Study of the antibody response against Mycobacterium tuberculosis antigens in Warao Amerindian children in Venezuela

Evaluation of serological assays for the diagnosis of childhood tuberculosis disease: a study protocol

BACKGROUND

Tuberculosis (TB) poses a major public health challenge, particularly in children. A substantial proportion of children with TB disease remain undetected and unconfirmed. Therefore, there is an urgent need for a highly sensitive point-of-care test. This study aims to assess the performance of serological assays based on various antigen targets and antibody properties in distinguishing children (0-18 years) with TB disease (1) from healthy TB-exposed children, (2) children with non-TB lower respiratory tract infections, and (3) from children with TB infection.

METHODS

The study will use biobanked plasma samples collected from three prospective multicentric diagnostic observational studies: the Childhood TB in Switzerland (CITRUS) study, the Pediatric TB Research Network in Spain (pTBred), and the Procalcitonin guidance to reduce antibiotic treatment of lower respiratory tract infections in children and adolescents (ProPAED) study. Included are children diagnosed with TB disease or infection, healthy TB-exposed children, and sick children with non-TB lower respiratory tract infection. Serological multiplex assays will be performed to identify M. tuberculosis antigen-specific antibody features, including isotypes, subclasses, Fc receptor (FcR) binding, and IgG glycosylation.

DISCUSSION

The findings from this study will help to design serological assays for diagnosing TB disease in children. Importantly, those assays could easily be developed as low-cost point-of-care tests, thereby offering a potential solution for resource-constrained settings.

CLINICALTRIALS

GOV IDENTIFIER

NCT03044509.

Differential levels of anti-Mycobacterium tuberculosis-specific IgAs in saliva of household contacts with latent tuberculosis infection

Introduction

Mucosal immunity is strongly elicited in early stages of many respiratory and enteric infections; however, its role in tuberculosis pathogenesis has been scarcely explored. We aimed to investigate Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) specific IgA levels in saliva in different stages of latent Tuberculosis Infection (TBI).

Methodology

A multiplex bead-based Luminex immunoassay was developed to detect specific IgA against 12 highly immunogenic Mtb antigens. A prospective cohort of household contacts (>14 years) of pulmonary TB cases was established in Santiago, Chile. Contacts were classified as Mtb-infected or not depending on serial interferon-γ release assay results. Saliva samples were collected and tested at baseline and at a 12-week follow-up.

Results

Mtb-specific IgA was detectable at all visits in all participants (n = 168), including the "non-Mtb infected" (n = 64). Significantly higher median levels of IgA were found in the "Mtb infected" compared to the uninfected for anti-lipoarabinomannan (LAM) (110 vs. 84.8 arbitrary units (AU), p < 0.001), anti-PstS1 (117 vs. 83 AU, p < 0.001), anti-Cell Membrane Fraction (CMF) (140 vs. 103 AU, p < 0.001) and anti-Culture Filtrate Proteins (CFP) (median 125 vs. 96 AU, p < 0.001), respectively. Nonetheless, the discriminatory performance of these specific mucosal IgA for TBI diagnosis was low.

Conclusion

Saliva holds Mtb-specific IgA against several antigens with increased levels for anti-LAM, anti-PstS1, anti-CMF and anti-CFP found in household contacts with an established TBI. The role of these mucosal antibodies in TB pathogenesis, and their kinetics in different stages of Mtb infection merits further exploring.

