Establishing the KRAS mutational status of tumor samples is essential to manage patients with colorectal or lung cancer, since these mutations preclude treatment with monoclonal anti-epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) antibodies. We report an inexpensive, rapid multiplex allele-specific qPCR method detecting the 7 most clinically relevant KRAS somatic mutations with concomitant amplification of non-mutated KRAS in tumor cells and tissues from CRC patients. Positive samples evidenced in the multiplex assay were further subjected to individual allele-specific analysis, to define the specific mutation. Reference human cancer DNA harbouring either G12A, G12C, G12D, G12R, G12S, G12V and G13D confirmed assay specificity with ≤1% sensitivity of mutant alleles. KRAS multiplex mutation analysis usefulness was also demonstrated with formalin-fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) from CRC biopsies.

CONCLUSION

Co-amplification of non-mutated DNA avoided false negatives from degraded samples. Moreover, this cost effective assay is compatible with mutation detection by DNA sequencing in FFPE tissues, but with a greater sensitivity when mutant DNA concentrations are limiting.

High-resolution melting (HRM) re-analysis of a polyposis patients cohort reveals previously undetected heterozygous and mosaic APC gene mutations

Familial adenomatous polyposis is most frequently caused by pathogenic variants in either the APC gene or the MUTYH gene. The detection rate of pathogenic variants depends on the severity of the phenotype and sensitivity of the screening method, including sensitivity for mosaic variants. For 171 patients with multiple colorectal polyps without previously detectable pathogenic variant, APC was reanalyzed in leukocyte DNA by one uniform technique: high-resolution melting (HRM) analysis. Serial dilution of heterozygous DNA resulted in a lowest detectable allelic fraction of 6 % for the majority of variants. HRM analysis and subsequent sequencing detected pathogenic fully heterozygous APC variants in 10 (6 %) of the patients and pathogenic mosaic variants in 2 (1 %). All these variants were previously missed by various conventional scanning methods. In parallel, HRM APC scanning was applied to DNA isolated from polyp tissue of two additional patients with apparently sporadic polyposis and without detectable pathogenic APC variant in leukocyte DNA. In both patients a pathogenic mosaic APC variant was present in multiple polyps. The detection of pathogenic APC variants in 7 % of the patients, including mosaics, illustrates the usefulness of a complete APC gene reanalysis of previously tested patients, by a supplementary scanning method. HRM is a sensitive and fast pre-screening method for reliable detection of heterozygous and mosaic variants, which can be applied to leukocyte and polyp derived DNA.

Single-tube, highly parallel mutation enrichment in cancer gene panels by use of temperature-tolerant COLD-PCR

BACKGROUND

Multiplexed detection of low-level mutations presents a technical challenge for many technologies, including cancer gene panels used for targeted-resequencing. Analysis of mutations below approximately 2%-5% abundance in tumors with heterogeneity, samples with stromal contamination, or biofluids is problematic owing to increased noise from sequencing errors. Technologies that reduce noise via deep sequencing unavoidably reduce throughput and increase cost. Here we provide proof of principle that coamplification at lower denaturation temperature (COLD)-PCR technology enables multiplex low-level mutation detection in cancer gene panels while retaining throughput.

METHODS

We have developed a multiplex temperature-tolerant COLD-PCR (fast-TT-COLD-PCR) approach that uses cancer gene panels developed for massively parallel sequencing. After multiplex preamplification from genomic DNA, we attach tails to all amplicons and perform fast-TT-COLD-PCR. This approach gradually increases denaturation temperatures in a step-wise fashion, such that all possible denaturation temperatures are encompassed. By introducing modified nucleotides, fast-COLD-PCR is adapted to enrich for melting temperature (Tm)-increasing mutations over all amplicons, in a single tube. Therefore, in separate reactions, both Tm-decreasing and Tm-increasing mutations are enriched.

