Time-course of coiling activity in zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos exposed to ethanol as an endpoint for developmental neurotoxicity (DNT) - Hidden potential and underestimated challenges

Detection of developmental neurotoxicity (DNT) has been recognized as a major challenge by regulatory bodies and science. In search of sensitive and specific test methods, spontaneous tail coiling of embryonic zebrafish has been recommended as a promising tool for identification of DNT-inducing chemicals. The present study was designed to develop a protocol for a prolonged test to study neurotoxicity during the entire development of coiling movement in zebrafish embryos. Ambient illumination was found to modulate coiling activity from the very onset of tail movements representing the earliest behavioral response to light possible in zebrafish. In the dark, embryos displayed increased coiling activity in a way known from photokinesis, a stereotypical element of the visual motor response. Elevated coiling activity during dark phases allows for the development of test strategies that integrate later coiling movements under the control of a further developed nervous system. Furthermore, zebrafish embryos were exposed to ethanol, and coiling activity was analyzed according to the new test protocol. Exposure of embryos to non-teratogenic concentrations of ethanol (0.4-1%) resulted in a delay of the onset of coiling activity and heartbeat. Moreover, ethanol produced a dose-dependent increase in coiling frequency at 26 h post-fertilization, indicating the involvement of neurotoxic mechanisms. Analysis of coiling activity during prolonged exposure allowed for (1) attributing effects on coiling activity to different mechanisms and (2) preventing false interpretation of results. Further research is needed to verify the potential of this test protocol to distinguish between different mechanisms of neurotoxicity.

Strategies to improve the regulatory assessment of developmental neurotoxicity (DNT) using in vitro methods

Currently, the identification of chemicals that have the potential to induce developmental neurotoxicity (DNT) is based on animal testing. Since at the regulatory level, systematic testing of DNT is not a standard requirement within the EU or USA chemical legislation safety assessment, DNT testing is only performed in higher tiered testing triggered based on chemical structure activity relationships or evidence of neurotoxicity in systemic acute or repeated dose toxicity studies. However, these triggers are rarely used and, in addition, do not always serve as reliable indicators of DNT, as they are generally based on observations in adult rodents. Therefore, there is a pressing need for developing alternative methodologies that can reliably support identification of DNT triggers, and more rapidly and cost-effectively support the identification and characterization of chemicals with DNT potential. We propose to incorporate mechanistic knowledge and data derived from in vitro studies to support various regulatory applications including: (a) the identification of potential DNT triggers, (b) initial chemical screening and prioritization, (c) hazard identification and characterization, (d) chemical biological grouping, and (e) assessment of exposure to chemical mixtures. Ideally, currently available cellular neuronal/glial models derived from human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) should be used as they allow evaluation of chemical impacts on key neurodevelopmental processes, by reproducing different windows of exposure during human brain development. A battery of DNT in vitro test methods derived from hiPSCs could generate valuable mechanistic data, speeding up the evaluation of thousands of compounds present in industrial, agricultural and consumer products that lack safety data on DNT potential.

Using primary organotypic mouse midbrain cultures to examine developmental neurotoxicity of silver nanoparticles across two genetic strains

Micromass culture systems have been developed as three-dimensional organotypic in vitro alternatives to test developmental toxicity. We have optimized a murine-based embryonic midbrain micromass system in two genetic strains to evaluate neurodevelopmental effects of gold-cored silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) of differing sizes and coatings-20 nm AgCitrate, 110 nm AgCitrate, and 110 nm AgPVP. AgNPs are increasingly used in consumer, commercial, and medical products for their antimicrobial properties and observations of Ag in adult and fetal brain following in vivo exposures to AgNPs have led to concerns about the potential for AgNPs to elicit adverse effects on neurodevelopment and neurological function. Cytotoxicity was assessed at three time points of development by both nominal dose and by dosimetric dose. Ag dosimetry was assessed in cultures and the gold core component of the AgNPs was used as a tracer for determination of uptake of intact AgNPs and silver dissolution from particles in the culture system. Results by both nominal and dosimetric dose show cell death increased significantly in a dose-dependent manner at later time points (days 15 and 22 in vitro) that coincide with differentiation stages of development in both strains. When assessed by dosimetric dose, cultures were more sensitive to smaller particles, despite less uptake of Ag in smaller particles in both strains.

