Subject-Based versus Population-Based Care after Radiation Exposure

The TLR2/TLR6 ligand FSL-1 mitigates radiation-induced hematopoietic injury in mice and nonhuman primates

Thrombocytopenia, hemorrhage, anemia, and infection are life-threatening issues following accidental or intentional radiation exposure. Since few therapeutics are available, safe and efficacious small molecules to mitigate radiation-induced injury need to be developed. Our previous study showed the synthetic TLR2/TLR6 ligand fibroblast stimulating lipopeptide (FSL-1) prolonged survival and provided MyD88-dependent mitigation of hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome (H-ARS) in mice. Although mice and humans differ in TLR number, expression, and function, nonhuman primate (NHP) TLRs are like those of humans; therefore, studying both animal models is critical for drug development. The objectives of this study were to determine the efficacy of FSL-1 on hematopoietic recovery in small and large animal models subjected to sublethal total body irradiation and investigate its mechanism of action. In mice, we demonstrate a lack of adverse effects, an easy route of delivery (subcutaneous) and efficacy in promoting hematopoietic progenitor cell proliferation by FSL-1. NHP given radiation, followed a day later with a single subcutaneous administration of FSL-1, displayed no adversity but showed elevated hematopoietic cells. Our analyses revealed that FSL-1 promoted red blood cell development and induced soluble effectors following radiation exposure. Cytologic analysis of bone marrow aspirates revealed a striking enhancement of mononuclear progenitor cells in FSL-1-treated NHP. Combining the efficacy of FSL-1 in promoting hematopoietic cell recovery with the lack of adverse effects induced by a single administration supports the application of FSL-1 as a viable countermeasure against H-ARS.

Where are the medical countermeasures against the ARS and DEARE? A current topic relative to an animal model research platform, radiation exposure context, the acute and delayed effects of acute exposure, and the FDA animal rule

PURPOSE

A question echoed by the National Biodefense Science Board (NBSB) in 2010, remains a reasonable question in 2023; 'Where are the Countermeasures?'. A critical path for development of medical countermeasures (MCM) against acute, radiation-induced organ-specific injury within the acute radiation syndrome (ARS) and the delayed effects of acute radiation exposure (DEARE) requires the recognition of problems and solutions inherent in the path to FDA approval under the Animal Rule. Keep Rule number one in mind, It's not easy.

CONSIDERATIONS

The current topic herein is focused on defining the nonhuman primate model(s) for efficient MCM development relative to consideration of prompt and delayed exposure in the context of the nuclear scenario. The rhesus macaque is a predictive model for human exposure of partial-body irradiation with marginal bone marrow sparing that allows definition of the multiple organ injury in the acute radiation syndrome (ARS) and the delayed effects of acute radiation exposure (DEARE). The continued definition of natural history is required to delineate an associative or causal interaction within the concurrent multi-organ injury characteristic of the ARS and DEARE. A more efficient development of organ specific MCM for both pre-exposure and post-exposure prophylaxis to include acute radiation-induced combined injury requires closing critical gaps in knowledge and urgent support to rectify the national shortage of nonhuman primates. The rhesus macaque is a validated, predictive model of the human response to prompt and delayed radiation exposure, medical management and MCM treatment. A rational approach to further development of the cynomolgus macaque as a comparable model is urgently required for continued development of MCM for FDA approval.

CONCLUSION

It is imperative to examine the key variables relative to animal model development and validation, The pharmacokinetics, pharmacodynamics and exposure profiles, of candidate MCM relative to route, administration schedule and optimal efficacy define the fully effective dose. The conduct of adequate and well-controlled pivotal efficacy studies as well as safety and toxicity studies support approval under the FDA Animal Rule and label definition for human use.

Determination of Lethality Curve for Cobalt-60 Gamma-Radiation Source in Rhesus Macaques Using Subject-Based Supportive Care

Well-characterized and validated animal models are required for the development of medical countermeasures (MCMs) for acute radiation syndrome to mitigate injury due to high doses of total- or partial-body irradiation. Animal models used in MCM development must reflect a radiation dose- and time-dependent relationship, clinical presentation, and pathogenesis of organ injuries in humans. The objective of the current study was to develop the lethality curve for the Armed Forces Radiobiology Research Institute high level cobalt-60 gamma-radiation source in nonhuman primates (NHPs) after total-body irradiation. A dose-response relationship was determined using NHPs (rhesus macaques, N = 36, N = 6/radiation dose) irradiated with 6 doses in the range of 6.0 to 8.5 Gy, with 0.5 Gy increments at a dose rate of 0.6 Gy/min. Animals were provided subject-based supportive care including blood transfusions and were monitored for 60 days postirradiation. Survival was the primary endpoint of the study and the secondary endpoint included hematopoietic recovery. The lethality curve suggested LD30/60, LD50/60, and LD70/60 values as 5.71, 6.78, and 7.84 Gy, respectively. The results of this study will be valuable to provide specific doses for various lethalities of 60Co-gamma radiation to test radiation countermeasures in rhesus macaques using subject-based supportive care including blood transfusion.

