Primary Retinal Cell Cultures as a Model to Study Retina Biology

Since its inception, primary retinal cultures have been an in vitro tool for modeling the in vivo environment of the retina for biological studies on development and disease. They offer simple and controlled experimental approaches when compared to in vivo models. In this review we highlight the strengths and weaknesses of primary retinal culture models, and the features of dispersed retinal cell cultures.

Retinoid X receptor activation promotes photoreceptor survival and modulates the inflammatory response in a mouse model of retinitis pigmentosa

Photoreceptor cell (PHR) death is a hallmark of most retinal neurodegenerative diseases, in which inflammation plays a critical role. Activation of retinoid X receptors (RXR) modulates and integrates multiple cell functions, and has beneficial effects in animal models of chronic inflammatory diseases. Nonetheless, the mechanisms involved and their role in retina neuroprotection are poorly understood. In this work we assessed whether RXR activation prevents inflammation and/or PHR death in retinitis pigmentosa, an inherited retina neurodegeneration, using as an ex vivo model, retinas from the rd1 mice, a murine model of this disease. We demonstrated that rd1 retinas had lower levels of RXR alpha isoform than their wt counterparts at early developmental times, whereas its distribution pattern remained similar. In mixed neuro-glial cultures obtained from either rd1 or wt retinas, both PHR and Müller glial cells (MGC) expressed RXRalpha, and RXR activation by its synthetic pan-agonist PA024 selectively increased mRNA levels of RXRgamma isoform. PA024 decreased PHR death in rd1 mixed cultures; it reduced the amount of non-viable neurons, delayed the onset of PHR apoptosis, and decreased Bax mRNA levels. PA024 also reduced MGC reactivity in vitro before and at the onset of degeneration, decreasing GFAP expression, increasing glutamine synthetase mRNA levels, and promoting the transcription of the anti-inflammatory cytokine, Il-10. These results suggest that RXR activation rescues rd1 PHR and decreases MGC reactivity, promoting an anti-inflammatory environment in the rd1 retina, thus supporting the potential of RXR agonists as pharmacological tools for treating retina degenerative diseases.

Ceramide-1-phosphate promotes the migration of retina Müller glial cells

Müller glial cells, the major glial cell type in the retina, are activated by most retina injuries, leading to an increased proliferation and migration that contributes to visual dysfunction. The molecular cues involved in these processes are still ill defined. We demonstrated that sphingosine-1-phosphate (S1P), a bioactive sphingolipid, promotes glial migration. We now investigated whether ceramide-1-phosphate (C1P), also a bioactive sphingolipid, was involved in Müller glial cell migration. We evaluated cell migration in primary Müller glial cultures, prepared from newborn rat retinas, by the scratch wound assay. Addition of either 10 μM C8-ceramide-1-phosphate (C8-C1P) or 5 μM C16-C1P (a long chain, natural C1P) stimulated glial migration. Inhibiting PI3K almost completely blocked C8-C1P-elicited migration whereas inhibition of ERK1-2/MAPK pathway diminished it and p38MAPK inhibition did not affect it. Pre-treatment with a cytoplasmic phospholipase A2 (cPLA2) inhibitor markedly reduced C8-C1P-induced migration. Inhibiting ceramide kinase (CerK), the enzyme catalyzing C1P synthesis, partially decreased glial migration. Combined addition of S1P and C8-C1P promoted glial migration to the same extent as when they were added separately, suggesting they converge on their downstream signaling to stimulate Müller glia migration. These results suggest that C1P addition stimulated migration of glial Müller cells, promoting the activation of cPLA2, and the PI3K and ERK/MAPK pathways. They also suggest that CerK-dependent C1P synthesis was one of the factors contributing to glial migration, thus uncovering a novel role for C1P in controlling glial motility.

Damaging effects of BMAA on retina neurons and Müller glial cells

B-N-methylamino-L-alanine (BMAA), a cyanotoxin produced by most cyanobacteria, has been proposed to cause long term damages leading to neurodegenerative diseases, including Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/Parkinsonism Dementia complex (ALS/PDC) and retinal pathologies. Previous work has shown diverse mechanisms leading to BMAA-induced degeneration; however, the underlying mechanisms of toxicity affecting retina cells are not fully elucidated. We here show that BMAA treatment of rat retina neurons in vitro induced nuclear fragmentation and cell death in both photoreceptors (PHRs) and amacrine neurons, provoking mitochondrial membrane depolarization. Pretreatment with the N-Methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist MK-801 prevented BMAA-induced death of amacrine neurons, but not that of PHRs, implying activation of NMDA receptors participated only in amacrine cell death. Noteworthy, BMAA stimulated a selective axonal outgrowth in amacrine neurons, simultaneously promoting growth cone destabilization. BMAA partially decreased the viability of Müller glial cells (MGC), the main glial cell type in the retina, induced marked alterations in their actin cytoskeleton and impaired their capacity to protect retinal neurons. BMAA also induced cell death and promoted axonal outgrowth in differentiated rat pheochromocytoma (PC12) cells, implying these effects were not limited to amacrine neurons. These results suggest that BMAA is toxic for retina neurons and MGC and point to the involvement of NMDA receptors in amacrine cell death, providing new insight into the mechanisms involved in BMAA neurotoxic effects in the retina.

A Defective Crosstalk Between Neurons and Müller Glial Cells in the rd1 Retina Impairs the Regenerative Potential of Glial Stem Cells

Müller glial cells (MGC) are stem cells in the retina. Although their regenerative capacity is very low in mammals, the use of MGC as stem cells to regenerate photoreceptors (PHRs) during retina degenerations, such as in retinitis pigmentosa, is being intensely studied. Changes affecting PHRs in diseased retinas have been thoroughly investigated; however, whether MGC are also affected is still unclear. We here investigated whether MGC in retinal degeneration 1 (rd1) mouse, an animal model of retinitis pigmentosa, have impaired stem cell properties or structure. rd1 MGC showed an altered morphology, both in culture and in the whole retina. Using mixed neuron-glial cultures obtained from newborn mice retinas, we determined that proliferation was significantly lower in rd1 than in wild type (wt) MGC. Levels of stem cell markers, such as Nestin and Sox2, were also markedly reduced in rd1 MGC compared to wt MGC in neuron-glial cultures and in retina cryosections, even before the onset of PHR degeneration. We then investigated whether neuron-glial crosstalk was involved in these changes. Noteworthy, Nestin expression was restored in rd1 MGC in co-culture with wt neurons. Conversely, Nestin expression decreased in wt MGC in co-culture with rd1 neurons, as occurred in rd1 MGC in rd1 neuron-glial mixed cultures. These results imply that MGC proliferation and stem cell markers are reduced in rd1 retinas and might be restored by their interaction with “healthy” PHRs, suggesting that alterations in rd1 PHRs lead to a disruption in neuron-glial crosstalk affecting the regenerative potential of MGC.

