Interlaboratory validation of the ToxTracker assay: An in vitro reporter assay for mechanistic genotoxicity assessment

ToxTracker is a mammalian cell reporter assay that predicts the genotoxic properties of compounds with high accuracy. By evaluating induction of various reporter genes that play a key role in relevant cellular pathways, it provides insight into chemical mode-of-action (MoA), thereby supporting discrimination of direct-acting genotoxicants and cytotoxic chemicals. A comprehensive interlaboratory validation trial was conducted, in which the principles outlined in OECD Guidance Document 34 were followed, with the primary objectives of establishing transferability and reproducibility of the assay and confirming the ability of ToxTracker to correctly classify genotoxic and non-genotoxic compounds. Reproducibility of the assay to predict genotoxic MoA was confirmed across participating laboratories and data were evaluated in terms of concordance with in vivo genotoxicity outcomes. Seven laboratories tested a total of 64 genotoxic and non-genotoxic chemicals that together cover a broad chemical space. The within-laboratory reproducibility (WLR) was up to 98% (73%-98% across participants) and the overall between-laboratory reproducibility (BLR) was 83%. This trial confirmed the accuracy of ToxTracker to predict in vivo genotoxicants with a sensitivity of 84.4% and a specificity of 91.2%. We concluded that ToxTracker is a robust in vitro assay for the accurate prediction of in vivo genotoxicity. Considering ToxTracker's robust standalone accuracy and that it can provide important information on the MoA of chemicals, it is seen as a valuable addition to the regulatory in vitro genotoxicity battery that may even have the potential to replace certain currently used in vitro battery assays.

In silico tools and transcriptomics analyses in the mutagenicity assessment of cosmetic ingredients: a proof-of-principle on how to add weight to the evidence

Prior to the downstream development of chemical substances, including pharmaceuticals and cosmetics, their influence on the genetic apparatus has to be tested. Several in vitro and in vivo assays have been developed to test for genotoxicity. In a first tier, a battery of two to three in vitro tests is recommended to cover mutagenicity, clastogenicity and aneugenicity as main endpoints. This regulatory in vitro test battery is known to have a high sensitivity, which is at the expense of the specificity. The high number of false positive in vitro results leads to excessive in vivo follow-up studies. In the case of cosmetics it may even induce the ban of the particular compound since in Europe the use of experimental animals is no longer allowed for cosmetics. In this article, an alternative approach to derisk a misleading positive Ames test is explored. Hereto we first tested the performance of five existing computational tools to predict the potential mutagenicity of a data set of 132 cosmetic compounds with a known genotoxicity profile. Furthermore, we present, as a proof-of-principle, a strategy in which a combination of computational tools and mechanistic information derived from in vitro transcriptomics analyses is used to derisk a misleading positive Ames test result. Our data shows that this strategy may represent a valuable tool in a weight-of-evidence approach to further evaluate a positive outcome in an Ames test.

Can in vitro mammalian cell genotoxicity test results be used to complement positive results in the Ames test and help predict carcinogenic or in vivo genotoxic activity? I. Reports of individual databases presented at an EURL ECVAM Workshop

Positive results in the Ames test correlate well with carcinogenic potential in rodents. This correlation is not perfect because mutations are only one of many stages in tumour development. Also, situations can be envisaged where the mutagenic response may be specific to the bacteria or the test protocol, e.g., bacterial-specific metabolism, exceeding a detoxification threshold, or the induction of oxidative damage to which bacteria may be more sensitive than mammalian cells in vitro or tissues in vivo. Since most chemicals are also tested for genotoxicity in mammalian cells, the pattern of mammalian cell results may help identify whether Ames-positive results predict carcinogenic or in vivo mutagenic activity. A workshop was therefore organised and sponsored by the EU Reference Laboratory for Alternatives to Animal Testing (EURL ECVAM) to investigate this further. Participants presented results from other genotoxicity tests with Ames-positive compounds. Data came from published, regulatory agency, and industry sources. The question was posed whether negative results in mammalian cell tests were associated with absence of carcinogenic or in vivo genotoxic activity despite a positive Ames test. In the limited time available, the presented data were combined and an initial analysis suggested that the association of negative in vitro mammalian cell test results with lack of in vivo genotoxic or carcinogenic activity could have some significance. Possible reasons why a positive Ames test may not be associated with in vivo activity and what additional investigations/tests might contribute to a more robust evaluation were discussed. Because a considerable overlap was identified among the different databases presented, it was recommended that a consolidated database be built, with overlapping chemicals removed, so that a more robust analysis of the predictive capacity for potential carcinogenic and in vivo genotoxic activity could be derived from the patterns of mammalian cell test results obtained for Ames-positive compounds.

A roadmap for the development of alternative (non-animal) methods for systemic toxicity testing

Systemic toxicity testing forms the cornerstone for the safety evaluation of substances. Pressures to move from traditional animal models to novel technologies arise from various concerns, including: the need to evaluate large numbers of previously untested chemicals and new products (such as nanoparticles or cell therapies), the limited predictivity of traditional tests for human health effects, duration and costs of current approaches, and animal welfare considerations. The latter holds especially true in the context of the scheduled 2013 marketing ban on cosmetic ingredients tested for systemic toxicity. Based on a major analysis of the status of alternative methods (Adler et al., 2011) and its independent review (Hartung et al., 2011), the present report proposes a roadmap for how to overcome the acknowledged scientific gaps for the full replacement of systemic toxicity testing using animals. Five whitepapers were commissioned addressing toxicokinetics, skin sensitization, repeated-dose toxicity, carcinogenicity, and reproductive toxicity testing. An expert workshop of 35 participants from Europe and the US discussed and refined these whitepapers, which were subsequently compiled to form the present report. By prioritizing the many options to move the field forward, the expert group hopes to advance regulatory science.

