Can knowledgeable experts assess costs and outcomes as if they were ignorant? An experiment within precision medicine evaluation

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the validity of the standard approach in expert judgment for evaluating precision medicines, in which experts are required to estimate outcomes as if they did not have access to diagnostic information, whereas in fact, they do.

METHODS

Fourteen clinicians participated in an expert judgment task to estimate the cost and medical outcomes of the use of exome sequencing in pediatric patients with intractable epilepsy in Thailand. Experts were randomly assigned to either an "unblind" or "blind" group; the former was provided with the exome sequencing results for each patient case prior to the judgment task, whereas the latter was not provided with the exome sequencing results. Both groups were asked to estimate the outcomes for the counterfactual scenario, in which patients had not been tested by exome sequencing.

RESULTS

Our study did not show significant results, possibly due to the small sample size of both participants and case studies.

CONCLUSIONS

A comparison of the unblind and blind approach did not show conclusive evidence that there is a difference in outcomes. However, until further evidence suggests otherwise, we recommend the blind approach as preferable when using expert judgment to evaluate precision medicines because this approach is more representative of the counterfactual scenario than the unblind approach.

Nine patients with KCNQ2-related neonatal seizures and functional studies of two missense variants

Mutations in KCNQ2 encoding for voltage-gated K channel subunits underlying the neuronal M-current have been associated with infantile-onset epileptic disorders. The clinical spectrum ranges from self-limited neonatal seizures to epileptic encephalopathy and delayed development. Mutations in KCNQ2 could be either gain- or loss-of-function which require different therapeutic approaches. To better understand genotype-phenotype correlation, more reports of patients and their mutations with elucidated molecular mechanism are needed. We studied 104 patients with infantile-onset pharmacoresistant epilepsy who underwent exome or genome sequencing. Nine patients with neonatal-onset seizures from unrelated families were found to harbor pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in the KCNQ2 gene. The p.(N258K) was recently reported, and p. (G279D) has never been previously reported. Functional effect of p.(N258K) and p.(G279D) has never been previously studied. The cellular localization study demonstrated that the surface membrane expression of Kv7.2 carrying either variant was decreased. Whole-cell patch-clamp analyses revealed that both variants significantly impaired Kv7.2 M-current amplitude and density, conductance depolarizing shift in voltage dependence of activation, membrane resistance, and membrane time constant (Tau), indicating a loss-of-function in both the homotetrameric and heterotetrameric with Kv7.3 channels. In addition, both variants exerted dominant-negative effects in heterotetrameric with Kv7.3 channels. This study expands the mutational spectrum of KCNQ2- related epilepsy and their functional consequences provide insights into their pathomechanism.

Exome sequencing as first-tier genetic testing in infantile-onset pharmacoresistant epilepsy: diagnostic yield and treatment impact

Pharmacoresistant epilepsy presenting during infancy poses both diagnostic and therapeutic challenges. We aim to identify diagnostic yield and treatment implications of exome sequencing (ES) as first-tier genetic testing for infantile-onset pharmacoresistant epilepsy. From June 2016 to December 2020, we enrolled patients with infantile-onset (age ≤ 12 months) pharmacoresistant epilepsy. 103 unrelated patients underwent ES. Clinical characteristics and changes in management due to the molecular diagnosis were studied. 42% (43/103) had epilepsy onset within the first month of life. After ES as first-tier genetic testing, 62% (64/103) of the cases were solved. Two partially solved cases (2%; 2/103) with heterozygous variants identified in ALDH7A1 known to cause autosomal recessive pyridoxine dependent epilepsy underwent genome sequencing (GS). Two novel large deletions in ALDH7A1 were detected in both cases. ES identified 66 pathogenic and likely pathogenic single nucleotide variants (SNVs) in 27 genes. 19 variants have not been previously reported. GS identified two additional copy number variations (CNVs). The most common disease-causing genes are SCN1A (13%; 13/103) and KCNQ2 (8%; 8/103). Eight percent (8/103) of the patients had treatable disorders and specific treatments were provided resulting in seizure freedom. Pyridoxine dependent epilepsy was the most common treatable epilepsy (6%; 6/103). Furthermore, 35% (36/103) had genetic defects which guided gene-specific treatments. Altogether, the diagnostic yield is 64%. Molecular diagnoses change management in 43% of the cases. This study substantiates the use of next generation sequencing (NGS) as the first-tier genetic investigation in infantile-onset pharmacoresistant epilepsy.

