Degradation of Micropollutants by UV–Chlorine Treatment in Reclaimed Water: pH Effects, Formation of Disinfectant Byproducts, and Toxicity Assay

Systematic analysis of the scientific-technological production on the use of the UV, H2O2, and/or Cl2 systems in the elimination of bacteria and associated antibiotic resistance genes

This study presents a systematic review of the scientific and technological production related to the use of systems based on UV, H2O2, and Cl2 for the elimination of antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB) and genes associated with antibiotic resistance (ARGs). Using the Pro Know-C (Knowledge Development Process-Constructivist) methodology, a portfolio was created and analyzed that includes 19 articles and 18 patents published between 2011 and 2022. The results show a greater scientific-technological production in UV irradiation systems (8 articles and 5 patents) and the binary combination UV/H2O2 (9 articles and 4 patents). It was emphasized that UV irradiation alone focuses mainly on the removal of ARB, while the addition of H2O2 or Cl2, either individually or in binary combinations with UV, enhances the removal of ARB and ARG. The need for further research on the UV/H2O2/Cl2 system is emphasized, as gaps in the scientific-technological production of this system (0 articles and 2 patents), especially in its electrochemically assisted implementation, have been identified. Despite the gaps identified, there are promising prospects for the use of combined electrochemically assisted UV/H2O2/Cl2 disinfection systems. This is demonstrated by the effective removal of a wide range of contaminants, including ARB, fungi, and viruses, as well as microorganisms resistant to conventional disinfectants, while reducing the formation of toxic by-products.

Toxicological aspect of water treated by chlorine-based advanced oxidation processes: A review

As well established in the literature, residual toxicity is an important parameter for evaluating the sanitary and environmental safety of water treatment processes, and this parameter becomes even more crucial when chlorine-based processes are applied for water treatment. Eliminating initial toxicity or preventing its increase after water treatment remains a huge challenge mainly due to the formation of highly toxic disinfection by-products (DBPs) that stem from the degradation of organic contaminants or the interaction of the chlorine-based oxidants with different matrix components. In this review, we present a comprehensive discussion regarding the toxicological aspects of water treated using chlorine-based advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) and the recent findings related to the factors influencing toxicity, and provide directions for future research in the area. The review begins by shedding light on the advances made in the application of free chlorine AOPs and the findings from studies conducted using electrochemical technologies based on free chlorine generation. We then delve into the insights and contributions brought to the fore regarding the application of NH₂Cl- and ClO₂-based treatment processes. Finally, we broaden our discussion by evaluating the toxicological assays and predictive models employed in the study of residual toxicity and provide an overview of the findings reported to date on this subject matter, while giving useful insights and directions for future research on the topic.

Performance evaluation of the UV activated chlorite process on trimethoprim: Degradation efficiency, energy consumption and disinfection by-products formation

As the primary inorganic by-product species of ClO₂, chlorite is believed to have negative toxicological effects on human health and therefrom greatly limits the wide application of ClO₂ in water treatment. The synergistic trimethoprim (TMP) removal concerning degradation efficiency, energy consumption and disinfection by-products (DBPs) formation in the UV activated chlorite process accompanied by the simultaneously elimination of chlorite was comprehensively evaluated. UV/chlorite integrated process removed TMP far more rapidly than UV (1.52%) or chlorite (3.20%) alone due to the endogenous radicals (Cl•, ClO• and •OH), the contributing proportions of which were 31.96%, 19.20% and 44.12%. The second-order rate constants of TMP reaction with Cl•, ClO• and •OH were determined to be 1.75 × 10¹⁰, 1.30 × 10⁹ and 8.66 × 10⁹ M^-1 s^-1. The effects of main water parameters including chlorite dosage, UV intensity, pH as well as water matrixes (nature organic matter, Cl^- and HCO₃^-) were examined. k_obs obeyed the order as UV/Cl₂>UV/H₂O₂≈UV/chlorite>UV, and the cost ranking via electrical energy per order (EE/O, kWh m^-3 order^-1) parameter was UV/chlorite (3.7034) > UV/H₂O₂ (1.1625) >UV/Cl₂ (0.1631). The operational scenarios can be optimized to achieve the maximum removal efficiencies and the minimum energy costs. The destruction mechanisms of TMP were proposed by LC-ESI-MS analysis. The overall weighted toxicity in subsequent disinfection was assessed as UV/Cl₂>UV/chlorite > UV, the values of which in post-chlorination were 6.2947, 2.5806 and 1.6267, respectively. Owing to the vital roles of reactive chlorine species (RCS), UV/chlorite displayed far higher TMP degradation efficiency than UV, and concurrently presented much less toxicity than UV/Cl₂. In an effort to determine the viability of the promising combination technology, this study was devoted to reduce and reuse chlorite and synchronously realize the contaminants degradation efficiently.