Application of in vitro cell transformation assays in regulatory toxicology for pharmaceuticals, chemicals, food products and cosmetics

Two year rodent bioassays play a key role in the assessment of carcinogenic potential of chemicals to humans. The seventh amendment to the European Cosmetics Directive will ban in 2013 the marketing of cosmetic and personal care products that contain ingredients that have been tested in animal models. Thus 2-year rodent bioassays will not be available for cosmetics/personal care products. Furthermore, for large testing programs like REACH, in vivo carcinogenicity testing is impractical. Alternative ways to carcinogenicity assessment are urgently required. In terms of standardization and validation, the most advanced in vitro tests for carcinogenicity are the cell transformation assays (CTAs). Although CTAs do not mimic the whole carcinogenesis process in vivo, they represent a valuable support in identifying transforming potential of chemicals. CTAs have been shown to detect genotoxic as well as non-genotoxic carcinogens and are helpful in the determination of thresholds for genotoxic and non-genotoxic carcinogens. The extensive review on CTAs by the OECD (OECD (2007) Environmental Health and Safety Publications, Series on Testing and Assessment, No. 31) and the proven within- and between-laboratories reproducibility of the SHE CTAs justifies broader use of these methods to assess carcinogenic potential of chemicals.

ECVAM prevalidation study on in vitro cell transformation assays: general outline and conclusions of the study

The potential for a compound to induce carcinogenicity is a key consideration when ascertaining hazard and risk assessment of chemicals. Among the in vitro alternatives that have been developed for predicting carcinogenicity, in vitro cell transformation assays (CTAs) have been shown to involve a multistage process that closely models important stages of in vivo carcinogenesis and have the potential to detect both genotoxic and non-genotoxic carcinogens. These assays have been in use for decades and a substantial amount of data demonstrating their performance is available in the literature. However, for the standardised use of these assays for regulatory purposes, a formal evaluation of the assays, in particular focusing on development of standardised transferable protocols and further information on assay reproducibility, was considered important to serve as a basis for the drafting of generally accepted OECD test guidelines. To address this issue, a prevalidation study of the CTAs using the BALB/c 3T3 cell line, SHE cells at pH 6.7, and SHE cells at pH 7.0 was coordinated by the European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM) and focused on issues of standardisation of protocols, test method transferability and within- and between-laboratory reproducibility. The study resulted in the availability of standardised protocols that had undergone prevalidation [1,2]. The results of the ECVAM study demonstrated that for the BALB/c 3T3 method, some modifications to the protocol were needed to obtain reproducible results between laboratories, while the SHE pH 6.7 and the SHE pH 7.0 protocols are transferable between laboratories, and results are reproducible within- and between-laboratories. It is recommended that the BALB/c 3T3 and SHE protocols as instituted in this prevalidation study should be used in future applications of these respective transformation assays. To support their harmonised use and regulatory application, the development of an OECD test guideline for the SHE CTAs, based on the protocol published in this issue, is recommended. The development of an OECD test guideline for the BALB/c 3T3 CTA should likewise be further pursued upon the availability of additional supportive data and improvement of the statistical analysis.

ECVAM prevalidation of three cell transformation assays

A prevalidation study on the cell transformation assays in SHE cells at pH 6.7, SHE cells at pH 7.0 and Balb/c 3T3 cell line was coordinated by ECVAM focussing on issues of standardisation of protocols, within-laboratory reproducibility, test method transferability and between-laboratory reproducibility. The Validation Management Team concluded that standardised protocols are now available that should be the basis for future use. The SHE pH 6.7, and the SHE pH 7.0 protocols and the assays system themselves are transferable between laboratories, and are reproducible within- and between-laboratories. For the Balb/c 3T3 method, some clarifications and modifications to the protocol were needed to obtain reproducible results. Overall, three methods have shown to be valuable to detect rodent carcinogens.

A core in vitro genotoxicity battery comprising the Ames test plus the in vitro micronucleus test is sufficient to detect rodent carcinogens and in vivo genotoxins

In vitro genotoxicity testing needs to include tests in both bacterial and mammalian cells, and be able to detect gene mutations, chromosomal damage and aneuploidy. This may be achieved by a combination of the Ames test (detects gene mutations) and the in vitro micronucleus test (MNvit), since the latter detects both chromosomal aberrations and aneuploidy. In this paper we therefore present an analysis of an existing database of rodent carcinogens and a new database of in vivo genotoxins in terms of the in vitro genotoxicity tests needed to detect their in vivo activity. Published in vitro data from at least one test system (most were from the Ames test) were available for 557 carcinogens and 405 in vivo genotoxins. Because there are fewer publications on the MNvit than for other mammalian cell tests, and because the concordance between the MNvit and the in vitro chromosomal aberration (CAvit) test is so high for clastogenic activity, positive results in the CAvit test were taken as indicative of a positive result in the MNvit where there were no, or only inadequate data for the latter. Also, because Hprt and Tk loci both detect gene-mutation activity, a positive Hprt test was taken as indicative of a mouse-lymphoma Tk assay (MLA)-positive, where there were no data for the latter. Almost all of the 962 rodent carcinogens and in vivo genotoxins were detected by an in vitro battery comprising Ames+MNvit. An additional 11 carcinogens and six in vivo genotoxins would apparently be detected by the MLA, but many of these had not been tested in the MNvit or CAvit tests. Only four chemicals emerge as potentially being more readily detected in MLA than in Ames+MNvit--benzyl acetate, toluene, morphine and thiabendazole--and none of these are convincing cases to argue for the inclusion of the MLA in addition to Ames+MNvit. Thus, there is no convincing evidence that any genotoxic rodent carcinogens or in vivo genotoxins would remain undetected in an in vitro test battery consisting of Ames+MNvit.

