T cells are just dying to accept grafts

Two papers suggest that apoptosis of alloreactive T cells is required for induction of peripheral transplantation tolerance. These findings raise new questions about how lymphocytes reach from beyond the grave to influence the immune response (pages 1298-1302 and 1303-1307).

Matrix metalloproteinase deficiencies affect contact hypersensitivity: stromelysin-1 deficiency prevents the response and gelatinase B deficiency prolongs the response

Matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) are expressed by T cells and macrophages, but there is a paucity of evidence for their role in immune responses. We have studied mice with deficiencies of stromelysin-1 (MMP-3) or gelatinase B (MMP-9) in a dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB)-induced model of contact hypersensitivity (CHS). Stromelysin-1-deficient mice showed a markedly impaired CHS response to topical DNFB, although they responded normally to cutaneously applied phenol, an acute irritant. Lymphocytes from lymph nodes of DNFB-sensitized stromelysin-1-deficient mice did not proliferate in response to specific soluble antigen dinitrobenzenesulfonic acid, but did proliferate identically to lymph node lymphocytes from wild-type mice when presented with the mitogen Con A. An intradermal injection of stromelysin-1 immediately before DNFB sensitization rescued the impaired CHS response to DNFB in stromelysin-1-deficient mice. Unlike stromelysin-1-deficient mice, gelatinase B-deficient mice exhibited a CHS response comparable to wild-type controls at 1 day postchallenge, but the response persisted beyond 7 days in contrast to the complete resolution observed in wild-type mice by 7 days. However, gelatinase B-deficient mice had a normal rate of resolution of acute inflammation elicited by cutaneous phenol. Gelatinase B-deficient mice failed to show IL-10 production at the site of CHS, an essential feature of resolution in control mice. These results indicate that stromelysin-1 and gelatinase B serve important functions in CHS. Stromelysin-1 is required for initiation of the response, whereas gelatinase B plays a critical role in its resolution.

Fas ligand (CD95 ligand) controls angiogenesis beneath the retina

A principal cause of blindness is subretinal neovascularization associated with age-related macular degeneration. Excised neovascular membranes from patients with age-related macular degeneration demonstrated a pattern of Fas+ new vessels in the center of the vascular complex, surrounded by FasL+ retinal pigment epithelial cells. In a murine model, Fas (CD95)-deficient (Ipr) and FasL-defective (gld) mice had a significantly increased incidence of neovascularization compared with normal mice. Furthermore, in gld mice there is massive subretinal neovascularization with uncontrolled growth of vessels. We found that cultured choroidal endothelial cells were induced to undergo apoptosis by retinal pigment epithelial cells through a Fas-FasL interaction. In addition, antibody against Fas prevented vascular tube formation of choroidal endothelial cells derived from the eye in a three-dimensional in vitro assay. Thus, FasL expressed on retinal pigment epithelial cells may control the growth and development of new subretinal vessels that can damage vision.

Degradation of chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan enhances the neurite-promoting potential of spinal cord tissue

The contribution of chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan (CSPG) in the suppression of axonal growth in rat spinal cord has been examined by means of an in vitro bioassay in which regenerating neurons are grown on tissue section substrata. Dissociated embryonic chick dorsal root ganglionic neurons were grown on normal and injured adult spinal cord tissue sections treated with chondroitinases. Neuritic growth on normal spinal cord tissue was meager. However, both the percentage of neurons with neurites and the average neurite length were substantially greater on sections treated with chondroitinase ABC. Enzymes that specifically degraded dermatan sulfate or hyaluronan were ineffective. Neuritic growth was significantly greater on injured (compared to normal) spinal cord and a further dramatic increase resulted from chondroitinase ABC treatment. Neurites grew equally within white and gray matter regions after chondroitinase treatment. Observed increases in neurite outgrowth on chondroitinase-treated tissues were largely inhibited in the presence of function-blocking laminin antibodies. These findings indicate that inhibitory CSPG is widely distributed and predominant in both normal and injured spinal cord tissues. Additionally, inhibitory CSPG is implicated in negating the potential stimulatory effects of laminin that might otherwise support spinal cord regeneration.