Utilisation of exome sequencing for muscular disorders in Thai paediatric patients: diagnostic yield and mutational spectrum

Muscular dystrophies and congenital myopathies are heterogeneous groups of inherited muscular disorders. An accurate diagnosis is challenging due to their complex clinical presentations and genetic heterogeneity. This study aimed to determine the utilisation of exome sequencing (ES) for Thai paediatric patients with muscular disorders. Of 176 paediatric patients suspected of genetic/inherited myopathies, 133 patients received a molecular diagnosis after performing conventional investigations, single gene testing, and gene panels. The remaining 43 patients from 42 families could be classified into three groups: Group 1, MLPA-negative Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) with 9 patients (9/43; 21%), Group 2, other muscular dystrophies (MD) with 18 patients (18/43; 42%) and Group 3, congenital myopathies (CM) with 16 patients (16/43; 37%). All underwent exome sequencing which could identify pathogenic variants in 8/9 (89%), 14/18 (78%), and 8/16 (50%), for each Group, respectively. Overall, the diagnostic yield of ES was 70% (30/43) and 36 pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants in 14 genes were identified. 18 variants have never been previously reported. Molecular diagnoses provided by ES changed management in 22/30 (73%) of the patients. Our study demonstrates the clinical utility and implications of ES in inherited myopathies.

Neuronal Ceroid Lipofuscinoses Presenting as Rett-like Phenotype: A Two-Case Report From Thailand

BACKGROUND

Neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses (NCLs) (hereafter described as CLN disease) comprise a rare and life-limiting set of genetically inherited neurodegenerative disorders that are characterized by abnormal lysosomal storage. The NCL disorders are, collectively, the most common group of degenerative brain disorders in children.

PATIENT DESCRIPTIONS

We report two cases of CLN disease that were diagnosed and treated at the Department of Pediatrics, Faculty of Medicine Siriraj Hospital, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand. Both cases of CLN disease (CLN1 and CLN6 diagnosed in 2016 and 2017, respectively) profiled in this report presented with clinical features of Rett syndrome. In the first case, a 2-year-old girl presented with Rett-like clinical features, including global developmental regression and hand-wringing action. Single-gene analysis of the MECP2 gene was negative. However, PPT1 gene sequencing revealed a novel homozygous frameshift mutation, c.629_630dupGT (p.Ile211Valfs∗10). In the second case, a 7.5-year-old girl presented with ataxia, progressive myoclonic epilepsy, and Rett-like hand-wringing. A c.794_796delCCT variant in the CLN6 gene was identified by whole-exome sequencing. Fingerprint bodies from electron microscopy of the skin also supported a diagnosis of CLN disease in our second case.

DISCUSSION

Presentation with clinical features of Rett syndrome has only been reported in patients diagnosed with CLN1 and CLN7 disease, and never in those with CLN6.

CONCLUSIONS

Physicians should suspect and investigate for CLN disease in patients with Rett-like phenotype who are negative for MECP2 mutation, especially in patients with visual impairment and early prominent brain atrophy.

Expanding the genotypic spectrum of PYCR2 and a common ancestry in Thai patients with hypomyelinating leukodystrophy 10

PYCR2 pathogenic variants lead to an autosomal recessive hypomyelinating leukodystrophy 10 (HLD10), characterized by global developmental delay, microcephaly, facial dysmorphism, movement disorder, and hypomyelination. This study identified the first two unrelated Thai patients with HLD10. Patient 1 harbored the novel compound heterozygous variants, c.257T>G (p.Val86Gly) and c.400G>A (p.Val134Met), whereas patient 2 possessed the homozygous variant, c.400G>A (p.Val134Met), in PYCR2. Haplotype analysis revealed that the two families' members shared a 2.3 Mb region covering the c.400G>A variant, indicating a common ancestry. The variant was estimated to age 1450 years ago. Since the c.400G>A was detected in three out of four mutant alleles and with a common ancestry, this variant might be common in Thai patients. We also reviewed the phenotype and genotype of all 35 previously reported PYCR2 patients and found that majorities of cases were homozygous with a consanguineous family history, except patient 1 and another reported case who were compound heterozygous. All patients had microcephaly and developmental delay. Hypotonia and peripheral spasticity were common. Hypomyelination or delayed myelination was a typical radiographic feature. Here, we report the first two Thai patients with HLD10 with the novel PYCR2 variants expanding the genotypic spectrum and suggest that the c.400G>A might be a common mutation in Thai patients.

Rapid exome sequencing as the first-tier investigation for diagnosis of acutely and severely ill children and adults in Thailand

The use of rapid DNA sequencing technology in severely ill children in developed countries can accurately identify diagnoses and positively impact patient outcomes. This study sought to evaluate the outcome of Thai children and adults with unknown etiologies of critical illnesses with the deployment of rapid whole exome sequencing (rWES) in Thailand. We recruited 54 unrelated patients from 11 hospitals throughout Thailand. The median age was 3 months (range, 2 days-55 years) including 47 children and 7 adults with 52% males. The median time from obtaining blood samples to issuing the rWES report was 12 days (range, 5-27 days). A molecular diagnosis was established in 25 patients (46%), resulting in a change in clinical management for 24 patients (44%) resulting in improved clinical outcomes in 16 patients (30%). Four out of seven adult patients (57%) received the molecular diagnosis which led to a change in management. The 25 diagnoses comprised 23 different diseases. Of the 34 identified variants, 15 had never been previously reported. This study suggests that use of rWES as a first-tier investigation tool can provide tremendous benefits in critically ill patients with unknown etiology across age groups in Thailand.

