Review on Additive Manufacturing of Multi-Material Parts: Progress and Challenges

Characterisation of 3D-printable thermoplastics to be used as tissue-equivalent materials in photon and proton beam radiotherapy end-to-end quality assurance devices

Objective.To investigate the potential of 3D-printable thermoplastics as tissue-equivalent materials to be used in multimodal radiotherapy end-to-end quality assurance (QA) devices.Approach.Six thermoplastics were investigated: Polylactic Acid (PLA), Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS), Polyethylene Terephthalate Glycol (PETG), Polymethyl Methacrylate (PMMA), High Impact Polystyrene (HIPS) and StoneFil. Measurements of mass density (ρ), Relative Electron Density (RED), in a nominal 6 MV photon beam, and Relative Stopping Power (RSP), in a 210 MeV proton pencil-beam, were performed. Average Hounsfield Units (HU) were derived from CTs acquired with two independent scanners. The calibration curves of both scanners were used to predict averageρ,RED and RSP values and compared against the experimental data. Finally, measured data ofρ,RED and RSP was compared against theoretical values estimated for the thermoplastic materials and biological tissues.Main results.Overall, goodρand RSP CT predictions were made; only PMMA and PETG showed differences >5%. The differences between experimental and CT predicted RED values were also <5% for PLA, ABS, PETG and PMMA; for HIPS and StoneFil higher differences were found (6.94% and 9.42/15.34%, respectively). Small HU variations were obtained in the CTs for all materials indicating good uniform density distribution in the samples production. ABS, PLA, PETG and PMMA showed potential equivalency for a variety of soft tissues (adipose tissue, skeletal muscle, brain and lung tissues, differences within 0.19%-8.35% for all properties). StoneFil was the closest substitute to bone, but differences were >10%. Theoretical calculations of all properties agreed with experimental values within 5% difference for most thermoplastics.Significance.Several 3D-printed thermoplastics were promising tissue-equivalent materials to be used in devices for end-to-end multimodal radiotherapy QA and may not require corrections in treatment planning systems' dose calculations. Theoretical calculations showed promise in identifying thermoplastics matching target biological tissues before experiments are performed.

The Structural and Mechanical Properties of Al2O3-Ni Composites Obtained by Magnetic Field-Assisted Centrifugal Slip Casting

This study investigates the influence of a magnetic field on the microstructure and properties of Al2O3-Ni composites fabricated via centrifugal slip casting at 1500 rpm. Al2O3 and Ni powders were combined with water and deflocculants, homogenized, and then cast into a porous plaster mold surrounded by Nd-Fe-B magnets. The resulting composites, sintered in a reducing atmosphere, exhibited a three-zone structure with varying Ni content due to the combined effects of the magnetic field and centrifugal force. SEM, EDX, and XRD analyses confirmed the distribution and composition of the phases. Hardness tests revealed the highest values at the outermost zone, with a gradual decrease toward the inner zones. Compression tests employing digital image correlation revealed high internal stresses and a significant improvement in compressive strength compared to non-magnetic field methods. This study confirms that magnetic field-assisted centrifugal slip casting significantly enhances the structural, hardness, and compressive strength properties of Al2O3-Ni composites, indicating promising potential for advanced applications.

Design of dissimilar material joint for defect-free multi-material additive manufacturing via laser-directed energy deposition

Additive manufacturing technology has advanced beyond creating optimized features, from strengthening materials to make them lightweight to fabricating multi-material combinations that offer functionalities beyond the capabilities of individual materials. In this study, a lamination method for laser-directed energy deposition (LDED) is developed to achieve dense multi-material features, and a design that combines different and dissimilar materials is developed. To evaluate these novel developments, two materials-AISI 316L stainless steel and Inconel 625-are introduced. Tensile specimens, fabricated via multi-material additive manufacturing using LDED, are subjected to tensile tests that are recorded on video for digital image correlation. After the tests, fracture surface analyses of the fractured specimens are performed via scanning electron microscopy, and optical monitoring analyses are performed on the specimens that are not subjected to the tensile tests. The results indicate that the specimens demonstrate varied mechanical properties due to the influence of lamination direction and order, which affect the formation of critical cracks and pores.

