Altered peptide ligand-induced partial T cell activation: molecular mechanisms and role in T cell biology

Identification of core structure and critical T cell receptor contact residues in an antigenic peptide by measuring acidification rates

A silicon-based biosensor microphysiometer measures real time cell response by monitoring an increase in extracellular acidification rate in response to ligands for specific membrane receptors. We used the microphysiometer to identify the minimal structure and critical residues of an antigenic peptide for its interaction with T cell receptor (TCR) using a synthetic peptide analog of human myelin basic protein (MBP) corresponding to residues 84-102 [MBP(83-102)Y83]. MBP(83-102)Y83 peptide analogs were allowed to interact with TCRs on a DRB5*0101-restricted Herpes virus saimiri (HVS) transformed human T cell clone (SS8T) which also contains major histocompatibility complexes (MHC) class II (DR2) molecules. Cultured SS8T cells were exposed to 11 N-terminus and 11 C-terminus truncated peptides separately in the microphysiometer chambers to determine the minimal amino acid residues required for the T cell response. In parallel, 13 analogs of the MBP(83-102)Y83 peptide with single alanine substitutions were tested in this assay to identify critical amino acid residues involved in TCR interactions. A minimal core length of MBP(91-100) peptide and residues F-91, K-93, N-94, I-95 and V-96 were essential for TCR interaction. Acidification rate measurements correlated well with enhanced levels of gamma-IFN (interferon gamma) and TNF-beta cytokine production and suggested that the increase in the extracellular acidification rate is a direct result of early T cell signaling events.

Biochemical features of anergic T cells

T cell anergy is a functionally defined state of hyporesponsiveness in which T cells neither proliferate nor produce IL2 following subsequent TCR ligation. Recent biochemical data from in vitro studies suggest that anergic cells do not utilize all of the signaling pathways normally initiated by TCR triggering. These findings appear to hold true for T cells rendered anergic in vivo, as well; however, biochemical studies on clonal anergy in vivo have been limited by the inability to recover a homogeneous population of anergic T cells. Here we review progress on TCR mediated signaling pathways as well as the description of surface marker phenotypes specific to T cell anergy.

Selective induction of CD8+ T cell functions by single substituted analogs of an antigenic peptide: distinct signals for IL-10 production

The CD8+ T cell clone 5F1 produces interleukin 10 (IL-10) and interferon gamma(IFN-gamma) in response to stimulation with a peptide corresponding to region 142-149 of bovine alpha(s1)-casein (p142-149). Ninety analog peptides derived from p142-149 with single amino acid substitutions of putative T cell receptor contact residues were prepared to examine whether production of IL-10 and IFN-gamma by 5F1 can be altered by stimulation with these peptides. We found that some peptides triggered only IL-10 production whereas others induced production of IFN-gamma alone or both of these cytokines. Peptides inducing IFN-gamma production triggered both cytotoxicity and a proliferative response, whereas peptides inducing production of IL-10 but not IFN-gamma triggered neither of these responses. Our results clearly demonstrate that the signaling pathway required for IL-10 production in CD8+ T cells differs from that required for IFN-gamma production. The distinct cellular signals for IL-10 production appear to be independent of those for cytotoxicity and the proliferative response of CD8+ T cells.

Islet T cells secreting IFN-gamma in NOD mouse diabetes: arrest by p277 peptide treatment

Non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice spontaneously develop insulin-dependent (type 1) diabetes mellitus (IDDM) caused by T cells which destroy the insulin-producing islet beta-cells. Since cytokines are involved in this auto-immune beta-cell damage, we used an ELISPOT assay to enumerate the islet-associated T cells that secreted interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) or interleukin-4 (IL-4). We used mitogenic anti-CD3 antibody to activate all the T cells capable of responding, irrespective of their antigen specificity. We found that NOD females, more susceptible than males to IDDM, accumulated islet IFN-gamma producers more rapidly with age than did the males. Acceleration of male IDDM by cyclophosphamide led to a marked increase in IFN-gamma secreting islet T cells. In contrast, a decrease in IFN-gamma-producing islet T cells was associated with arrest of IDDM by administration of peptide p277 of the 60 kDa heat-shock protein (hsp60) to 12-week-old female NOD mice. The p277-treated mice later manifested a greater number of islets and fewer leukocytes per islet than did the mice treated with a bacterial hsp60 peptide. Thus, the development of diabetes could be correlated with the accumulation in the islets of T cells producing IFN-gamma, and destructive insulitis could be downregulated by the administration of a single peptide.

Co-capping studies reveal CD8/TCR interactions after capping CD8 beta polypeptides and intracellular associations of CD8 with p56(lck)

CD8 is a T cell surface glycoprotein that participates in recognition of peptide/MHC class I molecules by binding to their alpha 3 domains. In addition, the cytoplasmic domain of CD8 associates with the intracellular tyrosine kinase p56(lck) (lck) promoting recruitment of lck to the TCR signaling complex. Recent data have suggested also that CD8 may interact with the TCR to promote energetically favorable conformations which increase its ligand binding. We have used the techniques of co-capping and confocal microscopy to ask whether we can detect an association between CD8 and the TCR independently of their binding to MHC class I molecules. We show that capping CD8 heterodimers with antibodies to the CD8 beta polypeptide is significantly more efficient than antibodies to the CD8 alpha polypeptide at inducing co-localization of TCR molecules with CD8, suggesting that there may be preferred conformations of CD8 which stabilize interactions with the TCR. In addition, we show by microscopy that intracellular lck redistributes very efficiently to the area of a CD8 cap, suggesting that there is a stronger association between lck and CD8 than has been proposed from immunoprecipitation analyses.

