[The unusual mobile element Penelope and its behavior in distant Drosophila species]

The retroelement Penelope isolated from Drosophila virilis has a very unusual structure and codes for reverse transcriptase and an endonuclease belonging to the UvrC type. As shown previously, Penelope is a key element in induction of the hybrid dysgenesis syndrome described in D. virilis, which also involves mobilization of several unrelated mobile element families. Here we report a successful introduction of Penelope into the D. melanogaster genome by P element-mediated transformation. In the new host genome, Penelope is actively transcribed producing major transcript which coincides with that detected in dysgenic hybrids of D. virilis. In situ hybridization on D. melanogaster polytene chromosomes and Southern blotting revealed multiple transpositions of Penelope in the transformed D. melanogaster strains. We determined the structure of six Penelope copies inserted into D. melanogaster chromosomes. Some transformed D. melanogaster strains showed dysgenesis effects similar to those observed in hybrids from D. virilis dysgenic crosses.

Phylogeny of the subgenus sophophora (Diptera: drosophilidae) based on combined analysis of nuclear and mitochondrial sequences

Sequences from the nuclear (nu) alcohol dehydrogenase gene, the nu 28S ribosomal RNA locus, and the mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase II gene were used both individually and in combined analyses to infer the phylogeny of the subgenus Sophophora (Diptera: Drosophilidae). We used several optimality criteria, including maximum likelihood, maximum parsimony, and minimum evolution, to analyze these partitions to test the monophyly of the subgenus Sophophora and its four largest species groups, melanogaster, obscura, saltans, and willistoni. Our results suggest that the melanogaster and obscura species groups are each monophyletic and form a closely related clade. The Neotropical clade, containing the saltans and willistoni species groups, is also recovered, as previous studies have suggested. While the saltans species group is strongly supported as monophyletic, the results of several analyses indicate that the willistoni species group may be paraphyletic with respect to the saltans species group.

Drosophila mediopunctata P elements: a new example of horizontal transfer

Sequences homologous to the P element of Drosophila melanogaster were previously identified in Drosophila mediopunctata, a member of the tripunctata group, subgenus Drosophila. We report here that the P element is present in about three to five copies in the D. mediopunctata genome. While one of the insertion sites appears to be fixed, others may be polymorphic, indicating relatively recent P element activity. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that the D. mediopunctata element belongs to the canonical subfamily of P elements and that divergence of the D. mediopunctata element from other members of this subfamily ranges from 2% to 5% at the nucleotide level. This is the first report of a canonical P element outside the subgenus Sophophora. Based primarily on the striking incongruence between P element and host species phylogenies, the presence of a canonical P element in D. mediopunctata is most likely explained by horizontal transfer between species.

[Structure and evolutionary role of the Penelope mobile element in Drosophila species of the virilis group]

The mobile element Penelope is activated and mobilizes several other transposons in dysgenic crosses in Drosophila virilis. Its structure proved to be complex and to vary greatly in all examined species of the virilis group. Phylogenetic analysis of the reverse transcriptase (RT) domain assigned Penelope to a new branch, rather than to any known family, of LTR-lacking retroelements. Amino acid sequence analysis showed that the C-terminal domain of the Penelope polyprotein is an active endonuclease, which is related to intron-encoded endonucleases and to bacterial repair endonuclease UrvC, and may act as an integras. Retroelements coding for a putative endonuclease that differs from typical integrase have thus far not been known. The N-terminal domain of the Penelope polyprotein was shown to contain a protease with significant homology to HIV-1 protease. Phylogenetic analysis divided the Penelope copies from several virilis species into two subfamilies, one including virtually identical full-length copies, and the other comprising highly divergent defective copies. The results suggest both vertical and horizontal transfer of the element. Possibly, Penelope invasion recurred during evolution and contributed to genome rearrangement in the virilis species. Chromosome aberrations detected in D. virilis, which is now being invaded by Penelope, is direct evidence for this assumption.

The structure and evolution of Penelope in the virilis species group of Drosophila: an ancient lineage of retroelements

The Penelope element is the key element responsible for mobilization of other transposable elements in the course of hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila virilis. Penelope has an unusually complex, highly variable organization in all studied species of the virlis group. Thc BRIDGE1 element from the fish Fugu rubripes is homologous to Penelope, and database searches detected additional homologous sequences among Expressed Sequence Tags from the flatworm Schistosoma mansonii and the nematode Ancylostoma caninum. Phylogenetic analysis shows that the reverse transcriptase of the Penelope group does not belong to any of the characterized major retroelement lineages, but apparently represents a novel branch of non-LTR retroelements. Sequence profile analysis results in the prediction that the C-terminal domain of the Penelope polyprotein is an active endonuclease related to intron-encoded endonucleases and the bacterial repair endonuclease UvrC, which could function as an integrase. No retroelements containing a predicted endonuclease of this family have been described previously. Phylogenetic analysis of Penelope copies isolated from several species of the virilis group reveals two subfamilies of Penelope elements, one of which includes full-length copies whose nucleotide sequences are almost identical, whereas the other one consists of highly diverged defective copies. Phylogenetic analysis of Penelope suggests both vertical transmission of the element and probable horizontal transfers. These findings support the notion that Penelope invasions occurred repeatedly in the evolution of the virilis group.

Invasion of Drosophila virilis by the Penelope transposable element

The Penelope family of transposable elements (TEs) is broadly distributed in most species of the virilis species group of Drosophila. This element plays a pivotal role in hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila virilis, in which at least four additional TE families are also activated. Here we present evidence that the Penelope family of elements has recently invaded D. virilis. This evidence includes: (1) a patchy geographical distribution, (2) genomic locations mainly restricted to euchromatic chromosome arms in various geographical strains, and (3) a high level of nucleotide similarity among members of the family. Two samples from a Tashkent (Middle Asia) population of D. virilis provide further support for the invasion hypothesis. The 1968 Tashkent strain is free of Penelope sequences, but all individuals collected from a 1997 population carry at least five Penelope copies. Furthermore, a second TE, Ulysses, has amplified and spread in this population. These results provide evidence for the Penelope invasion of a D. virilis natural population and the mobilization of unrelated resident transposons following the invasion.