Fabrication of translucent graded dental crown using zirconia-yttrium multi-slurry tape casting 3D printer

This paper aims to fabricate functionally graded dental crown using a multi-slurry tape casting additive manufacturing technology. The different luminescence of the dental crown was obtained with different composition of zirconia and yttria. Zirconia with tunable mechanical properties and translucency are obtained by adding 3, 3.5, 4, 4.5, and 5 mol% of yttrium oxide to zirconia powder. After obtaining the printable slurry with maximum solid loading, the green bodies are prepared using the in-house built high-speed multi-ceramic tape casting technology. They are later sintered with two-stage sintering method. After the successful fabrication, the mechanical properties and translucency of the specimens were evaluated with Vickers hardness, three-point bending and translucency parameter tests. Finally, an FGM tooth crown with five photocurable slurries is proposed to demonstrate the translucent gradient effect of sintered part. The solid loading of 80% zirconia and 20% resin delivered samples without any surface cracks. The shrinkage ratio analysis showed that the sintered sample dimension was reduced by 20%, 20%, and 23% along X, Y, and Z directions. The samples fabricated with 3% yttrium oxide to zirconia delivered excellent hardness (1687 HV) and flexural strength (650.6 MPa). However, the relative luminescence increased with increasing the yttrium oxide for 3-5 mol%. With the optimized process parameters, the proposed dental crown is fabricated and analyzed for their shrinkage ratio, mechanical, and translucency properties. The study proposes the potential of fabricating customized dental crown with gradient translucent appearance.

Multimaterial Additively Manufactured Metamaterials Functionalized with Customizable Thermal Expansion in Multiple Directions

Metamaterials functionalized with customizable multidirectional coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) are urgently needed for advanced shape control or dimensional stability under temperature variations. The currently reported metamaterials still lack the development of diverse base material systems and exploration of the multimaterial fabrication process. Especially, the reported range of customizable CTEs for metamaterials in multiple directions is limited within [-68.1, 56.4] ppm/°C. Here, this work explicitly proposes a strategy for closely linking base materials, additive manufacturing (AM) process, architecture, and CTE tunability, in order to provide a general guideline for the design or customization of such metamaterials. In detail, first, we systematically identify the key process parameters and related performance for additive manufacturing of polymers and propose various multimaterial systems such as polypropylene-polycarbonate (PP-PC). Then, six types of metamaterials have been fabricated with high quality by the established multimaterial additive manufacturing. By measuring the effective CTEs in multiple directions, the CTE tunability of metamaterials, including large positive values (+523.36 ppm/°C) and large negative values (-230.61 ppm/°C), far beyond the literature-reported CTE range, has been experimentally verified. Further, we have developed a bidirectional requirement-solution strategy here that acts as a bridge between design and fabrication. This work opens advanced avenues for metamaterials with multidirectionally customizable and extensive CTE tunability for a variety of engineering applications such as actuators, thermal stress relief, and improved structural stability.

Material extrusion of thermoplastic acrylic for intraoral devices: Technical feasibility and evaluation

