Cost-effectiveness of virtual reality and wet laboratory cataract surgery simulation

PURPOSE

To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of phacoemulsification simulation training in virtual reality simulator and wet laboratory on operating theater performance.

METHODS

Residents were randomized to a combination of virtual reality and wet laboratory phacoemulsification or wet laboratory phacoemulsification. A reference control group consisted of trainees who had wet laboratory training without phacoemulsification. All trainees were assessed on operating theater performance in 3 sequential cataract patients. International Council of Ophthalmology Surgical Competency Assessment Rubric-phacoemulsification (ICO OSCAR phaco) scores by 2 masked independent graders and cost data were used to determine the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). A decision model was constructed to indicate the most cost-effective simulation training strategy based on the willingness to pay (WTP) per ICO OSCAR phaco score gained.

RESULTS

Twenty-two trainees who performed phacoemulsification in 66 patients were analyzed. Trainees who had additional virtual reality simulation achieved higher mean ICO OSCAR phaco scores compared with trainees who had wet laboratory phacoemulsification and control (49.5 ± standard deviation [SD] 9.8 vs 39.0 ± 15.8 vs 32.5 ± 12.1, P < .001). Compared with the control group, ICER per ICO OSCAR phaco of wet laboratory phacoemulsification was $13,473 for capital cost and $2209 for recurring cost. Compared with wet laboratory phacoemulsification, ICER per ICO OSCAR phaco of additional virtual reality simulator training was US $23,778 for capital cost and $1879 for recurring cost. The threshold WTP values per ICO OSCAR phaco score for combined virtual reality simulator and wet laboratory phacoemulsification to be most cost-effective was $22,500 for capital cost and $1850 for recurring cost.

CONCLUSIONS

Combining virtual reality simulator with wet laboratory phacoemulsification training is effective for skills transfer in the operating theater. Despite of the high capital cost of virtual reality simulator, its relatively low recurring cost is more favorable toward cost-effectiveness.

Royal College of Ophthalmologists' National Ophthalmology Database study of cataract surgery: report 6. The impact of EyeSi virtual reality training on complications rates of cataract surgery performed by first and second year trainees

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the impact of EyeSi surgical simulators on posterior capsule rupture (PCR) rates of cataract surgery performed by first and second year trainee surgeons.

DESIGN

A Royal College of Ophthalmologists' National Ophthalmology Database audit study of first and second year surgeons' PCR rates over seven consecutive National Health Service (NHS) years. Participating centres were contacted to ascertain the date when their surgeons had access to an EyeSi machine and whether this was on-site or off-site. Operations were classified as before, after or no access to EyeSi.

SETTING

The study took place in 29 NHS Ophthalmology Units in a secondary care setting.

RESULTS

Two-hundred and sixty five first and second year trainee surgeons performed 17 831 cataract operations. 6919 (38.8%) operations were performed before access to an EyeSi, 8648 (48.5%) after access to an EyeSi and 2264 (12.7%) operations by surgeons with no access to an EyeSi. Overall, there was a 38% reduction in the first and second year surgeon's unadjusted PCR rates from 4.2% in 2009 to 2.6% in 2015 for surgeons with access to an EyeSi, and a 3% reduction from 2.9% to 2.8% for surgeons without access to an EyeSi. The overall first and second year unadjusted PCR rates for before, after and no access to EyeSi were 3.5%, 2.6% and 3.8%, respectively. The decrease in the with-access to an EyeSi group PCR rate was similar for surgeons with access to an EyeSi 'on site' or 'off site'.

CONCLUSIONS

First and second year trainee surgeons' unadjusted PCR rates have decreased since 2009 which has significant benefits for patients undergoing cataract surgery. This 38% reduction in complication rates aligns with the introduction of EyeSi simulator training.

Treatment outcomes for amblyopia using PEDIG amblyopia protocols: a retrospective study of 877 cases

BACKGROUND

The landmark Pediatric Eye Disease Investigators Group (PEDIG) Amblyopia Treatment Studies (ATS) 2A and 2B concluded that 6 hours of occlusion were as efficacious as full-time occlusion in treating severe amblyopia and that 2 hours occlusion were as effective as 6 in treating moderate amblyopia. We present the first retrospective study of real-world outcomes of amblyopia treatment using PEDIG amblyopia protocols in 877 patients treated at a single center.

METHODS

Electronic patient records were reviewed retrospectively to identify children meeting ATS2A (severe amblyopia) and ATS2B (moderate amblyopia) inclusion criteria who presented at the Gloucestershire Eye Unit from 2013 to 2017. Clinical data for each patient were entered during routine clinical care. Severely amblyopic children were prescribed 6 hours occlusion daily, and moderately amblyopic children 2 hours, after 12 weeks refractive adaptation.