Microsaccadic behavior when developing a complex dynamical activity

Microsaccade are sensitive to changes of perceptual inputs as well as modulations of cognitive states. There are just a few works analyzing microsaccade while subjects are processing complex information and fewer when doing predictions about upcoming events. To evaluate whether contextual predictability would change microsaccadic behavior, we evaluated microsaccade of twenty one persons when reading 40 regular sentences and 40 proverbs. Analysis of microsaccade during reading proverbs and regular sentences revealed that microsaccade rate on words before maxjump, during maxjump and words after maxjump varied depending on the kind of sentence and on the word predictability. Maxjump was defined as the word with the largest difference between the cloze predictability of two consecutive words. Low and high predictable words demanded less or more microsaccade on words previous, during and on maxjump depending of the semantic context and of the readers' predictions of upcoming words.In summary, the present study shows that microsaccade' rate evidenced significant differences when reading proverbs and regular sentences. Hence, evaluation of microsaccade during reading sentences with different contextual predictability might provide information about specific effect of cue attention on complex task.

Patients with Mild Alzheimer's Disease Fail When Using Their Working Memory: Evidence from the Eye Tracking Technique

Patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) develop progressive language, visuoperceptual, attentional, and oculomotor changes that can have an impact on their reading comprehension. However, few studies have examined reading behavior in AD, and none have examined the contribution of predictive cueing in reading performance. For this purpose we analyzed the eye movement behavior of 35 healthy readers (Controls) and 35 patients with probable AD during reading of regular and high-predictable sentences. The cloze predictability of words N - 1, and N + 1 exerted an influence on the reader's gaze duration. The predictabilities of preceding words in high-predictable sentences served as task-appropriate cues that were used by Control readers. In contrast, these effects were not present in AD patients. In Controls, changes in predictability significantly affected fixation duration along the sentence; noteworthy, these changes did not affect fixation durations in AD patients. Hence, only in healthy readers did predictability of upcoming words influence fixation durations via memory retrieval. Our results suggest that Controls used stored information of familiar texts for enhancing their reading performance and imply that contextual-word predictability, whose processing is proposed to require memory retrieval, only affected reading behavior in healthy subjects. In AD patients, this loss reveals impairments in brain areas such as those corresponding to working memory and memory retrieval. These findings might be relevant for expanding the options for the early detection and monitoring in the early stages of AD. Furthermore, evaluation of eye movements during reading could provide a new tool for measuring drug impact on patients' behavior.

Synthesis of docosahexaenoic acid from eicosapentaenoic acid in retina neurons protects photoreceptors from oxidative stress

Oxidative stress is involved in activating photoreceptor death in several retinal degenerations. Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), the major polyunsaturated fatty acid in the retina, protects cultured retina photoreceptors from apoptosis induced by oxidative stress and promotes photoreceptor differentiation. Here, we investigated whether eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA), a metabolic precursor to DHA, had similar effects and whether retinal neurons could metabolize EPA to DHA. Adding EPA to rat retina neuronal cultures increased opsin expression and protected photoreceptors from apoptosis induced by the oxidants paraquat and hydrogen peroxide (H2 O2 ). Palmitic, oleic, and arachidonic acids had no protective effect, showing the specificity for DHA. We found that EPA supplementation significantly increased DHA percentage in retinal neurons, but not EPA percentage. Photoreceptors and glial cells expressed Δ6 desaturase (FADS2), which introduces the last double bond in DHA biosynthetic pathway. Pre-treatment of neuronal cultures with CP-24879 hydrochloride, a Δ5/Δ6 desaturase inhibitor, prevented EPA-induced increase in DHA percentage and completely blocked EPA protection and its effect on photoreceptor differentiation. These results suggest that EPA promoted photoreceptor differentiation and rescued photoreceptors from oxidative stress-induced apoptosis through its elongation and desaturation to DHA. Our data show, for the first time, that isolated retinal neurons can synthesize DHA in culture. Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), the major polyunsaturated fatty acid in retina photoreceptors, and its precursor, eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) have multiple beneficial effects. Here, we show that retina neurons in vitro express the desaturase FADS2 and can synthesize DHA from EPA. Moreover, addition of EPA to these cultures protects photoreceptors from oxidative stress and promotes their differentiation through its metabolization to DHA.

Light, lipids and photoreceptor survival: live or let die?

Due to its constant exposure to light and its high oxygen consumption the retina is highly sensitive to oxidative damage, which is a common factor in inducing the death of photoreceptors after light damage or in inherited retinal degenerations. The high content of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), the major polyunsaturated fatty acid in the retina, has been suggested to contribute to this sensitivity. DHA is crucial for developing and preserving normal visual function. However, further roles of DHA in the retina are still controversial. Current data support that it can tilt the scale either towards degeneration or survival of retinal cells. DHA peroxidation products can be deleterious to the retina and might lead to retinal degeneration. However, DHA has also been shown to act as, or to be the source of, a survival molecule that protects photoreceptors and retinal pigment epithelium cells from oxidative damage. We have established that DHA protects photoreceptors from oxidative stress-induced apoptosis and promotes their differentiation in vitro. DHA activates the retinoid X receptor (RXR) and the ERK/MAPK pathway, thus regulating the expression of anti and pro-apoptotic proteins. It also orchestrates a diversity of signaling pathways, modulating enzymatic pathways that control the sphingolipid metabolism and activate antioxidant defense mechanisms to promote photoreceptor survival and development. A deeper comprehension of DHA signaling pathways and context-dependent behavior is required to understand its dual functions in retinal physiology.

Eye movement alterations during reading in patients with early Alzheimer disease

PURPOSE

Eye movements follow a reproducible pattern during normal reading. Each eye movement ends up in a fixation point, which allows the brain to process the incoming information and to program the following saccade. Alzheimer disease (AD) produces eye movement abnormalities and disturbances in reading. In this work, we investigated whether eye movement alterations during reading might be already present at very early stages of the disease.