With global demand for 3D printed medical devices on the rise, the search for safer, inexpensive, and sustainable methods is timely. Herein, we assessed the practicality of the material extrusion process for acrylic denture bases of which successful outcomes can be extended to implant surgical guides, orthodontic splints, impression trays, record bases and obturators for cleft palates or other maxillary defects. Representative materials comprising denture prototypes and test samples were designed and built with in-house polymethylmethacrylate filaments using varying print directions (PDs), layer heights (LHs) and reinforcements (RFs) with short glass fiber. The study undertook a comprehensive evaluation of the materials to determine their flexural, fracture, and thermal properties. Additional analyses for tensile and compressive properties, chemical composition, residual monomer, and surface roughness (Ra) were completed for parts with optimum parameters. Micrographic analysis of the acrylic composites revealed adequate fiber-matrix compatibility and predictably, their mechanical properties improved simultaneously with RFs and decreased LHs. Fiber reinforcement also improved the overall thermal conductivity of the materials. Ra, on the other hand, improved visibly with decreased RFs and LHs and the prototypes were effortlessly polished and characterized with veneering composites to mimic gingival tissues. In terms of chemical stability, the residual methyl methacrylate monomer contents are well below standards threshold for biological reactions. Notably, 5 vol% acrylic composites built with 0.05 mm LH in 0° on z-axis produced optimum properties that are superior to those of conventional acrylic, milled acrylic and 3D printed photopolymers. Finite element modeling successfully replicated the tensile properties of the prototypes. It may well be argued that the material extrusion process is cost-effective; however, the speed of manufacturing could be longer than that of established methods. Although the mean Ra is within an acceptable range, mandatory manual finishing and aesthetic pigmentation are required for long-term intraoral use. At a proof-of-concept level, it is evident that the material extrusion process can be applied to build inexpensive, safe, and robust thermoplastic acrylic devices. The broad outcomes of this novel study are equally worthy of academic reflection, and further translation to the clinic.

Metallic Coatings through Additive Manufacturing: A Review

Metallic additive manufacturing is expeditiously gaining attention in advanced industries for manufacturing intricate structures for customized applications. However, the inadequate surface quality has inspired the inception of metallic coatings through additive manufacturing methods. This work presents a brief review of the different genres of metallic coatings adapted by industries through additive manufacturing technologies. The methodologies are classified according to the type of allied energies used in the process, such as direct energy deposition, binder jetting, powder bed fusion, hot spray coatings, sheet lamination, etc. Each method is described in detail and supported by relevant literature. The paper also includes the needs, applications, and challenges involved in each process.

Modeling Materials Coextrusion in Polymers Additive Manufacturing

Material extrusion additive manufacturing enables us to combine more materials in the same nozzle during the deposition process. This technology, called material coextrusion, generates an expanded range of material properties, which can gradually change in the design domain, ensuring blending or higher bonding/interlocking among the different materials. To exploit the opportunities offered by these technologies, it is necessary to know the behavior of the combined materials according to the materials fractions. In this work, two compatible pairs of materials, namely Polylactic Acid (PLA)-Thermoplastic Polyurethane (TPU) and Acrylonitrile Styrene Acrylate (ASA)-TPU, were investigated by changing the material fractions in the coextrusion process. An original model describing the distribution of the materials is proposed. Based on this, the mechanical properties were investigated by analytical and numerical approaches. The analytical model was developed on the simplified assumption that the coextruded materials are a set of rods, whereas the more realistic numerical model is based on homogenization theory, adopting the finite element analysis of a representative volume element. To verify the deposition model, a specific experimental test was developed, and the modeled material deposition was superimposed and qualitatively compared with the actual microscope images regarding the different deposition directions and material fractions. The analytical and numerical models show similar trends, and it can be assumed that the finite element model has a more realistic behavior due to the higher accuracy of the model description. The elastic moduli obtained by the models was verified in experimental tensile tests. The tensile tests show Young's moduli of 3425 MPa for PLA, 1812 MPa for ASA, and 162 MPa for TPU. At the intermediate material fraction, the Young's modulus shows an almost linear trend between PLA and TPU and between ASA and TPU. The ultimate tensile strength values are 63.9 MPa for PLA, 35.7 MPa for ASA, and 63.5 MPa for TPU, whereas at the intermediate material fraction, they assume lower values. In this initial work, the results show a good agreement between models and experiments, providing useful tools for designers and contributing to a new branch in additive manufacturing research.

