Immune response hinders therapy for lysosomal storage diseases

Enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) for the lysosomal storage disease mucopolysaccharidosis I (MPS I) involves i.v. injection of alpha-l-iduronidase, which can be taken up by cells throughout the body. While a significant immune response to ERT has been shown in patients with MPS I, little is known about what effect anti-enzyme antibodies have on treatment efficacy. In this issue of the JCI, Dickson et al. demonstrate that anti-enzyme antibodies inhibit enzyme uptake and substantially limit the therapeutic efficacy of ERT in canines with MPS I (see the related article beginning on page 2868). Furthermore, the induction of immune tolerance--via oral delivery of cyclosporine A and azathioprine for two months at the time of initiation of ERT with recombinant human alpha-L-iduronidase--improved enzyme uptake in organs. Therefore, transient immunosuppression may enhance ERT for lysosomal storage diseases.

Upregulation of elastase proteins results in aortic dilatation in mucopolysaccharidosis I mice

Mucopolysaccharidosis I (MPS I), known as Hurler syndrome in the severe form, is a lysosomal storage disease due to alpha-L-iduronidase (IDUA) deficiency. It results in fragmentation of elastin fibers in the aorta and heart valves via mechanisms that are unclear, but may result from the accumulation of the glycosaminoglycans heparan and dermatan sulfate. Elastin fragmentation causes aortic dilatation and valvular insufficiency, which can result in cardiovascular disease. The pathophysiology of aortic disease was evaluated in MPS I mice. MPS I mice have normal elastic fiber structure and aortic compliance at early ages, which suggests that elastin assembly is normal. Elastin fragmentation and aortic dilatation are severe at 6 months, which is temporally associated with marked increases in mRNA and enzyme activity for two elastin-degrading proteins, matrix metalloproteinase-12 (MMP-12) and cathepsin S. Upregulation of these genes likely involves activation of STAT proteins, which may be induced by structural stress to smooth muscle cells from accumulation of glycosaminoglycans in lysosomes. Neonatal intravenous injection of a retroviral vector normalized MMP-12 and cathepsin S mRNA levels and prevented aortic disease. We conclude that aortic dilatation in MPS I mice is likely due to degradation of elastin by MMP-12 and/or cathepsin S. This aspect of disease might be ameliorated by inhibition of the signal transduction pathways that upregulate expression of elastase proteins, or by inhibition of elastase activity. This could result in a treatment for patients with MPS I, and might reduce aortic aneurism formation in other disorders.

Clinical characterization of cardiovascular abnormalities associated with feline mucopolysaccharidosis I and VI

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to define the cardiovascular abnormalities present in young and adult cats affected with the lysosomal storage diseases mucopolysaccharidosis (MPS) I and MPS VI.

METHOD

Eighteen cats affected with MPS I and 10 cats affected with MPS VI were evaluated by physical examination, electrocardiography and echocardiography. Electrocardiography (ECG) was performed on all MPS I and 9 of the MPS VI cats. Twelve unaffected cats underwent complete examinations for comparison purposes.

RESULTS

No cardiovascular abnormalities were noted on physical examination. Measured ECG intervals were normal in affected cats; however, sinus arrhythmia was noted more frequently than in the unaffected cats. Significant echocardiographic abnormalities included aortic valve thickening, regurgitation and aortic root dilation. Significant mitral valve thickening was also noted. The severity of changes increased in older affected cats.

CONCLUSION

As affected animals increased in age, more cardiac abnormalities were found with increasing severity. Significant lesions included the mitral and aortic valves and ascending aorta, but myocardial changes were not recognized. MPS I and MPS VI cats have similar cardiovascular findings to those seen in children and constitute important models for testing new MPS therapies.