Evaluation of the embryotoxic potency of compounds in a newly revised high throughput embryonic stem cell test

The ability of murine-derived embryonic stem cells (D3) to differentiate into cardiomyocytes is the basis of the embryonic stem cell test (EST). With the EST, chemicals and pharmaceuticals can be assessed for their embryotoxic potency early on in the development process. In order to come to a higher throughput EST, a 96-well based method was developed based on low attachment well plates that allow for the formation of embryonic bodies from which the stem cells can differentiate. Twelve test compounds were selected based on their reported in vitro and in vivo embryotoxic potency. In the 96-well based EST, reportedly strong embryotoxic compounds 5-fluorouracil, 6-aminonicotinamide (6AN), methylmercury chloride, and hydroxyurea were correctly ranked with corresponding Relative Embryotoxic Potency values (REP, based on the EC(50) (microM) value of 6AN) of 2.6 +/- 2.9, 1, 2.0 +/- 3.1, and 0.07 +/- 0.05, respectively. Moderately embryotoxic compounds valproic acid, boric acid, methoxyacetic acid, and lithium chloride resulted in a correct ranking with REP values of 0.01 +/- 0.003, 0.001 +/- 0.001, 0.0007 +/- 0.001, and 0.0006 +/- 0.0004, respectively. The included nonembryotoxic compounds Penicillin G, acrylamide, and saccharin did not result in an inhibition of D3 cells to differentiate into cardiomyocytes, other than related to cytotoxicity (REP value of 0.00001). However, diphenhydramine resulted in an inhibitory effect similarly to the strong embryotoxic compound hydroxyurea, with a REP value of 0.40 +/- 0.36. However, further evaluation suggested this was due to direct inhibition of the contractile capacity of the D3 cardiomyocytes, rather than an embryotoxic mechanism. The 96-well based EST is a promising addition to the screening process of newly developed chemicals and pharmaceuticals.

ECVAM retrospective validation of in vitro micronucleus test (MNT)

In the past decade several studies comparing the in vitro chromosome aberration test (CAT) and the in vitro micronucleus test (MNT) were performed. A high correlation was observed in each of the studies (>85%); however, no formal validation for the micronucleus in vitro assay had been carried out. Therefore, a working group was established by the European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM) to perform a retrospective validation of the existing data, in order to evaluate the validity of the in vitro MNT on the basis of the modular validation approach. The primary focus of this retrospective validation was on the evaluation of the potential of the in vitro MNT as alternative to the standard in vitro CAT. The working group evaluated, in a first step, the available published data and came to the conclusion that two studies [German ring trial, von der Hude, W., Kalweit, S., Engelhardt, G. et al. (2000) In-vitro micronucleus assay with Chinese hamster V79 cells: results of a collaborative study with 26 chemicals. Mutat. Res., 468, 137–163, and SFTG International Collaborative Study, Lorge, E., Thybaud, V., Aardema, M., Oliver, J., Wataka, A., Lorenzon, G. and Marzin, D. (2006) SFTG International Collaborative Study on in-vitro micronucleus test I. General conditions and overall conclusions of the study. Mutat. Res., 607, 13–36] met the criteria for a retrospective validation according to the criteria previously defined by the working group. These two studies were evaluated in depth (including the reanalysis of raw data) and provided the information required for assessing the reliability (reproducibility) of the test. For the assessment of the concordance between the in vitro MNT and the in vitro CAT, additional published data were considered. Based on this retrospective validation, the ECVAM Validation Management Team concluded that the in vitro MNT is reliable and relevant and can therefore be used as an alternative method to the in vitro CAT. Following peer review, these conclusions were formally endorsed by the ECVAM Scientific Advisory Committee.

Successful prevalidation of the slug mucosal irritation test to assess the eye irritation potency of chemicals

A previous 'in house' validation study showed that the SMI assay can be used as an alternative to the in vivo Draize eye irritation test. The aim of this multi-centre study with four participating laboratories was to assess the transferability and inter-laboratory variability of the assay using 20 reference chemicals covering the whole irritancy range. The eye irritation potency of the chemicals was assessed by measuring the amount of mucus produced during a 60-min contact period with a 1% dilution, and a second 60-min treatment with a 3.5% dilution. After each contact period the protein release from the mucosal surface was measured. Linear discriminant equations were used to convert the results into the corresponding EU eye irritation categories (NI, R36 and R41). All the non-irritants were predicted correctly by the four laboratories resulting in a 100% specificity. For the R36 compounds a correct classification rate of 89% (VITO) and 100% (SPL, JNJ and UGent) was obtained. The R41 compounds were classified correctly in 78% of the cases for VITO, 89% for SPL and JNJ and 100% for UGent. We can conclude that the SMI assay is a relevant, easily transferable and reproducible alternative to predict the eye irritation potency of chemicals.

How to reduce false positive results when undertaking in vitro genotoxicity testing and thus avoid unnecessary follow-up animal tests: Report of an ECVAM Workshop