Animal Care in Radiation Medical Countermeasures Studies

Animal models are necessary to demonstrate the efficacy of medical countermeasures (MCM) to mitigate/treat acute radiation syndrome and the delayed effects of acute radiation exposure and develop biodosimetry signatures for use in triage and to guide medical management. The use of animal models in radiation research allows for the simulation of the biological effects of exposure in humans. Robust and well-controlled animal studies provide a platform to address basic mechanistic and safety questions that cannot be conducted in humans. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has tasked the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) with identifying and funding early- through advanced-stage MCM development for radiation-induced injuries; and advancement of biodosimetry platforms and exploration of biomarkers for triage, definitive dose, and predictive purposes. Some of these NIAID-funded projects may transition to the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority (BARDA), a component of the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response in the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, which is tasked with the advanced development of MCMs to include pharmacokinetic, exposure, and safety assessments in humans. Guided by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) Animal Rule, both NIAID and BARDA work closely with researchers to advance product and device development, setting them on a course for eventual licensure/approval/clearance of their approaches by the FDA. In August 2020, NIAID partnered with BARDA to conduct a workshop to discuss currently accepted animal care protocols and examine aspects of animal models that can influence outcomes of studies to explore MCM efficacy for potential harmonization. This report provides an overview of the two-day workshop, which includes a series of special topic presentations followed by panel discussions with subject-matter experts from academia, industry partners, and select governmental agencies.

Total-Body Irradiation Is Associated With Increased Incidence of Mesenchymal Neoplasia in a Radiation Late Effects Cohort of Rhesus Macaques (Macaca mulatta)

PURPOSE

Cancer is a severe delayed effect of acute radiation exposure. Total-body irradiation has been associated with an increased risk of solid cancer and leukemia in Japanese atomic bomb survivors, and secondary malignancies, such as sarcoma, are a serious consequence of cancer radiation therapy. The radiation late effects cohort (RLEC) of rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta) is a unique resource of more than 200 animals for studying the long-term consequences of total-body irradiation in an animal model that closely resembles humans at the genetic and physiologic levels.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Using clinical records, clinical imaging, histopathology, and immunohistochemistry, this retrospective study characterized the incidence of neoplasia in the RLEC.

RESULTS

Since 2007, 61 neoplasms in 44 of 239 irradiated animals were documented (18.4% of the irradiated population). Only 1 neoplasm was diagnosed among the 51 nonirradiated controls of the RLEC (2.0%). The most common malignancies in the RLEC were sarcomas (38.3% of diagnoses), which are rare neoplasms in nonirradiated macaques. The most common sarcomas included malignant nerve sheath tumors and malignant glomus tumors. Carcinomas were less common (19.7% of diagnoses), and consisted primarily of renal cell and hepatocellular carcinomas. Neoplasia occurred in most major body systems, with the skin and subcutis being the most common site (40%). RNA analysis showed similarities in transcriptional profiles between RLEC and human malignant nerve sheath tumors.

CONCLUSIONS

This study indicates that total-body irradiation is associated with an increased incidence of neoplasia years following irradiation, at more than double the incidence described in aging, nonirradiated animals, and promotes tumor histotypes that are rarely observed in nonirradiated, aging rhesus macaques.

Pseudo Pelger-Huët anomalies as potential biomarkers for acute exposure radiation dose in rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta)

PURPOSE

The potential for malicious use of radiation, or radiation accidents could potentially lead to acute, high radiation doses to the public. Following acute accidental exposure to high doses of radiation, medical intervention is pivotal to the survivability of the patient, and the sooner the appropriate measures are taken the better the odds for survival. Early estimates of acute accidental radiation doses can be determined via biomarkers such as dicentric chromosome analysis or scenario reconstruction using computer software. However, both take valuable time and can be expensive. Increased frequencies of abnormal neutrophils in peripheral blood, referred to as pseudo Pelger-Huët anomalies (PPHAs), have been shown to be potential biomarkers of radiation exposure in several scenarios, including the 1958 Y-12 criticality accident and the radium dial painters. PPHAs are potentially a faster and cheaper quantitative biomarker for radiation exposure, and here they were evaluated in acutely exposed rhesus macaques.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Peripheral blood smears from acutely exposed rhesus macaques were evaluated for the percentage of neutrophils that displayed the PPHA morphology using light microscopy. Irradiated animals received 0 to 8.5 Gy total body radiation using one of two strategies: (1) linear accelerator-produced 6 MV photons delivered at 80 cGy/minute; or (2) Cobalt 60-produced gamma irradiation delivered at 60 cGy/min. Zero dose animals were used to determine a baseline percentage of PPHAs, and blood smears taken periodically throughout the lifetime of exposed animals post-irradiation were used to determine the persistence and biokinetics of PPHAs.

RESULTS

The baseline prevalence of the PPHA in rhesus macaques was determined to be 0.58 ± 0.46%. The dose-response curve with doses ranging from 0 Gy to 8.5 Gy (LD90/30) displayed a strong positive correlation between PPHA percentage and acute radiation dose (R² of 0.88 p =  3.62 × 10^-22). Statistically significant differences were found when animals were separated into dose cohorts of 0, 4, 6.4-6.5, and 8-8.5 Gy. The biokinetics model utilized only 4 Gy exposures and blood smears taken periodically over 3.1 years post-irradiation. PPHA morphology increases quickly following irradiation and appears stable over 3.1 years post-irradiation.

CONCLUSION

PPHA morphology was confirmed to be present in rhesus macaques, a dose-response relationship was constructed, and it is stable over 3 years post-irradiation. This study demonstrates that PPHA analysis can be a fast and cheap method of biodosimetry. Future studies will work to determine the accuracy of dose determination and lower limits of detection.

