Remodeling of elastic fiber components in scleroderma skin

Systemic sclerosis skin is a primed microenvironment for soft tissue calcification-a hypothesis

Calcinosis cutis, defined as sub-epidermal deposition of calcium salts, is a major clinical problem in patients with SSc, affecting 20-40% of patients. A number of recognized factors associated with calcinosis have been identified, including disease duration, digital ischaemia and acro-osteolysis. Yet, to date, the pathogenesis of SSc-related calcinosis remains unknown, and currently there is no effective disease-modifying pharmacotherapy. Following onset of SSc, there are marked changes in the extracellular matrix (ECM) of the skin, notably a breakdown in the microfibrillar network and accumulation of type I collagen. Our hypothesis is that these pathological changes reflect a changing cellular phenotype and result in a primed microenvironment for soft tissue calcification, with SSc fibroblasts adopting a pro-osteogenic profile, and specific driving forces promoting tissue mineralization. Considering the role of the ECM in disease progression may help elucidate the mechanism(s) behind SSc-related calcinosis and inform the development of future therapeutic interventions.

Fibrillin protein pleiotropy: Acromelic dysplasias

The fibrillins are large extracellular matrix molecules that polymerize to form microfibrils. Fibrillin microfibrils are distinctive architectural elements that are both ubiquitous in the connective tissue space and also unique, displaying tissue-specific patterns. Mutations in the genes for fibrillin-1 (FBN1) result in multiple distinct pleiotropic disorders. Most of the more than 3000 mutations known today in FBN1 cause the Marfan syndrome. Marfan mutations can occur in any of the 56 domains that compose fibrillin-1. In contrast, rare mutations in FBN1 that are confined to only certain domains cause several different types of acromelic dysplasia. These genetic disorders demonstrate that specific domains of fibrillin-1 perform roles important to musculoskeletal growth. Many of the phenotypes of acromelic dysplasias are the opposite of those found in Marfan syndrome. Knowledge of the functions and structural organization of fibrillin molecules within microfibrils is required to understand how one protein and one gene can be the basis for multiple genetic disorders.

Cartilage Oligomeric Matrix Protein Increases in Photodamaged Skin

Cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) is a structural component of cartilage. Recent studies have described COMP as a pathogenic factor that promotes collagen deposition in fibrotic skin disorders such as scleroderma and keloid skin. Although collagen, a major dermis component, is thought to decrease in photoaged skin, recent reports have demonstrated the presence of tightly packed collagen fibrils with a structural resemblance to fibrosis in the papillary dermis of photoaged skin. Here we examined how photoaging damage relates to COMP expression and localization in photoaged skin. In situ hybridization revealed an increase in COMP-mRNA-positive cells with the progress of photoaging in preauricular skin (sun-exposed skin). The signal intensity of immunostaining for COMP increased with photoaging in not only the papillary dermis but also the reticular dermis affected by advancing solar elastosis. Immunoelectron microscopy detected the colocalization of COMP with both elastotic materials and collagen fibrils in photoaged skin. Ultraviolet light A irradiation of human dermal fibroblasts induced COMP expression at both the mRNA and protein levels. Ultraviolet light A-induced COMP expression was inhibited by an anti-transforming growth factor-β antibody or SB431542, an activin receptor-like kinase 5 inhibitor. These results suggest that the transforming growth factor-β-mediated upregulation of COMP expression may contribute to the modulation of dermal extracellular matrix in the photoaging process.

Tight Skin 2 Mice Exhibit Delayed Wound Healing Caused by Increased Elastic Fibers in Fibrotic Skin