Immunology of neonatal gene transfer

Gene therapy could result in the permanent correction or amelioration of the clinical manifestations of many genetic diseases. However, immune responses to the therapeutic protein pose a significant hurdle for successful gene therapy. Problematic immune responses can include the development of a cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response that results in the destruction of genetically-modified cells and/or the formation of antibodies directed against the therapeutic protein. One approach to avoid an immune response is to perform gene therapy in newborns, which takes advantage of the fact that the immune system is relatively immature at birth. This approach has been highly effective in mice, and has resulted in stable expression without antibody formation for proteins that are highly immunogenic after transfer to adults. High levels of expression after neonatal gene therapy were more effective at inducing tolerance than low levels of expression in mice, which suggests that high antigen levels are more efficient at inducing tolerance. A criticism of this approach is that the murine immune system is less mature at birth than the immune systems of larger animals. Indeed, neonatal gene therapy to cats with mucopolysaccharidosis I resulted in a CTL response that destroyed expressing cells. Nevertheless, the immune system was still relatively immature, as transient administration of a single immunosuppressive agent at the time of neonatal gene therapy resulted in stable expression. Neonatal administration can reduce, but not eliminate, immune responses after gene therapy.

Gene therapy for cardiovascular manifestations of lysosomal storage diseases

Cardiac disease causes morbidity in several lysosomal storage diseases, which are the result of deficient activity of lysosomal enzymes. Mucopolysaccharidosis (MPS) causes aortic and valvular disease, Pompe disease causes cardiac muscle weakness, and Fabry disease causes left ventricular hypertrophy. Enzyme replacement therapy involves intravenous injection of enzyme modified with mannose 6-phosphate, which can be taken up by cells, and is currently approved for some lysosomal storage diseases. Gene therapy can result in secretion of mannose 6-phosphate-modified enzyme into blood, from where it can; similarly, be taken up by cells. Gene therapy has been effective in animal models of lysosomal storage disease, and holds great promise.

Gene therapy for mucopolysaccharidosis

Mucopolysaccharidoses (MPS) are due to deficiencies in activities of lysosomal enzymes that degrade glycosaminoglycans. Some attempts at gene therapy for MPS in animal models have involved intravenous injection of vectors derived from an adeno-associated virus (AAV), adenovirus, retrovirus or a plasmid, which primarily results in expression in liver and secretion of the relevant enzyme into blood. Most vectors can correct disease in liver and spleen, although correction in other organs including the brain requires high enzyme activity in the blood. Alternative approaches are to transduce hematopoietic stem cells, or to inject a vector locally into difficult-to-reach sites such as the brain. Gene therapy holds great promise for providing a long-lasting therapeutic effect for MPS if safety issues can be resolved.

High expression reduces an antibody response after neonatal gene therapy with B domain-deleted human factor VIII in mice

BACKGROUND

Gene therapy could prevent bleeding in patients with hemophilia A, but might induce antibodies that block factor VIII (FVIII) function.

OBJECTIVES

To test the efficacy of gene therapy in the newborn period for preventing a response to human FVIII (hFVIII) because of immaturity of the immune system.

METHODS

Varying doses of a retroviral vector (RV) expressing a B domain-deleted hFVIII cDNA were injected i.v. into newborn hemophilia A C57BL/6 or normal C3H mice. Mice were evaluated for hFVIII expression, hemostasis, and development of anti-hFVIII antibodies with inhibitory activity.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Injection of a high RV dose [10(10) transducing units (TU) kg(-1)] into newborn hemophilia A or C3H mice resulted in 61% and 13% of normal hFVIII antigen in plasma, respectively; most mice did not produce anti-hFVIII antibodies, and hemophilia A mice did not bleed. Furthermore, most mice with >20 ng mL(-1) of hFVIII in plasma (10% normal, 1 x 10(-10) m) were tolerant to hFVIII, as an antibody response was markedly reduced after challenge with hFVIII with or without adjuvant. However, most RV-treated animals with lower antigen levels developed antibodies before or after challenge. Thus, initiation of a gene therapy trial with low RV doses might increase inhibitor formation. Furthermore, frequent hFVIII infusions in newborns with hemophilia A might reduce inhibitor formation. Finally, difficulties in achieving tolerance after gene therapy for hemophilia A as compared to hemophilia B may relate to lower expression of FVIII than FIX, as high antigen levels are most effective at inducing tolerance.