Apolipoprotein E levels in the amygdala and prefrontal cortex predict relative regional brain volumes in irradiated Rhesus macaques

In the brain, apolipoprotein E (apoE) plays an important role in lipid transport and response to environmental and age-related challenges, including neuronal repair following injury. While much has been learned from radiation studies in rodents, a gap in our knowledge is how radiation might affect the brain in primates. This is important for assessing risk to the brain following radiotherapy as part of cancer treatment or environmental radiation exposure as part of a nuclear accident, bioterrorism, or a nuclear attack. In this study, we investigated the effects of ionizing radiation on brain volumes and apoE levels in the prefrontal cortex, amygdala, and hippocampus of Rhesus macaques that were part of the Nonhuman Primate Radiation Survivor Cohort at the Wake Forest University. This unique cohort is composed of Rhesus macaques that had previously received single total body doses of 6.5-8.05 Gy of ionizing radiation. Regional apoE levels predicted regional volume in the amygdala and the prefrontal cortex. In addition, apoE levels in the amygdala, but not the hippocampus, strongly predicted relative hippocampal volume. Finally, radiation dose negatively affected relative hippocampal volume when apoE levels in the amygdala were controlled for, suggesting a protective compensatory role of regional apoE levels following radiation exposure. In a supplementary analysis, there also was a robust positive relationship between the neuroprotective protein α-klotho and apoE levels in the amygdala, further supporting the potentially protective role of apoE. Increased understanding of the effects of IR in the primate brain and the role of apoE in the irradiated brain could inform future therapies to mitigate the adverse effects of IR on the CNS.

Recent advances in medical countermeasure development against acute radiation exposure based on the US FDA animal rule

Recent advances in medical countermeasures (MCMs) has been dependent on the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) animal rule (AR) and the final guidance document provided for industry on product development. The criteria outlined therein establish the path for approval under the AR. The guidance document, along with the funding and requirements from the federal agencies provided the basic considerations for animal model development in assessing radiation effects and efficacy against the potential lethal effects of acute radiation injury and the delayed effects of acute exposure. Animal models, essential for determining MCM efficacy, were developed and validated to assess organ-specific, potentially lethal, radiation effects against the gastrointestinal (GI) and hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome (H-ARS), and radiation-induced delayed effects to lung and associated comorbidities of prolonged immune suppression, GI, kidney and heart injury. Partial-body irradiation models where marginal bone marrow was spared resulted in the ability to evaluate the concomitant evolution of multiple organ injury in the acute and delayed effects in survivors of acute radiation exposure. There are no MCMs for prophylaxis against the major sequelae of the ARS or the delayed effects of acute exposure. Also lacking are MCMs that will mitigate the GI ARS consequent to potentially lethal exposure from a terrorist event or major radiation accident. Additionally, the gap in countermeasures for prophylaxis may extend to mixed neutron/gamma radiation if current modelling predicts prompt exposure from an improvised nuclear device. However, progress in the field of MCM development has been made due to federal and corporate funding, clarification of the critical criteria for efficacy within the FDA AR and the concomitant development and validation of additional animal models. These models provided for a strategic and tactical approach to determine radiation effects and MCM efficacy.

Acute Radiation Effects, the H-ARS in the Non-human Primate: A Review and New Data for the Cynomolgus Macaque with Reference to the Rhesus Macaque

ABSTRACT

Medical countermeasure development under the US Food and Drug Administration animal rule requires validated animal models of acute radiation effects. The key large animal model is the non-human primate, rhesus macaque. To date, only the rhesus macaque has been used for both critical supportive data and pivotal efficacy trials seeking US Food and Drug Administration approval. The potential for use of the rhesus for other high priority studies such as vaccine development underscores the need to identify another non-human primate model to account for the current lack of rhesus for medical countermeasure development. The cynomolgus macaque, Macaca fascicularis, has an existing database of medical countermeasure development against the hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome, as well as the use of radiation exposure protocols that mimic the likely nonuniform and heterogenous exposure consequent to a nuclear terrorist event. The review herein describes published studies of adult male cynomolgus macaques that used two exposure protocols-unilateral, nonuniform total-body irradiation and partial-body irradiation with bone marrow sparing-with the administration of subject-based medical management to assess mitigation against the hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome. These studies assessed the efficacy of cytokine combinations and cell-based therapy to mitigate acute radiation-induced myelosuppression. Both therapeutics were shown to mitigate the myelosuppression of the hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome. Additional studies being presented herein further defined the dose-dependent hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome of cynomolgus and rhesus macaques and a differential dose-dependent effect with young male and female cynomolgus macaques. The database supports the investigation of the cynomolgus macaque as a comparable non-human primate for efficacy testing under the US Food and Drug Administration animal rule. Critical gaps in knowledge required to validate the models and exposure protocols are also identified.

The Natural History of Acute Radiation-induced H-ARS and Concomitant Multi-organ Injury in the Non-human Primate: The MCART Experience