Workshop participants agreed that genotoxicity tests in mammalian cells in vitro produce a remarkably high and unacceptable occurrence of irrelevant positive results (e.g. when compared with rodent carcinogenicity). As reported in several recent reviews, the rate of irrelevant positives (i.e. low specificity) for some studies using in vitro methods (when compared to this "gold standard") means that an increased number of test articles are subjected to additional in vivo genotoxicity testing, in many cases before, e.g. the efficacy (in the case of pharmaceuticals) of the compound has been evaluated. If in vitro tests were more predictive for in vivo genotoxicity and carcinogenicity (i.e. fewer false positives) then there would be a significant reduction in the number of animals used. Beyond animal (or human) carcinogenicity as the "gold standard", it is acknowledged that genotoxicity tests provide much information about cellular behaviour, cell division processes and cellular fate to a (geno)toxic insult. Since the disease impact of these effects is seldom known, and a verification of relevant toxicity is normally also the subject of (sub)chronic animal studies, the prediction of in vivo relevant results from in vitro genotoxicity tests is also important for aspects that may not have a direct impact on carcinogenesis as the ultimate endpoint of concern. In order to address the high rate of in vitro false positive results, a 2-day workshop was held at the European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM), Ispra, Italy in April 2006. More than 20 genotoxicity experts from academia, government and industry were invited to review data from the currently available cell systems, to discuss whether there exist cells and test systems that have a reduced tendency to false positive results, to review potential modifications to existing protocols and cell systems that might result in improved specificity, and to review the performance of some new test systems that show promise of improved specificity without sacrificing sensitivity. It was concluded that better guidance on the likely mechanisms resulting in positive results that are not biologically relevant for human health, and how to obtain evidence for those mechanisms, is needed both for practitioners and regulatory reviewers. Participants discussed the fact that cell lines commonly used for genotoxicity testing have a number of deficiencies that may contribute to the high false positive rate. These include, amongst others, lack of normal metabolism leading to reliance on exogenous metabolic activation systems (e.g. Aroclor-induced rat S9), impaired p53 function and altered DNA repair capability. The high concentrations of test chemicals (i.e. 10 mM or 5000 microg/ml, unless precluded by solubility or excessive toxicity) and the high levels of cytotoxicity currently required in mammalian cell genotoxicity tests were discussed as further potential sources of false positive results. Even if the goal is to detect carcinogens with short in vitro tests under more or less acute conditions, it does not seem logical to exceed the capabilities of cellular metabolic turnover, activation and defence processes. The concept of "promiscuous activation" was discussed. For numerous mutagens, the decisive in vivo enzymes are missing in vitro. However, if the substrate concentration is increased sufficiently, some other enzymes (that are unimportant in vivo) may take over the activation-leading to the same or a different active metabolite. Since we often do not use the right enzyme systems for positive controls in vitro, we have to rely on their promiscuous activation, i.e. to use excessive concentrations to get an empirical correlation between genotoxicity and carcinogenicity. A thorough review of published and industry data is urgently needed to determine whether the currently required limit concentration of 10mM or 5000 microg/ml, and high levels of cytotoxicity, are necessary for the detection of in vivo genotoxins and DNA-reactive, mutagenic carcinogens. In addition, various measures of cytotoxicity are currently allowable under OECD test guidelines, but there are few comparative data on whether different measures would result in different maximum concentrations for testing. A detailed comparison of cytotoxicity assessment strategies is needed. An assessment of whether test endpoints can be selected that are not intrinsically associated with cytotoxicity, and therefore are less susceptible to artefacts produced by cytotoxicity, should also be undertaken. There was agreement amongst the workshop participants that cell systems which are p53 and DNA-repair proficient, and have defined Phase 1 and Phase 2 metabolism, covering a broad set of enzyme forms, and used within the context of appropriately set limits of concentration and cytotoxicity, offer the best hope for reduced false positives. Whilst there is some evidence that human lymphocytes are less susceptible to false positives than the current rodent cell lines, other cell systems based on HepG2, TK6 and MCL-5 cells, as well as 3D skin models based on primary human keratinocytes also show some promise. Other human cell lines such as HepaRG, and human stem cells (the target for carcinogenicity) have not been used for genotoxicity investigations and should be considered for evaluation. Genetic engineering is also a valuable tool to incorporate missing enzyme systems into target cells. A collaborative research programme is needed to identify, further develop and evaluate new cell systems with appropriate sensitivity but improved specificity. In order to review current data for selection of appropriate top concentrations, measures and levels of cytotoxicity, metabolism, and to be able to improve existing or validate new assay systems, the participants called for the establishment of an expert group to identify the in vivo genotoxins and DNA-reactive, mutagenic carcinogens that we expect our in vitro genotoxicity assays to detect as well as the non-genotoxins and non-carcinogens we expect them not to detect.

Prevalidation of a new in vitro reconstituted human cornea model to assess the eye irritating potential of chemicals

This multicentre study aimed at evaluating the reliability (reproducibility) and relevance (predictivity) of a new commercially available human corneal epithelial (HCE) model (SkinEthic Laboratories, Nice, France) to assess acute ocular irritation. A prevalidation approach (protocol optimisation, transfer and performance) was followed and at each of the four participating laboratories, 20 coded reference chemicals, covering the whole range of irritancy, were tested. The compounds were applied topically to the HCE cultures and the level of cytotoxicity (tissue viability and histological analysis) was determined. Once a standardised protocol was established, a high level of reproducibility between the laboratories was observed. In order to assess the capability of the HCE model to discriminate between irritants (I) and non-irritants (NI), a classification prediction model (PM) was defined based on a viability cut-off value of 60%. The obtained in vitro classifications were compared with different in vivo classifications (e.g. Globally Harmonised System) which were calculated from individual rabbit data described in the ECETOC data bank. Although an overall concordance of 80% was obtained (sensitivity = 100% and specificity = 56%), the predictivity of the HCE model substantially increased when other sources of in vivo and in vitro data were taken into account.