Developmental Neurotoxicity of Methamidophos in the Embryo-Larval Stages of Zebrafish

Methamidophos is a representative organophosphate insecticide. The knowledge of its developmental neurotoxicity is limited, especially for zebrafish in the early stages of their life. Four hour post-fertilization (hpf) zebrafish embryos were exposed to several environmentally relevant concentrations of methamidophos (0, 25, and 500 μg/L) for up to 72 hpf. Locomotor behavior was then studied in the zebrafish larvae at this timepoint. Acridine orange (AO) staining was carried out in the zebrafish larvae, and the mRNA levels of genes associated with neural development (mbp and syn2a) were analyzed by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). The number of escape responders for mechanical stimulation was significantly decreased in exposed groups. AO staining showed noticeable signs of apoptosis mainly in the brain. In addition, the mRNA levels of mbp and syn2a were both significantly down-regulated in exposed groups. Our study provides the first evidence that methamidophos exposure can cause developmental neurotoxicity in the early stages of zebrafish life, which may be caused by the effect of methamidophos on neurodevelopmental genes and the activation of cell apoptosis in the brain.

Prenatal Paraquat exposure induces neurobehavioral and cognitive changes in mice offspring

In the present work, we investigated developmental toxicity of Paraquat (PQ), from the 1st or 6th day of mating and throughout the gestation period. We have examined several parameters, including toxicity indices, reproductive performance, sensorimotor development, as well as anxiety and cognitive performance of the offspring. Our results showed that exposure to 20mg/kg of Paraquat during the first days of pregnancy completely prevents pregnancy in treated mice, but from the 6th day of pregnancy, an alteration in fertility and reproductive parameters was observed. In offspring, the PQ was responsible for an overall delay of innate reflexes and a deficit in motor development. All exposed animals showed a decrease in the level of locomotor activity, increased levels of anxiety-like behavior and pronounced cognitive impairment in adulthood. These results demonstrated that Paraquat led to the onset of many behavioral changes that stem from the impairment of neuronal developmental processes in prenatally exposed mice.

Windows of sensitivity to toxic chemicals in the motor effects development

Many chemicals currently used are known to elicit nervous system effects. In addition, approximately 2000 new chemicals introduced annually have not yet undergone neurotoxicity testing. This review concentrated on motor development effects associated with exposure to environmental neurotoxicants to help identify critical windows of exposure and begin to assess data needs based on a subset of chemicals thoroughly reviewed by the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) in Toxicological Profiles and Addenda. Multiple windows of sensitivity were identified that differed based on the maturity level of the neurological system at the time of exposure, as well as dose and exposure duration. Similar but distinct windows were found for both motor activity (GD 8-17 [rats], GD 12-14 and PND 3-10 [mice]) and motor function performance (insufficient data for rats, GD 12-17 [mice]). Identifying specific windows of sensitivity in animal studies was hampered by study designs oriented towards detection of neurotoxicity that occurred at any time throughout the developmental process. In conclusion, while this investigation identified some critical exposure windows for motor development effects, it demonstrates a need for more acute duration exposure studies based on neurodevelopmental windows, particularly during the exposure periods identified in this review.

Trace elements as paradigms of developmental neurotoxicants: Lead, methylmercury and arsenic

Trace elements have contributed unique insights into developmental neurotoxicity and serve as paradigms for such adverse effects. Many trace elements are retained in the body for long periods and can be easily measured to assess exposure by inexpensive analytical methods that became available several decades ago so that past and cumulated exposures could be easily characterized through analysis of biological samples, e.g. blood and urine. The first compelling evidence resulted from unfortunate poisoning events that allowed scrutiny of long-term outcomes of acute exposures that occurred during early development. Pursuant to this documentation, prospective studies of children's cohorts that applied sensitive neurobehavioral methods supported the notion that the brain is uniquely vulnerable to toxic damage during early development. Lead, methylmercury, and arsenic thereby serve as paradigm neurotoxicants that provide a reference for other substances that may have similar adverse effects. Less evidence is available on manganese, fluoride, and cadmium, but experience from the former trace elements suggest that, with time, adverse effects are likely to be documented at exposures previously thought to be low and safe.