Rationale: The Tight Skin 2 (Tsk2) mouse model of systemic sclerosis (SSc) has many features of human disease, including tight skin, excessive collagen deposition, alterations in the extracellular matrix (ECM), increased elastic fibers, and occurrence of antinuclear antibodies with age. A tight skin phenotype is observed by 2 weeks of age, but measurable skin fibrosis is only apparent at 10 weeks. We completed a series of wound healing experiments to determine how fibrosis affects wound healing in Tsk2/+ mice compared with their wild-type (WT) littermates. Method: We performed these experiments by introducing four 4 mm biopsy punched wounds on the back of each mouse, ventral of the midline, and observed wound healing over 10 days. Tsk2/+ mice showed significantly delayed wound healing and increased wound size compared with the WT littermates at both 5 and 10 weeks of age. We explored the potential sources of this response by wounding Tsk2/+ mice that were genetically deficient either for the NLRP3 inflammasome (a known fibrosis mediator), or for elastic fibers in the skin, using a fibulin-5 knockout. Conclusion: We found that the loss of elastic fibers restores normal wound healing in the Tsk2/+ mouse and that the loss of the NLRP3 inflammasome had no effect. We conclude that elastic fiber dysregulation is the primary cause of delayed wound healing in the Tsk2/+ mouse and therapies that promote collagen deposition in the tissue matrix in the absence of elastin deposition might be beneficial in promoting wound healing in SSc and other diseases.

Integrin-modulating therapy prevents fibrosis and autoimmunity in mouse models of scleroderma

In systemic sclerosis (SSc), a common and aetiologically mysterious form of scleroderma (defined as pathological fibrosis of the skin), previously healthy adults acquire fibrosis of the skin and viscera in association with autoantibodies. Familial recurrence is extremely rare and causal genes have not been identified. Although the onset of fibrosis in SSc typically correlates with the production of autoantibodies, whether they contribute to disease pathogenesis or simply serve as a marker of disease remains controversial and the mechanism for their induction is largely unknown. The study of SSc is hindered by a lack of animal models that recapitulate the aetiology of this complex disease. To gain a foothold in the pathogenesis of pathological skin fibrosis, we studied stiff skin syndrome (SSS), a rare but tractable Mendelian disorder leading to childhood onset of diffuse skin fibrosis with autosomal dominant inheritance and complete penetrance. We showed previously that SSS is caused by heterozygous missense mutations in the gene (FBN1) encoding fibrillin-1, the main constituent of extracellular microfibrils. SSS mutations all localize to the only domain in fibrillin-1 that harbours an Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD) motif needed to mediate cell-matrix interactions by binding to cell-surface integrins. Here we show that mouse lines harbouring analogous amino acid substitutions in fibrillin-1 recapitulate aggressive skin fibrosis that is prevented by integrin-modulating therapies and reversed by antagonism of the pro-fibrotic cytokine transforming growth factor β (TGF-β). Mutant mice show skin infiltration of pro-inflammatory immune cells including plasmacytoid dendritic cells, T helper cells and plasma cells, and also autoantibody production; these findings are normalized by integrin-modulating therapies or TGF-β antagonism. These results show that alterations in cell-matrix interactions are sufficient to initiate and sustain inflammatory and pro-fibrotic programmes and highlight new therapeutic strategies.

Matrix-dependent perturbation of TGFβ signaling and disease

Transforming growth factor beta (TGFβ) is a multipotent cytokine that is sequestered in the extracellular matrix (ECM) through interactions with a number of ECM proteins. The ECM serves to concentrate latent TGFβ at sites of intended function, to influence the bioavailability and/or function of TGFβ activators, and perhaps to regulate the intrinsic performance of cell surface effectors of TGFβ signal propagation. The downstream consequences of TGFβ signaling cascades in turn provide feedback modulation of the ECM. This review covers recent examples of how genetic mutations in constituents of the ECM or TGFβ signaling cascade result in altered ECM homeostasis, cellular performance and ultimately disease, with an emphasis on emerging therapeutic strategies that seek to capitalize on this refined mechanistic understanding.

Serum elastin-derived peptides and anti-elastin antibody in patients with systemic sclerosis

The elastin metabolism in systemic sclerosis (SSc) has been known to be abnormal. The authors investigated relationship between the clinical manifestations of systemic sclerosis (SSc) and serum levels of soluble elastin-derived peptide (S-EDP) and anti-elastin antibodies. Serum samples were obtained from 79 patients with SSc and 79 age- and sex-matched healthy controls. Concentrations of serum S-EDP and anti-elastin antibodies were measured by ELISA. The serum concentrations of S-EDP in SSc patients were significantly higher than in healthy controls (median, 144.44 ng/mL vs 79.59 ng/mL, P < 0.001). Serum EDP concentrations were found to be correlated with disease duration in SSc (P = 0.002) and particularly in diffuse cutaneous SSc (P = 0.005). Levels of anti-elastin antibodies were found to be more elevated in SSc patients than in healthy controls (median, 0.222 U vs 0.191 U, P = 0.049), more increased in diffuse cutaneous SSc than limited cutaneous SSc (median, 0.368 U vs 0.204 U, P = 0.031). In addition, levels of anti-elastin antibodies were also found to be negatively associated with presence of anti-centromere antibody (P = 0.023). The S-EDP levels were not found to be correlated with levels of anti-elastin antibodies. The increased S-EDP and anti-elastin antibody levels and association with clinical and laboratory characteristics may reflect the abnormal metabolism in SSc.

