Cornelia de Lange Syndrome as Paradigm of Chromatinopathies

ANKRD11 binding to cohesin suggests a connection between KBG syndrome and Cornelia de Lange syndrome

Ankyrin Repeat Domain-containing Protein 11 (ANKRD11) is a causative gene for KBG syndrome, a significant risk factor for Cornelia de Lange syndrome (CdLS), and a highly confident autism spectrum disorder gene. Mutations of ANKRD11 lead to developmental abnormalities in multiple organs/tissues including the brain, craniofacial and skeletal bones, and tooth structures with unknown mechanism(s). Here, we find that ANKRD11, via a short peptide fragment in its N-terminal region, binds to the cohesin complex with a high affinity, implicating why ANKRD11 mutation can cause CdLS. The crystal structure of the ANKRD11 peptide in complex with cohesin, together with biochemical experiments, revealed that ANKRD11 competes with CCCTC-binding factor in binding to the cohesin complex. Importantly, a single point mutation in ANKRD11 (Tyr347 to Ala) specifically disrupted the interaction between ANKRD11 and cohesin and perturbed gene expressions in a mouse embryonic stem cell model. Mice carrying the ANKRD11 Y347A mutation display neural and craniofacial anomalies, which mirror clinical phenotypes observed in KBG syndrome patients. Thus, our study reveals how ANKRD11 functions together with cohesin to regulate gene expression and also provides insights into the molecular mechanisms underpinning developmental disorders caused by ANKRD11 mutations.

An intragenic duplication in the AFF2 gene associated with Cornelia de Lange syndrome phenotype

Cornelia de Lange syndrome (CdLS, OMIM #122470, #300590, #300882, #610759, and #614701) is a rare congenital disorder that affects the development of multiple organs and is characterized by physical abnormalities and cognitive and behavioral disabilities. Its molecular basis is mainly based on alterations in genes encoding structural and regulatory proteins related to the cohesin complex. Moreover, other transcriptional regulatory factors have been linked to this syndrome. However, additional causative genes are still unknown, since many patients still lack a molecular diagnosis. Herein, we describe a case with multiple affected family members presenting with an intragenic duplication in the AFF2 gene. The direct tandem intragenic duplication of exons 10, 11 and 12 was detected through high-resolution array Comparative Genomic Hybridization and next-generation sequencing technologies. Confirming the X-linked inheritance pattern, the duplication was found in the patient, his mother and his maternal aunt affected (dizygotic twins). Targeted sequencing with Oxford Nanopore Technologies revealed an aberrant transcript which is predominantly expressed in the patient and his aunt. Along with these results, a significant reduction in AFF2 gene expression levels was detected in these two individuals. Clinically both subjects exhibit a classic CdLS phenotype, whereas the mother is mostly unaffected. Consistent with the phenotypical differences observed between the mother and the aunt, there is a marked difference in X-inactivation patterns skewing. Given the crucial role of AFF2 in transcriptional regulation, it is not surprising that AFF2 variants can give rise to CdLS phenotypes. Therefore, the AFF2 gene should be considered for the molecular diagnosis of this syndrome.

The NIPBL-gene mutation of a Cornelia de Lange Syndrome patient causes deficits in the hepatocyte differentiation of induced Pluripotent Stem Cells via altered chromatin-accessibility