Perspective: transposable elements, parasitic DNA, and genome evolution

The nature of the role played by mobile elements in host genome evolution is reassessed considering numerous recent developments in many areas of biology. It is argued that easy popular appellations such as "selfish DNA" and "junk DNA" may be either inaccurate or misleading and that a more enlightened view of the transposable element-host relationship encompasses a continuum from extreme parasitism to mutualism. Transposable elements are potent, broad spectrum, endogenous mutators that are subject to the influence of chance as well as selection at several levels of biological organization. Of particular interest are transposable element traits that early evolve neutrally at the host level but at a later stage of evolution are co-opted for new host functions.

Mobile elements and chromosomal evolution in the virilis group of Drosophila

Species of the virilis group of Drosophila differ by multiple inversions and chromosome fusions that probably accompanied, or led to, speciation. Drosophila virilis has the primitive karyotype for the group, and natural populations are exceptional in having no chromosomal polymorphisms. We report that the genomic locations of Penelope and Ulysses transposons are nonrandomly distributed in 12 strains of D. virilis. Furthermore, Penelope and Ulysses insertion sites in D. virilis show a statistically significant association with the breakpoints of inversions found in other species of the virilis group. Sixteen newly induced chromosomal rearrangements were isolated from the progeny of D. virilis hybrid dysgenic crosses, including 12 inversions, 2 translocations, and 2 deletions. Penelope and Ulysses were associated with the breakpoints of over half of these new rearrangements. Many rearrangement breakpoints also coincide with the chromosomal locations of Penelope and Ulysses insertions in the parental strains and with breakpoints of inversions previously established for other species of the group. Analysis of homologous sequences from D. virilis and Drosophila lummei indicated that Penelope insertion sites were closely, but not identically, located at the nucleotide sequence level. Overall, these results indicate that Penelope and Ulysses insert in a limited number of genomic locations and are consistent with the possibility that these elements play an important role in the evolution of the virilis species group.

Horizontal transfer and selection in the evolution of P elements

The roles of selection and horizontal transfer in the evolution of the canonical subfamily of P: elements were studied in the saltans and willistoni species groups of the genus Drosophila (subgenus Sophophora). We estimate that the common ancestor of the canonical P: subfamily dates back 2-3 Myr at the most, despite the much older age (more than 40 Myr) of the P: family as a whole. The evolution of the canonical P: subfamily is characterized by weak selection at nonsynonymous sites. These sites have evolved at three quarters the rate of synonymous sites, in which no selective constraints were detected. Their recent horizontal transfer best explains the high degree of similarity among canonical P: elements from the saltans and willistoni species groups. These results are consistent with a model of P:-element evolution in which selective constraints are imposed at the time of horizontal transfer. Furthermore, it is estimated that the spread and diversification of the canonical subfamily involved a minimum of 11 horizontal transfer events among the 18 species surveyed within the past 3 Myr. The presence of multiple P: subfamilies in the saltans and willistoni species groups is likely to be the result of multiple invasions that have previously swept through these taxa in a succession of horizontal transfer events. These results suggest that horizontal transfer among eukaryotes might be more common than anticipated.

How valuable are model organisms for transposable element studies?

Model organisms have proved to be highly informative for many types of genetic studies involving 'conventional' genes. The results have often been successfully generalized to other closely related organisms and also, perhaps surprisingly frequently, to more distantly related organisms. Because of the wealth of previous knowledge and their availability and convenience, model organisms were often the species of choice for many of the earlier studies of transposable elements. The question arises whether the results of genetic studies of transposable elements in model organisms can be extrapolated in the same ways as those of conventional genes? A number of observations suggest that special care needs to be taken in generalizing the results from model organisms to other species. A hallmark of many transposable elements is their ability to amplify rapidly in species genomes. Rapid spread of a newly invaded element throughout a species range has also been demonstrated. The types and genomic copy numbers of transposable elements have been shown to differ greatly between some closely related species. Horizontal transfer of transposable elements appears to be more frequent than for nonmobile genes. Furthermore, the population structure of some model organisms has been subject to drastic recent changes that may have some bearing on their transposable element genomic complements. In order to initiate discussion of this question, several case studies of transposable elements in well-studied Drosophila species are presented.

Distribution and evolution of mobile elements in the virilis species group of Drosophila

The distributions of Penelope and Ulysses, two transposable elements that can induce hybrid dysgenesis, were studied in several species groups of Drosophila. No significant hybridization to Penelope and Ulysses probes was detected by Southern blot analyses of species outside the virilis group. In contrast, both element families have had a long residence in all species of the virilis species group, as indicated by their strong presence in the heterochromatic chromocenter. Except for D. kanekoi, D. lummei, and some strains of D. virilis, species of the group carry full-sized, and at least potentially functional, copies of both element families. Consistent with the occurrence of recent transposition, Penelope and Ulysses elements are located at different chromosomal sites in different geographical strains of the same species. A total of 79 Penelope and 47 Ulysses euchromatic insertion sites were localized to chromosomal subsections in species of the virilis group. Highly significant deviations from independence of the distributions of Penelope and Ulysses and previously established inversion breakpoints were documented, suggesting that these transposable elements may have played an important role in genomic reorganization and evolution of the virilis species group, which is especially rich in karyotypic variation.