METHODS

Twenty female and male adult patients with the diagnosis of probable AD and 20 age-matched individuals with no evidence of cognitive decline participated in the study. Participants were seated in front of a 20-inch LCD monitor and single sentences were presented on it. Eye movements were recorded with an eye tracker, with a sampling rate of 1000 Hz and an eye position resolution of 20 arc seconds.

RESULTS

Analysis of eye movements during reading revealed that patients with early AD decreased the amount of words with only one fixation, increased their total number of first- and second-pass fixations, the amount of saccade regressions and the number of words skipped, compared with healthy individuals (controls). They also reduced the size of outgoing saccades, simultaneously increasing fixation duration.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study shows that patients with mild AD evidenced marked alterations in eye movement behavior during reading, even at early stages of the disease. Hence, evaluation of eye movement behavior during reading might provide a useful tool for a more precise early diagnosis of AD and for dynamical monitoring of the pathology.

Retinoid X receptor activation is essential for docosahexaenoic acid protection of retina photoreceptors

We have established that docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), the major polyunsaturated fatty acid in the retina, promotes survival of rat retina photoreceptors during early development in vitro and upon oxidative stress by activating the ERK/MAPK signaling pathway. Here we have investigated whether DHA turns on this pathway through activation of retinoid X receptors (RXRs) or by inducing tyrosine kinase (Trk) receptor activation. We also evaluated whether DHA release from phospholipids was required for its protective effect. Addition of RXR antagonists (HX531, PA452) to rat retinal neuronal cultures inhibited DHA protection during early development in vitro and upon oxidative stress induced with Paraquat or H2O2. In contrast, the Trk inhibitor K252a did not affect DHA prevention of photoreceptor apoptosis. These results imply that activation of RXRs was required for DHA protection whereas Trk receptors were not involved in this protection. Pretreatment with 4-bromoenol lactone, a phospholipase A2 inhibitor, blocked DHA prevention of oxidative stress-induced apoptosis of photoreceptors. It is noteworthy that RXR agonists (HX630, PA024) also rescued photoreceptors from H2O2-induced apoptosis. These results provide the first evidence that activation of RXRs prevents photoreceptor apoptosis and suggest that DHA is first released from phospholipids and then activates RXRs to promote the survival of photoreceptors.

Leukemia inhibitory factor coordinates the down-regulation of the visual cycle in the retina and retinal-pigmented epithelium

Leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF), an interleukin-6 family neurocytokine, is up-regulated in response to different types of retinal stress and has neuroprotective activity through activation of the gp130 receptor/STAT3 pathway. We observed that LIF induces rapid, robust, and sustained activation of STAT3 in both the retina and retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE). Here, we tested whether LIF-induced STAT3 activation within the RPE can down-regulate RPE65, the central enzyme in the visual cycle that provides the 11-cis-retinal chromophore to photoreceptors in vivo. We generated conditional knock-out mice to specifically delete STAT3 or gp130 in RPE, retina, or both RPE and retina. After intravitreal injection of LIF, we analyzed the expression levels of visual cycle genes and proteins, isomerase activity of RPE65, levels of rhodopsin protein, and the rates of dark adaptation and rhodopsin regeneration. We found that RPE65 protein levels and isomerase activity were reduced and recovery of bleachable rhodopsin was delayed in LIF-injected eyes. In mice with functional gp130/STAT3 signaling in the retina, rhodopsin protein was also reduced by LIF. However, the LIF-induced down-regulation of RPE65 required a functional gp130/STAT3 cascade intrinsic to RPE. Our data demonstrate that a single cytokine, LIF, can simultaneously and independently affect both RPE and photoreceptors through the same signaling cascade to reduce the generation and utilization of 11-cis-retinal.

Synthesis of sphingosine is essential for oxidative stress-induced apoptosis of photoreceptors

PURPOSE

Oxidative stress is involved in inducing apoptosis of photoreceptors in many retinal neurodegenerative diseases. It has been shown that oxidative stress increases in photoreceptors the synthesis of ceramide, a sphingolipid precursor that then activates apoptosis. In several cell types, ceramide is converted by ceramidases to sphingosine (Sph), another apoptosis mediator; hence, this study was undertaken to determine whether Sph participates in triggering photoreceptor apoptosis.

METHODS

Rat retina neurons were incubated with [(3)H]palmitic acid and treated with the oxidant paraquat (PQ) to evaluate Sph synthesis. Sph was added to cultures with or without docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), the major retina polyunsaturated fatty acid and a photoreceptor survival factor, to evaluate apoptosis. Synthesis of Sph and sphingosine-1-phosphate (S1P), a prosurvival signal, were inhibited with alkaline ceramidase or sphingosine kinase inhibitors, respectively, before adding PQ, C(2)-ceramide, or Sph. Apoptosis, mitochondrial membrane polarization, cytochrome c localization, and reactive oxygen species (ROS) production were determined.

RESULTS

PQ increased [(3)H]Sph synthesis in photoreceptors and blocking this synthesis by inhibiting alkaline ceramidase decreased PQ-induced apoptosis. Addition of Sph induced photoreceptor apoptosis, increased ROS production, and promoted cytochrome c release from mitochondria. Although DHA prevented this apoptosis, inhibiting Sph conversion to S1P blocked DHA protection.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that oxidative stress enhances formation of ceramide and its subsequent breakdown to Sph; ceramide and/or Sph would then trigger photoreceptor apoptosis. Preventing Sph synthesis or promoting its phosphorylation to S1P rescued photoreceptors, suggesting that Sph is a mediator of their apoptosis and modulation of Sph metabolism may be crucial for promoting photoreceptor survival.