Synergistic degradation of trimethoprim and its phytotoxicity via the UV/chlorine process: Influencing factors on removal and kinetic

Occurrence of trimethoprim (TMP), recalcitrant antibiotic, and its adverse effect on ecosystem have been reported in several countries. The study aims to remove the TMP and its phytotoxicity via a UV/chlorine process, compared with chlorination and UV irradiation alone. Various treatment conditions including chlorine doses, pHs, and TMP concentrations was conducted with synthetic waters and effluent waters. The UV/chlorine process exhibited a synergistic effect on the TMP removal, compared with chlorination and UV irradiation alone. The UV/chlorine process was the most effective in removing TMP, followed by chlorination. The UV irradiation slightly affected the TMP removal (less than 5%). The UV/chlorine process completely removed TMP by 15 min contact time, while chlorination for 60 min could achieve 71% of TMP removal. The TMP removal fitted well with the pseudo first-order kinetics, and the rate constant (k') increased with higher chlorine doses, lower TMP concentrations and low pH. HO• was the major oxidant affecting the TMP removal and its degradation rate, compared with other reactive chlorine species (e.g., Cl•, OCl•). The TMP exposure increased the phytotoxicity by decreasing a germination rate of Lactuca sativa and Vigna radiata seeds. The use of UV/chlorine process could effectively detoxify the TMP, resulting in the phytotoxicity level of treated waters equivalent or lower than those of TMP-free effluent water. The detoxification level depended on the TMP removal, and it was about 0.43-0.56 times of TMP removal. The findings indicated the potential use of UV/chlorine process in removing TMP residual and its phytotoxicity.

Treatment of synthetic dye containing textile raw wastewater effluent using UV/Chlorine/Br photolysis process followed by activated carbon adsorption

This study investigated the efficiency and feasibility of ultraviolet (UV)-assisted photolysis of synthetic dye containing textile raw wastewater effluent. For a said purpose, in-house developed UV/Chlorine/Br process was followed in the presence of activated carbon (AC) which additionally facilitate the dye adsorption. In UV/Chlorine process Cl^•, Cl₂^•-, and HO^• are generated in the solution and destroyed compounds that cannot be oxidized by the conventional oxidant. In this process, free bromine is formed and photolyzed by UV radiation and generate Br^• and Br₂^•- that can enhance the rate of pollutant degradation. In the present study, the dye removal efficiency was contributed by dark bromide (7.18%), UV irradiation (26.8%), dark chlorination (78.67%), and UV/Chlorine/Br (87.01%), respectively. With increasing pH from 3.0 to 8.30, the dye removal efficiency was enhanced but decreased by further increasing pH values. In addition, magnetized activated carbon from pomegranate husk using dual-stage chemical activation was used for post-adsorption of the residual dye and its degradation byproducts. The adsorption of the dye residues by AC followed the second-order kinetics with the rate constant of 1.7 × 10^-3. The phytotoxicity of the treated textile wastewater by UV irradiation, dark chlorination, and UV/Chlorine/Br was assessed by seed germination of Lepidium sativum seeds. The highest inhibition effect on seed germination was related to treated wastewater by UV irradiation (more than 90% inhibition) that alleviated to less than 10% when this effluent diluted to 5% v/v. The highest germination was observed when the seeds were irrigated by the effluent of the UV/Chlorine/Br process. The significant reduction in the toxicity of the treated wastewater revealed that the UV/Chlorine/Br process has a considerable potential to effectively detoxify textile wastewater. Graphical abstract.

Effects of MPUV/chlorine oxidation and coexisting bromide, ammonia, and nitrate on DBP formation potential of five typical amino acids

Disinfection byproduct (DBP) formation is a potential concern with regard to MPUV/Cl₂ application in water treatment. In this study, five typical amino acids (AAs) were selected to investigate their DBP alteration during short-term medium pressure (MP) UV/chlorine oxidation following post-chlorination relative to parallel dark controls. The five selected AAs include two potent DBP precursors (aspartic acid and tryptophan), one modest precursor (asparagine) and two poor precursors (phenylalanine and proline). MPUV/chlorine increased the total DBP formation and DBP-associated cytotoxicity of the two poor precursors phenylalanine (Phe) and proline (Pro) as well as their chlorine demands. Conversely, DBP formation and DBP-associated cytotoxicity of the three modest-to-potent DBP precursors showed the opposite changing trends due to MPUV/Cl₂ oxidation. The two aromatic AAs (tryptophan and phenylalanine) were more readily to be affected by MPUV/Cl₂ oxidation especially at acidic pH condition. Conversely, DBP formation and DBP-associated cytotoxicity of the three modest-to-potent precursors showed the opposite changing trends due to MPUV/Cl₂ oxidation. Among the measured DBPs, the absolute formation potential changes of haloacetic acids and haloacetonitriles were the most prominent. Presence of bromide increased the trihalomethane formation potential of five AAs. Ammonia-spiked samples resulted in notably higher chlorine demands but slightly reduced DBPFP. Photonitration caused increased haloacetonitrile and trichloronitromethane formation but lower overall DBP formation potential and DBP-associated cytotoxicity. Results indicated that increased DBP formation of unreactive aromatic AAs may be problematic with respect to MPUV/Cl₂ application, while the presence of inorganic ions may not contribute to further increase in calculated cytotoxicity of measured DBPs.