RESULTS

A total of 288 children were in the ATS2A group and 589 in the ATS2B group. Of the severely amblyopic eyes, 40% achieved best-corrected visual acuity better than 0.4 logMAR at 32 weeks, increasing to 55% at 48 weeks; of the moderately amblyopic eyes, 71% achieved best-corrected visual acuity better than 0.3 logMAR at 32 weeks. The mean number of lines of visual improvement was 4.2 for severely amblyopic eyes and 2.1 for moderately amblyopic eyes.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the largest reported series of amblyopia treated according to PEDIG protocols. The study population achieved outcomes comparable to those demonstrated by the PEDIG studies. This audit represents a "real-world" benchmark for treatment outcomes in clinical practice.

Ocular presentation of pediatric Miller-Fisher syndrome

The authors describe a case of Miller-Fisher syndrome in a child who presented to the ophthalmology department with bilateral abducens nerve palsies. Miller-Fisher syndrome is an important differential diagnosis in any case of bilateral sixth nerve palsies but should only be definitively diagnosed once tumors, infections, and other neurological diseases have been conclusively ruled out.

Independent sector treatment centres (ISTCS): early experience from an ophthalmology perspective

In 2001, the NHS plan concluded that there was a significant lack of capacity within current NHS structures to deliver adequate volumes of cataract surgery for England and Wales. The initial central 'solution' for this was to invite in overseas surgical teams to existing NHS centres for short-term surgical initiatives. However, with the advent of the Waiting, Booking and Choice Strategy, a target was set for treatment centers (TCs) to be carrying out an additional 250 000 inpatient/day-case episodes, across all specialties, by 2005. This paper outlines how these Ophthalmology TCs were commissioned, and some of the policy and medical agendas that surrounded their evolution. The concept of 'take or pay' contracts, which placed the onus on local Primary Care Trust organisations to provide the promised number of suitable cataract patients for the TCs, and the 'additionality' of medical and nursing staff are discussed. In September 2003, Netcare was awarded the contract to carry out 41 600 cataract procedures over a 5-year period in a mixture of mobile and fixed site units. Netcare's proposed patient care pathways are examined, as is the reality of its interaction with local Ophthalmology Departments and the response of the Royal College of Ophthalmologists to its standards of patient care. Although Netcare TCs may have contributed to reduced waiting times for cataract surgery in some districts, the quality of care provided by the Netcare TCs has yet to be established. There are ongoing concerns about both the continuity of care and the management of postoperative complications, as well as the economics of neighbouring NHS units.

Radiotherapy in thyroid eye disease: the effect on the field of binocular single vision

PURPOSE

Thyroid eye disease (TED) can be a functionally disabling condition if ocular muscle involvement causes diplopia. The extraocular muscle restriction creates a reduced or eccentric field of binocular single vision (BSV). Orbital radiotherapy is now widely used in the treatment of TED, and although it has been reported as improving ocular motility, there have been few quantitative studies of the effect of treatment on ocular motor function.

METHODS

Retrospective case note review of patients undergoing orbital radiotherapy for TED between 1992-1998 identified 79 case records. A total of 27 patients had diplopia in primary position or a significantly reduced binocular field before undergoing radiotherapy. The fields of BSV were analyzed pretreatment and at 3, 12, and 24 months after therapy to assess any improvement in function. We used the field of BSV as an outcome measure because it can be quantified and is a good indicator of functional ability.

RESULTS

None of the 12 patients with double vision in primary position pretreatment regained a central binocular field with radiotherapy alone. Of the 15 patients with a central but reduced binocular field, 8 (53%) remained unchanged with treatment. In 4 patients (26.6%), there was an improvement in the field, while in 3 (20%) the field deteriorated. In all, 12 patients (44%) went on to require strabismus surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Orbital radiotherapy alone is ineffective in treating restrictive thyroid myopathy and improving binocular function.

Rectus muscle trauma complicating sub-Tenon's local anaesthesia

PURPOSE

To describe three cases of rectus muscle trauma in patients undergoing phacoemulsification cataract extraction and intraocular lens implantation under sub-Tenon's local anaesthesia via the inferonasal quadrant.

METHODS

Retrospective review was carried out of 3 cases from 1080 patients who underwent phacoemulsification cataract extraction and intraocular lens implantation under sub-Tenon's local anaesthesia in our unit over a 3 year period up to April 2000.

RESULTS

Two patients complained postoperatively of vertical diplopia and were shown to have restriction of elevation of the eye, which was found at surgical exploration to be due to inferior rectus muscle restriction. One patient had post-operative horizontal diplopia due restriction of abduction and exploration of the medial rectus muscle was planned.

CONCLUSION

Rectus muscle trauma is proposed as a complication of sub-Tenon's local anaesthesia and caution is advised to operators to clearly identify the sub-Tenon's space for injection of local anaesthetic.