Insulin receptor signaling regulates actin cytoskeletal organization in developing photoreceptors

The insulin receptor (IR) and IR signaling proteins are widely distributed throughout the CNS. IR signaling provides a trophic signal for transformed retinal neurons in culture and we recently reported that deletion of IR in rod photoreceptors by Cre/lox system resulted in stress-induced photoreceptor degeneration. These studies suggest a neuroprotective role of IR in rod photoreceptor cell function. However, there are no studies available on the role of insulin-induced IR signaling in the development of normal photoreceptors. To examine the role of insulin-induced IR signaling, we analyzed cultured neuronal cells isolated from newborn rodent retinas. In insulin-lacking cultures, photoreceptors from wild-type rat retinas exhibited an abnormal morphology with a wide axon cone and disorganization of the actin and tubulin cytoskeleton. Photoreceptors from IR knockout mouse retinas also exhibited a similar abnormal morphology. A novel finding in this study was that addition of docosahexaenoic acid, a photoreceptor trophic factor, restored normal axonal outgrowth in insulin-lacking cultures. These data suggest that IR signaling pathways regulate actin and tubulin cytoskeletal organization in photoreceptors; they also imply that insulin and docosahexaenoic acid activate at least partially overlapping signaling pathways that are essential for the development of normal photoreceptors.

Retinal pigment epithelial cells promote spatial reorganization and differentiation of retina photoreceptors

Retina differentiation involves the acquisition of a precise layered arrangement, with RPE cells in the first layer in intimate contact with photoreceptors in the second layer. Here, we developed an in vitro coculture model, to test the hypothesis that RPE cells play a pivotal role in organizing the spatial structure of the retina. We cocultured rat retinal neurons with ARPE-19 epithelial cells under various experimental conditions. Strikingly, when seeded over RPE cells, photoreceptors attached to their apical surfaces and proceeded with their development, including the increased synthesis of rhodopsin. Conversely, when we seeded RPE cells over neurons, the RPE cells rapidly detached photoreceptors from their substrata and positioned themselves underneath, thus restoring the normal in vivo arrangement. Treatment with the metalloproteinase inhibitor TIMP-1 blocked this reorganization, suggesting the involvement of metalloproteinases in this process. Reorganization was highly selective for photoreceptors because 98% of photoreceptors but very few amacrine neurons were found to redistribute on top of RPE cells. Interestingly, RPE cells were much more efficient than other epithelial or nonepithelial cells in promoting this reorganization. RPE cells also promoted the growth of photoreceptor axons away from them. An additional factor that contributed to the distal arrangement of photoreceptor axons was the migration of photoreceptor cell bodies along their own neurites toward the RPE cells. Our results demonstrate that RPE and photoreceptor cells interact in vitro in very specific ways. They also show that in vitro studies may provide important insights into the process of pattern formation in the retina.

Trophic factors and neuronal interactions regulate the cell cycle and Pax6 expression in Müller stem cells

The finding that Müller cells have stem cell properties in the retina has led to the hypothesis that they might be a source for replacing neurons lost in neurodegenerative diseases. However, utilization of Müller cells for regenerative purposes in the mammalian eye still requires identifying those factors that regulate their multipotentiality and proliferation. In addition, because Pax6 expression is indispensable for eye development, its regulation would be required during regeneration. In the present study we investigated the regulation of cell-cycle progression and Pax6 expression in pure Müller glial cell cultures and neuroglial cocultures from rat retinas. At early times in vitro, glial cells showed high expression of Pax6 and of nestin, a stem cell marker, and of markers of cell-cycle progression; expression of these markers decreased during development in parallel with increased glial differentiation. The addition of glial-derived neurotrophic factor, basic fibroblast growth factor, and insulin restored proliferation and also Pax6 and nestin expression in glial cells. Noteworthy, in neuroglial cocultures Müller cells retained Pax6 expression for longer periods, and, in turn, neuronal progenitors preserved their proliferative potential for several days in vitro. This suggests that neuroglial interactions mutually regulate their mitogenic capacity. In addition, in glial secondary cultures incubated with insulin, many neuroblast-like cells expressed the neuronal marker NeuN. Our results suggest that the proliferative capacity and the features of eye stem cells of Müller glial cells are regulated by molecular and cellular factors, which might then provide potential tools for manipulating retinal regeneration.

Lutein and zeaxanthin protect photoreceptors from apoptosis induced by oxidative stress: relation with docosahexaenoic acid

PURPOSE

Oxidative stress has been proposed as a major pathogenic factor in age-related macular degeneration (AMD), the leading cause of vision loss among elderly people of western European ancestry. Lutein (LUT) and zeaxanthin (ZEA), major components in macular pigment, are among the retinal antioxidants. Though xanthophyll intake may reduce the likelihood of having advanced AMD, direct evidence of neuroprotection is lacking. Prior work has shown that docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), the major polyunsaturated fatty acid in the retina, delays apoptosis and promotes differentiation of photoreceptors. This study was conducted to investigate whether LUT, ZEA, and beta-carotene (BC), major dietary carotenoids protect photoreceptors from oxidative stress and whether this protection is synergistic with that of DHA.

METHODS

Pure rat retinal neurons in culture, supplemented with LUT, ZEA, or BC, with or without DHA, were subjected to oxidative stress induced with paraquat and hydrogen peroxide. Apoptosis, preservation of mitochondrial membrane potential, cytochrome c translocation, and opsin expression were evaluated.

RESULTS

Pretreatment with DHA, LUT, ZEA, and BC reduced oxidative stress-induced apoptosis in photoreceptors, preserved mitochondrial potential, and prevented cytochrome c release from mitochondria. ZEA and LUT also enhanced photoreceptor differentiation. In control cultures, photoreceptors failed to grow their characteristic outer segments; addition of DHA, ZEA, or LUT increased opsin expression and promoted the development of outer-segment-like processes.

CONCLUSIONS

These results show for the first time the direct neuroprotection of photoreceptors by xanthophylls and suggest that ZEA and LUT, along with DHA, are important environmental influences that together promote photoreceptor survival and differentiation.

