Increased heating efficiency of hyperthermia using an ultrasound contrast agent: a phantom study

Microbubble-Enhanced Heating: Exploring the Effect of Microbubble Concentration and Pressure Amplitude on High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound Treatments

High-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) is a non-invasive tool that can be used for targeted thermal ablation treatments. Currently, HIFU is clinically approved for treatment of uterine fibroids, various cancers, and certain brain applications. However, for brain applications such as essential tremors, HIFU can only be used to treat limited areas confined to the center of the brain because of geometrical limitations (shape of the transducer and skull). A major obstacle to advancing this technology is the inability to treat non-central brain locations without causing damage to the skin and/or skull. Previous research has indicated that cavitation-induced bubbles or microbubble contrast agents can be used to enhance HIFU treatments by increasing ablation regions and shortening acoustic exposures at lower acoustic pressures. However, little research has been done to explore the interplay between microbubble concentration and pressure amplitude on HIFU treatments. We developed an in vitro experimental setup to study lesion formation at three different acoustic pressures and three microbubble concentrations. Real-time ultrasound imaging was integrated to monitor initial microbubble concentration and subsequent behavior during the HIFU treatments. Depending on the pressure used for the HIFU treatment, there was an optimal concentration of microbubbles that led to enhanced heating in the focal area. If the concentration of microbubbles was too high, the treatment was detrimentally affected because of non-linear attenuation by the pre-focal microbubbles. Additionally, the real-time ultrasound imaging provided a reliable method to monitor microbubble activity during the HIFU treatments, which is important for translation to in vivo HIFU applications with microbubbles.

Evaluation of Pseudorandom Sonications for Reducing Cavitation With a Clinical Neurosurgery HIFU Device

Transcranial high-intensity focused ultrasound is used in clinics for treating essential tremor (ET) and proposed for many other brain disorders. This promising treatment modality requires high energy resulting eventually in undesired cavitation and potential side effects. The goals of the present work were: 1) to evaluate the potential increase of the cavitation threshold using pseudorandom gated sonications and 2) to assess the heating capabilities with such sonications. The experiments were performed with the transcranial magnetic resonance (MR)-compatible ExAblate Neuro system (InSightec, Haifa, Israel) operating at a frequency of 670 kHz, either in continuous wave (CW) or with pseudorandom gated sonications of 50% duty cycle. Cavitation activity with the two types of sonications was compared using chemical dosimetry of hydroxyl radical production at the focus of the transducer, after propagation in water or through a human skull. Heating trials were performed in a hydrogel tissue-mimicking material embedded in a human skull to mimic a clinical situation. The temperature was measured by MR-thermometry when focusing at the geometrical focus and steering off focus up to 15 mm. Compared with CW sonications, the use of gated sonication did not affect the efficiency (60%) nor the steering abilities of the transducer. After propagation through a human skull, gated sonication required a higher pressure level (10 MPa) to initiate cavitation as compared with CW (5.8 MPa). Moreover, at equivalent acoustic power above the cavitation threshold, the level of cavitation activity initiated with gated sonications was much lower with gated sonication than with continuous sonications, almost half after propagation through water and one-third after propagation through a skull. This lowered cavitation activity may be attributed to a breaking of the dynamic of the bubbles moving from monochromatic to more broadband sonications and to the removal of residual cavitation nuclei between pulses with gated sonications. The heating capability was not affected by the gated sonications, and similar temperature increases were reached at focus with both types of sonications when sonicating at equivalent acoustic power, both in water or after propagation through a human skull (+15 °C at 325 W for 10 s). These data, acquired with a clinical system, suggest that gated sonication could be an alternative to continuous sonications when cavitation onset is an issue.

Lipid bubbles combined with low-intensity ultrasound enhance the intratumoral accumulation and antitumor effect of pegylated liposomal doxorubicin in vivo