The Cornelia de Lange syndrome (CdLS) is a rare genetic disease, which is characterized by a cohesinopathy. Mutations of the NIPBL gene are observed in 65% of CdLS patients. A novel iPSC (induced Pluripotent Stem Cell) line was reprogrammed from the leukocytes of a CdLS patient carrying a missense mutation of the NIPBL gene. A mutation-corrected isogenic iPSC-line and two iPSC-lines generated from the healthy parents were used as controls. The iPSC lines were differentiated along the hepatocyte-lineage. Comparative immunofluorescence, RNA-seq and ATAC-seq analyses were performed on undifferentiated and differentiated iPSCs. In addition, chromatin organization was studied by ChIP-Seq analysis on the patient derived iPSCs as well as the respective controls. Relative to the mutation-corrected and the healthy-parents iPSCs, the patient-derived counterparts are defective in terms of differentiation along the hepatocyte-lineage. One-third of the genes selectively up-regulated in CdLS-derived iPSCs and hepatic cells are non-protein-coding genes. By converse, most of the selectively down-regulated genes code for transcription factors and proteins regulating neural differentiation. Some of the transcriptionally silenced loci, such as the DPP6 gene on chromosome 7q36.2 and the ZNF gene cluster on chromosome 19p12, are located in closed-chromatin regions. Relative to the corresponding controls, the global transcriptomic differences observed in CdLS undifferentiated iPSCs are associated with altered chromatin accessibility, which was confirmed by ChIP-Seq analysis. Thus, the deficits in the differentiation along the hepatocyte lineage observed in our CdLS patient is likely to be due to a transcriptional dysregulation resulting from a cohesin-dependent alteration of chromatin accessibility.

Chromatinopathies: insight in clinical aspects and underlying epigenetic changes

Chromatinopathies (CPs), a group of rare inborn defects characterized by chromatin state imbalance, have evolved from initially resembling Cornelia de Lange syndrome to encompass a wide array of genetic diseases with diverse clinical presentations. The CPs classification now includes human developmental disorders caused by germline mutations in epigenes, genes that regulate the epigenome. Recent advances in next-generation sequencing have enabled the association of 154 epigenes with CPs, revealing distinctive DNA methylation patterns known as episignatures.It has been shown that episignatures are unique for a particular CP or share similarities among specific CP subgroup. Consequently, these episignatures have emerged as promising biomarkers for diagnosing and treating CPs, differentiating subtypes, evaluating variants of unknown significance, and facilitating targeted therapies tailored to the underlying epigenetic dysregulation.The following review was conducted to collect, summarize, and analyze data regarding CPs in such aspects as clinical evaluation encompassing long-term patient care, underlying epigenetic changes, and innovative molecular and bioinformatic methodologies that have been devised for the assessment of CPs. We have also shed light on promising novel treatment options that have surfaced in recent research and presented a synthesis of ongoing clinical trials, contributing to the current understanding of the dynamic and evolving nature of CPs investigation.

Cornelia de Lange Syndrome Caused by an Intragenic Heterozygous Deletion in RAD21 Detected through Very-High-Resolution Chromosomal Microarray Analysis

Cornelia de Lange syndrome is a genetic and clinically heterogeneous entity, caused by at least five genes. It is characterized by short stature, gestalt facies, microcephaly, neurodevelopmental disorders, and other anomalies. In this report, we present a 13-year-old female patient with microcephaly, cleft palate, polydactyly, short stature, triangular facies, frontal bossing, a bulbous nose, an overfolded helix, limited pronosupination, and an anomalous uterus. No neurodevelopmental disorders were reported. A chromosomal microarray analysis of 6.5 million markers was performed in the proband and her parents. The results showed a de novo heterozygous microdeletion of exons 9-14 within RAD21, which confirmed the diagnosis of Cornelia de Lange syndrome type 4. Our patient did not show any neurologic phenotype (until the time of diagnosis), although neurodevelopmental disorders are frequently present in patients with Cornelia de Lange syndrome type 4, and despite carrying a deletion that was larger than previously reported. Therefore, unknown genetic modifiers or intrinsic mechanisms of RAD21 variants may exist and should be studied.

Cornelia de Lange Syndrome mutations in SMC1A cause cohesion defects in yeast

Cornelia de Lange Syndrome (CdLS) is a developmental disorder characterized by limb truncations, craniofacial abnormalities, and cognitive delays. CdLS is caused mainly by mutations in genes encoding subunits or regulators of the cohesin complex. Cohesin plays 2 distinct roles in chromosome dynamics as follows: it promotes looping, organization, and compaction of individual chromosomes, and it holds newly replicated sister chromatids together until cell division. CdLS-associated mutations result in altered gene expression likely by affecting chromosome architecture. Whether CdLS mutations cause phenotypes through impact on sister chromatid cohesion is less clear. Here, we show that CdLS-associated mutations introduced into the SMC1A gene of budding yeast had measurable impacts on sister chromatid cohesion, mitotic progression, and DNA damage sensitivity. These data suggest that sister chromatid cohesion-related defects may contribute to phenotypes seen in CdLS affected individuals.