Conserved motifs in T-cell receptor CDR1 and CDR2: implications for ligand and CD8 co-receptor binding

Recent X-ray crystallographic structures of the T-cell receptor (TCR) alpha and beta chains, as well as their trimolecular complexes with peptide-MHC ligand, have established their structural similarity with the immunoglobulin molecules. The complementarity-determining region (CDR1) and CDR2 encoded within the TCR germline variable (V) sequence genes are well conserved across different TCR V alpha and V beta subfamilies. Multiple sequence alignments have been made based on structural information; they indicate that there will be only a limited number of canonical conformations for the first and second CDR loops. The limited diversity shown by CDRs 1 and 2 contrasts with the extreme junctional CDR3 diversity. Furthermore, CDR2 alignments have revealed conservation of a positive net charge in V alpha subfamilies. A model has been proposed for a direct interaction of the lateral part of CDR2 alpha with the negatively charged membrane-proximal 'stalk' region of the CD8 molecule.

CD4 and CD8: modulators of T-cell receptor recognition of antigen and of immune responses?

The response of T cells to antigen involves the participation of a number of distinct receptor-ligand engagements. The major players in the recognition of complexes of major histocompatibility complex molecules and peptide antigens are the T-cell receptors and the co-receptors CD4 and CD8. Progress in understanding the physical structures of these molecules, and how complexes between them are formed, is helping our understanding of how they participate in regulating the signals transduced to T cells.

Cutting Edge Commentary: Differential TCR Signaling and the Generation of Memory T Cells

There are currently two models for the generation of memory T cells: 1) memory T cells arise directly from activated effector T cells that have reverted to the resting state via an unknown mechanism; and 2) memory T cells are generated directly from naive T cells, bypassing an effector stage. I discuss here how recent results on the activation and signaling requirements of naive vs memory CD4 T cells favor the second model and how differential signaling of naive T cells may direct their developmental outcome.

The role of regulatory T cells in Lewis rats resistant to EAE

Adult Lewis (LEW) rats are highly susceptible to experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), induced actively by immunization with guinea pig (GP) myelin basic protein (MBP) in complete Freund's adjuvant or adoptively transferred with activated T lymphocytes reactive to GP MBP peptide 68-88. Once LEW rats recover from active EAE or when given MBP in incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA), they become resistant to further attempts to induce active or passive EAE. In this study, we examined whether such EAE-resistant rats after MBP-IFA immunization have reduced frequencies of MBP-reactive T cells, whether these T cells are anergized, and whether the activity of regulatory T cells is increased to the event that they prevent activation of MBP-specific T cell subpopulations. By limiting dilution analyses (LDA) of unfractionated splenic T cells, the levels of MBP-reactive T cells in EAE-resistant rats appeared to be approximately 5% of the levels in EAE-susceptible rats. However, a subsequent analysis of CD4+ enriched T cell populations, depleted of the CD8 subset, showed similar frequencies of MBP-reactive cells in susceptible and resistant LEW rats. Not only were the frequencies on LDA altered by suppressor cells, but also LDA comparisons based on cell proliferation and cytokine production as indicators of MBP reactive cell frequencies gave markedly different results. We conclude that MBP-reactive T cells in this model of EAE-resistant LEW rats are hyporeactive to MBP as the result of an increased activity of a regulatory subset of CD8+ T cells. These results also demonstrate that the quantitation of MBP-reactive CD4+ T cells by LDA is strongly influenced by the presence of functionally antagonistic CD8+ T cells, which cause an underestimation of responder T cell frequencies, and by the method of detecting T cell reactivity.

Following the fate of individual T cells throughout activation and clonal expansion. Signals from T cell receptor and CD28 differentially regulate the induction and duration of a proliferative response

A detailed understanding of the effects of costimulatory signals on primary T cell expansion has been limited by experimental approaches that measure the bulk response of a cell population, without distinguishing responses of individual cells. Here, we have labeled live T cells in vitro with a stable, fluorescent dye that segregates equally between daughter cells upon cell division, allowing the proliferative history of any T cell present or generated during a response to be monitored over time. This system permits simultaneous evaluation of T cell surface markers, allowing concomitant assessment of cellular activation and quantitative determination of T cell receptor (TCR) occupancy on individual cells. Through this approach, we find that TCR engagement primarily regulates the frequency of T cells that enter the proliferative pool, but has relatively little effect on the number of times these cells will ultimately divide. In contrast, CD28-costimulation regulates both the frequency of responding cells (particularly at sub-maximal levels of TCR engagement), and more prominently, the number of mitotic events that responding cells undergo. When CD28-stimulation is blocked, provision of IL-2 restores the frequency of responding cells and the normal pattern of mitotic progression, indicating that the other CD28-induced genes are not required for this effect. An unexpected finding was that even at maximal levels of TCR engagement and CD28-mediated costimulation, only 50-60% of the original T cells in culture can be induced to divide. The nondividing cells are heterogeneous for naive versus memory markers, suggesting a more complex relationship between expression of memory markers and the ability to be recruited into the dividing pool. From these studies, we conclude that a stringent checkpoint regulates the participation of activated T cells in clonal expansion, with TCR and CD28 signals having both overlapping and differential effects on the induction and maintenance of T cell responses.

Systemic antigen in the treatment of T-cell-mediated autoimmune diseases

Systemic injection of antigen is one of the approaches that reproducibly induces effective antigen-specific hyporesponsiveness. Here, Roland Liblau and colleagues discuss the cellular and molecular bases of such tolerance, review the current use of this therapeutic strategy in experimental organ-specific autoimmune diseases and analyse what steps are necessary to make this approach suitable for clinical use.