Pegylated liposomal doxorubicin (PLD) is a representative nanomedicine that has improved tumor selectivity and safety profile. However, the therapeutic superiority of PLD over conventional doxorubicin has been reported to be insignificant in clinical medicine. Combination treatment with microbubbles and ultrasound (US) is a promising strategy for enhancing the antitumor effects of chemotherapeutics by improving drug delivery. Recently, several preclinical studies have shown the drug delivery potential of lipid bubbles (LBs), newly developed monolayer microbubbles, in combination with low-intensity US (LIUS). This study aimed to elucidate whether the combined use of LBs and LIUS enhanced the intratumoral accumulation and antitumor effect of PLD in syngeneic mouse tumor models. Contrast-enhanced US imaging using LBs showed a significant decrease in contrast enhancement after LIUS, indicating that LIUS exposure induced the destruction of LBs in the tumor tissue. A quantitative evaluation revealed that the combined use of LBs and LIUS improved the intratumoral accumulation of PLD. Furthermore, tumor growth was inhibited by combined treatment with PLD, LBs, and LIUS. Therefore, the combined use of LBs and LIUS enhanced the antitumor effect of PLD by increasing its accumulation in the tumor tissue. In conclusion, the present study provides important evidence that the combination of LBs and LIUS is an effective method for enhancing the intratumoral delivery and antitumor effect of PLD in vivo.

Fast and high temperature hyperthermia coupled with radiotherapy as a possible new treatment for glioblastoma

Background

A new transcranial focused ultrasound device has been developed that can induce hyperthermia in a large tissue volume. The purpose of this work is to investigate theoretically how glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) can be effectively treated by combining the fast hyperthermia generated by this focused ultrasound device with external beam radiotherapy.

Methods/Design

To investigate the effect of tumor growth, we have developed a mathematical description of GBM proliferation and diffusion in the context of reaction–diffusion theory. In addition, we have formulated equations describing the impact of radiotherapy and heat on GBM in the reaction–diffusion equation, including tumor regrowth by stem cells. This formulation has been used to predict the effectiveness of the combination treatment for a realistic focused ultrasound heating scenario.

Our results show that patient survival could be significantly improved by this combined treatment modality.

Discussion

High priority should be given to experiments to validate the therapeutic benefit predicted by our model.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s40349-016-0078-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Tumor growth suppression by the combination of nanobubbles and ultrasound

We previously developed novel liposomal nanobubbles (Bubble liposomes [BL]) that oscillate and collapse in an ultrasound field, generating heat and shock waves. We aimed to investigate the feasibility of cancer therapy using the combination of BL and ultrasound. In addition, we investigated the anti-tumor mechanism of this cancer therapy. Colon-26 cells were inoculated into the flank of BALB/c mice to induce tumors. After 8 days, BL or saline was intratumorally injected, followed by transdermal ultrasound exposure of tumor tissue (1 MHz, 0-4 W/cm2 , 2 min). The anti-tumor effects were evaluated by histology (necrosis) and tumor growth. In vivo cell depletion assays were performed to identify the immune cells responsible for anti-tumor effects. Tumor temperatures were significantly higher when treated with BL + ultrasound than ultrasound alone. Intratumoral BL caused extensive tissue necrosis at 3-4 W/cm2 of ultrasound exposure. In addition, BL + ultrasound significantly suppressed tumor growth at 2-4 W/cm2 . In vivo depletion of CD8+ T cells (not NK or CD4+ T cells) completely blocked the effect of BL + ultrasound on tumor growth. These data suggest that CD8+ T cells play a critical role in tumor growth suppression. Finally, we concluded that BL + ultrasound, which can prime the anti-tumor cellular immune system, may be an effective hyperthermia strategy for cancer treatment.

Nonthermal ablation in the rat brain using focused ultrasound and an ultrasound contrast agent: long-term effects

OBJECTIVE Thermal ablation with transcranial MRI-guided focused ultrasound (FUS) is currently under investigation as a less invasive alternative to radiosurgery and resection. A major limitation of the method is that its use is currently restricted to centrally located brain targets. The combination of FUS and a microbubble-based ultrasound contrast agent greatly reduces the ultrasound exposure level needed to ablate brain tissue and could be an effective means to increase the "treatment envelope" for FUS in the brain. This method, however, ablates tissue through a different mechanism: destruction of the microvasculature. It is not known whether nonthermal FUS ablation in substantial volumes of tissue can safely be performed without unexpected effects. The authors investigated this question by ablating volumes in the brains of normal rats. METHODS Overlapping sonications were performed in rats (n = 15) to ablate a volume in 1 hemisphere per animal. The sonications (10-msec bursts at 1 Hz for 60 seconds; peak negative pressure 0.8 MPa) were combined with the ultrasound contrast agent Optison (100 µl/kg). The rats were followed with MRI for 4-9 weeks after FUS, and the brains were examined with histological methods. RESULTS Two weeks after sonication and later, the lesions appeared as cyst-like areas in T2-weighted MR images that were stable over time. Histological examination demonstrated well-defined lesions consisting of a cyst-like cavity that remained lined by astrocytic tissue. Some white matter structures within the sonicated area were partially intact. CONCLUSIONS The results of this study indicate that nonthermal FUS ablation can be used to safely ablate tissue volumes in the brain without unexpected delayed effects. The findings are encouraging for the use of this ablation method in the brain.