Mutations in fibrillin-1 cause congenital scleroderma: stiff skin syndrome

The predisposition for scleroderma, defined as fibrosis and hardening of the skin, is poorly understood. We report that stiff skin syndrome (SSS), an autosomal dominant congenital form of scleroderma, is caused by mutations in the sole Arg-Gly-Asp sequence-encoding domain of fibrillin-1 that mediates integrin binding. Ordered polymers of fibrillin-1 (termed microfibrils) initiate elastic fiber assembly and bind to and regulate the activation of the profibrotic cytokine transforming growth factor-beta (TGFbeta). Altered cell-matrix interactions in SSS accompany excessive microfibrillar deposition, impaired elastogenesis, and increased TGFbeta concentration and signaling in the dermis. The observation of similar findings in systemic sclerosis, a more common acquired form of scleroderma, suggests broad pathogenic relevance.

Enhanced fibrillin-2 expression is a general feature of wound healing and sclerosis: potential alteration of cell attachment and storage of TGF-beta

Wound healing and sclerosis are characterized by an increase of extracellular matrix proteins, which are characteristically expressed in the embryo-fetal period. We analyzed the expression of fibrillin-2, which is typically found in embryonic tissues, but only scarcely in adult skin. In wound healing and sclerotic skin diseases such as lipodermatosclerosis and scleroderma, a marked increase of fibrillin-2 expression was found by immunohistology. Double labelling of fibrillin-2 and tenascin-C, which is also expressed in wound healing and sclerosis, showed co-localization of both proteins. Solid-phase and slot blot-overlay assays showed a dose-dependent binding of the recombinant N-terminal half of fibrillin-2 (rFBN2-N) to tenascin-C. Real-time PCR showed an increase of the fibrillin-2 gene expression in cell culture triggered by typical mediators for fibroblast activation such as serum, IL-4, and TGF-beta. By contrast, prolonged hypoxia is not associated with changes in fibrillin-2 expression. Tenascin-C is an anti-adhesive substrate for fibroblasts, whereas fibrillin-2 stimulates cell attachment. Attachment assays using mixed substrates showed decreased cell attachment when tenascin-C and rFBN2-N were coated together, compared with the attachment to rFBN2-N alone. Fibrillins are involved in storage and activation of TGF-beta. Immunohistology with an antibody against the latency-associated peptide (LAP (TGF-beta1)) showed a marked increase of inactive LAP-bound TGF-beta1 in wound healing and sclerotic skin whereas normal skin showed only a weak expression. Double immunofluorescence confirmed a partial colocalization of both proteins. In conclusion, we show that a stimulation of the fibrillin-2 expression is a characteristic feature of fibroblasts present in wound healing and sclerosis, which may be involved in the alteration of cell attachment and storage of inactive TGF-beta in the matrix.

Antagonistic effect of the matricellular signaling protein CCN3 on TGF-beta- and Wnt-mediated fibrillinogenesis in systemic sclerosis and Marfan syndrome