Analysis of immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif (ITAM) binding to ZAP-70 by surface plasmon resonance

The signaling function of the T cell antigen receptor (TCR) is mediated via CD3 polypeptides, the cytoplasmic sequences of which bear conserved immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motifs (ITAM). ITAM are defined by two YxxL/I sequences separated by a six-eight amino acid long spacer. Upon antigen recognition, ITAM become phosphorylated on both tyrosine residues, creating a high affinity binding site for the tandem SH2 domains found in the protein tyrosine kinase ZAP-70. Using surface plasmon resonance, we further dissected the sequences required for the binding of ZAP-70 to each TCR-associated ITAM. First, we generated protein tyrosine phosphatase-resistant ITAM peptide analogs, in which difluorophosphonomethyl phenylalanyl (F2p) replaced both phosphotyrosines, and showed that those protein tyrosine phosphatase-resistant analogs bind ZAP-70 with high affinity, establishing a rational strategy for the design of novel pharmacological tools capable of interfering with TCR signaling function. Second, we substituted the five amino acids separating the two YxxL/I sequences of the CD3 zeta 1 ITAM with a non-peptidic linker made up of gamma-amino butyric acid units and demonstrated that the length of this intervening sequence rather than its chemical composition is essential for high affinity binding of phosphorylated ITAM to the ZAP-70 SH2 domains.

The tetramer model: a new view of class II MHC molecules in antigenic presentation to T cells

Crystallographic studies suggest a plausible divalent interaction between T-cell receptor (TCR) and MHC class II molecules. In addition, biochemical data suggest that these divalent MHC molecules are preformed at the membrane of the antigen-presenting cell. The tetramer model is based on these preformed tetrameric class II molecules that can be loaded with identical or different peptides in their two grooves. This enables divalent class II molecules to deliver two different messages to T cell: 1) a two-peptide message, in which the tetramer with two identical peptides is able to cross-link two TCRs triggering full activation of a T cell. At the thymic level we propose that this message induces negative selection; or 2) a one-peptide message: only one of the peptides loaded in the class II tetramer is able to interact with that TCR. This message would be involved in triggering partial activation phenomena in mature lymphocytes, whereas in thymocytes this message would mediate positive selection. Since high concentrations of a peptide would favor the load of tetramers with identical peptides, the tetramer could therefore be viewed as a quantitative-qualitative transducer that would trigger different responses depending on the concentration of antigenic peptides.

T cell inactivation and cytokine deviation promoted by anti-CD3 mAbs

Fc receptor nonbinding anti-CD3 monoclonal antibodies show promise for clinical application, in that they suppress graft rejection without the toxicity associated with conventional anti-CD3 antibody therapy. Recent studies suggest that the mechanism of soluble anti-CD3 antibody mediated immunosuppression involves partial signaling, induced cytokine deviation and Th1 cell inactivation.

Endosomal proteases and antigen processing

T cells are activated by fragments of antigenic proteins bound to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules and displayed on the cell surface. MHC class II proteins scavenge processed protein antigens from within endosomal compartments. The antigenic peptides are generated within these and other intracellular compartments using the array of proteolytic enzymes normally involved in terminal protein degradation. Antigen-presenting cells use different mechanisms to exploit and control the activity of these enzymes so as to ensure the generation of a wide variety of peptides, while preventing the destruction of antigenic epitopes by excessive proteolysis.

Genetic analysis of host-parasite coevolution in human malaria

Recent twin studies of clinical malaria and immune responses to malaria antigens have underscored the importance of both major histocompatability complex (MHC) and non-MHC genes in determining variable susceptibility and immune responsiveness. By using a combination of whole genome genetic linkage studies of families and candidate genes analysis, non-MHC genes are being mapped and identified. Human leucocyte antigen (HLA) genotype was found to affect susceptibility to severe malaria in a large study of West African children. T lymphocytes that may mediate such resistance have been identified and their target antigens and epitopes characterized. Some of these epitopes show substantial polymorphism, which appears to result from immune selection pressure. Natural variant epitopes have been found to escape T-cell recognition in cytolytic and other T-cell assays. More recently a novel immune escape mechanism has been described in viral infections, altered peptide ligand antagonism, whereby variants of a T-cell epitope can downregulate or ablate a T cell response to the index peptide. The likely implications of such immune escape mechanisms for the population structure of malaria parasites, for HLA associations with malaria infection and disease, and for the design of new malaria vaccines, are discussed. The evolutionary consequences of such molecular interactions can be assessed by using mathematical models that capture the dynamic of variable host and parasite molecules. Combined genetic, immunological and mathematical analysis of host and parasite variants in natural populations can identify some mechanisms driving host-parasite coevolution.

p56lck is not essential for the T-cell response to allo-MHC antigens

In mice lacking the src family protein tyrosine kinase, p 56lck (lck -/-), a greatly reduced number of peripheral T cells is observed due to a profound blockage of the thymocyte development. The peripheral T cells in lck -/- mice exhibit proliferative response after T-cell receptor (TCR)-crosslinking, but can not respond to viral antigens. In this report, we examined the allo-responses of peripheral T cells in the lck -/- mice and the following results were thus obtained. (1) After an intravenous injection of fully allogeneic [allo-major histocompatability complex (MHC)] spleen cells, an increase of interleukin (IL)-2R alpha+ cells was observed in both the CD4+ or CD8+ peripheral T cells of the lck -/- mice and the increase was similar to those in the lck +/+ littermate, with only a somewhat delayed and prolonged time kinetics observed in the CD4+ T cells of the lck -/- mice. (2) the lck -/- mice rejected the fully allogeneic trunk skin grafts several days later than the lck +/+ mice, but did not reject the minor allogeneic grafts. (3) The peripheral T cells of the graft-rejected lck -/- mice exhibited a weaker but significantly proliferative response, while the cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) activities to allo-MHC antigens in vitro were comparable to those in lck +/+ mice. While the response to the minor allo-antigens was shown by the peripheral T cells in the lck +/+ mice with minor allogeneic skin grafts but not by those in the lck -/- mice with the grafts. These results thus suggest that p56lck is not essential for peripheral T cells to both respond and exhibit effector functions to allo-MHC antigens.

