Efficacy of Metformin for Benign Thyroid Nodules in Subjects With Insulin Resistance: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

View on Metformin: Antidiabetic and Pleiotropic Effects, Pharmacokinetics, Side Effects, and Sex-Related Differences

Metformin is a synthetic biguanide used as an antidiabetic drug in type 2 diabetes mellitus, achieved by studying the bioactive metabolites of Galega officinalis L. It is also used off-label for various other diseases, such as subclinical diabetes, obesity, polycystic ovary syndrome, etc. In addition, metformin is proposed as an add-on therapy for several conditions, including autoimmune diseases, neurodegenerative diseases, and cancer. Although metformin has been used for many decades, it is still the subject of many pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic studies in light of its extensive use. Metformin acts at the mitochondrial level by inhibiting the respiratory chain, thus increasing the AMP/ATP ratio and, subsequently, activating the AMP-activated protein kinase. However, several other mechanisms have been proposed, including binding to presenilin enhancer 2, increasing GLP1 release, and modification of microRNA expression. Regarding its pharmacokinetics, after oral administration, metformin is absorbed, distributed, and eliminated, mainly through the renal route, using transporters for cationic solutes, since it exists as an ionic molecule at physiological pH. In this review, particular consideration has been paid to literature data from the last 10 years, deepening the study of clinical trials inherent to new uses of metformin, the differences in effectiveness and safety observed between the sexes, and the unwanted side effects. For this last objective, metformin safety was also evaluated using both VigiBase and EudraVigilance, respectively, the WHO and European databases of the reported adverse drug reactions, to assess the extent of metformin side effects in real-life use.

Thyroid cancer and insulin resistance

Thyroid cancer has shown a parallel increase with diabetes in the last few years. This narrative review aims to explain the association between these two entities, focusing on insulin resistance as the mediator and exploring the effects of antidiabetic agents on thyroid cancer incidence and progression.We searched Pubmed for English-written articles on insulin resistance, diabetes, antidiabetic treatments, and thyroid cancer reported from January 2019 to April 2023. Exclusion criteria were preclinical and clinical studies involving a population with thyroid dysfunction, benign nodular goiter, or those that only analyzed thyroid cancer's association with obesity.The results of the narrative literature review revealed 96 articles. Additionally, four studies from a manual search were retrieved. After the exclusion criteria were applied, we included 20 studies. Out of 8 studies on insulin-resistant or Metabolic Syndrome patients, all suggest a positive association with thyroid cancer. At the same time, for diabetes, four out of five publications support a link with thyroid cancer. The seven remaining studies on antidiabetics suggest that metformin might benefit thyroid cancer. In contrast, the evidence for an association between Glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonists (GLP-1 RA) and increased thyroid cancer findings is limited.In conclusion, the association between thyroid cancer and diabetes may be explained by insulin resistance, as shown in observational studies. However, the causal role is yet to be defined. Although the wide use of different antidiabetic agents has been related to thyroid cancer prevalence and progression, future research with drugs such as metformin or GLP-1 RA is still needed.

Metformin in Differentiated Thyroid Cancer: Molecular Pathways and Its Clinical Implications

Metformin is a synthetic biguanide that improves insulin sensitivity and reduces hepatic gluconeogenesis. Aside being the first-line therapy for Type 2 Diabetes (T2D), many pleiotropic effects have been discovered in recent years, such as its capacity to reduce cancer risk and tumorigenesis. Although widely studied, the effect of metformin on thyroid cancer remains controversial. Potential mechanisms for its growth inhibitory effects have been elucidated in various preclinical studies that involved pathways related to adenosine mono-phosphate-activated protein kinase (AMPK), mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR), mitochondrial glycerophosphate dehydrogenase (mGPDH), and the nuclear factor κB (NF-κB). Hyperinsulinemia increases cell glucose uptake and oxidative stress, and promotes thyroid cell growth, leading to hyperproliferation, carcinogenesis, and the development of malignant tumors. Furthermore, it has also been related to thyroid nodules size in nodular disease, as well as tumoral size in patients with thyroid cancer. Several clinical studies concluded that metformin might have an important role as an adjuvant therapy to reduce the growth of benign and malignant thyroid neoplasms. This suggests that metformin might be useful for patients with differentiated or poorly differentiated thyroid cancer and metabolic diseases such as insulin resistance or diabetes.

A breakthrough-like effect of metformin reduces peripheral resistance to triiodothyronine in euthyroid, non-insulin-resistant, type 2 diabetic patients

BACKGROUND

Type 2 diabetes is characterized, beyond the insulin resistance, by polyhormonal resistance. Thyroid hormonal resistance has not yet been described in this population of patients. Metformin is used to decrease insulin resistance, and at present, it is assumed to influence the effect of triiodothyronine, as well.