Microstructure Evaluation of the Potential of Additive Manufactured Dissimilar Titanium-Aluminum Alloys

Pure titanium (Ti) ERTi-2 was accumulated on an aluminum (Al) alloy ER5356 component via wire and arc additive manufacturing. The effect of processing parameters, mainly the input heat per unit length, on Ti/Al components was investigated. The microstructure of the Ti deposited layer and the Ti/Al reaction layer was analyzed using optical microscopy, scanning electron microscope, energy-dispersive spectroscopy, and an X-ray diffractometer. The fabrication of the surface layer equivalent to pure Ti as the used wire or Ti-Al alloy on the Al alloy components was achieved under low and high input heat conditions, respectively, although the Ti/Al components had low joinability and cracks at the reaction layer. Finally, the potential of additive-manufactured Ti/Al components with reference to our results and previous reports was discussed.

Tensile Behavior of Joints of Strip Ends Made of Polymeric Materials

The strength of a joint between the ends of one or more strips can be improved by making the contours of the joint into the shape of either the Greek letter omega or of a dovetail. From the point of view of industrial practice, it is of interest to study the behavior of these joints under stretching demands. The emergence and development of additive manufacturing processes for parts made of polymeric materials has led to the idea of conducting experimental tests to highlight the behavior of omega and dovetail-type joints during the tensile test. For the tensile testing of some test samples in which omega and dovetail joints were used, a Taguchi array of type L18 was employed, with eight independent variables, one variable with a two-level variation, and seven variables with variations on three levels. As independent variables, the type of joint, the couple of polymer materials used to make the two components of the joint, some characteristic dimensions of the joint contours, and some input factors in the 3D printing process were established. The values of average force and average displacement at the peak were considered output parameters. The experimental results were mathematically processed, determining empirical mathematical models of the second-degree polynomial type. These models highlight the influence exerted by the considered input factors on the values of the output parameters.

Infill Strategy in 3D Printed PLA Carbon Composites: Effect on Tensile Performance

Tuning the infill pattern is one of the key features in additive manufacturing to optimise part weight. In this work, the effect of the infill strategy, including rate and pattern type, is studied on the mechanical performance of polylactic acid (PLA)-carbon composite. In particular, three types of patterns and four filling levels are combined. These combinations are evaluated by tensile loading applied on dogbone specimens. In addition, the underlined deformation mechanisms are further explored using filament-based finite element model. The numerical simulation is built from sliced models and converted into 3D meshes to predict tensile performance. The results show that the infill rate has a nonlinear effect on the density of PLA-carbon composites, and its magnitude depends on the complexity of the generated pattern. In addition, tensile loading is found to activate varied modes of shearing and uniaxial deformations depending on the pattern type. This leads to different profiles and rankings of the tensile performance and allows the infill strategy to significantly affect the part performance, along with its density.

Fabrication of Highly Compacted Green Body Using Multi-Sized Al Powder under a Centrifugal Force

This study investigates the application of centrifugal force for the compaction of metal powder. Previous studies using the centrifugal force for manufacturing the green bodies were focused on fine powders with narrow particle size distribution or binary mixtures. This study explores the particle packing of multi-sized powder. Aluminum alloy powder with a particle size less than 100 µm and polymer binder were admixed and compacted in the centrifugal casting with ranging magnitudes of centripetal acceleration. Three different centrifugal forces were tested: 700, 1800, and 3700 G. The microstructure of the green bodies was then observed on the SEM micrographs. The obtained green bodies had high packing densities ranging from 62 to 69%. The packing density and median particle size increase at the positions further away from the center of rotation of the centrifuge with an increase of centrifugal force. The effect of centrifugal force on the segregation of particles was investigated through the quasi-binary segregation index. The segregation phenomena was not observed at 700 G, but clear particle segregation was found at higher centrifugal forces. The increase of the centrifugal force resulted in higher segregation with finer particles moving to the inner part of the spinning mold, with a significant change in the size of particles located closer to the center of rotation. Overall, the centrifugal process was found to produce highly compacted green bodies while yielding a segregation effect due to wide particle size distribution.

