Assessing Equity of Access to Proton Beam Therapy: A Literature Review

Proton beam therapy (PBT) is one of the most advanced radiotherapy technologies, with growing evidence to support its use in specific clinical scenarios and exponential growth of demand and capacity worldwide over the past few decades. However, geographical inequalities persist in the distribution of PBT centres, which translate into variations in access and use of this technology. The aim of this work was to look at the factors that contribute to these inequalities, to help raise awareness among stakeholders, governments and policy makers. A literature search was conducted using the Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcomes (PICO) criteria. The same search strategy was run in Embase and Medline and identified 242 records, which were screened for manual review. Of these, 24 were deemed relevant and were included in this analysis. Most of the 24 publications included in this review originated from the USA (22/24) and involved paediatric patients, teenagers and young adults (61% for children and/or teenagers and young adults versus 39% for adults). The most reported indicator of disparity was socioeconomic status (16/24), followed by geographical location (13/24). All the studies evaluated in this review showed disparities in the access to PBT. As paediatric patients make up a significant proportion of the PBT-eligible patients, equity of access to PBT also raises ethical considerations. Therefore, further research is needed into the equity of access to PBT to reduce the care gap.

Outcomes of Patients Treated in the UK Proton Overseas Programme: Non-central Nervous System Group

AIMS

The UK Proton Overseas Programme (POP) was launched in 2008. The Proton Clinical Outcomes Unit (PCOU) warehouses a centralised registry for collection, curation and analysis of all outcomes data for all National Health Service-funded UK patients referred and treated abroad with proton beam therapy (PBT) via the POP. Outcomes are reported and analysed here for patients diagnosed with non-central nervous system tumours treated from 2008 to September 2020 via the POP.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

All non-central nervous system tumour files for treatments as of 30 September 2020 were interrogated for follow-up information, and type (following CTCAE v4) and time of onset of any late (>90 days post-PBT completion) grade 3-5 toxicities.

RESULTS

Four hundred and ninety-five patients were analysed. The median follow-up was 2.1 years (0-9.3 years). The median age was 11 years (0-69 years). 70.3% of patients were paediatric (<16 years). Rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS) and Ewing sarcoma were the most common diagnoses (42.6% and 34.1%). 51.3% of treated patients were for head and neck (H&N) tumours. At last known follow-up, 86.1% of all patients were alive, with a 2-year survival rate of 88.3% and 2-year local control of 90.3%. Mortality and local control were worse for adults (≥25 years) than for the younger groups. The grade 3 toxicity rate was 12.6%, with a median onset of 2.3 years. Most were in the H&N region in paediatric patients with RMS. Cataracts (30.5%) were the most common, then musculoskeletal deformity (10.1%) and premature menopause (10.1%). Three paediatric patients (1-3 years at treatment) experienced secondary malignancy. Seven grade 4 toxicities occurred (1.6%), all in the H&N region and most in paediatric patients with RMS. Six related to eyes (cataracts, retinopathy, scleral disorder) or ears (hearing impairment).

CONCLUSIONS

This study is the largest to date for RMS and Ewing sarcoma, undergoing multimodality therapy including PBT. It demonstrates good local control, survival and acceptable toxicity rates.

Outcomes of Patients Treated in the UK Proton Overseas Programme: Central Nervous System Group

AIMS

In 2008, the UK National Health Service started the Proton Overseas Programme (POP), to provide access for proton beam therapy (PBT) abroad for selected tumour diagnoses while two national centres were being planned. The clinical outcomes for the patient group treated for central nervous system (CNS), base of skull, spinal and paraspinal malignancies are reported here.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Since the start of the POP, an agreement between the National Health Service and UK referring centres ensured outcomes data collection, including overall survival, local tumour control and late toxicity data. Clinical and treatment-related data were extracted from this national patient database. Grade ≥3 late toxicities were reported following Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events (CTCAE) v 4.0 definition, occurring later than 90 days since the completion of treatment.