Induction of a heterogeneous TCR repertoire in (PL/JXSJL/J)F1 mice by myelin basic protein peptide Ac1-11 and its analog Ac1-11[4A]

Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) serves as a rodent model of the autoimmune disease multiple sclerosis. In mice, EAE is induced by immunizing with spinal cord homogenate, components of the myelin sheath, such as myelin basic protein (MBP) or proteolipid protein (PLP), or peptides derived from these components. EAE can be induced in H-2u or (H-2u x H-2s)F1 mice with the N-terminal peptide of MBP, Ac1-11. Coimmunization with Ac1-11 and Ac1-11[4A], an analog in which lysine at position four is substituted with alanine, prevents EAE. The mechanism of inhibition has not been elucidated, but probably does not work through MHC blockade, T cell anergy or clonal elimination of encephalitogenic T cells. We have isolated T cell clones and hybridomas from (PL/J x SJL/J)F1 mice immunized with either Ac1-11 alone or Ac1-11 and Ac1-11[4A] and analysed these cells for differences in their T cell receptor repertoire and in vitro response. Although T cells elicited by coinjection of Ac1-11 and Ac1-11[4A] expressed TCR that used V alpha and Vbeta gene elements similar to those elicited by Ac1-11 alone, they differed in the sequences of the junctional region of the alpha chain. Most of these T cells also responded less well to Ac1-11 in vitro, suggesting that coinjection of Ac1-11 and Ac1-11[4A] preferentially activates T cells bearing TCR of different affinity for Ac1-11 bound to I-A(u), and which may therefore be less encephalitogenic. Furthermore, our results show that a more diverse repertoire of V alpha and Vbeta genes are elicited by Ac1-11 in (PL/J x SJL/J)F1 mice compared to PL/J and B10.PL mice, providing further evidence that a restricted TCR repertoire is not required for the development of autoimmune disease.

Antigen-specific T cell receptor antagonism by antigen-presenting cells treated with the hemolysin of Listeria monocytogenes: a novel type of immune escape

We have examined the influence of listeriolysin O (LLO), the hemolysin secreted by the pathogenic bacterium Listeria monocytogenes, on major histocompatibility complex class II-dependent T cell activation. Stimulation of T cells by native antigens but not by peptides is inhibited upon pretreatment of antigen-presenting cells (APC) with LLO. Experiments presented here reveal that this inhibition is not due to a lack in processing of antigen by APC but is the result of an irreversible inactivation of T cells that recognize antigen on LLO-treated APC. Incubation of mixtures of two different T cells where only one antigen was presented on LLO-treated APC suggested that T cell inactivation is antigen specific. The inactivation was dominant and could be observed even in the presence of amounts of synthetic peptides that normally lead to T cell responses. This condition is reminiscent of the T cell inhibition observed when antagonistic and stimulatory peptides are added to APC at the same time. Our results thus reveal a novel type of interference by pathogens with antigen presentation and T cell stimulation that could give the pathogen a decisive advantage in dissemination and disease.

Human minor histocompatibility antigens: new concepts for marrow transplantation and adoptive immunotherapy

Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) is the present treatment for hematological malignancies. Two major drawbacks of allogeneic BMT are graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) and leukemia relapse. The use of HLA-matched siblings as marrow donors results in the best transplant outcome. Nonetheless, the results of clinical BMT reveal that the selection of MHC-identical donors' bone marrow (BM) is no guarantee for avoiding GVHD or ensuring disease-free survival even when donor and recipient are closely related. It is believed that non-MHC-encoded so-called minor histocompatibility antigens (mHag) are involved in both graft-versus-host and graft-versus-leukemia activities. The recent new insights into the chemical nature of mHag not only reveal their physiological function but, more importantly, provide insights into their role in BMT. Together with the information on the human mHag genetics and tissue distribution gathered in the past, we may now apply this knowledge to the benefit of human BMT. Directly relevant is the utility of mHag molecular typing for diagnostics in BM donor selection. Most promising is the use of mHag-specific cytotoxic T cells for adoptive immunotherapy of leukemia.

A retro-inverso analog mimics the cognate peptide epitope of a CD4+ T cell clone

Synthetic analogs of peptide epitopes may activate specific T helper cells, antagonize their antigen receptors, or block recognition by competing for major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II binding sites. Rationally designed peptides may therefore prove useful as vaccines and for treatment of autoimmune diseases and allergies mediated by CD4+ T cells. However, their susceptibility to proteolytic degradation limits the applicability of conventional peptides in vivo. By contrast, retro-inverso analogs, in which a native sequence is substituted with D-amino acids linked with a reversed backbone, resist proteolysis and still maintain the side chain topology of the corresponding natural peptide. We report here that an end group-modified retro-inverso analog of the IgG2ab heavy chain allopeptide determinant gamma 2ab 435-447 was recognized by an I-Ad-restricted, gamma 2ab 435-447-reactive T cell clone. The pseudopeptide elicited near-maximal interleukin-2 responses, although 300-fold higher concentrations were needed than the native determinant. The weaker antigenicity of the retro-inverso analog could be fully accounted for by an impaired I-Ad binding capacity, which might reflect reduced ability of the distorted main chain to form hydrogen bonds with I-Ad. Glycine substitution at the residue corresponding to the first primary anchor (P1) of the native peptide abrogated I-Ad binding and antigenicity of the retro-inverso analog. Thus, the pseudopeptide resembled the native determinant with respect to orientation in the class II binding site, configuration of the epitopic side chains, and the constraints that governed the interactions between a major anchoring side chain and I-Ad. In conclusion, proteolytically resistant compounds with predefined capacity to interact with MHC class II allelic products and T cell antigen receptors may be designed by retro-inverso modification of native determinants.