Additive Manufacturing: An Opportunity for the Fabrication of Near-Net-Shape NiTi Implants

Nickel–titanium (NiTi) is a shape-memory alloy, a type of material whose name is derived from its ability to recover its original shape upon heating to a certain temperature. NiTi falls under the umbrella of metallic materials, offering high superelasticity, acceptable corrosion resistance, a relatively low elastic modulus, and desirable biocompatibility. There are several challenges regarding the processing and machinability of NiTi, originating from its high ductility and reactivity. Additive manufacturing (AM), commonly known as 3D printing, is a promising candidate for solving problems in the fabrication of near-net-shape NiTi biomaterials with controlled porosity. Powder-bed fusion and directed energy deposition are AM approaches employed to produce synthetic NiTi implants. A short summary of the principles and the pros and cons of these approaches is provided. The influence of the operating parameters, which can change the microstructural features, including the porosity content and orientation of the crystals, on the mechanical properties is addressed. Surface-modification techniques are recommended for suppressing the Ni ion leaching from the surface of AM-fabricated NiTi, which is a technical challenge faced by the long-term in vivo application of NiTi.

Strength Properties of the Heat-Resistant Inconel 718 Superalloy Additively Manufactured by Direct Laser Deposition Method under Shock Compression

By recording and analyzing complete wave profiles using the VISAR laser interferometer, measurements of the Hugoniot elastic limit and critical fracture stresses were carried out under the spalling conditions of the heat-resistant Inconel 718 alloy, additively manufactured by direct laser deposition, at shockwave loading up to ~6.5 GPa using a light-gas gun. For comparison, similar experiments were performed with the Inconel 718 alloy made by the traditional method of vacuum induction melting. The process of the delay of an elastic compression wave during its propagation through the sample and the dependence of the spall strength on the strain before fracture in the range 105–106 s−1 were investigated. To identify the anisotropy of the strength properties of the material under study, two series of experiments were carried out on loading additively manufactured samples along and perpendicular to the direction of the deposition. The measurements performed showed that the additively manufactured Inconel 718 alloy demonstrates weak anisotropy of strength properties for both the initial and thermal-treated samples. The thermal treatment leads to a noticeable increase in the Hugoniot elastic limit and the spall strength of the samples at low strain rates. For all types of samples, there is an increase in the spall strength with an increase in the strain rate. The spall strength measured for the cast alloy practically coincides with the strength of the as-received additive alloy and is noticeably lower than the strength of the thermal-treated additive alloy over the entire range of the strain rates. The process of the decay of the elastic precursor in the cast alloy occurs much faster than in the additive one, and the minimum values of the Hugoniot elastic limit are measured for thick samples in the cast alloy.

Vat Photopolymerization Additive Manufacturing of Functionally Graded Materials: A Review

Functionally Graded Materials (FGMs) offer discrete or continuously changing properties/compositions over the volume of the parts. The widespread application of FGMs was not rapid enough in the past due to limitations of the manufacturing methods. Significant developments in manufacturing technologies especially in Additive Manufacturing (AM) enable us nowadays to manufacture materials with specified changes over the volume/surface of components. The use of AM methods for the manufacturing of FGMs may allow us to compensate for some drawbacks of conventional methods and to produce complex and near-net-shaped structures with better control of gradients in a cost-efficient way. Vat Photopolymerization (VP), a type of AM method that works according to the principle of curing liquid photopolymer resin layer-by-layer, has gained in recent years high importance due to its advantages such as low cost, high surface quality control, no need to support structures, no limitation in the material. This article reviews the state-of-art and future potential of using VP methods for FGM manufacturing. It was concluded that improvements in printer hardware setup and software, design aspects and printing methodologies will accelerate the use of VP methods for FGMs manufacturing.