Cavitation-enhanced nonthermal ablation in deep brain targets: feasibility in a large animal model

OBJECT Transcranial MRI-guided focused ultrasound (TcMRgFUS) is an emerging noninvasive alternative to surgery and radiosurgery that is undergoing testing for tumor ablation and functional neurosurgery. The method is currently limited to central brain targets due to skull heating and other factors. An alternative ablative approach combines very low intensity ultrasound bursts and an intravenously administered microbubble agent to locally destroy the vasculature. The objective of this work was to investigate whether it is feasible to use this approach at deep brain targets near the skull base in nonhuman primates. METHODS In 4 rhesus macaques, targets near the skull base were ablated using a clinical TcMRgFUS system operating at 220 kHz. Low-duty-cycle ultrasound exposures (sonications) were applied for 5 minutes in conjunction with the ultrasound contrast agent Definity, which was administered as a bolus injection or continuous infusion. The acoustic power level was set to be near the inertial cavitation threshold, which was measured using passive monitoring of the acoustic emissions. The resulting tissue effects were investigated with MRI and with histological analysis performed 3 hours to 1 week after sonication. RESULTS Thirteen targets were sonicated in regions next to the optic tract in the 4 animals. Inertial cavitation, indicated by broadband acoustic emissions, occurred at acoustic pressure amplitudes ranging from 340 to 540 kPa. MRI analysis suggested that the lesions had a central region containing red blood cell extravasations that was surrounded by edema. Blood-brain barrier disruption was observed on contrast-enhanced MRI in the lesions and in a surrounding region corresponding to the prefocal area of the FUS system. In histology, lesions consisting of tissue undergoing ischemic necrosis were found in all regions that were sonicated above the inertial cavitation threshold. Tissue damage in prefocal areas was found in several cases, suggesting that in those cases the sonication exceeded the inertial cavitation threshold in the beam path. CONCLUSIONS It is feasible to use a clinical TcMRgFUS system to ablate skull base targets in nonhuman primates at time-averaged acoustic power levels at least 2 orders of magnitude below what is needed for thermal ablation with this device. The results point to the risks associated with the method if the exposure levels are not carefully controlled to avoid inertial cavitation in the acoustic beam path. If methods can be developed to provide this control, this nonthermal approach could greatly expand the use of TcMRgFUS for precisely targeted ablation to locations across the entire brain.

Quantitative evaluation of sonophoresis efficiency and its dependence on sonication parameters and particle size

Transdermal drug delivery makes a critical contribution to medical practice and some advantages over conventional oral administration and hypodermic injection. Enhancement of percutaneous absorption or penetration of therapeutic agents (ie, drugs and macromolecules) by ultrasound, termed sonophoresis, has been applied and studied for decades. In this study, the penetration percentage through porcine ear skin specimens was determined quantitatively by measuring the fluorescence from nanoparticles of 60, 220, and 840 nm in size in a receptor chamber at different sonication parameters (ie, duty cycle, 20%-100%; acoustic intensity, 0.3-1.0 W/cm(2); duration, 7-30 minutes; and frequency, 1 MHz). In general, the sonophoresis efficiency increased with the acoustic intensity, duty cycle, and sonication duration but decreased with the particle size (mean ± SD, 62.6% ± 5.4% for 60-nm versus 11.9% ± 1.1% for 840-nm polystyrene nanospheres after 30 minutes of sonication at 0.5 W/cm(2) and a 100% duty cycle; P < .05). On scanning electron microscopy the pore size remained the same (≈100 μm), but more flakes were observed with the progress of sonication. In summary, sonophoresis efficiency is dependent on the ultrasound parameters and particle size. Sufficient sonication would lead to satisfactory penetration of even submicrometer objects through the pores.