Behavioural assessments of neurotoxic effects and neurodegeneration in zebrafish

Altered neurological function will generally be behaviourally apparent. Many of the behavioural models pioneered in mammalian models are portable to zebrafish. Tests are available to capture alterations in basic motor function, changes associated with exteroceptive and interoceptive sensory cues, and alterations in learning and memory performance. Excepting some endpoints involving learning, behavioural tests can be carried out at 4 days post fertilization. Given larvae can be reared quickly and in large numbers, and that software solutions are readily available from multiple vendors to automatically test behavioural responses in 96 larvae simultaneously, zebrafish are a potent and rapid model for screening neurological impairments. Coupling current and emerging behavioural endpoints with molecular techniques will permit and accelerate the determination of the mechanisms behind neurotoxicity and degeneration, as well as provide numerous means to test remedial drugs and other therapies. The emphasis of this review is to highlight unexplored/underutilized behavioural assays for future studies. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Zebrafish Models of Neurological Diseases.

Valproate-induced developmental neurotoxicity is affected by maternal conditions including shipping stress and environmental change during early pregnancy

Prenatal stress is known to affect the development of the brain, and exaggerate the developmental toxicity of chemicals. Many studies of developmental neurotoxicity (DNT) use pregnant rodents mated at the supplier, which consequently suffer from the stress of shipping and of environmental changes. Here, we demonstrated differences in the developmental neurotoxicity induced by valproate (VPA) between pregnant rats mated at our own animal facility (in-house group) and rats purchased pregnant (supplier group). Rats were treated with VPA (800mg/kg) orally on gestation day (GD) 9 or 11 (VPAE9 or VPAE11), and the fetal brain was examined at embryonic day 14 using immunohistochemistry for TuJ1 (a marker for immature neurons). The size of the fetal brain was also measured. The treatment decreased fetal live viability and fetal body weight only in the supplier group. VPA treatment on either day impaired the development of TuJ1-positive neurons in the cerebral cortex. The size of the forebrain was also affected by VPA. The supplier group was much more sensitive to these toxic effects. Therefore, difference in mating place (one's own animal facility or supplier) takes part in reproducibility of valproate-induced DNT.

Dextran 40 (Rheomacrodex) or Polygeline (Haemaccel) as an epidural patch for post dural puncture headache: a neurotoxicity study in a rat model of Dextran 40 and Polygeline injected intrathecally

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Although an epidural autologous blood patch is considered the most effective treatment for post dural puncture headache, which sometimes occurs following spinal or inadvertent spinal anaesthesia, there remains a need for alternative materials for epidural patches. We investigated the potential neurotoxicity of Dextran 40 (Rheomacrodex) and Polygeline (Haemaccel) used for this purpose in a rat model.

METHODS

Repeated boluses of 10% Dextran 40, 3.5% Polygeline or 0.9% saline were injected intrathecally over a period of 1 month in three groups of rats.

RESULTS

No behavioural or clinical derangements were observed in any of the three groups during this period. After sacrifice of the animals at the end of the experiment, no significant differences in the histopathological appearances of the spinal cords in the three groups were observed. No toxic effects diminishing viability of spinal cord cells were evident. Similarly, viability of renal, hepatic and peripheral blood mononuclear cells remained unaffected (98% +/- 2%).

CONCLUSIONS

No deleterious effects, clinical or cellular, were evident in this rat model when Dextran 40 or Polygeline were injected intrathecally. Thus, both substances can be considered as possible alternative materials for epidural patches.