Abnormal fibrillinogenesis is associated with connective tissue disorders (CTDs), including Marfan syndrome (MFS), systemic sclerosis (SSc) and Tight-skin (Tsk) mice. We have previously shown that TGF-beta and Wnt stimulate fibrillin-1 assembly and that fibrillin-1 and the developmental regulator CCN3 are both highly increased in Tsk skin. We investigated the role of CCN3 in abnormal fibrillinogenesis in Tsk mice, MFS, and SSc. Smad3 deletion in Tsk mice decreased CCN3 overexpression, suggesting that TGF-beta mediates at least part of the effect of Tsk fibrillin on CCN3 which is consistent with a synergistic effect of TGF-beta and Wnt in vitro on CCN3 expression. Disruption of fibrillin-1 assembly by MFS fibrillin decreased CCN3 expression and skin from patients with early diffuse SSc showed a strong correlation between increased CCN3 and fibrillin-1 expression, suggesting that CCN3 regulation by fibrillin-1 extends to these CTDs. Diffuse SSc skin and sera also showed evidence of increased Wnt activity, implicating a Wnt stimulus behind this correlation. CCN3 overexpression markedly repressed fibrillin-1 assembly and also blocked other TGFbeta- and Wnt-regulated profibrotic gene expression. Together, these data indicate that CCN3 counter-regulates positive signals from TGF-beta and Wnt for fibrillin fibrillogenesis and profibrotic gene expression.

Analysis of dermal elastic fibers in the absence of fibulin-5 reveals potential roles for fibulin-5 in elastic fiber assembly

Fibulin-5 is a 66 kDa modular, extracellular matrix protein that localizes to elastic fibers. Although in vitro protein-protein binding studies have shown that fibulin-5 binds many proteins involved in elastic fiber formation, the specific role of fibulin-5 in elastogenesis remains unclear. To provide a more detailed analysis of elastic fiber assembly in the absence of fibulin-5, the dermis of wild-type and fibulin-5 gene knockout (Fbln5(-/-)) mice was examined with electron microscopy (EM). Although light microscopy showed apparently normal elastic fibers near the hair follicles and the absence of elastic fibers in the intervening dermis of the Fbln5(-/-) mouse, EM revealed the presence of aberrantly assembled elastic fibers in both locales. Instead of the elastin being incorporated into the microfibrillar scaffold, the elastin appeared as globules juxtaposed to the microfibrils. Desmosine analysis showed significantly lower levels of mature cross-linked elastin in the Fbln5(-/-) dermis, however, gene expression levels for tropoelastin and fibrillin-1, the major elastic fiber components, were unaffected. Based on these results, the nature of tropoelastin cross-linking was investigated using domain specific antibodies to lysyl oxidase like-1 (LOXL-1). Immunolocalization with an antibody to the N-terminal pro-peptide, which is cleaved to generate the active enzyme, revealed abundant staining in the Fbln5(-/-) dermis and no staining in the wild-type dermis. Overall, these results suggest two previously unrecognized functions for fibulin-5 in elastogenesis; first, to limit the extent of aggregation of tropoelastin monomers and/or coacervates and aid in the incorporation of elastin into the microfibril bundles, and second, to potentially assist in the activation of LOXL-1.

Transcription factor Fli1 regulates collagen fibrillogenesis in mouse skin

Biosynthesis of fibrillar collagen in the skin is precisely regulated to maintain proper tissue homeostasis; however, the molecular mechanisms involved in this process remain largely unknown. Transcription factor Fli1 has been shown to repress collagen synthesis in cultured dermal fibroblasts. This study investigated the role of Fli1 in regulation of collagen biosynthesis in mice skin in vivo using mice with the homozygous deletion of the C-terminal transcriptional activation (CTA) domain of the Fli1 gene (Fli1(DeltaCTA/DeltaCTA)). Skin analyses of the Fli1 mutant mice revealed a significant upregulation of fibrillar collagen genes at mRNA level, as well as increased collagen content as measured by acetic acid extraction and hydroxyproline assays. In addition, collagen fibrils contained ultrastructural abnormalities including immature thin fibrils and very thick irregularly shaped fibrils, which correlated with the reduced levels of decorin, fibromodulin, and lumican. Fibroblasts cultured from the skin of Fli1(DeltaCTA/DeltaCTA) mice maintained elevated synthesis of collagen mRNA and protein. Additional experiments in cultured fibroblasts have revealed that although Fli1 DeltaCTA retains the ability to bind to the collagen promoter in vitro and in vivo, it no longer functions as transcriptional repressor. Together, these results establish Fli1 as a key regulator of the collagen homeostasis in the skin in vivo.