RESULTS

Using custom-made and commercial gene panels containing 8, 50, 190, or 16 000 amplicons, we demonstrate that fast-TT-COLD-PCR enriches mutations on all examined targets simultaneously. Incorporation of deoxyinosine triphosphate (dITP)/2,6-diaminopurine triphosphate (dDTP) in place of deoxyguanosine triphosphate (dGTP)/deoxyadenosine triphosphate (dATP) enables enrichment of Tm-increasing mutations. Serial dilution experiments demonstrate a limit of detection of approximately 0.01%-0.1% mutation abundance by use of Ion-Torrent and 0.1%-0.3% by use of Sanger sequencing.

CONCLUSIONS

Fast-TT-COLD-PCR improves the limit of detection of cancer gene panels by enabling mutation enrichment in multiplex, single-tube reactions. This novel adaptation of COLD-PCR converts subclonal mutations to clonal, thereby facilitating detection and subsequent mutation sequencing.

COLD-PCR enriches low-level variant DNA sequences and increases the sensitivity of genetic testing

Detection of low-level mutations is important for cancer biomarker and therapy targets discovery, but reliable detection remains a technical challenge. The newly developed method of CO-amplification at Lower Denaturation temperature PCR (COLD-PCR) helps to circumvent this issue. This PCR-based technology preferentially enriches minor known or unknown variants present in samples with a high background of wild type DNA which often hampers the accurate identification of these minority alleles. This is a simple process that consists of lowering the temperature at the denaturation step during the PCR-cycling protocol (critical denaturation temperature, T c) and inducing DNA heteroduplexing during an intermediate step. COLD-PCR in its simplest forms does not need additional reagents or specific instrumentation and thus, can easily replace conventional PCR and at the same time improve the mutation detection sensitivity limit of downstream technologies. COLD-PCR can be applied in two basic formats: fast-COLD-PCR that can enrich T m-reducing mutations and full-COLD-PCR that can enrich all mutations, though it requires an intermediate cross-hybridization step that lengthens the thermocycling program. An improved version of full-COLD-PCR (improved and complete enrichment, ice-COLD-PCR) has also been described. Finally, most recently, we developed yet another form of COLD-PCR, temperature-tolerant-COLD-PCR, which gradually increases the denaturation temperature during the COLD-PCR reaction, enriching diverse targets using a single cycling program. This report describes practical considerations for application of fast-, full-, ice-, and temperature-tolerant-COLD-PCR for enrichment of mutations prior to downstream screening.

COLD-PCR amplification of bisulfite-converted DNA allows the enrichment and sequencing of rare un-methylated genomic regions

Aberrant hypo-methylation of DNA is evident in a range of human diseases including cancer and diabetes. Development of sensitive assays capable of detecting traces of un-methylated DNA within methylated samples can be useful in several situations. Here we describe a new approach, fast-COLD-MS-PCR, which amplifies preferentially un-methylated DNA sequences. By employing an appropriate denaturation temperature during PCR of bi-sulfite converted DNA, fast-COLD-MS-PCR enriches un-methylated DNA and enables differential melting analysis or bisulfite sequencing. Using methylation on the MGMT gene promoter as a model, it is shown that serial dilutions of controlled methylation samples lead to the reliable sequencing of un-methylated sequences down to 0.05% un-methylated-to-methylated DNA. Screening of clinical glioma tumor and infant blood samples demonstrated that the degree of enrichment of un-methylated over methylated DNA can be modulated by the choice of denaturation temperature, providing a convenient method for analysis of partially methylated DNA or for revealing and sequencing traces of un-methylated DNA. Fast-COLD-MS-PCR can be useful for the detection of loss of methylation/imprinting in cancer, diabetes or diet-related methylation changes.