Diagnostic Potential of the Serological Response to Synthetic Peptides from Mycobacterium tuberculosis Antigens for Discrimination Between Active and Latent Tuberculosis Infections

Diagnosis and treatment of active tuberculosis (ATB) as well as latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) are required for effective tuberculosis (TB) control, especially in TB endemic area. The usefulness of conventional tests to distinguish between ATB and LTBI has remained challenging. The present study was aimed to demonstrate the usefulness of the serological response to synthetic peptides from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) antigens for discrimination between ATB and LTBI in Warao Amerindians. Serum IgG antibody levels were measured by the indirect ELISA assay using 22 designed and synthesized peptides derived from immunogenic Mtb ESAT-6 and Ag85A proteins. A total of 211 adult Warao Amerindians were included; cases with active TB (ATB, n = 75), latent TB infection (LTBI, n = 85) and non-infected (NI, n = 51). The approach’s diagnostic information was compared using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves. For ATB diagnostic performance between ATB and NI; ESAT-6; P-12037 had 100% of sensitivity (AUC = 0.812; 0.733 to 0.891 95% CI); and Ag85A; P-10997 had 100% of specificity (AUC = 0.691; 0.597 to 0.785 95% CI); and ATB and LTBI; Ag85A; P-29878 had 100% of sensitivity (AUC = 0.741; 0.666–0.817 95% CI), and P-29879 had 99% of specificity (AUC = 0.679; 0.593–0.765 95% CI). While that ESAT-6 P-12037 also allowed differentiation between LTBI and NI or healthy ones. It had 98.8% of sensitivity and 98.0% of specificity (AUC = 0.640; 0.545–0.735 95% CI). The potential of combination-antigen immunoassays with peptides could discriminate between Warao Amerindians with ATB, LTBI and NI. Further validation of this approach could lead to developing a complementary tool for rapid diagnosis of TB infections.

ESAT-6 and Ag85A Synthetic Peptides as Candidates for an Immunodiagnostic Test in Children with a Clinical Suspicion of Tuberculosis

Background

Tuberculosis (TB) is being underdetected in children as most are smear-negative. This work was aimed at evaluating ESAT-6 and Ag85A synthetic peptides' serodiagnostic potential for diagnosing children having a clinical suspicion of TB.

Methods

The study involved 438 children: 77 Creole nonindigenous (13 suspected of having TB and 64 healthy ones) and 361 Warao indigenous children (39 suspected of TB and 322 healthy children). The approach's diagnostic information was compared using operational characteristics and receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curves.

Results

Ag85A P-29879 had 94.6% sensitivity (AUC = 0.741: 0.651 to 0.819 95% CI) in indigenous children. ESAT-6 P-12036 and P-12037 had 100% and 92.3% of sensitivity (AUC = 0.929: 0.929: 0.846 to 0.975 95% CI and 0.791: 63.9 to 98.7 95% CI, respectively) in Creole children. ESAT-6 peptides also allowed a differentiation between children with TB and healthy ones.

Conclusions

Further validation of this approach could lead to developing a complementary tool for rapid TB diagnosis in children.

Host-Based Biomarkers in Saliva for the Diagnosis of Pulmonary Tuberculosis in Children: A Mini-Review

The diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) in children remains a significant challenge due to its paucibacillary nature, non-specificity of symptoms and suboptimal sensitivity of available diagnostic methods. In young children particularly, it is difficult to obtain high-quality sputum specimens for testing, with this group the least likely to be diagnosed, while most at risk of severe disease. The World Health Organization (WHO) has prioritized research into rapid biomarker-based tests for TB using easily obtainable non-sputum samples, such as saliva. However, the role of biomarkers in saliva for diagnosing TB in children has not been fully explored. In this mini-review, we discuss the value of saliva as a diagnostic specimen in children given its ready availability and non-invasive nature of collection, and review the literature on the use of host-based biomarkers in saliva for diagnosing active pulmonary TB in adults and children. Based on available data from adult studies, we highlight that combinations of cytokines and other proteins show promise in reaching WHO-endorsed target product profiles for new TB triage tests. Given the lack of pediatric research on host biomarkers in saliva and the differing immune response to TB infection between children and adults, we recommend that pediatric studies are now performed to discover and validate salivary host biosignatures for diagnosing pulmonary TB in children. Future directions for pediatric saliva studies are discussed, with suggestions for technologies that can be applied for salivary biomarker discovery and point-of-care test development.