Novel de novo mutation substantiates ATP6V0C as a gene causing epilepsy with intellectual disability

BACKGROUND

In approximately half of patients with epilepsy and intellectual disability (ID), the cause is unidentified and could be a mutation in a new disease gene.

PATIENT DESCRIPTION

To determine the discovery of disease-causing mutation in a female patient with epilepsy and ID, we performed trio whole-exome sequencing, reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) followed by Sanger sequencing.

RESULTS

Trio whole-exome sequencing was performed and revealed a novel de novo heterozygous stop-loss c.467A > T (p.*156Leuext*35) mutation in the ATP6V0C gene. Using RNA from leukocytes, RT-PCR followed by Sanger sequencing showed the existence of the mutant RNA, and real-time PCR demonstrated that the patient's ATP6V0C RNA level was approximately half of that in her parents, suggesting haploinsufficiency as a pathomechanism.

CONCLUSION

These findings, along with previous reports of individuals with similar phenotypes and variants in the same gene, substantiate ATP6V0C as a gene causing epilepsy with ID.

A patient with atypical presentation of chronic hepatosteatosis harboring a novel variant in the CPT1A gene

Carnitine palmitoyltransferase 1A (CPT1A) deficiency is a rare disorder of hepatic long-chain fatty acid oxidation. Most patients with CPT1A deficiency present with hypoketotic hypoglycemia and hepatic encephalopathy. We describe an atypical case of an 8-year-old male with CPT1A deficiency presenting with chronic liver steatosis and cirrhosis. He also had a history of developmental delay, autism spectrum disorder, and mild dysmorphic features of unknown cause. His newborn screening test suggested CPT1A deficiency, but confirmatory biochemical testing was not conclusive. The patient never experienced a metabolic crisis. At age six, hepatomegaly was detected. Further investigations showed transaminitis, hepatosteatosis and cirrhosis. Repeat acylcarnitine profile and total/free carnitine were consistent with CPT1A deficiency. The CPTI enzyme activity was 18% of normal on fibroblast enzyme assay. A novel homozygous variant in the CPT1A gene, c.1394G > A (p.Gly465Glu) was identified from whole-exome sequencing. To our knowledge, the patient is the first reported individual with CPT1A deficiency and chronic liver steatosis and fibrosis. Developmental delay and autistic spectrum disorder are not typical features of CPT1A deficiency, given that the patient never experienced any metabolic decompensation.

A case of GABRA5-related developmental and epileptic encephalopathy with response to a combination of antiepileptic drugs and a GABAering agent

BACKGROUND

GABA_A receptors are ligand-gated chloride channels that regulate inhibitory neurotransmission in the central nervous system. Recently, monoallelic de novo mutations in GABRA5 resulting in altered inhibitory synapses were found in three patients with developmental and epileptic encephalopathy. Patient description: We report on a four-year and six-month-old girl with epilepsy and global developmental delay. Serial head growth measurement revealed postnatal onset microcephaly.

RESULTS

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain was normal at the age of eight months and subsequently showed a decrease in white matter volume and thin corpus callosum at the age of 3 years. Using whole-genome sequencing, we identified the fourth patient harboring a de novo missense mutation in GABRA5. Interestingly, the c.880G > C (p.V294F) affects the same position found in two of the three previously reported patients.

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that the nucleotide c.880G is a mutation hotspot. Our patient also demonstrated significant seizure reduction after benzodiazepine. To our knowledge, this is the first case describing the favorable outcome of a GABAergic agent in seizure control for GABRA5-related developmental and epileptic encephalopathy.

Mutational and phenotypic expansion of ATP1A3-related disorders: Report of nine cases

BACKGROUND

Mutations in the ATP1A3 gene are known to be the cause of three distinct neurological syndromes including alternating hemiplegia of childhood (AHC), rapid-onset dystonia parkinsonism (RDP) and cerebellar ataxia, arefexia, pes cavus, optic atrophy and sensorineural hearing impairment (CAPOS). Recent studies have suggested the broader diversity of ATP1A3-related disorders. This study aimed to investigate the clinical spectrum in patients carrying causative mutations within the ATP1A3 gene.

METHOD

The medical histories of nine unrelated patients with diverse phenotypes harboring variants in ATP1A3 were retrospectively analyzed after they were referred to a tertiary epilepsy center in one of the two different health care systems (Germany or Thailand). Clinical features, neurophysiological data, imaging results, genetic characteristics and treatments were reviewed.

RESULTS

Three patients harbor novel mutations in the ATP1A3 gene. Atypical clinical features and imaging findings were observed in two cases, one with hemiplegia-hemiconvulsion-epilepsy syndrome, and the other with neurodegeneration with brain iron accumulation. All nine patients presented with intellectual impairment. Alternating hemiplegia of childhood (AHC) was the most common phenotype (67%). Flunarizine and topiramate led to symptom reduction in 83% and 25% of AHC cases administered, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The present case series expands the clinical and genetic spectrum of ATP1A3-related disorders.