KRAS mutations: analytical considerations

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the third most common cancer and the second most common cause of cancer death globally. Significant improvements in survival have been made in patients with metastasis by new therapies. For example, Cetuximab and Panitumumab are monoclonal antibodies that inhibit the epidermal growth receptor (EGFR). KRAS mutations in codon 12 and 13 are the recognized biomarkers that are analyzed in clinics before the administration of anti-EGFR therapy. Genetic analyses have revealed that mutations in KRAS predict a lack of response to Panitumumab and Cetuximab in patients with metastatic CRC (mCRC). Notably, it is estimated that 35-45% of CRC patients harbor KRAS mutations. Therefore, KRAS mutation testing should be performed in all individuals with the advanced CRC in order to identify the patients who will not respond to the monoclonal EGFR antibody inhibitors. New techniques for KRAS testing have arisen rapidly, and each technique has advantages and disadvantages. Herein, we review the latest published literature specific to KRAS mutation testing techniques. Since reliability and feasibility are important issues in clinical analyses. Therefore, this review also summarizes the effectiveness and limitations of numerous KRAS mutation testing techniques.

Non-invasive prenatal diagnosis of multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2A using COLD-PCR combined with HRM genotyping analysis from maternal serum

The multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2A (MEN2A) is a monogenic disorder characterized by an autosomal dominant pattern of inheritance which is characterized by high risk of medullary thyroid carcinoma in all mutation carriers. Although this disorder is classified as a rare disease, the patients affected have a low life quality and a very expensive and continuous treatment. At present, MEN2A is diagnosed by gene sequencing after birth, thus trying to start an early treatment and by reduction of morbidity and mortality. We first evaluated the presence of MEN2A mutation (C634Y) in serum of 25 patients, previously diagnosed by sequencing in peripheral blood leucocytes, using HRM genotyping analysis. In a second step, we used a COLD-PCR approach followed by HRM genotyping analysis for non-invasive prenatal diagnosis of a pregnant woman carrying a fetus with a C634Y mutation. HRM analysis revealed differences in melting curve shapes that correlated with patients diagnosed for MEN2A by gene sequencing analysis with 100% accuracy. Moreover, the pregnant woman carrying the fetus with the C634Y mutation revealed a melting curve shape in agreement with the positive controls in the COLD-PCR study. The mutation was confirmed by sequencing of the COLD-PCR amplification product. In conclusion, we have established a HRM analysis in serum samples as a new primary diagnosis method suitable for the detection of C634Y mutations in MEN2A patients. Simultaneously, we have applied the increase of sensitivity of COLD-PCR assay approach combined with HRM analysis for the non-invasive prenatal diagnosis of C634Y fetal mutations using pregnant women serum.

Competitive amplification of differentially melting amplicons (CADMA) improves KRAS hotspot mutation testing in colorectal cancer

Background

Cancer is an extremely heterogeneous group of diseases traditionally categorized according to tissue of origin. However, even among patients with the same cancer subtype the cellular alterations at the molecular level are often very different. Several new therapies targeting specific molecular changes found in individual patients have initiated the era of personalized therapy and significantly improved patient care. In metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) a selected group of patients with wild-type KRAS respond to antibodies against the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). Testing for KRAS mutations is now required prior to anti-EGFR treatment, however, less sensitive methods based on conventional PCR regularly fail to detect KRAS mutations in clinical samples.

Methods

We have developed sensitive and specific assays for detection of the seven most common KRAS mutations based on a novel methodology named Competitive Amplification of Differentially Melting Amplicons (CADMA). The clinical applicability of these assays was assessed by analyzing 100 colorectal cancer samples, for which KRAS mutation status has been evaluated by the commercially available TheraScreen® KRAS mutation kit.

Results

The CADMA assays were sensitive to at least 0.5% mutant alleles in a wild-type background when using 50 nanograms of DNA in the reactions. Consensus between CADMA and the TheraScreen kit was observed in 96% of the colorectal cancer samples. In cases where disagreement was observed the CADMA result could be confirmed by a previously published assay based on TaqMan probes and by fast COLD-PCR followed by Sanger sequencing.

Conclusions

The high analytical sensitivity and specificity of CADMA may increase diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of KRAS mutation testing in mCRC patients.