A P element-homologous sequence in the house fly, Musca domestica

Sequences homologous to the P transposable element have been identified in Musca domestica. Sequence analysis of a genomic clone (Md-P1) indicates that, although the house fly P element has lost its coding capacity, the basic general structure of drosophilid P elements is present. The house fly P element sequence shares a number of structural features with that from the blow fly, Lucilia cuprina, including a large intron separating exons 1 and 2, two additional introns interrupting exon 2 and the apparent absence of inverted repeat termini. Within a relatively well-conserved central region, the house fly sequence shows 59% similarity to the D. melanogaster P element, but distal regions are more diverged. Southern blot analysis of several strains indicated the presence of at least four P element copies.

Molecular evolution of P transposable elements in the Genus drosophila. II. The obscura species group

A phylogenetic analysis of P transposable elements in the Drosophila obscura species group is described. Multiple P sequences from each of 10 species were obtained using PCR primers that flank a conserved region of exon 2 of the transposase gene. In general, the P element phylogeny is congruent with the species phylogeny, indicating that the dominant mode of transmission has been vertical, from generation to generation. One manifestation of this is the distinction of P elements from the Old World obscura and subobscura subgroups from those of the New World affinis subgroup. However, the overall distribution of elements within the obscura species group is not congruent with the phylogenetic relationships of the species themselves. There are at least four distinct subfamilies of P elements, which differ in sequence from each other by as much as 34%, and some individual species carry sequences belonging to different subfamilies. P sequences from D. bifasciata are particularly interesting. These sequences belong to two subfamilies and both are distinct from all other P elements identified in this survey. Several mechanisms are postulated to be involved in determining phylogenetic relationships among P elements in the obscura group. In addition to vertical transmission, these include retention of ancestral polymorphisms and horizontal transfer by an unknown mating-independent mechanism.

Molecular evolution of P transposable elements in the genus Drosophila. III. The melanogaster species group

Phylogenetic relationships were determined for 76 partial P-element sequences from 14 species of the melanogaster species group within the Drosophila subgenus Sophophora. These results are examined in the context of the phylogeny of the species from which the sequences were isolated. Sequences from the P-element family fall into distinct subfamilies, or clades, which are often characteristic for particular species subgroups. When examined locally among closely related species, the evolution of P elements is characterized by vertical transmission, whereby the P-element phylogeny traces the species phylogeny. On a broader scale, however, the P-element phylogeny is not congruent with the species phylogeny. One feature of P-element evolution in the melanogaster group is the presence of more than one P-element subfamily, differing by as much as 36%, in the genomes of some species. Thus, P elements from several individual species are not monophyletic, and a likely explanation for the incongruence between P-element and species phylogenies is provided by the comparison of paralogous sequences. In certain instances, horizontal transfer seems to be a valid alternative explanation for lack of congruence between species and P-element phylogenies. The canonical P-element subfamily, which represents the active, autonomous transposable element, is restricted to D. melanogaster. Thus, its origin clearly lies outside of the melanogaster species group, consistent with the earlier conclusion of recent horizontal transfer.

Phylogeny of the Drosophila saltans species group based on combined analysis of nuclear and mitochondrial DNA sequences

Nucleotide sequences from two nuclear loci, alcohol dehydrogenase and internal transcribed spacer-1 of the nuclear ribosomal DNA repeats, and two mitochondrial genes, cytochrome oxidase I and cytochrome oxidase II, were determined from nine species in the Drosophila saltans species group. The partition homogeneity test and partitioned Bremer support were used to measure incongruence between phylogenetic hypotheses generated from individual partitions. Individual loci were generally congruent with each other and consistent with the previously proposed morphological hypothesis, although they differed in level of resolution. Since extreme conflict between partitions did not exist, the data were combined and analyzed simultaneously. The total evidence method gave a more resolved and highly supported phylogeny, as indicated by bootstrap proportions and decay indices, than did any of the individual analyses. The cordata and elliptica subgroups, considered to have diverged early in the history of the D. saltans group, were sister taxa to the remainder of the saltans group. The sturtevanti subgroup, represented by D. milleri and D. sturtevanti, occupies an intermediate position in this phylogeny. The saltans and parasaltans subgroups are sister clades and occupy the most recently derived portion of the phylogeny. As with previous morphological studies, phylogenetic relationships within the saltans subgroup were not satisfactorily resolved by the molecular data.

Testing transposable elements as genetic drive mechanisms using Drosophila P element constructs as a model system

The use of transposable elements (TEs) as genetic drive mechanisms was explored using Drosophila melanogaster as a model system. Alternative strategies, employing autonomous and nonautonomous P element constructs were compared for their efficiency in driving the ry+ allele into populations homozygous for a ry- allele at the genomic rosy locus. Transformed flies were introduced at 1%, 5%, and 10% starting frequencies to establish a series of populations that were monitored over the course of 40 generations, using both phenotypic and molecular assays. The transposon-borne ry+ marker allele spread rapidly in almost all populations when introduced at 5% and 10% seed frequencies, but 1% introductions frequently failed to become established. A similar initial rapid increase in frequency of the ry+ transposon occurred in several control populations lacking a source of transposase. Constructs carrying ry+ markers also increased to moderate frequencies in the absence of selection on the marker. The results of Southern and in situ hybridization studies indicated a strong inverse relationship between the degree of conservation of construct integrity and transposition frequency. These finding have relevance to possible future applications of transposons as genetic drive mechanisms.