Detection of elastin derived peptides in cerebrospinal fluid of patients with first ever ischaemic stroke

OBJECTIVE

We have previously reported the optimized methods for the detection of elastin derived peptides (EDP) in the serum, synovial fluid, and bronchoalveolar lavage. The aim of the present study was to investigate whether EDP are detectable in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of patients with acute brain ischaemia.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Twenty-seven first ever ischaemic stroke patients (mean age 61.5+/-10.8 years; age range 47-70 years; 12 women) were studied in acute phase (1-15 days after the onset) with clinical evaluations, radiological assessments, and the analysis of serum and CSF based on Western blot and ELISA for the detection and quantification of EDP.

RESULTS

None of the serum EDP concentrations are significantly higher in stroke patients compared with 25 healthy control individuals. However, EDP levels in CSF are strongly (p<0.0001) elevated compared with healthy subjects. They correlated with total cholesterol (r=0.53; p=0.02), triglycerides (r=0.67; p=0.004) and retinopathy (r=0.24; p=0.03), and with the interval between the stroke onset and the time of lumbar puncture (r=0.35; p=0.02).

CONCLUSION

EDPs are detectable in CSF of healthy subjects and patients with ischaemic stroke. Acute brain infarction is followed by increased levels of EDP in CSF.

Gene profiling of scleroderma skin reveals robust signatures of disease that are imperfectly reflected in the transcript profiles of explanted fibroblasts

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether biopsy specimens obtained from systemic sclerosis (SSc) lesions show a distinctive gene profile, whether that gene profile is maintained in fibroblasts cultured from SSc skin biopsy specimens, and whether results from tissue obtained from multiple clinical centers can be combined to yield useful observations in this rare disease.

METHODS

Biopsy samples and passaged fibroblasts were stored in RNAlater solution prior to processing for RNA. RNA from SSc and control skin biopsy specimens, as well as SSc and control explanted passage 4 fibroblasts, from 9 patients and 9 controls was hybridized to Affymetrix HG-U133A arrays. Data were analyzed using the BRB ArrayTools system. When appropriate, findings were followed up with immunohistochemical analysis or TaqMan studies.

RESULTS

Biopsy samples obtained from patients with SSc had a robust and distinctive gene profile, with approximately 1,800 qualifiers distinguishing normal skin from SSc skin at a significant level. The SSc phenotype was the major driver of sample clusters, independent of origin. Alterations in transforming growth factor beta and Wnt pathways, extracellular matrix proteins, and the CCN family were prominent. Explanted fibroblasts from SSc biopsy samples showed a far smaller subset of changes that were relatively variable between samples, suggesting that either nonfibroblast cell types or other aspects of the dermal milieu are required for full expression of the SSc phenotype.

CONCLUSION

SSc has a distinct gene profile that is not confounded by geographic location, indicating that extended multicenter studies may be worthwhile to identify distinct subsets of disease by transcript profiling. Explanted SSc fibroblasts show an incomplete reflection of the SSc phenotype.

Serum fibrillin-antifibrillin immune complexes among diabetic children

The fibrillins are large glycoproteins components of 10-nm microfibrils found in the extracellular matrix of most tissues. Microfibrils play a role in elastic fiber assembly and serve to link cells to elastic fibers in the extracellular matrix. Fibrillin-1 (FBN-1) and -2 (FBN-2) are large, secreted glycoproteins known to be components of extracellular matrix microfibrils located in the vasculature, basement membrane, and various connective tissues and are often associated with a superstructure known as the elastic fiber. Anti-fibrillin antibodies found in some autoimmune diseases could form circulating immune complexes (CIC) with corresponding antigens. Type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus is an autoimmune disease leading to formation of different types of autoantibodies. To determine the possible presence of FBN-anti-FBN CIC (IgG and IgM) were studied by modified version of ELISA 35 children with Type 1 diabetes mellitus (mean age--12.37+/-3.77 years, diabetes duration 4+/-3.5 years). Eight of the diabetics had vascular complications. Twenty healthy children (mean age--11.58+/-2.89 years) were used as controls. Diabetics showed statistically significant higher levels of FBN-anti-FBN-2 CIC - IgG (0.303+/-0.076 vs. 0.252+/-0.029; p=0.029) and IgM (0.415+/-0.085 vs. 0.348+/-0.069; p=0.018) compared to the control group. FBN-anti-FBN-1 CIC IgM correlate with diabetes duration (r=0.52; p=0.0015) and BMI (r=0.33, p=0.053) while FBN-anti-FBN-1 CIC IgG correlate with serum Zinc (r=0.49, p=0.006). FBN-anti-FBN-2 CIC IgG correlate with microalbuminuria (r=0.65, p=0.0046) and retinopathy (r=0.61, p=0.0001). This study suggests that there may be a relationship of levels of FBN-anti-FBN-2 CIC IgG with the development of diabetic microangiopathy. Of course the number of the tested patients is limited for definitive conclusions. Although the meaning of these results is still being determined, the measurement of FBN-anti-FBN CIC may represent immunologic markers of FBN metabolism.

