Recent Progress and Novel Applications in Enzymatic Conversion of Carbon Dioxide

Lactic Acid from CO2: A Carbon Capture and Utilization Strategy Based on a Biocatalytic Approach

The EU low-carbon economy aims to reduce the level of CO2 emission in the EU to 80% by 2050. High efforts are required to achieve this goal, where successful CCU (Carbon Capture and Utilization) technologies will have a high impact. Biocatalysts offer a greener alternative to chemical catalysts for the development of CCU strategies since biocatalysis conforms 10 of the 12 principles of green chemistry. In this study, a multienzymatic system, based on alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH), pyruvate decarboxylase (PDC), and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), that converts CO2 and ethanol into lactic acid leading to a 100% atom economy was studied. The system allows cofactor regeneration, thus reducing the process cost. Through reaction media engineering and enzyme ratio study, the performance of the system was able to produce up to 250 μM of lactic acid under the best conditions using 100% CO2, corresponding to the highest concentration of lactic acid obtained up to date using this multienzymatic approach. For the first time, the feasibility of the system to be applied under a real industrial environment has been tested using synthetic gas mimicking real blast furnace off-gases composition from the iron and steel industry. Under these conditions, the system was also capable of producing lactic acid, reaching 62 μM.

Biochemical characterization of a psychrophilic and halotolerant α-carbonic anhydrase from a deep-sea bacterium, Photobacterium profundum

Prokaryotic α-carbonic anhydrases (α-CA) are metalloenzymes that catalyze the reversible hydration of CO2 to bicarbonate and proton. We had reported the first crystal structure of a pyschrohalophilic α-CA from a deep-sea bacterium, Photobacterium profundum SS9. In this manuscript, we report the first biochemical characterization of P. profundum α-CA (PprCA) which revealed several catalytic properties that are atypical for this class of CA's. Purified PprCA exhibited maximal catalytic activity at psychrophilic temperatures with substantial decrease in activity at mesophilic and thermophilic range. Similar to other α-CA's, Ppr9A showed peak activity at alkaline pH (pH 11), although, PprCA retained 88% of its activity even at acidic pH (pH 5). Exposing PprCA to varying concentrations of oxidizing and reducing agents revealed that N-terminal cysteine residues in PprCA may play a role in the structural stability of the enzyme. Although inefficient in CO2 hydration activity under mesophilic and thermophilic temperatures, PprCA exhibited salt-dependent thermotolerance and catalytic activity under extreme halophilic conditions. Similar to other well-characterized α-CA's, PprCA is also inhibited by monovalent anions even at low concentrations. Finally, we demonstrate that PprCA accelerates CO2 biomineralization to calcium carbonate under alkaline conditions.

A Review on the Design and Performance of Enzyme-Aided Catalysis of Carbon Dioxide in Membrane, Electrochemical Cell and Photocatalytic Reactors

Multi-enzyme cascade catalysis involved three types of dehydrogenase enzymes, namely, formate dehydrogenase (FDH), formaldehyde dehydrogenase (FaldDH), alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH), and an equimolar electron donor, nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH), assisting the reaction is an interesting pathway to reduce thermodynamically stable molecules of CO₂ from the atmosphere. The biocatalytic sequence is interesting because it operates under mild reaction conditions (low temperature and pressure) and all the enzymes are highly selective, which allows the reaction to produce three basic chemicals (formic acid, formaldehyde, and methanol) in just one pot. There are various challenges, however, in applying the enzymatic conversion of CO₂, namely, to obtain high productivity, increase reusability of the enzymes and cofactors, and to design a simple, facile, and efficient reactor setup that will sustain the multi-enzymatic cascade catalysis. This review reports on enzyme-aided reactor systems that support the reduction of CO₂ to methanol. Such systems include enzyme membrane reactors, electrochemical cells, and photocatalytic reactor systems. Existing reactor setups are described, product yields and biocatalytic productivities are evaluated, and effective enzyme immobilization methods are discussed.