A comprehensive review of the circulation of microplastics in aquatic ecosystem using scientometric method

Nowadays, the extensive application of microplastics (MPs) has led to the gradual accumulation of toxicity in aquatic environment and caused potential harm to aquatic organisms and human life, which has become a hot issue of worldwide concern. Although MPs show inert or sublethal toxicity in many cases, its long-term existence can still cause harmful ecological effects. However, to our knowledge, there is a lack of comprehensive literature on the current research hotspots, circulation process, and future development trend of MPs in aquatic ecosystem. This study aims to comprehend the current research hotspots and future development trend in the field of the MPs in aquatic ecosystem using scientometric method. And the circulation process of MPs in aquatic ecosystem is also investigated. The results indicate the most of the current publications on MPs in aquatic ecosystems focus on the formation and harmful properties of MPs. The current research hotspots mainly include the causes of the formation of MPs, the extent of contamination, deposition phenomena, and the toxicity and harm caused to aquatic organisms and humans after ingestion. And the future trends in the researches related to MPs mainly include the study of microplastic cycling processes in aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems, as well as the effective collection of microplastics and their conversion into valuable carbon sources. This review has filled in the knowledge gap in the field of MPs research in aquatic ecosystem to some extent and plays a guiding role in the future researches.

Emerging pollutants-Part II: Treatment

Emerging pollutants (EPs) refer to a class of pollutants, which are emerging in the environment or recently attracted attention. EPs mainly include pharmaceutical and personal care products (PPCPs), endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs), and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). EPs have potential threats to human health and ecological environment. In recent years, the continuous detections of EPs in surface and ground water have brought huge challenges to water treatment and also made the treatment of EPs become an international research hotspot. This paper summarizes some research results on EPs treatment published in 2019. This paper may be helpful to understand the current situations and development trends of EP treatment technologies.

MBR-UV/Cl2 system in treating polluted surface water with typical PPCP contamination

This study proposed the membrane bioreactor–ultraviolet/chlorine (MBR-UV/Cl₂) process for treating polluted surface water with pharmaceutical personal care product (PPCP) contamination. Results showed that MBR-UV/Cl₂ effectively removed the organic matters and ammonia at approximately 80% and 95%. MBR-UV/Cl₂ was used in the removal of sulfadiazine(SDZ), sulfamethoxazole(SMZ), tetracycline(TC), oxytetracycline(OTC), ciprofloxacin(CIP), ofloxacin(OFX), erythromycin(ERY), roxithromycin(ROX), ibuprofen(IBU) and, naproxen(NAX) at 12.18%, 95.61%, 50.50%, 52.97%, 33.56%, 47.71%, 87.57%, 93.38%, 93.80%, and 71.46% in which their UV/Cl₂ contribution was 12.18%, 95.61%, 29.04%, 38.14%, 25.94%, 7.20%, 80.28%, 33.79%, 73.08%, and 23.05%, respectively. The removal of 10 typical PPCPs using UV/Cl₂ obtained higher contributions than those of the MBR process, except OTC, ROX, and IBU. The UV/Cl₂ process with 3-min hydraulic retention time and chlorine concentration at 3 mg/L effectively removed the trace of PPCPs. MBR-UV/Cl₂ has the potential to be developed as an effective technology in treating polluted surface water with PPCP contamination.

A Transport-Phenomena Approach to Model Hydrodynamic Cavitation of Organic Pollutants

Hydrodynamic cavitation (HC) has been extensively studied for the Advanced Oxidation of organic compounds in wastewaters since it physically produces an oxidative environment at ambient conditions. This process is simple and economical since it can be realized through a properly designed restriction in a pipeline, even in retrofit solutions. Several experimental works individuated similar values of the optimal operating conditions, especially with regard to the inlet pressure. Up to now, the available modeling works rely on a single-bubble dynamics (SBD) approach and do not consider the actual process configuration and pollutant transport in proximity to the oxidizing environment. This work describes different experimental results (from this research group and others) and applies a novel mathematical model based on a transport-phenomena approach, able to directly simulate the effect of HC on the pollutant degradation. The novel proposed model is able to reproduce well a large number of experimental data obtained in different conditions, with different apparatus and different molecules, and allows to interconnect both SBD, fluid-dynamics, and physio-chemical variables in order to deeply study the interaction between the transport of pollutants and the reactive environment. This paper includes collection and discussion of several experimental results with the related main process parameters, description of the novel model and validation against the cited experimental results (to explain the effect of the operating pressure), sensitivity analysis, and the performance limit of the HC with the proposed modeling approach.