Immunologic evaluation and validation of methods using synthetic peptides derived from Mycobacterium tuberculosis for the diagnosis of tuberculosis infection

The goal of this study was to demonstrate the usefulness of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the serodiagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) and extrapulmonary TB (EPTB). This assay used 20 amino acid-long, non-overlapped synthetic peptides that spanned the complete Mycobacterium tuberculosis ESAT-6 and Ag85A sequences. The validation cohort consisted of 1,102 individuals who were grouped into the following five diagnostic groups: 455 patients with PTB, 60 patients with EPTB, 40 individuals with non-EPTB, 33 individuals with leprosy and 514 healthy controls. For the PTB group, two ESAT-6 peptides (12033 and 12034) had the highest sensitivity levels of 96.9% and 96.2%, respectively, and an Ag85A-peptide (29878) was the most specific (97.4%) in the PTB groups. For the EPTB group, two Ag85A peptides (11005 and 11006) were observed to have a sensitivity of 98.3% and an Ag85A-peptide (29878) was also the most specific (96.4%). When combinations of peptides were used, such as 12033 and 12034 or 11005 and 11006, 99.5% and 100% sensitivities in the PTB and EPTB groups were observed, respectively. In conclusion, for a cohort that consists entirely of individuals from Venezuela, a multi-antigen immunoassay using highly sensitive ESAT-6 and Ag85A peptides alone and in combination could be used to more rapidly diagnose PTB and EPTB infection.

Genetic polymorphism and immune response to tuberculosis in indigenous populations: a brief review

We systematically reviewed studies of the immune response to tuberculosis and the genetic polymorphisms associated with Th1- or Th2-mediated cytokine expression in indigenous populations. A bibliographic search was performed on the Medline and ISI databases and included studies published between January 1980 and October 2011. The search terms were tuberculosis, American Indians, Amerindian, indigenous, Indians, native people, aboriginal, immun*, host immune, immune response, cytokine*, polymorphism*, and gene. Regardless of their design, studies that evaluated immunoglobulin, cytokine levels and genetic polymorphisms that altered cytokine expression were included. Thirteen studies met the inclusion criteria. The majority of studies were performed in Latin America, and five investigated the Warao ethnic group of Venezuela. Most of the investigations indirectly evaluated the immune response. Higher anergy to the tuberculin skin test, higher IgG4 and IgM levels, higher IL-5 production and lower TNF-α, IL-12p40 and IFN-γ production were found in the indigenous populations. The studies also reported a predominantly Th2-type response in these populations and a possibly higher susceptibility to tuberculosis. A better understanding of the relevant genetic polymorphisms and their role in immune regulation would help to clarify the immunogenetic mechanisms of TB infection in these populations. This information would be useful for identifying new treatments and preventing infection and progression to active disease.

Antibody responses to mycobacterial antigens in children with tuberculosis: challenges and potential diagnostic value

The identification of easily detectable biomarkers for active tuberculosis (TB) is a global health priority. Such biomarkers would be of particular value in childhood TB, which poses greater diagnostic challenges than adult TB. Serum antibodies can be detected by simple formats that provide extremely rapid results. However, attempts to develop accurate serodiagnostic tests for TB have been unsuccessful. Whereas antibody responses to mycobacterial antigens in adult TB have been studied extensively and reviewed, the same cannot be said for serologic data in pediatric populations. Here we appraise studies on serological responses in childhood TB and discuss findings and limitations in the context of the developing immune system, the age range, and the spectrum of TB manifestations. We found that the antibody responses to mycobacterial antigens in childhood TB can vary widely, with sensitivities and specificities ranging from 14% to 85% and from 86% to 100%, respectively. We conclude that the limitations in serodiagnostic studies of childhood TB are manifold, thereby restricting the interpretation of currently available data. Concerns about the methodology used in published studies suggest that conclusions about the eventual value of serodiagnosis cannot be made at this time. However, the available data suggest a potential adjunctive value for serology in the diagnosis of childhood TB. Despite the difficulties noted in this field, there is optimism that the application of novel antigens and the integration of those factors which contribute to the serological responses in childhood TB can lead to useful future diagnostics.