T-cell anergy induced by antigen presenting cells treated with the hemolysin of Listeria monocytogenes

Antigen presenting cells (APC) that are infected with listeriolysin (LLO) secreting Listeria lack the ability to stimulate MHC class II restricted T-cells by conventional antigens. Similarly, T-cell activation by native proteins but not by peptides was inhibited upon pretreatment of APC with purified listeriolysin. The inhibition is due to an irreversible inactivation of T-cells that recognize antigen on infected or LLO treated APC. Inhibition was found to dominate over stimulation by peptides. This condition is reminiscent of T-cells inactivation by antagonistic peptides and represents a novel type of immune escape.

Altered hapten ligands antagonize trinitrophenyl-specific cytotoxic T cells and block internalization of hapten-specific receptors

Low molecular chemicals (haptens) frequently cause T cell-mediated adverse immune reactions. Our previous work provided evidence that hapten-specific T cells, in analogy to those specific for nominal peptide antigens, direct their TCR towards hapten-modified, MHC-associated peptides. We now demonstrate that trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific, class I MHC-restricted CTL from mice may exhibit exquisite specificity for subtle structural details of these hapten determinants, surpassing even the specificity of immunoglobulins. More importantly, these CTL could be antagonized by ligands altered either in their peptide sequence or in their hapten structure. The system was employed to examine the molecular basis of T cell antagonism. Whereas agonists resulted in a dose-dependent downregulation of TCR in different mouse T cell clones, antagonistic peptides totally failed to do so despite engaging the specific TCR. Moreover, simultaneous presentation of antagonist and agonist on the same antigen presenting cell prevented TCR internalization. No signs of anergy or functional receptor inactivation were observed in CTL treated with antagonist-loaded target cells. Based on a serial triggering model of T cell activation, our data favor a model in which antagonists block T cell functions by competitively engaging the specific TCR in unproductive interactions.

Kinetics and extent of T cell activation as measured with the calcium signal

We have characterized the calcium response of a peptide-major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-specific CD4(+) T lymphocyte line at the single cell level using a variety of ligands, alone and in combination. We are able to distinguish four general patterns of intracellular calcium elevation, with only the most robust correlating with T cell proliferation. Whereas all three antagonist peptides tested reduce the calcium response to an agonist ligand, two give very different calcium release patterns and the third gives none at all, arguing that (a) antagonism does not require calcium release and (b) it involves interactions that are more T cell receptor proximal. We have also measured the time between the first T cell-antigen-presenting cell contact and the onset of the calcium signal. The duration of this delay correlates with the strength of the stimulus, with stronger stimuli giving a more rapid response. The dose dependence of this delay suggests that the rate-limiting step in triggering the calcium response is not the clustering of peptide-MHC complexes on the cell surface but more likely involves the accumulation of some intracellular molecule or complex with a half-life of a few minutes.

The anatomical basis of intestinal immunity

The lymphoid tissues associated with the intestine are exposed continuously to antigen and are the largest part of the immune system. Many lymphocytes are found in organised tissues such as the Peyer's patches and mesenteric lymph nodes, as well as scattered throughout the lamina propria and epithelium of the mucosa itself. These lymphocyte populations have several unusual characteristics and the intestinal immune system is functionally and anatomically distinct from other, peripheral compartments of the immune system. This review explores the anatomical and molecular basis of these differences, with particular emphasis on the factors which determine how the intestinal lymphoid tissues discriminate between harmful pathogens and antigens which are beneficial, such as food proteins or commensal bacteria. These latter antigens normally provoke immunological tolerance, and inappropriate responses to them are responsible for immunopathologies such as food hypersensitivity and inflammatory bowel disease. We describe how interactions between local immune cells, epithelial tissues and antigen-presenting cells may be critical for the induction of tolerance and the expression of active mucosal immunity. In addition, the possibility that the intestine may act as an extrathymic site for T-cell differentiation is discussed. Finally, we propose that, under physiological conditions, immune responses to food antigens and commensal bacteria are prevented by common regulatory mechanisms, in which transforming growth factor beta plays a critical role.

Effects of epitope modification on T cell receptor-ligand binding and antigen recognition by seven H-2Kd-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones specific for a photoreactive peptide derivative

We tested for antigen recognition and T cell receptor (TCR)-ligand binding 12 peptide derivative variants on seven H-2Kd-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) clones specific for a bifunctional photoreactive derivative of the Plasmodium berghei circumsporozoite peptide 252-260 (SYIPSAEKI). The derivative contained iodo-4-azidosalicylic acid in place of PbCS S-252 and 4-azidobenzoic acid on PbCS K-259. Selective photoactivation of the N-terminal photoreactive group allowed crosslinking to Kd molecules and photoactivation of the orthogonal group to TCR. TCR photoaffinity labeling with covalent Kd-peptide derivative complexes allowed direct assessment of TCR-ligand binding on living CTL. In most cases (over 80%) cytotoxicity (chromium release) and TCR-ligand binding differed by less than fivefold. The exceptions included (a) partial TCR agonists (8 cases), for which antigen recognition was five-tenfold less efficient than TCR-ligand binding, (b) TCR antagonists (2 cases), which were not recognized and capable of inhibiting recognition of the wild-type conjugate, (c) heteroclitic agonists (2 cases), for which antigen recognition was more efficient than TCR-ligand binding, and (d) one partial TCR agonist, which activated only Fas (C1)95), but not perforin/granzyme-mediated cytotoxicity. There was no correlation between these divergences and the avidity of TCR-ligand binding, indicating that other factors than binding avidity determine the nature of the CTL response. An unexpected and novel finding was that CD8-dependent clones clearly incline more to TCR antagonism than CD8-independent ones. As there was no correlation between CD8 dependence and the avidity of TCR-ligand binding, the possibility is suggested that CD8 plays a critical role in aberrant CTL function.

