Removal of Six Estrogenic Endocrine-Disrupting Compounds (EDCs) from Municipal Wastewater Using Aluminum Electrocoagulation

Sequestration of steroidal estrogen in aqueous samples using an adsorption mechanism: a systemic scientometric review

Steroidal estrogens (SEs) remain one of the notable endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) that pose a significant threat to the aquatic environment in this era owing to their interference with the normal metabolic functions of the human body systems. They are currently identified as emerging contaminants of water sources. The sources of SEs are either natural or synthetic active ingredients in oral contraceptive and hormonal replacement therapy drugs and enter the environment primarily from excretes in the form of active free conjugate radicals, resulting in numerous effects on organisms in aquatic habitats and humans. The removal of SEs from water sources is of great importance because of their potential adverse effects on aquatic ecosystems and human health. Adsorption techniques have gained considerable attention as effective methods for the removal of these contaminants. A systemic review and bibliometric analysis of the application of adsorption for sequestration were carried out. Metadata for publications on SE removal utilizing adsorbents were obtained from the Web of Science (WoS) from January 1, 1990, to November 5, 2022 (107 documents) and Scopus databases from January 1, 1949, to November 5, 2022 (77 documents). In total, 137 documents (134 research and 4 review articles) were used to systematically map bibliometric indicators, such as the number of articles, most prolific countries, most productive scholars, and most cited articles, confirming this to be a growing research area. The use of different adsorbents, include activated carbon graphene-based materials, single and multi-walled carbon nanotubes, biochar, zeolite, and nanocomposites. The adsorption mechanism and factors affecting the removal efficiency, such as pH, temperature, initial concentration, contact time and adsorbent properties, were investigated in this review. This review discusses the advantages and limitations of different adsorbents, including their adsorption capacities, regenerative potential, and cost-effectiveness. Recent advances and innovations in adsorption technology, such as functionalized materials and hybrid systems, have also been highlighted. Overall, the bibliographic analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the adsorption technique for the removal of SEs from other sources, serving as a valuable resource for researchers and policymakers involved in the development of efficient and sustainable strategies to mitigate the effects of these emerging contaminants.

Enhancing Electrochemical Biosensor Performance for 17β-Estradiol Determination with Short Split-Aptamers

Chronic exposure of 17β-estradiol (E2) even at low concentration can disorganize the endocrine system and lead to undesirable health problems in the long run. An electrochemical biosensor for rapid detection of E2 in water samples was successfully developed. The biosensor was based on split DNA aptamers attached onto poly (methacrylic acid-co-n butyl acrylate-succinimide) microspheres deposited on polypyrrole nanowires coated electrode (PPY/PMAA-NBA). The sandwich paired of split DNA aptamers used were truncated from 75 mer parent aptamers. These two strands of 12-mer and 14-mer split DNA aptamers were then immobilized on the PMAA-NBA microspheres. In the presence of E2, the split DNA aptamers formed an apt12-E2-apt14 complex, where the binding reaction on the electrode surface led to the detection of E2 by differential pulse voltammetry using ferrocyanide as a redox indicator. Under optimum conditions, the aptasensor detected E2 concentrations in the range of 1 × 10-4 M to 1 × 10-12 M (R2 = 0.9772) with a detection limit of 4.8 × 10-13 M. E2, which were successfully measured in a real sample with 97-104% recovery and showed a good correlation (R2 = 0.9999) with the established method, such as high-performance liquid chromatography. Interactions between short and sandwich-type aptamers (split aptamers) demonstrated improvement in aptasensor performance, especially the selectivity towards several potential interferents.

Research Advances in the Analysis of Estrogenic Endocrine Disrupting Compounds in Milk and Dairy Products

Milk and dairy products are sources of exposure to estrogenic endocrine disrupting compounds (e-EDCs). Estrogenic disruptors can accumulate in organisms through the food chain and may negatively affect ecosystems and organisms even at low concentrations. Therefore, the analysis of e-EDCs in dairy products is of practical significance. Continuous efforts have been made to establish effective methods to detect e-EDCs, using convenient sample pretreatments and simple steps. This review aims to summarize the recently reported pretreatment methods for estrogenic disruptors, such as solid-phase extraction (SPE) and liquid phase microextraction (LPME), determination methods including gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS), liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS), Raman spectroscopy, and biosensors, to provide a reliable theoretical basis and operational method for e-EDC analysis in the future.