MR-guided focused ultrasound surgery, present and future

MR-guided focused ultrasound surgery (MRgFUS) is a quickly developing technology with potential applications across a spectrum of indications traditionally within the domain of radiation oncology. Especially for applications where focal treatment is the preferred technique (for example, radiosurgery), MRgFUS has the potential to be a disruptive technology that could shift traditional patterns of care. While currently cleared in the United States for the noninvasive treatment of uterine fibroids and bone metastases, a wide range of clinical trials are currently underway, and the number of publications describing advances in MRgFUS is increasing. However, for MRgFUS to make the transition from a research curiosity to a clinical standard of care, a variety of challenges, technical, financial, clinical, and practical, must be overcome. This installment of the Vision 20∕20 series examines the current status of MRgFUS, focusing on the hurdles the technology faces before it can cross over from a research technique to a standard fixture in the clinic. It then reviews current and near-term technical developments which may overcome these hurdles and allow MRgFUS to break through into clinical practice.

Nonthermal ablation with microbubble-enhanced focused ultrasound close to the optic tract without affecting nerve function

OBJECT

Tumors at the skull base are challenging for both resection and radiosurgery given the presence of critical adjacent structures, such as cranial nerves, blood vessels, and brainstem. Magnetic resonance imaging-guided thermal ablation via laser or other methods has been evaluated as a minimally invasive alternative to these techniques in the brain. Focused ultrasound (FUS) offers a noninvasive method of thermal ablation; however, skull heating limits currently available technology to ablation at regions distant from the skull bone. Here, the authors evaluated a method that circumvents this problem by combining the FUS exposures with injected microbubble-based ultrasound contrast agent. These microbubbles concentrate the ultrasound-induced effects on the vasculature, enabling an ablation method that does not cause significant heating of the brain or skull.

METHODS

In 29 rats, a 525-kHz FUS transducer was used to ablate tissue structures at the skull base that were centered on or adjacent to the optic tract or chiasm. Low-intensity, low-duty-cycle ultrasound exposures (sonications) were applied for 5 minutes after intravenous injection of an ultrasound contrast agent (Definity, Lantheus Medical Imaging Inc.). Using histological analysis and visual evoked potential (VEP) measurements, the authors determined whether structural or functional damage was induced in the optic tract or chiasm.

RESULTS

Overall, while the sonications produced a well-defined lesion in the gray matter targets, the adjacent tract and chiasm had comparatively little or no damage. No significant changes (p > 0.05) were found in the magnitude or latency of the VEP recordings, either immediately after sonication or at later times up to 4 weeks after sonication, and no delayed effects were evident in the histological features of the optic nerve and retina.

CONCLUSIONS

This technique, which selectively targets the intravascular microbubbles, appears to be a promising method of noninvasively producing sharply demarcated lesions in deep brain structures while preserving function in adjacent nerves. Because of low vascularity--and thus a low microbubble concentration--some large white matter tracts appear to have some natural resistance to this type of ablation compared with gray matter. While future work is needed to develop methods of monitoring the procedure and establishing its safety at deep brain targets, the technique does appear to be a potential solution that allows FUS ablation of deep brain targets while sparing adjacent nerve structures.

Magnetic resonance-guided focused ultrasound surgery: Part 2: A review of current and future applications

Magnetic resonance-guided focused ultrasound surgery (MRgFUS) is a novel combination of technologies that is actively being realized as a noninvasive therapeutic tool for a myriad of conditions. These applications are reviewed with a focus on neurological use. A combined search of PubMed and MEDLINE was performed to identify the key events and current status of MRgFUS, with a focus on neurological applications. MRgFUS signifies a potentially ideal device for the treatment of neurological diseases. As it is nearly real time, it allows monitored provision of treatment location and energy deposition; is noninvasive, thereby limiting or eliminating disruption of normal tissue; provides focal delivery of therapeutic agents; enhances radiation delivery; and permits modulation of neural function. Multiple clinical applications are currently in clinical use and many more are under active preclinical investigation. The therapeutic potential of MRgFUS is expanding rapidly. Although clinically in its infancy, preclinical and early-phase I clinical trials in neurosurgery suggest a promising future for MRgFUS. Further investigation is necessary to define its true potential and impact.

Modeling of thermal effects in antivascular ultrasound therapy

Antivascular ultrasound consisting of low-intensity sonication in the presence of circulating microbubbles of an ultrasound contrast agent has been demonstrated to disrupt blood flow in solid cancers. In this study a mathematical framework is described for the microbubble-induced heating that occurs during antivascular ultrasound. Biological tissues are modeled as a continuum of microbubble-filled vasculature, cells, and interstitial fluids with compressibility equal to the sum of the compressibility of each component. The mathematical simulations show that the absorption of ultrasound waves by viscous damping of the microbubble oscillations induced significant local heating of the tissue vasculature. The extent and the rate of temperature increase not only depends on the properties of the microbubbles and the sonication parameters but is also influenced markedly by the blood flow. Slow flow conditions lead to higher tissue temperatures due to a stronger interaction between microbubbles and ultrasound and reduced heat dissipation. Because tumors have slower blood flow than healthy tissue, the microbubble-induced ultrasound antivascular therapy is likely to affect cancerous tissue more extensively than healthy tissue, providing a way to selectively target the vasculature of cancers.