The single positive T cells found in CD3-zeta/eta-/- mice overtly react with self-major histocompatibility complex molecules upon restoration of normal surface density of T cell receptor-CD3 complex

CD3-zeta/eta-deficient mice have small thymuses containing cells that show a profound reduction in the surface levels of T cell receptors and terminate their differentiation at the CD4+CD8+ stage. Rather unexpectedly, CD3- or very low single positive T cells accumulate over time in the spleen and lymph nodes of CD3-zeta/eta-deficient mice after a process dependent on MHC expression. Fusion of these peripheral T cells with a CD3-zeta-positive derivative of the BW5147 TCR-alpha-/beta- thymoma resulted in hybridomas that do express an heterogeneous set of T cell receptor alpha/beta dimers at their surface and at density comparable to those found in hybridomas derived from wild-type peripheral T cells. We have investigated the specificities of these T cell receptors using spleen cells from congenic and mutant mouse strains, and showed that the majority of them readily recognized self-MHC class I or class II molecules. These results demonstrate that by increasing the density and/or output of the T cell receptors expressed in peripheral T cells, one can confer them with the capacity to respond to normal density of self-MHC molecules.

The efficiency of CD4 recruitment to ligand-engaged TCR controls the agonist/partial agonist properties of peptide-MHC molecule ligands

One hypothesis seeking to explain the signaling and biological properties of T cell receptor for antigen (TCR) partial agonists and antagonists is the coreceptor density/kinetic model, which proposes that the pharmacologic behavior of a TCR ligand is largely determined by the relative rates of (a) dissociation ofligand from an engaged TCR and (b) recruitment oflck-linked coreceptors to this ligand-engaged receptor. Using several approaches to prevent or reduce the association of CD4 with occupied TCR, we demonstrate that consistent with this hypothesis, the biological and biochemical consequence of limiting this interaction is to convert typical agonists into partial agonist stimuli. Thus, adding anti-CD4 antibody to T cells recognizing a wild-type peptide-MHC class II ligand leads to disproportionate inhibition of interleukin-2 (IL-2) relative to IL-3 production, the same pattern seen using a TCR partial agonist/antagonist. In addition, T cells exposed to wild-type ligand in the presence of anti-CD4 antibodies show a pattern of TCR signaling resembling that seen using partial agonists, with predominant accumulation of the p21 tyrosine-phosphorylated form of TCR-zeta, reduced tyrosine phosphorylation of CD3epsilon, and no detectable phosphorylation of ZAP-70. Similar results are obtained when the wild-type ligand is presented by mutant class II MHC molecules unable to bind CD4. Likewise, antibody coligation of CD3 and CD4 results in an agonist-like phosphorylation pattern, whereas bivalent engagement of CD3 alone gives a partial agonist-like pattern. Finally, in accord with data showing that partial agonists often induce T cell anergy, CD4 blockade during antigen exposure renders cloned T cells unable to produce IL-2 upon restimulation. These results demonstrate that the biochemical and functional responses to variant TCR ligands with partial agonist properties can be largely reproduced by inhibiting recruitment of CD4 to a TCR binding a wild-type ligand, consistent with the idea that the relative rates of TCR-ligand disengagement and of association of engaged TCR with CD4 may play a key role in determining the pharmacologic properties of peptide-MHC molecule ligands. Beyond this insight into signaling through the TCR, these results have implications for models of thymocyte selection and the use of anti-coreceptor antibodies in vivo for the establishment ofimmunological tolerance.

Functional inactivation in the whole population of human V gamma 9/V delta 2 T lymphocytes induced by a nonpeptidic antagonist

Nonpeptidic compounds stimulate human T cells bearing the TCR-gamma delta in the absence of major histocompatibility complex restriction. We report that one of these ligands, 2,3-diphosphoglyceric acid (DPG), which induces expansion of V gamma 9/V delta T cells ex vivo, antagonizes the same cell population after repetitive activation. Stimulation with DPG results in partial early protein tyrosine phosphorylation and a prolonged, but reversible, state of unresponsiveness to agonist ligands in V gamma 9/V delta 2, but not in other T cells. These findings show that TCR antagonism is a general phenomenon of T cells. However, in contrast to the clonal specificity of altered peptides antagonizing alpha beta T cells, all the tested V gamma 9/V delta 2 polyclonal cell lines and clones become unresponsive, a fact that may be relevant for the regulation of their response in vivo.

Induction of Th1 and Th2 CD4+ T cell responses: the alternative approaches

T helper lymphocytes can be divided into two distinct subsets of effector cells based on their functional capabilities and the profile of cytokines they produce. The Th1 subset of CD4+ T cells secretes cytokines usually associated with inflammation, such as IFN-gamma and TNF and induces cell-mediated immune responses. The Th2 subset produces cytokines such as IL-4 and IL-5 that help B cells to proliferate and differentiate and is associated with humoral-type immune responses. The selective differentiation of either subset is established during priming and can be significantly influenced by a variety of factors. One of these factors, the cytokine environment, has been put forward as the major variable influencing Th development and is already well reviewed by others. Instead, in the current review, we focus on some of the alternative approaches for skewing Th1/Th2 responses. Specifically, we discuss the effects on Th priming of (a) using altered peptide ligands as antigens, (b) varying the dose of antigen, and (c) altering costimulatory signals. The potential importance of each of these variables to influence immune responses to pathogens in vivo is discussed throughout.