RESULTS

Between 2008 and September 2020, 830 patients were treated within the POP for the above listed malignancies. Overall survival data were available for 815 patients and local control data for 726 patients. Toxicity analysis was carried out on 702 patients, with patients excluded due to short follow-up (<90 days) and/or inadequate toxicity data available. After a median follow-up of 3.34 years (0.06-11.58), the overall survival was 91.2%. The local control rate was 85.9% after a median follow-up of 2.81 years (range 0.04-11.58). The overall grade ≥3 late toxicity incidence was 11.97%, after a median follow-up of 1.72 years (0.04-8.45). The median radiotherapy prescription dose was 54 GyRBE (34.8-79.2).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study indicate the safety of PBT for CNS tumours. Preliminary clinical outcomes following PBT for paediatric/teen and young adult and adult CNS tumours treated within the POP are encouraging, which reflects accurate patient selection and treatment quality. The rate of late effects compares favourably with published cohorts. Clinical outcomes from this patient cohort will be compared with those of UK-treated patients since the start of the national PBT service in 2018.

P01.07.A Neurocognitive outcomes after proton beam therapy for skull base tumours

Background

Evidence suggests that Proton Beam Therapy (PBT) may lessen the risk of neurocognitive decline (NCD) by reducing the dose to the normal brain as compared to conventional photon radiotherapy (XRT). We report the incidence of moderate-severe (Grade ≥3) NCD in adults treated for skull base chordomas and chondrosarcomas within the United Kingdom’s Proton Overseas Programme (POP).

Material and Methods

Baseline (pre-PBT) and follow-up clinical outcomes data were prospectively collected as part of a national PBT-outcomes registry, which started in 2008 . This registry is curated by a dedicated Proton Clinical Outcomes Unit. Specifically, late toxicities ≥G3 as per CTCAE (Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events) v4.0 definition, occurring later than 90 days after treatment completion, were recorded. This study focuses on the incidence of memory impairment (MI) in the adult (≥25 y) cohort.

Results

Between 2008-2018, 141 adult patients were treated for skull base chordomas (77 patients, 54.6%) and chondrosarcomas (64 patients, 45.4%) via the POP (the majority -62.8%- treated at the University of Florida PBT Institute). Median age at treatment was 51 years (range 26-77). Median prescription dose was 73.8 GyRBE (70-75.6), with a median dose per fraction of 1.8 Gy (1.2-2.1). Of note, the median dose for chondrosarcomas was 70.2 GyRBE (70-75.6), whereas the median dose for chordomas was 73.8 GyRBE (72-75.6). Median follow up was 39 months (0-138). On clinical assessment, 4 patients (2 chordomas, 2 chondrosarcomas) were reported with G3 MI after a median time of 43 months (27-49). None of them had impaired memory at baseline, nor relevant neurological comorbidities. Median age of those who developed G3 MI was 63 y (39-70). Median prescription dose was 72.9 GyRBE (70-73.8). Plans were available for 3 of these 4 patients. Relevant dose statistics to hippocampi and temporal lobes were extracted. Dmean to the omo- and contralateral hippocampi in these 3 patient plans were: patient 1) 33.7 and 11.6 GyRBE; patient 2) 28.1 and 24.4 Gy; patient 3) 8.7 and 8.2 GyRBE, respectively. V20 to the omo- and contralateral temporal lobes in the same patients were: patient 1) 47% and 10%; patient 2) 29% and 28.7%; patient 3) 30% and 28%, respectively. Suggested constraints for these structures are: Dmean &lt; 20 Gy to the hippocampi and V20Gy &lt;10% to the temporal lobes.

Conclusion

Our results indicate that adult patients undergoing high dose radiation for radioresistant tumours may experience detrimental effects on memory. Neurocognitive baseline and follow-up assessment is not routinely performed in this age group but might be appropriate to explore which domains of cognitive function are mainly affected. Larger cohorts are warranted to establish predictive factors and better understand dose volume effect of brain structures and neurocognitive sequelae.