Flow cytometric analysis of micronucleated reticulocytes: Time- and dose-dependent response of known mutagens in mice, using multiple blood sampling

According to the current Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and International Committee on Harmonization (ICH) guidelines for the mammalian erythrocyte micronucleus (MN) test, analysis of peripheral blood reticulocytes (RETs) for the presence of micronuclei can be performed using flow cytometry. The MicroFlow PLUS method (Litron Laboratories, Rochester, NY) for MN analysis by flow cytometry is based on the binding of FITC-labeled antibodies to the CD71 transferrin receptor of immature RETs, on parallel RNA degradation, and on propidium iodide staining of DNA present as micronuclei. The objective of this study was to assess the sensitivity of this flow cytometry method to detect time- and dose-dependent induction of micronuclei in mouse peripheral blood RETs after treatment with nine chemical agents. Five known clastogens, two known aneugens, and two compounds previously reported to be inactive in the mouse bone marrow MN test were evaluated at three dose levels. Multiple blood sampling of the same animal before and at two time points after treatment was conducted. All known mutagens produced a dose-dependent increase in micronucleated reticulocytes (MN-RETs); the compounds previously shown to be inactive in the in vivo MN test were also negative using the present methodology. The highest frequency of MN-RETs was observed at 48 hr after treatment, except for 5-fluorouracil, which had its peak response at 72 hr. The results indicate that micronuclei can be measured by multiple blood sampling of the same animal before and after treatment without altering the sensitivity of the assay. The results confirm that the flow cytometric assessment of MN-RETs in mouse peripheral blood using MicroFlow PLUS is a sensitive method with high analysis throughput, and robust quality control.

Interlaboratory validation of a CD71-based flow cytometric method (Microflow) for the scoring of micronucleated reticulocytes in mouse peripheral blood

An interlaboratory study was performed to validate an anti-CD71/flow cytometry-based technique for enumerating micronucleated reticulocytes (MN-RETs) in mouse peripheral blood. These experiments were designed to address International Workshop on Genotoxicity Test Procedures validation criteria by evaluating the degree of correspondence between MN-RET measurements generated by flow cytometry (FCM) with those obtained using traditional microscopy-based methods. In addition to these cross-methods data, flow cytometric MN-RET measurements for each blood sample were performed at two separate sites in order to evaluate the reproducibility of data between laboratories. In these studies, groups of male CD-1 mice were treated with vehicle (saline or vegetable oil), a negative control (saline or vegetable oil), or four dose levels of five known genotoxicants (clastogens: cyclophosphamide, benzo[a]pyrene, 5-fluorouracil, methotrexate; aneugen: vincristine sulfate). Exposure occurred on 3 consecutive days via intraperitoneal injection, and blood samples were obtained approximately 24 hr after the final treatment. MN-RET frequencies were determined for each sample based on the analysis of 2,000 (microscopy) and 20,000 (FCM) reticulocytes. Regardless of the method utilized, each genotoxic agent was observed to cause statistically significant increases in the frequency of MN-RETs, and each response occurred in a dose-dependent manner. Spearman's correlation coefficient (rs) for FCM versus microscopy-based MN-RET measurements (nine experiments, 252 paired measurements) was 0.740, indicating a high degree of correspondence between methods. The rs value for all flow cytometric MN-RET measurements performed at the two independent sites was 0.857 (n = 248), suggesting that the automated method is highly transferable between laboratories. Additionally, the flow cytometric system offered advantages relative to microscopy-based scoring, including a greater number of cells analyzed, much faster analysis times, and a greater degree of objectivity. Collectively, data presented in this report suggest that the overall performance of mouse peripheral blood micronucleus tests is enhanced by the use of the flow cytometric scoring procedure.

ECVAM and pharmaceuticals

In the pharmaceutical industry, toxicology testing is normally done by preclinical scientists during the Development phase. In the last decade, the implementation of high-throughput screens during the Discovery phase has resulted in an ever-increasing number of lead candidates to be selected for drug development. The low throughput of the conventional safety tests is a bottleneck in the drug-development process. The pharmaceutical industry needs new techniques, down-scaled tests and in vitro alternative test models to determine the absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion (ADME) and toxicology profiles of compounds in the late-Discovery phase and/or early in the Development phase. Medium-throughput ADME and toxicity tests will enhance the selection of safer new chemical entities for animals and/or humans. Consequently, this testing strategy will not only reduce the use of resources and the overall development time, but will also result in a substantial decrease in animal use.

The mucosal toxicity of different benzalkonium chloride analogues evaluated with an alternative test using slugs

PURPOSE

The objective of this study was to evaluate the mucosal toxicity of different benzalkonium chloride (BAC) analogues using slugs as the alternative test organism.

METHODS

The effect of different BAC analogues on the mucosal tissue of slugs was determined from the protein, lactate dehydrogenase, and alkaline phosphatase released from the foot mucosa after treatment. Additionally, mucus production and reduction in body weight of the slugs were measured. The eye irritation potency of the molecules was evaluated with the Bovine Corneal Opacity and Permeability (BCOP) assay. The antimicrobial activity of the different BAC analogues was also assessed.

RESULTS

All BAC analogues induced severe damage to the mucosal epithelium of the slugs, and the irritation increased with decreasing alkyl chain length: BAC-C16 < BAC-C14 < BAC-C12 approximately BAC-mix. A similar ranking was obtained with the BCOP assay for eye irritation. The relative order of activities among the three BAC analogues was the same, i.e., BAC-C14 > or = BAC-C16 > BAC-C12. The BAC-C14 exhibited higher activity than the BAC-mix.

CONCLUSIONS

The toxicity and activity of BAC analogues depend on the alkyl chain length. The use of BAC-C14 as a conservative agent in pharmaceutical preparations instead of the BAC-mix should be considered.

The in vivo gut micronucleus test detects clastogens and aneugens given by gavage

A general testing battery for pharmaceuticals includes a bacterial gene mutation assay, an in vitro chromosomal aberration or a gene mutation test on mammalian cells and an in vivo test for chromosome/genome mutations. The aim of this study was to determine whether the in vivo mouse gut micronucleus assay could be a more sensitive method to detect direct clastogens and/or aneugens given orally by gavage than the in vivo bone marrow micronucleus assay (which can also detect indirect genotoxins). Two laboratories collaborated in this project, one analysing bone marrow cells and the other analysing gut cells from the same animals. The reference substances tested in this study were colchicine (COL), carbendazim (CAR), tubulazole (TUB) and griseofulvin (GRI), all known aneugens, and 1,2-dimethylhydrazine (DMH), a colon carcinogen with clastogenic activity. For all substances tested, the in vivo gut micronucleus test was as sensitive as or more sensitive than the in vivo bone marrow micronucleus assay: COL and TUB induced micronuclei in both gut and bone marrow cells; DMH, CAR and GRI induced micronuclei only in gut cells. The results show that the micronucleus test on gut cells is able to detect clastogens and aneugens given orally by gavage, some of which were not detected by the bone marrow micronucleus test.