ABSTRACT

The dose response relationship and corresponding values for mid-lethal dose and slope are used to define the dose- and time-dependent parameters of the hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome. The characteristic time course of mortality, morbidity, and secondary endpoints are well defined. The concomitant comorbidities, potential mortality, and other multi-organ injuries that are similarly dose- and time-dependent are less defined. Determination of the natural history or pathophysiology associated with the lethal hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome is a significant gap in knowledge, especially when considered in the context of a nuclear weapon scenario. In this regard, the exposure is likely ill-defined, heterogenous, and nonuniform. These conditions forecast sparing of bone marrow and increased survival from the acute radiation syndrome consequent to threshold doses for the delayed effects of acute radiation exposure due to marrow sparing, medical management, and use of approved medical countermeasures. The intent herein is to provide a composite natural history of the pathophysiology concomitant with the evolution of the potentially lethal hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome derived from studies that focused on total body irradiation and partial body irradiation with bone marrow sparing. The marked differential in estimated LD50/60 from 7.5 Gy to 10.88 Gy for the total body irradiation and partial body irradiation with 5% bone marrow sparing models, respectively, provided a clear distinction between the attendant multiple organ injury and natural history of the two models that included medical management. Total body irradiation was focused on equivalent LD50/60 exposures. The 10 Gy and 11 Gy partial body with 5% bone marrow sparing exposures bracketed the LD50/60 (10.88 Gy). The incidence, progression, and duration of multiple organ injury was described for each exposure protocol within the hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome. The higher threshold doses for the partial body irradiation with bone marrow sparing protocol induced a marked degree of multiple organ injury to include lethal gastrointestinal acute radiation syndrome, prolonged crypt loss and mucosal damage, immune suppression, acute kidney injury, body weight loss, and added clinical comorbidities that defined a complex timeline of organ injury through the acute hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome. The natural history of the acute radiation syndrome presents a 60-d time segment of multi-organ sequelae that is concomitant with the latent period or time to onset of the evolving multi-organ injury of the delayed effects of acute radiation exposure.

Total body irradiation models in NHPs - consideration of animal sex and provision of supportive care to advance model development

PURPOSE

Harmonized animal models are an indispensable tool for the development of safe and effective medical countermeasures (MCMs) against radiation injury, and rhesus macaques (referred herein as NHPs) play a critical role in FDA approval of radiation medical countermeasures for acute and delayed radiation syndromes. Reliance on such models requires that they be well characterized, which consists, in part, of a reproducible dose to mortality response relationship (DRR). However, data describing the DRR for both male and female NHPs from the same study are scarce. Furthermore, the level of supportive care and the use of blood transfusions may shift the DRR, yet such information can be difficult to compare across publications. To address these knowledge gaps, the DRRs of two different NHP total body irradiation (TBI) models are compared in this paper, one which is reliant on the use of male animals provided blood transfusions, and the other which incorporates both sexes wherein animals are not provided transfusions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Studies were conducted using NHPs (Macacca mulatta) receiving TBI, with survival reported over a 60 days. Two primary studies, incorporating both male and female animals not receiving blood transfusions as a provision of supportive care, were compared to two previously published studies, which incorporated only male animals provided blood transfusions as a part of the supportive care regimen. Criterion for euthanasia, and all other provisions of supportive care were comparable. Linear probit plots estimating the lethal dose (LD) and upper and lower limits of the 95% confidence interval (CI) for 10, 30, 50, 70 and 90% mortality, were compared between individual studies and the two models presented.

RESULTS

Comparison of probit estimates reveals two important findings. (1) Females have higher mortality than males at identical radiation doses, and (2) blood transfusions increased survival of male animals at lower doses but not at high doses of radiation exposure.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of single sex animal models may lead to an incomplete understanding of potential sex differences in the dose to mortality response of the TBI model. Consistent use of both sexes and type of supportive care will improve the transferability and reliability of NHP-TBI models currently in use, assist in the selection of radiation doses for single dose lethality studies, and allow investigators to determine the effectiveness of a particular MCM.

A Systematic Review of the Hematopoietic Acute Radiation Syndrome (H-ARS) in Canines and Non-human Primates: Acute Mixed Neutron/Gamma vs. Reference Quality Radiations

A systematic review of relevant studies that determined the dose response relationship (DRR) for the hematopoietic (H) acute radiation syndrome (ARS) in the canine relative to radiation quality of mixed neutron:gamma radiations, dose rate, and exposure uniformity relative to selected reference radiation exposure has not been performed. The datasets for rhesus macaques exposure to mixed neutron:gamma radiation are used herein as a species comparative reference to the canine database. The selection of data cohorts was made from the following sources: Ovid Medline (1957-present), PubMed (1954-present), AGRICOLA (1976-present), Web of Science (1954-present), and US HHS RePORT (2002-present). The total number of hits across all search sites was 3,077. Several referenced, unpublished, non-peer reviewed government reports were unavailable for review. Primary published studies using canines, beagles, and mongrels were evaluated to provide an informative and consistent review of mixed neutron:gamma radiation effects to establish the DRRs for the H-ARS. Secondary and tertiary studies provided additional information on the hematologic response or the effects on hematopoietic progenitor cells, radiation dosimetry, absorbed dose, and organ dose. The LD50/30 values varied with neutron quality, exposure aspect, and mixed neutron:gamma ratio. The reference radiation quality varied from 250 kVp or 1-2 MeV x radiation and Co gamma radiation. A summary of a published review of a data set describing the DRR in rhesus macaques for mixed neutron:gamma radiation exposure in the H-ARS is included for a comparative reference to the canine dataset. The available evidence provided a reliable and extensive database that characterized the DRR for the H-ARS in canines and young rhesus macaques exposed to mixed neutron:gamma radiations of variable energy relative to 250 kVp, 1-2 MeV x radiation and Co gamma, and uniform and non-uniform total-body irradiation without the benefit of medical management. The mixed neutron:gamma radiation showed an energy-dependent RBE of ~ 1.0 to 2.0 relative to reference radiation exposure within both species. A marginal database described the DRR for the gastrointestinal (GI)-ARS. Medical management showed benefit in both species relative to the mixed neutron:gamma as well as exposure to reference radiation. The DRR for the H-ARS was characterized by steep slopes and relative LD50/30 values that reflected the radiation quality, exposure aspect, and dose rate over a range in time from 1956-2012.