The challenges of using NAD+-dependent formate dehydrogenases for CO2 conversion

In recent years, CO₂ reduction and utilization have been proposed as an innovative solution for global warming and the ever-growing energy and raw material demands. In contrast to various classical methods, including chemical, electrochemical, and photochemical methods, enzymatic methods offer a green and sustainable option for CO₂ conversion. In addition, enzymatic hydrogenation of CO₂ into platform chemicals could be used to produce economically useful hydrogen storage materials, making it a win-win strategy. The thermodynamic and kinetic stability of the CO₂ molecule makes its utilization a challenging task. However, Nicotine adenine dinucleotide (NAD⁺)-dependent formate dehydrogenases (FDHs), which have high selectivity and specificity, are attractive catalysts to overcome this issue and convert CO₂ into fuels and renewable chemicals. It is necessary to improve the stability, cofactor necessity, and CO₂ conversion efficiency of these enzymes, such as by combining them with appropriate hybrid systems. However, metal-independent, NAD⁺-dependent FDHs, and their CO₂ reduction activity have received limited attention to date. This review outlines the CO₂ reduction ability of these enzymes as well as their properties, reaction mechanisms, immobilization strategies, and integration with electrochemical and photochemical systems for the production of formic acid or formate. The biotechnological applications of FDH, future perspectives, barriers to CO₂ reduction with FDH, and aspects that must be further developed are briefly summarized. We propose that constructing hybrid systems that include NAD⁺-dependent FDHs is a promising approach to convert CO₂ and strengthen the sustainable carbon bio-economy.

Bioelectrocatalytic Cofactor Regeneration Coupled to CO2 Fixation in a Redox-Active Hydrogel for Stereoselective C-C Bond Formation

The sustainable capture and conversion of carbon dioxide (CO2 ) is key to achieving a circular carbon economy. Bioelectrocatalysis, which aims at using renewable energies to power the highly specific, direct transformation of CO2 into value added products, holds promise to achieve this goal. However, the functional integration of CO2 -fixing enzymes onto electrode materials for the electrosynthesis of stereochemically complex molecules remains to be demonstrated. Here, we show the electricity-driven regio- and stereoselective incorporation of CO2 into crotonyl-CoA by an NADPH-dependent enzymatic reductive carboxylation. Co-immobilization of a ferredoxin NADP+ reductase and crotonyl-CoA carboxylase/reductase within a 2,2'-viologen-modified hydrogel enabled iterative NADPH recycling and stereoselective formation of (2S)-ethylmalonyl-CoA, a prospective intermediate towards multi-carbon products from CO2 , with 92±6 % faradaic efficiency and at a rate of 1.6±0.4 μmol cm-2  h-1 . This approach paves the way for realizing even more complex bioelectrocatalyic cascades in the future.

Mechanisms of metal-dependent non-redox decarboxylases from quantum chemical calculations

Quantum chemical calculations are today an extremely valuable tool for studying enzymatic reaction mechanisms. In this mini-review, we summarize our recent work on several metal-dependent decarboxylases, where we used the so-called cluster approach to decipher the details of the reaction mechanisms, including elucidation of the identity of the metal cofactors and the origins of substrate specificity.

Decarboxylases are of growing potential for biocatalytic applications, as they can be used in the synthesis of novel compounds of, e.g., pharmaceutical interest. They can also be employed in the reverse direction, providing a strategy to synthesize value‐added chemicals by CO₂ fixation. A number of non-redox metal-dependent decarboxylases from the amidohydrolase superfamily have been demonstrated to have promiscuous carboxylation activities and have attracted great attention in the recent years. The computational mechanistic studies provide insights that are important for the further modification and utilization of these enzymes in industrial processes. The discussed enzymes are: 5‐carboxyvanillate decarboxylase, γ‐resorcylate decarboxylase, 2,3‐dihydroxybenzoic acid decarboxylase, and iso-orotate decarboxylase.

Capture and Reuse of Carbon Dioxide (CO2) for a Plastics Circular Economy: A Review

Plastic production has been increasing at enormous rates. Particularly, the socioenvironmental problems resulting from the linear economy model have been widely discussed, especially regarding plastic pieces intended for single use and disposed improperly in the environment. Nonetheless, greenhouse gas emissions caused by inappropriate disposal or recycling and by the many production stages have not been discussed thoroughly. Regarding the manufacturing processes, carbon dioxide is produced mainly through heating of process streams and intrinsic chemical transformations, explaining why first-generation petrochemical industries are among the top five most greenhouse gas (GHG)-polluting businesses. Consequently, the plastics market must pursue full integration with the circular economy approach, promoting the simultaneous recycling of plastic wastes and sequestration and reuse of CO2 through carbon capture and utilization (CCU) strategies, which can be employed for the manufacture of olefins (among other process streams) and reduction of fossil-fuel demands and environmental impacts. Considering the previous remarks, the present manuscript’s purpose is to provide a review regarding CO2 emissions, capture, and utilization in the plastics industry. A detailed bibliometric review of both the scientific and the patent literature available is presented, including the description of key players and critical discussions and suggestions about the main technologies. As shown throughout the text, the number of documents has grown steadily, illustrating the increasing importance of CCU strategies in the field of plastics manufacture.