Flow cytometric enumeration of micronucleated reticulocytes: high transferability among 14 laboratories

This laboratory previously described a single-laser flow cytometric method, which effectively resolves micronucleated erythrocyte populations in rodent peripheral blood samples. Even so, the rarity and variable size of micronuclei make it difficult to configure instrument settings consistently and define analysis regions rationally to enumerate the cell populations of interest. Murine erythrocytes from animals infected with the malaria parasite Plasmodium berghei contain a high prevalence of erythrocytes with a uniform DNA content. This biological model for micronucleated erythrocytes offers a means by which the micronucleus analysis regions can be rationally defined, and a means for controlling interexperimental variation. The experiments described herein were performed to extend these studies by testing whether malaria-infected erythrocytes could also be used to enhance the transferability of the method, as well as control intra- and interlaboratory variation. For these studies, blood samples from mice infected with malaria, or treated with vehicle or the clastogen methyl methanesulfonate, were fixed and shipped to collaborating laboratories for analysis. After configuring instrumentation parameters and guiding the position of analysis regions with the malaria-infected blood samples, micronucleated reticulocyte frequencies were measured (20,000 reticulocytes per sample). To evaluate both intra- and interlaboratory variation, five replicates were analyzed per day, and these analyses were repeated on up to five separate days. The data of 14 laboratories presented herein indicate that transferability of this flow cytometric technique is high when instrumentation is guided by the biological standard Plasmodium berghei.

VITOTOX bacterial genotoxicity and toxicity test for the rapid screening of chemicals

The VITOTOX test is a new bacterial genotoxicity test that was previously shown to be very rapid and sensitive. Initially only one Salmonella typhimurium strain (TA104 recN2-4) was used in the test. In this paper we introduce a second strain (TA104pr1) that can be used as an internal control to further enhance the reliability of the test. We demonstrate the usefulness of this pr1 strain in genotoxicity and toxicity testing. We also report on the results of a study where the VITOTOX test was performed on newly synthesized pharmaceutical compounds, or intermediate products in the synthesis of drug candidates. We demonstrate that the test gives identical results when performed independently in two different laboratories and that it correlates well with either the Ames test or SOS chromotest.

Review of alternative methods of carcinogenicity testing and evaluation of human pharmaceuticals

Hundreds of pharmaceuticals have been reported to give a positive result in the standard "Chronic Bioassay", which consists of an 18 to 24 month daily administration of the test compound in mice and rats. This is in contrast with 20 pharmaceuticals, which are known to be carcinogenic to humans. The high incidence of apparently false-positive results in the Chronic Bioassay may be related to differences in mechanism of pharmacological action between rodents and humans, but also to the very high dose levels that have to be administered to rodents in accordance to regulatory guidelines. Lack of relevance to man therefore often has to be demonstrated by additional mechanistic studies. Based upon the deficiencies of the Chronic Bioassay and on the increased knowledge on cellular and molecular mechanisms involved in carcinogenicity, extensive discussions have recently taken place between regulatory agencies and industry associations at the occasion of International Conferences on Harmonization (ICH). These discussions have resulted in the possibility to use alternative short-to-medium-term carcinogenicity models in combination with a single two-year carcinogenicity study for evaluation of carcinogenicity. A description of these models is provided in this review as well as possible strategies for carcinogenicity testing and evaluation in the future.

Sampling times in micronucleus testing

A series of micronucleus inducers were evaluated in the mouse bone marrow micronucleus test to determine if a 72-h sampling time enhances the sensitivity for detecting genotoxic agents. Male and female Swiss albino mice were dosed once with 7,12- dimethylbenz[a]anthracene, 6-mercaptopurine, benzo[a]pyrene, benzene, cyclophosphamide, 2-acetylaminofluorene, tubulazole, or mitomycin C. According to the EEC and OECD guidelines, the mice were killed at 24, 48 and 72 h after dosing. All test compounds induced an increase in the number of micronucleated polychromatic erythrocytes at 24 and/or 48 h. From the results obtained, it was evident that the 72-h sampling time does not enhance the sensitivity of the micronucleus test. The present data show that for screening purposes two sampling times at 24 and 48 h are sufficient to detect clastogens as well as aneugens. Although quantitative differences were found in sensitivity to micronucleus inducers between male and female mice, no qualitative differences were observed between the two sexes.

Discrimination of aneuploidogens from clastogens by C-banding, DNA and area measurements of micronuclei from mouse bone marrow

Micronuclei (MN) obtained from mouse bone marrow cells, in vivo exposed to 3 typical clastogens (procarbazine, azathioprine, ethyl methanesulfonate) and 3 typical aneuploidogens (vinblastine, tubulazole, colchicine), were examined for C-band, area and DNA content. C-banding allows a clear discrimination between clastogens and aneuploidogens: the clastogens do not exceed 50% C-band-positive MN and the aneuploidogens all 3 produce 65-75% C-band-positive MN. Concerning the DNA content the percentages of MN containing more DNA than an average chromosome (chr) are lower than 12% for the clastogens and 38-60% for the aneuploidogens. As far as the area of the MN is concerned the percentages of MN which have a larger area than chr are lower than 23% for the clastogens and range from 47% to 71% for the aneuploidogens. Additionally 3 other mutagens were studied. Hydroquinone induces 43% C-band-positive MN with DNA content far below the content of chr; considering the area measurements, however, hydroquinone behaves as an aneuploidogen (65% of the MN are larger than chr). Mitomycin C lies between the clastogens and the aneuploidogens for all 3 criteria but 5-azacytidine is comparable to the model aneuploidogens.