NIPBL and cohesin: new take on a classic tale

Cohesin folds the genome in dynamic chromatin loops and holds the sister chromatids together. NIPBLScc2 is currently considered the cohesin loader, a role that may need reevaluation. NIPBL activates the cohesin ATPase, which is required for topological entrapment of sister DNAs and to fuel DNA loop extrusion, but is not required for chromatin association. Mechanistic dissection of these processes suggests that both NIPBL and the cohesin STAG subunit bind DNA. NIPBL also regulates conformational switches of the complex. Interactions of NIPBL with chromatin factors, including remodelers, replication proteins, and the transcriptional machinery, affect cohesin loading and distribution. Here, we discuss recent research addressing how NIPBL modulates cohesin activities and how its mutation causes a developmental disorder, Cornelia de Lange Syndrome (CdLS).

Optical Genome Mapping Identifies Novel Recurrent Structural Alterations in Childhood ETV6::RUNX1+ and High Hyperdiploid Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia

The mutational landscape of B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukemia (BCP-ALL), the most common pediatric cancer, is not fully described partially because commonly applied short-read next generation sequencing has a limited ability to identify structural variations. By combining comprehensive analysis of structural variants (SVs), single-nucleotide variants (SNVs), and small insertions-deletions, new subtype-defining and therapeutic targets may be detected. We analyzed the landscape of somatic alterations in 60 pediatric patients diagnosed with the most common BCP-ALL subtypes, ETV6::RUNX1+ and classical hyperdiploid (HD), using conventional cytogenetics, single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) array, whole exome sequencing (WES), and the novel optical genome mapping (OGM) technique. Ninety-five percent of SVs detected by cytogenetics and SNP-array were verified by OGM. OGM detected an additional 677 SVs not identified using the conventional methods, including (subclonal) IKZF1 deletions. Based on OGM, ETV6::RUNX1+ BCP-ALL harbored 2.7 times more SVs than HD BCP-ALL, mainly focal deletions. Besides SVs in known leukemia development genes (ETV6, PAX5, BTG1, CDKN2A), we identified 19 novel recurrently altered regions (in n ≥ 3) including 9p21.3 (FOCAD/HACD4), 8p11.21 (IKBKB), 1p34.3 (ZMYM1), 4q24 (MANBA), 8p23.1 (MSRA), and 10p14 (SFMBT2), as well as ETV6::RUNX1+ subtype-specific SVs (12p13.1 (GPRC5A), 12q24.21 (MED13L), 18q11.2 (MIB1), 20q11.22 (NCOA6)). We detected 3 novel fusion genes (SFMBT2::DGKD, PDS5B::STAG2, and TDRD5::LPCAT2), for which the sequence and expression were validated by long-read and whole transcriptome sequencing, respectively. OGM and WES identified double hits of SVs and SNVs (ETV6, BTG1, STAG2, MANBA, TBL1XR1, NSD2) in the same patient demonstrating the power of the combined approach to define the landscape of genomic alterations in BCP-ALL.

De novo variants in GATAD2A in individuals with a neurodevelopmental disorder: GATAD2A-related neurodevelopmental disorder

GATA zinc finger domain containing 2A (GATAD2A) is a subunit of the nucleosome remodeling and deacetylase (NuRD) complex. NuRD is known to regulate gene expression during neural development and other processes. The NuRD complex modulates chromatin status through histone deacetylation and ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling activities. Several neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs) have been previously linked to variants in other components of NuRD's chromatin remodeling subcomplex (NuRDopathies). We identified five individuals with features of an NDD that possessed de novo autosomal dominant variants in GATAD2A. Core features in affected individuals include global developmental delay, structural brain defects, and craniofacial dysmorphology. These GATAD2A variants are predicted to affect protein dosage and/or interactions with other NuRD chromatin remodeling subunits. We provide evidence that a GATAD2A missense variant disrupts interactions of GATAD2A with CHD3, CHD4, and CHD5. Our findings expand the list of NuRDopathies and provide evidence that GATAD2A variants are the genetic basis of a previously uncharacterized developmental disorder.