Docosahexaenoic acid prevents apoptosis of retina photoreceptors by activating the ERK/MAPK pathway

Identifying the trophic factors for retina photoreceptors and the intracellular pathways activated to promote cell survival is crucial for treating retina neurodegenerative diseases. Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), the major retinal polyunsaturated fatty acid, prevents photoreceptor apoptosis during early development in vitro, and upon oxidative stress. However, the signaling mechanisms activated by DHA are still unclear. We investigated whether the extracellular signal regulated kinase (ERK)/mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) or the phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase (PI3K) pathway participated in DHA protection. 1,4-Diamino-2,3-dicyano-1,4-bis(2-aminophynyltio) butadiene (U0126), a specific MEK inhibitor, completely blocked the DHA anti-apoptotic effect. DHA rapidly increased ERK phosphorylation in photoreceptors, whereas U0126 blocked this increase. U0126 hindered DHA prevention of mitochondrial depolarization, and blocked the DHA-induced increase in opsin expression. On the contrary, PI3K inhibitors did not diminish the DHA protective effect. DHA promoted the early expression of Bcl-2, decreased Bax expression and reduced caspase-3 activation in photoreceptors. These results suggest that DHA exclusively activates the ERK/MAPK pathway to promote photoreceptor survival during early development in vitro and upon oxidative stress. This leads to the regulation of Bcl-2 and Bax expression, thus preserving mitochondrial membrane potential and inhibiting caspase activation. Hence, DHA, a lipid trophic factor, promotes photoreceptor survival and differentiation by activating the same signaling pathways triggered by peptidic trophic factors.

Docosahexaenoic Acid Promotes Photoreceptor Differentiation without Altering Crx Expression

PURPOSE

The precise molecular cues required for photoreceptor development are still unknown. Pax6 and Crx are essential during early retinal development and for photoreceptor differentiation, respectively. The lipid molecule docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) has also been shown to promote photoreceptor differentiation. Pax6 expression during the early steps in photoreceptor development and whether the mutual contribution of Crx and DHA enhances photoreceptor differentiation were investigated.

METHODS

Neuroblast proliferation, Crx, and Pax6 expression were investigated in rat retinas in vivo and in neuronal cultures with or without DHA. BrdU incorporation, nestin and opsin expression, apical differentiation, and axonal outgrowth were determined by phase microscopy and immunochemistry.

RESULTS

Pax6 expression occurred in all proliferating retinal neuroblasts in vivo; however, after their last mitotic division, photoreceptors stopped expressing Pax6 and started expressing Crx. In vitro, photoreceptor progenitors also showed a switch from Pax6 to Crx expression immediately after they exited the cell cycle and started differentiation. In contrast, those progenitors differentiating into amacrine neurons continued expressing Pax6 and did not express Crx. Most postmitotic photoreceptors expressing Crx showed little axon development and few of them expressed opsin. The addition of DHA dramatically increased differentiation in Crx-positive photoreceptors, enhancing opsin expression, apical differentiation, and axonal outgrowth, without affecting Crx expression.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that Pax6 and Crx expression are mutually exclusive during photoreceptor differentiation. Onset of Crx expression may provide a permissive stage that is essential to initiate photoreceptor differentiation, but additional support of DHA, among other environmental signals, is necessary to accomplish further differentiation.

Protective effect of docosahexaenoic acid on oxidative stress-induced apoptosis of retina photoreceptors

PURPOSE

In a recent study, it was demonstrated that docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) promotes the survival of retinal photoreceptors in vitro, delaying apoptosis. However, lipid enrichment in DHA is known to contribute to retina vulnerability to oxidative stress. In this study, the effect of oxidative damage on rat retina neurons in vitro and whether DHA enhances or diminishes this damage were investigated.

METHODS

Rat retina neurons in 3-day cultures, with or without DHA, were treated with the oxidant paraquat. After 24 hours, apoptosis, mitochondrial membrane integrity, and Bcl-2 and Bax expression were immunocytochemically determined.

RESULTS

Paraquat induced apoptosis in amacrine and photoreceptor neurons, major neuronal types in the culture. Neuronal apoptosis was accompanied by mitochondrial membrane depolarization, an increase in the amount of photoreceptors expressing Bax, and a decrease in those expressing Bcl-2. Addition of DHA reduced photoreceptor apoptosis by almost half, simultaneously preserving their mitochondrial membrane integrity. DHA blocked the paraquat-induced increase in Bax expression and remarkably upregulated Bcl-2 expression. Glia-derived neurotrophic factor, a photoreceptor trophic factor, only slightly increased Bcl-2 expression and did not protect photoreceptors from oxidative damage. Similarly, other fatty acids tested did not prevent photoreceptor apoptosis.

CONCLUSIONS

These results show that oxidative damage induces apoptosis in retinal neurons during their early development in culture and suggest that the loss of mitochondrial membrane integrity is crucial in the apoptotic death of these cells. DHA activates intracellular mechanisms that prevent this loss and by modulating the levels of pro- and antiapoptotic proteins of the Bcl-2 family selectively protect photoreceptors from oxidative stress.

Cell cycle regulation in retinal progenitors by glia-derived neurotrophic factor and docosahexaenoic acid

PURPOSE

A recent study has shown that glia-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) promote the survival and differentiation of retina photoreceptors. The current study was undertaken to investigate whether these molecules participate in cell cycle regulation in retinal progenitors in vitro.

METHODS

Developmental changes in the expression of the stem cell marker nestin and of cell cycle and differentiated neuron markers were analyzed in neuroblasts obtained from 1-day-old rat retinas. The effects of GDNF and DHA on those changes were then determined.

RESULTS

Expression of nestin, found in more than one third of neuroblasts at day 1, rapidly decreased during development, with most neuroblasts acquiring the photoreceptor phenotype. GDNF increased the percentage of photoreceptor progenitors expressing nestin, whereas DHA reduced it, simultaneously enhancing photoreceptor differentiation. Several markers of cell cycle progression indicated that photoreceptor progenitors maintained an active cell cycle during the first 2 days in vitro. GDNF stimulated the cell cycle, increasing the number of dividing cells and generating more photoreceptor progenitors, whereas DHA induced cell cycle exit and photoreceptor differentiation. Analysis of the expression of the cyclin-Cdk inhibitor p27(Kip1) confirmed these results.

CONCLUSIONS

GDNF and DHA acted as molecular cues, counterbalancing the decision of photoreceptors to remain in or exit the cell cycle. The results strongly suggest that both factors participate in determining the number of photoreceptors in vitro, regulating the cell cycle and survival at early and late stages of development, respectively. Hence, GDNF and DHA may coordinately control the histogenesis of photoreceptors in the retina by modulating both neurogenesis and apoptosis.

Effect of GDNF on neuroblast proliferation and photoreceptor survival: additive protection with docosahexaenoic acid

PURPOSE

In a previous study, it was reported that docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) is essential to postpone apoptosis and to promote differentiation of rat retina photoreceptors in vitro. In the current study, the protective effects of GDNF on photoreceptor cells during development in vitro and its action when combined with DHA were investigated.