Correction of clinical manifestations of canine mucopolysaccharidosis I with neonatal retroviral vector gene therapy

Mucopolysaccharidosis I (MPS I) (Hurler syndrome) is due to deficient alpha-L-iduronidase (IDUA) activity and is the most common of the MPS disorders. Neonatal MPS I dogs were injected intravenously (IV) with a gamma retroviral vector containing a complete long-terminal repeat (LTR) and an internal human alpha(1)-antitrypsin (hAAT) promoter upstream of the canine IDUA complementary DNA (cDNA). This resulted in stable serum IDUA activity of 366 +/- 344 units (U)/ml (28-fold normal) for up to 1.8 years, which likely derived primarily from secretion of IDUA by transduced liver cells. Retroviral vector (RV)-treated dogs had >18% of normal IDUA activity in organs and had decreased severity and/or incidence of hernias, chest deformities, joint disease, facial dysmorphia, corneal clouding, valvular heart disease, and aortic dilatation as compared with untreated MPS I dogs. The marked reduction that was observed in lysosomal storage in the brain of RV-treated dogs may have been due in part to expression from the LTR of the vector in cells in the brain. This possibility will be explored in future studies, because the potential for insertional mutagenesis has raised concerns about using vectors with an intact LTR. If proven safe, this gene therapy technique may be utilized in treating children with Hurler syndrome.

Improvements in mucopolysaccharidosis I mice after adult retroviral vector-mediated gene therapy with immunomodulation

Mucopolysaccharidosis I (MPS I) is caused by deficient alpha-L-iduronidase (IDUA) activity and results in the accumulation of glycosaminoglycans and multisystemic disease. Gene therapy could program cells to secrete mannose 6-phosphate-modified IDUA, and enzyme in blood could be taken up by other cells. Neonatal retroviral vector (RV)-mediated gene therapy has been shown to reduce the manifestations of murine MPS I; however, intravenous injection of RV into adults was ineffective owing to a cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response against transduced cells. In this study, prolonged inhibition of CD28 signaling with CTLA4-Ig, or transient administration of CTLA4-Ig with an anti-CD40 ligand antibody or with an anti-CD4 antibody, resulted in stable expression in most mice that received RV as adults. Mice with stable expression had 81 +/- 41U/ml IDUA activity in serum. This resulted in reductions in bone disease, improvements in hearing and vision, and reductions in biochemical and pathological evidence of lysosomal storage in most organs. Improvements in brain were likely due to diffusion of enzyme from blood. However, aortic disease was refractory to treatment. This demonstrates that most manifestations of MPS I can be prevented using adult gene therapy if an immune response is blocked.

Cutting edge: treatment of complement regulatory protein deficiency by retroviral in vivo gene therapy

Gene therapy is an attractive means to replace a deficient or defective protein. Using a murine retroviral vector, we provide an example of reconstituting a C regulator by neonatal in vivo gene transfer. The fusion gene containing the mouse C receptor 1-related gene/protein y (Crry) and a single chain Ab fragment with specificity for mouse glycophorin A was placed under transcriptional control of a liver-specific promoter. Shortly after birth, Crry KO mice were injected with the retroviral vectors. Protein expression progressively increased over the next 6-8 wk after which an equilibrium was established. Coating levels on RBCs were obtained that inhibited C activation similar to wild-type cells and remained constant for > 1 year. Thus, gene therapy with targeted regulators represents a treatment option to provide a long-term and sustained protein supply for the site-specific blockade of undesirable complement activation.

Effect of neonatal administration of a retroviral vector expressing alpha-L-iduronidase upon lysosomal storage in brain and other organs in mucopolysaccharidosis I mice

Mucopolysaccharidosis I (MPS I) due to deficient alpha-L-iduronidase (IDUA) activity results in accumulation of glycosaminoglycans in many cells. Gene therapy could program cells to secrete IDUA modified with mannose 6-phosphate (M6P), and enzyme could be taken up by other cells via the M6P receptor. We previously reported that newborn MPS I mice that were injected intravenously with 10(9) (high-dose) or 10(8) (low-dose) transducing units/kg of a retroviral vector (RV) expressing canine IDUA achieved stable levels of IDUA activity in serum and had reduced disease in heart, eye, ear, and bone in a dose-dependent fashion. However, the dose required for improvement in manifestations of disease in other organs was not reported. High-dose and low-dose RV mice with an average serum IDUA activity of 1037+/-90 U/ml (471-fold normal) and 43+/-12 U/ml (20-fold normal), respectively, had complete correction of biochemical and pathological evidence of disease in the liver, spleen, kidney, and small intestines. Although mice that received high-dose RV had complete correction of lysosomal storage in thymus, ovary, lung, and testis, correction in these organs was only partial for those that received low-dose RV. Storage in brain was almost completely corrected with high-dose RV, but was not improved with low-dose RV. The correction of disease in brain may be due to diffusion of enzyme from blood. We conclude that high-dose RV prevents biochemical and pathological manifestations of disease in all organs in MPS I mice including brain.