The New Zealand white rabbit animal model of acute radiation syndrome: hematopoietic and coagulation-based parameters by radiation dose following supportive care

PURPOSE

Animal models that accurately reflect human responses to radiation injury are needed for advanced mechanistic investigation and development of effective therapeutics. The rabbit is an established animal model accepted by the FDA for studies of cardiovascular disease, lipid metabolism, the development of anticoagulants, testing of bone implants, and the development of treatments for infectious diseases such as HIV. The purpose of this study was to investigate the New Zealand White (NZW) Rabbit model as a model of acute radiation exposure because of its established similarity to human vascular, immune, and coagulation responses.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two sequential studies were performed in a total of 81 male NZW rabbits, 16-20 weeks of age. All animals underwent clinical observations and peripheral blood analyses following a single dose of 0, 6, 7, 8, 8.5, 9, or 10 Gy of total body irradiation via a 6 MV Linear accelerator photon source on day 0. Animals were treated with timed release fentanyl patch (days 0-30), subcutaneous hydration (day 1, Study 2 only), and oral sulfamethoxazole/trimethoprim 30 mg/kg once daily (days 3-30) and were followed for 30 days or to time of mortality.

RESULTS

Study 1 revealed the estimated LD30, -50, -70, and -90 with 95% confidence intervals (CI) at 30 days to be 6.7 (CI: 5.9-7.4), 7.3 (CI: 6.7-7.8), 7.9 (CI: 7.3-8.4), and 8.8 (CI: 7.9-9.7) Gy, respectively. In study 2, a survey of blood coagulation and biochemical parameters were performed over time and necropsy. Complete blood counts taken from animals exposed to 7, 8, or 10 Gy, demonstrated dose-dependent depletion of lymphocytes, neutrophils, and platelets. Platelet counts recovered to baseline levels in survivors by day 30, whereas lymphocyte and neutrophil counts did not. Decedent animals demonstrated grade 3 or 4 neutropenia and lymphopenia at time of death; 64% of the decedents experienced a 30% or greater drop in hematocrit. Decedent animals demonstrated more than 100% increases from serum baseline levels of blood urea nitrogen, creatinine, aspartate aminotransferase, and triglyceride levels at the time of death whereas survivors on average demonstrated modest or no elevation.

CONCLUSION

This NZW rabbit model demonstrates dose-dependent depletion of hematopoietic parameters. The LD_50/30 of 7.8 Gy (95% CI: 6.6-8.4) with supportive care appears to be close to the ranges reported for rhesus macaques (5.25-7.44 Gy) and humans (6-8 Gy) with supportive care. These findings support the utility of the NZW rabbit model for further mechanistic investigation of acute radiation exposure and medical countermeasure testing.

Non-Human Primates Receiving High-Dose Total-Body Irradiation are at Risk of Developing Cerebrovascular Injury Years Postirradiation

Nuclear accidents and acts of terrorism have the potential to expose thousands of people to high-dose total-body iradiation (TBI). Those who survive the acute radiation syndrome are at risk of developing chronic, degenerative radiation-induced injuries [delayed effects of acute radiation (DEARE)] that may negatively affect quality of life. A growing body of literature suggests that the brain may be vulnerable to radiation injury at survivable doses, yet the long-term consequences of high-dose TBI on the adult brain are unclear. Herein we report the occurrence of lesions consistent with cerebrovascular injury, detected by susceptibility-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), in a cohort of non-human primate [(NHP); rhesus macaque, Macaca mulatta] long-term survivors of high-dose TBI (1.1-8.5 Gy). Animals were monitored longitudinally with brain MRI (approximately once every three years). Susceptibility-weighted images (SWI) were reviewed for hypointensities (cerebral microbleeds and/or focal necrosis). SWI hypointensities were noted in 13% of irradiated NHP; lesions were not observed in control animals. A prior history of exposure was correlated with an increased risk of developing a lesion detectable by MRI (P = 0.003). Twelve of 16 animals had at least one brain lesion present at the time of the first MRI evaluation; a subset of animals (n = 7) developed new lesions during the surveillance period (3.7-11.3 years postirradiation). Lesions occurred with a predilection for white matter and the gray-white matter junction. The majority of animals with lesions had one to three SWI hypointensities, but some animals had multifocal disease (n = 2). Histopathologic evaluation of deceased animals within the cohort (n = 3) revealed malformation of the cerebral vasculature and remodeling of the blood vessel walls. There was no association between comorbid diabetes mellitus or hypertension with SWI lesion status. These data suggest that long-term TBI survivors may be at risk of developing cerebrovascular injury years after irradiation.

Acute Radiation-induced GI-ARS and H-ARS in a Canine Model of Mixed Neutron/Gamma Relative to Reference Co-60 Gamma Radiation: A Retrospective Study

Studies performed decades ago in the canine and nonhuman primate established the dose response relationships for the hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome in response to mixed neutron/gamma, x-radiation, and Co gamma radiation. There were no published studies that determined the dose response relationships for the gastrointestinal acute radiation syndrome in response to either noted radiation quality. This analysis of a retrospective, unpublished study provided the dose response relationships in a canine model for the acute gastrointestinal syndrome relative to the acute hematopoietic syndrome due to mixed neutron/gamma radiation. Canines were exposed to total-body, steady state, bilateral, 0.40 Gy min, mixed neutron/gamma (5.4:1) radiation from a TRIGA reactor. The average neutron/gamma energy (MeV) was 0.85/0.9, and exposure was reported as midline tissue dose. Medical management was not administered. The mixed neutron/gamma exposure resulted in an estimated LD50/6 of 2.83 Gy [2.76, 2.94] and LD50/30 of 2.16 Gy [2.01, 2.24] for the GI- and H-ARS respectively. The mean survival times for decedents after mixed neutron/gamma exposure approximate to the LD50/6 were 8.5 d, 10.5 d, and 4 d for 2.75 Gy, 2.80 Gy, 3.00, and 3.12 Gy exposures, respectively. The mean survival times for decedents for mixed neutron/gamma exposure approximate to the LD50/30 were 21.3 d and 15.6 d for 2.00 Gy and 2.25 Gy, respectively. Furthermore, the dose response relationships for the acute hematopoietic syndrome due to mixed neutron/gamma exposure (0.85/0.9 MeV; 5.4:1) resulted in an estimated relative biological effectiveness of 1.2 as compared with reference Co gamma radiation.