A phylogenetic perspective on P transposable element evolution in Drosophila

The P element, originally described in Drosophila melanogaster, is one of the best-studied eukaryotic transposable elements. In an attempt to understand the evolutionary dynamics of the P element family, an extensive phylogenetic analysis of 239 partial P element sequences has been completed. These sequences were obtained from 40 species in the Drosophila subgenus Sophophora. The phylogeny of the P element family is examined in the context of a phylogeny of the species in which these elements are found. An interesting feature of many of the species examined is the coexistence in the same genome of P sequences belonging to two or more divergent subfamilies. In general, P elements in Drosophila have been transmitted vertically from generation to generation over evolutionary time. However, four unequivocal cases of horizontal transfer, in which the element was transferred between species, have been identified. In addition, the P element phylogeny is best explained in numerous instances by horizontal transfer at various times in the past. These observations suggest that, as with some other transposable elements, horizontal transfer may play an important role in the maintenance of P elements in natural populations.

Transposable elements as sources of variation in animals and plants

A tremendous wealth of data is accumulating on the variety and distribution of transposable elements (TEs) in natural populations. There is little doubt that TEs provide new genetic variation on a scale, and with a degree of sophistication, previously unimagined. There are many examples of mutations and other types of genetic variation associated with the activity of mobile elements. Mutant phenotypes range from subtle changes in tissue specificity to dramatic alterations in the development and organization of tissues and organs. Such changes can occur because of insertions in coding regions, but the more sophisticated TE-mediated changes are more often the result of insertions into 5' flanking regions and introns. Here, TE-induced variation is viewed from three evolutionary perspectives that are not mutually exclusive. First, variation resulting from the intrinsic parasitic nature of TE activity is examined. Second, we describe possible coadaptations between elements and their hosts that appear to have evolved because of selection to reduce the deleterious effects of new insertions on host fitness. Finally, some possible cases are explored in which the capacity of TEs to generate variation has been exploited by their hosts. The number of well documented cases in which element sequences appear to confer useful traits on the host, although small, is growing rapidly.

Molecular evolution of P transposable elements in the genus Drosophila. I. The saltans and willistoni species groups

A phylogenetic survey using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) has identified four major P element subfamilies in the saltans and willistoni species groups of Drosophila. One subfamily, containing about half of the sequences studied, consists of elements that are very similar to the canonical (and active) P element from D. melanogaster. Within this subfamily, nucleotide sequence differentiation among different copies from the same species and among elements from different species is relatively low. This observation suggests that the canonical elements are relatively recent additions to the genome or, less likely, are evolving slowly relative to the other subfamilies. Elements belonging to the three noncanonical lineages are distinct from the canonical elements and from one another. Furthermore, there is considerably more sequence variation, on the average, within the noncanonical subfamilies compared to the canonical elements. Horizontal transfer and the coexistence of multiple, independently evolving element subfamilies in the same genome may explain the distribution of P elements in the saltans and willistoni species groups. Such explanations are not mutually exclusive, and each may be involved to varying degrees in the maintenance of P elements in natural populations of Drosophila.

The Wilhelmine E. Key 1991 Invitational Lecture. The evolutionary history of the P family of transposable elements

Similar to other transposable genetic elements, P elements occasionally exhibit non-Mendelian inheritance because of their ability to move, from one genomic site in their host species to another, during certain phases of their life cycle. The biological range of this capacity for transposition is almost always restricted to new sites within the same nuclear genome, but exceptionally it appears that interspecific horizontal transfer of P elements can occur. Although the P family appears to have had an ancient origin, its present natural distribution appears to be patchy and phylogenetically restricted to a limited number of Dipteran species. The most likely explanation of the observed restriction is the requirement of transposition for a host-encoded factor whose range is itself similarly restricted. Occasional horizontal transfer of P elements into a new host species, together with the normal mode of vertical transfer, may be the mechanism that ensures the survival of this, and other transposable element families, over long periods of evolutionary time.

Differences in P element population dynamics between the sibling species Drosophila melanogaster and Drosophila simulans

Patterns of P element establishment and evolution were compared in populations of D. melanogaster and D. simulans. For each species, mixed populations were initiated with M strain flies lacking P elements together with P strain flies having similar P element copy numbers and phenotypes. The mixed populations were subsequently maintained under similar environmental conditions. On the basis of gonadal sterility assays, P elements tended to be significantly more active in D. melanogaster than in D. simulans populations. This activity difference between the two species was positively associated with P element copy number, determined by restriction enzyme analysis, and transposition frequency, as determined by a transposition assay. Host factors are the most likely explanation for the observed species variation. Difficulty of establishment may be a factor determining the absence of P elements in natural populations of D. simulans.

Phylogenetic analysis supports horizontal transfer of P transposable elements

Nucleotide sequence comparisons were used to investigate the evolution of P transposable elements and the possibility that horizontal transfer has played a role in their occurrence in natural populations of Drosophila and other Diptera. The phylogeny of P elements was examined using published sequences from eight dipteran taxa and a new, partial sequence from Scaptomyza elmoi. The results from a number of different analyses are highly consistent and reveal a P-element phylogeny that contradicts the phylogeny of the species. At least three instances of horizontal transfer are necessary to explain this incongruence, but other explanations cannot be ruled out at this time.

Transposable elements as population drive mechanisms: specification of critical parameter values

With a view to the possible use of transposable elements (TEs) as a mechanism to drive genes into insect vector populations, we used a three-parameter density dependent growth equation to examine the critical parameter values that determine whether or not a mobile element will spread and become fixed in a finite diploid vector population. Populations were simulated with parameter values affecting size, reproductive rate, density-dependence, and transposition efficiency of the mobile element. Simulations indicated that an equilibrium was reached quickly, typically in < 50 generations. Even when initially present at < or = 1% of a large population, the mobile element spread quickly and became fixed if transposition efficiency was equal to unity and infertility caused by the element decreased reproductive capacity by as much as 45%. These results were insensitive to the values of basic wild type reproductive rates and density dependence, but population size, transposition efficiency of the element, reproductive rate individuals bearing TEs and initial ratio of TE-bearing to wild individuals modified the outcome. As population size and transposition efficiency decreased in value, TEs became fixed less easily. However, even in populations as small as n = 100, an element with a transposition efficiency > 0.75 that reduces fertility < 25% will become fixed when introduced at a frequency as low as 1% of the total population. These results are consistent with previously reported population genetics models. They suggest that engineered transposons with a wide range of properties may be used to drive genes, such as those for parasite resistance, into wild vector populations.