Immune response after neonatal transfer of a human factor IX-expressing retroviral vector in dogs, cats, and mice

INTRODUCTION

Gene therapy could prevent bleeding in hemophilia. However, antibodies could inhibit coagulation, while cytotoxic T lymphocytes could destroy modified cells. The immaturity of the newborn immune system might prevent these immune responses from occurring after neonatal gene therapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Newborn dogs, cats, or mice were injected intravenously with a retroviral vector expressing human Factor IX. Plasma was evaluated for antigen and anti-human Factor IX antibodies. Cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses were evaluated indirectly by analysis of retroviral vector RNA in liver. Lymphocytes were evaluated for cytokine secretion and the ability to suppress an immune response to human Factor IX in mice.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Hemophilia B dogs that achieved 942+/-500 ng/ml (19% normal) or 5+/-0.4 ng/ml (0.1% normal) of human Factor IX in plasma only bled 0 or 1.2 times per year, respectively, and were tolerant to infusion of human Factor IX. Normal cats expressed human Factor IX at 118+/-29 ng/ml (2% normal) in plasma without antibody formation. However, plasma human Factor IX disappeared at late times in 1 of 4 cats, which was probably due to a cytotoxic T lymphocyte response that destroyed cells with high expression. C3H mice were tolerant to human Factor IX after neonatal gene therapy, which may involve clonal deletion of human Factor IX-responsive cells. These data demonstrate that neonatal gene therapy does not induce antibodies to human Factor IX in dogs, cats, or mice. The putative cytotoxic T lymphocyte response in one cat requires further study.

Gene therapy for hemophilia

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review will highlight the progress achieved in the past 2 years on using gene therapy to treat hemophilia in animals and humans.

RECENT FINDINGS

There has been substantial progress in using gene therapy to treat animals with hemophilia. Novel approaches for hemophilia A in mice include expression of Factor VIII in blood cells or platelets derived from ex-vivo transduced hematopoietic stem cells, or in-vivo transfer of transposons expressing Factor VIII into endothelial cells or hepatocytes. Advances in large-animal models include the demonstration that neonatal administration of a retroviral vector expressing canine Factor VIII completely corrected hemophilia A in dogs, and that double-stranded adeno-associated virus vectors resulted in expression of Factor IX that is 28-fold that obtained using single-stranded adeno-associated virus vectors. In humans, one hemophilia B patient achieved 10% of normal activity after liver-directed gene therapy with a single-stranded adeno-associated virus vector expressing human Factor IX. Expression fell at 1 month, however, which was likely due to an immune response to the modified cells.

SUMMARY

Gene therapy has been successful in a patient with hemophilia B, but expression was unstable due to an immune response. Abrogating immune responses is the next major hurdle for achieving long-lasting gene therapy.

Mucopolysaccharidosis I cats mount a cytotoxic T lymphocyte response after neonatal gene therapy that can be blocked with CTLA4-Ig

Although gene therapy has reduced manifestations of genetic diseases, immune responses can abrogate the effect. One approach to inducing tolerance is to perform gene transfer in newborns when the immune system is immature. We demonstrate here that the dose of retroviral vector (RV) is important in mice, as mucopolysaccharidosis I (MPS I) mice that received neonatal intravenous gene therapy with a high dose of a canine alpha-L-iduronidase (cIDUA)-expressing RV had stable expression, while those that received a low dose did not. It was unclear, however, if neonatal transfer with any dose could induce tolerance in large animals. Therefore, newborn MPS I cats were injected intravenously with the RV expressing cIDUA. Although this resulted in high serum IDUA activity due to secretion by transduced cells, expression fell due to a CTL response. Cats that transiently received the immunosuppressive agent CTLA4-Ig did not develop a CTL response. In contrast, MPS I dogs, which can respond immunologically to canine IDUA, had stable serum IDUA activity after neonatal gene therapy. We conclude that cats, but not dogs, mount a potent CTL response to canine IDUA after neonatal gene therapy, which can be prevented with transient CTLA4-Ig.