Endophytic Microorganisms Associated with Reversion of Silverleaf Disease Symptoms in Apple

Silverleaf is caused by the fungus Chondrostereum purpureum, which produces wood necrosis and foliar silvering in woody plants. Field observations and studies in apple have shown the reversion of foliar symptoms. Because plants were clones and received identical agronomical management, it was hypothesized that reversion is driven by endophytic microbiota. Thus, the objectives of this study were to compare healthy, diseased, and reverted plants with respect to their physiology, endophytic microbial communities, antagonistic ability of their endophytes against C. purpureum, and defense genes expression. Water potential, stomatal conductance, chlorophyll content, and fluorescence were measured. Endophytic bacterial and fungal DNA were analyzed by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis, and community richness and similarity were calculated. Wood cores were collected and bacterial and fungal endophytes were isolated and confronted with C. purpureum-virulent strains in dual-culture assays. Defense genes expression was measured by quantitative PCR. Results indicated that there were no differences in physiological parameters between healthy and reverted plants, except for fluorescence, and both type of plants differed from diseased ones. Bacterial and fungal community richness was similar in healthy and reverted plants and higher than in diseased ones. Endophytes from reverted and healthy plants showed high antagonism to C. purpureum. Furthermore, nonexpressor of pathogenesis-related gene 1 expression was upregulated in reverted plants, whereas phenylalanine ammonia lyase and polygalacturonase-inhibiting protein genes showed higher values in diseased plants. Overall, physiological, molecular, and microbial characteristics were similar between healthy and reverted plants, and both differed from diseased ones. Therefore, reversion of symptoms is associated with changes in the endophytic microbiota, which seems to be a promising source of biological control agents against C. purpureum.

A Predictive Model for Reactive Tube Feeding in Head and Neck Cancer Patients Undergoing Definitive (Chemo) Radiotherapy

AIMS

Careful management of a patient's nutritional status during and after treatment for head and neck squamous cell cancers (HNSCC) is crucial for optimal outcomes. The aim of this study was to develop a model for stratifying a patient's risk of requiring reactive enteral feeding through a nasogastric tube during radiotherapy for HNSCC, based on clinical and treatment-related factors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A cohort of consecutive patients treated with definitive (chemo)radiotherapy for HNSCC between January 2016 and January 2018 was identified in the institutional electronic database for retrospective analysis. Patients requiring enteral feeding pretreatment were excluded. Clinical and treatment data were obtained from prospectively recorded electronic clinical notes and planning software.

RESULTS

Baseline patient characteristics and tumour-related parameters were captured for 225 patients. Based on the results of the univariate analysis and using a stepwise backwards selection process, clinical and dosimetric variables were selected to optimise a clinically predictive multivariate model, fitted using logistic regression. The parameters found to affect the probability, P, of requiring a nasogastric feeding tube for >4 weeks in our clinical multivariate model were: tumour site, tumour stage (early T0/1/2 stage versus advanced T3/T4 stage), chemotherapy drug (none versus any drug) and mean dose to the contralateral parotid gland. A scoring model using the regression coefficients of the selected variables in the clinical multivariate model achieved an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.745 (95% confidence interval 0.678-0.812), indicating good discriminative performance. Internal validation of the model involved splitting the dataset 80:20 into training and test datasets 10 times and assessing differences in AUC of the model fitted to these.

CONCLUSIONS

We developed an easy-to-use prediction model based on both clinical and dosimetric parameters, which, once externally validated, can lead to more personalised treatment planning and inform clinical decision-making on the appropriateness of prophylactic versus reactive enteral feeding.

A PCR-Based Method for the Rapid Detection of Chondrostereum purpureum in Apple

Silverleaf caused by the basidiomycete Chondrostereum purpureum affects numerous woody species, including fruit tree crops like apple, resulting in wood necrosis and foliar silvering. There are no curative alternatives for this disease, and its management is by prevention methods. Therefore, the aim of this study was to develop a rapid diagnostic tool for the detection and identification of C. purpureum directly from woody tissues to help distinguish the pathogen from other basidiomycetes that are commonly found on apple. The silverleaf pathogen was isolated from different hosts and locations, and Koch's postulates were performed by inoculating the isolates on apple cuttings and measuring internal necrosis. A previously described APN 1 pair of primers specificity was also tested against 25 C. purpureum isolates in this study, using other wood rotting species as negative controls. Seven virulent isolates were inoculated on apple cuttings, and DNA was extracted from the cuttings' sawdust and amplified using APN 1, after 22 days of incubation. To prove the efficiency of the method in the field, DNA from healthy nursery plants inoculated with two virulent isolates, and naturally infected plants showing different levels of foliar symptoms, were tested. Presence of the fungus was verified by reisolation on APDA in all assays. Koch's postulates indicated that all C. purpureum isolates were pathogenic, showing different virulence levels, and APN 1 primers were able to discriminate them from other basidiomycetes. The method was also able to detect C. purpureum from artificially inoculated plants as well as naturally infected ones, demonstrating that the protocol may become a rapid minimally destructive diagnostic tool to detect the pathogen without the need to isolate it from tissues, and thus taking measures to prevent its dissemination.