METHODS

In this open-label, pilot, hypothesis-generating, follow-up study, 21 patients were included; all of them were euthyroid with drug naïve, newly diagnosed type 2 diabetes. Before and after 4 weeks of metformin therapy, fructosamine, homeostasis model assessment for insulin resistance (HOMA-IR), thyroid hormones, T3/T4 ratio, and TSH, as well as blood pressure and heart rate using ambulatory blood pressure monitor were measured. We also conducted an in vitro study to investigate the possible mechanisms of T3 resistance, assessing T3-induced Akt phosphorylation among normal (5 mM) and high (25 mM) glucose levels with or without metformin treatment in a human embryonal kidney cell line.

RESULTS

Metformin decreased the level of T3 (P < 0.001), the ratio of T3/T4 (P = 0.038), fructosamine (P = 0.008) and HOMA-IR (P = 0.022). All these changes were accompanied by an unchanged TSH, T4, triglyceride, plasma glucose, bodyweight, blood pressure, and heart rate. In our in vitro study, T3-induced Akt phosphorylation decreased in cells grown in 25 mM glucose medium compared to those in 5 mM. Metformin could not reverse this effect.

CONCLUSION

Metformin seems to improve T3 sensitivity in the cardiovascular system in euthyroid, type 2 diabetic patients, the mechanism of which may be supracellular.

Can "VAI" Better Indicate Metabolic Syndrome Compared with Other Metabolic Syndrome-Related Parameters in Patients with Thyroid Nodules? A Study from Turkey

Background: To investigate the relationship between visceral adiposity index (VAI) and other metabolic syndrome (MetS)-related parameters, and thyroid nodules. Methods: This single-center, prospective, case-control study included 67 patients with thyroid nodules and 48 healthy volunteers with similar age, sex, and body mass index (BMI). Biochemical parameters were obtained from medical charts. Anthropometric measurements and total body composition analysis were performed to calculate VAI and other MetS parameters. The parenchymal structure was evaluated according to VESINC (Volume, Echogenicity, Sonographic texture, Infiltration of pseudonodular Nodules, Cysts) system on thyroid ultrasound and nodule characteristics were also detected. MetS was defined according to International Diabetes Federation criteria. Results: We examined a total of 67 patients with thyroid nodule and 48 healthy volunteers. Sixty-one (91%) were female in the patient group; and 43 (90%) were female in the control group. The mean age was 48.5 ± 11.6 years in the patient group; 47.2 ± 9.5 years in the control. The median VAI was significantly higher in the patient group than the control group [4.1 interquartile range (IQR: 2.6-5.9) vs. 3 (IQR: 2-4.3), P = 0.024]. There was a positive correlation between VAI and BMI, waist/hip ratio (WHpR), waist/height ratio (WHtR), and homeostasis of model assessment of insulin resistance (HOMA-IR). On the other hand, there was no significant correlation between VAI and thyroid function tests and autoantibodies and thyroid volume. Conclusions: In conclusion, we demonstrated that MetS was more common in patients with thyroid nodules. Although VAI and HOMA-IR levels were significantly different between the two groups, we found no significant difference in terms of waist circumference, WHpR, and WHtR. This might suggest that VAI compared with these parameters, better predicts the risk of MetS in patients with thyroid nodules.

Metformin reduces autoimmune antibody levels in patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

In the past few years, an increasing number of studies have proposed the idea of extending the therapeutic range of metformin from traditional hypoglycaemic to autoimmune diseases, and confirmed in a variety of autoimmune diseases. However, whether metformin can be used to treat Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), which is characterised by thyroid peroxidase antibody (TPOAb) and thyroglobulin antibody (TgAb), is unknown. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to evaluate whether metformin can reduce the levels of TPOAb and TgAb in patients with HT or subclinical hypothyroidism (SH), so as to provide a theoretical basis for metformin treatment of these diseases.

METHODS

PubMed, Web Of Science and Embase were searched for observational studies investigating the changes of TPOAb and TgAb in patients with HT after metformin treatment. Two authors extracted data from eligible studies and classified them as HT and subclinical hypothyroidism subgroups. The calculation was then performed by weighted mean difference (WMD) combined with a fixed-effects model analysis or standard mean difference (SMD) with a random-effects model analysis, based on the measurement of the outcome.

RESULTS

Metformin significantly reduced TPOAb levels and TgAb levels in patients with HT and SH, especially TPOAb (HT: p _TPOAb = .009, p _TgAb = .046; SH: p _TPOAb = .034, p _TgAb = .066). In addition, metformin also reduced the levels of thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH), homeostasis model assessment of insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) in patients with HT and SH (HT: p _TSH = .000 and p _HOMA-IR = .000; SH: p _TSH = .000 and p _HOMA-IR = .000, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Metformin significantly reduces TPOAb level and TgAb level in patients with HT and SH, especially TPOAb. This study is the first to provide a preliminary theoretical basis for the clinical application of metformin in the treatment of HT.