Modeling cavitation nucleation from laser-illuminated nanoparticles subjected to acoustic stress

In an earlier work by Farny et al. [ARLO 6, 138-143 (2005).] it was demonstrated that the acoustic cavitation threshold in a tissue mimicking gel phantom can be lowered from 4.5 to ∼1 MPa by "seeding" the optically transparent phantom with light absorptive gold nanoparticles and irradiating these absorbers with nanosecond pulses of laser light at intensities less than 10 mJ/cm(2). As a follow-up study, a three-stage numerical model was developed to account for prenucleation heating, the nucleation and formation of the vapor cavity, and the resulting vapor bubble dynamics. Through examination of the radius-time evolution of the cavity, the combined thresholds for laser radiant exposure and acoustic peak pressure required to induce inertial cavitation are deduced. It is found that the threshold pressure decreases when laser exposure increases; but the rate depends on exposure levels and the size of the particle. Investigations of the roles of particle size and laser pulse length are performed and optimum choices for these parameters determined in order to obtain inertial cavitation at the lowest possible acoustic pressure and laser intensity.

Expression of heat shock protein 70 in rabbit liver after contrast-enhanced ultrasound and radiofrequency ablation

Heat shock proteins (HSPs) induced by thermal ablation therapy may help presenting tumor antigen to the host immune system and be a valuable adjuvant in the ablation therapy of liver cancer. This paper described our preliminary study on the expression of HSP70 in rabbit liver after contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) and radiofrequency (RF) ablation. Twenty-five male New Zealand white rabbits were divided into five groups as: control group (n=5), ultrasound group (n=5), CEUS group (n=5), RF group (n=5) and CEUS+ RF group (n=5). Clinical ultrasound and RF ablation equipment were used in the present experiment. Sonazoid was used as the contrast agent. All the animals were sacrificed 24 h after the procedure, and HSP70 was detected by immunohistochemistry staining and Western blot analysis. In the groups without RF ablation, there was no evidence of HSP70 expression in the liver tissue of the control group and ultrasound group, whereas positive HSP70 expression was detected in the liver tissue of the CEUS group, with a mean optical density of 0.33. In the RF and CEUS+ RF groups, there were cells showing HSP70 expression in the normal liver tissue far from the ablation region. The mean densities of HSP70 expression were 0.31 in the RF group and 0.35 in the CEUS+ RF group, respectively. With regard to the distribution of HSP70 expression of the RF and CEUS+ RF groups, the marginal areas were stronger than liver tissue 1 cm away from the margin, and the ablated tissues showed no evidence of HSP70 expression. The mean density of HSP70 expression in the marginal areas were 0.47 in the RF group and 0.42 in the CEUS+ RF group, respectively. CEUS using Sonazoid may produce HSP70 expression in the normal liver parenchyma after CEUS examination and RF ablation. (E-mail: moriyasu@tokyo-med.ac.jp).

Current status and future potential of MRI-guided focused ultrasound surgery

The combination of the imaging abilities of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with the ability to delivery energy to targets deep in the body noninvasively with focused ultrasound presents a disruptive technology with the potential to significantly affect healthcare. MRI offers precise targeting, visualization, and quantification of temperature changes and the ability to immediately evaluate the treatment. By exploiting different mechanisms, focused ultrasound offers a range of therapies, ranging from thermal ablation to targeted drug delivery. This article reviews recent preclinical and tests clinical of this technology.

Bioeffects considerations for diagnostic ultrasound contrast agents

Diagnostic ultrasound contrast agents have been developed for enhancing the echogenicity of blood and for delineating other structures of the body. Approved agents are suspensions of gas bodies (stabilized microbubbles), which have been designed for persistence in the circulation and strong echo return for imaging. The interaction of ultrasound pulses with these gas bodies is a form of acoustic cavitation, and they also may act as inertial cavitation nuclei. This interaction produces mechanical perturbation and a potential for bioeffects on nearby cells or tissues. In vitro, sonoporation and cell death occur at mechanical index (MI) values less than the inertial cavitation threshold. In vivo, bioeffects reported for MI values greater than 0.4 include microvascular leakage, petechiae, cardiomyocyte death, inflammatory cell infiltration, and premature ventricular contractions and are accompanied by gas body destruction within the capillary bed. Bioeffects for MIs of 1.9 or less have been reported in skeletal muscle, fat, myocardium, kidney, liver, and intestine. Therapeutic applications that rely on these bioeffects include targeted drug delivery to the interstitium and DNA transfer into cells for gene therapy. Bioeffects of contrast-aided diagnostic ultrasound happen on a microscopic scale, and their importance in the clinical setting remains uncertain.