The Gastrointestinal Subsyndrome of the Acute Radiation Syndrome in Rhesus Macaques: A Systematic Review of the Lethal Dose-response Relationship With and Without Medical Management

Well-characterized animal models that mimic the human response to potentially lethal doses of radiation are required to assess the efficacy of medical countermeasures under the criteria of the US Food and Drug Administration's Animal Rule. Development of a model for the gastrointestinal acute radiation syndrome requires knowledge of the radiation dose-response relationship and time course of mortality and morbidity across the acute and prolonged gastrointestinal radiation syndrome. The nonhuman primate, rhesus macaque, is a relevant animal model that has been used to determine the efficacy of medical countermeasures to mitigate major signs of morbidity and mortality relative to the hematopoietic acute radiation syndrome, gastrointestinal acute radiation syndrome, and lung injury. It can be used to assess the natural history of gastrointestinal damage, concurrent multiple organ injury, and aspects of the mechanism of action for acute radiation exposure and treatment. A systematic review of relevant studies that determined the dose-response relationship for the gastrointestinal acute and prolonged radiation syndrome in the rhesus macaque relative to radiation dose, quality, dose rate, exposure uniformity, and use of medical management has never been performed.

The Time Course of Radiation-induced Lung Injury in a Nonhuman Primate Model of Partial-body Irradiation With Minimal Bone Marrow Sparing: Clinical and Radiographic Evidence and the Effect of Neupogen Administration

The primary objectives of two companion manuscripts were to assess the natural history of delayed radiation-induced lung injury in a nonhuman primate model of acute high-dose, partial-body irradiation with 5% bone marrow sparing, to include the clinical, radiographic, and histopathological evidence and the effect of Neupogen administration on the morbidity and mortality. Nonhuman primates were exposed to 10.0 or 11.0 Gy with 6 MV linac-derived photons at approximately 0.80 Gy min. All nonhuman primates received subject-based, medical management. Subsets of nonhuman primates were administered Neupogen (10 μg kg) starting on day 1, day 3, or day 5 until recovery (absolute neutrophil count ≥ 1,000 cells μL for three consecutive days). Mortality due to multiple organ injury at 180 d study duration: Mortality at 180 d post either 10.0 Gy or 11.0 Gy was the consequence of concurrent injury due to the acute radiation syndrome (gastrointestinal and hematological) and delayed radiation-induced lung injury. The 180-d all-cause mortality observed in the control cohorts at 10.0 Gy (53%) or 11.0 Gy (86%) did not vary from cohorts that received Neupogen at any administration schedule. Mortality ranged from 43-50% (10 Gy) to 75-100% (11.0 Gy) in the Neupogen-treated cohorts. The study, however, was not powered to detect statistical significant differences between mortality in the control and Neupogen-treated cohorts. Clinical and radiographic evidence of radiation-induced lung injury: The mean nonsedated respiratory rate in the control cohorts exposed to 10 or 11 Gy increased from a baseline value of 37 breaths min to >60 breaths min within 103 d and 94 d postexposure, and the incidence of nonsedated respiratory rate > 80 breaths min was 50% and 70%, respectively. The mean duration of latency to development of clinical pneumonitis and/or fibrosis (nonsedated respiratory rate > 80 breaths min) was not significantly different between the 10.0-Gy or 11.0 Gy-cohorts (range 100-107 d). Neupogen (granulocyte colony-stimulating factor) administration had no apparent effect of the latency, incidence, or severity of nonsedated respiratory rate within either radiation dose or administration schedule. Computed tomography scans were obtained and images were analyzed for evidence of lung injury, e.g., pneumonitis and/or fibrosis, pleural and pericardial effusion. A quantitative, semiautomated method was developed based on differences in radiodensity (Hounsfield units) and lung morphology to extract the volume of pneumonitis/fibrosis and pleural effusion as indexed against total lung at each time point obtained. At both irradiation doses, 100% of the nonhuman primates surviving acute radiation syndrome manifested radiographic evidence of radiation-induced lung injury as pneumonitis and/or fibrosis. There was no apparent effect of Neupogen administration on the latency, incidence, severity, or progression of pneumonitis/fibrosis:total lung volume or pleural effusion:total lung volume at either exposure. A comparative review of the data illustrated the concomitant time course of increased mortality, nonsedated respiratory rate, and pneumonitis/fibrosis:total lung volume and pleural effusion:total lung volume consequent to 10.0-Gy or 11.0-Gy partial-body irradiation with 5% bone marrow sparing. All key parameters proceeded from a latent period of approximately 60 d followed by an increase in all three indices of clinical and radiographic evidence of radiation-induced lung injury within the next 60 d to 120 d postexposure. The subsequent time course and longitudinal analysis was influenced by the persistent progression of radiation-induced lung injury, administration of dexamethasone, and loss of nonhuman primates due to lethality. Companion paper: Lung and Heart Injury in a Nonhuman Primate Model of Partial-body Irradiation With Minimal Bone Marrow Sparing: Histopathological Evidence of Lung and Heart Injury (Parker et al. 2019): Note that the computed tomography-based radiodensity data do not permit differentiation of pneumonitis and fibrosis. The companion paper employed Masson's trichrome, collagen 1, and selected staining to identify the key time and incidence parameters relative to excessive collagen deposition indicative of fibrosis and associated histopathology in the lung. This histological database provided valuable longitudinal analysis in support of the clinical and radiographic evidence associated with the time course of radiation-induced lung injury.