The role of an anti-diabetic drug metformin in the treatment of endocrine tumors

Incidence of endocrine cancers is rising every year. Over the last decade, evidence has accumulated that demonstrates the anti-cancer effects of an anti-diabetic drug, metformin, in endocrine malignancies. We performed a literature review utilizing the PubMed, Medline and clinicaltrials.gov databases using the keyword 'metformin' plus the following terms: 'thyroid cancer', 'thyroid nodules', 'parathyroid', 'hyperparathyroidism', 'adrenal adenoma', 'Cushing syndrome', 'hyperaldosteronism', 'adrenocortical cancer', 'neuroendocrine tumor (NET)', 'pancreatic NET (pNET)', 'carcinoid', 'pituitary adenoma', 'pituitary neuroendocrine tumor (PitNET)', 'prolactinoma', 'pheochromocytoma/paraganglioma'. We found 37 studies describing the preclinical and clinical role of metformin in endocrine tumors. The available epidemiological data show an association between exposure of metformin and lower incidence of thyroid cancer and pNETs in diabetic patients. Metformin treatment has been associated with better response to cancer therapy in thyroid cancer and pNETs. Preclinical evidence suggests that the primary direct mechanisms of metformin action include inhibition of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation via inhibition of both mitochondrial complex I and mitochondrial glycerophosphate dehydrogenase, leading to metabolic stress. Decreased ATP production leads to an activation of a cellular energy sensor, AMPK, and subsequent downregulation of mTOR signaling pathway, which is associated with decreased cellular proliferation. We also describe several AMPK-independent mechanisms of metformin action, as well as the indirect mechanisms targeting insulin resistance. Overall, repositioning of metformin has emerged as a promising strategy for adjuvant therapy of endocrine tumors. The mechanisms of synergy between metformin and other anti-cancer agents need to be elucidated further to guide well-designed prospective trials on combination therapies in endocrine malignancies.

Metformin reduces risk of benign nodular goiter in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus

Background Whether metformin might affect the risk of benign nodular goiter in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus has not been investigated. Methods Patients with new-onset type 2 diabetes mellitus during 1999-2005 were enrolled from Taiwan's National Health Insurance database. Analyses were conducted in a propensity score matched-pairs of 20,048 ever users and 20,048 never users of metformin. The patients were followed until December 31, 2011, for the incidence of benign nodular goiter. Hazard ratios were estimated by Cox regression incorporated with the inverse probability of treatment weighting using the propensity score. Results Among the never users and ever users of metformin, 392 and 221 cases were diagnosed of benign nodular goiter during follow-up, with incidence of 457.88 and 242.45 per 100,000 person-years, respectively. The overall hazard ratio for ever versus never users was 0.527 (95% confidence interval: 0.447-0.621). When cumulative duration of metformin therapy was divided into tertiles, the hazard ratios for the first (<25.3 months), second (25.3-57.3 months) and third (>57.3 months) tertiles were 0.815 (0.643-1.034), 0.648 (0.517-0.812) and 0.255 (0.187-0.348), respectively. Sensitivity analyses estimating the overall hazard ratios for patients enrolled in each specific year from 1999 to 2005 consistently showed a lower risk of benign nodular goiter among users of metformin. Conclusion Metformin use is associated with a lower risk of benign nodular goiter in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus.

Effects of Metformin on TSH Levels and Benign Nodular Goiter Volume in Patients Without Insulin Resistance or Iodine Insufficiency

Objectives: To evaluate the impact of metformin (MTF) use on TSH levels, thyroid volume and volume of benign thyroid nodules (TNs). Additionally, to study if iodine status influences the outcomes. Methods: A total of 23 euthyroid patients (42 TNs) with benign thyroid nodules, diagnosed by fine needle aspiration biopsy, were randomly assigned to MTF or placebo (P) use for 6 months. Serum TSH, homeostatic model assessment for insulin resistance (HOMA-IR), and urinary iodine concentrations (UIC) were assessed. Ultrasound was used to evaluate TNs and thyroid volumes (TV) and their variations throughout the study. Diabetic patients, those undergoing levothyroxine replacement, and/or using thyroid- or insulin level-influencing drugs were excluded. Results: The sample consisted predominantly of patients without IR. Both intervention groups were similar regarding several confounding variables and showed a comparable median UIC. Serum TSH decreased significantly after MTF (-0.21 vs. 0.09 mUI/L in the P group; p = 0.015). At 6 months, no significant variations were found between groups with respect to TN volumes, TV, HOMA-IR, or body mass index (BMI). However, a tendency toward enlargement of TV with placebo (16.0%; p = 0.09) and a protective effect of MTF on growing TN (OR: 0.25; CI 0.05-1.20) was detected after excluding patients with IR (a lower UIC subgroup). The reduction on TSH levels with MTF maintained in the population without iodine insufficiency (-0.24 vs. +0.07 in the P group; p = 0.046) and was accentuated in those with excessive or more than adequate UIC (-0.69; p = 0.043). A protective effect of MTF on growing TN was suggested (OR: 0.11; IC: 0.02-0.84) in those with higher UIC. Conclusions: This study demonstrated that MTF caused a reduction in TSH levels in benign nodular goiter. This effect was more accentuated in patients with higher levels of UIC and was accompanied by a suggested protective effect on TN enlargement.