Pathogenesis of idiopathic macular holes

An improvement in our understanding of the pathogenesis and natural history of idiopathic macular holes over the last 10 years has led to a more optimistic and interventionist approach to the surgical management of this vitreoretinal disorder. This article reviews the theories postulated for the pathogenesis of this condition and looks at recent work that has investigated the role of the vitreous, internal limiting membrane, and posterior vitreous detachment in the natural history of macular holes.

Screening for cytomegalovirus retinitis in HIV-positive and AIDS patients

The ability of physicians to screen for AIDS-related cytomegalovirus retinitis (CMVR) was studied at a London AIDS centre. Patients had undergone direct ophthalmoscopy as part of their general examination by the physicians and were referred if fundal abnormalities were found, if a focus of extra-ocular CMVR was present or if the patient complained of visual symptoms. The provisional diagnoses of the physicians were compared with the final diagnoses of the ophthalmologists. Of 348 consecutive patients referred for an ophthalmic opinion, the physicians made the correct diagnosis in 69% of those referred with a provisional diagnosis of CMVR, in 66% of those with normal fundi and in 81% of those with toxoplasma chorioretinitis. Those cases of CMVR which were misdiagnosed by the physicians were usually mistaken for other retinal pathology which would warrant a specialist referral. Screening for CMVR in HIV-positive and AIDS patients may safely be undertaken by physicians familiar with the ocular manifestations of HIV-related disease.

Retinal detachment in AIDS-related cytomegalovirus retinitis

Patients with acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) and cytomegalovirus retinitis (CMVR) are surviving longer due to the use of virostatic medicines and improved treatment of opportunistic infections. As a result, retinal detachment is likely to become an increasingly common cause of visual morbidity in these patients. The incidence and outcome of retinal detachment complicating CMVR was studied at two London AIDS centres. Patients with CMVR were identified prospectively and underwent standard treatment. Retinal detachments were diagnosed during regular follow-up. If retinal reattachment surgery was performed, a standard procedure of vitrectomy and silicone oil internal tamponade was employed. Of 147 patients with CMVR, 41 (28%) developed retinal detachments (47 eyes). Forty-three detachments were rhegmatogenous and 4 were exudative. Fifteen eyes of 9 patients with rhegmatogenous detachments underwent retinal reattachment surgery. Of these, visual acuity remained stable or improved in 12 eyes (80%) in the immediate post-operative period. At the last clinic visit, 8 eyes (53%) maintained a visual acuity of 6/60 or better. The visual results of surgery are good in selected patients, bearing in mind the progressive nature of the underlying disease and poor life expectancy.

Quantification of melanin and iron content in uveal malignant melanomas and correlation with magnetic resonance image

Eleven patients with uveal malignant melanomas (MM) were studied by magnetic resonance (MR) imaging before enucleation. The MR appearances varied, but often were different from those previously reported to be characteristic of these tumours. Using an image analyser to assess quantitatively the melanin and iron content of each tumour, a wide range of tumour melanin concentrations was found, but universally low tumour iron concentrations. These values were compared with MR appearances that were quantified and expressed as contrast to noise ratios. The correlation between T1 and T2 shortening and increasing melanin content did not reach statistical significance. There was no correlation between MR appearances and iron content. The theories postulated to explain the diverse MR appearances of uveal MMs are discussed and variations in tumour melanin content and differences in scanner strengths are suggested as the most likely explanations.

Appearances of choroidal osteomas with diagnostic imaging

The diagnostic imaging appearances of three choroidal osteomas (osseous choristomas) are presented. This rare, benign choroidal tumour is being recognized with increasing frequency, and is important to remember in the differential diagnosis of any unusual mass in the ocular fundus lest it be mistaken for a more sinister lesion. All three osteomas were demonstrated by ocular ultrasound (US), fluorescein angiography (FA) and computed tomography (CT) but none by plain radiography. None of the lesions was visible on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI); the reason for this is probably the bony nature of the tumours. The appearances of choroidal osteomas on US, FA, plain radiography and CT are discussed. To our knowledge this is the first report of a series of choroidal osteomas investigated by MR.

Magnetic resonance imaging. Diverse appearances of uveal malignant melanomas

Fifteen patients with uveal malignant melanomas were studied by magnetic resonance imaging. The magnetic resonance imaging appearances varied from those that have been reported previously to be characteristic of these tumors. In our series, malignant melanomas were of high signal on the T1 sequence and of variable but usually also of high signal on the T2 and Short Tau Inversion Recovery (STIR) sequences, a signal combination rarely described before. We postulate that magnetic resonance imaging appearances may be dependent on variations in histologic factors and on the type and field strength of the scanner used. It is widely believed that the paramagnetic melanin in malignant melanomas gives these tumors characteristic magnetic resonance imaging appearances, but our finding of diverse magnetic resonance imaging appearances for proved malignant melanomas suggests that this may not always be the case. We advise caution in diagnosing malignant melanomas from magnetic resonance imaging appearances alone.