White Matter is the Predilection Site of Late-Delayed Radiation-Induced Brain Injury in Non-Human Primates

Fractionated whole-brain irradiation for the treatment of intracranial neoplasia causes progressive neurodegeneration and neuroinflammation. The long-term consequences of single-fraction high-dose irradiation to the brain are unknown. To assess the late effects of brain irradiation we compared transcriptomic gene expression profiles from nonhuman primates (NHP; rhesus macaques Macaca mulatta) receiving single-fraction total-body irradiation (TBI; n = 5, 6.75-8.05 Gy, 6-9 years prior to necropsy) to those receiving fractionated whole-brain irradiation (fWBI; n = 5, 40 Gy, 8 × 5 Gy fractions; 12 months prior to necropsy) and control comparators (n = 5). Gene expression profiles from the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), hippocampus (HC) and deep white matter (WM; centrum semiovale) were compared. Stratified analyses by treatment and region revealed that radiation-induced transcriptomic alterations were most prominent in animals receiving fWBI, and primarily affected white matter in both TBI and fWBI groups. Unsupervised canonical and ontologic analysis revealed that TBI or fWBI animals demonstrated shared patterns of injury, including white matter neuroinflammation, increased expression of complement factors and T-cell activation. Both irradiated groups also showed evidence of impaired glutamatergic neurotransmission and signal transduction within white matter, but not within the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex or hippocampus. Signaling pathways and structural elements involved in extracellular matrix (ECM) deposition and remodeling were noted within the white matter of animals receiving fWBI, but not of those receiving TBI. These findings indicate that those animals receiving TBI are susceptible to neurological injury similar to that observed after fWBI, and these changes persist for years postirradiation. Transcriptomic profiling reaffirmed that macrophage/microglial-mediated neuroinflammation is present in radiation-induced brain injury (RIBI), and our data provide novel evidence that the complement system may contribute to the pathogenesis of RIBI. Finally, these data challenge the assumption that the hippocampus is the predilection site of injury in RIBI, and indicate that impaired glutamatergic neurotransmission may occur in white matter injury.

Late effects of total body irradiation on hematopoietic recovery and immune function in rhesus macaques

While exposure to radiation can be lifesaving in certain settings, it can also potentially result in long-lasting adverse effects, particularly to hematopoietic and immune cells. This study investigated hematopoietic recovery and immune function in rhesus macaques Cross-sectionally (at a single time point) 2 to 5 years after exposure to a single large dose (6.5 to 8.4 Gray) of total body radiation (TBI) derived from linear accelerator-derived photons (2 MeV, 80 cGy/minute) or Cobalt 60-derived gamma irradiation (60 cGy/min). Hematopoietic recovery was assessed through measurement of complete blood counts, lymphocyte subpopulation analysis, and thymus function assessment. Capacity to mount specific antibody responses against rabies, Streptococcus pneumoniae, and tetanus antigens was determined 2 years after TBI. Irradiated macaques showed increased white blood cells, decreased platelets, and decreased frequencies of peripheral blood T cells. Effects of prior radiation on production and export of new T cells by the thymus was dependent on age at the time of analysis, with evidence of interaction with radiation dose for CD8+ T cells. Irradiated and control animals mounted similar mean antibody responses to proteins from tetanus and rabies and to 10 of 11 serotype-specific pneumococcal polysaccharides. However, irradiated animals uniformly failed to make antibodies against polysaccharides from serotype 5 pneumococci, in contrast to the robust responses of non-irradiated controls. Trends toward decreased serum levels of anti-tetanus IgM and slower peak antibody responses to rabies were also observed. Taken together, these data show that dose-related changes in peripheral blood cells and immune responses to both novel and recall antigens can be detected 2 to 5 years after exposure to whole body radiation. Longer term follow-up data on this cohort and independent validation will be helpful to determine whether these changes persist or whether additional changes become evident with increasing time since radiation, particularly as animals begin to develop aging-related changes in immune function.

WAG/RijCmcr rat models for injuries to multiple organs by single high dose ionizing radiation: similarities to nonhuman primates (NHP)

Purpose: Defined animal models are needed to pursue the FDA Animal Rule for approval of medical countermeasure for radiation injuries. This study compares WAG/RijCmcr rat and nonhuman primate (NHP) models for acute radiation syndrome (ARS) and delayed effects of acute radiation exposure (DEARE).Materials and methods: Irradiation models include total body irradiation, partial body irradiation with bone marrow sparing and whole thorax lung irradiations. Organ-specific sequelae of radiation injuries were compared using dose-response relationships.Results and conclusions: Rats and NHP manifest similar organ dysfunctions after radiation, starting with acute gastrointestinal (GI-ARS) and hematopoietic (H-ARS) syndromes followed by lung, heart and kidney toxicities. Humans also manifest these sequelae. Latencies for injury were earlier in rats than in NHP. After whole thorax lung irradiations (WTLI) up to 13 Gy, there was recovery of lung function from pneumonitis in rats. This has not been evaluated in NHP. The latency, incidence, severity and progression of radiation pneumonitis was not influenced by early multi-organ injury from ARS in rats or NHP. Rats developed more severe radiation nephropathy than NHP, and also progressed more rapidly. Dosimetry, anesthesia, environment, supportive care, euthanasia criteria etc., may account for the alterations in radiation sensitivity observed between species.