Lateral transfer in natural populations of eukaryotes

Although there are several likely instances of trans-kingdom lateral transfer of genomic sequences involving eukaryotes and prokaryotes, almost all well-documented cases of eukaryote to eukaryote transfer seem to involve mobile elements or other parasitic sequences. Consistent with general observations of phylogenetic regularity, the limited molecular evidence suggests that lateral transfer of eukaryotic genomic sequences is at best very rare. However, due to limited data, the possibility of rare transfers that could have considerable evolutionary significance cannot be ruled out. A possible propensity for lateral transfer by mobile elements may reflect their innate capacity for genomic wandering. In addition, occasional cross-species mobility may play a critical role in the long-term evolutionary survival of these elements and have been subject to natural selection. Much work is needed to fully understand the dynamics of TEs and other multigene families. Problems of paralogy, recombination, and variation in evolutionary rates currently present important difficulties in distinguishing conclusively between occasional lateral transfer and strictly vertical transfer. The importance of lateral transfers for host organisms must await answers to more general questions about the long-term evolutionary significance of mobile elements and the extent to which they can act as vectors for host genomic sequences.

Transposable elements in commercially useful insects: I. Southern hybridization study of silkworms and honeybees using Drosophila probes

As a first step in surveying transposable elements in silkworms and honeybees, hybridization analyses were carried out using 16 known families of Drosophila transposable elements as probes. jockey and G were the only transposable elements that hybridized with genomic DNA of either honeybees or silkworms under the conditions of this study. jockey hybridized with genomic DNA of both European honeybees (Apis mellifera) and silkworms (Bombyx mori and Antheraea yamamai) and showed significant bands in Southern blots. Banding patterns were highly polymorphic. jockey did not, however, hybridize with any strains of the Asian honeybee (A. cerana). G elements showed a faint signal with the Asian honeybee, but not with any other insects tested. The results suggest that, even though it has some limitations, this approach can be used in practice as a first preliminary step in surveys for the presence of transposable elements in organisms which do not have good genetic information.

Horizontal transfer

Eukaryotic transposable elements provide some of the best documented examples of the occasional horizontal transfer of DNA sequences between both closely and distantly related species. Although the mechanisms involved in such a transfer remain a puzzle, new ideas are beginning to emerge. The rapidly expanding number of reports of transposable elements that may have been transferred horizontally raises questions both about whether these elements are more prone to this mode of transfer than non-mobile genes, and about the possible evolutionary significance if such a difference is real.

Can transposable elements be used to drive disease refractoriness genes into vector populations?

A number of biological procedures are currently being considered as alternatives to insecticide-based methods for the control of insect vectors of disease. Among these are the adaptation of various genetic mechanisms to drive genes of interest, such as refractoriness to malaria in mosquitoes, into natural populations, for vector control purposes. Here, Margaret Kidwell and Jose Ribeiro develop a rationale for the possible use of transposable genetic elements, one of these potential drive mechanisms, and some of the problems being faced in seeking to determine the feasibility of such a strategy are described.

Distribution of Drosophila melanogaster transposable element sequences in species of the obscura group

Fifteen species belonging to the obscura group of the genus Drosophila were screened for sequences homologous to Drosophila melanogaster transposable elements (TEs) as an initial step in the examination of the possible occurrence of TEs at chromosomal inversion breakpoints. Blots of genomic DNAs from species of the obscura group were hybridized at three different stringencies with 14 probes representing the major families of TEs described in D. melanogaster. The probe DNAs included copia, gypsy, 412, 297, mdg1, mdg3, 3S18, F, G, I, jockey, P, hobo, and FB3. D. melanogaster TEs were not well represented in the species of the obscura group analyzed. The TEs that were observed generally exhibited heterogeneous distributions, with the exception of F, gypsy and 412 which were ubiquitous, and 297, G, Sancho 2, hobo and FB which were not detected.

Horizontal transfer of P elements and other short inverted repeat transposons

Evidence for horizontal transfer of the P family of transposable elements in the genus Drosophila is reviewed and evaluated, along with observations consistent with the recent invasion of Drosophila melanogaster by these elements. Some other examples of horizontal transfer involving other groups of transposable elements having short inverted terminal repeats are also briefly described. The sequential mechanistic steps likely to be involved in a horizontal transfer event are explored, including the requirement for suitable interspecific vectors or carriers. Finally, the frequency and significance of horizontal transfer of transposable elements are briefly discussed within an evolutionary framework.

Possible horizontal transfer of Drosophila genes by the mite Proctolaelaps regalis

There is strong inferential evidence for recent horizontal gene transfer of the P (mobile) element to Drosophila melanogaster from a species of the Drosophila willistoni group. One potential vector of this transfer is a semiparasitic mite, Proctolaelaps regalis DeLeon, whose morphology, behavior, and co-occurrence with Drosophila are consistent with the properties necessary for such a vector. Southern blot hybridization, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification, and DNA sequencing showed that samples of P. regalis associated with a P strain of D. melanogaster carried P element sequences. Similarly, Drosophila ribosomal DNA sequences were identified in P. regalis samples that had been associated with Drosophila cultures. These results have potentially important evolutionary implications, not only for understanding the mechanisms by which genes may be transferred between reproductively isolated species, but also for improved detection of some host-parasite and predator-prey relationships.