Hormetic effect of 17α-ethynylestradiol on activated sludge microbial community response

Synthetic estrogen analogues are among the most potent estrogenic contaminants in effluents from wastewater treatment plants. Although its effects have been well elucidated in the feminization of male fish and interference with the endocrine systems in humans, it has not been fully explored in the activated sludge (AS) microbiome, particularly EE2 (17α-ethynylestradiol). Therefore, in this study, the bacterial community shift in a 6-day laboratory-scale reactor in environmental (0, 5, 10, and 100 ng/L) and predictive elevated concentrations (5, 10, and 100 mg/L) of EE2 was investigated using culture-based and metagenomics approaches. Results showed significant changes (t-test, all p < 0.05) between initial and final physicochemical parameters (pH, DO, and EC). Although environmental concentrations showed a slight decrease in microbial counts (5.6 × 10⁶ to 4.6 × 10⁶ CFU/ml) after a 24-h incubation for the culturable approach, the predictive elevated concentrations (5 to 100 mg/L) revealed a drastic microbial counts reduction (5.6 × 10⁶ to 8 × 10² CFU/ml). The metagenomic data analysis uncovered that bacterial communities in the control sample were dominated by Proteobacteria, followed by Bacteroidetes and Firmicutes. The taxonomic classification after exposure of microbial communities in various concentrations revealed significant differences in community composition between environmental concentration (Shannon indices between 2.58 to 3.68) and predictive elevated concentrations (Shannon indices between 2.24 and 2.84; t-test, all p < 0.05). The EE2 enriched seven OTUs were Novosphingobium, Cloacibacterium, Stenotrophomonas, Enterobacteriaceae_unclassified, Stenotrophomonas, Enterobacteriaceae_unclassified and Rhodobacteraceae_unclassified. These results were supported by a dehydrogenase activity (DHA) test, which demonstrated less (about 40%) DHA in predictive elevated concentrations than in environmental concentrations. Notwithstanding, these findings suggest that EE2 may possess potent hormetic effect as evidenced by promotion of microbiome richness and dehydrogenase activity of AS in lower EE2 doses.

A review on advances in removal of endocrine disrupting compounds from aquatic matrices: Future perspectives on utilization of agri-waste based adsorbents

In the recent past, a class of emerging contaminants particularly endocrine disrupting compounds (EDCs) in the aquatic environment have gained a lot of attention. This is due to their toxic behaviour, affecting endocrine activities in humans as well as among aquatic animals. Presently, there are no regulations and discharge limits for EDCs to preclude their negative impact. Furthermore, the conventional treatment processes fail to remove EDCs efficiently. This necessitates the need for more research aimed at development of advanced alternative treatment methods which are economical, efficient, and sustainable. This paper focusses on the occurrence, fate, toxicity, and various treatment processes for removal of EDCs. The treatment processes (physical, chemical, biological and hybrid) have been comprehensively studied highlighting their advantages and disadvantages. Additionally, the use of agri-waste based adsorption technologies has been reviewed. The aim of this review article is to understand the prospect of application of agri-waste based adsorbents for efficient removal of EDCs. Interestingly, research findings have indicated that the use of these low-cost and abundantly available agri-waste based adsorbents can efficiently remove the EDCs. Furthermore, the challenges and future perspectives on the use of agri-waste based adsorbents have been discussed.

A comprehensive review on current technologies for removal of endocrine disrupting chemicals from wastewaters

In the recent years, endocrine disrupting compounds (EDCs) has received increasing attention due to their significant toxic effects on human beings and wildlife by affecting their endocrine systems. As an important group of emerging pollutant, EDCs have been detected in various aquatic environments, including surface waters, groundwater, wastewater, runoff, and landfill leachates. Their removal from water resources has also been an emerging concern considering growing population as well as reducing access to fresh water resources. EDC removal from wastewaters is highly dependent on physicochemical properties of the given EDCs present in each wastewater types as well as various aquatic environments. Due to chemical, physical and physicochemical diversities in these parameters, variety of technologies consisting of physical, biological, electrochemical, and chemical processes have been developed for their removal. This review highlights that the effectiveness of EDC removal is highly dependent of selecting the appropriate technology; which decision is made upon a full wastewater chemical characterization. This review aims to provide a comprehensive perspective about all the current technologies used for EDCs removal from various aquatic matrices along with rising challenges such as the antimicrobial resistance gene transfer during EDC treatment.