Micronuclei as an index of cytogenetic damage: past, present, and future

The workshop was designed to present what is known about the production of micronuclei, what protocols are now accepted or proposed internationally, what new results have been obtained, and what new methods and protocols are likely to be forthcoming. This report is designed to convey the flavour of the workshop and to provide the essence of the new information. After the workshop an effort was made to determine what single protocol would satisfy the requirements set for the micronucleus test by as many regulatory agencies as possible. The result, reported here, includes the requirements of six regulatory authorities in Canada, the European Economic Community, the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Japan, and the United States.

Toxicity and mutagenicity of the molluscicidal plant Ambrosia maritima L

The acute and subchronic toxicity of the molluscicidal plant, Ambrosia maritima L., has been tested on rats. No toxic signs could be detected neither after oral administration of 5 g/kg of dried leaves of the plant as a powder or as a methanolic extract, nor after the incorporation of 50,000 ppm powdered leaves in the feed during 4 weeks. Using an aqueous extract of the plant material of A. maritima or using ambrosin, one of the active molluscicidal components of the plant, no mutagenic activity could be detected in the S. typhimurium strains TA97, TA 98, TA1538, TA100 and TA1535.

Safety aspects of oral antifungal agents

Four main targets have to be considered when evaluating the safety of new systemically acting, oral antifungals: the liver, the endocrine system, serum cholesterol and the developing embryo. The major endocrine targets for high levels of the antifungal azoles are the adrenal cortex and the gonads. Endocrine studies demonstrate that itraconazole has little potential for interfering with steroid hormones in man. Available data also indicate that itraconazole has low predictable hepatotoxicity potential in man. In rats, serum cholesterol levels are raised during treatment with itraconazole, especially after chronic exposure. This is, however, a species-specific phenomenon which leads to secondary events at toxic doses, especially in long-term toxicity studies. In man, including patients with existing hypercholesterolaemia, serum cholesterol levels are not raised. Ketoconazole has been shown to be teratogenic at high, toxic doses in pregnant rats. The same observation has been made for itraconazole, and it may also be true for fluconazole. However, all three azoles show no teratogenicity in the rabbit. Studies with itraconazole in adrenalectomised rats and in rats given exogenous arachidonic acid indicate that adrenal effects occurring at toxic dose levels are important mediators of teratogenicity. Since itraconazole does not affect adrenal function at levels used to treat infections in man, the teratogenic risk is estimated to be low. Itraconazole is therefore a promising new drug, especially with regard to the assessment of its safety in the liver and endocrine system. Moreover, it is more potent and has a broader antifungal spectrum than other azole antifungals, and its development is considered to be an important step forward in chemotherapy.

The micronucleus assay as a test for the detection of aneugenic activity

The aim of this work was to determine the usefulness of the micronucleus assay for the detection of aneugenic potential. Chemicals affecting microtubule assembly, i.e., colchicine, vinblastine sulfate and tubulazole, and chemicals affecting targets other than microtubuli, i.e., mitomycin C, cyclophosphamide and miconazole, and the clastogens azathioprine and procarbazine were administered once orally or intraperitoneally to male and female mice. Bone marrow preparations were made at 24, 48 and 72 h after dosing. All the clastogens and aneugens, except miconazole, yielded positive results in the micronucleus test. Measurements of the area of the micronuclei and their distribution clearly showed that the chemicals affecting microtubule assembly produced larger micronuclei than did the clastogens. The pattern of area distribution of the micronuclei found with cyclophosphamide and mitomycin C was between those found for the tubulin inhibitors and the clastogens. These findings indicate that the micronucleus test not only detects chemicals affecting microtubule assembly, but also can discriminate them from clastogens by measurements of the area of the micronuclei.

Toxicological profile and safety evaluation of antifungal azole derivatives

For the development of new systemically acting, oral antifungal azoles, it is of key importance to compare them with ketoconazole, the first available drug in this therapeutic class. Ketoconazole is a major breakthrough although hepatic side-effects as well as interactions with mammalian steroids might rarely occur during prolonged treatment. The prediction of these side-effects is difficult but the potential to interact with mammalian cytochrome P-450 enzymes is considered to be important. Therefore, for the selection of itraconazole a multidisciplinary approach was applied to study this potential. The present paper deals with the toxicological profile of itraconazole and its safety evaluation. In addition, a further comparison with ketoconazole and also with fluconazole is provided, in so far sufficient information is available. For the liver as a potential target organ, the available data indicate that itraconazole is not a predictable hepatotoxic drug in man. The major endocrine targets for overdosing with antifungal azoles are the adrenal cortex and the gonads. Endocrine studies show that itraconazole is not bearing a potential to interfere with steroid hormones in patients, which is a major improvement when compared to ketoconazole. In rats, elevation of serum cholesterol is observed especially after chronic exposure to itraconazole. This species-specific phenomenon leads at toxic dose levels to secondary events, especially in the long-term toxicity studies. In man, including those with existing hypercholesterolemia, serum cholesterol is not adversely affected by itraconazole. In pregnant rats, ketoconazole was shown to be teratogenic at high, toxic doses. The same observation has been made for itraconazole and this also might be true for fluconazole.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The mouse bone marrow micronucleus assay can be used to distinguish aneugens from clastogens

The occurrence of aneuploidy can be measured in several assays. However, none of them have been sufficiently validated. The bone marrow micronucleus test may be considered as a method for aneuploidy detection. In this work, micronuclei were induced by two aneugens, vincristine sulfate (0.1 mg/kg) and nocodazole (80 mg/kg), and two clastogens ethylmethanesulfonate (EMS) (300 mg/kg) and cyclophosphamide (60 mg/kg). Three criteria have been examined in order to distinguish micronuclei induced by aneugens and clastogens: the area of the micronuclei, the percentage of micronuclei with C-band-positive material and the DNA content of the micronuclei. C-band-positive micronuclei were found in 47% of the micronuclei for vincristine sulfate, 58% for nocodazole, 17% for EMS and 20% for cyclophosphamide. Areas of micronuclei showed a significant difference when induced by aneugens or by clastogens. Finally, the DNA content of micronuclei also showed a totally different distribution pattern when comparing the aneugen vincristine sulfate with the clastogen EMS. The three methods analysed could thus all make a difference between micronuclei induced by aneugens and those induced by clastogens.