Evidence for horizontal transmission of the P transposable element between Drosophila species

Several studies have suggested that P elements have rapidly spread through natural populations of Drosophila melanogaster within the last four decades. This observation, together with the observation that P elements are absent in the other species of the melanogaster subgroup, has lead to the suggestion that P elements may have entered the D. melanogaster genome by horizontal transmission from some more distantly related species. In an effort to identify the potential donor in the horizontal transfer event, we have undertaken an extensive survey of the genus Drosophila using Southern blot analysis. The results showed that P-homologous sequences are essentially confined to the subgenus Sophophora. The strongest P hybridization occurs in species from the closely related willistoni group. A wild-derived strain of D. willistoni was subsequently selected for a more comprehensive molecular examination. As part of the analysis, a complete P element was cloned and sequenced from this line. Its nucleotide sequence was found to be identical to the D. melanogaster canonical P, with the exception of a single base substitution at position 32. When the cloned element was injected into D. melanogaster embryos, it was able to both promote transposition of a coinjected marked transposon and induce singed-weak mutability, thus demonstrating its ability to function as an autonomous element. The results of this study suggest that D. willistoni may have served as the donor species in the horizontal transfer of P elements to D. melanogaster.

Hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila simulans lines transformed with autonomous P elements

The molecular and phenotypic analysis of several previously described P element-transformed lines of Drosophila simulans was extended in order to determine whether they had the potential to produce a syndrome of P-M hybrid dysgenesis analogous to the one in Drosophila melanogaster. The transformed line with the highest number of P elements at the beginning of the analysis, DsP pi-5C, developed strong P activity potential and P element regulation, properties characteristic of D. melanogaster P strains. The subsequent analysis of sublines derived from 34 single pair matings of DsP pi-5C revealed that they were heterogeneous with respect to both their P element complements and P activity potentials, but similar with respect to their regulatory capabilities. The subline with the highest P activity, DsP pi-5C-27, was subsequently used as a reference P strain in the genetic analysis of the D. simulans transformants. In these experiments, the reciprocal cross effect was observed with respect to both gonadal sterility and male recombination. As in D. melanogaster, the induction of gonadal sterility in D. simulans was shown to be temperature-dependent. Molecular analysis of DsP pi-5C-27 revealed that it has approximately 30 P elements per genome, at least some of which are defective. The number of potentially complete P elements in its genome is similar to the number in the D. melanogaster P strain, Harwich-77. Overall our analysis indicates that P-transformed lines of D. simulans are capable of expressing the major features of P-M hybrid dysgenesis previously demonstrated in D. melanogaster and that P elements appear to behave in a similar way in the two sibling species.

Molecular analysis of the P-M gonadal dysgenesis cline in eastern Australian Drosophila melanogaster

The latitudinal cline in P-M gonadal dysgenesis potential in eastern Australia has been shown to comprise three regions which are, from north to south respectively, P, Q, and M, with the P-to-Q and Q-to-M transitions occurring over relatively short distances. The P element complements of 30 lines from different regions of the cline were determined by molecular techniques. The total amount of P element-hybridizing DNA was high in all lines, and it did not correlate in any obvious way with the P-M phenotypes of individual lines. The number of potentially full-sized P elements per genome was high in lines from the P regions, but variable or low among lines from the Q and M regions, and thus declined overall from north to south. A particular P element deletion-derivative, the KP element, occurred in all the tested lines. The number of KP elements was low in lines from the P region, much higher in lines from the Q region, and highest among lines from the M region, thus forming a cline reciprocal to that of the full-sized P elements. Another transposable element, hobo, which has been described as causing dysgenic traits similar to those of P-M hybrid dysgenesis, was shown to be present in all lines and to vary among them in number, but not in any latitudinal pattern. The P-M cline in gonadal dysgenesis potential can be inferred to be based on underlying clinal patterns of genomic P element complements. P activity of a line was positively correlated with the number of full-sized P elements in the line, and negatively correlated with the number of KP elements. Among Q and M lines, regulatory ability was not correlated with numbers of KP elements.

Evolution of hybrid dysgenesis potential following P element contamination in Drosophila melanogaster

P elements were introduced into M strain genomes by chromosomal contamination (transposition) from P strain chromosomes under conditions of P-M hybrid dysgenesis. A number of independently maintained contaminated lines were subsequently monitored for their ability to induce gonadal (GD) sterility in the progeny of reference crosses, over a period of 60 generations, in two experiments. The efficiency of chromosomal contamination was high; all tested lines acquired P elements following the association of M and P chromosomes in the same genome for a single generation. All the contaminated lines also sustained an initial unstable phase, marked by high frequencies of transposition and sterility within lines, in the absence of P element regulation. Subsequently, each of the lines rapidly evolved to one of three relatively stable strain types whose phenotypic and molecular properties correspond rather closely to those of the P, Q and M' strains that have previously been characterized. The numbers and structures of P elements and the presence or absence of P element regulation during the early generations appeared to be critical factors determining the subsequent course of evolution. On the basis of GD sterility frequencies, both the mean level of P activity, and the average capacity for P element regulation, were reduced in lines raised at 25 degrees, relative to those raised at 20 degrees, during the early generations. This latter result is consistent with the expectation that natural selection will tend to modify the manifestation of dysgenic traits, such as high temperature sterility, which cause a reduction of fitness. However, overall, stochastic factors appeared to predominate in determining the course of evolution of individual lines.