Specific Members of the Gut Microbiota are Reliable Biomarkers of Irradiation Intensity and Lethality in Large Animal Models of Human Health

The development of effective biomarkers for detecting the magnitude of radiation exposure and resiliency of host response is crucial to identifying appropriate treatment strategies after radiation exposure. We hypothesized that the gastrointestinal resident bacteria would demonstrate predictable, dose-dependent changes after radiation exposure across two large animal models of acute radiation syndrome. Here, Göttingen minipigs (GMP) (n = 50) and rhesus macaques (n = 48) were exposed to five dose levels (resulting in mortality rates of 33-100% and 25-68.7%, respectively). Fecal samples taken prior to and after irradiation (day 0 for GMP; day 0, 3 and 14 for macaques) were used for 16S rRNA gene sequence amplicon high-throughput sequencing. Baseline gut microbiota profiles were dissimilar between GMP and macaques, however, radiation appeared to have similar effect at the phylum level, resulting in Bacteroidetes decrease and Firmicutes increase in both models. The abundance of the main Bacteroidetes genus ( Bacteroides for GMP, Prevotella for macaques) was profoundly decreased by irradiation. Intracellular symbionts [Elusimicrobia in GMP, Treponema (Spirochaetes) in macaques] consistently increased after irradiation, suggesting their use as potential biomarkers of intestinal injury, and potential negative effect on health. Prevotella, Lactobacillus, Clostridium XIVa, Oscillibacter and Elusimicrobium/ Treponema abundances were found to be very significantly correlated with radiation intensity. Furthermore, Prevotella, Enterorhabdus and Ruminococcus and Enterorhabdus maintenance was strongly associated with survival in GMP, while Prevotella, Oscillibacter and Treponema were strongly associated with survival and Streptococcus with death in macaques. Overall, we found that a wide range of gut bacterial genera known to be abundant in the human gut microbiota are excellent biomarkers of radiation intensity and resilience in animal models, and that detrimental effects can be monitored, and potentially prevented, by targeting selected genera.

A comparative analysis of gut microbiota disturbances in the Gottingen minipig and rhesus macaque models of acute radiation syndrome following bioequivalent radiation exposures

In rodent studies, the gut microbiota has been implicated in facilitating both radioresistance, by protecting the epithelium from apoptotic responses and radiosensitivity, inducing endothelial apoptotic responses. Despite the observation that large animal models, such as the Chinese Rhesus macaque and the Gottingen Minipig, demonstrate similarity to human physiologic responses to radiation, little is known about radiation-induced changes of the gut microbiome in these models. To compare the two models, we used bioequivalent radiation doses which resulted in an LD50 for Gottingen Minipigs and Chinese Rhesus macaques, 1.9 Gy and 6.8 Gy, respectively. Fecal samples taken prior and 3 days post-radiation were used for 16S rRNA gene sequence amplicon high throughput sequencing (Illumina MiSeq). Baseline gut microbiota profiles were dissimilar between minipigs and rhesus macaques. Irradiation profoundly impacted gut microbiota profiles in both animals. Significant increases of intracellular symbionts were common to both models and to reported changes in rodents suggesting universality of these findings post-radiation. Remarkably, opposite dynamics were observed for the main phyla, with increase of Firmicutes and decrease of Bacteroidetes and Proteobacteria in minipigs but with enrichment of Bacteroidetes in rhesus macaques. Minipig changes in magnitude and in variety of species affected were more extensive than those observed in rhesus macaques. This pilot study provides an important first step in comparing the radiosensitive pig model to the comparatively more radioresistant macaque model, for the identification of microbial elements which may influence radiosensitivity.

Combined Hydration and Antibiotics with Lisinopril to Mitigate Acute and Delayed High-dose Radiation Injuries to Multiple Organs

The NIAID Radiation and Nuclear Countermeasures Program is developing medical agents to mitigate the acute and delayed effects of radiation that may occur from a radionuclear attack or accident. To date, most such medical countermeasures have been developed for single organ injuries. Angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors have been used to mitigate radiation-induced lung, skin, brain, and renal injuries in rats. ACE inhibitors have also been reported to decrease normal tissue complication in radiation oncology patients. In the current study, the authors have developed a rat partial-body irradiation (leg-out PBI) model with minimal bone marrow sparing (one leg shielded) that results in acute and late injuries to multiple organs. In this model, the ACE inhibitor lisinopril (at ~24 mg m d started orally in the drinking water at 7 d after irradiation and continued to ≥150 d) mitigated late effects in the lungs and kidneys after 12.5-Gy leg-out PBI. Also in this model, a short course of saline hydration and antibiotics mitigated acute radiation syndrome following doses as high as 13 Gy. Combining this supportive care with the lisinopril regimen mitigated overall morbidity for up to 150 d after 13-Gy leg-out PBI. Furthermore, lisinopril was an effective mitigator in the presence of the growth factor G-CSF (100 μg kg d from days 1-14), which is FDA-approved for use in a radionuclear event. In summary, by combining lisinopril (FDA-approved for other indications) with hydration and antibiotics, acute and delayed radiation injuries in multiple organs were mitigated.