Modeling photothermal and acoustical induced microbubble generation and growth

Previous experimental studies showed that powerful heating of nanoparticles by a laser pulse using energy density greater than 100 mJ/cm(2), could induce vaporization and generate microbubbles. When ultrasound is introduced at the same time as the laser pulse, much less laser power is required. For therapeutic applications, generation of microbubbles on demand at target locations, e.g. cells or bacteria can be used to induce hyperthermia or to facilitate drug delivery. The objective of this work is to develop a method capable of predicting photothermal and acoustic parameters in terms of laser power and acoustic pressure amplitude that are needed to produce stable microbubbles; and investigate the influence of bubble coalescence on the thresholds when the microbubbles are generated around nanoparticles that appear in clusters. We develop and solve here a combined problem of momentum, heat and mass transfer which is associated with generation and growth of a microbubble, filled with a mixture of non-vaporized gas (air) and water vapor. The microbubble's size and gas content vary as a result of three mechanisms: gas expansion or compression, evaporation or condensation on the bubble boundary, and diffusion of dissolved air in the surrounding water. The simulations predict that when ultrasound is applied relatively low threshold values of laser and ultrasound power are required to obtain a stable microbubble from a single nanoparticle. Even lower power is required when microbubbles are formed by coalescence around a cluster of 10 nanoparticles. Laser pulse energy density of 21 mJ/cm(2) is predicted for instance together with acoustic pressure of 0.1 MPa for a cluster of 10 or 62 mJ/cm(2) for a single nanoparticle. Those values are well within the safety limits, and as such are most appealing for targeted therapeutic purposes.

Increased acoustic and electromagnetic energy deposition in a layered tissue model

By analyzing and optimizing acoustic and electromagnetic waves absorption in a simplified layered model of hyperthermic configuration, it is shown that the commonly used attenuation metrics are not always proper means for determining the generally optimal parameters of typical thermal therapy problem with finite extent target The conditions, parameters and bounds for optimal (maximal) incident power absorption for the layered model have been found analytically and explicitly and are presented in terms of basic wave propagation characteristics, thus, also providing the necessary data for optimal synthesis of absorbing tissues and materials.

Induction of apoptosis in vivo in the rabbit brain with focused ultrasound and Optison

Histologic effects of focused ultrasound (FUS) exposures combined with an ultrasound contrast agent (Optison) were investigated to examine whether the lesions were dominated by apoptosis or necrosis. The rabbit brains (n = 17) were sonicated (1.5 MHz, peak rarefactional pressure amplitude: 1.4 to 8.8 MPa) after Optison was injected intravenously (IV). MRI and light microscopy were used to examine tissue effects. To detect apoptosis, TUNEL staining based on labeling of DNA strand breaks was used. The average number of apoptotic and necrotic cells in 300 x 220 microm microscopic fields were counted in 18 representative lesions. Lesions in the rabbit brains were created at lowered acoustic power levels when FUS was combined with Optison. In histology, the lesions exhibited red blood cell extravasations and destruction of blood vessels. At 4 h after sonication, the lesions lost many cells, and the remaining cells exhibited both necrotic and apoptotic features. Overall, apoptosis dominated; there were, on average, 32.3 +/- 13.2 apoptotic cells per microscopic field compared with only 5.1 +/- 3.4 necrotic cells per field. In conclusion, FUS combined with Optison could produce lesions that are dominated by apoptosis, presumably induced primarily via ischemia after cavitation-produced damage to the brain vasculature.