Developmental neurotoxicity of pyrethroid insecticides: critical review and future research needs

Pyrethroid insecticides have been used for more than 40 years and account for 25% of the worldwide insecticide market. Although their acute neurotoxicity to adults has been well characterized, information regarding the potential developmental neurotoxicity of this class of compounds is limited. There is a large age dependence to the acute toxicity of pyrethroids in which neonatal rats are at least an order of magnitude more sensitive than adults to two pyrethroids. There is no information on age-dependent toxicity for most pyrethroids. In the present review we examine the scientific data related to potential for age-dependent and developmental neurotoxicity of pyrethroids. As a basis for understanding this neurotoxicity, we discuss the heterogeneity and ontogeny of voltage-sensitive sodium channels, a primary neuronal target of pyrethroids. We also summarize 22 studies of the developmental neurotoxicity of pyrethroids and review the strengths and limitations of these studies. These studies examined numerous end points, with changes in motor activity and muscarinic acetylcholine receptor density the most common. Many of the developmental neurotoxicity studies suffer from inadequate study design, problematic statistical analyses, use of formulated products, and/or inadequate controls. These factors confound interpretation of results. To better understand the potential for developmental exposure to pyrethroids to cause neurotoxicity, additional, well-designed and well-executed developmental neurotoxicity studies are needed. These studies should employ state-of-the-science methods to promote a greater understanding of the mode of action of pyrethroids in the developing nervous system.

Disruption of cholesterol homeostasis in the developing brain as a potential mechanism contributing to the developmental neurotoxicity of ethanol: an hypothesis

While excess cholesterol may have deleterious consequences, as in the case of atherosclerosis, too little cholesterol may endanger the development of the brain. Different degrees of mental retardation are often observed in inborn errors of cholesterol synthesis, such as the Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome or in maternal phenylketonuria, where the metabolite of accumulating phenylalanine, phenylacetate, is an inhibitor of cholesterol synthesis. Lack of cholesterol during brain development as a consequence of these genetic defects leads to severe brain damage, microencephaly and mental retardation, which are also hallmarks of the fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS). The brain relies on the in situ synthesis of cholesterol, which occurs mostly in astrocytes. Astrocyte-produced cholesterol is utilized for cell proliferation, or is released, via astrocyte-secreted high density lipoprotein-like particles containing apolipoprotein E, outside the cell, where it is taken up and utilized by neurons for dendrite outgrowth and to form synapses. We propose the hypothesis that ethanol may disrupt cholesterol homeostasis during brain development, and that this effect may be responsible, at least in part, for the central nervous system dysfunctions observed in the FAS, which include altered astrocyte proliferation, neuronal death and diminished synaptic contacts.

Guidelines for Developmental Neurotoxicity and Their Impact on Organophosphate Pesticides: A Personal View from an Academic Perspective

The appropriate regulation of drugs, chemicals and environmental contaminants requires the establishment of clear and accepted guidelines for developmental neurotoxicity. Ideally, these guidelines should encompass the ability to assess widely disparate classes of compounds through routine tests, with high throughput and low cost. Increasingly, however, the progress in primary research from academic laboratories deviates from this goal, focusing instead on categorizing novel effects of toxicants, development of new testing paradigms, and extension of techniques into molecular biology. The differing objectives of academic science as opposed to those of regulatory agencies or industry, are driven in part, by the priorities of the agencies that fund primary research. Recent work on organophosphate pesticides (OPs) such as chlorpyrifos (CPF) illustrate this dichotomy. Originally, OPs were thought to affect brain development through their ability to elicit cholinesterase inhibition and consequent cholinergic hyperstimulation. This common mechanism allowed for parallels to be drawn between standard measures of systemic toxicity, gross morphological examinations, and exposure testing utilizing an easily-assessed surrogate endpoint, plasma cholinesterase activity. In the past decade, however, it has become increasingly evident that CPF, and probably other OPs, have direct effects on cellular processes that are unique to brain development, and that these effects are mechanistically unrelated to inhibition of cholinesterase. The identification and pursuit of these mechanisms and their consequences for brain development represent new and exciting scientific findings, while at the same obscuring the ability to sustain a uniform approach to neurotoxicity guidelines or biomarkers of exposure. In the future, a new set of test paradigms, relying on primary work in cell culture, invertebrates, or non-mammalian models, followed by more targeted examinations of specific processes in mammalian models, may unite cutting-edge academic research with the need for establishing flexible guidelines for developmental neurotoxicity.