COLD-PCR and innovative microarray substrates for detecting and genotyping MPL exon 10 W515 substitutions

BACKGROUND

Myeloproliferative neoplasms (MPNs) include polycythemia vera (PV), essential thrombocythemia (ET), and primary myelofibrosis (PMF). Somatic mutations in exon 10 of the MPL (myeloproliferative leukemia virus oncogene) gene, mainly substitutions encoding W515 variants, have recently been described in a minority of patients with ET or PMF. We optimized analytically sensitive methods for detecting and genotyping MPL variants.

METHODS

We used DNA previously isolated from circulating granulocytes of 60 patients with MPN that had previously been analyzed by high-resolution melting (HRM), direct sequencing, and the TaqMan allelic-discrimination assay. We developed conditions for enriching tumor mutant alleles with COLD-PCR (coamplification at lower denaturation temperature PCR) and coupled it with direct sequencing. Assays were designed for identifying MPL W515 substitutions with full COLD-PCR protocols. In parallel, we used innovative microarray substrates to develop assays for evaluating the mutant burden in granulocyte cells.

RESULTS

Mutations that were present at very low levels in patients who had previously been scored as having an MPL variant by HRM and as wild type by direct sequencing were successfully identified in granulocyte DNA. Notably, the microarray approach displayed analytical sensitivities of 0.1% to 5% mutant allele, depending on the particular mutation. This analytical sensitivity is similar to that obtained with COLD-PCR. The assay requires no enrichment strategy and allows both the characterization of each variant allele and the evaluation of its proportion in every patient.

CONCLUSIONS

These procedures, which are transferable to clinical diagnostic laboratories, can be used for detecting very low proportions of minority mutant alleles that cannot be identified by other, conventional methods.

Targeting tyrosine kinases in cancer: the converging roles of cytopathology and molecular pathology in the era of genomic medicine

Because of knowledge gained in the field of cancer biology, clinicians are currently witnessing an explosion of molecular tests as companion diagnostics to targeted therapies against growth factor receptors and their signaling pathways. Such tests are being applied increasingly to cytology specimens as essential components of genomic medicine, because less invasive diagnostic procedures are becoming the norm. The objective of this review was to present an overview of the current and future role of cytopathology in molecular diagnostics, including the adequacy of cytology specimens for such studies. The authors also discuss the critical methodologic aspects of the molecular assays used for the selection of tyrosine kinase treatment for oncology patients.

Temperature-tolerant COLD-PCR reduces temperature stringency and enables robust mutation enrichment

BACKGROUND

Low-level mutations in clinical tumor samples often reside below mutation detection limits, thus leading to false negatives that may impact clinical diagnosis and patient management. COLD-PCR (coamplification at lower denaturation temperature PCR) is a technology that magnifies unknown mutations during PCR, thus enabling downstream mutation detection. However, a practical difficulty in applying COLD-PCR has been the requirement for strict control of the denaturation temperature for a given sequence, to within ±0.3 °C. This requirement precludes simultaneous mutation enrichment in sequences of substantially different melting temperature (T(m)) and limits the technique to a single sequence at a time. We present a temperature-tolerant (TT) approach (TT-COLD-PCR) that reduces this obstacle.

METHODS

We describe thermocycling programs featuring a gradual increase of the denaturation temperature during COLD-PCR. This approach enabled enrichment of mutations when the cycling achieves the appropriate critical denaturation temperature of each DNA amplicon that is being amplified. Validation was provided for KRAS (v-Ki-ras2 Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene homolog) and TP53 (tumor protein p53) exons 6-9 by use of dilutions of mutated DNA, clinical cancer samples, and plasma-circulating DNA.

RESULTS

A single thermocycling program with a denaturation-temperature window of 2.5-3.0 °C enriches mutations in all DNA amplicons simultaneously, despite their different T(m)s. Mutation enrichments of 6-9-fold were obtained with TT-full-COLD-PCR. Higher mutation enrichments were obtained for the other 2 forms of COLD-PCR, fast-COLD-PCR, and ice-COLD-PCR.

CONCLUSIONS

Low-level mutations in diverse amplicons with different T(m)s can be mutation enriched via TT-COLD-PCR provided that their T(m)s fall within the denaturation-temperature window applied during amplification. This approach enables simultaneous enrichment of mutations in several amplicons and increases significantly the versatility of COLD-PCR.