Helminthic therapy: using worms to treat immune-mediated disease

There is an epidemic of immune-mediated disease in highly-developed industrialized countries. Such diseases, like inflammatory bowel disease, multiple sclerosis and asthma increase in prevalence as populations adopt modern hygienic practices. These practices prevent exposure to parasitic worms (helminths). Epidemiologic studies suggest that people who carry helminths have less immune-mediated disease. Mice colonized with helminths are protected from disease in models of colitis, encephalitis, Type 1 diabetes and asthma. Clinical trials show that exposure to helminths reduce disease activity in patients with ulcerative colitis or Crohn's disease. This chapter reviews some of the work showing that colonization with helminths alters immune responses, against dysregulated inflammation. These helminth-host immune interactions have potentially important implications for the treatment of immune-mediated diseases.

Humoral immunity in tuberculin skin test anergy and its role in high-risk persons exposed to active tuberculosis

The most common test to identify latent tuberculosis is the tuberculin skin test that detects T cell responses of delayed type hypersensitivity type IV. Since it produces false negative reactions in active tuberculosis or in high-risk persons exposed to tuberculosis patients as shown in this report, we studied antibody profiles to explain the anergy of such responses in high-risk individuals without active infection. Our results showed that humoral immunity against tuberculin, regardless of the result of the tuberculin skin test is important for protection from active tuberculosis and that the presence of high antibody titers is a more reliable indicator of infection latency suggesting that latency can be based on the levels of antibodies together with in vitro proliferation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells in the presence of the purified protein derivative. Importantly, anti-tuberculin IgG antibody levels mediate the anergy described herein, which could also prevent reactivation of disease in high-risk individuals with high antibody titers. Such anti-tuberculin IgG antibodies were also found associated with blocking and/or stimulation of in vitro cultures of PBMC with tuberculin. In this regard, future studies need to establish if immune responses to Mycobacterium tuberculosis can generate a broad spectrum of reactions either toward Th1 responses favoring stimulation by cytokines or by antibodies and those toward diminished responses by Th2 cytokines or blocking by antibodies; possibly involving mechanisms of antibody dependent protection from Mtb by different subclasses of IgG.

Humoral immune response against 38- and 16-kDa mycobacterial antigens in childhood tuberculosis

Several enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) based on mycobacterial antigens have been tried for the rapid diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB). In this study, the value of the 16 and 38-kDa mycobacterial antigens in the diagnosis of TB was investigated in pediatric patients in Izmir, Turkey in whom they were found using clinical and/or bacteriological methods. A commercial ELISA kit was used for measuring IgG against 38 and 16-kDa recombinant antigens. The humoral immune response was analyzed in a group of 32 TB patients (24 pulmonary, 3 lymphadenitis and 2 pleuritis, 2 meningitis and a disseminated TB) and in control groups consisting of 20 healthy children and 20 pulmonary diseases other than TB cases. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and the negative predictive value of the test were found to be 25%, 90%, 66.7%, and 60%, respectively, in the TB cases. The ELISA test shows very good specificity, but low level of sensitivity and negative predict value. It was thought that it might be used in combination with other methods to increase diagnostic accuracy, especially for culture-negative TB pediatric cases, which are difficult to diagnose.

Increased levels of immunological markers in the respiratory tract but not in serum correlate with active pulmonary mycobacterial infection in mice