Synthesis and characterization of ordered mesoporous silicas for the immobilization of formate dehydrogenase (FDH)

This work studied the influence of the pore size and morphology of the mesoporous silica as support for formate dehydrogenase (FDH), the first enzyme of a multi-enzymatic cascade system to produce methanol, which catalyzes the reduction of carbon dioxide to formic acid. Specifically, a set of mesoporous silicas was modified with glyoxyl groups to immobilize covalently the FDH obtained from Candida boidinii. Three types of mesoporous silicas with different textural properties were synthesized and used as supports: i) SBA-15 (D_P = 4 nm); ii) MCF with 0.5 wt% mesitylene/pluronic ratio (D_P = 20 nm) and iii) MCF with 0.75 wt% mesitylene/pluronic ratio (D_P = 25 nm). As a whole, the immobilized FDH on MCF_0.75 exhibited higher thermal stability than the free enzyme, with 75% of residual activity after 24 h at 50 °C. FDH/MCF_0.5 exhibited the best immobilization yields: 69.4% of the enzyme supplied was covalently bound to the support. Interestingly, the specific activity increased as a function of the pore size of support and then the FDH/MCF_0.75 exhibited the highest specific activity (namely, 1.05 IU/g_MCF0.75) with an immobilization yield of 52.1%. Furthermore, it was noted that the immobilization yield and the specific activity of the FDH/MCF_0.75 varied as a function of the supported enzyme: as the enzyme loading increased the immobilization yield decreased while the specific activity increased. Finally, the reuse test has been carried out, and a residual activity greater than 70% was found after 5 cycles of reaction.

Engineering stable carbonic anhydrases for CO2 capture: a critical review

Targeted inhibition of misregulated protein-protein interactions (PPIs) has been a promising area of investigation in drug discovery and development for human diseases. However, many constraints remain, including shallow binding surfaces and dynamic conformation changes upon interaction. A particularly challenging aspect is the undesirable off-target effects caused by inherent structural similarity among the protein families. To tackle this problem, phage display has been used to engineer PPIs for high-specificity binders with improved binding affinity and greatly reduced undesirable interactions with closely related proteins. Although general steps of phage display are standardized, library design is highly variable depending on experimental contexts. Here in this review, we examined recent advances in the structure-based combinatorial library design and the advantages and limitations of different approaches. The strategies described here can be explored for other protein-protein interactions and aid in designing new libraries or improving on previous libraries.

Improved biocatalytic cascade conversion of CO2 to methanol by enzymes Co-immobilized in tailored siliceous mesostructured cellular foams

CO2 can be enzymatically reduced to methanol in a cascade reaction involving three enzymes: formate-, formaldehyde- and alcohol dehydrogenase (FateDH, FaldDH, ADH).

Protein-caged zinc porphyrin as a carbonic anhydrase mimic for carbon dioxide capture

Zinc tetraphenylporphyrin (Zn-TPP) solubilized by GroEL protein cage was prepared as a supramolecular mimic of carbonic anhydrase (CA) for CO2 capture. It is shown that the soluble Zn-TPP-GroEL complex can be formed easily by detergent dialysis. The Zn-TPP/GroEL binding ratio was found to increase with their dialysis ratio until reaching the maximum of about 30 porphyrins per protein cage. Moreover, the complex showed hydrase activity that catalyzes the CO2 hydration in HCO3- and H+. It is further seen that the catalytic activity of Zn-TPP-GroEL was about one-half of that of a bovine CA at 25 °C. On the other hand, as the temperature was increased to 60 °C close to an industrial CO2 absorption temperature, the natural enzyme lost function while Zn-TPP-GroEL exhibited better catalytic performance indicative of a higher thermal stability. Finally, we demonstrate that the GroEL-solubilized Zn-TPP is able to accelerate the precipitation of CO2 in the form of CaCO3 and has better long-term performance than the bovine CA. Thus a new type of nano-caged system mimicking natural CAs for potential applications in carbon capture has been established.