Molecular characteristics of diverse populations are consistent with the hypothesis of a recent invasion of Drosophila melanogaster by mobile P elements

Approximately 100 strains derived from natural populations of Drosophila melanogaster were tested for the presence or absence of P-element sequences by using two molecular probes derived from internal regions of a full-sized P element. Strains that had been collected from several continents at varying times during the past 60 years were examined. The oldest available strains, representing most major geographical regions of the world, exhibited no detectable hybridization to the P-element probes. In contrast, all recently collected natural populations that were tested carried P-element sequences. The earliest appearance of P elements occurred in collections made during the 1950s and early 1960s in the Americas and during the late 1960s on other continents. The youngest strains that were completely devoid of P elements originated in populations sampled during the mid-1960s in America, but as late as 1974 in populations from the USSR. There are differences in the patterns of hybridization to the two P-element probes between populations from different geographical regions. These differences are consistent with the varying P-M phenotypic properties of these populations. Taken together with the results of phenotypic tests reported in earlier studies, the available evidence is consistent with the hypothesis of a worldwide P-element invasion of D. melanogaster during the past 30 years and suggests that the putative invasion of the Americas possibly preceded by approximately a decade that in Europe, Africa, and the rest of the world.

KP elements repress P-induced hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster

Molecular and genetic analysis has revealed a specific P factor deletion derivative (the KP element) which is able to repress P-induced hybrid dysgenesis. All naturally occurring strains lacking the P cytotype (M') that were examined, throughout the world contain up to 30 copies of KP per haploid genome together with complete P factors. The KP element is derived from the P factor by an internal deletion of 1753 bp removing nucleotides 808-2560 and is transcribed to yield an abundant 0.8-kb poly(A)+ RNA with the coding capacity for an in-frame 207 amino acid polypeptide. Genetic crosses show that KP elements preferentially accumulate in the presence of P factors and suppress hybrid dysgenesis. Suppression is transmitted through both sexes and is thus distinct from the maternally transmitted P cytotype mode of suppression. The spread of KP elements is probably due to the continual selection of individuals with the highest numbers of KP elements in which P-induced hybrid dysgenesis is suppressed.

The P-M hybrid dysgenesis cline in Eastern Australian Drosophila melanogaster: discrete P, Q and M regions are nearly contiguous

The dramatic latitudinal cline in P-M hybrid dysgenesis characteristics along the east coast of Australia is not smooth. Tests of recent collections of Drosophila melanogaster from the southeastern coast define the previously described cline as comprising three discrete, apparently contiguous regions of P, Q and M phenotypes, respectively. Northern populations from Cairns (16.9 degrees SLat) to Ourimbah (33.4 degrees SLat) are phenotypically P; populations from Wollongong (34.4 degrees SLat) to Eden (37.1 degrees SLat) are Q; and populations from Genoa (37.5 degrees SLat) to Cygnet (43.2 degrees SLat) are M. The decline in P activity from northern Queensland (55-60% gonadal dysgenesis (GD) in cross A) to mid-New South Wales (20-30% GD in cross A) is gradual; proceeding south, there then is a sharp drop to Q populations (less than 10% GD in crosses A and A*). This drop in P activity occurs in only 150 km, across the urban and suburban area of Sydney. Q populations are then found south to Eden, but Genoa, only about 50 km further southeast, is clearly M (48% GD in cross A*), as are two populations further south. The two discontinuities in the P-M cline do not correspond to obvious climatic differences along the coast, nor to obvious barriers to dispersal of D. melanogaster. The cline has apparently not moved between 1983 and 1985-1986.

Genetic transformation of Drosophila melanogaster with an autonomous P element: phenotypic and molecular analyses of long-established transformed lines

Following transformation of a Drosophila melanogaster true M strain with an autonomous P element, six lines were established and monitored for their molecular and phenotypic properties during a 4-yr period. The number of P elements increased with time in all the lines but the rate of increase differed among lines. Furthermore, degenerate elements arose in each of the lines during propagation. By the end of the 4th yr, the total number of elements in every line was similar to that of a very strong P strain.--At the phenotypic level, all of the transformed lines evolved high P activity, but only three developed complete or nearly complete regulatory ability. The other three lines attained only intermediate levels of regulation over the 4-yr period. One of these lines was particularly noteworthy. Although it contained as many as 55 P elements per genome (20 of which were potentially complete) and had extremely high P activity potential, it continued to exhibit limited regulatory ability. In addition, when females of this line were maintained at high temperatures, the ability to suppress P activity was even further diminished. A strain with this combination of molecular and phenotypic properties, in an apparently stable configuration, has not been previously described.--The results are discussed in the context of the possible role of degenerate elements in regulating P element expression.

Hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster: synthesis of RP strains by chromosomal contamination

Several strains have been synthesized which have reactive (R) properties in theI–Rsystem of hybrid dysgenesis and which are also classified as activePstrains in theP–Msystem. The synthesis of this previously unknown combination of types was accomplished by employing a mating scheme which allowed transposition (chromosomal contamination) ofP, but notI, factors fromIPtoRMchromosomes in dysgenic F1males. The successful synthesis ofRPstrains provides strong evidence that the apparent absence of this combination in natural and laboratory populations ofmelanogasteris not due to a biological incompatibility between these two types.

Hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster: nature and inheritance of P element regulation

The genetic determination of the control of resistance or susceptibility to germ line changes mediated by P elements was studied in two strains and in derivatives of crosses between them. One strain, characterized as true M, completely lacked P elements. The second strain, pseudo-M (M'), carried a number of P elements, but these did not have the potential to induce the gonadal sterility that is associated with P-M hybrid dysgenesis. Individuals from the true M strain were invariably unable to suppress P factor activity (i.e., all daughters of outcrosses of M females and P males were sterile). In contrast, individuals from the M' strain showed variable degrees of suppression that were manifested in a wide range of gonadal sterility frequencies in standard tests. This continuous distribution pattern was reproducible for more than 25 generations.--The results of the genetic analysis indicate that a strain with a variable degree of suppression of gonadal dysgenesis is not necessarily in a transient state between the extreme conditions of P and M cytotype. A large variance in the ability to suppress gonadal dysgenesis with a mean value intermediate between the extremes of P and M cytotype may be a relatively stable strain characteristic. No reciprocal cross effect was observed in the suppression of sterility of F1 females from M X M' matings. Thus, the existence of M' strains indicates a Mendelian component in P element regulation and suggests that cytotype, which has an extrachromosomal aspect, may be only one of perhaps several mechanisms involved in regulation. Analysis of the effects of individual chromosomes from the M' strain showed that each chromosome contributed to the reduction of gonadal dysgenesis in the progeny of test matings. The results are consistent with a one-component titration model for P element regulation.

Hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster: the evolution of mixed P and M populations maintained at high temperature

The ability of hybrid dysgenesisPfactors to survive and multiply under conditions of strong negative sterility selection was studied in mixedPandMlaboratory cultures. Eight populations were initiated with varying proportions ofPandMstrains. Mixed populations and controls were maintained for seventeen generations at 27 °C, a temperature sufficiently high to induce maximum frequencies of sterility in dysgenic hybrids. The two components of dysgenesis,Pfactor activity and cytotype, were monitored every generation for the first ten generations and intermittently thereafter. With one exception, all the mixed populations evolved to thePtype indicating thatPfactors can survive and multiply, despite low initial frequency and strong negative selection against dysgenic hybrids. However, the average level ofPfactor activity attained at equilibrium was considerably lower than that of thePstrain control population maintained under the same conditions. It was also lower than the equilibrium level ofPfactor activity attained in a similar experiment carried out at a lower temperature, suggesting that selection favouredPfactors with weak rather than strong sterility potential.

Hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster: partial sterility associated with embryo lethality in the P-M system

Variable frequencies of unhatched eggs were observed to be produced by a number of F1interstrain hybrids. This type of partial sterility resulting from F2embryo death was found to be associated with theP-Msystem of hybrid dysgenesis. Dysgenic hybrid progeny of crosses betweenMstrain females andPstrain males may therefore have reduced fertility due to the disruption of development at two different stages: early F1gonadal development and early F2embryo development. These disruptions result in the previously described F1gonadal dysgenesis (GDsterility) and F2embryo lethality (ELsterility) respectively. The two morphologically distinct types ofP-M-associated sterility differ in their patterns of response to F1developmental temperature, and the temperature-sensitive period forELsterility occurs considerably later in F1development than forGDsterility.ELsterility is similar toSFsterility, which is associated with theI–Rsystem of hybrid dysgenesis in that both result from death during early F2embryogenesis. However,ELsterility differs fromSFsterility in not being restricted to hybrids of the female sex and in showing different patterns of response to temperature and ageing in the F1generation. Some implications of the existence ofELsterility for methods of strain classification in theI–Rsystem are explored.

HYBRID DYSGENESIS IN DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER: FACTORS AFFECTING CHROMOSOMAL CONTAMINATION IN THE P-M SYSTEM

The two interacting components of the P-M system of hybrid dysgenesis are chromosomally associated elements called P factors and a susceptible cytoplasmic state referred to as M cytotype. Previous experiments have indicated that P factors are a family of multiple-copy transposable genetic elements dispersed throughout the genome of P strains but absent in long-established M strains.—Evidence is presented that the sterility and male recombination-inducing potential of P elements may be acquired by X chromosomes, derived from M strains, through nonhomologous association with P strain autosomes, a process referred to as "chromosomal contamination." The frequencies of chromosomal contamination of X chromosomes by P strain autosomes were highly variable and depended on a number of factors. M cytotype (as opposed to P cytotype) was essential for high frequencies of P factor contamination. There were large differences in contamination potential among individual female families, and a weak negative correlation existed between family size and contamination frequency. Chromosomal contamination in the P-M system was shown to be independent of that in the I-R system.—Frequency distributions suggested that the relationship between sterility production and P factor insertion is complex. The majority of P element transpositions, identified by in situ hybridization in one X chromosome, were not associated with gonadal sterility. However, high sterility potential was found to be associated with the presence of at least one P element inserted into the X chromosome. This potential was lost at a rate of about one-sixth per generation in M cytotype but was stabilized in P cytotype. Various hypotheses concerning the relationship between transposition and chromosomal contamination are discussed.

Evolution of hybrid dysgenesis determinants in Drosophila melanogaster

Hybrid dysgenesis is manifested as a group of correlated aberrant genetic traits such as sterility, increased mutation rate, and male recombination. Previous work has shown that it appears when males of strains carrying either of two independent families of transposable elements called I and P factors are hybridized with females of susceptible strains called R and M, respectively. Here the results of an extensive survey for dysgenic potential in Drosophila melanogaster strains are reported. Striking temporal trends in the distribution of strains were observed with respect to the two transposable element systems; in particular, the frequency of R and M strains is positively correlated with laboratory age. In recent tests of strain samples, those collected from nature about 50 years ago were the earliest observed to possess I characteristics. The I type was increasingly frequent in samples from strains more recently originating in the wild. This type is apparently ubiquitous in present day natural populations. the P type was not found in strain samples collected before 1950, and collections made subsequently showed increasing frequencies of P-factor activity with decreasing laboratory age. Marked geographical patterns are documented in the contemporary worldwide distribution of variant strains within the P-M system. M strains are currently fairly common in natural populations from various parts of the world, except on the American continent where they are rare. The degree and distribution of quantitative variation within M and P strain categories is related to their time of origin in the wild. The implications of these results are discussed in relation to the hypothesis that hybrid dysgenesis determinants have evolved recently in natural populations and to an alternative hypothesis of laboratory evolution.