Usability Testing of an Interactive Dashboard for Surgical Quality Improvement in a Large Congenital Heart Center

BACKGROUND

Interactive data visualization and dashboards can be an effective way to explore meaningful patterns in large clinical data sets and to inform quality improvement initiatives. However, these interactive dashboards may have usability issues that undermine their effectiveness. These usability issues can be attributed to mismatched mental models between the designers and the users. Unfortunately, very few evaluation studies in visual analytics have specifically examined such mismatches between these two groups.

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to evaluate the usability of an interactive surgical dashboard and to seek opportunities for improvement. We also aimed to provide empirical evidence to demonstrate the mismatched mental models between the designers and the users of the dashboard.

METHODS

An interactive dashboard was developed in a large congenital heart center. This dashboard provides real-time, interactive access to clinical outcomes data for the surgical program. A mixed-method, two-phase study was conducted to collect user feedback. A group of designers (N = 3) and a purposeful sample of users (N = 12) were recruited. The qualitative data were analyzed thematically. The dashboards were compared using the System Usability Scale (SUS) and qualitative data.

RESULTS

The participating users gave an average SUS score of 82.9 on the new dashboard and 63.5 on the existing dashboard (p = 0.006). The participants achieved high task accuracy when using the new dashboard. The qualitative analysis revealed three opportunities for improvement. The data analysis and triangulation provided empirical evidence to the mismatched mental models.

CONCLUSION

We conducted a mixed-method usability study on an interactive surgical dashboard and identified areas of improvements. Our study design can be an effective and efficient way to evaluate visual analytics systems in health care. We encourage researchers and practitioners to conduct user-centered evaluation and implement education plans to mitigate potential usability challenges and increase user satisfaction and adoption.

Differences in Cost of Care by Palliation Strategy for Infants With Ductal-Dependent Pulmonary Blood Flow

BACKGROUND

In infants with ductal-dependent pulmonary blood flow, initial palliation with patent ductus arteriosus (PDA) stent or modified Blalock-Taussig (BT) shunt have comparable mortality but discrepant length of stay, procedural complication rates and reintervention burdens, which may influence cost. The relative economic impact of these palliation strategies is unknown.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Retrospective study of infants with ductal-dependent pulmonary blood flow palliated with PDA stent (n=104) or BT shunt (n=251) from 2008 to 2015 at 4 centers of the Congenital Catheterization Research Collaborative. Inflation-adjusted inpatient hospital costs were calculated for first year of life using Pediatric Health Information System data. Costs derived from outpatient catheterizations not in Pediatric Health Information System were imputed. Costs were compared using propensity score-adjusted multivariable models, to account for baseline differences between groups. After propensity score adjustment, first year of life costs were significantly lower in PDA stent ($215 825 [190 644-244 333]) than BT shunt ($249 855 [230 693-270 609]) patients ( P=0.05). After addition of imputed costs, first year of life costs were not significantly different between PDA stent ($226 403 [200 274-255 941]) and BT shunt ($252 072 [232 955-272 759]) groups ( P=0.15). Patient characteristics associated with higher costs included: younger gestational age, genetic syndrome, noncardiac diagnoses, procedural complications, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, duration of ventilation, intensive care unit and hospital length of stay and reintervention ( P≤0.02 for all).

CONCLUSIONS

In this first multicenter comparative cost study of PDA stent or BT shunt as palliation for infants with ductal-dependent pulmonary blood flow, adjusted for baseline differences, PDA stent was associated with lower to equivalent costs over the first year of life. Combined with previous evidence suggesting clinical noninferiority, these findings suggest that PDA stent provides competitive health care value.