Immunological tests for the diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB) have relied mostly on detection of immune markers in serum or release of cytokines by mononuclear cells in vitro. These tests, although useful, sometimes fail to discriminate between active infection and contact with mycobacteria or vaccination. TB is primarily a disease of the lung, and therefore identification of immunological markers in the respiratory tract will be more likely to reflect the infection status or disease activity. In this study, it is demonstrated that active infection of mice with Mycobacterium bovis bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG), but not exposure to heat-killed BCG, induced production of interleukin-12 (IL-12), interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) or soluble tumour necrosis factor receptors (sTNFRs) locally in the lungs, as detected in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid. There was a strong correlation between bacterial growth in the lung and levels of sTNFRs, and to some extent IL-12 and IFN-gamma, in BAL fluid. Furthermore, sTNFR levels increased significantly in BAL fluid after reactivation of controlled infection with dexamethasone, and this correlated with increased bacterial growth in the lungs. Finally, infection, but not exposure to non-replicating mycobacteria, induced specific IgG and IgA in BAL fluid. Elevated levels of all biomarkers measured were also detected in the serum, but correlation with infection was not as clear as in the case of BAL fluid. Taken together, the detection of sTNFRs and mycobacterium-specific antibodies, especially IgA, locally in the lungs could be used as immunological markers for the diagnosis of TB.

Assessment of three commercially available serologic assays for detection of antibodies to Mycobacterium tuberculosis and identification of active tuberculosis

Tuberculosis (TB) caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis remains a major world disease, with approximately 9 million new cases each year. Identification and treatment of active disease are essential for TB control. Serology may offer increased detection of active disease in patients with a positive tuberculin skin test (TST) or QuantiFERON-TB (QFT-G). The InBios Active TbDetect immunoglobulin G (IgG) enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), IBL M. tuberculosis IgG ELISA, and Anda Biologics TB ELISAs were evaluated for the ability to detect M. tuberculosis antibodies in patients with active disease. Agreement, sensitivity, and specificity for each ELISA were determined and compared to those for culture or amplified direct detection and M. tuberculosis low-risk control patients. The InBios Active TbDetect ELISA had an agreement of 96.2%, a sensitivity of 83.3%, and a specificity of 98.9%. The IBL M. tuberculosis ELISA had an agreement of 84.0%, a sensitivity of 5.6%, and a specificity of 100.0%. The agreement, sensitivity, and specificity of the Anda Biologics TB ELISA were 74.2%, 83.3%, and 72.0%, respectively. The sensitivity for detecting M. tuberculosis antibodies in human immunodeficiency virus-associated TB was 50% for both the InBios Active TbDetect ELISA and the Anda Biologics TB ELISA and 0% for the IBL M. tuberculosis ELISA. The positivity rates for InBios Active TbDetect ELISA, IBL M. tuberculosis ELISA, and Anda Biologics TB ELISA in latently infected individuals positive by TST and/or QFT-G were 5.1%, 0.0%, and 30.8%, respectively. It can be concluded that the InBios Active TbDetect IgG ELISA is superior to the other ELISAs in accurately detecting active TB.

Progress in serodiagnosis of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection

One-third of the world population is estimated to have Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection. Accurate and timely identification of infected individuals is critical for treatment and control. The current diagnostic methods lack the desired sensitivity and specificity, require sophisticated equipment and skilled workforce or take weeks to yield results. Diagnosis of extrapulmonary TB, TB-HIV co-infection, childhood TB and sputum smear-negative pulmonary TB pose serious challenges. Interest in developing serodiagnostic methods is increasing because detection of antibody is rapid, simple and relatively inexpensive, and does not require a living cell for detection. Three types of tests, namely screening tests to overcome diagnostic delay, specific tests for diagnosis of extrapulmonary TB and other bacteriologically negative cases, and tests for vaccine-induced immunity need critical consideration. Several factors must be considered to develop serodiagnostic methods for TB. Antigen recognition by infected individuals is highly heterogeneous due to stage of disease, differences in HLA types, strain of the bacilli, health of the patient and bacillary load. With advances in molecular biological techniques, a number of novel antigens have been identified. Some of these antigens have proven valuable in detecting specific antibodies in some of the most challenging TB patients. The best example is a fusion protein containing several M. tuberculosis proteins (e.g. CFP-10, MTB8, MTB48, MTB81 and the 38-kDa protein) which showed encouraging results in detecting antibodies in sera of patients, including TB-HIV co-infection. This review presents progress made in the serodiagnosis of TB during the last decade.