Success and Pitfalls of Genetic Testing in Undiagnosed Diseases: Whole Exome Sequencing and Beyond

Novel approaches to uncover the molecular etiology of neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD) are highly needed. Even using a powerful tool such as whole exome sequencing (WES), the diagnostic process may still prove long and arduous due to the high clinical and genetic heterogeneity of these conditions. The main strategies to improve the diagnostic rate are based on family segregation, re-evaluation of the clinical features by reverse-phenotyping, re-analysis of unsolved NGS-based cases and epigenetic functional studies. In this article, we described three selected cases from a cohort of patients with NDD in which trio WES was applied, in order to underline the typical challenges encountered during the diagnostic process: (1) an ultra-rare condition caused by a missense variant in MEIS2, identified through the updated Solve-RD re-analysis; (2) a patient with Noonan-like features in which the NGS analysis revealed a novel variant in NIPBL causing Cornelia de Lange syndrome; and (3) a case with de novo variants in genes involved in the chromatin-remodeling complex, for which the study of the epigenetic signature excluded a pathogenic role. In this perspective, we aimed to (i) provide an example of the relevance of the genetic re-analysis of all unsolved cases through network projects on rare diseases; (ii) point out the role and the uncertainties of the reverse phenotyping in the interpretation of the genetic results; and (iii) describe the use of methylation signatures in neurodevelopmental syndromes for the validation of the variants of uncertain significance.

Full circle: a brief history of cohesin and the regulation of gene expression

The cohesin complex has a range of crucial functions in the cell. Cohesin is essential for mediating chromatid cohesion during mitosis, for repair of double-strand DNA breaks, and for control of gene transcription. This last function has been the subject of intense research ever since the discovery of cohesin's role in the long-range regulation of the cut gene in Drosophila. Subsequent research showed that the expression of some genes is exquisitely sensitive to cohesin depletion, while others remain relatively unperturbed. Sensitivity to cohesin depletion is also remarkably cell type- and/or condition-specific. The relatively recent discovery that cohesin is integral to forming chromatin loops via loop extrusion should explain much of cohesin's gene regulatory properties, but surprisingly, loop extrusion has failed to identify a 'one size fits all' mechanism for how cohesin controls gene expression. This review will illustrate how early examples of cohesin-dependent gene expression integrate with later work on cohesin's role in genome organization to explain mechanisms by which cohesin regulates gene expression.

Chung-Jansen syndrome can mimic Cornelia de Lange syndrome: Another player among chromatinopathies?

Cornelia de Lange syndrome (CdLS) is a rare multisystem congenital neurodevelopmental disorder (NDD) characterized by distinctive facial anomalies, short stature, developmental delay, hirsutism, gastrointestinal abnormalities and upper limb reduction defects. CdLS syndrome is associated with causative variants in genes encoding for the cohesin complex, a cellular machinery involved in chromatid pairing, DNA repair and gene-expression regulation. In this report, we describe a familial case of a syndromic presentation in a 4-year-old patient (P1) and in his mother (P2). Trio-based Whole Exome Sequencing (WES) performed on P1 was first negative. Since his phenotypic evolution during the follow-up was reminiscent of the CdLS spectrum, a reanalysis of WES data, focused on CdLS-related genes, was requested. Although no alterations in those genes was detected, we identified the likely pathogenetic variant c.40G > A (p.Glu14Lys) in the PHIP gene, in the meanwhile associated with Chung-Jansen syndrome. Reverse phenotyping carried out in both patients confirmed the molecular diagnosis. CHUJANS belongs to NDDs, featuring developmental delay, mild-to-moderate intellectual disability, behavioral problems, obesity and facial dysmorphisms. Moreover, as here described, CHUJANS shows a significant overlap with the CdLS spectrum, with specific regard to facial gestalt. On the basis of our findings, we suggest to include PHIP among genes routinely analyzed in patients belonging to the CdLS spectrum.