Inducible nonlymphoid expression of Fas ligand is responsible for superantigen-induced peripheral deletion of T cells

Fas (CD95) and Fas ligand (FasL) play major roles in staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB)-induced peripheral deletion of Vbeta8+ T cells. We found that peripheral deletion was defective in radiation chimeras with non-functional tissue FasL, regardless of the FasL status of the bone marrow-derived cells. SEB induced a dramatic upregulation of FasL expression and function in nonlymphoid cells of liver and small intestine. This effect was resistant to inhibition by cyclosporin A, which also failed to inhibit peripheral deletion. In SCID animals nonlymphoid tissues did not express FasL in response to SEB unless transplanted lymphocytes were present. Thus, some immune responses induce FasL in nonlymphoid tissues, which in turn kills activated lymphocytes, leading to peripheral T cell deletion.

Antiinflammatory effects of CD95 ligand (FasL)-induced apoptosis

Apoptosis is critical to homeostasis of multicellular organisms. In immune privileged sites such as the eye, CD95 ligand (FasL)-induced apoptosis controls dangerous inflammatory reactions that can cause blindness. Recently, we demonstrated that apoptotic cell death of inflammatory cells was a prerequisite for the induction of immune deviation after antigen presentation in the eye. In this report, we examine the mechanism by which this takes place. Our results show that Fas- mediated apoptosis of lymphoid cells leads to rapid production of interleukin (IL)-10 in these cells. The apoptotic cells containing IL-10 are responsible for the activation of immune deviation through interaction with antigen-presenting cells (APC). In support of this, we found that apoptotic cells from IL-10(+/+) animals fed to APC in vitro promote Th2 cell differentiation, whereas apoptotic IL-10(-/-) cells, as well as nonapoptotic cells, favor Th1 induction. Thus, apoptotic cell death and tolerance are linked through the production of an antiinflammatory cytokine to prevent dangerous and unwanted immune responses that might compromise organ integrity.

Neuronal matrix metalloproteinase-2 degrades and inactivates a neurite-inhibiting chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan

Chondroitin sulfate proteoglycans (CSPGs) are implicated in the regulation of axonal growth. We previously reported that the neurite-promoting activity of laminin is inhibited by association with a Schwann cell-derived CSPG and that endoneurial laminin may be inhibited by this CSPG as well [Zuo J, Hernandez YJ, Muir D (1998) Chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan with neurite-inhibiting activity is upregulated after peripheral nerve injury. J Neurobiol 34:41-54]. Mechanisms regulating axonal growth were studied by using an in vitro bioassay in which regenerating embryonic dorsal root ganglionic neurons (DRGn) were grown on sections of normal adult nerve. DRGn achieved slow neuritic growth on sections of normal nerve, which was reduced significantly by treatment with metalloproteinase inhibitors. Similar results were obtained on a synthetic substratum composed of laminin and inhibitory CSPG. DRGn expressed the matrix metalloproteinase, MMP-2, which was transported to the growth cone. Recombinant MMP-2 inactivated the neurite-inhibiting CSPG without hindering the neurite-promoting potential of laminin. Similarly, neuritic growth by DRGn cultured on normal nerve sections was increased markedly by first treating the nerve sections with MMP-2. The proteolytic deinhibition by MMP-2 was equivalent to and nonadditive with that achieved by chondroitinase, suggesting that both enzymes inactivated inhibitory CSPG. Additionally, the increases in neuritic growth resulting from treating nerve sections with MMP-2 or chondroitinase were blocked by anti-laminin antibodies. From these results we conclude that MMP-2 provides a mechanism for the deinhibition of laminin in the endoneurial basal lamina and may play an important role in the regeneration of peripheral nerve.