Unresolved issues in diagnosis and management of inherited bleeding disorders in the perinatal period: A White Paper of the Perinatal Task Force of the Medical and Scientific Advisory Council of the National Hemophilia Foundation, USA

Haemophilia and inherited bleeding disorders in newborns and their carrier mothers pose unique challenges. The pattern of bleeding and the causes and risk factors for bleeding are decidedly different than an older child or an adult with haemophilia/inherited bleeding disorder. This document outlines the needs for further research and education, summarizes the state of the art background information and provides guidance regarding research, education and access to care issues in this population.

Absence of a desmopressin response after therapeutic expression of factor VIII in hemophilia A dogs with liver-directed neonatal gene therapy

Hemophilia A (HA) is a bleeding disorder caused by factor VIII (FVIII) deficiency. FVIII replacement therapy can reduce bleeding but is expensive, inconvenient, and complicated by development of antibodies that inhibit FVIII activity in 30% of patients. Neonatal hepatic gene therapy could result in continuous secretion of FVIII into blood and might reduce immunological responses. Newborn HA mice and dogs that were injected i.v. with a retroviral vector (RV) expressing canine B domain-deleted FVIII (cFVIII) achieved plasma cFVIII activity that was 139 +/- 22% and 116 +/- 5% of values found in normal dogs, respectively, which was stable for 1.5 yr. Coagulation tests were normalized, no bleeding had occurred, and no inhibitors were detected. This is a demonstration of long-term fully therapeutic gene therapy for HA in a large animal model. Desmopressin (DDAVP; 1-deamino-[d-Arg(8)]vasopressin) is a drug that increases FVIII activity by inducing release of FVIII complexed with von Willebrand factor from endothelial cells. It has been unclear, however, if the FVIII is synthesized by endothelial cells or is taken up from blood. Because the plasma cFVIII in these RV-treated dogs derives primarily from transduced hepatocytes, they provided a unique opportunity to study the biology of the DDAVP response. Here we show that DDAVP did not increase plasma cFVIII levels in the RV-treated dogs, although von Willebrand factor was increased appropriately. This result suggests that the increase in FVIII in normal dogs after DDAVP is due to release of FVIII synthesized by endothelial cells.

Gene therapy ameliorates cardiovascular disease in dogs with mucopolysaccharidosis VII

BACKGROUND

Mucopolysaccharidosis VII (MPS VII) is a lysosomal storage disease caused by deficient beta-glucuronidase (GUSB) activity resulting in defective catabolism of glycosaminoglycans (GAGs). Cardiac disease is a major cause of death in MPS VII because of accumulation of GAGs in cardiovascular cells. Manifestations include cardiomyopathy, mitral and aortic valve thickening, and aortic root dilation and may cause death in the early months of life or may be compatible with a fairly normal lifespan. We previously reported that neonatal administration of a retroviral vector (RV) resulted in transduction of hepatocytes, which secreted GUSB into the blood and could be taken up by cells throughout the body. The goal of this study was to evaluate the effect on cardiac disease.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Six MPS VII dogs were treated intravenously with an RV-expressing canine GUSB. Echocardiographic parameters, cardiovascular lesions, and biochemical parameters of these dogs were compared with those of normal and untreated MPS VII dogs.

CONCLUSIONS

RV-treated dogs were markedly improved compared with untreated MPS VII dogs. Most RV-treated MPS VII dogs had mild or moderate mitral regurgitation at 4 to 5 months after birth, which improved or disappeared when evaluated at 9 to 11 and at 24 months. Similarly, mitral valve thickening present early in some animals disappeared over time, whereas aortic dilation and aortic valve thickening were absent at all times. Both myocardium and aorta had significant levels of GUSB and reduction in GAGs.