A bis(thiosemicarbazonato)-copper complex, a new catalyst for electro- and photo-reduction of CO2 to methanol

A bis(thiosemicarbazonato)-copper complex, a new catalyst for electro- and photo-reduction of CO₂ to methanol.

Enhanced Bio-Electrochemical Reduction of Carbon Dioxide by Using Neutral Red as a Redox Mediator

Microbial electrosynthetic cells containing Methylobacterium extorquens were studied for the reduction of CO2 to formate by direct electron injection and redox mediator-assisted approaches, with CO2 as the sole carbon source. The formation of a biofilm on a carbon felt (CF) electrode was achieved while applying a constant potential of -0.75 V versus Ag/AgCl under CO2 -saturated conditions. During the biofilm growth period, continuous H2 evolution was observed. The long-term performance for CO2 reduction of the biofilm with and without neutral red as a redox mediator was studied by an applied potential of -0.75 V versus Ag/AgCl. The neutral red was introduced into the systems in two different ways: homogeneous (dissolved in solution) and heterogeneous (electropolymerized onto the working electrode). The heterogeneous approach was investigated in the microbial system, for the first time, where the CF working electrode was coated with poly(neutral red) by the oxidative electropolymerization thereof. The formation of poly(neutral red) was characterized by spectroscopic techniques. During long-term electrolysis up to 17 weeks, the formation of formate was observed continuously with an average Faradaic efficiency of 4 %. With the contribution of neutral red, higher formate accumulation was observed. Moreover, the microbial electrosynthetic cell was characterized by means of electrochemical impedance spectroscopy to obtain more information on the CO2 reduction mechanism.

Technology Evolution in Membrane-Based CCS

In recent years, many CO2 capture technologies have been developed due to growing awareness about the importance of reducing greenhouse gas emissions. In this paper, publications from the last decade addressing this topic were analyzed, paying special attention to patent status to provide useful information for policymakers, industry, and businesses and to help determine the direction of future research. To show the most current patent activity related to carbon capture using membrane technology, we collected 2749 patent documents and 572 scientific papers. The results demonstrated that membranes are a developing field, with the number of applications growing at a steady pace, exceeding 100 applications per year in 2013 and 2014. North American assignees were the main contributors, with the greatest number of patents owned by companies such as UOP LLC, Kilimanjaro Energy Inc., and Membrane Technology and Research Inc., making up 26% of the total number of published patents. Asian countries (China, Japan, and Korea) and international offices were also important knowledge sources, providing 29% and 24% of the documents, respectively. Furthermore, this paper highlights 10 more valuable patents regarding their degree of innovation and citations, classified as Y02C 10/10 according to the Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC) criteria.

Electrocatalytic CO2 reduction catalyzed by nitrogenase MoFe and FeFe proteins

Nitrogenases catalyze biological dinitrogen (N₂) reduction to ammonia (NH₃), and also reduce a number of non-physiological substrates, including carbon dioxide (CO₂) to formate (HCOO^-) and methane (CH₄). Three versions of nitrogenase are known (Mo-, V-, and Fe-nitrogenase), each showing different reactivities towards various substrates. Normally, electrons for substrate reduction are delivered by the Fe protein component of nitrogenase, with energy coming from the hydrolysis of 2 ATP to 2 ADP+2 Pi for each electron transferred. Recently, it has been demonstrated that energy and electrons can be delivered from an electrode to the catalytic nitrogenase MoFe-protein without the need for Fe protein or ATP hydrolysis. Here, it is demonstrated that both the MoFe- and FeFe-protein can be immobilized as a polymer layer on an electrode and that electron transfer mediated by cobaltocene can drive CO₂ reduction to formate in this system. It was also found that the FeFe-protein diverts a greater percentage of electrons to CO₂ reduction versus proton reduction compared to the MoFe-protein. Quantification of electron flow to products exhibited Faradaic efficiencies of CO₂ conversion to formate of 9% for MoFe protein and 32% for FeFe-protein, with the remaining electrons going to proton reduction to make H₂.