The secretory immunoglobulin A response to Mycobacterium tuberculosis in a childhood population

We report on the measurement of saliva anti-Purified Protein Derivative sIgA and 38kDa antibodies from 127 children, of whom 31 were strong tuberculosis suspects and 96 were healthy contact children. The results concerning the percentage of children with antibody reactivity to PPD and 38kDa antigens showed that, of these 2 antigens, 38kDa induced higher reactivity in patients positive and negative for the Tuberculin Skin Test (28% and 16.6%, respectively) in comparison to controls positive and negative for the TST (11.7% and 7.1%, respectively). There was a statistically significant difference between patients positive and controls negative for the TST. In relation to the Purified Protein Derivative antigen, while 14.2% of patients positive for the TST showed antibody reactivity to the PPD antigen, no patients negative for the TST had reactivity to this antigen. The findings suggest that these two antigens seem be associated with a different development of the mucosal defence mechanisms mediated by sIgA against Mycobacterium tuberculosis.

Diversity of the MBL2 gene in various Brazilian populations and the case of selection at the mannose-binding lectin locus

The mannose binding lectin (MBL2) polymorphism is responsible for a common immunodeficiency in the human species. There were suggestions that the MBL2 polymorphism has been under balancing selection, based on the high global frequency of alleles generating MBL deficiency and on the worldwide distribution of diseases negatively associated with them. To describe the distribution of MBL2 allelic haplotypes in Brazilian populations and to discuss the evolution of this polymorphism, we analyzed six South Brazilian populations (152 Guarani Amerindian, 239 Kaingang Amerindian, 107 admixed, Brazilian 32 Afro-Brazilian, 202 Euro-Brazilian and 16 Oriental-Brazilian). Eight haplotypes were observed: MBL2*HYPA, LYQA, LYPA, LXPA, LYPB, LYQC, HYPD, and LYPD. In addition, through sequencing of the promoter and exon 1 from Amerindian and Oriental individuals, three new single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were found in the MBL2 promoter region in the Kaingang. Analysis of the sequencing data by neutrality tests (Tajima's D and Fu and Li's D* and F*) revealed no deviation from selective neutrality equilibrium in the Guarani and Kaingang. Significant Fay and Wu's H results are explained by the recent gene flow in these populations. Contrarily to previous thoughts, stochastic evolutionary factors seem therefore to have had a predominant role in shaping the MBL2 polymorphism, at least in the Amerindians.

Teste tuberculínico na estimativa da prevalência de infecção por Mycobacterium tuberculosis em populações indígenas do continente americano: uma revisão da literatura

Realizou-se revisão sistemática da literatura sobre trabalhos que utilizaram PPD para estimar a prevalência e o risco de infecção tuberculosa entre os povos indígenas do continente americano. Foram consultadas as bases de dados MEDLINE e LILACS, utilizando-se a combinação dos seguintes descritores: "tuberculosis", "south american indians", "north american indians", "tuberculin skin test", "PPD", "risk assessment" e "BCG vaccine", para o período de 1974/2004. Foram incluídos estudos longitudinais e seccionais que consideraram como desfecho a prevalência de infecção por M. tuberculosis definida por reações > 5mm e > 10mm. Foi possível localizar 54 artigos, dos quais 16 foram incluídos nesta revisão. Com base nos artigos selecionados, foram contabilizadas 13.186 pessoas, sendo 50% menores de 15 anos. A prevalência oscilou de 0 a 93,4% e o risco de infecção de 0 a 35,4%. A análise da heterogeneidade nas condições ambientais e nos métodos utilizados para estimar a infecção entre os estudos revisados demonstrou que o teste tuberculínico foi oportuno em decisões clínicas (p.ex., início da quimioprofilaxia), e que os inquéritos tuberculínicos são úteis para avaliar as medidas de controle da tuberculose entre os povos indígenas.