A review on electrocoagulation process for the removal of emerging contaminants: theory, fundamentals, and applications

Electrocoagulation (EC) is an excellent and promising technology in wastewater treatment, as it combines the benefits of coagulation, flotation, and electrochemistry. During the last decade, extensive researches have focused on removal of emerging contaminants by using electrocoagualtion, due to its several advantages like compactness, cost-effectiveness, efficiency, low sludge production, and eco-friendness. Emerging contaminants (ECs) are micropollutants found in trace amounts that discharging into conventional wastewater treatment (WWT) plants entering surface waters and imposing a high threat to human and aquatic life. Various studies reveal that about 90% of emerging contaminants are disposed unscientifically into water bodies, creating problems to public health and environment. The studies on removal of emerging contaminants from wastewater are by global researchers are critically reviewed. The core findings proved that still more research required into optimization of parameters, system design, and economic feasibility to explore the potential of EC combined systems. This review has introduced an innovative collection of current knowledge on electro-coagulation for the removal of emerging contaminants.

Abatement technology of endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) by means of enhanced coagulation and ozonation for wastewater reuse

In this study, we have investigated the purification efficiency during enhanced coagulation, ozone oxidation and their combined processes for the removal of trace amounts of EDCs in different DOM matrices. The results indicated that the maximum removal efficiency of EDCs occurred at or near pH 7.0 when measured over a pH range of 4.0-10.0. The addition of natural colloids had a two-part influence. While the floc generated by polyaluminium chloride (PAC) significantly increased in size from 198.0 μm to 290.4 μm with a simultaneous improvement in the removal efficiency of EDCs, the floc size generated by polyferric sulfate (PFS) had no worthwhile change except for a slight decrement. The removal efficiency of EDCs and the decrease in spectral parameters including UVA254, UVA280 and humic-like fluorescence during ozonation processes with and without pre-coagulation were investigated. During the ozonation process, efficient elimination of target EDCs are achieved at low O₃ doses (O₃/dissolved organic carbon (DOC) < 0.2) in different water matrices. The pH-titration differential absorbance spectra technique further demonstrated that the high reactivity of O₃ to EDCs is owing to their phenolic moieties. In addition, when mgO₃/mgDOC ratio reaches to ~0.40, >90% of estrogenic activity was eliminated. In a nutshell, ozonation with pre-coagulation together leads to considerably higher abatement of EDCs and estradiol (E2) equivalent values (EEQ) at the same ozone dosage than ozonation only process for wastewater treatment.

Chemico-nanotreatment methods for the removal of persistent organic pollutants and xenobiotics in water - A review

While the technologies available today can generate high-quality water from wastewater, the majority of the wastewater treatment plants are not intended to eliminate emerging xenobiotic pollutants, pharmaceutical and personal care items. Most endocrine disrupting compounds (EDCs) and personal care products (PPCPs) are more arctic than most regulated pollutants, and several of them have acid or critical functional groups. Together with the trace occurrence, EDCs and PPCPs create specific challenges for removal and subsequent improvements of wastewater treatment plants. Various technologies have been investigated extensively because they are highly persistent which leads to bioaccumulation. Researchers are increasingly addressing the human health hazards of xenobiotics and their removal. The emphasis of this review was on the promising methods available, especially nanotechnology, for the treatment of xenobiotic compounds that are accidentally released into the setting. In terms of xenobiotic elimination, nanotechnology provides better treatment than chemical treatments and their degradation mechanisms are addressed.

Environmental aspects of hormones estriol, 17β-estradiol and 17α-ethinylestradiol: Electrochemical processes as next-generation technologies for their removal in water matrices

Hormones as a group of emerging contaminants have been increasingly used worldwide, which has increased their concern at the environmental level in various matrices, as they reach the water bodies through effluents due to the ineffectiveness of conventional treatments. Here we review the environmental scenario of hormones estriol (E3), 17β-estradiol (E2), and 17α-ethinylestradiol (EE2), explicitly their origins, their characteristics, interactions, how they reach the environment, and, above all, the severe pathological and toxicological damage to animals and humans they produce. Furthermore, studies for the treatment of these endocrine disruptors (EDCs) are deepened using electrochemical processes as the remediation methods of the respective hormones. In the reported studies, these micropollutants were detected in samples of surface water, underground, soil, and sediment at concentrations that varied from ng L^-1 to μg L^-1 and are capable of causing changes in the endocrine system of various organisms. However, although there are studies on the ecotoxicological effects concerning E3, E2, and EE2 hormones, little is known about their environmental dispersion and damage in quantitative terms. Moreover, biodegradation becomes the primary mechanism of removal of steroid estrogens removal by sewage treatment plants, but it is still inefficient, which shows the importance of studying electrochemically-driven processes such as the Electrochemical Advanced Oxidation Processes (EAOP) and electrocoagulation for the removal of emerging micropollutants. Thus, this review covers information on the occurrence of these hormones in various environmental matrices, their respective treatment, and effects on exposed organisms for ecotoxicology purposes.