METHODS

Rat retina neuronal cultures were incubated in a chemically defined medium, either without photoreceptor survival factors or supplemented with GDNF, DHA, or GDNF plus DHA. Evolution of survival, apoptosis, opsin expression, mitochondrial functioning, and cell proliferation were investigated at different times of development in vitro.

RESULTS

Incubation with GDNF selectively increased the number of surviving photoreceptors, reduced their apoptosis, and augmented opsin expression. Proliferative cell nuclei antigen (PCNA) determination and addition of [(3)H]-thymidine or bromodeoxyuridine showed that GDNF promoted neuroblast proliferation during the first hours of development in vitro. The combined addition of GDNF and DHA enhanced opsin expression and photoreceptor survival in an additive manner. The advance of photoreceptor apoptosis in cultures without trophic factors correlated with an increased impairment in mitochondrial functionality. Addition of GDNF and DHA significantly diminished the loss of mitochondrial activity.

CONCLUSIONS

These results show that GDNF stimulated the cell cycle progression, leading to neuroblast proliferation at early stages of development, and delayed the onset of apoptosis later on, improving differentiation and acting as a trophic factor for photoreceptors. The combination of GDNF with DHA had an additive effect both on photoreceptor survival and on opsin expression. Preservation of mitochondrial function may be involved in the antiapoptotic effect of both factors.

Insulin-like growth factor-I is a potential trophic factor for amacrine cells

In this study we show that insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-I selectively promotes survival and differentiation of amacrine neurons. In cultures lacking this factor, an initial degeneration pathway, selectively affecting amacrine neurons, led to no lamellipodia development and little axon outgrowth. Cell lysis initially affected 50% of amacrine neurons; those remaining underwent apoptosis leading to the death of approximately 95% of them by day 10. Apoptosis was preceded by a marked increase in c-Jun expression. Addition of IGF-I or high concentrations (over 1 microM) of either insulin or IGF-II to the cultures prevented the degeneration of amacrine neurons, stimulated their neurite outgrowth, increased phospho-Akt expression and decreased c-Jun expression. The high insulin and IGF-II concentrations required to protect amacrine cells suggest that these neurons depend on IGF-I for their survival, IGF-II and insulin probably acting through IGF-I receptors to mimic IGF-I effects. Inhibition of phosphatidylinositol-3 kinase (PI 3-kinase) with wortmannin blocked insulin-mediated survival. Wortmannin addition had similar effects to IGF-I deprivation: it prevented neurite outgrowth, increased c-Jun expression and induced apoptosis. These results suggest that IGF-I is essential for the survival and differentiation of amacrine neurons, and activation of PI 3-kinase is involved in the intracellular signaling pathways mediating these effects.

Docosahexaenoic acid promotes differentiation of developing photoreceptors in culture

PURPOSE

The purpose of this work was to study the effects of diverse fatty acids on the composition, metabolism, differentiation, and characteristics of opsin expression in retina photoreceptors.

METHODS

Cultures of rat retinal neurons were incubated with or without 22:6 n-3, 22:5 n-3, 20:4 n-6, 18:1 n-9, and 16:0, labeled and unlabeled.

RESULTS

In photoreceptor cells incubated with 22:6 n-3 and 22:5 n-3, the proportions of these fatty acids in phospholipids increased four- to sixfold. The remaining fatty acids did not change lipid acyl chain composition. The labeled fatty acids were all actively esterified in neuronal lipids, particularly in phosphatidylcholine. Addition of unlabeled 22:6 n-3 did not affect the distribution among lipids of the other fatty acids but displaced [3H]20:4 n-6 from phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine. These results suggest that retinal neurons have specific mechanisms for processing fatty acids of different lengths and degrees of unsaturation and that 22:6 n-3 incorporation takes priority. Of all fatty acids, 22:6 n-3 was the most effective in promoting photoreceptor differentiation. In 22:6-sufficient photoreceptors, new apical processes formed, the expression of opsin augmented, and its localization improved, concentrating in the apical processes of the cells.

CONCLUSIONS

The advancement in differentiation selectively elicited by 22:6 correlates with the fact that 22:6 n-3, but none of the other fatty acids, delays significantly the onset of apoptosis in photoreceptors in culture. The synthesis of 22:6-containing phospholipid molecules could be required for the proper localization of opsin. This could contribute to furthering the differentiation of photoreceptors, preventing their apoptosis, and extending their survival.

Selective outgrowth and differential tropism of amacrine and photoreceptor axons to cell targets during early development in vitro

The axonal guidance and outgrowth in retinal neurons were investigated in cultures of pure retinal neurons (control) or in cocultures with heterologous BC3H-1 cells. Under control conditions, only about 10% of retinal neurons developed axons; coculturing with BC3H-1 cells induced early axonal outgrowth and guidance to BC3H-1 cells in most amacrine neurons. Both mechanisms were dependent on laminin and neural cell-adhesion molecules (N-CAMs) released by BC3H-1 cells, because they were prevented by antibodies directed against these molecules. The protein kinase C (PKC) inhibitor, staurosporine, reduced the effect of laminin on amacrine axonal outgrowth, suggesting that this effect was mediated by PKC. The occurrence of structures resembling synaptic boutons and the expression of synaptophysin at the amacrine axon ends of heterologous connections suggested that amacrine axons establish true synaptic contacts rather than simply overlapping with the BC3H-1 cells. In contrast to the heterologous contacts with BC3H-1 cells, the amacrine-amacrine axonal contacts observed in the cocultures were independent of laminin and N-CAM. Axonal outgrowth occurred in about 10% of the photoreceptors and was not affected by BC3H-1 cells or by substratum pretreatment with laminin or N-CAM. These results show that different mechanisms affect axonal outgrowth and guidance in amacrine and photoreceptor neurons in vitro, and they suggest that similar mechanisms could contribute to the development of the scaffold of axon pathways in the retina in vivo.