Fas ligand is positioned in mouse uterus and placenta to prevent trafficking of activated leukocytes between the mother and the conceptus

Despite intimate juxtaposition of maternal and fetal tissues during mammalian pregnancy, reciprocal migration of cells is limited. To evaluate the postulate that cell traffic is restricted by expression of Fas ligand (FasL) in the uterus and placenta, FasL mRNA was identified by using reverse transcription-PCR, and FasL protein was identified by Western blotting and immunohistology. FasL mRNA and protein were detected at all stages tested (gestation days (g.d.) 6-18). At g.d. 6 to 10, immunoreactive FasL was prominent in glandular epithelial cells and decidual cells. Between g.d. 12 and 14, expression shifted to placental trophoblast cells bordering maternal blood spaces and fetal placental endothelial cells. Thus, FasL is appropriately positioned, first in the uterus and then in the placenta, to deter trafficking of activated Fas+ immune cells between the mother and the fetus. To test whether the absence of functional FasL affects pregnancy, uteroplacental units from homozygous matings of gld mice, a mutant strain lacking functional FasL, were examined. Extensive leukocytic infiltrates and necrosis at the decidual-placental interface were observed from day 10 onward, resorption sites were common, and small litters were delivered by gld mice. These observations are consistent with the idea that FasL at the maternal-fetal interface protects the placenta against a maternal leukocytic influx that reduces fertility.

Fas ligand is positioned in mouse uterus and placenta to prevent trafficking of activated leukocytes between the mother and the conceptus

Despite intimate juxtaposition of maternal and fetal tissues during mammalian pregnancy, reciprocal migration of cells is limited. To evaluate the postulate that cell traffic is restricted by expression of Fas ligand (FasL) in the uterus and placenta, FasL mRNA was identified by using reverse transcription-PCR, and FasL protein was identified by Western blotting and immunohistology. FasL mRNA and protein were detected at all stages tested (gestation days (g.d.) 6-18). At g.d. 6 to 10, immunoreactive FasL was prominent in glandular epithelial cells and decidual cells. Between g.d. 12 and 14, expression shifted to placental trophoblast cells bordering maternal blood spaces and fetal placental endothelial cells. Thus, FasL is appropriately positioned, first in the uterus and then in the placenta, to deter trafficking of activated Fas+ immune cells between the mother and the fetus. To test whether the absence of functional FasL affects pregnancy, uteroplacental units from homozygous matings of gld mice, a mutant strain lacking functional FasL, were examined. Extensive leukocytic infiltrates and necrosis at the decidual-placental interface were observed from day 10 onward, resorption sites were common, and small litters were delivered by gld mice. These observations are consistent with the idea that FasL at the maternal-fetal interface protects the placenta against a maternal leukocytic influx that reduces fertility.

A vision of cell death: insights into immune privilege

Immune privilege is a term applied to several organs that have a unique relationship with the immune response. These sites prohibit the spread of inflammation since even minor episodes can threaten organ integrity and function. The most prominent examples of these are the eye, brain and reproductive organs where immune responses either do not proceed, or proceed in a manner different from other areas. Once thought to be a passive process relying on physical barriers, immune privilege can now be viewed as an active process that utilizes multiple mechanisms to maintain organ function. Recently there has been a renewed interest in immune privilege when it was shown that two privileged sites (the eye and testes) constitutively express FasL, which functions by killing lymphoid cells that invade these areas. Here we will examine the role of FasL in immune privilege and discuss how this molecule interacts with other elements of the inflammatory response to maintain organ integrity in the face of potentially damaging immune reactions.

CD95 ligand (FasL)-induced apoptosis is necessary for corneal allograft survival

Although anatomical barriers and soluble mediators have been implicated in immune privilege, it appears that the apoptotic cell death of Fas+ cells by tissue-associated CD95 ligand (Fas ligand, FasL) is an important component. One clinical example of the function of an immune privileged site is the success of human corneal transplants, where a very high percentage of transplants accept without tissue matching or immunosuppressive therapy. Since the mouse cornea expresses abundant Fas ligand and immune privilege has been implicated in the success of these transplants, we examined the role of FasL in corneal transplantation. Our results show that human corneas express functional FasL capable of killing Fas+ lymphoid cells in an in vitro culture system. Using a mouse model for corneal allograft transplantation, FasL+ orthografts were accepted at a rate of 45%, whereas FasL- grafts, or normal grafts transplanted to Fas- mice, were rejected 100% of the time. Histological analysis found that FasL+ grafts contained apoptotic mononuclear cells indicating the induction of apoptosis by the graft, while rejecting FasL- corneas contained numerous inflammatory cells without associated apoptosis. Taken together our results demonstrate that FasL expression on the cornea is a major factor in corneal allograft survival and, thus, we provide an explanation for one of the most successful tissue transplants performed in humans.