Systemic sclerosis: the susceptible host (genetics and environment)

It is becoming evident that several genetic factors participate in modulating susceptibility to SSc and its clinical manifestations. Some genes that specifically affect ECM metabolism and vascular function may be unique to SSc and scleroderma-related disorders; others, such as those genes involved in regulating immune tolerance, are likely shared with other autoimmune diseases. The effect of genetic variations (or polymorphisms) that are found in most of these genes taken individually will likely have only a small or modest effect on disease risk; only a few genetic variations are expected to be highly penetrant. Moreover, genetic studies in SSc have to deal with the additional issues of heterogeneous phenotypes, low disease prevalence in the general population, and an even greater paucity of multiplex families that makes traditional linkage studies difficult, if not impossible. Alternative approaches include allelic association studies, but conventional case-controls designs may be subject to selection bias and will require large sample sizes if the genes that are under investigation confer only modest (OR = 1.5-2.0) disease risk (Fig. 2). The simultaneous examination of several genes that are biologically relevant to a specific disease process to attain higher aggregate ORs, is one approach that was used in several reports that were cited in this review. The use of family-based controls, such as in the transmission-disequilibrium test (based on assessment of the transmitted or nontransmitted alleles that are associated with disease from heterozygous parents to affected offspring), would provide more robustness to spurious associations from population stratification, but is actually less powerful and efficient than case-control designs. Furthermore, for many late adult-onset diseases the effort required to obtain samples from living parents are for a variety of reasons not trivial. The success of these allelic association-based approaches depends on the identification of likely candidate disease genes (or at least markers in disequilibrium with disease genes), careful definition/ascertainment of disease phenotypes to minimize genetic heterogeneity, and for case-control designs, strategies to account for population stratification or admixture. The identification of candidate genes will be aided by rapid progress in the Human Genome Project and other genome efforts that will eventually identify all human genetic variations. Although this will lead to better understanding of the genes that might be involved in complex diseases, much work is required to understand the basic biology of how disease genotypes become clinical phenotypes. This is especially daunting in complex diseases, such as SSc, where the phenotype (including disease susceptibility and clinical presentation) is influenced by dynamic interactions between genetic variations and environment. Multi-center collaborative efforts with research paradigms that integrate genetic and environmental factors (including sociodemographic variables) will be required to elucidate the contribution of environment and genetics in the pathogenesis of SSc.

Association of fibrillin 1 single-nucleotide polymorphism haplotypes with systemic sclerosis in Choctaw and Japanese populations

OBJECTIVE

Previously, we demonstrated with the use of microsatellite markers that a 2-cM haplotype on chromosome 15q containing the fibrillin 1 gene (FBN1) was strongly associated with systemic sclerosis (SSc) in the Choctaw, a population with high SSc prevalence. In this study, all 69 known FBN1 exons were sequenced to ascertain the presence of changes that might show associations with SSc in the Choctaw and Japanese SSc patients and controls.

METHODS

Screening of FBN1 exons was accomplished by polymerase chain reaction-based fluorescence sequencing of genomic DNA using single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) haplotypes, and their frequencies were determined with a new algorithm that recognizes past recombination events between sites. Haplotype phylogenies were inferred using the median-joining network analysis.