Differential signaling by lymphocyte antigen receptors

Studies performed during the past several years make plain that ligand occupancy of antigen receptors need not necessarily provoke identical responses in all instances. For example, ligation of antigen receptors may stimulate a proliferative response, induce a state of unresponsiveness to subsequent stimulation (anergy), or induce apoptosis. How does a single type of transmembrane receptor induce these very heterogeneous cellular responses? In the following pages, we outline evidence supporting the view that the nature of the ligand/receptor interaction directs the physical recruitment of signaling pathways differentially inside the lymphocyte and hence defines the nature of the subsequent immune response. We begin by providing a functional categorization of antigen receptor components, considering the ways in which these components interact with the known set of signal transduction pathways, and then review the evidence suggesting that differential signaling through the TCR is achieved by qualitative differences in the effector pathways recruited by TCR, perhaps reflecting the time required to bring complicated signal transduction elements into proximity within the cell. The time-constant of the interaction between antigen and receptor in this way determines, at least in part, the nature of the resulting response. Finally, although our review focuses substantially on T cell receptor signaling, we have included a less detailed description of B cell receptor signaling as well, simply to emphasize the parallels that exist in these two closely related systems.

Antigen-specific inhibition of CD4+ T-cell responses to beta-lactoglobulin by its single amino acid-substituted mutant form through T-cell receptor antagonism

T-cell responses can be antagonized by some single amino acid-substituted analogs of a peptide ligand for T-cell receptors (TCR), and these are called TCR antagonists. In this study, we addressed the question of whether TCR antagonism can be elicited by a whole protein antigen carrying a mutated T-cell determinant region corresponding to a TCR antagonist peptide. To clarify this, we examined the ability of a single amino acid-substituted mutant form of bovine beta-lactoglobulin (beta-Lg) to inhibit three CD4+ T-cell clones recognizing a peptide corresponding to an immunodominant determinant region 119-133 of beta-Lg (p119-133). First, we identified pD129A, an analog of p119-133 with a substitution of Ala for 129Asp, as an antagonist which can inhibit the response of two of the three T-cell clones. Then, using a yeast expression system, we prepared a mutant beta-Lg (mutD129A) with the same substitution of Ala for 129Asp as that in pD129A. This mutant protein could inhibit the proliferation of the two T-cell clones in a manner similar to the effect of pD129A. From these results we can demonstrate that TCR antagonism can be elicited by peptides naturally processed from a single-substituted mutant protein as well as by the corresponding peptides added exogenously.

T cell receptor biochemistry, repertoire selection and general features of TCR and Ig structure

T cell recognition is a central event in the development of most immune responses, whether appropriate or inappropriate (i.e. autoimmune). We are interested in reducing T cell recognition to its most elemental components and relating this to biological outcome. In a model system involving a cytochrome c-specific I-Ek restricted T cell receptor (TCR) derived from the 2B4 hybridoma, we have studied the interaction of soluble TCR and soluble peptide-MHC complexes using surface plasmon resonance. We find a striking continuum in which biological activity correlates best with the dissociation rate of the TCR from the peptide-MHC complex. In particular, we have found that weak agonists have significantly faster off-rates than strong agonists and that antagonists have even faster off-rates. This suggests that the stability of TCR binding to a given ligand is critically important with respect to whether the T cell is stimulated, inhibited or remains indifferent. It also suggests that the phenomenon of peptide antagonists might be explained purely by kinetic models and that conformation, either inter- or intramolecular, may not be a factor. We have also studied TCR repertoire selection during the establishment of a cytochrome c response, initially using an anti-TCR antibody strategy, but more recently using peptide-MHC tetramers as antigen-specific staining reagents. These tetramers work well with either class I or class II MHC-specific TCRs and have many possible applications. Lastly, we have also tried to correlate the structural and genetic features of TCRs with their function. Recent data on TCR structure as well as previous findings with antibodies suggest that both molecules are highly dependent on CDR3 length and sequence variation to form specific contacts with antigens. This suggests a general "logic' behind TCR and Ig genetics as it relates to structure and function that helps to explain certain anomalous findings and makes a number of clear predictions.

Collaboration of TCR-, CD4- and CD28-mediated signalling in antigen-specific MHC class II-restricted T-cells

A previously developed experimental system was applied to obtain qualitative and quantitative data on the contribution of TCR-, CD4- and CD28-mediated signalling in the activation of an antigen specific T-cell hybridoma. All the three signal transducing receptors were stimulated by their natural ligands, and intermediate and late responses of an I-Ed restricted, CD4 +, influenza HA specific murine T-hybridoma (IP-12-7) were monitored by measuring the concentration of intracellular calcium [Ca2+]i and secreted IL-2. This type of analysis of T-cell activation revealed: (i) calcium mobilization induced by peptide loaded APC requires rapid conjugate formation; (ii) a direct correlation between the magnitude of the intermediate and the late responses was observed as a consequence of differential TCR ligation modulated by peptide dose or by the presence CD4; (iii) considering the APC/peptide and T/APC ratios, the concentration dependence of the intermediate and late responses was similar in both assays but a substantial difference in the sensitivity of the two methods was observed; (iv) CD4 mediated signalling has a co-stimulatory effect predominantly at suboptimal in vitro conditions; and (v) sustained increase of [Ca2+]i as well as the production of high concentrations of IL-2 is highly dependent on the CD28-B7 interaction. These results demonstrate that distinct peptide doses and the presence or absence of CD4 result in quantitative changes in T-cell responses, while the degree of CD28 mediated signalling has a qualitative affect on the outcome of T-cell activation, revealed by complete or partial inhibition of IL-2 secretion as a result of limited CD28-B7 interaction as well as by alteration in the duration and time kinetics of the calcium response.