Mutagenicity evaluation of azaperone in the Salmonella/microsome test

Azaperone was evaluated for its mutagenic potential by the Salmonella/microsome test. No mutagenic activity towards six S. typhimurium strains could be evidenced with azaperone at doses up to 2,000 micrograms/plate, either without or with metabolic activation at usual test conditions. Higher concentrations of liver post-mitochondrial fraction from Aroclor 1254 (ARO)-pretreated rats did not reveal any increase in the number of revertants towards S. typhimurium strains TA1537, TA1538 and TA98. Moreover, a plate-incorporation test with liver post-mitochondrial fractions from mice pretreated with phenobarbital (PB) and a liquid preincubation test with liver post-mitochondrial fractions from rats pretreated with ARO also failed to reveal any mutagenic action of azaperone towards S. typhimurium strain TA98. Thus, none of the tests used provided any indication of azaperone having a mutagenic action.

Mutagenic and leukemogenic activity of haloperidol: a negative study

The mutagenic and leukemogenic potential of haloperidol, a neuroleptic of the butyrophenone class, has been studied in an in vitro Ames Salmonella/microsome test and in an 18-month carcinogenicity study in mice. Three variants of the Salmonella mutation assay were included: the spot test, the standard plate incorporation test and the preincubation test. There was no evidence that haloperidol had any mutagenic activity in any of the Salmonella mutation tests with any of the Salmonella typhimurium tester strains in the presence or absence of Aroclor 1254-induced rat- or mouse-liver S9-mix. In the 18-month study, haloperidol was injected intraperitoneally as a solution (HaldolR) at a dosage of 5 mg/kg daily for 5, 10 and 20 consecutive days in 5-week-old mice. Leucocyte counts at several time points and histopathological tumor evaluation 18 months later did not reveal any leukemogenic or other carcinogenic effect. On the basis of these data, it may be concluded that haloperidol is not mutagenic in Salmonella nor leukemogenic in mice.

In vivo mutagenicity evaluation of domperidone in Drosophila germ cells and rat bone marrow cells

Possible induction of chromosome aberrations and gene mutations by domperidone was studied in vivo respectively by a micronucleus test on female rats and a sex-linked recessive lethal test on Drosophila. In accordance with previous results all these studies revealed negative findings for domperidone so that it can be concluded that domperidone has no potential to induce chromosome aberrations and/or gene mutations.

Toxicological properties of closantel

The acute, subacute and chronic toxicity studies in laboratory animals showed that closantel is a well tolerated substance. At multiples of the clinical dose, overdosing might result in central nervous system effects and death. Repeated oral dosing was without effects up to 40 mg/kg in rats and dogs except for focal swelling of the epididymis in male rats at 40 mg/kg due to formation of spermatic granulomas. In sheep repeated dosing at 10 and 40 mg/kg orally and at 5 and 20 mg/kg intramuscularly every four weeks during 40 weeks demonstrated an acceptable safety margin in this target species. Reproduction studies including a three-generation study in rats showed that fertility was not affected except slightly in male rats at 40 mg/kg whereas an embryotoxic or teratogenic potential in rats and rabbits was absent. Peri- and postnatal parameters in rats were not affected. In target animals, reproduction was extensively studied in bulls, rams and ewes showing no risk of closantel for reproduction parameters. A mutagenic potential was found to be absent in a Salmonella Ames test, a sex-linked recessive lethal test in Drosophila melanogaster and a dominant lethal test in male and female mice. In 400 mice and 400 rats closantel was shown not to be carcinogenic. Tolerance studies in sheep and cattle demonstrated that oral and parenteral clinical doses were very well tolerated and devoid of serious side-effects.

Genetic toxicology in the pharmaceutical industry

The main objective of the pharmaceutical industry is health protection. Drugs not intended for use in life-threatening diseases should be free from toxic effects, but every natural or man-made chemical has potential toxicity depending on the exposure dose. The pharmaceutical industry considers genetic toxicology as a part of overall safety evaluation. No single genetic toxicity test is satisfactory; a battery of test is necessary to cover the whole spectrum of genetic events. Numerous tier approaches have been proposed for mutagenicity testing but from the toxicological viewpoint a phylogenic testing model seems more appropriate than a sequential step model. Evaluation of the mutagenic potential of drugs should rely on in vivo animal models, although for screening purposes and to promote understanding of the mutagenic action, in vitro tests using different systems can be used. Rejection solely on the basis of in vitro tests can lead to the unnecessary loss of a valuable drug. More inexpensive and relatively short tests on non-mammalian and mammalian cells are needed for studying structure-mutagenic activity relationships. For extrapolating to man and in the framework of clinical studies, it might be worthwhile to focus more time on developing inexpensive and simple tests using models directly relevant to man (e.g. human body fluids).

Mutagenicity tests with astemizole in vitro and in vivo

Possible induction of chromosomal aberrations and/or sister chromatid exchanges by astemizole was studied in vitro on human lymphocytes. In vivo chromosomal damage was assessed by a micronucleus test on rats and a dominant lethal test on both male and female mice. All these tests yielded negative results for astemizole so that is can be concluded that astemizole has no potential to induce chromosomal aberrations.