Lipopolysaccharide results in a marked decrease in hepatocyte nuclear factor 4 alpha in rat liver

The acute-phase response can result in decreased liver-specific functions and death as a result of liver failure. We show here that lipopolysaccharide (LPS), an endotoxin that induces the acute-phase response, results in a marked decrease in the major isoforms of the transcription factor, hepatocyte nuclear factor 4 alpha (HNF-4 alpha), in livers of rats. HNF-4 alpha is a nuclear receptor that is critical for the expression of several liver-specific genes. This decrease in HNF-4 alpha is primarily the result of a posttranscriptional mechanism, because mRNA levels are normal, and there are no major changes in the splicing patterns. This decrease was of functional significance, because expression of a gene that is highly dependent on HNF-4 alpha, HNF-1 alpha, was reduced. Interleukin-1 beta (IL-1 beta) is a cytokine whose levels are increased in vivo in response to LPS. IL-1 beta resulted in a decrease in HNF-4 alpha levels in HepG2 cells. This IL-1 beta-induced decrease was likely caused by degradation via the proteasome, because it was prevented by the addition of the proteasome inhibitor, MG132. We conclude that the decrease in HNF-4 alpha that occurs in vivo after the administration of LPS may be the result of IL-1 beta-induced degradation, and likely contributes to the liver insufficiency that occurs. IL-1 beta antagonists or proteasome inhibitors might increase HNF-4 alpha protein levels in the acute-phase response, which could result in increased liver function and survival.

Lipopolysaccharide potentiates the effect of hepatocyte growth factor upon replication in lung, thyroid, spleen, and colon in rats in vivo

Induction of replication may potentiate in vivo gene therapy, as some viral vectors only transduce dividing cells. Hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) increases the percentage of replicating hepatocytes to 18-fold that in normal rats, and lipopolysaccharide (LPS) modestly potentiates this effect. In this study, the effect of iv HGF upon replication in other organs was determined. HGF at 10 mg/kg resulted in replication that was < or =3-fold that of normal rats in alveolar and proximal renal tubular cells. HGF alone had no effect upon replication of epithelial cells from the bronchi, thyroid, pancreas, or colon or upon cells from the muscle, pancreatic islets, spleen, blood vessels, or thymus. HGF and LPS at 5 mg/kg resulted in replication that was 9-fold that of normal rats in alveolar cells, 25-fold in bronchial epithelial cells, 4-fold in thyroid epithelial cells, 1.5-fold in the red pulp of the spleen, and 2-fold in colonic epithelial cells. The synergistic effect may be due to the fact that LPS upregulated the HGF receptor c-met in thyroid, spleen, and colon. We conclude that iv administration of HGF alone is relatively specific for inducing hepatocyte replication and would allow selective gene transfer into the liver.

Delivery of a retroviral vector expressing human beta-glucuronidase to the liver and spleen decreases lysosomal storage in mucopolysaccharidosis VII mice

Mucopolysaccharidosis VII (MPS VII) is caused by beta-glucuronidase (beta-gluc) deficiency and results in lysosomal storage due to the inability to degrade glycosaminoglycans. Transfer of a beta-gluc gene into the liver reduces hepatic pathology as well as storage in other organs via uptake of secreted protein. A Moloney murine leukemia-based retroviral vector expressing the human beta-gluc cDNA was injected intravascularly into MPS VII mice during hepatocyte replication, which was induced with im injection of an adenoviral vector that transiently expressed hepatocyte growth factor (Ad.CMV. HGF). This procedure resulted in transduction of approximately 1% of hepatocytes, 1% of normal liver enzyme activity, and a reduction in lysosomal storage in the liver at 3.5 months. Surprisingly, controls that received retroviral vector without HGF had transduction of nonparenchymal cells in the liver, significant levels of enzyme and RNA in the liver at 2 but not 3.5 months, and reduced lysosomal storage at 3.5 months. Transduction was also achieved in the replicating cells of the spleen, where lysosomal storage was reduced. An approach using a retroviral vector without a growth factor might temporarily reduce lysosomal storage in the liver and spleen in humans. Addition of HGF might be used to augment and prolong gene transfer.