Microbubble contrast agent with focused ultrasound to create brain lesions at low power levels: MR imaging and histologic study in rabbits

PURPOSE

To evaluate magnetic resonance (MR) imaging-based thermometry for predicting the onset and spatial extent of lesions produced by focused ultrasound combined with a microbubble contrast agent (Optison; GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, Wis) and to compare the resulting induced temperature increase and threshold for damage with those in studies performed without the agent.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The experiments were approved by the animal care committee. Fifty-three locations in the brains of 15 rabbits were sonicated with various exposure parameters by using a 1.5-MHz focused ultrasound transducer. MR imaging was used to map the temperature rise and, along with light microscopy, to examine the lesions. Diameters of isotherms created from thermometry were compared with the resulting lesions by using Bland-Altman analysis and linear regression. The minimum acoustic power necessary for lesion creation was determined, and the apparent temperature threshold for damage was calculated with probit analysis. These thresholds were compared with prior work performed without the contrast agent. The heating induced with the microbubbles was compared with that in sonications performed without them by using a t test.

RESULTS

The MR imaging-mapped temperature distributions matched the shape of the lesions. The diameters of isotherms correlated well with diameters measured at contrast material-enhanced MR imaging (mean difference between measurements, 0.0 mm +/- 0.5; R = 0.93). The temperature increase with microbubbles was statistically larger (P < .01) than for sonications performed without microbubbles. In some locations (mostly continuous wave exposures), damage was observed along the ultrasound beam path. The time-averaged acoustic power damage threshold was reduced by 91% for 10-second exposures when compared with earlier studies performed without microbubbles. The probability of producing lesions was 50% at a temperature increase of 5.9 degrees C, 5.5 degrees C lower than was observed earlier without the agent.

CONCLUSION

MR imaging-based temperature measurements appeared to correlate with focused ultrasound-induced lesions in the brain when microbubbles were present, even though the temperature appeared to be below the threshold for thermal damage.

Contrast-agent-enhanced ultrasound thermal ablation

The small thermal lesions induced when using high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) to ablate tumors results in long treatment duration. In this study, the effect of using ultrasound contrast agent (UCA, Definity) to enhance the ultrasound (US) thermal effects and, thus to enlarge the lesion size, was studied in transparent tissue phantoms insonified by 1.85-MHz US with acoustical powers of 28.9 and 40.4 W. The experimental results show that the lesion size depended strongly on the electrical power and the concentration of UCA. UCA also reduced the power required to form a lesion of a certain size by about 30%. However, UCA moved the greatest heating position from the transducer focus, by 2.16 cm for 0.015% UCA at 40.4 W, and with lesions forming at the surface for UCA concentrations higher than 0.1%. An optimal result was obtained when using 0.001% UCA and 28.9-W US, which produced a lesion 12 times larger and an acceptable shift (less than half of the lesion length). UCA can effectively increase the size of the HIFU lesions, but lesion shift should be carefully considered while performing HIFU ablations.

Enhanced heat deposition using ultrasound contrast agent--modeling and experimental observations

Ultrasound contrast agents (UCA), created originally for visualization and diagnostic purposes, recently have been suggested as efficient enhancers of ultrasonic power deposition in tissue. The ultrasonic energy absorption by the contrast agents, considered as problematic in diagnostic imaging, might have beneficial impact in therapeutic applications such as targeted hyperthermia-based or ablation treatments. Introduction of gas microbubbles into the tissue to be treated can improve the effectiveness of current treatments by limiting the temperature rise to the treated site and minimizing the damage to the surrounding healthy tissues. To this end, proper assessment of the governing parameters of energy absorption by ultrasonically induced stabilized bubbles is important for both diagnostic and therapeutic ultrasound applications. The current study was designed to predict theoretically and measure experimentally the dissipation and heating effects of encapsulated UCA in a well-controlled and calibrated environment. The ultrasonic effects of the microbubble concentration, transmitted intensity, and frequency on power dissipation and stability of the UCA have been studied. The maximal temperature elevation obtained during 300 s experiments was 21 degrees C, in a 10 ml volume target containing UCA, insonifled by unfocused 3.2 MHz continuous wave (CW) at spatial average intensity of 1.1 W/cm2 (182 kPa). The results also suggest that higher frequencies are more efficiently absorbed by commonly used UCA. In particular, for spatial average intensity of 1.1 W/cm2 and concentration of 5 x 10(6) microspheres/cm3, no significant reduction of UCA absorption was noticed during the first 150 s for insonation at 3.2 MHz and the first 100 s for insonation at 1 MHz. In addition, when lower average intensity of 0.5 W/cm2 (160 kPa) at 3.2 MHz was used, the UCA absorptivity sustained for almost 200 s. Thus, when properly activated, UCA may be suitable for localized hyperthermic therapies.