Regulation of CD95 ligand expression: a key element in immune regulation?

Peripheral deletion of activated T cells has an important function in the regulation of the extent of an immune response. Upon restimulation through the T cell receptor previously stimulated cells have been shown to die by activation-induced cell death. Recent data indicate that this process is mediated by a CD95 (Fas/APO-1)/CD95 ligand interaction which induces apoptosis of the T cell. CD95 ligand (CD95-L) is absent on unactivated T cells but is readily expressed upon stimulation. Here we discuss evidence that CD95-L expression is induced by T cell receptor-mediated signals and is regulated at different levels. Different inhibitors of activation-induced cell death have been found to directly or indirectly act on the signal transduction pathway leading to CD95-L expression. CD95-L seems not only to be induced in T cells after activation but is also found constitutively expressed in many non-lymphoid tissues. This indicates that CD95-L is not only critically involved in activation-induced T cell death, but may have other functions as well. One such function is in the maintenance of immunological privilege, the protection of some tissues from potentially destructive immune responses. Thus, the regulation of CD95 expression in lymphoid and non-lymphoid cells appears to represent a key element in immune regulation.

CD95-induced apoptosis of lymphocytes in an immune privileged site induces immunological tolerance

We examined the relationship between cell death and tolerance induction following antigen injection into the anterior chamber of the eye. Our data show that when inflammatory cells undergo apoptosis following infection with HSV-1, tolerance to the virus was observed. In contrast, when cell death was absent due to defects in Fas or FasL, immune tolerance was not observed. Further studies revealed that cell death and tolerance required that the lymphoid cells be Fas+ and the eye be FasL+. Additionally, we show that while Fas/FasL-mediated apoptosis occurred in the eye, it was apoptotic cell death that was critical for tolerance induction. Our results further demonstrate immune privilege is not a passive process involving physical barriers, but is an active process that employs an important natural mechanism to induce cell death and immune tolerance.

Mice deficient in IL-1beta manifest impaired contact hypersensitivity to trinitrochlorobenzone

Mice rendered deficient in IL-1 beta by gene targeting in embryonic stem cells develop and grow normally in a protected laboratory environment. Endotoxin-stimulated peritoneal macrophages from IL-1beta-deficient mice showed normal synthesis and cellular release of IL-1alpha after treatment with 5 mM ATP demonstrating that IL-1beta is not necessary for expression and release of the IL-1alpha isoform. Mice deficient in IL-1beta showed unaltered sensitivity to endotoxic shock, with or without pretreatment with D-galactosamine. In contrast, IL-1beta-deficient mice showed defective contact hypersensitivity responses to topically applied trinitrochlorobenzene (TNCB). This defect could be overcome either by application of very high doses of sensitizing antigen, or by local intradermal injection of recombinant IL-1beta immediately before antigen application. These data demonstrate an essential role for IL-1beta in contact hypersensitivity and suggest that IL-1beta acts early during the sensitization phase of response. They suggest an important role for IL-1beta in initiation of the host of response at the epidermal barrier.

Fas ligand-induced apoptosis as a mechanism of immune privilege

The eye is a privileged site that cannot tolerate destructive inflammatory responses. Inflammatory cells entering the anterior chamber of the eye in response to viral infection underwent apoptosis that was dependent on Fas (CD95)-Fas ligand (FasL) and produced no tissue damage. In contrast, viral infection in gld mice, which lack functional FasL, resulted in an inflammation and invasion of ocular tissue without apoptosis. Fas-positive but not Fas-negative tumor cells were killed by apoptosis when placed within isolated anterior segments of the eyes of normal but not FasL-negative mice. FasL messenger RNA and protein were detectable in the eye. Thus, Fas-FasL interactions appear to be an important mechanism for the maintenance of immune privilege.