Apoptosis of retinal photoreceptors during development in vitro: protective effect of docosahexaenoic acid

When rat retinal cells are cultured in a serum-free medium, the photoreceptor cells start dying after 7 days. The addition of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) to the cultures prevents the selective death of photoreceptors. Here it is shown that, unlike other retinal neurons, photoreceptors die through an apoptotic pathway. Hallmarks of apoptosis, such as nuclear fragmentation and condensation and DNA cleavage forming a ladder pattern on an agarose gel, were observed. The timing and high selectivity of the triggering of photoreceptor cell apoptosis suggest the existence of a programmed cell death. Compared with other fatty acids, DHA not only was the most effective in promoting photoreceptor survival, but also the only one to decrease the number of apoptotic nuclei. The results suggest that DHA is important among the factors preventing apoptosis of photoreceptors in the developing retina. A limitation in the availability of this fatty acid might trigger apoptosis as a result of the failure to develop functional photoreceptor outer segments.

Docosahexaenoic acid is required for the survival of rat retinal photoreceptors in vitro

The effect of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) on neuronal survival was studied in cultured cells isolated from newborn rat retina. In vivo, the content of DHA in the retina increased nearly fourfold from days 2 to 12 after birth, whereas in retinal cells in culture it remained constant. Unlike amacrine cells, the photoreceptor cells in control cultures underwent a selective degeneration, starting at day 7, that led to their massive death by day 11. The addition of DHA at day 7 led to its active incorporation by the cultures, increasing from 6 to 21% of total fatty acids in cell lipids, and completely prevented photoreceptor cell death. When other fatty acids were tested, both neuronal fatty acid composition and photoreceptor death were the same as in control cultures. These results indicate that DHA is specifically required for the survival of retinal photoreceptors.

Heterologous retinal cultured neurons and cell adhesion molecules induce clustering of acetylcholine receptors and polynucleation in mouse muscle BC3H-1 clonal cell line

Several features of the clonal cell line BC3H-1 resemble those of embryonic muscle cells at their early stage of development (Patrick et al.: J Biol Chem 252:2143-2153, 1977). Under normal culture conditions, fully differentiated BC3H-1 cells possess a spindle-shaped, muscle-like morphology with a single nucleus. Like embryonic muscle cell counterparts, they neither express the epsilon subunit nor exhibit the clustered organization of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) characteristic of mature myocytes. Instead, AChRs are evenly distributed upon the sarcolemma upon differentiation. Here we report that BC3H-1 cells can be induced to express AChR clusters by co-culturing the cell line with heterologous retinal neurons, which establish contacts with former cells. Clustering was also triggered by pretreating the culture substratum with several cell adhesion molecules. Polynucleation, a phenomenon observed in mature myotubes in vivo, was also observed in BC3H-1 cells under the two sets of experimental conditions. AChR clustering and polynucleation, both characteristic of the mature postsynaptic region, can thus be induced in BC3H-1 cells by at least two quite distinct pathways: neuronal cell contact and/or cell adhesion molecules. It is suggested that heterologous retinal neurons can elicit only an incomplete differentiation of BC3H-1 cells, failing to concentrate the clusters beneath the neuronal endings, and failing to induce expression of the epsilon subunit, characteristic of the mature AChR.

Myogenic differentiation of the muscle clonal cell line BC3H-1 is accompanied by changes in its lipid composition

Phospholipid and neutral lipid composition was studied in the course of myogenic differentiation of the clonal cell line BC3H-1. Total phospholipid content increased during differentiation, predominantly in the major classes of choline and ethanolamine glycerophospholipids. The contents of other lipids, such as triacylglycerols, diminished more than 50% during this period. The content and distribution of fatty acids also underwent marked differentiation-dependent changes. The polyunsaturated (tetrapenta- and hexaenoic) fatty acid species of several phospholipid classes diminished during differentiation, especially those in choline, serine and inositol glycerophospholipids. Most noticeable were the changes in phosphatidylserine; long-chain fatty acids having 20 to 22 carbon atoms and 4 to 6 double bonds decreased from about 30 to about 10 mol%. Although increased levels of saturation in other phospholipid fatty acyl chains appear to accompany the myogenic changes of BC3H-1 cells, some unsaturated fatty acids, such as oleic acid (18:1), increased by as much as 80% during the same period, suggesting the activation of a delta 9 desaturase. Sphingomyelin contained only saturated and monoenoic fatty acids and exhibited a four- to five-fold decrease in its content of monoenoic acyl groups. Diacylglycerols became enriched in arachidonate and docosahexaenoate. The amount of cholesterol and its esters increased slightly during differentiation of BC3H-1 cells. The data show that several metabolic pathways change during myogenic differentiation of the BC3H-1 clonal cell line, particularly de novo biosynthetic pathways, elongation/desaturation reactions, and acyl chain turnover.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Synthesis and secretion of interphotoreceptor retinoid-binding protein (IRBP) by isolated normal and rd mouse retinal photoreceptor neurons in culture

Cultures of dissociated retinal neurons and photoreceptors from homozygous wild-type, heterozygous rd/+ and homozygous rd/rd retinas have been used to investigate the capacity of isolated photoreceptor cells to synthesize and secrete the interphotoreceptor retinoid-binding protein (IRBP). Retinal cells were dissociated on postnatal day 2 and grown in chemically defined medium in the absence of glial and pigmented epithelial cells. Expression of IRBP immunoreactive materials in these cultures was cell type-specific and developmentally regulated. Thus increasing numbers of rod photoreceptor cells showed immunoreactivity during the first week in culture, whereas nonphotoreceptor cell types remained consistently negative. Photoreceptor immunoreactivity could be detected in permeated (detergent-treated) as well as in unpermeated preparations, the latter suggesting that some IRBP is associated with the photoreceptor cell surface. These materials appeared to be loosely bound to the photoreceptors, since they disappeared when the cultures were exposed for 6 hr to IRBP-free medium but not when they were exposed to IRBP-containing medium. IRBP synthesis and secretion could be demonstrated by analyzing either cell extracts or conditioned medium by "slot blot" and Western blot techniques using affinity purified antibodies against bovine IRBP as well as by fluorographic analysis after metabolic labeling of the cultures with 35S-methionine. Comparisons of cultures from the different genotypes showed many similarities, including the abundance of IRBP-immunoreactive photoreceptors in 7 day cultures. However, immunochemical analysis showed lower conditioned medium/cell extract IRBP ratios in rd/rd cultures, an observation consistent with previous reports suggesting that IRBP secretion may be deficient in rd/rd photoreceptor cells.