In vivo acceleration of ultrasonic tissue heating by microbubble agent

The ultrasonic power absorbed by a microbubble in its continuous wave response is estimated through numerically solving a version of the Rayleigh-Plesset equation. At an ultrasonic frequency of 3 MHz, a resonant microbubble, approximately 1.1 microm in radius, showed an absorption cross section of about 0.005 mm2 in its low power response. This estimation predicts that the tissue ultrasonic absorption will be doubled when such microbubbles are delivered to the tissue at a concentration of about eight bubbles/mm3 in tissue. An exteriorized murine kidney was exposed to focused ultrasound at 3.2 MHz in degassed saline, and the tissue temperature change was measured. With an intravenous bolus administration of a microbubble agent, the ultrasonically induced temperature elevation was multiplied by up to five times. The enhancement in temperature elevation gradually decreased as the microbubble agent was eliminated from the body. The experimental results agreed with the prediction in the order of magnitude. This effect may have a potential use to enhance the throughput as well as the selectivity of focused ultrasound treatment.

Microbubble-enhanced cavitation for noninvasive ultrasound surgery

Experiments were conducted to explore the potential of stabilized microbubbles for aiding tissue ablation during ultrasound therapy. Surgically exteriorized canine kidneys were irradiated in situ using single exposures of focused ultrasound. In each experiment, up to eight separate exposures were placed in the left kidney. The right kidney was then similarly exposed, but while an ultrasound contrast agent was continually infused. Kidneys were sectioned and examined for gross observable tissue damage. Tissue damage was produced more frequently, by lower intensity and shorter duration exposures, in kidneys irradiated with the contrast agent present. Using 250-ms exposures, the minimum intensity that produced damage was lower in kidneys with microbubbles than those without (controls) in 10 of 11 (91%) animals. In a separate study using approximately 3200 W/cm2 exposures, the minimum duration that produced damage was shorter after microbubbles were introduced in 11 of 12 (92%) animals. With microbubbles, gross observable tissue damage was produced with exposure intensity > or = approximately 800 W/cm2 and exposure duration > or = 10 micros. The overall intensity and duration tissue damage thresholds were reduced by approximately 2x and approximately 100x, respectively. Results indicate that acoustic cavitation is a primary damage mechanism. Lowering in vivo tissue damage thresholds with stabilized microbubbles acting as cavitation nuclei may make acoustic cavitation a more predictable, and thus practical, mechanism for noninvasive ultrasound surgery.

Measurements of bubble-enhanced heating from focused, MHz-frequency ultrasound in a tissue-mimicking material

Time-resolved measurements of the temperature field in an agar-based tissue-mimicking phantom insonated with a large aperture 1-MHz focused acoustic transducer are reported. The acoustic pressure amplitude and insonation duration were varied. Above a critical threshold acoustic pressure, a large increase in the temperature rise during insonation was observed. Evidence for the hypothesis that cavitation bubble activity in the focal zone is the cause of enhanced heating is presented and discussed. Mechanisms for bubble-assisted heating are presented and modeled, and quantitative estimates for the thermal power generated by viscous dissipation and bubble acoustic radiation are given.

Modeling of high-intensity focused ultrasound-induced lesions in the presence of cavitation bubbles

The classical "Bio Heat Transfer Equation (BHTE)" model is adapted to take into account the effects of oscillating microbubbles that occur naturally in the tissue during high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) treatment. First, the Gilmore-Akulichev model is used to quantify the acoustic pressure scattered by microbubbles submitted to HIFU. Because this scattered pressure is not monochromatic, the concept of harmonic attenuation is introduced and a global attenuation coefficient is estimated for bubble-filled tissues. The first results show that this global attenuation coefficient varies significantly with respect to several parameters such as the frequency and the density of microbubbles in the medium, but also with respect to the incident acoustic pressure which thus becomes a transcendental function. Under these conditions, a layer-by-layer modeling, in the direction of propagation, is proposed to calculate the ultrasonic beam. Finally, the BHTE is solved and the HIFU-induced lesions are estimated by the calculation of the thermal dose. Using this model, it can be observed first that, when the firing power increases, the lesion develops clearly in the direction of the transducer, with a shape agreeing with in vivo experimentation. Next, it is observed that the lesion can be significantly modified in size and position, if an interface (skin or inner wall) is simulated as a zone with multiple cavitation nuclei. With a firing power increase, it is also shown how a secondary lesion can appear at the interface and how, beyond a certain threshold, this lesion develops at the main lesion expense. Finally, a better in-depth homogeneity of lesions is observed when the acoustic frequency of HIFU is increased.