The immune response and the eye. TCR alpha-chain related molecules regulate the systemic immunity to antigen presented in the eye

Injection of antigen into the anterior chamber (AC) of the eye results in the induction of immune deviation in which antibody production is activated and delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) is inhibited. This system is termed anterior chamber associated immune deviation (ACAID) and the model is used to examine certain aspects of the immunologic privilege of the eye. Recent studies have established that following antigen presentation in the eye, an 'ACAID-inducing' signal is produced that directly enters the blood. This signal then homes to the spleen where T cells that down-regulate DTH are activated. For many antigens this 'ACAID signal' is a soluble protein released within 2 days of AC injection. Although the presence of this molecule (or molecules) has been described using several antigens, the exact nature of the soluble mediator has escaped characterization. We have further explored the nature of this signal using HSV-1-induced immune deviation. Our results show the soluble 'signal' was released by T cells that encounter antigen in the ocular microenvironment. This mediator was antigen specific, contained TCR alpha-chain (but not the TCR beta-chain) determinants and had an apparent molecular weight of 46 kDa. These results show that the release of soluble TCR alpha-chain from sites of T cell interaction within the microenvironment of the eye can regulate systemic immune responses. These results have implications for the control of immune response that might be damaging to organs such as the eye.

Neuropeptides modulate immune deviation induced via the anterior chamber of the eye

Ag presentation via the anterior chamber of the eye results in a form of immune deviation termed anterior chamber-associated immune deviation (ACAID). The hallmarks of this response are the suppression of delayed-type hypersensitivity with simultaneous induction of Ab production. In this study, we examined the role of the neuropeptides vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) and substance P (SP) and found that the levels of these two peptides are controlled by neurogenic stimulation of the eye by light, and that these molecules determine the outcome of Ag presentation in the eye. Mice reared under diurnal conditions had VIP in the iris and ciliary body (not free in aqueous humor) and low levels of SP. Mice that were reared in the dark (or dark-adapted) did not contain detectable levels of VIP but had high levels of SP. The adaptation of diurnal mice to the dark eliminated VIP and increased SP, while adapting dark-reared mice to the diurnal cycle increased VIP and reduced SP. We then tested the hypothesis that immune reactions resulting from Ag presentation in the eye were linked to SP and VIP. We found that a VIP receptor antagonist, when injected into the eye with Ag, reversed ACAID in diurnal mice, while a SP receptor antagonist restored ACAID to dark-adapted mice. We further determined that injection of Ag or TNF-alpha induced VIP release, while SP was liberated into the aqueous humor following reexposure of dark-reared mice to light. Our results demonstrate a close linkage of intraocular immune reactions to neuropeptide levels in the eye.

Neuropeptides modulate immune deviation induced via the anterior chamber of the eye

Ag presentation via the anterior chamber of the eye results in a form of immune deviation termed anterior chamber-associated immune deviation (ACAID). The hallmarks of this response are the suppression of delayed-type hypersensitivity with simultaneous induction of Ab production. In this study, we examined the role of the neuropeptides vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) and substance P (SP) and found that the levels of these two peptides are controlled by neurogenic stimulation of the eye by light, and that these molecules determine the outcome of Ag presentation in the eye. Mice reared under diurnal conditions had VIP in the iris and ciliary body (not free in aqueous humor) and low levels of SP. Mice that were reared in the dark (or dark-adapted) did not contain detectable levels of VIP but had high levels of SP. The adaptation of diurnal mice to the dark eliminated VIP and increased SP, while adapting dark-reared mice to the diurnal cycle increased VIP and reduced SP. We then tested the hypothesis that immune reactions resulting from Ag presentation in the eye were linked to SP and VIP. We found that a VIP receptor antagonist, when injected into the eye with Ag, reversed ACAID in diurnal mice, while a SP receptor antagonist restored ACAID to dark-adapted mice. We further determined that injection of Ag or TNF-alpha induced VIP release, while SP was liberated into the aqueous humor following reexposure of dark-reared mice to light. Our results demonstrate a close linkage of intraocular immune reactions to neuropeptide levels in the eye.

The immune response and the eye: the ACAID inducing signal is dependent on the nature of the antigen

PURPOSE

To examine conditions that determine the nature of the blood-borne, ACAID-inducing signal produced after intracameral injection of antigen.