Differential susceptibility of isolated mouse retinal neurons and photoreceptors to kainic acid toxicity. In vitro studies

Dissociated cultures of mouse retinal neurons and photoreceptors in chemically defined medium were used to investigate the susceptibility of these cells to the neurotoxin kainic acid (KA). Cells isolated from the newborn mouse retina were initially insensitive to this toxin, and the cells that differentiated as rod photoreceptors retained this resistance throughout the culture period. However, amacrine neurons became increasingly sensitive to KA toxicity as they differentiated in culture; after the fifth day in vitro approximately 90% of these cells were killed by KA in a concentration- and time-dependent fashion. The neurons showed pronounced swelling within 10 min of treatment onset, and cell lysis and nuclear fragmentation were evident during the next few hours. KA-induced degeneration of these neurons was corroborated using the amacrine cell-specific monoclonal antibody HPC-1, as well as autoradiographic and biochemical determinations of the high affinity uptake for GABA. This inhibitory neurotransmitter was taken up by amacrine neurons but not by photoreceptor cells, and this uptake was completely abolished in KA-treated cultures. Similar results were obtained with the neuronal enzyme choline acetyltransferase. However, both photoreceptor survival and the expression of photoreceptor markers such as opsin and the retinoid-binding protein interphotoreceptor (IRBP) were similar in KA-treated and control cultures. Similarly, the high affinity uptake of glutamate, an excitatory amino acid which is predominantly taken up by photoreceptors, showed only modest changes in KA-treated cultures.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Development of neonatal mouse retinal neurons and photoreceptors in low density cell culture

We describe here a culture method which allows the growth of dissociated mouse retinal neurons and photoreceptors in chemically defined medium. Neural retinas from 2-day-old C57/BL mice were dissected from other ocular tissues, including the pigment epithelium, and dissociated into a cell suspension after brief trypsination. Most cells attached as single, unaggregated units to substrata pretreated with polyornithine and the neurite-promoting factor (PNPF). The cells were cultured in serum-free, high pyruvate Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium containing chemically defined supplements. Under these conditions, onset of cell process development was rapid, giving rise to extensive neurite networks. Three morphologically distinct cell types were apparent during the first week in vitro. Some cells retained a circular outline and failed to produce processes, while 50-60% of the cells developed as multipolar neurons showing a large cell body and several neurites. Approximately 90% of these cells reacted with an amacrine cell-specific monoclonal antibody. Some 30% of the cultured cells expressed phenotypic properties characteristic of rod photoreceptors, including a small cell body, an apical cilium, a short neurite with a spherule-like terminal body, and immunoreactivity with antibodies against opsin as well as a rod cell-specific monoclonal antibody. No further signs of outer segment differentiation were observed in these cells. Non-neuronal "flat" cells, which represented less than 0.5% of the total cell number, reacted with an antibody against the glial fibrillary acidic protein. The number of neurons and photoreceptors remained relatively stable during the first 4-7 days in vitro. During the second week in culture, however, there was specific degeneration of greater than 90% of the photoreceptor cells, while less than 20% of the multipolar neurons were similarly affected. Consequently, in addition to providing a system for studying the differentiation of retinal neurons and photoreceptors, the specific degeneration of photoreceptors in these mouse retinal cell cultures makes this system ideal for investigating factors influencing photoreceptor survival.

Differential sensitivity of cultured retinal neurons and photoreceptors to herpes simplex infection

Infection of the retina with herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) causes devastating lesions usually leading to blindness. However, the interactions between individual retinal cell types and this virus have not been well characterized, probably because of limitations posed by the complexity of the intact retina. We have now approached this problem through the use of separate, purified populations of isolated chick embryo retinal neurons and photoreceptor cells, of glial cells, and of pigmented epithelial cells. This manuscript deals with the initial part of these studies, aimed at determining the susceptibility of different retinal types to HSV-1 infection. The different cultures were exposed to HSV-1 for 3-48 hr, and cell infection was evaluated by immunocytochemical detection of viral antigens or by autoradiographic study of viral DNA replication. Practically 100% of the retinal glial cells and pigmented epithelial cells appeared susceptible to HSV-1 infection. On the other hand, as many as 70% of the neurons present in glia-free, pigment epithelium-free cultures, also appeared infected after a 24-hr exposure to the virus. Neuronal susceptibility to HSV-1 was already present in early (2-day) cultures, was time- and concentration-dependent, and led to neuronal degeneration after 24-48 hr. Neuronal infection was also corroborated by the detection of viral particles by transmission electron microscopy. Photoreceptor cells were consistently and selectively resistant to HSV-1 infection at all the concentrations and time points investigated. Both immunocytochemical and autoradiographic studies showed similar results. Photoreceptor resistance to HSV-1 appears to be selective, since they could be readily infected with RNA viruses such as vesicular stomatitis virus and influenza virus. These cell culture preparations offer an attractive system for the investigation of cellular mechanisms involved in the differential susceptibility of retinal cells to viral infection. Moreover, they could also help in the screening of treatments potentially capable of preventing and (or) curing HSV-induced retinal infection.

Generation of enriched populations of cultured photoreceptor cells

This laboratory has recently described a monolayer culture system that allows the survival and differentiation of chick embryo retinal neurons and photoreceptors in the absence of contamination by connective tissue, endothelial, glial, or pigmented epithelial cells. The authors report here that the photoreceptor cells can be further purified by exploiting the selective toxicity of kainic acid (KA) and beta-bungarotoxin (BBT), which are known to destroy many retinal neurons without affecting photoreceptors. When added to retinal cultures, both KA and BBT caused developmental stage- and concentration-dependent degeneration without affecting the number or qualitative properties of photoreceptors. Some retinal neurons were already sensitive to KA after only 2 days in vitro, and their number increased as the cultures matured. The maximum effect of KA (a loss of 60% of the neurons) was obtained with an 8-24 hr treatment with 2 mM KA after 6 days in vitro. Neuronal sensitivity to BBT showed a developmental pattern similar to KA. However, maximum neuronal losses produced by BBT were higher (70% of the neurons) and occurred at lower concentrations (1-2 nM). Combined treatments with KA and BBT did not show additive effects or potentiation between toxins. KA- or BBT-induced neuronal degeneration was accompanied by a greater than 90% loss of neuronal markers such as choline acetyltransferase activity or high-affinity GABA uptake. Transmission electron microscopy showed the integrity of photoreceptor cells in KA- and BBT-treated cultures. These results show that both KA and BBT are useful tools for the generation of enriched photoreceptor populations in vitro.