Somatic mosaicism in STAG2-associated cohesinopathies: Expansion of the genotypic and phenotypic spectrum

STAG2 is a component of the large, evolutionarily highly conserved cohesin complex, which has been linked to various cellular processes like genome organization, DNA replication, gene expression, heterochromatin formation, sister chromatid cohesion, and DNA repair. A wide spectrum of germline variants in genes encoding subunits or regulators of the cohesin complex have previously been identified to cause distinct but phenotypically overlapping multisystem developmental disorders belonging to the group of cohesinopathies. Pathogenic variants in STAG2 have rarely been implicated in an X-linked cohesinopathy associated with undergrowth, developmental delay, and dysmorphic features. Here, we describe for the first time a mosaic STAG2 variant in an individual with developmental delay, microcephaly, and hemihypotrophy of the right side. We characterized the grade of mosaicism by deep sequencing analysis on DNA extracted from EDTA blood, urine and buccal swabs. Furthermore, we report an additional female with a novel de novo splice variant in STAG2. Interestingly, both individuals show supernumerary nipples, a feature that has not been reported associated to STAG2 before. Remarkably, additional analysis of STAG2 transcripts in both individuals showed only wildtype transcripts, even after blockage of nonsense-mediated decay using puromycin in blood lymphocytes. As the phenotype of STAG2-associated cohesinopathies is dominated by global developmental delay, severe microcephaly, and brain abnormalities, we investigated the expression of STAG2 and other related components of the cohesin complex during Bioengineered Neuronal Organoids (BENOs) generation by RNA sequencing. Interestingly, we observed a prominent expression of STAG2, especially between culture days 0 and 15, indicating an essential function of STAG2 in early brain development. In summary, we expand the genotypic and phenotypic spectrum of STAG2-associated cohesinopathies and show that BENOs represent a promising model to gain further insights into the critical role of STAG2 in the complex process of nervous system development.

Bi-allelic loss-of-function variants in TMEM147 cause moderate to profound intellectual disability with facial dysmorphism and pseudo-Pelger-Huët anomaly

The transmembrane protein TMEM147 has a dual function: first at the nuclear envelope, where it anchors lamin B receptor (LBR) to the inner membrane, and second at the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), where it facilitates the translation of nascent polypeptides within the ribosome-bound TMCO1 translocon complex. Through international data sharing, we identified 23 individuals from 15 unrelated families with bi-allelic TMEM147 loss-of-function variants, including splice-site, nonsense, frameshift, and missense variants. These affected children displayed congruent clinical features including coarse facies, developmental delay, intellectual disability, and behavioral problems. In silico structural analyses predicted disruptive consequences of the identified amino acid substitutions on translocon complex assembly and/or function, and in vitro analyses documented accelerated protein degradation via the autophagy-lysosomal-mediated pathway. Furthermore, TMEM147-deficient cells showed CKAP4 (CLIMP-63) and RTN4 (NOGO) upregulation with a concomitant reorientation of the ER, which was also witnessed in primary fibroblast cell culture. LBR mislocalization and nuclear segmentation was observed in primary fibroblast cells. Abnormal nuclear segmentation and chromatin compaction were also observed in approximately 20% of neutrophils, indicating the presence of a pseudo-Pelger-Huët anomaly. Finally, co-expression analysis revealed significant correlation with neurodevelopmental genes in the brain, further supporting a role of TMEM147 in neurodevelopment. Our findings provide clinical, genetic, and functional evidence that bi-allelic loss-of-function variants in TMEM147 cause syndromic intellectual disability due to ER-translocon and nuclear organization dysfunction.

Cornelia de Lange syndrome mutations in NIPBL can impair cohesin-mediated DNA loop extrusion

Cornelia de Lange syndrome (CdLS) is a developmental multisystem disorder frequently associated with mutations in NIPBL. CdLS is thought to arise from developmental gene regulation defects, but how NIPBL mutations cause these is unknown. Here we show that several NIPBL mutations impair the DNA loop extrusion activity of cohesin. Because this activity is required for the formation of chromatin loops and topologically associating domains, which have important roles in gene regulation, our results suggest that defects in cohesin-mediated loop extrusion contribute to the etiology of CdLS by altering interactions between developmental genes and their enhancers.