RESULTS

Five SNPs were identified in FBN1. They are located in the 5'-untranslated region (SNP-1), exon 15 (SNP-2), intron 17 (SNP-3), exon 27 (SNP-4), and intron 27 (SNP-5). Only SNP-1 (T-->C) demonstrated an association with SSc in the Choctaw. Eleven FBN1 SNP haplotypes were ascertained in the Choctaw population, 2 of which (SNPs 5 and 6) were found only in the SSc patients. These same FBN1 SNP haplotypes were associated with SSc in the Japanese.

CONCLUSION

A SNP in the 5'-untranslated region of FBN1 (SNP-1, C allele) was strongly associated with SSc in the Choctaw. Furthermore, this polymorphism is present on 2 unique FBN1 haplotypes found only in Choctaw SSc patients. The same 2 haplotypes demonstrate associations with SSc in the Japanese. These data extend the earlier microsatellite studies and are consistent with the hypothesis that FBN1 or a nearby gene on chromosome 15q is involved in SSc susceptibility in the Choctaw and the Japanese.

Genetic factors in the etiology of systemic sclerosis and Raynaud phenomenon

There is increasing evidence that genetic factors play important roles in susceptibility to and expression of systemic sclerosis (SSc), as well as primary Raynaud phenomenon. Familial aggregation for SSc, although infrequent (1.2%-1.5% of SSc families), has now been established, and when compared with population prevalence represents a significant risk factor for the disease and lays a firmer foundation for genetics in etiopathogenesis. Major histocompatibility complex class II alleles increase disease risk in some populations but are more strongly correlated with specific autoantibody profiles. Microchimerism influenced by human leukocyte antigen also remains an intriguing hypothesis. A variety of extracellular matrix genes, including fibrillin-1, have become additional candidates for contributing to what is likely a complex genetic disease. Reviewed here is evidence relating to these concepts, especially new data reported over the last year.

Autoantibodies to fibrillin 1 in systemic sclerosis: ethnic differences in antigen recognition and lack of correlation with specific clinical features or HLA alleles

OBJECTIVE

We previously reported the presence of autoantibodies to the extracellular matrix protein, fibrillin 1, in sera from patients with systemic sclerosis (SSc). These autoantibodies appeared to be highly disease-specific but had significantly different frequencies among ethnic groups. The aims of this study were 3-fold: 1) to determine whether sera from SSc patients of different ethnic backgrounds recognized different antigenic epitopes of fibrillin 1, 2) to determine whether sera from patients with polymyositis/dermatomyositis (PM/DM) with or without interstitial lung disease (ILD) also produced these antibodies, and 3) to determine any correlation of anti-fibrillin 1 antibodies with specific clinical features of SSc, other autoantibodies, or HLA class II alleles in a prospectively studied cohort of SSc patients with early (<5 years' duration) disease (the Genetics versus Environment In Scleroderma Outcome Study [GENISOS] cohort).

METHODS

Three recombinant peptides accounting for the N-terminal end, proline-rich C region, and epidermal growth factor-like calcium-binding (EGF-cb) domains of fibrillin 1 were used in a radioimmunoassay to screen sera from a large group of SSc and PM/DM patients and ethnically matched controls.

RESULTS

The majority of Choctaw American Indians, Japanese, and African Americans with SSc produced IgM and/or IgG autoantibodies to one or more recombinant fibrillin 1 proteins, while <50% of Caucasians with SSc showed seroreactivity. There were striking ethnic differences in fibrillin 1 antigenic epitope recognition among these ethnic groups. African American SSc sera recognized primarily the N-terminal end, and Caucasian sera mostly recognized the EGF-cb repeats and the proline-rich C region. In contrast, most Choctaw American Indian and Japanese SSc sera appeared to recognize 2 or 3 epitopes, respectively. PM/DM patient sera did not recognize any of the fibrillin 1 epitopes regardless of the presence of ILD. In the prospective, multiethnic GENISOS cohort, the presence of anti-fibrillin 1 antibodies did not correlate with any major clinical manifestations, other autoantibodies, or HLA class II alleles.

CONCLUSION

There are striking ethnic differences in antigenic epitope specificity of anti-fibrillin 1 antibodies in patients with SSc, and the majority of SSc patients, except for Caucasians, produce antibodies to fibrillin 1. The antifibrillin response thus far remains specific for scleroderma syndromes, but it does not correlate with any major clinical features, other autoantibodies, or HLA class II alleles.