New insights and new issues in developmental neurotoxicology

Here, I will review accumulating evidence that during the developmental period of synaptogenesis, also known as the brain growth spurt period, neurons are very sensitive to specific disturbances in their synaptic environment. During this period, abnormal increases in NMDA glutamate (Glu) receptor activity triggers excitotoxic neurodegeneration, and abnormal inhibition of neuronal activity (by blockade of NMDA Glu receptors or excessive activation of GABAA receptors) triggers neuronal suicide (apoptosis). Only a transient disturbance, lasting for a few hours, is sufficient to trigger either excitotoxic or apoptotic neurodegeneration during this developmental period. Ethanol, which has both NMDA antagonist and GABAmimetic properties, triggers widespread apoptotic neurodegeneration in the developing rat, mouse or guinea pig brain, and this provides a likely explanation for the reduced brain mass and lifelong neurobehavioral disturbances associated with the human fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS). The brain growth spurt occurs in different species at different times relative to birth. In rats and mice it is a postnatal event, but in humans it extends from the 6th month of gestation to several years after birth. Thus, there is a period in fetal and neonatal human development, lasting for several years, during which immature central nervous system (CNS) neurons are exquisitely sensitive to environmental agents (the specific number and variety of which remains to be established) that can trigger widespread neurodegeneration by inducing specific abnormal changes in the synaptic environment. Agents identified thus far include drugs that may be abused by pregnant mothers (ethanol, phencyclidine (PCP) (angel dust), ketamine (Special K), nitrous oxide (laughing gas), barbiturates, benzodiazepines) and many medicinals used in obstetric and pediatric medicine as sedatives, anti-convulsants or anesthetics (all general anesthetics are either NMDA antagonists or GABAmimetics). Many other chemicals in the human environment remain to be evaluated for their ability to cause developing CNS neurons to commit suicide, and this provides an exciting challenge for the field of developmental neurotoxicology.

Ontogeny of the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor system and susceptibility to neurotoxicity

The NMDA receptor has been widely investigated in recent years as a target for the pharmacological management of seizures, pain and a variety of neurological disorders. Its role in normal central nervous system (CNS) activity and development, as well as in the development of CNS abnormalities and neurodegeneration has also been of interest. The NMDA receptor is one of three pharmacologically distinct subtypes of ionotropic receptor channels that are sensitive to the endogenous excitatory amino acid, L-glutamate. The ontogeny of the NMDA receptor, a multiple tetrameric and heteromeric channel complex with at least six known subunits, is controlled by three gene families and varies in developmental profile with species and regional brain area. NMDA receptors play a role in excitatory synaptic transmission, in the activity-dependent synaptic plasticity underlying learning and memory, and in pre- and postnatal CNS development, including brain cell differentiation, axonal growth and degeneration of unused neurons. The results of recent studies suggest that sustained alteration of NMDA receptor activation during critical periods of development may have deleterious effects on normal CNS development and function. Neonatal rats administered the NMDA receptor antagonists 2-amino-5-phosphonovalerate (AP5) and MK-801 during the first two weeks of life develop abnormal axonal arborization in the retinal connections to the superior colliculus, interfering with normal visual responses. Results from monkey studies suggest that chronic developmental exposure to high doses of a NMDA antagonist, remacemide, has pronounced and long-lasting effects on learning. Recent findings indicate that if NMDA receptors are blocked during a specific period in neonatal life (first two weeks postnatally in the rat), massive apoptotic neurodegeneration results, due not to excitotoxic overstimulation of neurons but to deprivation of stimulation. These observations require further laboratory evidence and support in order to establish their relevance to drug-induced human neurodevelopmental concerns. It is necessary to investigate the relevance of these findings in other animal species in addition to the rat, most notably, nonhuman primates, where neuronal cytoarchitecture and development are significantly different than the rodent but more like the human.