Recent Advances in the Rejection of Endocrine-Disrupting Compounds from Water Using Membrane and Membrane Bioreactor Technologies: A Review

Water is a critical resource necessary for life to be sustained, and its availability should be secured, appropriated, and easily obtainable. The continual detection of endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) (ng/L or µg/L) in water and wastewater has attracted critical concerns among the regulatory authorities and general public, due to its associated public health, ecological risks, and a threat to global water quality. Presently, there is a lack of stringent discharge standards regulating the emerging multiclass contaminants to obviate its possible undesirable impacts. The conventional treatment processes have reportedly ineffectual in eliminating the persistent EDCs pollutants, necessitating the researchers to develop alternative treatment methods. Occurrences of the EDCs and the attributed effects on humans and the environment are adequately reviewed. It indicated that comprehensive information on the recent advances in the rejection of EDCs via a novel membrane and membrane bioreactor (MBR) treatment techniques are still lacking. This paper critically studies and reports on recent advances in the membrane and MBR treatment methods for removing EDCs, fouling challenges, and its mitigation strategies. The removal mechanisms and the operating factors influencing the EDCs remediation were also examined. Membranes and MBR approaches have proven successful and viable to eliminate various EDCs contaminants.

Adsorption Properties of Polyethersulfone-Modified Attapulgite Hybrid Microspheres for Bisphenol A and Sulfamethoxazole

In this paper, attapulgite purified by acid heat was employed, and millimeter polyethersulfone-modified attapulgite hybrid microspheres were prepared. The effects of mixed bisphenol A (BPA) and sulfamethoxazole (SMX) solution on the modified attapulgite doping ratio, initial solution pH, adsorbent dosage, contaminant concentration, and temperature were studied. The experimental results showed that BPA and SMX compete in the adsorption process, and the hybrid microspheres preferentially select the BPA molecules (anionic endocrine disruptors) compared to the SMX. The adsorption process in the mixed solution conforms to the quasi-secondary-order kinetic model. The adsorption of BPA and SMX by hybrid microspheres is more consistent with the extended Langmuir adsorption thermodynamic model, and the adsorption of BPA + SMX is more in line with the Langmuir adsorption thermodynamic model. At 25 °C, the maximum adsorption capacity of hybrid microspheres for BPA and SMX was 102.04 and 12.80 μmol·g⁻¹, respectively, and the maximum adsorption of BPA + SMX was 112.36 μmol·g⁻¹. After five regenerations, the removal effect of the hybrid microspheres on the endocrine disruptors remained above 95%.

Removal of Organic Micropollutants by Grainy Bentonite-Activated Carbon Adsorbent in a Fixed Bed Column

Organic micropollutants enter effluent streams and then flow into receiving waters. The volume adversely affects aquatic biota substantially. Therefore, many efforts have been made to develop methods for their elimination. The aim of this study was the removal of organic micropollutants with different properties from WWTP (wastewater treatment plant) effluent in fixed bed columns packed with several combinations of sand, granular activated carbon (GAC), and granular clay-carbonaceous composite. Two types of bentonite-powder activated carbon-based granules (Ben-AC) were prepared within this work, with different calcination temperature. It was found that higher calcination temperature enhanced the surface porosity and adsorption potential versus studied micropollutants due to dihydroxylation resulting in higher chemical activity. Introduction of these granules in the place of GAC in a fixed bed column enhances the removal degree of micropollutants and typical water quality parameters. For example, the reduction degree of color, phosphate, and nitrate concentrations increased from 83%, 69%, and 4% to 95%, 83%, and 24% for column I and II, respectively. The concentration of carbamazepine, octylphenol, nononylphenol, and anthracene was reduced by 75%, 83%, 72%, 99% in column I, while using column II or III their removal was: 86%, 97%, 99%, 99%, respectively. Independent of the column filling, the removal of carbamazepine was the lowest (75–86%), while the highest retention was obtained for anthracene (99%). The study of column performance in the treatment of effluent in time showed that column filled with Ben-AC-400 guaranteed high removal degree in the operating time. The batch adsorption data were better described by both the Langmuir model.