Potential clinical significance of plasma-based KRAS mutation analysis using the COLD-PCR/TaqMan(®) -MGB probe genotyping method

Despite the improved ability to detect mutations in recent years, tissue specimens cannot always be procured in a clinical setting, particularly from patients with recurrence of tumors or metastasis. Therefore, the aim of this study was to investigate whether plasma is able to be used for mutation analysis instead of tissue specimens. We collected plasma from 62 patients with colorectal cancer (CRC) prior to treatment. DNA extracted from plasma and matched tumor tissues were obtained. Mutations in KRAS were amplified from the tissue specimens and sequenced by regular polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and co-amplification at lower denaturation temperature (COLD)-PCR. Plasma KRAS gene mutation on codon 12 (GGT>GAT) was detected using a nested COLD-PCR/TaqMan(®) -MGB probe. Mutations in plasma and matched tumors were compared. KRAS mutation on codon 12 (GGT>GAT) was found in 13 (21.0%) plasma specimens and 12 (19.4%) matched tumor tissues. The consistency of KRAS mutations between plasma and tumors was 75% (9/12), which indicated a high correlation between the mutations detected in plasma DNA and the mutations detected in the corresponding tumor DNA (P<0.001; correlation index, k=0.649). Notably, four (6.5%) patients with plasma DNA mutations had no detectable KRAS mutations in the corresponding primary tumors, and three (4.8%) patients with tumor DNA mutations had no detectable KRAS mutations in the corresponding plasma DNA samples. Thus, KRAS mutations in plasma DNA correlate with the mutation status in matched tumor tissues of patients with CRC. Our study provides evidence to suggest that plasma DNA may be used as a potential medium for KRAS mutation analysis in CRC using the COLD-PCR/TaqMan-MGB probe method.

COLD-PCR enrichment of rare cancer mutations prior to targeted amplicon resequencing

BACKGROUND

Despite widespread interest in next-generation sequencing (NGS), the adoption of personalized clinical genomics and mutation profiling of cancer specimens is lagging, in part because of technical limitations. Tumors are genetically heterogeneous and often contain normal/stromal cells, features that lead to low-abundance somatic mutations that generate ambiguous results or reside below NGS detection limits, thus hindering the clinical sensitivity/specificity standards of mutation calling. We applied COLD-PCR (coamplification at lower denaturation temperature PCR), a PCR methodology that selectively enriches variants, to improve the detection of unknown mutations before NGS-based amplicon resequencing.

METHODS

We used both COLD-PCR and conventional PCR (for comparison) to amplify serially diluted mutation-containing cell-line DNA diluted into wild-type DNA, as well as DNA from lung adenocarcinoma and colorectal cancer samples. After amplification of TP53 (tumor protein p53), KRAS (v-Ki-ras2 Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene homolog), IDH1 [isocitrate dehydrogenase 1 (NADP(+)), soluble], and EGFR (epidermal growth factor receptor) gene regions, PCR products were pooled for library preparation, bar-coded, and sequenced on the Illumina HiSeq 2000.

RESULTS

In agreement with recent findings, sequencing errors by conventional targeted-amplicon approaches dictated a mutation-detection limit of approximately 1%-2%. Conversely, COLD-PCR amplicons enriched mutations above the error-related noise, enabling reliable identification of mutation abundances of approximately 0.04%. Sequencing depth was not a large factor in the identification of COLD-PCR-enriched mutations. For the clinical samples, several missense mutations were not called with conventional amplicons, yet they were clearly detectable with COLD-PCR amplicons. Tumor heterogeneity for the TP53 gene was apparent.

CONCLUSIONS

As cancer care shifts toward personalized intervention based on each patient's unique genetic abnormalities and tumor genome, we anticipate that COLD-PCR combined with NGS will elucidate the role of mutations in tumor progression, enabling NGS-based analysis of diverse clinical specimens within clinical practice.