First Report of Root Rot of Chicory Caused by Phytophthora cryptogea in Chile

Chicory (Cichorium intybus L. var sativum Bisch.), a relatively new high-value crop in Chile, was introduced for commercial production of inulin. Inulins are polysaccharides extracted from chicory tap roots that are used in processed foods because of their beneficial gastrointestinal properties. Approximately 3,000 ha of chicory are grown for local processing in the BioBio Region near Chillan in south central Chile. Recently, a severe rot of 1 to 3% of mature roots in the field and after harvest has been observed in most fields, which caused yield and quality losses. Typical symptoms include a brown discoloration and a soft, watery decay of the root. Tissue pieces from symptomatic roots were placed on water agar and clarified V8 juice agar medium amended with antibiotics (1) for isolation of the causal pathogen. A Phytopthora sp. had been consistently isolated from root lesions, and axenic cultures were obtained using single-hypha transfers. The species was provisionally identified as Phytopthora cryptogea (Pethybridge and Lafferty, 1919) on the basis of morphological and cultural characteristics (1). Mycelia grew between 5 and 30°C with optimal growth at 20 to 25°C and no growth at 35°C. All isolates produced hyphal swellings and nonpapillate, persistent, internally proliferating, and ovoid to obpyriform sporangia with mean dimensions of 45 × 31 μm in sterile soil extract. The isolates were of A1 mating type because they produced oospores only when paired with reference isolates of P. cinnamomi A2 on clarified V8 juice agar amended with thiamine, tryptophan, and β-sitosterol (1) after 20 days at 20°C in the dark. On the basis of morphological and sequence data from cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 and 2, internal transcribed spacer 2, and β-tubulin (GenBank Accession Nos. JQ037796 to JQ037798, respectively), the pathogen was identified as P. cryptogea. Pathogenicity tests were conducted using three isolates of P. cryptogea by placing a 7-mm-diameter disk from a 1-week-old V8 agar culture on 10 wounded and nonwounded healthy chicory roots (2). Control roots were mock inoculated with agar plugs. The inoculated roots were incubated at 20°C in a moist chamber. Root rot symptoms, identical to those observed both in field and storage, developed after 4 to 6 days only on wounded sites inoculated with the pathogen, and P. cryptogea was reisolated from these inoculated plants. Mock-inoculated roots remained healthy. This experiment was completed twice and similar results were obtained. To our knowledge, this is the first report of Phytophthora root rot of chicory caused by P. cryptogea in Chile. References: (1) D. C. Erwin and O. K. Ribeiro. Phytophthora Diseases Worldwide. The American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, MN, 1996. (2) M. E. Stanghellini and W. C. Kronland. Plant Dis. 66:262, 1982.

Distal nephron sodium-potassium exchange in children with nephrotic syndrome

While recent literature data suggest that a primary impairment in sodium excretion is the basic abnormality in the pathogenesis of edema formation in the nephrotic syndrome, there is ample evidence that functional hypovolemia contributes to stimulation of renal sodium and fluid retention. Vasoactive hormones such as renin and aldosterone are involved in this process. Discrimination between both mechanisms would be possible by assessment of aldosterone bioactivity and will have therapeutical consequences by indicating the need for administration of i.v. albumin or diuretics. In this paper, several indices of aldosterone bioactivity were assessed in 85 patients with minimal lesion nephrotic syndrome (118 measurements were performed in patients while in remission and 210 following relapses), and in 41 nephrotic patients with different types of nephropathy and were related to plasma renin and aldosterone levels. A better correlation was found between log aldosterone and U(K+)/U(Na+) + U(K+) ratio than with other parameters measuring renal potassium handling such as transtubular potassium gradient, fractional excretion of potassium and urine K+/urine Na+ or urine K+ creatinine ratios. In patients with renal sodium retention (FE(Na)% less than 0.5), an U(K+)/U(Na+) + U(K+) ratio higher than 0.60 identifies patients with increased aldosterone levels and indicates functional hypovolemia. This index may therefore be used to assess which patients will benefit from i.v. albumin administration.