Functional diversity of helper T lymphocytes

The existence of subsets of CD4+ helper T lymphocytes that differ in their cytokine secretion patterns and effector functions provides a framework for understanding the heterogeneity of normal and pathological immune responses. Defining the cellular and molecular mechanisms of helper-T-cell differentiation should lead to rational strategies for manipulating immune responses for prophylaxis and therapy.

Transplantation tolerance: fooling mother nature

Images

The natural killer cell receptor Ly-49A recognizes a peptide-induced conformational determinant on its major histocompatibility complex class I ligand

Natural killer (NK) cells are inhibited from killing cellular targets by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules. In the mouse, this can be mediated by the Ly-49A NK cell receptor that specifically binds the H-2Dd MHC class I molecule, then inhibits NK cell activity. Previous experiments have indicated that Ly-49A recognizes the alpha 1/alpha 2 domains of MHC class I and that no specific MHC-bound peptide appeared to be involved. We demonstrate here that alanine-substituted peptides, having only the minimal anchor motifs, stabilized H-2Dd expression and provided resistance to H-2Dd-transfected, transporter associated with processing (TAP)-deficient cells from lysis by Ly-49A+ NK cells. Peptide-induced resistance was blocked only by an mAb that binds a conformational determinant on H-2Dd. Moreover, stabilization of "empty" H-2Dd heavy chains by exogenous beta 2-microglobulin did not confer resistance. In contrast to data for MHC class I-restricted T cells that are specific for peptides displayed MHC molecules, these data indicate that NK cells are specific for a peptide-induced conformational determinant, independent of specific peptide. This fundamental distinction between NK cells and T cells further implies that NK cells are sensitive only to global changes in MHC class I conformation or expression, rather than to specific pathogen-encoded peptides. This is consistent with the "missing self" hypothesis, which postulates that NK cells survey tissues for normal expression of MHC class I.

Selective activation of the calcium signaling pathway by altered peptide ligands

We previously demonstrated that altered peptide ligands (APL) can partially activate T cells, resulting in multiple distinct functional phenotypes, including the induction of anergy. Such APL stimulate a unique pattern of T cell receptor (TCR) phospho-zeta species, and lack associated ZAP-70 kinase activity. While these data suggested that selective signaling pathways downstream of the TCR/CD3 molecules are activated upon APL stimulation, they did not directly demonstrate this. Thus, we pursued intracellular signaling events successfully stimulated by APL. Because our previous studies showed that cyclosporin A (CsA) completely inhibited anergy induction, we assessed whether TCR ligation by APL cause a rise in cytosolic calcium (Ca+2). Our results show that these ligands can induce Ca+2 transients, in contrast to data generated using analogue peptides in other antigen systems. These opposing results may reflect differences in the intracellular signaling pathways utilized by different APL, or may be due to the exquisite sensitivity of the assay used here. Importantly, the APL-stimulated Ca+2 induction is both initiated and sustained at lower levels than that stimulated by a strong agonist signal, but resembles that stimulated by a weaker agonist stimulus. Alone, the less than optimal Ca+2 induction does not cause anergy, because ionomycin treatment together with the APL does not result in a proliferative signal. Instead, we propose that a combination of this and other signaling pathways induces T cell anergy. Overall, these data support the concept of differential signaling in T cells, as a direct consequence of the phosphotyrosine status of the TCR/CD3 molecules.

Structural basis for T cell recognition of altered peptide ligands: a single T cell receptor can productively recognize a large continuum of related ligands

T cells recognize short linear peptides bound to major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-encoded molecules. Subtle molecular changes in peptide antigens produce altered peptide ligands (APLs), which induce different T cell responses from those induced by the antigenic ligand. A molecular basis for how these slight molecular variations lead to such different consequences for the T cell has not been described. To address this issue, we have made amino acid substitutions at the primary T cell receptor (TCR) contact residue of the murine hemoglobin determinant, Hb(64-76)/I-Ek and produced 12 peptides that interact with the TCR of the T cell clone 3.L2. The 3.L2 T cell responds to these peptides, which vary 1 million-fold in their activity, and enables them to be ranked according to their relative ability to signal through the 3.L2 TCR. Such a ranking reveals that the ability of the 3.L2 T cell to respond to these peptides depends on how well the structure of the side chain at the primary TCR contact site mimics that of the Asn residue present in the antigenic ligand. The reactivity of the 3.L2 T cell also depends on an MHC contact residue that is next to the primary TCR contact residue, suggesting that conformation of the Asn side chain is also important. By using nonnatural amino acids at a TCR contact residue, we have demonstrated that APLs can be rationally designed based on structure. These data are consistent with a model in which the affinity of a peptide-MHC complex for the TCR determines how the T cell will respond.

A TCR binds to antagonist ligands with lower affinities and faster dissociation rates than to agonists

T lymphocyte activation is mediated by the interaction of specific TCR with antigenic peptides bound to MHC molecules. Single amino acid substitutions are often capable of changing the effect of a peptide from stimulatory to antagonistic. Using surface plasmon resonance, we have analyzed the interaction between a complex consisting of variants of the MCC peptide bound to a mouse class II MHC (Ek) and a specific TCR. Using both an improved direct binding method as well as a novel inhibition assay, we show that the affinities of three different antagonist peptide-Ek complexes are approximately 10-50 times lower than that of the wildtype MCC-Ek complex for the TCR, largely due to an increased off-rate. These results suggest that the biological effects of peptide antagonists and partial agonists may be largely based on kinetic parameters.