METHODS

Balb/c mice were splenectomized, rested, and injected in the anterior chamber with various antigens. Two days later the animals were bled, the plasma and white cells were isolated, and these fractions were transferred to naive mice (with spleens). Recipients were immunized subcutaneously within 2 to 7 days and delayed type hypersensitivity was assessed 10 to 14 days after immunization by challenge with the appropriate antigen.

RESULTS

The antigens HSV-1, TNP-coupled cells, and P815 tumors cells induced a soluble ACAID-inducing signal found in the plasma portion of blood. The soluble protein antigens bovine serum albumin (BSA) and conalbumin induced a cell-associated signal. When T-cells were included with protein antigens, a soluble (not cellular) ACAID-inducing signal was induced.

CONCLUSIONS

Particulate antigens, such as HSV-1 and P815, that elicit intraocular T-cell responses or antigens that contain T-cells (e.g., TNP cells) induce a soluble, ACAID-inducing signal. Soluble antigens (e.g., BSA and conalbumin) induce a cell-associated ACAID signal. Additionally, T-cells are capable of modulating the type of ACAID signal produced. These results show that two methods of delivering the ACAID signal exist that are dependent on the nature of the antigen and the presence of T-cells. The authors conclude that the eye shows great versatility in regulating potentially damaging immune responses.

Regulation of contact hypersensitivity by interleukin 10

Contact hypersensitivity (CHS) responses require the participation of T cells, along with a variety of cytokines and adhesion molecules. In the classical CHS, antigen-specific T cells are recruited to a site of antigenic challenge, where they react with antigen, release cytokines, and attract other inflammatory cells. In the mouse model of CHS, this reaction is elicited in sensitized mice by application of the immunogen 4-7 d after immunization. The reaction peaks at 24 h, is slightly reduced by 48 h, and can return to normal by 72 h. This is in spite of the fact that some antigen is still present at the site of challenge. Here we examined the hypothesis that locally produced interleukin 10 (IL-10) regulates the duration of the response. Our data show that IL-10 protein peaked 10-14 h after antigenic challenge and returned to background by 24 h. The production of IL-10 protein corresponded with, and followed IL-10 mRNA transcription as detected by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction. During peak IL-10 production after antigenic challenge, it was not possible to transfer CHS with immune lymphoid cells, unless neutralizing antibody to IL-10 was given first. Additionally, when sensitized mice were given neutralizing anti-IL-10 antibody at the time of antigenic challenge, the duration of CHS was prolonged well beyond the natural course of the response. Finally, we demonstrate that rIL-10, when injected into the skin before antigenic challenge, prevented the elicitation of CHS in previously sensitized mice. Taken together, our data show an important role for IL-10 in the natural regulation of CHS responses in vivo.

The immune response and the eye: a role for TNF alpha in anterior chamber-associated immune deviation

PURPOSE

Interleukin-1 and tumor necrosis factor (TNF) alpha are proinflammatory cytokines and crucial mediators in many aspects of immunity. In this study, their role in anterior chamber-associated immune deviation (ACAID) was investigated.

METHODS

The role of these cytokines was examined by the use of neutralizing antibodies to TNF and interleukin (IL)-1 alpha, IL-1 beta, and IL-1 receptor. These reagents were co-injected with antigen into the anterior chamber and the effect on ACAID assessed. In addition, reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) was performed on eyes injected with TNP-spleen or bovine serum albumin to determine the levels of TNF alpha mRNA induced.

RESULTS

Neutralizing antibody to TNF, when injected with TNP-spleen cells into the anterior chamber, blocked ACAID to the TNP hapten. Antibodies to IL-1 alpha, IL-1 beta, and IL-1 receptors either alone or in combination did not block the establishment of ACAID: Studies with reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (Rt-PCR) confirmed that early (within 2 hours) after anterior chamber injection of TNP-cells, messenger RNA levels for TNF alpha were dramatically increased. The induction of ACAID to bovine serum albumin also required the production of TNF alpha. Further studies showed that the production of blood borne "ACAID-inducing" signals after anterior chamber injection of bovine serum albumin or TNP-spleen were dependent on TNF.

CONCLUSIONS

TNF alpha plays a crucial role in ACAID: Induction of TNF alpha within the eye may be an important event in the complex series of events that induce ACAID and possibly maintain immunologic privilege.