Surfactant-aided, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry of hydrophobic and hydrophilic peptides

The analysis of hydrophobic and hydrophilic peptides in an aqueous medium using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) is reported. The key development allowing for simultaneous analysis of both hydrophobic and hydrophilic components of the sample mixture is the use of surfactants to solubilize the hydrophobic components in the MALDI matrix solution. A wide variety of anionic, cationic, zwitterionic, and nonionic surfactants were evaluated for their ability to assist in the generation of an abundant pseudomolecular ion from a model hydrophobic peptide ([tert-butoxycarbonyl]Glu[gamma-O-benzyl]-Ala-Leu-Ala[O-phenacyl ester]). The results indicate that the most successful surfactant among those studied for analyzing the model hydrophobic peptide is sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). SDS exhibited no interfering surfactant background ions, little to no loss of the acid-labile protecting groups from the model hydrophobic peptide, and an abundant pseudomolecular ion of the analyte. In addition, the use of surfactants is shown to be compatible with hydrophilic peptides as well. Mixtures of hydrophobic and hydrophilic peptides were characterized using surfactant-aided (SA) MALDI-MS, and it is demonstrated that all components are detectable once the surfactant is included in the sample solution. We conclude that the key benefit of using SA-MALDI-MS is its ability to simultaneously analyze hydrophobic and hydrophilic peptides from a single sample mixture, including synthetic peptides containing acid- and base-labile protecting groups.

Transition metals as protease inhibitors

An alternative approach to the development of clinically useful protease inhibitors was investigated. The approach utilized coordination chemistry of transition metal ions rather than substrate analogs to block active sites of these enzymes. In the case of serine proteases it was found that aqueous Ti(IV) is a potent inhibitor of the trypsin subclass, but not the chymotrypsin subclass. The direct binding of Ti(IV) to trypsin was made possible by the presence of a free carboxyl group at the bottom of the substrate binding pocket of the enzyme, and the five-coordinate geometry of TiO(SO4)(H2O). Although initial binding of Ti(IV) was reversible, it was followed in time by irreversible inhibition. Direct binding of octahedral or tetrahedral metal ion complexes was prevented by the inability of the enzyme active sites to promote formation of a five-coordinate transition state of the metal ion required for reaction. These studies demonstrate the ability of direct metal ion binding as a way to enhance blocking of enzyme active sites as compared with that of traditional organic inhibitors. Application of these findings was investigated by measuring the affect Ti(IV) had on growth of Escherichia coli, Salmonella typhimurium, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Five-coordinate titanyl sulfate completely inhibited the growth of these organisms. This suggests that five-coordinate titanyl sulfate, which is easier and less expensive to manufacture than conventional antibiotics, may be useful in controlling endemic infections of E. coli and S. typhimurium.

Ventilation tube placement in a managed care population

To date, little information is available regarding the actual incidence of ventilation tube placement in a known population of pediatric patients. We evaluated the incidence of ventilation tube placement in a known population of pediatric patients whose health coverage is provided through a large managed care organization. Epidemiological data provided by a large managed care organization on a population of 67,995 children from July 1, 1993, through June 30, 1994, were evaluated. A primary care physician referral to an otolaryngologist was required for assessment, and precertification for ventilation tube placement was obtained using explicit criteria developed by a large national health services utilization review organization. In children younger than 24 months, 30.11% underwent ventilation tube placement compared with an overall incidence of 4.49% for all children younger than 18 years. The details of this study are presented to understand better the implications of the epidemiology of otitis media and how it relates to a physician's participation in a managed care organization.

The current value of tuberculin testing and BCG vaccination in school children

We have examined the value of routine tuberculin testing and BCG vaccination in Edinburgh school children from 1970 to 1983. Over 89,000 children were observed for a mean period of 7 years, during which 77 new cases of tuberculosis were notified in Caucasians. The average annual incidence of tuberculosis in the 65,692 children receiving BCG vaccination at school was 7/10(5), significantly less than the 19/10(5) estimated in 12,987 Heaf negative children who missed BCG vaccination, and the 41/10(5) in 5,308 tuberculin positive children (P less than 0.001). The efficacy of BCG vaccination in this study exceeded 60%. The 5,308 tuberculin positive children were offered chest radiographs with an initial yield (new cases of tuberculosis detected/radiographs taken) of 1/555 for Heaf grade II children, 1/75 for grade III, and 1/25 for grade IV (P less than 0.001). During the period of this study approximately 700 BCG vaccinations were necessary to prevent one new case of tuberculosis and this represents considerably greater benefit than in England and Wales during the same period. There may be a case for continuing the schools' BCG programme in Scotland for a number of years longer than in England and Wales. A national BCG survey for Scotland would be valuable.